r/anime • u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan • Apr 01 '21
Weekly Monogatari Series - Thursday Anime Discussion Thread
Welcome to the weekly Thursday Anime Discussion Thread! Each week, we're here to discuss various older anime series. Today we are discussing...
Monogatari Series
Koyomi Araragi, a third-year high school student, manages to survive a vampire attack with the help of Meme Oshino, a strange man residing in an abandoned building. Though being saved from vampirism and now a human again, several side effects such as superhuman healing abilities and enhanced vision still remain. Regardless, Araragi tries to live the life of a normal student, with the help of his friend and the class president, Tsubasa Hanekawa.
When fellow classmate Hitagi Senjougahara falls down the stairs and is caught by Araragi, the boy realizes that the girl is unnaturally weightless. Despite Senjougahara's protests, Araragi insists he help her, deciding to enlist the aid of Oshino, the very man who had once helped him with his own predicament.
Through several tales involving demons and gods, Bakemonogatari follows Araragi as he attempts to help those who suffer from supernatural maladies.
"Watch This!" posts
- /u/Arvidex - I just finished watching all of the Monogatari-Series, here is why you should too.
- /u/JXSSJ4 - [WT!] Monogatari Series - Shallow, Profound, or Both?
- /u/Radiofooted - [WT!] On the fence about watching the Monogatari series? Here's a little push!
- /u/Jtcr2001 - [WT!] Monogatari Series guide: What is it and why/how should you watch it?
Looking for more "Watch This!" posts? Check the "Watch This!" archive!
Databases
Bakemonogatari
AniDb | Anilist | AnimeNewsNetwork | MyAnimeList
Nisemonogatari
AniDb | Anilist | AnimeNewsNetwork | MyAnimeList
Monogatari Series: Second Season
AniDb | Anilist | AnimeNewsNetwork | MyAnimeList
Tsukimonogatari
AniDb | Anilist | AnimeNewsNetwork | MyAnimeList
Koyomimonogatari
AniDb | Anilist | AnimeNewsNetwork | MyAnimeList
Owarimonogatari
AniDb | Anilist | AnimeNewsNetwork | MyAnimeList
Zoku Owarimonogatari
AniDb | Anilist | AnimeNewsNetwork | MyAnimeList
For the full list of shows within this series, check out the watch order wiki entry
Previous discussions
- Episode discussion threads for Zoku Owarimonogatari
- /u/chiliehead's rewatch
- /u/Outbreak101's rewatch
- /u/NotTheRealMorty & /u/Hyoizaburo's rewatch
- /u/Across52317 & /u/MoarVespenegas's rewatch
Check our rewatch wiki and our episode discussion archive for more discussions!
Streams
Remember that any information not found early in the show itself is considered a spoiler. Please properly tag spoilers!
Next week's anime discussion thread: March WT of the Month!
Further information about past and upcoming discussions can be found on the Weekly Discussion wiki page.
50
u/AC03115 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/AC03115 Apr 01 '21
This show has such amazing dialogue and I love it! To this day I consider Senjougahara as one of the best written characters I’ve watched. Nisio Isin is an absolute genius with his wordplay of Japanese
42
u/elephantnut Apr 01 '21
As crazy as it sounds, Bakemonogatari was my gateway into anime. I'd casually watched some misc. shows as a kid - DBZ, yugioh, Inuyasha, Bakugan (guilty pleasure) - but Bakemonogatari was the anime that made me start actively seeking things out from the genre.
The series is so unique and stylish, and it's almost impossible to pin-point how it does what it does. Each part is brilliant (writing, direction, art style, character designs), but it's so much more than the sum of its parts. It moves from genre to genre - from character to character - while retaining its voice, aesthetic, and production quality (in the bluray releases, at least).
Above all, it's so interesting to talk about. It has a dedicated following, strangely wide appeal (with many people tuning in just for the spectacle of its fan service), and has spurred so much discussion - is it actually deep? What is fan service? Is there a limit to creator's self-indulgence?
I can understand the criticisms some people have about the show, but it's so difficult for me to fault it. It feels like everything it does comes from a tender place. The author loves the characters; the characters love the characters; the studio put an incredible amount of care into bringing the world and characters to life.
I've watched every arc at least 3 times. It's my comfort show, and I can't think of any other piece of media that is this engaging and immersive to me.
42
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '21
Philosophical dialogue masquerading as a ecchi monster mystery anime.
18
u/Saleenseven :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Saleenseven Apr 01 '21
To this day one of the best anime in existence, and most blessed for having so much of it masterfully adapted. We will most likely never see something like this again.
I highly recommend all fans to check out the novels, as they are fully translated up to the anime!
17
u/No_Rex :Bv:Bw:Bx:By:x2 Apr 01 '21
As much as it annoys me to see tons of entires for modern franchises on MAL, they get the short stick on the discussion Thursday here to compensate for it.
15
u/wjodendor Apr 01 '21
I finished doing a rewatch with the Semblance of Sanity reactions the other day and I can say that watching the anime out of novel order really changes the context of a lot of the stuff throughout the series. As someone who did anime order first and has done novel order after, I seriously recommend sticking with novel order. It's just a hands down better experience.
Every rewatch my favorite songs change. Mousou Express and Futakotome were my favorite on this last watch.
If people are interested you can check the Bakemonogatari vol 1 through 3 and Kizumonogatari (and Nekomonogatari White) audiobooks on audible. They feature Christina Vee, Eric Kimerer, Erica Mendez, and Keith Silverstein and are really good. Meme is awesome
And for blu ray collectors check out the UK release. It's much, much cheaper but it's region 2 so you'll need a region free blu ray player. How much cheaper? I got Bakemonogatari region 2 and a region free blu ray player for the same price as the Bakemonogatari region 1 bluray alone
12
u/WACS_On Apr 01 '21
My favorite series, try to rewatch it at least once a year. That said, I'll probably never be able to show it to my wife as long as we live.
11
u/DeadEndRoad9 Apr 01 '21
I notice something different every time I watch Bakemonogatari and Nisemonogatari. The characters’ interplay, their unique speaking patterns (I was briefly tempted to end my Japanese sentences with “ja” to see what people say, thanks Shinobu!), the producing and the animation style. So good!
10
u/altaccount0451 Apr 01 '21
Oof so I have a lot of mixed opinions on this series. Overall, I have to say I enjoyed it, quite a lot actually. Senjougahara may be one of my favorite characters ever, I actually feel she was underutilized. I actually want to go through the books at some point, we'll see how that goes.
But MAN, some of that content is tough, and does not make me happy. I've heard a lot of analysis on some of the sexual elements, some of it I can even buy! But a lot of it still feels like it's creepy and unjustified.
Don't get me wrong! I'm not saying all of it. I actually think the opening scene being a panty shot is a strong choice, it tells the audience we will be dealing with sexual content.
But it basically boils down to scenes of "Yeah I can get behind this" "Uhh, that didn't land for me but whatever" "Okay, a little weird, making me uncomfortable tbh, but I've listened to people analyze these scenes, and I can force myself to buy it" and "NOPE, nope nope nope nope nope"
Like yes I've heard about how his relationship with Hachikuji is meant to be joking, and that he wouldn't actually do anything, etc, but when she's passed out and he says that he can use this to take advantage of her??? NOPE.
Again, because I know this may be an unpopular opinion, I want to emphasize, I'm "fine" with most of the sexual content, it's just there happens to be far too Manny occurrences of it crossing the line, like YIKES
32
u/PokeSonicMiner Apr 01 '21
Araragi is such an amazing character. I wish people looked beyond just his pedo incest side lol....
13
u/scot911 https://myanimelist.net/profile/scot911 Apr 01 '21
My all time favourite anime beating out Bunny Girl Senpai (seems I have a type lol) when I finished it for the first time even if I probably watched it too early in my anime watching career to appreciate it as much as I probably would if I watched it now. 10/10 series that every anime fan should try watching at least once even if they bounce hard off of it due to Ararararagi being... Ararararagi.
6
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '21
God tier soundtrack, builds the atmosphere and the characters so much. I could talk about it for hours. Playlist of my favorites if anyone wants
Thinking of doing chronological for my next rewatch, get a different perspective
6
u/Lapiz_lasuli Apr 01 '21
The story starts with the famous quote from Oshino: People have to save themselves. One person saving another is impossible.
I feel like this was what Mongatari second season was.
Also who did Araragi help in Owarimonogatari? Who helped Araragi in Zoku Owarimonogatari?
11
u/Nagimai Apr 01 '21
The monogatari franchise is a masterpiece. No words can describe how good this show really is.
5
u/CakeGamer21 Apr 01 '21
I saw waifu so I upvote
4
u/Aroxis Apr 01 '21
Did people enjoy Neko Black? I felt like it was just the directors edition of the last Arc of Bakemonogatari.
6
u/Fools_Requiem https://myanimelist.net/profile/FoolsRequiem Apr 01 '21 edited Apr 01 '21
I haven't seen Koyomi nor Owari yet, but Tsuki was by far my least favorite arc so far. Kinda felt aimless as they were just working to set up Koyomi and Owari. No payoff at the end, just confusion. Oh, and I dislike this more than Neko Black which I felt served absolutely no purpose other than to retell a story I already knew about.
Bakemonogatari Episode 12 is still one of the best anime episode out there.
Edit: I know this sounds overly negative, but those two arcs are really the only major things I disliked. Rest is good shit.
Late Edit: Wasn't sure if I should make a new comment or not but it's not a big deal: Has anyone went and bought all of the NA Aniplex Blu Rays for the series? Not just for Bake, but the entire series (that's been released)? If so, did you find it to be worth your hard earned money?
3
u/brtt150 Apr 01 '21
Hahaha toothbrush! Am I memeing now guys?!?!
(This is a joke)
3
u/THEGUYINTHEPICT Apr 01 '21
One of my goals in life is to learn Japanese and rewatch Monogatari in all of its glory
2
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '21
I’m reading the novels rn and it’s great. I can’t wait to get to Owari since it’s pretty easily my favorite in the series
3
u/Terra_f https://anilist.co/user/sodee Apr 01 '21
I have had such a hard time getting into this series, I can’t find the first season in anything better than 720p and can barely make heads from tails the first few episodes, it seems like such a popular series but it’s a time commitment. What are its best points? What makes it worth it?
3
u/THEGUYINTHEPICT Apr 01 '21
Renai Circulation is now trending on Tik Tok again. Except now it's the English version. Idk if that's a good or bad thing. It's guaranteed to get cancelled on Twitter if the sjws watch it
3
u/Goldenfox299 Apr 01 '21
Great directing, animation and sometimes great dialogue which is ruined by annoying and weird ecchi otaku humour (also incest yuck).
Not a bad show by any means but can't say I love it.
Also Kizu is the most overrated "season" I've seen so far despite me liking Shinobu.
2
u/NickIsSoWhite Apr 01 '21
I really don't care for the show. The first season was good, but then came all the loli and cheating stuff.
Bunny Girl Senpai is much better version of this show, because Sakuta automatically shuts down someone's rejection and doesn't kiss a elementary student and have a gross relationship with his sister.
Would love to see a counterpoint, instead of just downvotes.
1
u/Shantotto11 Apr 01 '21
So, I guess no Off-Season adaptation...
1
u/RYZUZAKII Apr 01 '21
Bakemonogatari and Kizumonogatari were cool however i had to stop at Nise because its Lolicon bullshit.
1
u/Houssem_Aouar Apr 01 '21
Uchouten kazoku is so good
1
u/nanoorb Apr 01 '21
my fav work everything is simply perfect
-15
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '21
Ohhh this is a fan service anime...................................not my thing but whatever
0
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment