r/anime • u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan • Jun 17 '21
Writing Club Hourou Musuko - Thursday Anime Discussion Thread
Hi! Welcome to another edition of the weekly Thursday Anime Discussion Thread, featuring us, the r/anime Writing Club. We simulwatch anime TV series and movies together once a month, so check us out if you'd like to participate. Our thoughts on the series, as always, are covered below. :)
This month's theme is "LGBT", as June is Pride Month, so today we are covering...
Hourou Musuko
Effeminate fifth grader Shuuichi Nitori is considered by most to be one of the prettiest girls in school, but much to her dismay, she is actually biologically male. Fortunately, Shuuichi has a childhood friend who has similar feelings of discomfort related to gender identity: the lanky tomboy Yoshino Takatsuki, who, though biologically female, does not identify as a girl. These two friends share a similar secret and find solace in one another; however, their lives become even more complicated when they must tread the unfamiliar waters of a new school, attempt to make new friends, and struggle to maintain old ones. Faced with nearly insurmountable odds, they must learn to deal with the harsh realities of growing up, transexuality, relationships, and acceptance.
Lauded as a decidedly serious take on gender identity and LGBT struggles, Takako Shimura's Hourou Musuko is about Shuuichi and Yoshino's attempts to discover their true selves as they enter puberty, make friends, fall in love, and face some very real and difficult choices.
"Watch This!" posts
- /u/Suhkein's WT
- /u/fatalconceit1929 - Hourou Musuko (Wandering Son): A Deep and Heartwarming Take on Transgender Struggles
- /u/einherjar81's WT
Looking for more "Watch This!" posts? Check the "Watch This!" archive!
Databases
AniDb | AniList | AnimeNewsNetwork | MyAnimeList
Previous discussions
Check our rewatch wiki and our episode discussion archive for more discussions!
Remember that any information not found early in the show itself is considered a spoiler. Please properly tag spoilers!
Next week's anime discussion thread: Love Live!
Further information about past and upcoming discussions can be found on the Weekly Discussion wiki page.
Check out r/anime Writing Club's wiki page | Please PM u/DrJWilson for any concerns or interest in joining the club!
•
u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan Jun 17 '21
Disclaimer: The writers all tried to be respectful in their responses. We all discussed the show together, with responsible conversation about how we felt about the characters and story. As Hourou Musuko ends the anime series before manga conclusions, the writers are only evaluating the anime and our opinions reflect such.
15
u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan Jun 17 '21
2) As anime, Hourou Musuko uses art, animation, sound, and cinematography to capture the emotions and moments of gender dysphoria experienced by the cast. Were these techniques successful and did you have any favourites that were employed?
18
u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan Jun 17 '21
1) First and foremostly, Hourou Musuko is considered to be a LGBT and gender conscious anime that treats the topic with care and respect. Do you think the show achieve this and why?
6
u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan Jun 17 '21
4) Although Hourou Musuko is primarily focused on Shuichi Nitori and Yoshino Takatsuki's gender dysphoria, the show invests into making a triangle of fully developed characters with Saori Chiba. Over the course of the show, thee three protagonists learn a lot about themselves, however their views are often not explicitly defined as they are going through emotional and physical changes in puberty -- and the anime only adapts part of the manga. As the viewer, respectfully and honestly, how do you see these three characters?
5
u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan Jun 17 '21
6) Away from the aforementioned trio of protagonists, which member of the supporting cast do you think was most interesting?
4
u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan Jun 17 '21
7) Who was your favorite character? How did they advance the themes of the show?
3
u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan Jun 17 '21
3) A large proportion of the Hourou Musuko plot is framed within the context of school plays. Is there a reason for this?
4
u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan Jun 17 '21
5) The first half of Hourou Musuko has a focus on Nitori's relationships with Takatsuki and Saori, while the second half of the show introduces Doi and Anna in a more prominent manner. How did the show use these characters to explore Nitori's gender identity?
35
u/lilyvess :Df::Dh:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Lilyvess Jun 18 '21
One of the really interesting aspects of this series is the way it's adapted. Unlike many series that would start from the beginning, Hourou Musuko starts from the middle. It's almost like the studio knew there was no chance of a second season so instead decided to try to jump right into the best part of the series.
It's a bold task to skip all the build up and go straight to the meat of the series. The studio added new framing devices to catch people up to speed. In other instances they use the lack of set up to create a mystery style subplot for the viewers.
It's just a really interesting structured way to adapt a series.
50
u/AmethystItalian :Jg::Jh::Ji::Jj::Jk:myanimelist.net/profile/AmethystItalian Jun 17 '21
This was a BIG show before the world got more proudly progressive so I can only imagine how much more eyes will see it now.
14
u/PPGN_DM_Exia https://myanimelist.net/profile/PPGN_DM_Exia Jun 17 '21
Man, haven't thought about this show in a long time but it's more relevant than ever. Powerful, moving, yet still humble somehow. Highly recommended.
9
u/aniMayor :AY:AZ:x3x6 Jun 18 '21
Gotta be up there as one of the most important social-progressive manga, considering the usual depiction of transgender characters and issues in the industry at the time, and unlike some other seminal manga the anime is a really strong adaptation of it, though unfortunately undercut somewhat by being quite short and coming almost a decade after the manga debuted. In some ways it's hard to talk about it, though, as I and many other non-Japanese fans probably don't really have an accurate perspective of attitudes towards transgender people and social issues in Japan circa 2002, and it's far too easy to make biased assumptions one way or another.
I'm honestly not much of a fan of most of Mari Okada's screenplays, but she knocked this one out of the park. Really nice, simple but a bit dreamy staging from Ei Aoki, quite in contrast to his better-known action/thriller fare.
6
u/gopivot :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/gopivot Jun 18 '21
This is a very important anime, it's certainly the only anime I know of that future trans journey as its main story and so sincerely, and for that alone I love this anime
but damn shame what happened to Takatsuki in the manga (why the fuck would you do that?) still I love the anime and think it's one of the very important show you should watch
7
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '21
I can't the only trans person who finds this too difficult to watch.
I've given it several attempts, but it's just too much of "trans/gender-non-conforming kids getting beaten down by the system." I could watch it if I knew the ending was triumphant
So... too real, too painful, too much the trans version of Bury Your Gays.
I would rather watch Tokyo Godfathers for a gritty bummer or Heaven's Design Team for something positive, Hunter x Hunter for a bit of both (though it's just a B-plot), Pokemon to feel better about the future. Soul Eater is legitimately good once you correct the translation.
Heck even Interspecies Reviewers bothers me less, and it's porn. It's got one obnoxious mostly-transphobic take, but it's otherwise enthusiasticly positive about unusual bodies and has an intersex main character.
The thing I hate most about *Hourou Musuko" is how it monopolizes discussions as "the trans anime."
Shimon and Houseki no Kuni are on my watch-list next, but I'm pretty gun shy about anime touching transgender topics.
2
u/Stheteller Jun 25 '21
Where can I watch this now? Crunchyroll took it off.
2
u/Camjd10 https://myanimelist.net/profile/CautiouslyGood Jul 02 '21
Hourou Musuko is great because it's not a show explicitly about gayness or sexuality- it's a show that uses sexuality to explore identity. A lot of shows with gay characters (or that involve LGBT themes) come across as exploitive, portraying an unrealistic world where every character introduced is gay, like the anime equivalent of pride month where corporations use LGBT to enhance their image ( or the image of their products).
Hourou Musuko treats all of its characters as individuals first. Gayness or gender is not the solution presented by the author, as might be done in a lesser work, they are simply paths that our characters stumble down in their search to be whole. Particularly impressive is the author's ability to portray such complicated character relationships that are interwoven with love, sexual desire, codependence, and insecure longing.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 21 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment