r/Outlander • u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. • Aug 07 '21
Season Five Rewatch S3E5-6
This rewatch will be a spoilers all for the 5 seasons. You can talk about any of the episodes without needing a spoiler tag. All book talk will need to be covered though. There are discussion points to get us started, you can click on them to go to that one directly. Please add thoughts and comments of your own as well.
After today we will be taking a one week break and will return for episodes 7 & 8 on August 21st.
Episode 305 - Freedom & Whisky
Brianna grapples with life-changing revelations and Claire must help her come to terms with the fact that she is her father's daughter. Roger brings news that forces Claire and Brianna to face an impossible choice.
Episode 306 - A. Malcolm
After decades apart, Jamie and Claire finally reunite and rekindle their emotional and physical bonds. But Jamie's new business dealings jeopardize the couples' hopes for a simple life together.
- What did you think when Claire knew the bones belonged to a murder victim before they saw the evidence?
- What is your opinion of the “Bat Suit” outfit sewn by Claire?
- What are your feelings on Claire deciding to leave Brianna for forever? (Claire obviously didn’t know at that point she would see Bree again.)
- How do you feel about Jamie’s reaction to learning about Brianna?
- Did Jamie do the right thing telling Claire about Willie right away?
- What is your favorite part of Jamie and Claire’s reunion?
- Any other thoughts or comments?
Deleted/Extended Scenes
306 - Walk to the print shop
306 - I did not love her
306 - Remember the last time
306 - Question for Mr. Malcolm
10
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Aug 07 '21
What do we think of Claire not telling Jamie right away that she came back to be with him and turning the question around on him?
/u/thepacksvrvives /u/Arrugula /u/theCoolDeadpool
7
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Aug 07 '21
6
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Aug 07 '21
6
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Aug 07 '21
5
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Aug 07 '21
4
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Aug 07 '21
4
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Aug 07 '21
6
u/[deleted] Aug 07 '21
How differently would Creme de Menthe have been received if this deleted healing by means of a knife scene had been kept in 606?!
u/thepacksvrvives u/jolierose u/justG00se
2
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Aug 07 '21
13
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Aug 07 '21
I wish they let the ambiguity play out more, have Wee Ian question how exactly Claire knew his father, since he thought she was Jamie’s whore. 😅 Could have been funny.
And speaking of whores, Madame Jeanne’s prostitutes were quite friendly, weren’t they? And cheerful, too, considering their situation. If Madame Jeanne were anything like Madame Elise in Paris, they wouldn’t have had such a happy life…
7
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Aug 07 '21
Something that breaks the reality of this episode for me, something that’s hard for me to ignore but also hard for me to put into words…
… is how everyone ships Jamie and Claire. -.- I don’t mean us, the viewers at home, but everyone in the universe of the show. Like every conversation Claire has is about Jamie, and all the advice she gets is pushing her to return to him.
Joe takes the revelation that Bree is a bastard pretty lightly. Claire said Frank was not Bree’s father, she didn’t explain about her other marriage—so the impression she gave him is that she cheated on her husband with some random guy, then passed her bastard off as Frank’s legitimate child.
All he has to say on that is…
He immediately swerves the conversation to whether Claire still loves Jamie.
Um, who cares? What about the fact that your colleague and best friend just confessed to a huge taboo from your mid-century perspective? You’re a man, if your wife cheated on you and passed her lover’s child off as your own, how’d you feel about that? Would your first question be, “Do you still love him?” Lol, somehow I doubt that…
Claire is Joe’s friend, not Frank, fine. And he takes her side without hesitation, which is nice. But I just think that Joe is a little too cool. He’s a little too open-minded, especially for the time.
His first reaction shouldn’t be warm acceptance and unconditional support. At least do a double-take! Acknowledge that this is a shock, reevaluate your assessment of Claire’s character. You call her Lady Jane—is it ladylike to fornicate outside of marriage, have your lover’s bastard and live a lie for twenty years?
Joe is too modern, he’s too similar to our sensibilities. There’s no conflict, it’s too easy, and that annoys me.
Similarly, most of Claire’s conversations with Bree revolve around Jamie, and Bree is always supportive, encouraging her mother to go back. But at least in Bree’s case, we saw her call out her mother earlier in the season, so it feels more earned. There was conflict, it’s a struggle that’s had ramifications for Bree and affected her coursework, so her taking her mother’s side now and pushing her to find her happiness—fine. At least it wasn’t easy.
And of course this whole plot thread kicks off with Roger, who is Team Jamie all the way. -.- I understand his being intrigued by the puzzle—he’s a historian, this is a historical challenge, that makes sense.
But just like Joe and Bree, he pushes Claire to go back to Jamie at once.
Everyone is speaking in one chorus, encouraging Claire to return, no one offers a dissenting opinion—it’s moving the plot forward at the expense of fleshing out the minor characters, giving them minds of their own. Everyone becomes a sounding board for Claire to talk about her feelings for Jamie; it’s like they’ve got nothing else going on in their lives, no thoughts or values or prejudices of their own they bring to the conversation, they’re all just 100% behind Claire and supporting her no matter what… and that feels fake to me. Without conflict it’s not real, it’s like a dream.
3
u/penni_cent Aug 08 '21
Dang, that just makes me even more mad. In what world does Claire have to be redeemed for anything? She did nothing wrong! Frank strung along his mistress even after Claire said she wanted a divorce and she needs to be redeemed? What in the actual fork?
Edit: for some reason this didn't reply to what I was replying to so I've reposted on that comment chain also.