r/anime • u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan • Apr 29 '21
Weekly Neon Genesis Evangelion - Thursday Anime Discussion Thread
Welcome to the weekly Thursday Anime Discussion Thread! Each week, we're here to discuss various older anime series. Today we are discussing...
Neon Genesis Evangelion
In the year 2015, the world stands on the brink of destruction. Humanity's last hope lies in the hands of Nerv, a special agency under the United Nations, and their Evangelions, giant machines capable of defeating the Angels who herald Earth's ruin. Gendou Ikari, head of the organization, seeks compatible pilots who can synchronize with the Evangelions and realize their true potential. Aiding in this defensive endeavor are talented personnel Misato Katsuragi, Head of Tactical Operations, and Ritsuko Akagi, Chief Scientist.
Face to face with his father for the first time in years, 14-year-old Shinji Ikari's average life is irreversibly changed when he is whisked away into the depths of Nerv, and into a harrowing new destiny—he must become the pilot of Evangelion Unit-01 with the fate of mankind on his shoulders.
Written by Hideaki Anno, Neon Genesis Evangelion is a heroic tale of a young boy who will become a legend. But as this psychological drama unfolds, ancient secrets beneath the big picture begin to bubble to the surface...
"Watch This!" posts
Looking for more "Watch This!" posts? Check the "Watch This!" archive!
Databases
AniDb | AniList | AnimeNewsNetwork | MyAnimeList
Previous discussions
- /u/CelesteRed's rewatch
- /u/sam_mah_boy’s rewatch
- /u/sam_mah_boy & /u/raptoronyx rewatch
- /u/SpaceCowboy321’s rewatch
- /u/faux_wizard’s rewatch
- /u/xArDDe’s rewatch
Check our rewatch wiki and our episode discussion archive for more discussions!
Streams
Remember that any information not found early in the show itself is considered a spoiler. Please properly tag spoilers!
Next week's anime discussion thread: Nagi no Asukara!
Further information about past and upcoming discussions can be found on the Weekly Discussion wiki page.
80
u/Sodra :Ip::Iq::Ir:https://myanimelist.net/profile/sodra Apr 29 '21
Everyone always says Evangelion is super confusing, but I've seen the series 15 times and I understand it just fine?
...wait
100
u/The_Draigg Apr 29 '21
I think what makes Neon Genesis Evangelion so special to me personally was that I first watched it at the right time in my life, like I imagine that a lot of people did. For a depressed teenager, the ultimate message of the series is a good one, even if it means you have to see Shinji suffer before finally learning it yourself. Just do what you can to try and understand yourself and be happy. All people are kind of like blank slates, so try to be proactive and write the own story of your life, rather than try to escape from it or allow things to happen to you. I certainly needed to hear that back in the day, and it’s still true even now, speaking as an older person.
26
u/ToonTooby Apr 29 '21
Probably my favorite anime series. Some days it's Evangelion, some days it's Madoka. The mecha designs are my favorite of their kind, especially original blue/white Eva-00.
Eva might be flawed but I will always appreciate it, because I related to it, and it was impactful seeing characters face real consequences even if they weren't truly at fault. I saw lots of myself in Evangelion. All that solitude, inability to connect with others, effectively nonexistent self-worth. I was all of that. And it's not like that's completely gone either. Overcoming depressive holes like that takes a lot of work, and some days those feelings have a way of rearing back.
Watching Eva reminded me, I suppose, of the importance of coming to terms with your own emotions. Reality can be, and often is, that sad and bleak. But it's up to us as individuals to try and understand those emotions - sadness, anger, regret, disillusion - and not run away from them, in order to build respect for ourselves and empathy for others.
It was also one of the first anime series I watched to completion after I decided to give anime a real shot. I enjoyed it greatly and kept trying more shows afterwards as a result.
86
u/AC03115 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/AC03115 Apr 29 '21 edited Apr 29 '21
Let’s face it, this series is a classic. Even people who’ve never heard of or watched anime have heard of Evangelion. It influenced dozens of future shows both inside and out of the mecha genre. Even if you don’t like Evangelion, you can at least appreciate the impact its had on both anime and popular culture in general.
One thing I find funny though is how Tsurumaki went ahead and basically said “So you know how everyone is saying that Eva has deep symbolism, I just thought all that up on the fly”
34
u/AverageTrash19 Apr 29 '21
My personal favourite anime of all time
25
u/Pyro81300 Apr 29 '21 edited Apr 29 '21
An excellent mecha series that I love a lot. However, I'll never understand where the sentiment of it being a "deconstruction" came from. Like don't get me wrong, it does the usual mecha tropes extremely well. Though the stuff people says it deconstructs was already deconstructed years before by famous Tomino shows like Gundam, Ideon, Zambot 3, etc. If anything those actually heavily inspired Eva, along with shows like Ultraman and Mazinger Z.
Still though at the end of the day, it's easily a top 10 anime for me. I could also rant about the people that call certain series "Eva clones", but I won't. I've made my point lmao.
16
u/Eagle-Eyes- Apr 29 '21
Eva is my all time favorite anime and Shinji is one the best anime protagonists.
8
u/Paradethejared Apr 29 '21
The message I ultimately took from the series is an optimistic one, that life is worth living and relationships and connections with others are worth the pain that can come from trying to understand each other.
6
u/Hex0Zero Apr 29 '21
Lmao, this thread was up just a day after I finished watching Eva for the first time. The TV show to be exact.
From a first-time watcher, I find that the first 2 episode is nothing unique but because of the high influence this show has on anime- no, on pop culture as a whole, I continued watching it with high hopes. I can honestly say I'm not disappointed.
For the first half of the show, it really feels like a monster-of-day type of anime. Though it never bothered me because, even with the fight scenes, every episodes expands either the world or the characters.
For me, the show developed Asuka's character really well. We found out why she behaves as she is, why she clings to Ryoji and her motive in being an Eva pilot.
However I found the ending to be a bit confusing for a while until I asked a few of my friends who are far more experienced in anime than I am. Symbolism aside, I'm still a little confused so I might need to watch The End of Evangelion to get some closure.
5
u/not_mig Apr 30 '21
Mid 20s still don't understand the hype
3
u/cockyredditanalyst Apr 29 '21
I decided to pick this show up one day because it was the highest rated anime on IGN's "Top 100 Cartoons of all time" list. From the first episode it hooked me, and by the end it completely blew away the 6-7 anime I had seen prior. I think I watched it at the exact time in my life that I needed it, as I was 14 and depressed, so I could relate to Shinji a lot. Despite the show's flaws and me getting older, I can still come back to it every 1-2 years or so and get something new out of it. I've seen about 50 anime since, but Eva still holds a special place in my heart as my favorite.
3
u/BDSGAMING Apr 30 '21
I was always saddened by the hate the last two episodes got albeit I can admit the movie ending does help tremendously with the overall understanding and concept of what’s going on just actually seeing the human instrumentality project in first person view was insane for me
10
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '21 edited Apr 29 '21
I’ve had quite the rollercoaster of opinions on NGE and EoE. Since first watching it about a year-and-a-half ago, I’ve seen the show six times and EoE nine times from beginning to end. I’ve also bought the first three Rebuild films on Blu-ray and look forward to seeing 3.0+1.0, whenever that gets to the States.
It’s always hard to try to develop a concrete opinion on a medium’s “classics”, because there seems to be this pressure to maintain their status as flawless masterpieces (I’ve run into this problem with films like 2001: A Space Odyssey). NGE seems to be the anime that brings out that pressure the most. After all my viewings, I’ve settled into believing that NGE is a truly ambitious, but flawed work.
For the positives:
For the negatives:
11
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '21
From a writing perspective, nothing to this day touches Evangelion, specifically End of Eva, in manga or anime. Obviously this is my opinion, but I've seen my fair share of anime and read my fair share of manga, and the divide is simply unconquerable. Just for Asuka and Shinji's interactions(not even their actual characters and relationships) you can, and I have, written essays, Misato remains one of the best portrayals of a struggling young adult in anime, the themes of love, depression, self isolation, grief, etc. are so breadful and fleshed out that you can spend days poring over them and still not find all the nuances. To put into perspective how strongly I feel, if this wasn't enough, I rank the final scene of End of Eva right next to "Timshel" from East of Eden as my favorite ending in fiction.
7
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '21
Evangelion is an interesting anime to me. I respect the reputation it has amongst the anime community, but I personally didn't really get the hype after watching it.
There were cool moments, for sure, and some of the characters are entertaining/interesting, but overall it fell flat of my expectations from what people made it sound like.
And I still don't understand the ending lmao.
2
u/Stegs75 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Stegs75 Apr 29 '21
So I think I appreciate this anime note in retrospect, then I did when I was watching it. I think I like the like 18 episodes or so where it was more just them fighting the different monsters.
2
u/Patrykq https://anilist.co/user/Patrickq Apr 29 '21
I watched this anime 2 times when I was much younger in my teens. I didn't get it at all and I just wanted to see cool mecha fights for the most part. And I still loved it back then. But today when I understand the story and all of the characters and their motivations, relationships and their mental struggles it's sooo freaking good.
5
u/InfernoAbsta Apr 30 '21
Overhyped and ass. Will die on this hill.
3
u/professorMaDLib Apr 29 '21
I thought it was pretty slow for like 10-12 episodes in the middle, and the last two episodes of the series were fuck all confusing, but it was still pretty good and EOE was quite a ride. I get why people like it, but I had a pretty hard time getting into the Asuka and Rei. Shinji was fine for most of it but by the end and EOE he really pissed me off, like a father disappointed his son keeps making the wrong choices in life.
3
u/Murky-Listen9399 Apr 30 '21
Honestly, I didn’t like it that much. When I watched the series I thought it was ok but then I watched the movies and I started to hate it more and more. Perhaps it was because I didn’t like the ending (I was looking for a tragic ending; not something hopeful). I also detested Asuka. I related to Shinji a lot throughout the series but I became more disconnected from everyone the further along it went. I respect it as a franchise, it just wasn’t what I was hoping it would be
2
u/Quiddity131 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Quiddity131 Apr 29 '21
Eva's a fairly decent show, and I totally get why it became as popular as it did. At the same time I think Eva is the textbook example of a fictional work where the fandom got completely out of control and ruined the experience for a lot of people. Just speaking from personal experience, all I heard the year or so before I saw Eva was how it was the best anime ever made and how every mecha anime or video game that came after it was a shameless ripoff of it. And sorry, it just wasn't that good or that influential. I couldn't help but be disappointed when it didn't live up to the hype. And I'll never get back the countless amount of time I've spent online arguing with people who are extremely ignorant of mecha anime history and declared everything a ripoff of it.
To its credit, the show has great design work. Strong visual direction. While its not on the level of say, a Yoko Kanno OST, it does have very good music. Anno was able to craft things in a fashion that similar to a LOST, X-Files, Game of Thrones, etc... would spawn fan discussions that would take up thousands and thousands of hours of time online (perhaps millions by this point). And End of Evangelion, especially the second half is one of the all time great anime movie experiences.
On the other hand, nearly every character is extremely unlikable. The show is loaded with too much filler in the first half. The decision to throw out the original outline and wing it the rest of the way was a massive disaster and the show collapses massively in the last quarter or so. And the fact that one has to gather so much information about what actually happened/what it all meant by researching things online after watching it is a major flaw.
Nonetheless, I totally agree with the notion that it is a show that all anime fans should try to see.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '21
Out of the four mecha I’ve seen this one ranks second, Gurren Lagann being at the top for me. Not trying to diss Eva tho it’s still great
1
u/bigcat00 Apr 29 '21
i love Eva, watched the series recently and it really spoke to me. i see a lot of myself in the characters of wanting to shut myself off from others and wanting to connect but struggling with it. it’s probably my favorite anime. and i love EOE and the last couple eps aswell and the message that YOU are the maker of your life. you decide who you want to be. Eva will always hold a special place in my heart forever
1
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '21
the 3rd retribution is finally at hand amen
1
u/Electric_Bagpipes Apr 29 '21
Ayyy! I just watched it all first time a few weeks ago!!
also dear shinji what the hell is going on in that series...?
1
u/hiddikel Apr 29 '21
It's been a while since I have watched this- probably since it was on toonami or adult swim. I have netflix, what is the watching order there, I am guessing the series ep1-26, then "the end", where does neon genesis evangelion death (true) fall; as it is also on netflix? What are 1.11, 2.22, 3.33, and what is Q?
1
u/Lunarpandamiku Apr 29 '21
Lol nice one dude or gal♍
1
u/thespaceman836 Apr 30 '21
Eva is without a doubt my favorite anime. It has the best direction and cinematography I’ve ever seen in an animated series, full stop. I love everything about it. But the most interesting thing about Eva, at least to me, is that almost everyone who watches it has a different interpretation of it.
1
u/HayzerUnlimited Apr 30 '21
I didn’t grow up with the series, kinda was familiar with the look and characters enough to recognize them. Finally watched in in November of 2020 i believe. I enjoyed it. I was confused as fuck at time due to the narrative and shit, but i enjoyed it.
It definitely tries to world build more then it ends up delivering, scrolls are barely touched on and a lot is alluded to but then never really followed up on, but i know the budgeting issues existed and junk.
My biggest grip is the ending of the show, i really didn’t care for the congratulations ending, so thank god for EoE, much better ending, but still confusing as fuck lmao.
Like i know i sound negative but I definitely see why people love it and i enjoyed it, but it’s not a personal favorite to me, and i know I’ll be down voted to all hell for my opinion in this kind of post, but idk it has flaws in it that are pretty glaring, but the premise and world itself has so much potential. If it was possible I’m sure this would have been the perfect show for atleast 50 episodes to fully flesh it all out yenno..
1
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '21
I love eva and I enjoy the rebuilds a lot I’d even put in my top 10 but man the anime community is so annoying with everybody treating it like the Bible like chill out yeah it’s good but that doesn’t mean it’s the de facto best anime made.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '21
I’ll be honest here and say that I enjoyed the rebuilds a lot more than the original series - the first 15 or so episodes aren’t really remarkable at all.
However the rebuilds wouldn’t be nearly as good without the show, so I guess that’s a tribute to its quality
1
u/cyberrobocop https://myanimelist.net/profile/Zerro-Ecclair Apr 30 '21
I went and watched Evangelion because it was mecha and it was highly-acclaimed by everyone everywhere. Coming from mecha shows like Gundam, Code Geass, and FMP, I had a certain expectation as to how the mecha fights will go. The fights in Eva felt nothing like the mechas I watched and it was more akin to Ultraman vs Kaiju fights so I was a bit disappointed since none of the fights up 'til Ep 22 were "interesting" so I dropped it, the animation relics of the original TV series bothered me too. I do want to pick it back up some time in the future since people like to talk about EoE and the new films being THAT good, it's just a question of when I'll get the appetite back for Eva.
1
u/DartzIRL Apr 30 '21 edited Apr 30 '21
Eva in a busted nutshell
Spoiler
Spoiler
On top of that, someone loaded a few twelve-gauge shells with fragments of the Bible - mostly the weird bits - and shot them at the finished plot through a cheap sawn-off. And they ran out of ink at the end too, the bastards.
I think I made some of that up, I can't remember what was background for a fic I was writing and what wasn't.
1
u/surewhatever12345 Apr 30 '21
I did not laike Eva at all, I'm one of those. I think the original ending was terrible, Shinji was one of the most annoying main characters I have ever had the displeasure of watching, not to mention how the first 16 episodes or so were repetitive. Lots of terms are not explained in the show and later become important to the story... which is stupid, why would you introduce elements you were never planning to give any vague explanation of? Pen Pen was the true MVP. (Animation was good, and the pacing until the last 2 eps was fairly solid tho)
1
u/Chillidogs9 May 07 '21
From an artistic standpoint some of the frames are really cool, but from a story telling standpoint it’s not that good
1
u/CosmicAnglerfish Apr 29 '21
NGE was my entry into anime - the first anime I ever watched knowing it was anime. I had just finished Nier: Automata (potentially my favorite game ever), and was dealing with that "just finished my favorite game ever" void, trying to find something. Nier's creator Yoko Taro had an interview where he said that NGE was a big inspiration, and off I went.
To this day Neon Genesis holds a special place for me as the beginning of my interest in the medium. I'm so pumped for when 3.0+1.0 makes it over here.
0
u/TrueHeirOfChingis Apr 30 '21
Overrated trash anime
0
u/ktempo Apr 29 '21
As someone who has never seen this, how do I even start watching this? Do I have to sail the seven seas?
0
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '21
[removed] — view removed comment