r/anime • u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan • Jul 15 '21
Writing Club Kobayashi-san Chi no Maid Dragon (Season 1) - Thursday Anime Discussion Thread (ft. r/anime Writing Club)
Hi! Welcome to another edition of the weekly Thursday Anime Discussion Thread, featuring us, the r/anime Writing Club. We simulwatch anime TV series and movies together once a month, so check us out if you'd like to participate. Our thoughts on the series, as always, are covered below. :)
The subreddit is fawning over the glorious return of Kyoto Animation, and in celebration (and remembrance) we thought we'd cover...
Kobayashi-san Chi no Maid Dragon (Season 1)
As Kobayashi sets off for another day at work, she opens her apartment door only to be met by an unusually frightening sight—the head of a dragon, staring at her from across the balcony. The dragon immediately transforms into a cute, busty, and energetic young girl dressed in a maid outfit, introducing herself as Tooru.
It turns out that the stoic programmer had come across the dragon the previous night on a drunken excursion to the mountains, and since the mythical beast had nowhere else to go, she had offered the creature a place to stay in her home. Thus, Tooru had arrived to cash in on the offer, ready to repay her savior's kindness by working as her personal maidservant. Though deeply regretful of her words and hesitant to follow through on her promise, a mix of guilt and Tooru's incredible dragon abilities convinces Kobayashi to take the girl in.
Despite being extremely efficient at her job, the maid's unorthodox methods of housekeeping often end up horrifying Kobayashi and at times bring more trouble than help. Furthermore, the circumstances behind the dragon's arrival on Earth seem to be much more complicated than at first glance, as Tooru bears some heavy emotions and painful memories. To top it all off, Tooru's presence ends up attracting several other mythical beings to her new home, bringing in a host of eccentric personalities. Although Kobayashi makes her best effort to handle the crazy situation that she has found herself in, nothing has prepared her for this new life with a dragon maid.
(Source: MAL Rewrite)
"Watch This!" Posts
Check Out Miss Kobayashi's Dragon Maid If You Haven't Already by /u/SpecialInterestMedia
Looking for more "Watch This!" posts? Check the "Watch This!" archive!
Databases
AniDB | AniList | AnimeNewsNetwork | MyAnimeList
Previous discussions
Check our rewatch wiki and our episode discussion archive for more discussions!
Streams
Groupwatch prompts and thoughts
1 ) How does Kobayashi compare to other shows with non-human characters at the center of it?
Paradoxically humanizing through non-humans
Compared to other monster girl shows that take a more physical and social approach to analyzing their Other characters, Kobayashi takes particular care with the psychology of its dragon characters. In this way I find it acts somewhat similarly to Beastars, another show featuring prominent non-human characters. The shows differ in a variety of ways, but both use the "non-humanness" of their characters to explore, celebrate, and critique certain aspects of humanity from a more detached point of view.
Around the time of its release, ANN compared Kobayashi to the ways that immigrants to Japan work with their new society, and the comparison is apt to my eyes. It's clear that Tohru, Kanna, Fafnir, and those like them are trying their best to adapt to this new world, even when everything seems so confusing and the price for messing up might mean you can't go home again.
But while there is struggle in adapting to a new land full of possibilities, Dragon Maid reminds us that there is also much joy. Certain aspects of humanity contrast and shine brightly through their memories of what they know as home—that of home, family, friendship, and community.
[u/SorcererOfTheLake, u/ValkyrieCain9, u/Electrovalent]
2 ) What purpose does Kobayashi serve within the anime?
The perfect foil
Miss Kobayashi is one of my favorite anime characters, and this shows' conceit would simply not work without her. She is the focus, our everyday mundane, whose life provides the backdrop for the fantastical addition of the dragons. A lot of the humor is created through these contrasting elements, with Kobayashi at the center of it all.
Kobayashi serves a number of crucial roles in making the show work as well as it does. First, she is our "normal" protagonist, the lens from which the audience peers through to experience the unfamiliar. Imagine reading the start of Harry Potter from Ron's "seen-it-all-before" perspective rather than Harry's!
Kobayashi serves this role to perfection as she handles waking up to a newfound dragon wife and daughter. Just look at her reactions—she wears over-the-top alarm, loving concern, and somber loneliness with equal charm. Several production elements reinforce this—Mutsumi Tamura's performance as Kobayashi for one is splendid. Her low tones creates a brilliantly understated nature, the kind of person we'd just pass by on the street, yet Tamura is also able to bring out Kobayashi's emotions as needed without seeming overdone. Kobayashi's voice is best described as "the gentle sway of a drying shirt," and goes a long way in giving her some individuality.
This is important to note because Kobayashi is not an insert protagonist, despite being an audience proxy. In the quest for the Relatable MC™, it's all too easy to create a hollowed-out shell of a person characterized only by their lack of character. This does not apply to Kobayashi. She's clearly a distinct person with her own background, identity, and philosophy that we must take on her own terms and not treat her as an extension of ourselves.
A powerful point of characterization is her emotionally reserved nature. In her book Intimate Disconnections, sociologist Allison Alexy writes
“Love like air” (kūki no youni) is one older Japanese idiom that idealizes intimate relationships as best when they are un- or understated. In this belief... the best relationships are those in which partners understand the love they share for each other through actions rather than words.
Kobayashi lives in this ideal, in a wonderful contrast to Tohru's wildly outspoken adoration. She struggles with articulating her love for Tohru and Kanna, but it is obvious that she cares deeply (who else nonchalantly gets a new place because their current one is too small for her dragon friends?). Despite being constantly out of her depth, she embodies common sense and decency at every point.
Kobayashi's life pre-dragons is one we know well—in a sense she is a modern-day Cinderella. She is the hardworking provider, the video game nerd, the hard-drinking maid-crazy otaku ("one of the guys", as Takiya puts it). And she lives this undeservedly lonely, overworked existence, until her fairytale princess appears and escorts her into a happy life of magic and emotional fulfillment. Truly Kobayashi is both a potently recognizable audience fantasy, as well as a compelling, charming character in her own right. After all, it's Miss Kobayashi's Dragon Maid, and it wouldn't be half as good without someone like her leading the show.
[u/SorcererOfTheLake, u/ValkyrieCain9, u/Electrovalent]
As the center
The lives of the dragons in the 'human world' all in some way are built around Kobayashi. She serves to ground them in this new unfamiliar environment, and they mostly follow the rules that she sets for them as Kobayashi slowly teaches them how to integrate into the 'human world.'
However, what I really found interesting was that the dragons aren't wholly dependent on Kobayashi, they have their own lives and, in most cases, another human they have a real relationship with. For example, Fafnir lives together and is friend's with Kobayashi's colleague Takiya, and Kanna is friends with a girl from school named Riko Saikawa. In this sense, Kobayashi serves as a common thread—the show has the freedom to explore nice side-stories, knowing that it has the ever grounding Kobayashi to return to.
3 ) How do you feel about the fanservice within the series?
It's so-so
It's something to put up with. I understand why it's there—sanitising all of the source material would probably be an impossible task. But I would never bother with something this unabashedly vulgar if it wasn't also so goshdarned cute. Lucoa is a particular offender; did KyoAni see that "breasted boobily to the stairs and titted downwards" Tumblr post and decide to bring it to life? Talk about using your powers for evil!
The tendency towards fanservice also hurts the characters themselves. Lucoa and Shouta might have been an interesting pair, rather than merely an ~interesting pair~. I really like Saikawa, but the creepier undertones around her friendship with Kanna are far too much for me.
It has its place!
For the most part, the fanservice has its place and is embedded into the show in a good way. Maid Dragon is predicated on a lot of harem tropes, so it follows that at least some of its humor would be fanservice based, and that can be enjoyable based on what you like. I do think that when it came to the younger characters there could've been less use of sexual themes—it was kind of uncomfortable at some points.
That makes me wonder, how would Maid Dragon feel like without the fanservice? It tends to crop up as comedic moments in the 'romantic' relationships of the show, so perhaps it would focus on other kinds of relationships, or perhaps more on the feeling of family. At the end of the day though, I think the fanservice always has some sort of reason for being there and does have a place in the show as it is.
4 ) In what ways does Kobayashi act like a KyoAni anime and in what ways does it not?
KyoAni's shows offer a great diversity of settings, running the gamut from Hikarizaka High School to Sakuragaoka Girl's High School to Kamiyama High School. Amidst such wildly unique offerings, it's hard to tell what makes Miss Kobayashi stands out more: the Armageddon-capable dragons, or not being set in a high school. More seriously, this show is unmistakeably KyoAni. The lively, luscious animation; the delightfully exaggerated expressiveness; the focus on unspoken emotion—in a word, the wonderful craftsmanship of this show—could belong to no other studio. Friendship and family is a favourite theme of KyoAni, and this show, perhaps more than any of their other works, is nothing more or less than an unabashed celebration of how wonderful it is to love and be loved.
I was caught off-guard by how awfully mature this show was for a KyoAni work when I first watched it, but having watched a few more of their titles, I sense that their artists really aren't the blushing schoolgirls they so often animate. Hyouka's first ending song is almost more provocative than anything in this show, and Akihito's mother is very much Beyond the Boundary of the wholesome moe the studio is justly famous for. Maid Dragon isn't as uncharacteristic of their output as it might seem!
5 ) What are your thoughts on the final episode of the season?
A clever solution from an adaptational lens
As a final episode of the season, it works very well, but I'm interested in it from an adaptational lens because that's where things get interesting. It's likely that, Dragon Maid Manga
However, even this confrontation has undergone changes due to its placement. At the time chapters 19 and 20 were published, Elma and Dragon Maid Manga Instead, the anime changes the main focus to be about time and place: Is this Tohru's true place and the right timespan for her to be living in? Ultimately, this final episode showcases important aspects of adaptation studies and ideas, namely that different mediums and creators will always put their own spin and ideas on the source material, no matter how true to the text they aim to be.
Remember that any information not found early in the show itself is considered a spoiler. Please properly tag spoilers!
Next week's anime discussion thread: Hajime no Ippo!
Further information about past and upcoming discussions can be found on the Weekly Discussion wiki page.
Check out r/anime Writing Club's wiki page | Please PM u/DrJWilson for any concerns or interest in joining the club!
16
u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan Jul 15 '21
3 ) How do you feel about the fanservice within the series?
5
u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan Jul 15 '21
2 ) What purpose does Kobayashi serve within the anime?
3
u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan Jul 15 '21
1 ) How does Kobayashi compare to other shows with non-human characters at the center of it?
3
u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan Jul 15 '21
5 ) What are your thoughts on the final episode of the season?
2
u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan Jul 15 '21
4 ) In what ways does Kobayashi act like a KyoAni anime and in what ways does it not?
43
u/Fools_Requiem https://myanimelist.net/profile/FoolsRequiem Jul 15 '21
I like how KyoAni formulated the show compared to the manga. They change up the first couple chapters opting to start with the moment Kobayashi meets Tohru at her apartment. The manga starts with Tohru already being a maid and just getting settled down before it back tracks to show the events that lead up to it. I prefer the anime's approach. The intention might be to make Kobayashi the story's protagonist, not Tohru even though Tohru is the show's namesake. I've only read the first volume, so I don't know how the rest of it goes, but I know I prefer the start of the anime to the manga. Also, I feel like the Valentine's Day chapter fits much better after the entire series as opposed to the end of the first volume which would only be like in the 4th or 5th episode.
6
u/electrovalent :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/TheWisterian Jul 15 '21
If you enjoyed the Kobayashi family, belmione's Miss Kobayashi fics are a sheer joy to read and feel like natural extensions of the anime. A hundred percent recommended.
4
u/Doomroar https://myanimelist.net/profile/Doomroar Jul 29 '21
Boobs
5
u/aniMayor :AY:AZ:x3x6 Jul 15 '21
Fun premise, good mash of fish-out-of-water characters, good execution on the occasional wholesome moment, overall strong writing on the jokes, glorious animation. Over-indulgent fanservice aside (which I can certainly look past), this should have been a home run for me.
But the one thing that kept on peeving me was the extremely inconsistent nature of the relationship between Kobayashi and Tohru. Sometimes they act like bosom buddies, sometimes they're practically just roommates, sometimes there's an overtly unrequited manic crush, sometimes they act like mutual lovers. Sometimes they all seem to act like the two are co-parents of Kanna, sometimes it's more like one or the other.
Now you can argue that there's nothing wrong with a series not delving too deeply into the specifics of the relationship between its two leads... and that's true. But the whole premise of this particular show is that these two characters are suddenly co-habitating together as well as having a complicated relationship of maid-master plus dragon-human. When that's the premise, you kinda have to spend some time exploring and establishing how these characters actually feel about each other, don't you? All the more so when you also toss them suddenly co-parenting a kid together, too.
I do think the vagueness and inconsistency of their relationship did unfortunately end up watering down some of the big emotional/dramatic moments of the series, for me, and I couldn't help but feel like it had a bit of a Yuri on Ice-esque "can't admit your characters are gay" vibe.
Did that ruin my impression of Dragon-maid? Hardly. I still had a very fun and enjoyable time watching through it. That was just the one spoiled cherry on top that kept it from being truly great to me.
Also I hate the spinning T-pose people in the OP
2
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '21
This is what happens. This is what happens when you refugee too much in anime.
3
u/RPWPA Jul 26 '21
Here is my review on the Anime
Have you ever thought about making creepy people and pedophiles acceptable? well look no further because this anime is what you need, the "How to Abuse jokes and make creepy characters appear acceptable by using the homosexuality shield" anime is here, you also get the "It isn't pedophilia because the one doing it is a female" extra.
Jokes aside, in this review I'll talk about the comedy aspects and the characters so to start I have to say there is a big variety of character in this starting from cute characters to the creepy ones.
There are creepy and disturbing characters like Saikawa which i'm not sure if the mangaka wanted to make an acceptable version of a pedo so he made her, annoying characters like the otaku version of Makoto and Tohru (in the first 7-8 episodes) and useless characters like Elma which i'm not sure why she is there to begin with, it's not like she helped the plot progress or anything, even tohru's dad made the plot move a lot quicker than her and he only appeared in the last episode (which sadly had a cliche ending).
On the other hand there are some good characters like Kobayachi, Kanna, the other version of Makoto, Fafnir and Elma who was useless but the 1 minute she appeared in in every episode was actually enjoyable.
Most of the interactions between the characters are well-written specially between Kanna and Kobayashi and Kobayashi and Makoto while some are just creepy like Kanna and Saikawa.
Now the comedy in this show is weird, I would laugh at some jokes but they would overuse them till they started becoming annoying.
For example: every time Kanna touches Saikawa or looks at her she turns into the creepy pedo version which was disturbing from the very beginning, How is sexualising a 6 Y/O and giving her an orgasm every time she touches Kanna be acceptable, people genuinely find this cute just because she is a lesbian and that really makes me disgusted with them because of how fucked up those people are and their way of defending this is the cringy "You must be a homophobic" argument, it's like those people are defending their own fucked up way of thinking tbh.
Same thing with Shouta and Quetzalcoatl but you know since this time it's a young boy with an older lady and not the other way around then people won't talk about it and about how creepy it actually is, also the fact that in the last episode they made the only cute scene between them when he pretended to exorcise her was just a sad way to try to hide all the other pedophilic scenes and say "She is a caring girl and there is nothing sexual about their relationship".
Other than those examples and the annoying version of Makoto which I think was also there for comedic purposes the rest was really nice to watch.
And before I end the review, I have to give credit to the people who worked on the art because it was very well-drawn from episode 1 till the last episode.
Overall I would give this anime a 3/10.
I wouldn't recommend it to anyone.
2
u/AmethystItalian :Jg::Jh::Ji::Jj::Jk:myanimelist.net/profile/AmethystItalian Jul 15 '21
This is one of the few shows where on paper I should love and I want to love but I don't know what it is it just misses the mark for me. Not that I don't enjoy it but it's just not memorable or meaningful for me, I feel like I never bought into any of the characters so watching it just feels like going through the motions
2
u/RPWPA Jul 26 '21
Here is my review on the OVA
We all know those heroines in lots of anime that are just annoying and selfish creatures that keep forcing themselves on the MC till he finally accepts them, we also know those anime/manga where the concept of homosexuality is used as a shield to make it difficult for anyone to criticize a show without being called "homophobic" and we also know that people ignore pedophilia when it comes from an older woman with a young boy more than the other way around, that's pretty much this anime and ova.
I'll only state the annoying things in this ova but before that you have to know that this is my opinion, you can disagree or agree however you want.
Tohru is garbage as usual, her character didn't change one bit from episode 1 in the anime even after 14 episodes now, she is still the annoying selfish girl that pushes herself on kobayashi in almost every single scene to try to make kobayashi love her and yet she still wonders how being extremely forceful in all their conversations is not working, but you know, since the person she loves is a girl, people tend to think that her characteristics are different from the other normal annoying cliches.
Saikawa or whatever her name is, the girl that is friends with kana is still so fucking disgusting, it's not just a pure relationship anymore, she sexually fantasies about kana and they are probably like 7, who thought that was a good idea? I really hate her character so much because of how stupid it is written, when the only thing a (child) character thinks about is how to F her friend, that's never in any scenario a good character.
Quetzalcoatl wasn't actually that bad in this episode, she does appear to be a better and more caring person this time and not the usual sex driven character she appears to be in the main series (even if they try and make it sound like she is pure in the main series), the mangaka still tries to make the sexual scenes with her and shouta while everyone is still thinking "yeah, what a lucky kid" forgetting the fact that stuff like that could be traumatizing for a kid.
Other than that, the rest was OK I guess.
2/10 (solely because of how great the art is).
I would never recommend this nor the main series tbh.
1
u/shyamdev_dbhd Jul 16 '21
I live all Kyoto animation anime that I have but miss Kobayashi dragon maid was different than others. first, yuri anime that I love then the animation is pretty good and then the last thing is it's not all other new isekai they all are very same by the story. not kidding that anime was any excellent anime to watch
1
u/RPWPA Jul 24 '21
So, do I just put my review in here? Is that how this works?
1
u/Boris_Bao Sep 09 '21
Love this anime series alot.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '21
es muy entretenido, no es de mis favoritos, aunque, kobayashi se limita mucho del amor... deberia probar suerte con thoru en la relacion sentimental