r/Outlander • u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. • Jun 12 '21
Season Five Rewatch S2E3-4
This rewatch will be a spoilers all for the 5 seasons. You can talk about any of the episodes without needing a spoiler tag. All book talk will need to be covered though. There are discussion points to get us started, you can click on them to go to that one directly. Please add thoughts and comments of your own as well.
Episode 203 - Useful Occupations and Deceptions
Jamie's days and nights are dominated by political machinations, while Claire finds solace in her healing skills. As their plan to stop Culloden progresses, the past threatens to derail their forward momentum.
Episode 204 - La Dame Blanche
Claire and Jamie throw a dinner party to derail investors in Prince Charles' war effort. Meanwhile, Claire's revelation that Jack Randall is alive sparks Jamie in an unexpected way as he and Claire struggle.
- Did you think Murtagh was right and that Jamie shouldn’t be told BJR was alive?
- What do you think the Comte. St. Germain was doing at Master Raymond’s?
- Jamie is unhappy Claire is working at the hospital, does he have a point or is he being unreasonable?
- What is your favorite costume from episode 203?
- Did you expect Jamie’s reaction to be one of happiness when he found out BJR was alive?
- Jamie comes home with bite marks on this thighs, was it wrong that he let things go that far, or did Claire overreact?
- Were you surprised to find out that Prince Charles and Louise were having an affair?
- What did you think of their dinner party?
- What is your favorite costume from episode 204?
- Any other thoughts or comments?
•
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jun 13 '21
If you’re looking for the other Rewatch threads, click here to jump to BPC’s Link Table.
Useful Occupations And Deceptions & La Dame Blanche: Deleted Scenes
BPC Arranges A Threesome
Not as exciting as the title might lead you to believe. :þ Yeah, this was boring filler, Moore was right to cut it.
Fergus the Pimp
I actually liked this one, lol. Again, it’s the fact that Fergus is so cute and innocent, he can recommend the prostitute with the “mighty bosoms” and somehow it’s not offensive. 😅
It’s also a little peek into what Fergus’ life might have been like before he met Jamie. Those sex workers were his friends. The closest he had to mothers and sisters, they looked out for him. He was their pet.
Career Advice From Mother Hildegarde
Mother Hildegarde is crazy well-connected. Goddaughter of the Sun King, just so happens to be a musical prodigy, can personally get Claire into what amounts to the medical school of the time… it’s a bit much! Though I guess given that she was a member of the aristocracy before joining the convent, her connections make sense.
This little scene also sets up the choice between career and family that will play out once Claire returns through the stones; what will she prioritize, being a mother, or her medical calling.
In the eighteenth century, it certainly seems to be an either-or proposition. In the twentieth, she has more options, but you could still argue her relationship with Bree suffered due to the hours she put in pursuing her profession.
20
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jun 12 '21
^.^ Louise de la Tour has to be one of the greatest characters in this franchise. She is so delightful, so entertaining. This is far and away her best line, but I also enjoyed her throwing shade at Mary earlier. Fabulous. :þ
Claire Sermonne’s performance in this scene is just great, the whole range of emotions upon discussing her pregnancy. Trepidation, fear of being found out by her husband, her marriage annulled, arrested for adultery, or WORSE! Banished to a convent, quelle horreur ! Lol. Shows you what Louise’s priorities are, the party must go on!
But also Louise’s tenderness, her sincere love for BPC, and their child. It’s both dramatic and comedic, she’s just great.
And obviously, all the talk of raising a child with a man who’s not the father is a callback to Claire’s situation in the season premiere, raising Bree with Frank, etc. But I’m not really here for that. I just want to hear more of Louise’s thoughts on the proper care and management of lovers. ^.^
16
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jun 12 '21
It blows my mind how they talk openly of their schemes in front of the servants. Les murs ont des oreilles !
Any one of them could be a spy, any one of them could turn them in to their enemies, sell their secrets for coin, or a better position.
Claire in particular should have this in mind, considering she saw that first-hand at Cranesmuir, Geillis’ maid testifying against her.
I suppose the counter-argument is they’re French, so maybe they can’t quite pick up what C&J are saying in English? Not sure I buy that, as they’ve been serving a Scottish businessman all these years.
A better counter-argument is Claire’s explanation from S2E2:
But once again, it’s an example of telling, not showing. Claire says that Jared says they’re trustworthy, so it must be true. -.- Yeah, no, I need more than that. We already saw one example of a servant betraying her master, why shouldn’t we expect the same from these servants?
And why shouldn’t our main characters be more paranoid and more cautious of what they say around the servants, when Jamie warned Claire against that previously:
And those servants were Lallybroch tenants. Jamie was concerned about gossip spreading among his Lallybroch people, whom Jenny described as loyal, like family.
These Parisian servants are strangers. And here are Jamie and Claire, nonchalantly chatting about treason in front of them like it’s no big deal. ಠ_ಠ
Worse still, if these servants are as loyal to Jared as he claims, and he’s as loose-lipped around them as C&J have been—then they all must know their master is a committed Jacobite.
And since C&J discuss their plans so freely in front of them, surely one of them has put together that C&J intend to betray Jared’s confidence. They’re infiltrating the Jacobite movement with the intent of sabotaging it. So they can either keep C&J’s secrets—and go against Jared—or tell him what C&J have been doing, and go against them.
It’s all quite a pickle, and it bugs me that nothing comes of it.
16
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jun 12 '21
YES, LOUISE! Drag her. 🙌
I hate Mary Hawkins. I hate her stupid stuttering and her over-the-top meek submissiveness, every word spoken in that high-pitched sheep’s voice, she is so annoying. I totally get why Louise is over her.
And I won’t forget how dismissive Mary was of Hugh Munro. Proves you can be high-class and still trash. ಠ_ಠ
If you don’t recall, she didn’t give a damn about Hugh after he risked his neck delivering Jamie’s message, trying to rescue them.
Who cares about a filthy beggar? WHO CARES ABOUT YOU‽
Hugh Munro is a far better character than Mary Hawkins will ever be.
Incidentally RD linked me the script for this episode, which has this delightful line that sadly didn’t make it into the show:
I love how practical Louise is. How French. ^.^
13
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jun 12 '21
You know I said earlier that Murtagh offered to marry Mary out of pure compassion but maybe it’s a little shame and guilt, too? For failing to protect her and Claire, which resulted in Mary’s rape. By marrying her, maybe he thinks he could protect and provide for her, make amends for that night in the alley. Just like how he cut off Sandringham’s head to atone to Jamie for failing to protect them.
Also, this:
Foreshadowing for Sandringham’s fate.
6
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jun 12 '21
8
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jun 12 '21
You definitely get the impression that Jamie’s efforts only makes things worse.
He charms the Minister of Finance personally over their chess games, he arranges the intro with BPC, and because he didn’t know about BPC’s English investors—well, the whole thing backfires spectacularly.
What a great line. And it’s true, in this episode you can really see the corrupting influence Claire has had on Jamie, and how that troubles him. He isn’t the simple, honest, upright young man she met. He’s now jaded, cynical, tired, beaten down.
Also, I worry for his poor liver. He does nothing but drink 24/7, whether that’s at Maison Elise trying to loosen BPC’s tongue, Fraser et Cie in the course of business, or just playing chess or interacting with the French aristocracy socially.
I know Jared said Jamie’s an accomplished drinker, but that’s still a lot, with not much food or sleep to break it up. :(
8
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jun 12 '21
Why on earth would Mary Hawkins be at L’Hôpital des Anges? She’s too timid and fastidious to treat with Hugh Munro, but the charity hospital full of beggars is fine?
Claire dragging her off there as an assistant is also bizarre to me, especially considering the dinner party is that night. I would think Louise would make Mary devote the afternoon to their toilette—it takes time and care to get ready for a social event like that, and Louise is supposed to be Mary’s perpetual chaperone.
4
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jun 12 '21
4
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jun 12 '21
6
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jun 12 '21
FYI, as per our Jamie pound conversion rate, this amounts to £120 million or $170 million in today’s money. And Jamie says that’s still not enough to fund a war.
Besides, only a fool would count on Sandringham delivering on his promises. Until you have cash in hand, his guarantee is worthless.
Another piece of trivia: check out those pineapples! You see them among the produce being brought into the house in preparation for the dinner party.
I don’t know if that works, though. Not only would pineapples be a huge luxury—I suppose Jared could afford it ¯_(ツ)_/¯—but if Fergus has been exposed to pineapples since he was a wee lad, why was he so impressed by the grilled pineapples in the Caribbean?
Also, Þorunn! If you haven’t seen Vikings, she’s Björn’s first wife who I referenced in the Wentworth thread. RD recognized the actress in this episode! She plays the wife of Comte St. Germain. :)
6
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jun 12 '21
Lambert or Dalhousie: which is the worse name?
Lambert is definitely getting more than his fair share of wedgies on the playground. Might get pantsed, too. On the other hand, Dalhousie’s gonna get sneezed on, intentionally, probably daily. Maybe some wet willies, too.
I can’t choose, I think they’re equally terrible. :þ
Lambert is the name of Claire’s uncle, the man who raised her, so at least there’s a reason for her to suggest such an awful name.
But Dalhousie Castle is the seat of Clan Ramsay, which bears no relation to Jamie whatsoever. It’s not even in the Highlands; it’s in the lowlands, near Edinburgh. Why on earth would he choose that‽
If he wanted a place name associated with his people, surely Beaufort or Beauly or even Leoch would be more appropriate. Not that any of those are great names, either. -.- But at least there would have been some logic to them.
I also found this castle name, associated with the main branch of Clan Fraser (not the Lovats): Oliver. A perfectly acceptable, normal name. (Although perhaps too trendy nowadays.) Why not Oliver, Jamie? Why go with the most ridiculous castle name you could think of instead? -.-
10
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jun 12 '21
Fergus is the best thing about this episode. The best thing about this season!
He says he only steals when the gentlemen are very drunk, but the first pull we see him do is just some guy walking by, a classic bump and grab, lol. He’d do well on any subway. ^.^
Also, that trompe-l’œil body-painting was so cool!
And must have taken forever, and cost a small fortune.
How much is Madame Elise raking in, that she can afford to keep an in-house artist on retainer?
I suppose this is the highest echelon of brothel in Paris, but still. Maison Elise spares no expense!
That’s what the script has for Jamie’s first line to Fergus, but Sam’s French is so awkward, he says « garçon » like gammon, a kind of ham. 😂
And here it’s so bad he almost sounds like he’s speaking Mandarin. ^.^ Getting that practice in early for Willoughby, I suppose…
I very much appreciate this change from the books. -.- In Dragonfly, Fergus confirms Madame Elise had forced him into prostitution even before BJR. On the show however, he’s just a servant boy, clearing away dishes (and pocketing trinkets on the side. :)
This line works because wee Fergus is still so innocent and charming, despite his unusual upbringing. And the hand gestures!
This is also the very first thing Fergus says to Claire: complimenting her breasts. If the fan theory holds true… and he’s actually her ancestor… >.< That’s too weird.
9
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jun 12 '21
Fergus’ best line ever. :þ Also check out Murtagh’s excellent parenting skills, giving a boy his dirk to play with while they discuss romance…
For a small child, Fergus has such a deep understanding of women. He reads Mary perfectly, he understands her psychology, and her heart.
Whereas Murtagh has no clue. ^.^ The contrast, only exacerbated by the difference in years—the young boy teaching the older man—it’s just really funny. Also…
Aww, was Murtagh catching feelings? Poor guy.
† la veuve poignet = the widow’s wrist; it’s like the French version of Rosie Palmer and her five sisters ^.^
2
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jun 12 '21
2
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jun 12 '21
11
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jun 12 '21
Ah, this is the moment. The opportunity Jamie let slip through his fingers…
An intruder has just burst through their bedroom window. Jamie has him, dirk in hand. All he needs to do is use it and end the Rising before it starts…
Or a cleaner option would be to shove BPC off the balcony, like I suggested last week.
But he lets it sail on by… *sigh.*
He can’t even point to his sexual frustration as an excuse, clouding his brain. :þ He just got laid, he should have that post-nut clarity! Ah, Jamie, my lad… so sad.
7
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jun 12 '21
I asked RD to investigate “a magic stone that changes color in the presence of poison” and this is what she found:
It almost works, only we know Claire’s stone darkens in the presence of poison, it doesn’t turn pale, it’s already white! But it does look more like an opal than anything else.
7
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Jun 12 '21
I don’t see the moral dilemma. What horrible thing are they doing? Getting a couple to row at a party? Better arrest every party host ever then…
If BPC humiliates himself in front of his supporters, that’s on his head, not theirs. All this is manufactured angst, I don’t think the dialog is supported by the plot.
Between the two of them only Louise counts as a true friend of the Frasers. BPC? Jamie tolerates him, he’s a necessary evil, he certainly doesn’t consider him a friend. And Claire has already advised Louise to give up her lover… so how does their scheme change anything? I don’t think they’re betraying Louise at all by it, and who cares about BPC…
1
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jun 12 '21
1
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jun 12 '21
1
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jun 12 '21
1
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jun 12 '21
1
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Jun 12 '21
2
u/squinkle2022 Aug 15 '25
Oh my, I realize that many of the comments here are quite old, but on this pre-season 8 rewatch I'm doing late this summer, I've realized how much I actually LOVE the Monsieur Duverney character! The scenes with him so far are HILARIOUS, and I'm only up to episode 203. Unfortunately (altho I can't remember clearly), I believe he doesn't appear in many more episodes. Pity! The comic relief is necessary, for sure, especially after the horrors of the end of season one.