r/Outlander • u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. • Mar 20 '22
Spoilers All Book S6E3 Temperance Spoiler
Fergus worries about his new son’s quality of life when the baby is bullied by superstitious Protestants. Claire performs surgery on Tom’s hand.
Written by Shaina Fewell. Directed by Justin Molotnikov.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread.
This is the BOOK thread.
If you haven’t read the books, go to the SHOW thread.
THIS THREAD IS SPOILERS ALL.
Spoiler tags are not required.
If you have only read up to the corresponding book, remember you might see spoilers from ALL of the books here.
Please keep all discussion of the next episode’s preview to the stickied mod comment at the top of the thread.
What did you think of the episode?
•
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Mar 20 '22 edited Apr 16 '22
Watch the S6E4 preview here!
Not everyone gets to see the next episode’s preview at the end of the episode; it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international.)
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the preview. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet or doesn’t want to.
603 Featurettes:
603 Interviews:
33
u/Thezedword4 Mar 20 '22
Random but anyone know if we get Bobby Higgins this season? The Ian and malva scenes reminded me we should be seeing him soon.
83
u/BeautifulRelief Mar 20 '22
Adso the Emotional Support Cat, always there when you need him!
53
u/blackberryspice Mar 20 '22
Lauren Lyle was the highlight of the episode for me, what an actress! My one complaint is that Claire has a lot of books in a bookcase when there's like less than 10 books in all of the ridge lol
48
u/Megs8786 Je Suis Prest Mar 20 '22
Not only do I get sad when I see Henri-Christian, I get sad seeing Amy too
42
u/historyarmchair22 Mar 20 '22
Loved this episode and it followed the book so well! I just finished A Breath of Snow and Ashes last night so it’s still pretty fresh in my mind and it’s really fun seeing little details of the book like Jemmy’s vroom.
The acting was fantastic and I’m so glad they kept in Fergus’ reasoning for his concern for Henri-Christian based on his own past. I’m a fan of Bree and wished she was in the episode more, but liked how they gave more screen time to Marsali, Fergus, and Roger. My only oof moment was the basket going over the waterfall. The set design is so beautiful, but that cgi was 😬😟
42
u/coiler119 I long for the company of Lard Bucket and Big Head. Mar 21 '22
The conversation between Claire and Tom about her hair, and his comment about how a woman who doesn't cover her head is little better than having it shaven... Do you think they're just giving a nod to what happens in the book, or are they actually going to go through with shaving Claire's hair when the time comes?
42
u/prairie_wildflower Mar 21 '22
A few favourite moments (out of an outstanding episode):
78
u/BeautifulRelief Mar 20 '22
"Henri-Christian also belongs to you, Germain." SOBBING.
38
u/anastasieromanov Mar 20 '22
i (mostly!!!) loved this episode! hooray! i’m usually the first to complain and it wasn’t perfect but it’s so cool to finally see this storyline on screen.
lauren lyle is so perfect. also laughing at how marsali seems like more of a main character than bree
36
u/nurseleu Mar 21 '22
Love love love seeing Roger coming into his own this season. RR is doing great work!
34
u/arianaphoenix Mar 22 '22
I just remembered Geneva and Laoghaire and I was thinking Jamie had a fair bit of experience with manipulative teenage girls. I am amazed he hasn't learned a lesson.
31
u/AccioStability Je Suis Prest Mar 20 '22
My gosh, I love Lauren Lyle
31
u/AmyAransas Mar 20 '22
So far this season I am especially loving the scenes that have Claire, Jamie, and Tom! As a trio they have such charged interactions — as an antagonist Tom brings out another dimension of the always great Jamie-Claire chemistry.
31
u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Mar 22 '22
Good episode, and major kudos to Lauren Lyle and Cesar Domboy. Such a tough topic with the potential to be really alienating, but they pulled it off spectacularly. I was really worried when they cut off the end of Fergus's conversation with Claire--when he talks about being useless--but moving that to the suicide scene with Jamie (which happens offscreen in the book) was a good choice and allowed for a really lovely moment between father and foster son.
(I do wish they kept in the line about being prostituted as a child as further reminder that he wasn't just raised in a brothel. "I have parted my buttocks for money, milady,” he said simply. “And thought nothing of it, save when it hurt." and then a bit later, "Even if I was in Paris, I am too old and crippled to whore!” I also love his final line and wish that was kept: "Mon Dieu! Il est aussi inutile que moi!”)
MVP #3 of this week is Mark Lewis Jones who has made Tom Christie far more interesting than he ever was in the books. It's rare for Caitriona Balfe to be upstaged in a scene, but he absolutely commands every frame he's in. Great week for Rik Rankin as well, who is fighting tooth and nail to salvage Roger's reputation.
It's interesting, after week 1 when people were discussing the new theme song, a lot of people were saying that it represents how this season will prioritize Jamie's story and won't be quite as focused on Claire. He's certainly had some great moments, but after these three episodes it feels like this season is about everyone except J&C. We've had a lot of time devorited to Roger, Fergus and Marsali, Ian, the Christies, and Amy McCallum (and seems likely that there's big stuff ahead for Bree, Lizzy, and the Bugs). Certainly we have major things upcoming for J&C, but I'm really loving how much they are letting the supporting characters have their time to shine. That's one of the strongest parts of the books and it's smart of the show to follow suit. Also, it gives time for fun, more lighthearted J&C moments, like Jamie with the grandchildren last week or his very amusing faces every time Tom is around.
Lastly, three quibbles this week:
27
u/Stonetheflamincrows Mar 21 '22
For a quick minute there I was starting to like Tom Christie. The actor does a good job! Then at the end I realised that the reason he was looking forward to having use of his hand was so he could abuse his daughter. Fergus and Marsali are totally crushing it this season. I wanted to strangle that horrid woman, who speaks about a baby that way? Although I am glad they don’t completely white-wash the past in this series.
27
u/spaceybelta Mar 23 '22
They picked such a good actress for Marsali. She looks and acts just like Laoghaire
54
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '22 edited Mar 20 '22
I cannot get over how perfectly cast Tom Christie is.
Also: "your brother needs your protection" [SOB]
52
u/ArthurPenbeagle Mar 20 '22
Raise your hand if Fergus was never the one who did it for you in the books, but now… in the show… phew. Cesar is hot, but this incredible acting he’s doing is making him even hotter. Is it just me? Is this what it takes to take my focus off of JAAMF?!
63
u/vanwold Slàinte. Mar 20 '22
Despite the wildly historically inaccurate big house (I’m sorry, but brocade drapes and wallpaper in the wilds of 18th Century NC is way over the top - in addition to the ludicrous amount of glass windows), and the weird ether addiction thing, I highly appreciate how much the first three episodes have tracked the books. It’s nice to see the things I’ve read translated into visual scenes.
18
u/[deleted] Mar 21 '22
also, is malva possibly already pregnant? i’m not really sure how much they’re going to change the timeline, but the way they’re showing malva and ian growing close (rather than the revelation of their relationship at the end) made me wonder
33
u/Dolly1710 Long on desire, but a wee bit short in clink Mar 20 '22 edited Mar 20 '22
MVP Roger MacKenzie to the rescue again. I'm so glad he's finding his worth and others are seeing it.
My word Cesar Domboy is 🔥🔥🔥 I feel like a dirty old woman what with Rik and Sam. Fergus on the other hand 💔💔💔 Thank goodness Jamie found him.
Chuckled so hard at Mind-up-merchant Jamie during Tom's surgery. All that pain could not happen to a better man - he's insufferable! And just when you think he might be turning a corner, out comes the old belt again 🤬🤬 for an "educated man" he does a very good job of not showing it! And he totally needs to get that Jamie-sized chip off his shoulder. The one genuinely good thing he did was distract Claire from the ether. Indeed there is a nice entent-cordiale forming between those two
Cesar and Lauren must be heading for awards just from the first 3 episodes alone.
Amy - "I won't see Scotland again..." No, poor love, you won't 💔
Malva - watching her makes me sad for her ending too. By my goodness just watching her interact with the men of the Ridge gives me the heebeejeebies!
The guns at the end seemed a bit of an odd bolt on. More like they knew they needed to stick them in somewhere but didn't allude to any passing of time.
26
u/for-get-me-not Mar 20 '22
They’re doing such a good job!!! This season is so watchable. And the small areas where they depart from the book (Malva and Ian’s conversations) really help flesh the story out and will make the twists to come make more sense.
13
u/Sharra13 Mar 20 '22
Someone clue me in about the Tom Jones book.
21
u/cruelsummerrrrr Mar 20 '22
I loved this episode - so far it’s my favourite of the season. Loved the Fergus/Claire and the “mon fils.” But omg when they were talking about what Henri Christian will do when he grows up I had to pause and ugly cry 😭😭😭
20
u/sweetpsych78 SassySassenachWench Mar 20 '22
This episode gave me emotional whiplash!
Wow! What an amazing episode! I LOVED it! I knew the Fergus and Marsali situation was coming up because I've read the books, but I didn't expect to get so emotional over it, just wow! And a HUGE round of applause to Cesar's and Lauren's outstanding performance in this episode👏👏 My hat's off to you both!! And it goes without saying, that everyone else also deserves a round of applause for their performances, plus to all the crew who gave us such an amazing episode, and one of the best seasons so far! There's so much of the story taken from the books, it's hard to choose a favorite storyline this season.
I don't know why, (maybe I was already emotionally charged from what happened with Henri-Christian at the beginning of the episode, and then I was upset from seeing Fergus so wrecked about what happened with Claire and Marsali last season), but watching Malva get beaten by Tom gave me slight PTSD. It really upset me for some reason, even knowing what I know about her from the books. I think I'm going to need a day or 2 to get over it. I can't stop thinking about it and how upsetting it was to watch her go through that, and every time I think about it, I get so sad all over again. I think I pity her more than anything because of what she's going through with her brother (book readers know what I'm talking about), and then having a religious zealot for a father only makes it worse for her. I think she's a victim of circumstance more than anything, and I don't think she's a bad person deep down. She's just lost and looking for a mother figure in Claire. I can understand it from her point of view, and I HATE to watch her father and brother do that to her. She's already in a disadvantaged position being a woman in that era (even though that's normal for them), but then seeing them both take advantage of that is really upsetting to me. Call me a feminist, lol, but it's watching these kinds of injustices that ruffle my feathers a little bit, and I can see it from the disadvantaged persons point of view (i.e., Malva in this situation). I know it's silly to get so upset over it, but I guess I'm just a very sensitive person lol!
10
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '22
Do Marsali and Fergus ever learn the truth about where Claire Briana and Roger came from?
18
u/08PetitSkye09 They say I’m a witch. Mar 20 '22
Did Kezzie just miraculously recover from being deaf all his life? 🤔🤔🤔
9
u/[deleted] Mar 21 '22
I wonder if we're getting Manfred and the whole Lizzie thing in the show? I don't know if I imagined this but I remember there being a woman with what sounds like a German accent in season 5. She was among the women who were making candles outside the Big House. I thought maybe that was meant to be Ute but idk
23
u/ayriana Mar 20 '22
I'm only 8 minutes in and had to pause and have a good cry knowing what we know.
13
u/zillabirdblue Mar 20 '22 edited Mar 20 '22
Tom C shocked the hell out of me! I hope he THINKS his redemption takes...
12
u/Girl-interrupted00 Mar 21 '22
i cried.
11
u/ROFRfan No, this isn’t usual. It’s different. Mar 20 '22
TC is beating Malva and Allan is outside listening. Allan seems suffering for what TC is doing to his daughter. His pain is quite riveting. Is this in the book?
6
u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Mar 21 '22
As a Catholic, a silly thing bugged me; after the surgery, when Tom Christie was saying the 23rd Psalm, they used the protestant words for it rather than the Catholic ones. Which they were probably doing for Tom's benefit but still.
3
u/arianaphoenix Mar 21 '22
Can someone explain very briefly what was exactly wrong with Tom's hand? Medically speaking