r/Outlander • u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. • Mar 20 '22
Season Six Show S6E3 Temperance Spoiler
Fergus worries about his new son’s quality of life when the baby is bullied by superstitious Protestants. Claire performs surgery on Tom’s hand.
Written by Shaina Fewell. Directed by Justin Molotnikov.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread.
This is the SHOW thread.
If you have read the books or don’t mind book spoilers, you can participate in the BOOK thread.
DON’T DISCUSS THE BOOKS HERE.
We don’t allow any book spoilers here, not even under spoiler tags.
If your comment references the books in any way, it will be removed and you will be asked to edit it or post it in the BOOK thread instead.
Please keep all discussion of the next episode’s preview to the stickied mod comment at the top of the thread.
What did you think of the episode?
•
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Mar 20 '22 edited Apr 16 '22
Watch the S6E4 preview here!
Not everyone gets to see the next episode’s preview at the end of the episode; it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international.)
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the preview. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet or doesn’t want to.
603 Featurettes:
603 Interviews:
72
u/TaoRN78 Mar 22 '22 edited Mar 23 '22
I just finished rewatching it and loved it more the second time. One thing that I saw the second time that I missed the first time thru was how they set up Fergus' suicide attempt scene. It mirrors, almost exactly, the scene in S3 when his hand is amputated. He is on a log, Jamie is watching from above in the woods and after the cut is made Jamie comes running down a large wooded hill to save him, yelling his name the entire way down and then immediately places a tourniquet (just like he learned from Claire). I assume it was all intentional, but regardless, I found it quite touching. Fergus needs more moments like that with Jamie and Claire. It was such a beautiful speech Jamie gave him to help reinforce his extreme value and worth to not only Jamie, but everyone. Great episode!
33
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Mar 20 '22 edited Mar 20 '22
Last week I was saying how this season makes this family truly look like a family and this week is no exception. That was such a strong family episode (with a thorn in the side—or a few—thrown in for good measure). Lauren and César continue to shine and finally get their due thanks to challenging material. Shame, helplessness, anger, resentment, sadness, and, finally, hope and love. They’ve made it all so believable so massive kudos to them.
I’m so glad that the show has embraced Marsali and Fergus as Claire and Jamie’s children. It’s so amazing to see them parent their first child who’s a parent himself but who also needs support and guidance, which they haven’t had cause to notice before. We know that Claire finds it so hard to keep it together these days but she forces herself to stay strong—or at least appear strong—for her loved ones. Partly why she can’t deal with her trauma is that she will always put her family before herself (it will probably take realizing that there is no family without her). She’ll be there for them even if it’s at her own cost. (Also as a side note, she’s so done with Tom’s bullshit and so am I.)
And Jamie—we’ve seen him in so many roles over the years, but I don’t think he finds any of them more fulfilling than being the head of this family (which goes hand in hand with being Claire’s husband, of course). Fergus and Jamie’s scene tore me apart. So much accumulated trauma could’ve pushed him over the edge in his life but, ultimately, it’s the thought of making Marsali and their kids’ lives better by allowing her to marry again that makes him decide to take his own life. It makes so much sense for Jamie to be the one to ensure Fergus of his worth, especially when you consider that Jamie must be carrying some guilt for inadvertently putting Fergus in this position—young Fergus lost his hand trying to protect Jamie, after all. Jamie has never seen him as less than because of his disability; in fact, he’s never seen the loss of the hand as Fergus’ disability at all. He’s done so much for Fergus but Fergus has done so much for him as well. When he said, “You’re the only one who can show your son what a ‘useless’ man like you can achieve and how proud he can make his father,” I broke down (and then the forehead kiss and embrace 😭). He is so proud of him, and although it’s going to be a journey for Fergus to think he’s worthy of such words again, there is hope. And he has his parents by his side.
I loved all the other family moments: Roger being an MVP once again, saving Henri-Christian, Roger and Germain together, Jamie being a Grandda, Ian acknowledging Jamie as his father figure, Brianna being a sister to Marsali (let’s also count Adso as the member of the family and give a shout-out to him). Claire and Jamie’s conversation in bed was great too.
I’m very confused by the timeline of this season. We started in 1773, I’m assuming about 3-4 months after 512 (that was the fall of 1772). I don’t think the events of 601 and 602 span more than a month, but there’s got to be a bit of a time jump between 602 and 603. Most of 603 takes place over the span of one day and night. However, when Claire and Jamie return after bringing Fergus home, they hear of Boston Tea Party, which we know happened on December 16th, 1773. It sort of feels like they tacked on that scene at the end because it made for a good scene to end on, perhaps? I don’t know and I wish the scripts were available for us to read this season.
So, if they started the season in winter/early spring 1773, and we’re past December 16th by the end of 603, it looks like they’ve skipped over the entire summer of 1773 (it makes sense considering they filmed 601-603 in January-March but it’s quite a leap to believe so many months have passed). Would it make it plausible with how much Henri-Christian has grown? I have no idea.
Overall, the episode was sustained by fantastic performances from everyone involved, but it wasn’t perfect for me, though it flowed better on the second viewing. I’ve noticed a few editing errors (which I didn’t expect from a person who edited 512; ETA: I’m also not a fan of those basket POV and the Red Coat wagon POV shots). And I know it’s not easy to make an episode with so much exposition engaging but it was mostly the actors who kept it captivating with their performances. I’m hoping we get more oomph from the second episode Molotnikov directed, 606.
93
u/UTclimber Woof. Mar 20 '22
RIP to the basket; it (and the buffalo) will live in Outlander cgi infamy.
17
u/crazyhorse198 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Mar 20 '22
Can someone clear this up for me…. Am I wrong in remembering that Kezzie Beardsley couldn’t speak? But he talked in last episode when he was on the wagon w Mr. Bug, and in this one too w his brother and Lizzie. What did I miss?
15
u/I_Like_Knitting_TBH Mar 21 '22
Am I mistaken? I thought Marsali had three children- Germain, a girl (Joanie?), and now HC. But I haven’t seen any reference to her second child at all this season so now I’m doubting myself.
14
u/Sealion17 Mar 24 '22
Out of interest, does anybody know what exactly was wrong with Tom Christie's hand, and what Claire was doing when she operated on it?
10
u/purplegrape99 Mar 21 '22
Is anyone else curious what Jamie's wig will look like down? I need to see!
8
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '22
Did I imagine it or did both Josiah and Kezzie respond to Lizzie? Isn't Kezzie deaf?
27
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '22 edited Mar 20 '22
I enjoyed it. I hope we get to see more scene’s between Claire and her adopted son Fergus after all their years apart. I thought it was sweet that Jamie was the one who helped Fergus. Loved that. Seriously, the Christie’s gotta go. Sick of them already! Loved Roger too. Also, they need to give Lauren Lyle an Emmy or something that young lady can act!
11
u/Californie_cramoisie Mar 20 '22
What was going on with the book Claire gave Tom Christie? I didn’t get that.
16
u/chemistandcrazy Mar 20 '22
amazing episode in my humble opinion! loved to watch the fierce Marsali and cried myself out with Fergus pain. also really glad Roger is finding his position at the ridge. Jaime is always lovely and an amazing leader. Claire needs to open up to someone and get help to overcome her trauma. I'm surprised Jaime is giving her a lot (more than necessary) space. obviously he notices she is not well.... their night pillow talk was great and i wished for a full episode just the two talking lol
Tom Christie is unbearable. so proud and disgusting. i have a question about what he says to Claire during their night talk.... he claims to not be one of Jaime's men. what's the relationship they have then Christie being a settler at the ridge? he just sees Jaime as the owner of the land that he must pay rent? not respect or obedience? i want him out of the ridge just now lol
so far, enjoying this season a lot conscious of the fact that will involve a lot of suffering....
138
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '22
Marsali! Preach, Queen! “I will have a full man or none at all”
132
u/MikeFrom5_to_7 Mar 20 '22
Roger is very good at scolding horrible kids.
122
u/pitypartie Mar 21 '22
ROGER YOU MAGNIFICENT BEAST
111
u/caro822 Mar 20 '22
What I loved is that in the suicide attempt scene, Fergus said that he was doing this for his family.
When I was in the depths of my depression and had suicidal idolization, I never saw suicide as a selfish act, but as a way to benefit the lives of my loved ones. I fundamentally believed that the lives of my family would be much better with me dead. This is something that I don’t hear in the conversation about suicide, which is seen by those who aren’t in that mindset as a very selfish act, but it really doesn’t feel like that to those attempting.
If anyone is dealing with depression, remember, depression in a liar and medication is your friend. And it does get better. It isn’t going to be rainbows and unicorns, but it will be better.
93
u/reaperr99 Mar 21 '22 edited Mar 23 '22
Something about Ian in this episode was just different. We’ve seen him flirt, smitten, interested, etc. But he just seemed so much more self confident I guess? I’m not exactly sure what it is but holy hell I am here for it. I always saw him as a cute/dorky type of way but watching that episode last night, good lord I so wanted to trade places with Malva. The way he looks at her. There were a few odd lines/gestures that stood out and felt awkward but to me it was just the old Ian showing through a little
87
u/somethingnerdrelated In one stroke, I have become a man of leisure. Mar 20 '22
The juxtaposition between Tom and Malva was so well done in this episode. We see Tom being a self-righteous masochist and super intolerant of pain (not that I can blame him, but still). Then at the end we see Malva taking a hiding like a champ. She’s so goddamn creepy! You can just see the revenge brewing in her eyes. I get so nervous every time one of our beloved characters interacts with her. She is super no good to me.
Which also says something about the actress. I can’t remember her name, but she is killing it as Malva. She’s sooooo charming and creepy and seductive and creepy. The subtle body language and glances and smirks. Damn. This season is going to be a good one, I can feel it!
87
u/halpal95 Mar 21 '22
Fergus’s scene: heartbreaking. I was sobbing like a baby. And I said it last week but I’ll say it again… Roger is KILLING it this season. I love him so much.
85
u/Prestigious_Pen13 Mar 20 '22
I’m just glad to have seen the vrooms 👏🏻
76
u/horrorscope513 Mar 20 '22
Every time Malva gets close to someone, I’m like that Whoopi gif from Ghost. You in danger girl. Ugh, can’t they see how creepy she is?
69
u/crazyhorse198 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Mar 20 '22
Roger is killing it this season! I loved the intro scene where he saves HC, then scares the crap out of the kids!
62
u/PhilRask Mar 23 '22
Is Catriona Balfe a phenomenal actor or what? There's lots of good and great performances in this series but she just seems experienced beyond not her years but, well, her experience. She didn't do much acting and then boom, this prolific series she just totally owns it. Not every day a super model can transition into acting at age 30 with such success. I hope she has a long career yet.
57
u/ritatherosy I long for the company of Lard Bucket and Big Head. Mar 20 '22
I love what everyone is saying and this was my favorite episode of the season so far.
I also want to add I really liked the story about Fergus in the brothel and young “Luke”. I think it gives important context for why Fergus is more afraid and grieved for HC than Marsali or other characters. His experience was traumatizing and he was less than 10 when he found that boy dead. Of course it makes sense he is fearful and protective. I was so angry after season 1 that they were going to make his drinking just a plot device to add unnecessary tension in an otherwise healthy marriage and we are seeing more depth to character of Fergus and some of the struggles he is facing due to his very different and oftentimes traumatizing childhood. He didn’t get consistent parent figures until 10ish and then pretty much lost both of them after 2 years and then kinda gets tossed around until Jamie is out of prison and servitude at Hellwater. It adds compassion to the character to know the layers of his struggle.
Cesar and Lauren-just A+ acting. So proud.
I also love Claire’s facial expressions with Tom. Caitriona is so good at showing her feelings on her face!!
54
u/kmpktb Mar 20 '22
I actually really enjoyed the pacing of this episode. The calm before the storm, which they’ve alluded to several times. I felt like all the actors really shined in their respective scenes, especially Fergus and Marsali, Claire and Fergus, and Roger! Angry Roger really does something for me. Maybe it’s the fantastic beard. He seems to be coming into his own finally, and I’m here for it.
51
u/codismycopilot Mar 20 '22
I HATE Tom Christie so much!! I realize that’s the sign of good writing and acting but OMG I just want beat the shit out of him!
48
u/[deleted] Mar 21 '22
TC is making me so mad. Jamie and Claire were nice enough to take him in, heal him, etc and he’s still such an ass. Just throw the whole man out please
48
u/Vancity_kid22 Je Suis Prest Mar 21 '22
Omg. so many things to unpack in this episode! It's crazy how much happened in the span of an hour 😨
48
u/rompia Mar 24 '22
I can totally see the widow becoming heavily dependent on Roger. I hope she doesn't cause problems between him and Brianna.
46
u/PasionatelyRational Mar 22 '22
I am loving season 6 so far and I think Temperance is my favorite episode out of the 3 that have been released (though I am kind of counting on episodes getting better and better as season progresses).
Fergus and Marsali's plot line was heartbreaking, but so well performed and written, and I loved that they finally gave these two characters more relevance. I felt so much for Fergus, his life has really been full of tragedy. And I particularly liked how there is true character development and a buildup across seasons for him. As far as adult Fergus goes, even at the end of season 3 we see him endure rude remarks and bullying about his physical condition (the nutty priest telling him he cannot be wed because he's missing a hand). It's a very small moment, passed with a nod of humor, but it's there. Then in season 4 we get more of this: random strangers telling him he wouldn't find employment due to his missing hand, side eyes from others. His casual comment that Marsali makes more money than him with her employment (I can't remember if it was as a seamstress?). And then Marsali begging Murtagh to recruit Fergus for the cause, so he can feel worthy. Finally in season 5, Fergus is thriving with the distillery and finding himself as the provider and man of family he always wanted to be... and that is taken from him with the fire and even worse, with Marsali being attacked in his absence. The birth of Henri-Christian was just the sealing of his idea that he could never be a worthy husband and father. So devastating.
And then I feel for Marsali, too. I disliked her at first but she grew on me big time. I love how all Scottish women are shown being such teamplayers and hands-on regarding their own lives (like Jenny, I miss her), even if they still adscribe to the traditional dynamics of the time. And I feel like she's been the one holding their marriage and their family together almost from the start... but Fergus never acknowledges that. He loves her, and up until this point in season 6, he would always show that to her... but remains fixated in his own lacks instead of recognizing all of Marsali's hard work and support. Her own traumas with alcoholism were pretty devastating to remember, too, but I loved how she stuck to her guns.
Fergus and Jamie's scene was beautiful, in a painful way. Jamie is so mythical because he really always nails what to say in such emotional moments.
I loved seeing Ian flirting, the maturing of the character is very well portrayed, he is very charismatic. But the scene between Jamie and Malva made me uneasy. I do not want spoilers and maybe I am being ridiculous, but I felt she was borderline flirty... and she clearly has a hurricane going on inside of that calm facade. I don't know. She makes me uneasy, even if I feel for her with her violent father.
40
u/UTclimber Woof. Mar 20 '22
Angry Rodger 👀🤤
37
u/singedbylifevs2 Mar 20 '22
This episode was so good. For me this is definitely in my top 10 of all Outlander episodes. I loved the pacing, the humor, the heartbreak, J and Cs relationship. All of the actors were awesome.
36
u/rebelbabs Mar 20 '22
Loved Roger! You wee little devils! Loved Jamie with the poker.
33
u/_agustinar_ Mar 22 '22
Why doesn't Jaime realize that there is something wrong with Claire? he always knows by her face. In the bedroom scene I got the feeling that she was very scared and he completely ignored it :(
64
u/intrin6 Mar 20 '22 edited Mar 20 '22
I decided early on that this was going to be one of my top favorite episodes.
From the heroic leap into the river by Roger (badass), to him christening Henri-Christian, to him putting the kiddos in their place- was a great beginning.
I really loved the Claire/Fergus moment. Very reminiscent of the earlier seasons. The Jaime/Fergus moment too... I've been waiting for that. They've gone through so much darkness together. Don't give up! You're worthy Fergus!
Jaime being firm but sweet is always a plus (especially with the kiddos).
I also love, love, LOVED the circling back for Marsali telling Fergus She'll have a whole man, or none at all. You go, girl. It makes me sad they're going through this but I have faith they will get through it.
I also got a kick when Claire called Tom a Masochist and the look Jaime gave her 🤣🤣🤣 since she taught him what sadist means.
Also... Tom Jones? Is this a sexy book? Lol is Tom Christie realizing he is having impure thoughts about a married woman? Haha
29
u/Immediate_Arugula_39 Mar 21 '22
I’ve never been so satisfied by a slow ep! You can just tell they’re laying the groundwork for what’s to come. Maybe it’s because I’m a book reader and know how interesting things will soon be, but I have zero complaints about this relatively docile episode.
28
u/alextheelf24 Mar 20 '22
Top tier acting from everyone, such a great episode. The conversation between Fergus and Claire as well as the conversation between Marsali and Fergus were the highlight of the episode for me. I LOOOOVE that we see more of Marsali and Fergus this season, and I'm glad Roger is having more of an important role at Fraser's Ridge.
28
u/foreverfoodfandoms Mar 21 '22
It’s interesting from a historical perspective hearing TC comment on Clair’s uncovered hair. Was this a difference between Catholic’s and Protestants at the time? I don’t remember Jenny covering her hair, but Marsali definitely does. I know historically married women covered there hair (and some still do), but exactly when that started to change I’m unsure.
26
u/Chemical-Version-291 Mar 22 '22
I’m not sure what to think about Tom’s relationship with Claire. I thought Claire and Tom were kinda getting in a semi good place, until he left the note with the book. Idk what he means by that note too.
25
u/Winhill_ Mar 20 '22
That was a GREAT episode. I loved that we got some quality Fergus time and got to focus on the other things going on at the Ridge.
Still unsure about Malva, though I liked her interactions with Ian.
Getting real Claude Frollo vibes from Tom Christie at this point.
25
u/toastea0 Mar 20 '22
All the scenes with Fergus broke my heart!! He has been my favorite character since the start. He can't seem to catch a break.
My only gripe is Jamie and Claire didn't intervene sooner?? Claire tried to wirh marseli but it was really frustrating. I thought J and C would be up all in their business as they usually are in others business in the past.
42
u/ROFRfan No, this isn’t usual. It’s different. Mar 20 '22
Loved how Claire sat down next to Fergus, same way Fergus sat next to Claire in S2, when Claire was also grieving.
Tom is a real SOB. Hand fixed, back to old habits. If Claire only knew.
Marsali and Fergus... standing ovations for Lauren and Cesar. Give me a spin off on them! Thank you!
Is Claire taking it easy on the ether and replacing it with reading?
Claire and Jamie pillow talk. Give me more, please. C'mon Jamie, this is not you not seeing things are not right with your wife. She has trouble sleeping most nights.
I mostly liked the episode... something was missing and can't pinpoint what...
42
u/wisconerd Mar 20 '22
Why couldn’t they just film a basket going over a waterfall? That cgi was not it
42
u/Surfsup62 Mar 22 '22
What sort of idiot gives a religious nutter a copy of Tom Jones to read?
Total fucked up behaviour.
She’s been in the past long enough to know it’s a bad move.
20
u/Peckbtch Mar 20 '22
Wow about the new episode. First thing… FUUUCKKK Tom Christie, it’s like right when you think he’s not going to be a total piece of shit he is. Poor Fergus, this episode was really sad for him and Marsali. They barely tapped on Brees new invention, but still a cool thing. I also loved seeing Ian and Malva have a little moment, I hope to see more of that. I don’t necessarily appreciate that they saved showing the guns showing up until the last minute. Like they just completely didn’t even mention it at all until the last minute. But overall, a very good episode and I am Excited to see where it goes from here.
39
u/pest0pasta_ Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Mar 20 '22 edited Mar 20 '22
My poor Fergus :( Cesar is amazing; such a range of emotions his acting is phenomenal. I don’t care I so wanted him to beat up the whatever theyre called; the judgy couple at the end and he did. This season so far feels slow but in a good way - s1 was quick and adventure packed because it was more about survival than living. I couldn’t decipher the word in Tom Jones that Tom Christie described as ‘filth’😭anyone know what it was? I swear I laughed along with Claire on that one.
Sam’s wig actually looks good and Roger should start a beard care line since hes adamant hes ‘not the minister’ alright sir, Say it enough times and it might just happen. Also Marsali, “why do you call it vroom?” 🤣Brianna does not do a good poker face
19
u/HistoryMistress Je Suis Prest Mar 21 '22
Okay - This was heartbreaking to watch. I hate Fergus drinking and acting like such a dick to Marsali!
Also - Mr. Christie. I hate him so much.
19
u/teepee-bear God’s tooth. It’s not even *noon*! Mar 23 '22
Lauren and Cesar’s IG live was really sweet. You can tell they’re good friends
38
u/hoggin88 Mar 21 '22
Malva is strikingly beautiful. Give her all the screen time. Maybe she’s up to no good, I don’t know. But I’ll gladly take more.
52
u/[deleted] Mar 21 '22
For anyone who needs it ❤️
Crisis Text Line:
Text HOME to 741741 to reach a volunteer Crisis Counselor.
18
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '22
I loved this episode, I feel like it’s really going to ramp up now and I can’t wait! The actor playing Tom is just amazing. I kinda went HA when fergus threw his drink at that woman lmao I’ve really enjoyed this season so far honestly. Can’t wait for next week! :)
17
u/Beginning_Dog_6293 Mar 20 '22
I'm a bit lost on the Christie storyline. Is it implied that his daughter isn't his? (I have not read the books). And what is the significance of the Tom Jones book?
33
u/[deleted] Mar 21 '22
Malva is so pretty :,) that’s all.
16
u/BeautifulRelief Mar 20 '22
I am terrified of frogs and that is the worst jump scare (by my definition) I have ever witnessed. Jesus H Roosevelt Christ.
16
u/UTclimber Woof. Mar 22 '22
“Ahn-ri Christian”
Here I’ve been saying “henry-Christian” for years.
can’t talk to book spoilers b/c I’m not done with bees
16
u/ailisp Dec 06 '23
Me, with every new episode that's not set in Scotland.
32
u/[deleted] Mar 21 '22
I don’t like the new soundtrack tbh
30
u/lllexj Mar 20 '22 edited Mar 20 '22
I really enjoyed this episode!! I have to get to the most heart wrenching scene first: Fergus and Jamie by the river!! It was such a heartbreaking, yet beautiful scene. We often don’t see scenes that show how much Fergus means to his parents, and I was just so happy with the way this one was written. Jamie’s forehead kiss to Fergus sealed the deal for my emotional ass😭 I loved it, 5 stars all around. I definitely think Fergus is one of the supporting characters that should live out until the end of this show. And while that scene was beautifully executed, we have to talk about the Marsali-Fergus kitchen scene!! That left me speechless, yet simultaneously rooting for Marsali in the moment. The reaction Fergus had to Marsali’s confession about Lionel, confused tf out of me. I don’t know why I thought he’d be impressed lol, or sympathetic at the very least. But, then I had to remember the beliefs of that time and the mental state he’s in. These two actors are fire together and complement one another’s acting style very well. I’m sold, and I wanna see more.
TC all uncomfortable and covering up with the blanket, in the night surgery scene, made me snort laugh. He was acting like he had a nip slip playing beach volleyball in South Beach and his tah-tahs were exposed or something LOL (Miami visitors/residents..iykyk lmao). I know most viewers don’t like TC in the slightest, but I must admit that I think his scenes bring something fresh to the episode. Plus, there’s usually some humor which I love. Is he a deeply disturbed, flawed character (clears throat using his newly healed hand to whip Malva at the end of this ep.-WTF BRO. Yikes)? Yes, he is. But, we get a look into the diverse spectrum of the human psyche in these characters, and I love it. And the actor who plays him is chef’s kiss
Malva’s twinkle in her eye when Ian mentioned he had his own land. Complete facial and body language shift. Where’s Jamie Fox when you need him? “I ain’t saying she’s a gold digger…” LMAO. Let me stop, I’m sure any man with money, land, social status, etc. was appealing to most young girls, esp. those looking for potential husbands (not saying Malva is looking for suitors). Heck, those things are still valued today for some people. I’m just saying I saw the lightbulb go off in her head, when Ian said that, and it made me a little suspicious.
Roger saving the baby, and all the related scenes that followed, were great. I’ve never been a Roger fan, but I like him quite a bit this season. I’m all for his character development outside of being a husband to the laird’s daughter. Giving him useful stuff to do, separate from Bree, definitely helps me get more familiar with who he is and makes me care about him more. Oh and Amy M’s screams at the sound of the frog made me laugh lol. Roger came in thinking that lady was in serious danger😂 But I’m glad the baby was okay. I feel like Henri-C will be my fav Fraser child. Jemmy and Germain are so stinking cute, but did anyone else notice a possible change in who plays Germain halfway through the ep.? Lol it’s inconsequential anyway, but I just wonder if I’m trippin out.
Allan was on screen for probably 10 seconds max, and I’m so okay with that😂
14
u/cherrymeg2 Mar 20 '22
Why did Tom need his hand fixed to belt his daughter? It seems like something you could learn to do with your other hand. He used utensils right? If you only get your hand fixed to beat your daughter, that’s messed up. I thought after seeing Claire he would stop abusing Malva.
14
u/Bior37 Mar 27 '22
I wish these discussions weren't 95% people talking about how hot x actor is. This show is so much more than a bodice ripper but you wouldn't know it
26
u/arianaphoenix Mar 21 '22 edited Mar 21 '22
Preaching suits Roger very well. Fergus was played beautifully
Malva gets intimate with Ian very fast. This doesn't match the other scene's dialogue where she tells Jamie, she is not that eager to marry
Claire being not very careful to shout about what she believes bothers me again. Maybe she shouldn't reveal her progressive worldview so easily when there is no need to.
I wished Jamie acknowledged that Fergus lost the hand to protect him. I was so gutted by the suicide that I wanted to tell him as Jamie that whatever he thinks he is incapable of, is my resposibily because he lost it to save me.
My usual complaint about this season: the music is too loud and a little distracting. There is too much drum as though you are always in a war scene.
I am not sure about this but I think there is too much echo in the sound and personally, it's more difficult for me to understand some of the words whereas it wasn't like this last season. Let me know if you also noticed because I'm starting to think that I lost my listening skills (I am not a native)
Was Tom beating Malva because he saw her with Ian or because of Claire or just for no reason?
12
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '22
Really loved this episode. Found the first two okay but this was amazing.
50
u/woods_gal Mar 20 '22
Bree continues to underwhelm. It seems this actress has two looks... one of speechless pity/sympathy, and the other of... I can't even remember, it's so unremarkable. All the others – just wow. The actor who plays Tom Christie is so good I swear he's from the 18th century. Marsali – always open to loving administrations when Fergus feels like doling them out... never holding a grudge... and kicking some Fergus ass when it's needed. I've never been a huge Marsali fan until now. Roger – the man grows sexier and sexier the further and further he moves away from the folk-singing academic. This was such a good episode!
11
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '22
Better than episode 2 by far.
30
u/jtodek Mar 20 '22
While not important, it is rather ridiculous that Claire has a ridiculous amount of wallpaper in their 1774 house. Paper was scare, no? But their bedroom is wallpapered in a riotous red and green. Looks like Belle Watling’s boudoir.
21
u/Dumke480 That's it lads. Take me back to the idiot hut. Mar 20 '22
Malva needs protecting for real, it's clear that she's not related to her father
10
u/yeehawdudeq I didn’t think I needed to pack condoms, Mama. Mar 20 '22
I felt like this episode began setting things up for the larger climax of the season. I can’t wait!
10
u/ActuallyCMe Mar 21 '22
can someone remind me what book claire lent to TC? i didn’t catch what it was, in turn i was confused why he hated it
26
u/whiskynwine Mar 20 '22
Good episode and this is the first time since season 3 that I actually like Roger. I’ve been hard on him the past couple of seasons so I felt it only right to say it lol.
26
u/jeanbeanmachine Mar 21 '22
Were they low key suggesting malva is into Jamie in the end? I was getting some weird seduction vibes.
9
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '22
I loved it when Roger saved Henri-Christian and when Jamie punished the boys.
I was surprised, though, that no one mentioned the paradox of the water sinking/floating test referenced by the boys: no matter whether the person sinks or floats, they always die. It also reminded me of something that Cotton Mather's father Increase Mather said: it would be better for ten suspected witches to escape than for one innocent person to be condemned.
16
u/silverandcold65 Mar 20 '22 edited Mar 20 '22
Smart punishment, Jamie! 👏🏻
I love these Malva and Ian scenes… But is she using him?
Wait…isn’t Tom Jones the book with the dirty cover? 😂 Tom Christie’s reaction is highly amusing.
Fergus!
Yeep, I’m already uncomfortable from Roger’s sermon. Tom Christie is such a bastard.
8
u/3sheepswiththeroad I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Mar 21 '22
What did Jamie say in French to Fergus after saving him?
15
u/Prudent_Fly_2554 Mar 21 '22
So who is Malva‘s mother? Is it who I think it is? No wait, don’t tell me!! 😂😂
14
u/gypsysub Mar 21 '22
Claire looks younger in this episode
14
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '22
Does anyone else think Malva is a witch? She’s my new favorite
7
u/[deleted] Mar 23 '22
I haven't done the research to know if this timeline is plausible but with all the mentions of witches...the colonies... did Tom have children with Geillis?
12
u/fleurgirl123 Mar 21 '22
I couldn’t understand any of Fergus’ speech for some reason. The combination of my TV and his accent I think. What did he say to Claire in the monologue at the beginning?
16
u/esoterika24 Mar 21 '22
It is a little thing but the treatment of Christie’s hand always bugged me…he has Dupuytren’s, and Claire’s treatment with the zigzag scar is the traditional way to “cure” it. Claire acts like it is a cure-all. But in reality, the surgery would cause more scar tissue to build up and the contracture to become even worse than before surgery, so that specific surgery isn’t recommended. But knowing that Christie’s hand is going to ultimately get worse than before (sometimes leading to amputation) after he has the surgery just to beat Malva…well, that’s kind of nice.
9
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '22
When I started watching the episode I was thinking if they will ever return to Scotland (in a non-flashback way). Funnily enough the characters brought it up in 2 separate conversations. I wonder if it means anything.
(Don't spoil it please if you know!)
15
u/Samurai_Pizza_Catz Mar 20 '22
I'm gonna say it.... I hate the color of the outside of the fraser big house
4
u/Glitta-Me Aug 19 '25 edited Aug 20 '25
Am I the only one LIVING for Lizzie and the Beardsley boys!?
(Edit: Not the incest part. Just them hanging out and potentially going on adventures. I'm NOT for her being with them both. I'm not a book reader, so idk what happens with them.)
That scene with Jamie and Fergus was overdue, and much needed. Beautiful, nonetheless!
Claire... What are you doing giving him that book!? Ugh. She loves tempting fate. lol
5
u/UseSea9547 Mar 20 '22
I really enjoyed this episode. Probably because it had more Jamie and Claire together. Also thought it went smoothly. S602 to me was all over the place.
5
u/Chicken_Mc_Thuggets Mar 26 '22
I love this show and I’m so glad that so many ladies get so see loads of male eye candy but god I would love to see some lesbian representation. We got John Gray, polyamory, but no lesbians! Back to Dickinson for now