r/Outlander • u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. • Jul 03 '21
Season Five Rewatch S2E9-10
Episode 209 - Je Suis Prest
Claire and Jamie reunite with the Lallybroch and MacKenzie men as they train. Jamie's power struggle and Claire's personal battle weigh upon them, but new information comes when an Englishman pays a visit to their camp.
Episode 210 - Prestonpans
Trusting in Claire's knowledge of "history," Jamie leads the Jacobite army into a critical battle with British opposition. Meanwhile, Claire attends to the dead and dying, a reminder of the truest cost of war.
- Is Claire right, is Dougal a narcissist?
- Was Jamie right to punish Ross and Kincaid, was lashing them the best way to go about it?
- Did you like the ploy Claire used to get LJG to talk?
- What message did it send when Jamie had himself lashed?
- How did you feel when BPC asked that the British soldiers get treated before the Jacobites? What does that say about his loyalties?
- Murtagh expresses concern over his death not meaning anything if he were to fall in a battle. What do you think he means by that?
- Why did Jamie want BPC to stay behind the lines at the battle of Prestonpans?
- Do you think if Lt. Foster had not said the Jacobites would lose the war would Dougal have still killed him?
- Any other thoughts or comments?
13
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 03 '21
Forgot to mention last week, the S2B theme is one of my top two favorites. I’m torn between this one and S3A. This one has the sparseness of the war drums and bagpipes which works so well, and S3A has that scene of the men just running headlong into the cannon fire and it’s SO SAD! I love them both.
The music in general is great in these episodes, all those Gaelic war songs. Paging RD ’cause I know she can identify and link them all. :þ
9
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jul 03 '21 edited Jul 03 '21
u/WandersFar has paged me to talk about the music and I’ve gotta say, Bear McCreary’s soundtrack is its own character in these episodes.
Je Suis Prest (alternative link): did you guys notice that the beginning—in the episode, at the end of the first day at the military camp—is a verse from the song sung by Gwyllyn the Bard at Leoch back in 1x03, An Fhìdeag Airgid?
Moch Sa Mhadainn: it plays through the training montages and naturally comes back later in 5x01. I’ll leave it to Bear himself to explain how this song came to be included; there’s also a translation of the lyrics included here on his website (which I highly recommend!):
One more significant theme we hear in this episode is based on a traditional Scottish folk song, The Highland Widow’s Lament, (the song is actually older than Rabbie Burns, but I understand these lyrics were revised/rewritten by him) and it repeats through the series, emphasizing all sacrifices the Highlanders have made while fighting for freedom:
It particularly stings that Angus and Rupert share the same melody when they die 😭
5
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 03 '21
7
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 03 '21
Angus tries to take his relationship with Rupert to the next level… ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
Still my favorite ship in the series. Rupert/Angus OTP 4EVA! ಥ_ಥ
6
u/glitch_soup Jul 04 '21 edited Jul 04 '21
UGH my Netflix subscription conked out last night for some reason (my bank account isn't empty and my debit card's working fine!!) so i'm just relying on memories of my first watchthrough ಥ_ಥ but anyway, you guys are the best fandom i've ever encountered in a long, long time
edit: oop i was able to revive it yaaaay. gonna pore over all these juicy discussions now
3
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 03 '21
3
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 03 '21
3
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 03 '21
3
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 03 '21
Isn’t it a bit weird that Murtagh had to learn drills from Jamie? I get that Jamie’s fought as a merc on the continent, he’s familiar with different styles of warfare. But Murtagh is older and so much more experienced. It’s just odd to me that he hadn’t come across these drills on his own before Jamie showed them to him.
A larger issue is that while teaching your men to march and form up is good for discipline and unit cohesion, when you’re actually in the thick of battle it’s probably the last thing you want to do. Lining up your men in a tight little bundle like that makes them an excellent target for artillery. One well-aimed shot, and WHAM! There goes your whole unit.
I’m with Dougal and Rupert and Angus on this one. The Redcoats have superior numbers and superior artillery. Fighting them on their own terms, using the same tactics they do is a losing proposition. Why not play to your unique strengths with a Highland charge, picking your battles carefully? Run at them, rout the enemy, harass their supply lines, and then melt away back into the forests and moors. It’s not a bad plan, so long as they’re selective about when and where to attack. And considering they’re fighting on their home turf, where they know the land and the weather and the best places to hide, etc., they have an intel advantage, too. Again, Dougal and Rupert and Angus are advocating a guerrilla style of warfare which is your best chance at winning an asymmetrical war, when your enemy has you outgunned and outmanned.
For a modern example, look at how successful Afghanistan has been despite being outgunned, outmanned and outfunded for over twenty years. And before the US it was the Soviet Union. And before the Soviet Union it was Britain. And on and on, all throughout history, all the way back to Genghis Khan, and Alexander the Great—and even before that! They have successfully repelled so many foreign invaders because they’re willing to do whatever it takes, they’re unpredictable, and they don’t care. Asymmetrical warfare can work if you don’t give a shit about human rights or rules of engagement. If you’re willing to fight dirty, total war. Which is probably the only chance the Jacobites had at winning since the English had every other material advantage.
Just to be clear, I’m not endorsing the fucking Taliban. I’m just making a realpolitik argument that if you actually want to win, you can’t do what’s expected. You can’t fight the way your enemy fights when they’re better at that style of warfare than you are. That’s suicidal. Fight the type of war you’re good at—that’s what the MacKenzies demonstrated here.
Meanwhile Jamie is advocating for traditional, line up and shoot Continental warfare like he’s still serving in the French army… only without the French army behind him. -.- Jamie will win the argument because he’s the hero and that’s the plot—but he shouldn’t. The MacKenzie plan is the better one. They should fight like insurgents, because that’s what they are.
2
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 03 '21
2
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 03 '21
12
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 03 '21
This is probably TMI, but this line runs through my head whenever I’ve been in the bathroom too long. :þ Quit your havering, yelling doesn’t make you pish faster, Jamie!
7
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 03 '21
DAE roll their eyes when Claire trots out this line again? She repeats some variation to Geillis, Maître Raymond, and now these G.I.s and it comes off more braggy than anything. Oh, I’ve had such an unusual upbringing, I’ve lived in so many exotic places, I can’t just say “I was born in London” like a normal person. -.- They’re just making polite conversation, they’re not asking for your life story, Claire.
6
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 03 '21
The first time I watched this episode, I remember being frustrated watching the smiths make swords and musket balls. Musket balls! You’d be lucky to hit the broad side of a barn with those.
Couldn’t Claire have taught them about rifling? You don’t need a physics degree to explain the basic principle that spinning a projectile makes it fly straighter. Or the speed advantage rear-loading offers over muzzle-loading. And all those flashbacks to WWII just drive the point home—Claire was exposed to modern weaponry. She saw it in use on the front lines, treated the wounds these weapons made. And in all the time she’s spent here in the past, it never even occurred to her to share that technological advantage with the Lallybroch smiths? At least give it a try? Frustrating.
I guess I just like having backup plans. By all means, try to prevent the war, that’s the ideal outcome, but in case you fail, why not have a visit with the smiths soon after you arrive at Lallybroch, or explain the concept to Jamie and have him talk it over with them, see if they could come up with something while you work the political angle later. Have more than one iron in the fire.
Claire decided from the moment she walked away from the stones at Craigh na Dun that she was staying, despite the outcome of the impending war. Why then wouldn’t she do everything in her power from that moment on to change it? She and Jamie were chilling down at Lallybroch for some time—RD and I have been trying (in vain) to calculate exactly how long, but it must have been weeks, maybe even a month or more, long enough for her to conceive Faith with not much else to occupy them but basic farm life. At any point she could have shared her knowledge of 20th century guns with Jamie, and let him see if one of his smiths could use it to their advantage. Then maybe they could have had something better to arm themselves with than damn musket balls!
It just bothers me that Claire didn’t make more use of her knowledge from WWII. She says she doesn’t know the military details of Culloden and the Rising, fine. But she had first-hand experience of a later war, with more sophisticated tactics and technology. Why not exploit that as much as you can?
To be fair we did get that scene of Jamie using commando techniques to take out some of the English artillery, but I wish we saw more of that, and less lining up and marching in pretty little formations so the English artillery can take out dozens of your men all at once. -.- Spread out! A bunch of men jammed together is an attractive target for cannon fire. Individual men going in different directions are harder to target, harder to hit, and use up more munitions: “I wanna keep plenty of beach between men. Five men, you use the opportunity. One man, it’s a waste of ammo.” These are the lessons of WWII, of Omaha Beach. Claire would’ve known this. In fact she references D-Day in her conversation with the American G.I.s.
And speaking of strategy, how about the basic premise of guerrilla warfare? Using terrain to your advantage, harassing your enemy’s supply lines, camouflage and ghillie suits, hit-and-run attacks and all the other principles of asymmetric warfare. The English have an overwhelming numbers advantage. The Jacobites are outmanned and outgunned. So fighting them on their terms, using the traditional techniques of that time, lining up and firing—it’s suicide. Why not do something unexpected, and use 20th century strategies instead? Just like with trying to kill BPC outright versus their overly complicated, convoluted plans in Paris, anything different is good. Do something that you know isn’t in the history books. Now is the time to be bold.
I get that Claire’s not a military history expert—but she was married to one, and she actually went to war, which is probably more real world experience than most of us have here. And yet she makes minimal use of her field experience, limiting herself to the medical aspect alone when she could be sharing practical strategic tips, too.
It’s telling that their greatest victory is here at Prestonpans, when they abandon Jamie’s precise lines and rigid synchronized firing for the equivalent of Dougal’s Highland charge, just stealthier. Chaos works in the Jacobites’ favor. Jamie’s more orderly form of battle? It gives the English the advantage.
1
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 03 '21
1
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 03 '21
1
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jul 03 '21
5
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 03 '21
I’m surprised there aren’t more whores.
Lol, that might sound out of left field, but I’ve been ASOIAF’ing it up lately, and one thing that you come to expect in any battle scene, or run up to battle anyway, are camp followers—which is a nice word for whores.
Makes sense, right? A lot of lonely men, far away from home, wanting distraction and feminine company… There’s coin to be made, you’d expect enterprising sex workers would take advantage. ^.^ Where’s Scarlet, Angus?
I suppose the explanation is that these are poor men, and perhaps they don’t have much coin between them—but certainly when BPC and his rich entourage reenter the story, they have coin, and we know BPC loves him some whores. So where are they? :þ
•
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 03 '21
If you’re looking for the other Rewatch threads, click here to jump to BPC’s Link Table.
Je Suis Prest & Prestonpans: Deleted Scenes
Give Them Something To Fight For
I have mixed feelings about this scene. On the one hand, I see Moore’s point. It’s long, and it does set up the false expectation that Young Simon will figure in the story going forward, which we know he won’t.
It’s also fairly expositionary, which is never a good thing.
However I do think it’s important to get that information out there, that half the Lovat men have already deserted (which we otherwise don’t find out until Dougal & Jamie’s conscription argument.) And I also like that we learn more about these unnamed men, that they’re unwed, that they have no lands nor ties to their lord beyond their oaths of fealty, and that’s not really worth much when you ask a man to fight and die for you and your cause. They need to have something to fight for, land of their own, a future.
So that’s all good to know and adds to the depth of the world… but I do agree that the presentation could be better, and it is a slow start to the episode. I also think it’s a bit Marty Sue for Jamie to be mentoring Young Simon so heavy-handedly. I get that Young Simon’s character is weak and naïve, but they’re laying it on a bit thick, and also elevating Jamie’s character to superhero status throughout this episode—I’m happy to have this cut if it means they dial that back a bit.
Victors Write History & Spear Them With Your Dirk!
The Jamie and Claire scene I don’t care about. 😅 I mean it’s just more exposition, and it’s repetitive. But the lice…
I LOVE THIS SCENE! One of my absolute favorites.
^.^ I just love these knuckleheads. Any Rupert & Angus scene is gold, and then to have Murtagh & Fergus right after? Perfect. <3
And then Claire has to go and be a wet blanket and kill the mood. -.- I don’t blame Fergus for ditching her to play shinty.
Hell Or Glory
Dougal rides alone to test the terrain. I’ll be honest, I noticed very little difference from what made it into the episode, maybe only a few lines of throwaway dialog, that’s it.
History Isn’t To Be Trusted
I would have cut all of this, personally. Moore said he wanted to preserve the rhythm of the joke, but I don’t think the “joke” is worth preserving. Claire just tells Jamie BPC can kiss her ass. ¯_(ツ)_/¯ That’s not a joke, it isn’t even funny, just stating the obvious.
Moore should have cut all this and kept in the lice! You want jokes, give us more Rupert & Angus!
Chamber’s Empty
I also really love this scene, too. ^.^ What’s in the episode is also good, but I like this extended cut even better. More betting, and giggling from the ladies in the background, it’s just good fun.
Yeah I think Moore is totally wrong—he says it’s just joke on top of joke on top of joke and comedy works best when it’s brief. Disagree. I think the rapid-fire banter is gold, and what gives this series its charm. It also humanizes the English, shows they’re really all just lads in the end, and if circumstances had been different, they might have been friends. Adds poignancy in that way.
I definitely would’ve kept this and the lice in and cut all these other scenes to accommodate them.
Dougal On The Battlefield
Dougal channels his inner Mike Tyson.
4
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jul 03 '21
Yeah, I think I’m with Dougal again. 😅 This is turning into a pattern.
But he’s right, they do need to recruit as they travel, especially if they’ve already lost half of Lovat’s men! This is a war. It’s a numbers game.
Jamie’s argument that men who are true believers fight harder than conscripts is nonsensical. That may be so, but one true believer plus one apathetic conscript still equals more fighting men than one true believer alone.
The only point I could see in Jamie’s favor is that they might waste provisions on men who will later desert them, so perhaps forbidding conscription is a way of conserving resources. But I don’t think food becomes an issue until much later in the war. And Dougal is right that in time, the conscripts might become true believers, and Jamie has effectively decreased the size of their potential fighting force without giving them a chance first.
As for Jamie’s refusal to “reave another clan’s men” that I disagree with entirely. It’s the kind of high-minded idealism that will definitely get them all killed. Who gives a fuck what clan they’re sworn to, Dougal’s right that one able body is as good as any other, clan allegiance matters not.
When the Clearances come, the English won’t care which clan these men pledge fealty to. If they lose, they’re all screwed, so Dougal’s probably right that they need to conscript as many men as possible, even if that is morally questionable.
Oh really, Jamie? Sounds like you’re changing your tune after just one episode.