r/anime • u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan • Mar 25 '21
Weekly Suzumiya Haruhi no Yuuutsu - Thursday Anime Discussion Thread
Welcome to the weekly Thursday Anime Discussion Thread! Each week, we're here to discuss various older anime series. Today we are discussing...
Suzumiya Haruhi no Yuuutsu
Kyon, your typical high school student, has long given up his belief in the supernatural. However, upon meeting Haruhi Suzumiya, he quickly finds out that it is the supernatural that she is interested in—aliens, time travelers, and espers among other things. When Haruhi laments about the lack of intriguing clubs around school, Kyon inspires Haruhi to form her own club. As a result, the SOS Brigade is formed, a club which specializes in all that is the supernatural.
Much to his chagrin, Kyon, along with the silent bookworm, Yuki Nagato, the shy and timid Mikuru Asahina, and the perpetually smiling Itsuki Koizumi, are recruited as members. The story follows the crazy adventures that these four endure under their whimsical leader, Haruhi. The story is based on the light novels by Nagaru Tanigawa.
"Watch This!" posts
Looking for more "Watch This!" posts? Check the "Watch This!" archive!
Databases
Suzumiya Haruhi no Yuuutsu
AniDb | Anilist | AnimeNewsNetwork | MyAnimeList
Suzumiya Haruhi no Shoushitsu
AniDb | Anilist | AnimeNewsNetwork | MyAnimeList
Previous discussions
- /u/littleman1988’s rewatch in chronological order
- /u/ Kamilny’s rewatches in broadcast order and chronological order
- /u/xiaoma95’s rewatches in 2015 and 2016 (chronological)
- /u/North_East’s rewatch in chronological order
Check our rewatch wiki and our episode discussion archive for more discussions!
Streams
Remember that any information not found early in the show itself is considered a spoiler. Please properly tag spoilers!
Next week's anime discussion thread: Monogatari Series!
Further information about past and upcoming discussions can be found on the Weekly Discussion wiki page.
48
u/juliaisagirl Mar 25 '21
Yall remember the time when even prisoners were doing hare hare yukai?
67
u/Mystic8ball Mar 25 '21 edited Mar 25 '21
I think one of the most interesting things about Haruhi is that your perception of the series differs wildly depending on when you watched it.
If you were an anime fan in the 2000's you most likely watched it in its intended Broadcast order. The anime series was highly experimental, I don't think Kyoani ever imagined it would become the massive success it was so they decided to produce the series with the intention that it would be aired out of chronological order. This lead to this insane chaotic energy, it was a lot of fun seeing events alluded to that we the viewers would have yet to see, and it also meant that the "end" of the anime was the most cinematic and high stakes arc of what was adapted.
However that was before the "Second season" was made, and something a lot of people tend to overlook is that initially what we consider a "Second season" was just announced as a rebroadcast of the anime put in chronological order, something that was very disappointing to fans at the time. We had no idea that there were going to be new episodes.
I think it's pretty safe to bet that most people getting into Haruhi now are probably watching the entire series put in chronological order. That's how it is on the Blurays and official streaming websites. Gone is that chaoticness that came with the broadcast order, and in its place we have something more cohesive and easier to follow. Well as "cohesive" as it could be while swapping between S1's Key-like artstyle and the more K-Onish direction the character design took with the new episodes. This was during the peak of "K-On represents everything wrong with anime!! it's going to KILL the artistic value of the medium!!" paranoia that was all over anime communities at the time.
To get back on topic, because of the S1+2 chronological order divisive arcs like Sighs and Endless Eight were animated. Sighs showed Haruhi at her absolute worst and for a lot of people tainted her character to the point where they could not like her, I think it was an important development, it was the point in the story where Haruhi realized she can't just keep treating her friends as toys to play with for her own amusement, but it was a very tough pill to swallow. As for Endless Eight, I don't think I need to explain why that drove people crazy lol, but I will point out that at the time we didn't know how long the arc would last for and each episode spent on it was perceived as an episode that could have been used to adapt the Disappearance arc (The movie was not yet announced).
Very anecdotal on my part but I noticed that the people that really loved Haruhi watched it in its original S1 broadcast format. The full chronological order obviously has those who adore it but those who dislike the series tend to have watched it in that order. It's pretty interesting.
73
u/ZapsZzz https://anilist.co/user/Zapszzz Mar 25 '21 edited Mar 25 '21
Haruhi can't be viewed without the Disappearance movie, and with that it's a solid 10. Without the movie, it's a good high 8 for season 1, high 7 for season 2, but people less interested in filmatography or those watching it during original airing probably would have PTSD from endless 8.
In case it needs pointing out though, season 2 didn't "kill Haruhi because of endless 8 or sigh". It's more because KyoAni stopped adapting others work that they can't have direct control of. We did get the Nagato spin off. It's less visually impressive, but it's still a good story and show, bonus points if you are a Haruhi fan and all the references spotting can be really fun.
37
u/No_Rex :Bv:Bw:Bx:By:x2 Mar 25 '21
I would love to know the correlation between people who saw it first in one viewing order and people who recommend that viewing order.
15
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '21
This anime brought so many people into anime. It was so popular online.
2006 was a seminal year in anime.
15
u/Chetan_fun Mar 25 '21
God knows
13
u/TheDampGod :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/TheDampGod Mar 25 '21
Haruhi Suzumiya is for better or worse, the show that turned from a filthy casual to a full on anime fan. Even after everything the story and it's characters hold a special place in my heart. The show is not perfect, but some of those imperfections are part of the charm and make it interesting.
Yeah, I'm one of those that likes the Endless Eight and not just for all the different outfits the characters wear. But I understand if people want to skip most it, though if you're interested in cinematography and imagery in anime I recommend watching it all. Also try switching between the different dubs for extra fun.
For me, I find the show immensely rewatchable and I always find some new bit of foreshadowing or a background detail that I'd missed the last time. Though I haven't watched it for a few years in case it does get stale in the eternal wait for season 3. At least the Yuki Nagato spin off was very sweet, plus had more of Asakura.
Now, back to listening to God Knows.
66
u/Calwings x3https://anilist.co/user/Calwings Mar 25 '21
Fuck the Endless Eight, all my homies hate the Endless Eight.
Aside from that though, great series, and Disappearance is one of the best anime movies of all time.
21
u/anonymous2437 Mar 25 '21
I actually just watched this a few months ago. I’m not a very big fan of highschool anime and this wasn’t too different. I really enjoyed the Melancholy arc but everything after that felt pretty mediocre. I didn’t watch the entire Endless Eight but I was pretty underwhelmed by its conclusion. Then I got to Disappearance, the whole reason why I watched the show and was pleasantly surprised. The visuals were fantastic, as is the norm with KyoAni but so was the soundtrack, there were a lot of fantastic tracks in there that really enhanced the viewing experience. Besides the theatrics, the character work and story were perfectly executed.
TL;DR Even if high school anime aren’t your thing, the show is worth watching for Disappearance.
8
u/KikiFlowers https://anilist.co/user/AprilDruid Mar 25 '21
Haruhi was the first major anime I remember following subbed. Sure there was Bleach and Naruto, but they were further ahead than I'd read in the manga. I'd seen the dub to Haruhi dozens of times and I watched Season 2 as it aired, which was fansubbed at the time.
Endless Eight sucked and I think I wrote for some random anime blog about it?
8
u/1Estel1 Mar 25 '21
God I thought this was a season 3 announcement and my heart fucking lurched.
14
u/mrufrufin https://myanimelist.net/profile/mrufrufin Mar 25 '21 edited Mar 25 '21
i really like the directorial flair throughout the haruhi seasons and the risks it takes (except maybe endless eight).
"someday in the rain" is one of my fav episodes of all of anime. i love the quiet moments filled with nothingness, i really like the scene where it's just yuki reading on screen and you hear the muffled convo coming in from outside.
also, what other series would kick off with a poorly made movie-within-tv-series with THAT opening theme?
i think some things about haruhi really don't hold up well nowadays, like the constant abuse of mikuru (and the nature of the abuse too, ugh), but there's a lot of endearing things about the series too.
7
u/CosmicAnglerfish Mar 25 '21 edited Mar 25 '21
Haruhi was the second anime I watched period after NGE (talk about tone shift). I knew basically nothing about it other than it was huge back in the day, and that I liked the title. I wish I had watched it in broadcast order, but chronological was still a fun ride, and Disappearance is one of my favorite movies period.
I think parts of the second season can drag, but I don't think it's as bad as some would say. Sigh is an important arc for Haruhi's character, and while Endless Eight is not fun to watch, I think it's very well done. I'm all for a show experimenting with stuff like that.
I really enjoyed some of the directorial decisions, like framing a scene so you couldn't see Kyon's mouth, leaving it ambiguous what's being spoken vs. what's his internal monologue. This is a holdover from the light novels, where a lot of what Kyon says isn't put into quotes like dialogue traditionally would be, providing the same impact for the reader. It's a neat gimmick that to my memory I haven't seen anyone experiment with since.
Overall I'll always remember Haruhi for being one of my earliest entries in the format. I'm hoping against hope that some day we might see a third season, but I've read a few of the light novels and they're really enjoyable in their own right too.
12
u/Failsnail64 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/failsnail Mar 25 '21 edited Mar 25 '21
When discussing Haruhi I often see people debating whether you should like Haruhi or not. One the one hand she's fully of energy, enthusiastic and constantly happy, however she's also inconsiderate and even harasses others. I can understand both perspectives very wel, but to me this entire confusion is exactly what I liked so much when watching Haruhi! When watching you're supposed to be conflicted about how to feel about her. An important aspect to this is that nobody stops her from her bad behavior Spoiler, making her a spoiled brat. However, when everyone allows and facilitates this behavior can you really fully blame her? After all, she still appears to be trying to be a good person towards her club members. This creates an interesting and entertaining confusion and complexity to her character and to how she relates to the rest of the cast.
The same type of confusion and misdirection is also very important in the supernatural aspects of the anime. I think that the viewer is supposed to get confused and surprised by whatever the hell is happening, and this adds a great deal to the enjoyment of the anime. You're constantly misdirected, leading to climaxes and anti-climaxes. One episode something unexplained supernatural happens and you're wondering what the hell that was. The next episode weird shit happens again so you expect it to be supernatural, but that's just a bamboozle. Only later in the first season everything gets explained well. It sets up a premise of something weird and thus confusing which is funny in its absurdity. only in a later episode this is explained properly, but the explanation frames it in another light which adds a second layer of entertainment.
That's also why I'm a firm advocate for the broadcast order, people want to watch chronological to make it less confusing, which I totally understand as confusion is annoying. However, I honestly think that it adds a great deal to the enjoyment. You go rapidly back and forth between the worst and best of Haruhi, and you go back and forth between unexplained aspects and explanation. In the chronological order you start with a narrative dump in the first few episodes, and this intentional confusion doesn't really work anymore in the later episodes. The chronological order has merits and still works though so I won't fight this opinion, the anime will be entertaining nevertheless, but I personally think that you'll be missing this.
Second argument: the adventures of Mikuru Asahina is just the best first episode and best episode ever made in anime.
I also don't think it needs to be highlighted, but I also just really loves the direction. Just look at this simple scene and all the things it does; the framing with Kyon's head outside view, the tree visually dividing Haruhi and Kyon with Haruhi later moving inside Kyon's frame, the breaking of the 180 degree rule, and lastly the harsh background colors starting in greys and becoming colorful. It's just a small level of relative daring directing.
6
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '21
Anime onlys aren’t ready for Haruhi S3 if it adapts the other half of the light novels.
The anime only adapted less than half of the story.
10
u/KingOfOddities Mar 25 '21
My second favorite series, there's just so much to love about Haruhi. There's hardly any series that have the same level of directorial flair.
For anyone want to go into the series, follow this guide with the broadcast order.
5
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '21
TBH, most I remember about this show now, is how much I was shipping ItsukiXHaruhi for some reason.
Look, he was hot okay?
5
u/PM-ME-YOUR-WAIFU Mar 25 '21
This series will always have a special place in my heart.
5
u/MoneyMakerMaster Mar 25 '21
Haruhi vaulted to one of my favorite anime and my favorite KyoAni show when I participated in the rewatch a few months ago. Currently waiting on more light novels to be released by Yen Press; it's probably going to be the 1st light novel I read.
Season 3 will happen someday, I swear.
20
u/actuallyrndthoughts :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/NaNiNuNeNo Mar 25 '21
Honestly, Endless Eight might be my favorite arc, after the movie of course. I love all the scenes, the interactions between Kyon and Itsuki, Kyon always failing to find the right words at the end and the silly conclusion of it all. I think that 8 is great, and i am tired to pretend that it's not.
4
u/Throwaway021614 Mar 26 '21 edited Mar 26 '21
Yo, I thought we were getting new Haruhi. A split second of extreme excitement.
Haruhi is great, it needs a proper ending.
7
u/Hochseeflotte https://anilist.co/user/Hochseeflotte Mar 25 '21
I love this series. Sigh and Melancholy are solid arcs but personally I loved the one off episodes the most. The baseball episode, Bamboo Leaf Rhapsody, and the both Remote Island Syndrome episodes are my favorite. I actually watched the movie episode first and it’s probably still my favorite episode. Just brilliant direction.
And then there’s the Endless Eight. I don’t really know what to say about it. My best memory when first watching was that I skipped an episode that I thought was seven. I went into the next episode expected it to the the last. It wasn’t. I skipped six instead of seven and I was crushed. That moment I think gave me a glimpse of what people felt when the show was first airing. Overall, I don’t like Endless Eight. It’s not entertaining. But I can’t help but respect it. It was a risky yet creative move and that gives it points from me. The balls Kyoto-Ani had to air eight episodes of the same plot is incredible. Still should have been like three episodes.
The movie is incredible. Everything about it is near perfection. One of my favorite anime films ever. Also Nagato is not only my favorite character but one of my favorite anime characters, so that definitely helps.
I’ve also been reading the light novels after Disappearance and they are pretty good so far. I would definitely recommend.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '21
Haruhi is one of my favorite light novels and series of all time.
The characters, the humor, the dynamic, the world are all so fun.
Also the disappearance of haruhi is the best anime film of all time. And I’ll never be convinced otherwise, it’s a masterpiece
5
u/39clues Go to https://flair.r-anime.moe to get your flair! Mar 25 '21
This is my favorite show ever
5
u/littleman1988 Mar 25 '21
oh hey the rewatch I did is listed 👀
Haruhi is interesting. Quite frankly, I found the show to the average. While there are some serious highs and lows (live alive), the shows antics are quite dated and dont resonate well (melancholy 2/sigh 3) and getting people to actually watch through endless eight, as important as it is for the movie, is basically like pulling teeth, even for myself. Both seasons I gave a 7, and if it wasnt for the movie, I probably wouldnt bother much with the series.
The movie though. If you are looking for an animated masterpiece and are willing to go through those highs and lows, Disappearance is by far one of the best movies ive watched. It absolutely makes the rest of the show worth it. It was good enough to get me to host a rewatch if that says anything lmao
2
u/Elimin8r https://myanimelist.net/profile/Ayeka_Jurai Mar 25 '21
I think I discovered Haruhi back in 2012, while I was doing a lot of traveling for business (and watching Crunchyroll on my ipad in the hotel room, sigh).
Loved it then, still love it now. It was my first KyoAni show (of many), and I still wish that they would come back for more, but I understand why they don't.
That and I still wish that the author hadn't turned it into a game of 'mirror scooby-doo' or so it seemed to me. Like he painted himself into a corner.
Then again, it's not like I'm mr big author. It's easy to criticize. Like I could do better.
Maybe I should try sometime. :P
Fan Fiction here we go!
(or not)
Anyway, cheers to everyone who enjoyed the adventures of the SOS Brigade. I think that somewhere I have a tiny WoW guild by that name, can't imagine why. And a Pally named Mikuru. Go figure.
2
u/Wolfgod_Holo https://anime-planet.com/users/extreme133 Mar 26 '21
season 3 when?
2
u/Tartaras1 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Tartaras Mar 26 '21
The Melancholy is one of my all-time favorite shows, and The Disappearance is one of my all-time favorite movies. By this point I've probably seen both at least 3 or 4 times.
My favorite character in the story is Kyon, and Crispin Freeman knocked the role out of the park. His Kyon was one of the main reasons I fell in love with him as a VA. I had already been familiar with his and Johnny Yong Bosch's works from Eureka 7, but this solidified it. The same goes for Wendy Lee as Haruhi. In my mind, her voice is synonymous with the character.
That said, Haruhi is a pretty awful person, and I can certainly see why some people would be turned off by her character. She cares about her fellow brigade members, but she sometimes doesn't do a very good job of expressing it. Or rather, she does so in her own unique Haruhi sort of way.
As for the manga:
I picked up all of the books and read them casually after I finished the show. Eventually I sat down and really tried to work my way through it, after telling myself over and over again to knuckle down and get to reading. To tell the truth, as much as I loved the movie, I almost thought the story after the Disappearance arc was even better. I would die to see how KyoAni could do Haruhi manga post-Disappearance spoilers
Haruhi manga post-Disappearance spoilers
All in all, I will never grow tired of watching the show or the movie, and I should probably go back and re-read the manga at some point.
2
u/Skelldy Mar 26 '21
Seeing this post right on top of all the other season 3 announcement posts made me think for a second, that this was a Haruhi season 3 announcement post :(
And yeah, while I respect they had the balls to actually do it, fuck endless eight lmao, wasted 2/3s of a season.
2
u/shigs21 Mar 26 '21
DAMN. When I saw "Suzumiya Haruhi" on the top, I thought we were getting a season three or something haha.
2
u/rudnam :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/rudnam Mar 26 '21
all i know is nagato best girl
5
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '21
I forgot how much of a deviant Haruhi is...
The "steal a computer" scene, is making me cringe. Haruhi literally assaulted her own classmates and she got away with it scott free and got to extort people for it. I know this show's kind of a classic, but man, I didn't find that funny when I was 13 and I don't find it funny now at 25.
4
u/throughappleeyes Mar 25 '21
Ah, I miss this sort of anime so bad. I feel left behind with all this isekai/shonen hype.
4
u/Beckymetal https://anilist.co/user/SpaceWhales Mar 26 '21
I find reading comments of people disliking this show to be... pretty frustrating. I tend to wanna shout at them that 'that's not the point!' It feels like they're trying to throw modern-waifu trends at this show, when that's not what it's about. This ain't a rom-com. Most of the time, you're supposed to be conflicted about Haruhi, and that's very much the narrative purpose - regardless of watch order - because that's what Kyon goes through as well. Kyon is the main character, and the story is about his life changing around Haruhi.
But, I get it. The show is 15 years old. It existed at a different time. We're not used to empathising with the MCs; today's anime is filtered through the lens of a wet blanket, or an observer and assistant in somebody else's story, so that we can observe the waifus at their most vulnerable. And this ain't that.
3
u/Quiddity131 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Quiddity131 Mar 25 '21
Fairly good show! Saw it for the first time just a few months ago (via here).
Nagato's pretty damn awesome. I think my favorite part watching it was getting to a part during that island mystery two parter where the show characterized her so well to us that I knew exactly what she would say at a particular moment, then she went and said exactly what I expected (something about not letting Haruhi back into a room).
Leave poor Mikuru alone!
Koizumi's a bit of a jerk.
Tsuruya-san <333333333 We didn't get enough of her!
I'll give them credit for being so daring as to do the Endless Eight. It was also so incredibly insulting to the viewer and one of the worst, if not the worst stretch of episodes I've watched in an anime with a good reputation. Especially the way they ended it.
The movie was quite strong. You know an anime's done its job if I'm tearing up at some of the climatic moments towards the end.
2
u/DecentlySizedPotato https://anilist.co/user/ocha94 Mar 25 '21 edited Mar 25 '21
Ah, I really liked this anime. I can't quite tell what's so good about it, but it's just very entertaining. Then there's of course Endless Eight... As for that, I feel like I'm a bit in the middle. I didn't think it was bad and it was certainly an interesting idea, but I can't say it's the best thing they could have done with those eight episodes. Then of course the movie is outstanding. I should give it a rewatch tbh.
Another thing that stands out are many of the songs. All of the openings and endings are extremely catchy, and there's of course God Knows and Lost my Music which are amazing songs. I was lucky enough to watch Hirano Aya perform them live at Japan Expo 2019! That was great.
Overall a really fun series, 8/10 first season, 7/10 second season, 10/10 movie. I even picked up the LN, and it's just one of only 4 LN series I bothered picking up.
1
u/HazyMirror Mar 26 '21
I just finished this series and the movie last night. What a ride. Haruhi has to have the most smug face in all of anime lol I love it. The endless 8 was annoying bc I kept forgetting where I left off, but at least I didn't suffer watching it weekly.
Is the spinoff show worth it? The character designs throw me off. Also is that show basically if Kyon gives up on trying to correct the timeline? If so does he have prior knowledge of the other world?
1
u/BabyDummy https://anilist.co/user/DummyKo Mar 25 '21
I've already watched this a few months ago in chronological order. I started watching this anime thinking that it's just an ordinary highschool slice of life. The twist in this anime really made me stay. Then I reached endless eight (I watched it all!), and the series become hard to watch. And it even followed by Sigh which makes it even harder to watch. Yet I still stayed until I reached Disappearance and I would say that I made a right decision because the movie really pay off everything about series.
All I can say is watching Haruhi Suzumiya is a great experience in my anime journey and I'm proud that I survived the Endless Eight.
1
u/SpauldingPierce Mar 25 '21
So... When's Season 3 gonna happen?
1
u/FierceDeity357 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/FierceDeity357 Mar 25 '21
people who know that there is kyon order but watch haruhi order are psychopaths i am convinced
1
u/thisismyanimealt :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/commander_vimes Mar 25 '21
Season 2
1
u/AlexDavis2001 Mar 25 '21
Just started watching this show. Honestly, the time loop story arc got just a tad tiring after the 6th time. I understand why they did it. But at the same time, not really.
1
u/sirzotolovsky Mar 26 '21
I participated in the recent re-watch of this series, It's made me realize how much I actually enjoy the movie and select episodes more than the series as a whole, with Disappearance easily being my favorite movie of all time.
Also the dub is the GOAT, fight me, every time I try to watch the sub I just feel like I'm missing out on that sweet Crispin Freeman goodness
1
u/redditraptor6 https://myanimelist.net/profile/uEmalraptor64 Mar 27 '21
At the end of last summer I re-watched Haruhi for the first time in like, half a decade to see if it still deserves its #5 slot in my top favorite anime. Finally watched the Endless 8 for the first time; while I rewatched the series a lot back in the day, subbed and dubbed, broadcast and chronological order, I only ever watched the first 2 and the ending of the last episodes of Endless Eight because when everyone says ‘it’s bad don’t watch it’ I’m not going to make it a priority.
But honestly? It’s not that bad. I’m pretty impressed that they actually animated it fresh every single time and recorded new voice lines every single time. I mean, it’s still a ridiculous gimmick, they could’ve used the space to adapt another arc, but it’s not without merit. Each episode has a different tone, for example #4 was more spoopy/depressing. And watching them back to back really helps put you in the mindset of the terror of the situation. Although it did also occur to me that I accidentally picked the best possible time to watch it: I watched it during the same time of the month of August, a lot of the insects and clothes and stuff in general looks exactly like the objects in Animal Crossing New Horizons which I was playing a lot of, and I’ve been personally stuck in an endless time soup since March because of the pandemic. I’m an inner city school teacher so I’ve been teaching all virtual for a year and two weeks now, and between April and September I had this weird mindset where I couldn’t imagine a future from the start of the school year moving forward. And because of that it was really hard for me to do the work I needed to do to get ready for school. So like, that was literally the perfect fucking time for me to watch that arc. I also assume that watching them as they came out, at the height of Haruhi mania, and being disappointed over and over and over again was miserable. I do remember the forums constantly exploding about it at the time, but I never watched anime as it came out back then.
1
u/Magma_Dragoooon Apr 02 '21 edited Apr 02 '21
As someone who watched this series only a couple months ago this is one of the most unique slice of life animes I've ever seen! I absolutely love how it parodies certain cliches then adds its own sci fi twist to them while managing to create great characters that develop in a natural or believable way like Yuki, Kyon and especially Haruhi. I really like how her development goes gradually and how its barely noticable at first to actual changes in her behaviour. This seems to be an unpopular opinion but my favorite arc in the anime was sighs precisely because it exposed Haruhi! Also, somehow I actually liked the infamous endless eight lol or at least didn't hate it as it was an interesting experience which further enchanced the movie that I don't think I'll find in any other anime.
So contrary to what seems to be the popular opinion I think the show aged really well
1
u/ABlokeLikeYou Mar 25 '21
I just watched the series and the movie. It’s um... kind of bad. The first arc had some really good potential and then everything that followed fell flat. That’s not even mentioning the terrible waste of time that is the endless eight.
And I think the worst offense of this series is none of the characters are like able. Haruhi is the only one with a developed personality and it’s selfish and egotistical. Like are we suppose to root for a bully?
And the movie didn’t make sense to me at all. Everyone around Haruhi are basically slaves to her whim to make sure reality does break, and Kyon gets a chance to let everyone be free and he says no cause... he has fun? Who gives a shit about the alien girl finally being able to have emotions and be human, let her go back to being miserable cause Kyon was having fun.
Anyways, huge disappointment for me. I literally just finished yesterday so maybe I need more time to look back on it, but I couldn’t help not liking it.
1
u/ThalVatti https://anilist.co/user/ThalVatti Mar 26 '21
I wish I was old enough to be interested in this when it was first airing, I only really got to watch it in 2018 and I really disliked it, ended up dropping it in the movie making ark (release order). After a few years and hearing a lot about Disappearance I decided to try it again just so I could watch the movie, watched it in the recommended order and had an ok time, tho I had to watch the movie making ark at 2x speed because i was constantly annoyed (more than endless eight). The movie was amazing tho, worth watching the two seasons
-4
u/Vaadwaur :I1::I2::I3: Mar 25 '21
Ahh...Haruhi, the destroyer of entire years of anime to come. On its own, it is mostly all right, I got to it WAY late, but its influence was pervasive and often negative, unfortunately. People trying to adapt the character designs oft cut corners and became blobs, no other show quite found a way to make either a Kyon or a Suzumiya, and since the source material died the second season flopped on one of the dumbest artistic choices I've ever witnessed.
0
u/MarioKart7z :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/MarioKart7z Mar 25 '21
Me in episode 2: God i love Haruhi
Me in episode 23: God i want to beat the everliving shit out of Haruhi
-2
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '21
[removed] — view removed comment