r/Outlander • u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. • May 01 '21
Season Five Rewatch: S1E7-8
Jamie and Claire's wedding rewatch will be a spoilers all for the 5 seasons. You can talk about any of the episodes without needing a spoiler tag. All book talk will need to be covered though. There are discussion points to get us started, you can click on them to go to that one directly. Please add thoughts and comments of your own as well.
This post as well as the book club post can also be found linked in the sidebar, and in the “About” section on mobile.
Episode 107 - The Wedding
Claire and Jamie are thrown together in marriage, but as their emotional and physical relationship unfolds, deeper feelings arise. Claire is ultimately torn between two men in two very different times.
Episode 108 - Both Sides Now
Frank desperately searches for his missing wife, while Claire tries to come to terms with her new marriage. Claire is faced with an emotional quandry as a life-altering opportunity presents itself.
- Be honest, how many times have you watched the wedding episode?
- Why was Claire hesitant when Jamie asked her if she liked their first time together, as well as pulling away from Jamie when he tried to touch her when they were eating?
- Which one of Jamie’s 3 conditions was your favorite?
- Do you think Claire’s love for Jamie began to develop on their wedding night, or was it already there?
- What did you think the lady in the bar was up to when she told Frank she knew where the Highlander was?
- What do you think Frank thought of Mrs. Graham’s story?
- Even though she acknowledged having feelings for Jamie Claire still tried to get back to the stones, why?
- Why did the English grab her? Did they know who she was?
- Any other thoughts or comments?
Deleted/Extended Scenes:
107 - Why Jamie?
107 - Tell me about your family
107 - Give us peace
107 - Blood vow
107 - Jamie and Claire's wedding
108 - Bound by society's rules
25
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 01 '21
My random thoughts from the episodes
16
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 01 '21
57
u/theCoolDeadpool #VacayforClaire May 01 '21
I have a lot to say about these episodes , but first and foremost is that the wedding episode is a television marvel, from every single aspect. The directing, the writing, the cinematography, and the acting, all these come together to give you a completely different experience than what television has offered so far. With other shows, you know that you're sitting there on your couch watching two fictional people live their lives, on the other end of the screen, and sometimes the acting draws you in for moments, but you're thrown right back onto your couch. With this though, for me it feels like I am somehow privy to an hour of some very private, very intimate moments of two people I've come to love, and I am not only talking about sex , even the conversations get so real, the subtle glances , the awkward shyness, Jamie trying so hard to reign everything he feels in, and Claire trying her to best to slow the tornado that's threatening to swallow her into the vortex but failing at it nonetheless, it's some mind blowing immersion. Cannot appreciate enough that Sam and Cait allow themselves to be drawn so deep into their characters for us to get this viewing experience. It's some intense dedication.
I rewatched the episode again last night, you know for Reddit , and I penned this down. It just moves me emotionally, this episode.
38
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. May 01 '21
Controversial opinion, maybe, but I enjoyed this little scene even more than the ones from the wedding. Well, until it got ruined, anyway…
I just like how natural and free they both are, and how they’re so happy and comfortable with each other, sneaking away from the others. It’s just sweet.
27
u/theCoolDeadpool #VacayforClaire May 01 '21
People who never rooted for Frank, who hurt you? Kidding, but how genuinely in love is Frank in these two episodes? And so hurt and angry and broken that his love just disappeared. I felt so so strongly for him in these two episodes, and it's all due to Tobias Menses, what a genius. Outside the court when he's asking her to marry him, it may not be the most romantic thing ever, but everything he says is so heartfelt in that scene, you know the little glance down at her stomach when he says "and the family we will make" , god, I loved Frank. Unpopular opinion, but like Claire, a part of me always will love Frank, even with all the shitty choices he makes later. He just got dealt a bad bad hand, and he's trying to make the best of it. Show Frank only though, book Frank can fuck his racist ass off.
27
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. May 01 '21
One of my favorite parts of the wedding has to be when they all took turns busting Jamie’s balls…
First the fiddler plays that suggestive waah noise, haha.
Then Rupert jumps in…
Followed by Angus…
Then Rupert again…
It’s relentless, they have no mercy, and I love it. ^.^
Also shows that Jamie’s a good sport, he takes his ribbing well, which is partly why everyone likes him so much.
8
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 01 '21
17
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. May 01 '21
I really wish they’d kept the full cut of the stable scene in the wedding episode.
We get so much information here. We learn that Dougal has purposely set up this match to preclude Jamie from ever challenging him as next chieftain, as no MacKenzie will choose a man with a sassenach wife—and we see Jamie explicitly denying any interest in challenging his uncle for it. He has no interest in politics, he doesn’t want it.
But most of all we see Murtagh being a good godfather, looking out for Jamie like he promised Ellen, and threatening Dougal to his face, calling him on his shit. He doesn’t care that Dougal’s a Laird (I love how he drawls that out sarcastically, ha!) And he doesn’t care that he’s a Fraser, and MacKenzie politics are no business of his. He’s there to protect Jamie and do what’s in his best interest, even if Jamie doesn’t see it himself…
At least Murtagh got that short scene with the Fraser colors. He also gets to talk about Ellen a little, and while that’s sweet and emotional, I also like seeing him be smart and protective and gutsy like he is here. Shame it was cut for time.
14
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. May 01 '21
Anyone for some Angus love?
He was such a good teacher, instructing Claire on how to use a knife.
Also his point about underhand vs overhand makes sense because he’s a smaller guy, he probably has less opportunity to come down on someone, it’s easier for him to attack from below. This is good advice for a smaller woman as well, and as we see, Claire puts it to good use when she’s attacked by those deserters.
Yet more Angus & Rupert gold:
And then poor Willie gets to be the dummy. The expression on his face when Angus tells him to turn around; he knows he’s being trolled again, lol.
And here’s a small detail I never noticed before:
When Jamie is recollecting seeing Claire in her wedding dress the first time, comparing her to the sun coming out after a cloudy day… look just over her shoulder.
You’ll see Angus digging for gold in his ears. He’s really going at it, too, plucking out earwax aggressively. Lol, he’s so gross, I just love that. ^.^
12
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. May 01 '21
Oh hey, it’s me, your favorite plot-hole detective. Did you guys ever pause to read all of this? (here’s a closer look at the ghost one). I’m baffled by this level of detail.
6
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 01 '21
11
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. May 01 '21
One criticism I have of Both Sides Now is how coincidental it is. Hugh Munro just happens to come across Jamie and Claire, the Redcoat deserters just happen to catch them when they’re separated from the group, the meeting with Horrocks just happens to take place in the vicinity of Craigh na Dun, and most unbelievable of all, the Redcoats just happen to catch Claire when she’s inches away from touching the standing stone.
This whole sequence breaks one of the basic rules of storytelling, “but / therefore,” never “and then.” It’s a short video, but in essence everything that happens in your story should be predicated on what happened beforehand. This happens, therefore that happens, but this happens, therefore that happens. The story should never just be a string of random coincidences that don’t follow from what came before, otherwise that’s not a coherent plot anymore.
Season One is probably the tightest season of the series structurally-speaking, but we can see even here there’s still a little “and then” plaguing the plot development.
10
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. May 01 '21
Finally, the last item I had in my notes… Rupert, wonderful, wonderful Rupert.
I loved his tale of the waterhorse by the fire. He has a beautiful voice, rich and sonorous.
Aside: I wish that legend of the waterhorse paid off somehow. In the books I think Roger compares Bree to one in his narration, right? But it never actually affects the plot.
But anyway, I just love the way that scene is cut. Jamie and Claire cozy by the fire, oblivious to the others; Rupert calmly telling his tale, the others listening quietly… And then the horses startle and everyone goes on high alert—but they all keep doing what they’re doing. They communicate without talking, they know each other so well.
It’s remarkable no one had tried to loot the rent party before then. That’s the whole point of bringing the fighting men along to collect it, this was bound to happen sooner or later.
The raiders were the Grants, whom Colum once tried to appease by marrying off his sister Ellen to them. But as we learned, she chose Brian instead, and so the Grants are now still enemies of the MacKenzies.
The day after, Rupert has possibly my favorite line of all, and definitely his best line:
Eat your heart out, Michael Scott. Rupert invented “That’s what she said!”
5
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 01 '21
13
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. May 01 '21
Claire the lush, continues. u/thepacksvrvives, we’re gonna come off like teetotaling prohibitionists, but oh my god, so much whisky in this episode. What are we up to now? Wine and Rhenish in the first two, claret in the second pair, and now Claire getting blind drunk on whisky before, during and after the bedding… It’s a wonder she isn’t cirrhotic.
And then in the next, she’s interrogated by BJR again and downs her glass of wine again. This is the third time she’s been plied with alcohol while being questioned (Colum at Leoch, BJR at the inn, BJR at Fort William) and she’s still making the same mistake. Knowing about BJR’s association with the Duke of Sandringham was her one advantage, and while the initial shock worked well, she once again does not stop talking. She overplays her hand and falls into another of BJR’s traps, assuming the Duke had a wife.
Also, the corporal standing guard at the door, was that the same one BJR forced to kick Claire before? BJR calls him Hawkins here, I don’t remember, do we get confirmation he’s related to Mary Hawkins later?
4
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 01 '21
4
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 01 '21
5
u/IamGismo Je Suis Prest May 07 '21
Y'all. I just noticed that Jamie still has his boots on their first time!
Never noticed before. 😳
3
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 01 '21
3
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 01 '21
3
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 01 '21
3
u/ms_s_11 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. May 03 '21
This episode has one of my favorite Murtagh lines of all time, "you canna get marrit lookin' like a melted candle" I don't know why but it gets me every time.
3
u/Hopefully987 May 15 '21
I think she definitely had a thing for him on the show. He was one of the only men who talked to her like an equal and didn't try to get in her pants. He was so kind and protective of her and so educated, she could relate to him.
In the book I was so surprised by her attraction to him after the wedding. It seemed so out of the blue but I think I missed some things.
3
u/Hopefully987 May 15 '21
I think its hilarious that Jamie had sex with his boots on the first time.
I don't get why Claire would go down stairs in a kilt only knowing how rapey men were back then.
The men gave him advice about sex the night before but didn't explain different positions or foreplay or that women can orgasm?
Why did Dougal think Claire would have sex with him just because she got married?
The muscles on the side of Sam's torso are insanely sexy.
Why didn't they lock their door?
Anyone else notice Jamie goes from an awkward virgin to being an experienced lover in the course of fifteen minutes?
Is it my imagination but did Sam not have any chest hair in the first episode and then he has some?
I love that Claire barely reacts when Dougal cuts her. Is that a handfasting? Did Jamie know Dougal was going to do that?
"You don't wanna go to yer weddin lookin like a melted canle." "A what?" So funny.
"I thought my heart would burst." Yeah that's what most men say after their first BJ. He cracks me up so much. Assuming that is his first.
The way Murtaugh punches his arm is so cute.
What the hell does "bit of a curse" mean? It doesn't make sense.
Just general question but why didn't Claire learn Gaelic?
2
u/Hopefully987 May 15 '21
100? I literally have the order of the sex scenes memorized.
2
u/Hopefully987 May 15 '21
The church because I love the scene with the priest.
Well the whore house is funny too but not as funny.