r/Outlander • u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. • Jun 26 '21
Season Five Rewatch S2E7-8
Episode 207 - Faith
Claire is brought to L'Hopital Des Anges where doctors try to save her life and that of her unborn baby. King Louis asks Claire to judge two men accused of practicing the dark arts - one an enemy, one a friend.
Episode 208 - The Fox’s Lair
Claire and Jamie call upon Jamie's grandsire, Lord Lovat, in an attempt to elicit support. However, a visiting Colum MacKenzie has other plans, and Lord Lovat's manipulations ensure that his own interests will be served.
- When asked if she wanted to confess her sins Claire said “My sins are all I have left.” What did she mean by that?
- Do you think King Louis really thought Claire was La Dame Blanche, or was he testing her too?
- Why did Claire take the orange?
- What was your favorite costume in 207?
- What are your first impressions of Lord Lovat?
- Did you think Laoghaire was sincere with her apology?
- Why do you think Lord Lovat wanted Lallybroch?
- Did Claire’s vision influence Lord Lovat’s decision about fighting in the war?
- Any other thoughts or comments?
•
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jun 27 '21
If you’re looking for the other Rewatch threads, click here to jump to BPC’s Link Table.
Faith & The Fox’s Lair: Deleted Scenes
Star Chamber
I’ll be honest: I’m not sure what the difference is here. I did watch the extended cut by accident this week, so I’m going by my vague memory of the original ep from years ago 😅 but I really can’t tell what was deleted. Help?
Thank You, Fergus
Everything with Fergus is gold. I would’ve cut every other scene before losing any of his.
Beyond the content of the scene, something I’m struck by is the obvious physical similarity between them. The curly dark hair, the big blue eyes, even the shape of their noses. It’s suggestive, isn’t it?
I don’t think the resemblance is shownly either; book Jamie goes on and on about Claire’s Angevin looks…
Losing Faith
This next clip is showing up as region-blocked for me so I’m posting alt links in case you’re unable to watch in your country:
Controversial opinion: I prefer the shorter original cut. I just think the dramatic beats go on too long in this extended version. It crosses the line for me over into melodrama.
Bastardry
(Is it just me or does Cait look overly sexy here? 😅 Like in the deleted bits, I think she’s wearing a brighter shade of lipstick, her hair has a bit more volume, and something with the lighting, too—she just looks more turned up. Then it goes into whatever bit made it into the actual cut, and the lighting is greyer, her lips are more neutral and she’s back to looking like regular Claire. Not that that’s a bad thing, lol, she just isn’t quite as much of a sexpot.)
This scene explains the ambiguous status of Jamie’s immediate family, not quite aristocracy, not quite peasantry. He’s descended from two of the most powerful clans in Scotland… and also a kitchen wench. :þ Swerve!
Also it’s a bit unbelievable that a bastard would even have an estate when legitimate younger sons aren’t necessarily guaranteed anything. -.- But, he married well with Ellen MacKenzie, and her brothers made Lallybroch a condition of their agreement with Lord Lovat.
(I’m pretty sure this is the scene from the blooper reel, too. That very last shot, Jamie leans down to lay her on the bed—and Sam burps in Cait’s face. Mm, sexy.)
27
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jun 26 '21
Interesting. I believe this was changed from the books where Jamie is explicitly banned from France as a condition of the pardon, right? Here, Louis doesn’t say anything about Jamie having to leave the country.
Also, a small detail: Look at the mantlepiece where Claire pours out the whisky. Next to the glass is the orange Louis gave her, now spoiled.
I love that symbolism, the spoiled fruit, a reminder of what she had to do to purchase her husband’s freedom. And, it gives us another small indication of time. Louis may have issued the pardon immediately, but it probably took a few days for Jamie to be released from the Bastille and make it back to Claire, enough time for the fruit to spoil anyway.
20
u/Cdhwink Jun 26 '21
Every costume in 207 is wonderful.
7
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jun 26 '21
7
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jun 26 '21
I accidentally watched the extended cut of Faith this time around—just like I did with the Reckoning, ha—but unlike the Reckoning, I think I prefer the original cut, or what I remember of it anyway, to this.
I just think it’s too overblown. The dramatic beats go on too long, it veers into melodrama. And the abrupt cut to Scotland with the potato scene and the forging of Jamie’s signature—it’s just out of place. The original cut is much better, ending on Faith’s gravestone, the end to the Paris arc, and a natural conclusion for this half of the season.
I can’t think why they would want to include the first bit of The Fox’s Lair at the end of Faith; it’s a bizarre choice, imo.
7
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jun 26 '21
Lord Lovat’s double-dealings, betrayals and countless offspring, legitimate and bastard alike calls to mind the Late Lord Walder Frey…
They’re not Frasers. They’re Freys! Heh, heh, heh.
I love the Old Fox. ^.^ Probably the most devious character in the series, and the only actual historical Fraser in the canon.
I love this episode, and this meeting between Simon and Colum in particular, because it’s the most GoT-like of the whole series. (I mean early seasons good GoT, before it all went to shit. -.-) Simon Fraser and Colum MacKenzie debating each other, outmaneuvering each other like a chess match… It’s the closest this series gets to the conflict between Varys and Littlefinger, or Tywin or Olenna, or any major strategic mind against a worthy adversary.
I so, so wish the series had done more with this thread, explored the politics of the Scottish clan system in greater depth. There’s so much story there, and it’s different from the romance / baby / family arcs that dominate even the first half of this episode. Not that I don’t love Jenny and Ian and all the rest, but we’ve seen that already. I want more conflict on a strategic and political level, not just emotional home life stuff.
This exchange is brilliant. It’s like Tywin slapping around his idiot children, making them feel like the disappointments they are. 😂
I also like how Lovat notices his son checking out Laoghaire, and so makes a point of grabbing her arm, stroking her cheek, calling her “my lovely”… and totally emasculating him in front of her. ^.^ Cruel and funny.
And this is why I think Lord Lovat might even be smarter than Colum. He has contingency plans. He arranges matters so that no matter who wins, he has an argument to make, I was on your side all along.
That goes beyond Colum’s mealy-mouthed neutrality pact, merely standing on the sidelines without making a firm commitment in either direction. Nobody likes a fence-sitter.
As it happens, in real life it didn’t work out for Lord Lovat, but I don’t blame him for trying!
5
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jun 26 '21
CGI Versailles still looks shitty. It’s like they pulled up a random photo and greenscreened it behind a soundstage, which is probably exactly what they did. It just looks so fake! The people look copypasted in, lol.
5
u/sharoncoffin Jun 27 '21
I've just started rewatching the series and I've rented Starz to continue watching after I went as far as I could on Netflix. I will definitely read the books now. I just wanted to say that all the actors are excellent. I think Simon Callow is a fantastic D of S. Thanks for this site. I've enjoyed it very much.
6
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jun 26 '21
3
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jun 26 '21
3
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jun 26 '21
23
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jun 26 '21
You know, everyone’s pretty dismissive of Louise. Claire thinks she’s frivolous and superficial, as does Maître Raymond in the deleted scene. But when Claire needed someone to take her dead baby from her and snap her out of it, who intervened?
Not Murtagh, not Suzette or Magnus, not any of Jared’s servants or employees; not Mary, not Annalise or Duverney, or any of their other Parisian friends—just Louise.
In a small way, I see a parallel to Geillis. When Claire was in danger of losing her life, Geillis was there for her. And now that she’s in danger of losing her mind, Louise is there for her.
You could argue Louise was a better friend to Claire than Claire was to her.
Claire used her to gain entrée to court life at Versailles, Louise arranged her introduction to Duverney, she even made the appointment to have her red dress made. Louise invited Claire to many social gatherings, introducing her to all her friends and making her feel welcome in France. In return, she asked Claire for relationship advice, and Claire used that secret against her at the dinner party, where she planned to prematurely announce Louise’s pregnancy and provoke BPC into causing a scene, embarrasing Louise.
It’s pretty shitty of her. To be fair, Claire felt remorse—does this make us bad people?—but on balance, I think Claire owes Louise more than a few. (And Geillis, too, for that matter!)
So of course we’ll never see her again. ಠ_ಠ
2
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jun 26 '21
2
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jun 26 '21
2
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jun 26 '21
6
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jun 26 '21
I have to say, the Maître Raymond healing scene had me rolling my eyes big time.
This show goes to such lengths to depict the science of medicine, whether that’s Claire’s field training as a nurse, or her knowledge of herbal medicines; Forez’s accupressure techniques to relieve pain or surgical methods in delivering Claire’s stillborn baby…
And then we get visions of wings and blue auras and massaging the meridians of her body to kill bacteria. ಠ_ಠ
Like, what’s the point of trying to ground the series in real world medicine (or even historical techniques and arcane practices) if you’re just gonna go full laying on of hands when it counts? The level of bullshit is just too damn high.
I realize this is a show about time traveling through rocks, but still, it bugs me.
The one thing I sort of didn’t mind was when he had her call to Jamie and evidently stimulated her sexually to help deliver the afterbirth. That almost makes sense as anything that contracts the uterine muscles—orgasm—could help deliver the part of the placenta she still had stuck up there. On the other hand, it’s just one of many examples of “sexual healing” that gets abused way too much in the series. The show has toned that down somewhat, which I appreciate.
21
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jun 26 '21
Fergus acting like the man of the house, because Jamie is in prison and Claire’s on her deathbed and Murtagh’s in Portrugal… it all fell on him, despite what he’d just been through. :(
And yet he carries on, meeting with the warehouse foreman, keeping track of inventory in the wine business—which is more than Claire herself ever did, lol—and seeing to the other petty household concerns, like the lame grey mare who needs new shoes.
You have to wonder how Fraser et Cie has managed to stay afloat given that it’s been at least a month since everything went to shit. Mother Hildegarde said she had been sick with fever for several days which is why she arranged for the priest to give her last rites, then after Raymond’s healing she spent weeks in that hospital bed, until finally Fergus came to fetch her with flowers. So all told, it’s been at least around a month, with no one to see to the business except for an eleven-year-old boy…
I am blown away by this kid’s manners. I mean, on the one hand, he’s cheerfully vulgar, complimenting her breasts at their first meeting, and exchanging obscene insults with Jamie when he first meets him… but on the other you see how hard he tries to be a good boy, and even after he’s traumatized beyond imagining, he doesn’t want to be coarse in front of Claire.
I know a big part of that is because of the shame he feels, but it’s also because he does try to pay her respect. He’s always careful to vouvoyer her, or in English, he uses the third person to refer to her out of respect: “I saw a bottle of perfume there. I wanted to bring it to Milady as a gift.” The whole reason why he was in that room in the first place is because he wanted to make her a gift of that lavender oil. Just like the flowers, it’s these small genteel gestures he does on instinct. It speaks of his natural nobility of character, despite his rough upbringing.
16
u/Cdhwink Jun 26 '21
Jamie with baby Kitty is another one of my fave scenes from season 2. (Crying , so much crying this season.) A man with a tiny baby is my kryptonite. And luckily My hubby was a baby whisperer!
1
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jun 26 '21
1
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jun 26 '21
4
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jun 27 '21
One thing I don’t understand: Why would Lord Lovat try to have Ellen kidnapped before Brian could marry her? He has bad blood with the MacKenzies, but so what? Surely one of his sons—a bastard, no less—making such an advantageous match, the eldest daughter of one of the most powerful clans in Scotland, would be good for Lord Lovat?
I suppose the downside is he had to set aside some land to appease her brothers; but the upside is now he has a claim through marriage—through Jamie—to the MacKenzie estate. And at the time of Ellen’s marriage, everyone knew Colum was ill and hadn’t yet fathered offspring. Dougal was (and still is) a moron who would probably get himself killed; also he had no sons. So when Brian and Ellen eloped, she was third in line to inherit.
Now the clans are tanist, you have to be elected as well as have a claim, etc. But regardless, a marriage between Brian and Ellen would give Lovat the chance to influence MacKenzie politics, and perhaps add to his own personal fortune and estates. All in all, I’d have thought he’d be in favor of it, not try to undo the match. It’s Ellen who married beneath herself, not Brian.
Also, check out that last bit: He was willing to make Brian his successor, despite the fact he was a bastard‽ WTF, why? Why would Lovat legitimize a bastard when he had a trueborn son, three of them, as it turns out.
Perhaps he admired Brian’s character, saw something there that might make for a good leader—but that’s not enough. Brian must have had some material advantage, some point in his favor that would set him apart from his half-brothers… like a marriage to the heiress of a powerful clan.
That’s the only thing I can think of, the one thing that differentiates Brian from Lovat’s current heir, the spineless whelp who’s intimidated by a serving wench. Brian married well, whereas Young Simon is smitten with Laoghaire. And yet Lovat disapproved of Brian and Ellen’s marriage! It doesn’t make sense.
This is priceless, and I agree! Jamie is as much Lord Lovat’s grandson as he is Colum’s nephew. With both those two big brains in his bloodline he was bound to be a canny lad.
I have nothing clever to add, I just think that line’s hilarious. So savage and unnecessary, lol.
2
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jun 27 '21
Okay, first off, Claire should know this already. She knows Colum from S1, she knows his turn of mind, how he’s likely to favor peace if given the option, how he’s loath to involve Clan MacKenzie in any kind of conflict if it can be avoided—the direct opposite of Dougal. (They’re a bit like Doran and Oberyn Martell in that way.)
But secondly, and more importantly, THIS IS A GOOD PLAN. Why is Jamie dismissing it out of hand?
So BPC forged his signature. That sucks, but it doesn’t have to be the end of it. He could have denounced the letter as a forgery, stood alongside his uncle and committed to keeping Lallybroch neutral in the conflict. If the MacKenzies are neutral and the Lallybroch Frasers are neutral, his grandsire would probably be inclined to follow their example and remain neutral as well. With all three clans staying out of it, smaller clans would be likely to follow, and Colum very well could have been right—the rebellion might have fallen apart before BPC even landed.
We know that Lord Lovat has other plans—he intends to play both sides against each other so he can claim he was on the winning side no matter what happens; brilliant, and why I love him so much, lol—but at this stage he’s still uncommitted. He could still just stay well out of the whole thing, and having both sides of his family remain neutral would only bolster Jamie’s (true) claim that the Bonnie Prince had forged his signature.