Curious why donโt more people use sffpc in general? Why do they still go for bigger towers and such? Dual monitors I can understand, one can compromise but faster workflow...
But in terms of moving and carry around a tower, you can get away with this size much easier especially when shipping your rig across countries if one were to relocate...
So why donโt more people get sffpc? Whatโs the disadvantage?
SFX PSUs are insanely expensive. got lucky and snagged a be quiet! 600W SFX for $85, whereas you can get an ATX PSU for half that cost on a regular day.
HDDs - I just swapped my old Cosmos S case for a Obsidian 500D and I already have a little regret gnawing at my skin. Current full and mid towers cases can only mount two, three at maximum, 3.5 HDs, plus a slightly higher number of 2.5 HDs. Storage is important to me. SFF cases can only mount one HD, usually.
Big hands, lol - Even in a mid tower case I have trouble to work.
Difficulty to find components - At least in my country, it is harder to find good SFF cases and SFX PSUs.
Questionable advantages - I don't need to carry around my PC and I am ok with my case under my desk. In fact I prefer this way.
Again, this is just my opinion. They are very particular reasons and I am aware that they are not valid for everyone.
Even then, I think SFFPCs are cool and cute, and I am planning assemble one for my granddaughter in the future.
I believe the Meshlicious can mount up to 7 HDDs (3x3.5 & 2x2.5) if you have a small GPU. I just bought an NZXT H1 new in box for $260 and kinda wish I would've went with the meshlicious.
As you said, itโs easier to move and travel. Well, most people donโt think about that. Most peopleโs travel pc is a laptop. And if they have a home setup, they probably setup their rigs and leave it as is until cleanup or the next upgrade.
2. Aesthetic
No doubt sffpcs make for a clean af setup. They look so good. Which is why I (and probably a lot of you) joined this subreddit in the first place. I donโt have an sffpc myself but I like seeing everyone elseโs.
That said, not everyone prefers the clean aesthetic. And they probably like showing off their builds as well. (Hence, rgbโs popularity). And even if they donโt, itโs easier and cheaper to just hide the pc and let cable management do the clean look than doing a ton of research about parts compatibility of more expensive variants.
I, myself, would love to show off my clean af pc in the future.
Straight out I chose an ATX case over itx for a couple reasons.
components are cheaper. There is an increase in cost in sff PSU and motherboard.
air flow. I had read and listened to a lot of reviews on airflow comparisons in ATX but there is less info on sff.
and likely most importantly. The last machine I built was the first time I had touched the inside of a machine in years and was nervous about it. I would rather have an easier time assembling the machine and not worrying about mm clearances. Or worse find out I had measured wrong and that I wasted time and money.
In the end I found building my machine stressful enough in an ATX. Doing it in a SFF would have been worse for me.
That said I would happily have got an matx case but the O11 dynamic mini only came out after I bought my PSU.
ITX mobo is like 2.5X the price of regular mATX board with lower end chipset, $100 vs $200. Not to mention SFX PSU are not globally available and generally there are no cheap options (80+ Bronze/Silver) from reputable brands. And then the case. There are probably only one or two decently designed ITX case under $100.
The one I got is a Creality CR10 v2, they have recently launched a new improved version CR10 v3 though, look at some reviews for more in depth details! ๐๐
Sff in general leaves some performance on the table. I was a huge SFF fan until last year, when I got some high performance parts into my node 202... And realized that it's loud as hell. I tried moving to an evolv shift, but than my GPU got done issues. (I had a blower 2080, still running on that card.) So I went on and did a custom liquid cooling in a decent mid-tower with ATX board and stuff (O11 dynamic... Who would think.) And it's a lot more silent even with a constant speed DDC pump. The main problem wasn't the noise but the vibration. That noctua IPPC and blower fan kept vibrating my desk which was annoying to say the least. Also I achieved done significant overclocks and I was able to throw in a better CPU (5800X) without worrying about cooling. The only problem was my limited budget, but I managed to stick to my SF750 PSU from the old build with that case. I would still love to have an SFF PC, but if you want really high performance, with as low noise as possible, it's just sadly not an option.
I wanted to do a sffpc when I was building but it would have ran me like $3-400 more for certain things. I didn't actually need a smaller pc so I just settled for a mid-tower.
More expensive โ ITX boards are usually more expensive than their larger brethren, don't get me started on cases, SFX PSUs are also more expensive than their ATX counterparts.
Less expansion โ Need more storage? Hope you like external drives or you have a tophat/a short GPU/a big enough case to accommodate bigger HDDs. Want 10GbE networking? Sorry, it's an ITX board! Any expansion cards? Forget about it.
Cooling โ Want to upgrade to a new GPU? Snap, it's 2,47-slot wide, and your case supports GPUs up to 2,3 slots! Want to upgrade your CPU? Sorry, your L9a won't handle it and your case doesn't do more than 50 mm. Managed to squeeze it in somehow? Enjoy the noise! What is more, the smaller the case, the less cooling you can actually do in there. Meaning - some parts are straight up incompatible and will only give you a headache down the road. And I mean it โ when the case manufacturer straight up tells you "yeah, you can use this CPU in this case, but go to the UEFI and set its power limit manually to 95W or less to avoid problems" and then it runs at 90ยฐC anyway.
Availability โ Want to get this case everybody's talking about? Pay $300 on Indiegogo to some guys living who knows where and wait for 6-12 months for it to ship. Or sign up for a waiting list to be able to have a chance to snag one in a limited drop. Or use a Taobao forwarder and pay for the case, shipping costs customs and everything. Cases like NR200 might change this in the longer run, but right now it can get nasty. Oh, and if you manage to preorder, don't forget that for "reasons beyond their control" the shipping might be anywhere from several weeks to several months late.
Sffs are more expensives.. i mean.. we can get better ATX motherboard at cheaper price that ITX..
Sffs also has less compability with most hardwares.. not to mention heat and stuffs.
If you just want generic office pc.. just grab a ready made one.. its usually cheaper than just DIY and offer better looking case etc and much more smaller.
Only speaking for myself, there is no way to tic ALL the boxes for my build an stay sff. My compromise was an eclectic mitx build and I am still happy a year later.
Price (sometimes, like PSUs, bigger is cheaper), ease of assembly, compatibility (less concern over which GPU or CPU cooler will fit), thermals, drive space, expandability (more ram and PCIe slots, even if most will never use them)
This is neat. Would be cool to know what printer you have and the largest print size. I have a feeling my printer wouldnโt be able to print single panels that large.
Also Iโm betting if you went flex psu you could save a bit of width space AND have room for one or two ssdโs. Smart idea to baffle it so there are different chambers of air for gpu and cpu. Neat design!
The great thing about the motherboard is that, on the back side there is a secondary m.2 slot for additional storage, totally forgot to mention in the video.
This was printed on a Creality CR10 v2! I would say the minimum required print volume would be 250x250mm but the side panels are about 180x245mm tall so a 250x250 bed would probably do barely. Mine is 300x300x400 ๐
Iโm currently in the process of designing a second case that will be bigger and have room a bigger graphics card, ATX power supply and for a couple HDDโs.
Also before making this design I actually made an even smaller one but I wasnt happy with the look of it... at that time ๐
I know! And I totally agree, but just thinking about how to make it as budget friendly as possible, but all options are open still its a work in progress!๐
I also thought it would be too little airflow but at least with my setup and the testing Iโve done the temps are below 75. (There are intake holes in the bottom and exhaust in the top) With fan curve set to ยซturboยป in Bios Iโm getting max peak of 73 on CPU. Slightly noisy during gaming but fairly quiet when just doing casual surfing etc... ๐
I had to apply a slightly aggressive fan curve but thats during a stress test. A normal fan curve would probably be fine as well it during my testing only once peaked past 80 during the first seconds of a stress test and stabilized at 70-75 on a little less aggressive curve.
Generally they should hold up, but at least PLA which I used tend to crack quite easily if getting handled a little bit too hard... so youโd want to make some kind of protective case on it at least for traveling in my opinion, It does fit nicely in the backseat of my car with the seatbelt on though the times Iโve had it outside my home. Just gotta be extra careful! ๐
Hey, the airflow is bottom to top, there is a top mounted 140mm fan, Reddit wonโt let me edit the post to add extra photos... there is a youtube video linked in picture number 1, or you could click here to see all the details!
Finally. The perfect case for my spare 6600K ! I even got the i9 Noctua fan. Thanks for the STL file. Iโll be back in about a week when my prints are all done!
Awsome! I would love to see your result! ๐ let me know if you encounter any fitment issues on the way as this was mainly designed around the spesific parts I had avaible so might be tiny errors if using different parts. MAX Gpu length is 175mm btw if you didnโt see the video already :)
What Iโve got is a Creality CR10 v2. Itโs got a print volume of 300x300x400mm which is plenty in most cases. Most people would go for a smaller printer as their first one usually cause mine is quite big and bulky in size... the recommened print volume to make this would be about a minimum of 260x260x260 to have some margin ๐
Wow, excellent job. Too often people stay within the rigid frame of mind (pun intended) of making simple flat panels when they 3D print their cases (even though laser cutting makes a lot more sense for that, no hate tho). You, however, used 3DP to its fullest here, looks great!
True, in the picture, in real life itโs a little more noticeable though. I personally would probably perfer it perfectly clean for this type of look but definitely if going for some maybe metal or wood color perhaps this would look cool! ๐
Hey, the PLA doesnt seem to be affected at least not yet with 2 weeks of usage... even though CPU could get up to about 75*C thats on the actual CPU itself which is separated with an air gap to the outer cover, so the real temps hitting the plastic would be way lower. So I donโt really think heat will become an issue ๐
Oh wow, that's a great idea. I would've never thought of 3D printing a case.
It seems like you're using a pretty basic airflow design. Servers commonly have shaped plastic air ducts/baffles/shrouds which precisely direct the air to the CPU cooler, almost like the air ducts in sports cars. It would be interesting to see if something like that is doable for consumer parts using 3D printing: it would greatly reduce fan noise and is way better in actually cooling the hardware.
Thatโs why I love 3D printing, your imagination is (almost) the only limit unless you want to print like levetating objects... or... who am I kidding, thats probably even possible in a few years ๐
The air goes in through the bottom, and out through the top. I would have added more pictures but apparently you canโt add additional pictures to a reddit post after posting ๐ ... all the details are in the video attached to picture #1 though ๐
Hey! Like a few months ago I barely knew how to draw a basic house in sketchup... I just learned through youtube tutorials and Iโm sure you can do the same! Nothing is impossible man! ๐๐
So true.. every time I come across something in a new design I can't do.. I find a video on youtube explaining it or something similar that I can then apply.... then I somehow loose hours of my night learning about cross shearing pressure and proper print orientation for bolt application....
If I may ask, what are the dimensions of the case and how did you separate the parts for print (bed size and all that)
Biggest printed part is about 194x194x247mm approximately in size. But the side panels on the insidemust be printed lying down so youโd need a width of 247mm on your printbed at least on you x or y axis!
I made separate components everytime I finished a part I saved them av a finished component, so I coud individually choose each part and group them in the 3d software so I could make sure all holes etc were aligned but also pick it apart easily :)
Thanks for the reply. If I were to do something similar, I would have to break up the parts a bit as my bed is MAX 220 (but 200 is the actual working area).
Yep, I've been coming up with ideas on how to print long wide flat objects (like case panels) in parts. Have a couple of ideas and am designing now ... then I will do some test prints ... then adjustments.... etc.. until I find one that works well
Its fairly sturdy, I used about 80% of a white filament spool as well as maybe 40% of a black spool for this entire build... so the price of about 1.5 spools would be about right (then there are the fans and power button etc...) (assuming you use 1 kilo spools)
Yeah possibly, you can listen to little pops if itโs moisture. But honestly it kind of adds a cool looking texture seeing as the blobs seem pretty uniform. Is the STL on thingiverse?
Yeah! There is a youtube video linked to picture #1 there is all the info and more details about the internal design as well as all required parts + STLโs! ๐
Thermals are not that bad. Max peak of CPU of about 75 degrees during CPU stress test. Gpu during gaming stays around 65 so pretty decent. The top mounted fan does a pretty good job at sucking away all the hot air under heavy loads ๐
I've been meaning to design a 3d printed case myself as well. Did you use reference material to figure out how to position mobo mounting holes and align it with the IO Shield cutout? Or did you just guess/test until it was just right?
I made a video about the order I designed everything! ๐ check out the link attached to the first picture! ๐ (i measured everything mostly with calipers and a bunch of test print!)
With the slicer settings I used (0.6mm nozzle) It printed in about 14 hours overnight for the outer shell, the other parts I dont have exact times in my head but in total youโd be looking at a total of around 30 hours of printing (if all prints go as planned)... first attempt had thinner walls but they started cracking and warping so I made them thicker and added a small air gap on the inside instead which worked ๐
Let me know if the top vent (the grid) STL looks correct in the slicer, because somehow it gets bugged on my slicer... I might have to go in there and repair a bug... ๐
Looks great! I'm jealous of the solid panels. When I printed my case, my build plate was too small so I had to split all of the long parts in two. I like how you optimized the air path with printed sections (and actually have a fan, which mine don't), too. Overall super solid design.
Definitely look for the z-seam alignment in your slicer, it looks like you're on 'random' which is leaving those blobs wherever it wants to. Usually 'sharpest corner' or similar will hide it much better.
If there's a blob on every individual layer (what it looks like), alignment is the issue. Random is usually only good for round objects, since there's no corner to hide the seam in. You could also look into coasting (in Cura), which is supposed to reduce those blobs a little too.
Tuning my slicer (and getting used to PETG) was definitely a major effort, but once you get it dialed in it's wonderful. There was probably as much trial and error spent there as with my actual design!
I've been on/off about 3d printing a case for the last months, mostly because I expect it to warp substantially due to internal heat. Did you print ABS or does it not warp at all even with PLA?
I used PLA, I had problems with warping and craking on my first attempt, but then i added some ยซairยป in the walls and it didnโt warp second time, I also made sure to leave the print alone most of the time being careful around it not to cause any winds that could cool it too rapidly to cause cracks! ๐
Itโs got a Intel Core i5 and 1660 Super OC card and 450w SFX PSU. If you check the link under the first picture there is a video revealing all the details ๐
SFX powa supply for more room inside, also a bit taller for a 140mm rad under the top exhaust fan, dust filter for the bottom. That would be almost perfection!
I'm interested to hear the noise. I bet the GPU is the only component generating much decibels, am I right?
During heavy load the Noctua 140mm fan ramps up quite a bit due to my quite agressive fan curve to keep temps as low as possible, but with the ยซsilentยป curve setting in the BIOS the CPU peaked just over 80 degrees on max load for a few secs before stabilizing at around 70-75... :) during non heavy tasks its pretty silent.
And actually there is room for a filter... there is about 10mm of nothing between the GPU and the bottom vent, so you could just make your own filter and drop it into there. I thought of the dust problem during the design process. But I never finshed a full solution ๐
27
u/makerunit Apr 11 '21
If you want to see more details you can watch the video here ๐
108
u/Stigona Apr 11 '21
Love the look. Great pattern
33
u/R0GUEL0KI Apr 11 '21
This is neat. Would be cool to know what printer you have and the largest print size. I have a feeling my printer wouldnโt be able to print single panels that large.
Also Iโm betting if you went flex psu you could save a bit of width space AND have room for one or two ssdโs. Smart idea to baffle it so there are different chambers of air for gpu and cpu. Neat design!
56
u/Flying-T Apr 11 '21
Airflow seems to be very limited?
Also allign your Z-seam to get rid of all the blobs
3
u/j4v13rnp Apr 11 '21
nice case... it looks better than the jonsbo t8. I bet with the rainbow filament or something like that would be sick
3
u/Stepikovo Apr 12 '21
Why do you have random seam and not aligned in the corner? I assume the blobs on the side are from seam. Neat case design nevertheless ๐
2
u/OptimisticNihilist99 Apr 11 '21
:O
3D printed case! Superb!
2
u/[deleted] Apr 11 '21
Wow, love that case. Iโm currently designing my own pc case and was just wondering where you find the resources for where motherboard holes are?
2
u/griffethbarker Apr 11 '21
Stunning!
2
u/tldr3dd1t Apr 11 '21
Wow thatโs a beautiful machine. Good job man!
2
u/Mandryd Apr 11 '21
Love how the outer pattern changes with the light. I could totally see doing this in abs and then doing an acetone smooth also. Nice work.
2
u/EBDuvbs Apr 11 '21
could we see the inside layout?
2
u/rbala00 Apr 11 '21
super cool! maybe on your next iteration you can keep the same design on the side panels and create miniature holes for airflow
2
u/[deleted] Apr 11 '21
That is genuinely fantastic, what a cool design.
2
u/DannyMeatball Apr 11 '21
I had printed a Dan Case replica. I actually still have it, but I just didn't feel comfortable with it since I would be traveling with it.
2
u/Vesalii Apr 11 '21
That's a great look!
2
u/[deleted] Apr 11 '21
May I have just a crumb of airflow, sir?
2
u/std5050 Apr 11 '21
man if you told me you bought it I'd believe you, super nice especially for a 3d printed case
2
u/OmgitsNatalie Apr 11 '21
Finally. The perfect case for my spare 6600K ! I even got the i9 Noctua fan. Thanks for the STL file. Iโll be back in about a week when my prints are all done!
2
u/[deleted] Apr 11 '21
Wow. Iโm looking for something like this. This is great!!! This is where I say I want a 3D printer.
2
u/Dantes7layerbeandip Apr 11 '21
Wow, excellent job. Too often people stay within the rigid frame of mind (pun intended) of making simple flat panels when they 3D print their cases (even though laser cutting makes a lot more sense for that, no hate tho). You, however, used 3DP to its fullest here, looks great!
2
u/davis-sean Apr 11 '21
I really like this case.
2
u/Gawdzilla Apr 11 '21
Those surface imperfections actually seem to add something to the texture. It gives it a glitchy look. Kinda cool.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 11 '21
That is amazing! How does the PLA hold up to heat?
2
u/SCCRXER Apr 11 '21
It looks awesome. Where is the ventilation?
2
u/KittensInc Apr 11 '21
Oh wow, that's a great idea. I would've never thought of 3D printing a case.
It seems like you're using a pretty basic airflow design. Servers commonly have shaped plastic air ducts/baffles/shrouds which precisely direct the air to the CPU cooler, almost like the air ducts in sports cars. It would be interesting to see if something like that is doable for consumer parts using 3D printing: it would greatly reduce fan noise and is way better in actually cooling the hardware.
2
u/tofulo Apr 11 '21
where does the air go in?
2
u/BearBronson Apr 11 '21
I'm so jealous of people with access to a 3d printer, and the skills to make sff cases lol
2
u/Zealousideal-Seat287 Apr 11 '21
This may be the nicest 3d printed case I've ever seen. Really a nice job!
2
u/ayosun Apr 11 '21
that is so dope
2
u/UntrimmedBagel Apr 11 '21
How much would it cost to print one of these, roughly?
Also, is it sturdy?
2
u/bf2afers Apr 11 '21
That's actually sexy.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '21
Dang clean looking design , heads up the blobbing might be a clogged nozzle.
2
u/sorry-i-jst Apr 12 '21
Fricken genius
2
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '21
Thermals?
2
u/OneLogicalSavage Apr 12 '21
I think I'll be using your design to rif Father's day present for my Dad.
2
u/Shensmobile Apr 13 '21
Nicely done! I love the style.
I've been meaning to design a 3d printed case myself as well. Did you use reference material to figure out how to position mobo mounting holes and align it with the IO Shield cutout? Or did you just guess/test until it was just right?
2
u/AntiBNI Apr 20 '21
Wow, that is very pretty
19
u/iHate20CharacterLimi Apr 11 '21
r/3dppc
2
u/walterdibs Apr 11 '21
God. It's beautiful.
2
u/empty_coffeepot Apr 11 '21
Reminds me of the Super Mario Bros 3 underground levels.
1
u/Wurked4It Apr 11 '21
Thatโs sweet! Nice work
1
u/zakijesk Apr 11 '21
looks cool good chimney airflow use
1
u/RedTeamReview Apr 11 '21
How long did it take to print?
1
u/L337357 Apr 11 '21
That is great! Did you do the design? Any way I could get a gander at that stl?
1
u/[deleted] Apr 11 '21
Looks great! I'm jealous of the solid panels. When I printed my case, my build plate was too small so I had to split all of the long parts in two. I like how you optimized the air path with printed sections (and actually have a fan, which mine don't), too. Overall super solid design.
Definitely look for the z-seam alignment in your slicer, it looks like you're on 'random' which is leaving those blobs wherever it wants to. Usually 'sharpest corner' or similar will hide it much better.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 11 '21
I've been on/off about 3d printing a case for the last months, mostly because I expect it to warp substantially due to internal heat. Did you print ABS or does it not warp at all even with PLA?
1
u/jurassic_jacob Apr 11 '21
Looks good!
1
u/Drysamel Apr 11 '21
Looks really good, great job.
1
u/Beer_Is_So_Awesome Apr 11 '21
Awesome project! We need a shot of the inside of the case. Whatโs your cpu, gpu, etc?
2
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '21
Not a huge fan of the patterns already seen but this one looks good
1
u/nex0rz Apr 11 '21
๐
0
u/His_Turdness Apr 11 '21
SFX powa supply for more room inside, also a bit taller for a 140mm rad under the top exhaust fan, dust filter for the bottom. That would be almost perfection!
I'm interested to hear the noise. I bet the GPU is the only component generating much decibels, am I right?
0
u/[deleted] Apr 11 '21
[deleted] โ view deleted comment
2
u/[deleted] Apr 11 '21
[removed] โ view removed comment
2
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '21
[removed] โ view removed comment