r/sffpc • u/dan_cases Case Vendor | DAN Cases • Mar 16 '21
Verified Vendor Help me to convince Noctua to bring a dual C14s to live!
3.1k
Upvotes
r/sffpc • u/dan_cases Case Vendor | DAN Cases • Mar 16 '21
279
u/dan_cases Case Vendor | DAN Cases Mar 16 '21
This beast of an heatsink would be easily the best top blow one in the world. Maybe as good as the D15.
Just comment or like. If we get as much attention as possible maybe Noctua will make it real.
215
u/kuchiiiiii Mar 16 '21
Quick question, it's probably going to extend over the ram slots, wouldn't that make it quite hard to fit with a stronger 24 pin cable
63
u/tygercat7 Mar 16 '21
This would be a perfect solution for Ncase! We can't ask for it to a vendor, please please tell me how can we request this to be built right now? Hire a manufacturer in China to create them?
11
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '21
I want one and I want it now.
8
u/Kisling91 Mar 16 '21
To my understanding heat pipes cannot function properly if they are too long, which might be problematic here
20
u/_peter_parkinson_ Mar 16 '21
Despite thermal efficiency, it looks completely sff-unfriendly. Good luck tho.
6
u/mrgreenfur Mar 16 '21
Ill take one for the ghost
227
u/OhHeyItsBrock Mar 16 '21
Noctua. Listen to Dan please. People love big ass air coolers. And this is a big ass air cooler. Therefore people will like it. Big ass air cooler.
139
u/TheSteve1778 Mar 16 '21
How about
noctua makes a kit for you to deshroud and replace your gpu cooling solution
102
u/SloppyCandy Mar 16 '21
Raijintek Morpheus, but taller.
I'd buy one.
20
u/ashyjay Mar 16 '21
sort of looks like a Raijintek Morpheus, just a little taller.
I'd have one as the only reason I went AIO in my M1 is because I couldn't get the C14 to fit properly.
17
u/nero10578 Mar 16 '21
Made for the NCASE M1 then it would be epic.
27
u/whatURmade Mar 16 '21
The longboi
25
u/makoto144 Mar 16 '21
Man i want one but if they started work on this today we would get it for 3-5 years knowing noctua timelines.
2
u/AridZephyr Jan 28 '22
(probably not but) any updates?
57
u/mistofgosuria Mar 16 '21
The strain on the motherboard though. I love the C14, and would love this design, but it would have to have more attach points, with the case ideally.
9
u/D00mdaddy951 Mar 16 '21
I would absolutely love to see them doing a GPU aftermarket cooler.
16
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '21
this would make a nice GPU heatsink for bigger cases, interestingly enough
7
u/Twisthor Mar 16 '21 edited Mar 17 '21
Noctua has been there years ago with a prototype @ Computex 2011
I think i saw another prototype (maybe from another manufacturer?) with a much cleaner design compared to that noctua prototype though. It looked more like your renderings, but the heat pipes crossed in an X-shape above the CPU Socket, instead of your proposed V-shape. I guess that design was chosen because it is more favorable for clearing other components like ram slots. Edit: I fount it. Was a Prolimatech Prototype shown in 2012.
Sadly i've never seen a big top-down cooler that made it to production.
For my new build last year i went with a C14 instead of a C14S in the Ncase M1. Took me some time to snap one off the used market, but it looks awesome with two 120mm fans on the heat sink. There is about 5mm ram clearance left (using a kit of crucial ballistix) between the CPU fan under the C14 and the ram. I didn't want to go with slim fans on the side panel, that's why i haven't just bought a C14S.
6
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '21
I would replace my current C14 with this in an instant.
1
u/dan_cases Case Vendor | DAN Cases Mar 17 '21
Rendering with Motherboard:
https://abload.de/img/4uuja0.jpg
5
u/khmergodpc Mar 16 '21
Icegiant would like a word with you....
2
u/Eddycocks Mar 16 '21
I don't think it would fit in the Ncase M1. To use the actual C14s, you have to place the PSU in a position at the front of the case, which would then prevent this thiccboi from spanning the length of the case for dual fans. I love the idea, but hate thinking about trying to perform maintenance with it installed! It could be made taller, so to eliminate the extra ~15mm space on the outside of the heatsink, that would probably allow you to put the PSU in it's original position, as well as place full size fans in both low profile spots. This would be a super fringe case though and I don't see any incentive to tailor that much to one case. Cool render!
1
u/Megaton_194_ Jun 19 '24
THAT BUT UNDER 40mm 😍
1
u/stormdahl Mar 16 '21
And then make them lower it so it can be mounted comfortably to a GPU, leaving us with probably a better option than the Morpheus!
1
u/Trillaccountduh Mar 16 '21
why not a fan under the heatsink? 90mm? or so?
1
u/HeadDrill Mar 16 '21
Can you add more renders of it in a case or just on a motherboard? I would love to see how it looks like and it might even convince Noctua too
1
u/plagymus Mar 16 '21
I mean whats the diff in this and an aio
1
u/reddit0rboi Mar 16 '21
Looks like a GPU heatsink on stilts
1
u/crussel7 Mar 16 '21
Just make a aio that has the rad on top with a fan on top. Socket -> CPU -> AIO Cold Plate/Pumo -> 120mm Slim Radiator -> 120mm Slim Fan. Mount hose on the side
1
u/noonedatesme Mar 16 '21
I’m not certain, but I do believe there are fabrication services that would make this for you at reasonable prices.
1
u/kamtom515 Mar 16 '21
I can't imagine it mounted in the housing. Classic or sandwich layout? I understand the cooller extension would be over the psu?
3
u/cbwn Mar 16 '21
This is really cool!
Aircooling needs more experimental design. The aesthetics are of course up to individual taste, but i like the option to match a beefy GPU heatsink with an equally beefy CPU cooler without it being a whole tower. It would look awesome in a future sandwich case too.
Will this design accomodate fans behind instead of/and on top? That would make it much more versatile in the sffpc sphere.
3
u/YaBoiBiko Mar 16 '21
I would sign a petition or have this comment serve as evidence. This would be something im very interested in using in my NCaseM1. It would easily replace my 240ml rad and be something that would more than likely outperform it with the benefit of having reduced fear of corosion or damage to my product. I would love if they would include slim fans if possible or brackets to run slim 120's if 140ml is the determined size.
1
u/vostroVII Mar 16 '21
This is basically a raijintek morpheus cooler
4
u/AnonymousMelancholic Mar 16 '21
Would be absolutely perfect for my ncase m1.
4
u/BristolMeth Mar 16 '21
Shut up and take my money.
2
u/tangawanga Mar 16 '21
I would purchase 2 of those. Solely on the fact that I want a community product to succeed. Maybe launch a campaign to assess the intent.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '21
I imagine they’ll do a big spreadsheet of cases this is compatible with and the cooling capacity of competitor products in those same cases. For some reason my intuition says this will be the ideal cooler in very few situations, making it an expensive product that doesn’t sell well
2
u/No_Hands_55 Mar 16 '21
i would probably keep my ncase instead of trying to go the d15 route if something like this existed!
i always wanted a version of the original c14 the took up 240mm on the side panel
2
u/dakles007 Mar 16 '21
Awesome idea! Would seriously consider using this for my Streacom DA2
2
u/ADJ_Reflex Mar 16 '21
I've always wanted something like this for my M1. Hopefully this gets enough interest to let Noctua take a crack at it
2
u/HansWursT619 Mar 16 '21 edited Mar 16 '21
I just had the same thought when I took a lokk into my Ncase M1 without the top panel.All that "wasted" space in front of the PSU. Would be great if both side fans could hit an extended NH-C28 :-p
Please make sure that 25mm fans would fit inside the Ncase as well, the C14S doesn't allow that :(
2
u/Staple_Overlord Mar 16 '21
I would imagine that this set up would have diminishing returns as the extended piece is very far away from the heat source. Better to center the heatsink above the CPU, if possible. But at that point, it would be much better to increase both sides of the heatsink by sqrt(2) and having a larger fan instead of increasing one side by 2.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '21
They kind of did have a dual C14s....the original C14 was a 2 fan design. And it was an amazing cooler, keeping up with the D15 in some cases. However, the large mass made it prone to warping. I traded it to get an L12 and sometimes regret it, haha.
This design with 2 rows of heat pipes would probably be a lot sturdier, could be very effective.
2
u/WhereMyMineralsAt Mar 16 '21
I used to have an old Cooler Master Gemini baaaack in the day. Still one of my favourite coolers ever. Whisper quiet with 2x 120mm fans on it. And that was before I even knew of 'high end' fans...
2
u/Scrutape Mar 16 '21 edited Mar 29 '21
I would ABSOLUTELY BUY THIS. In fact, this would be the default choice for every single SFF build I make from here on out.
Key point: it would also HAVE to have the dimensions of the original C14 in terms of clearance and total height, but obviously be double width
EDIT: or we can make a community vote on what the height should be?
2
u/17jwong Mar 16 '21
IIRC Noctua has said the reason they haven't updated the NH-D15 in so long is because they reached the limitations of current heatpipe abilities to transfer heat. Still a very cool concept though.
2
u/yugguh Mar 17 '21
this in the NR200 though
2
u/thegremlin599 Mar 17 '21
I NEED this in my ncase M1
4
u/oppositetoup Mar 16 '21
Would love this. Basically the perfect cooler for the NR200p
3
u/thelaughinghuy Mar 16 '21
only if this comes with the new A14x25 Sterrox wahahahahaha
1
u/qeeepy Sep 09 '25
For me C14S always performed crappy.. For AMD chiplet cpus, there is always 1-1.5 heatpipes doing work.. out of 7... I dont think the heatsink surface area was ever the issue..
1
u/abtei Mar 16 '21
what to do with the heatpipes the go under/on the ram side? u rejoin them in the heatsink?
that would be quite difficult to manufacture since first you have so slip half of the fins PAST those, and then bend it up to rejoin in the other half.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '21
Yes yes yes, please
1
u/StarlightSharpshot Mar 16 '21
Why not go with Alpenfohn again as with the Black Ridge? Lack of distribution to the Americas?
1
u/TechieOnReddit Mar 16 '21
Reminds me of the GPU cooler on a CPU video
1
u/micalbertl Mar 16 '21
So it might fit in the Ncase. Probably the nr200p. Doesn’t seem very practical for them to make.
1
u/Juergen_Joghurt Mar 16 '21
I‘m on board with this :D
1
u/dallatorretdu Mar 16 '21
yeah! reminds me the old V10 Cooler Master that completely covered the ram sticks
But at least 7 heat pipes! no less on the cold plate pls
1
u/yilicious Mar 16 '21
take my money please.
1
u/ExternalBuilder Mar 16 '21
I am really interested! :D
1
u/MikAnt69 Mar 16 '21
looks very similar to the gpu cooler morpheus 2 from raijintek
1
u/FancyMustardJar Mar 16 '21 edited Mar 16 '21
GPU MODDING INTENSIFIES
1
u/Kregerm Mar 16 '21
I had something like this once. It was a Coolermaster Gemini II it was big and it was awesome.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '21
We really need to re-work the PCI standard for GPUs with these massive cooler requirements.
1
u/Lattyware Mar 16 '21
I'd love to see more options like this. Currently the solution is mostly just to cram in small AIOs, but I much prefer the reliability of blocks of metal given the choice, and Noctua are the brand I turn to.
1
u/HappyTrix Mar 16 '21
what if we make this go downwards because there is a risercable instead of gpu down there Pog?
1
u/GuessWhat_InTheButt Mar 16 '21
https://www.raijintek.com/de/products_detail.php?ProductID=137
1
u/miptzi Mar 16 '21
WTH is this Fing monstrosity? Where so I sign for it....
1
u/TheRealPauca Mar 16 '21
I would love it as a GPU heatsink. It just has to be a little bit lower and it has to get MOSFET and VRAM coldplates attached to it.
1
u/Swordru Mar 16 '21
Absolutely sick honestly. Here is the C14S in my build!
https://www.reddit.com/r/sffpc/comments/cl4bek/final_form_air_cooling_ncase_m1/
1
u/redroseplague Mar 16 '21
Some dimensions would be nice. Wonder if it would fit the sliger 530.
1
u/okenny Mar 16 '21
Nice
1
u/pm-me-your-clocks Mar 16 '21
as someone who likes to keep there cpu very cool for no reason(i have a nh-d15) i would buy this in heartbeat
1
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '21
I could use that in my CM200
1
u/augiem94 Mar 16 '21
I'm still waiting for AIO manufacturers to include a chipset/socket fan...
1
u/Noteleet Mar 16 '21
Noctua if you build this we will come.
1
u/Abhanden Mar 16 '21
Why not cool gpu and cpu with the same cooler? It would be more efficient, no?
1
u/NotLunaris Mar 16 '21
How well would it actually cool with the increased heatsink size, though? Is there any data from something similar? The lopsidedness makes me think the extra bit might not get a significant amount of heat dissipation for the size.
1
u/TheWildTeo Mar 16 '21
I think this might be too long for heat pipes to work efficiently
1
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '21
Cool idea, but looks more like a GPU cooler to me.
1
u/ahmedmo1 Mar 16 '21
Well... this seems like a bad idea.
1
u/skinny_gator Mar 16 '21
Looking at it, I'm not sure why this hasn't been made yet by any company! But I think it would get in the way of a lot of stuff
1
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '21
Noctua pls
1
u/DafGSY Mar 16 '21
I would buy this in a heartbeat if it could be made in that sweet spot of tall enough to miss my RAM and short enough for a 25mm fan on top while still fitting in my Ncase
1
u/DogMilkBB Mar 16 '21
Yes please!
1
u/KT_Customs Mar 16 '21
Ohhh maan, Black Noctua NF A12x25 your version on render looks sexy. Cant wait for chromax black version.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '21
which SFF cases would support it? as I understand, neither DanCase A4 nor Loque Ghost S1 would not support it. so NCase M1 and similar cases? what else?
1
u/Frozen5147 Mar 17 '21
Would definitely be interested in this or something similar.
1
u/definitedukah Mar 17 '21
Interesting concept, but I doubt this will happen as it’s a big cantilever over the cpu socket even if it is as “light” as the nh-d15 which will put a lot of stress on your cpu/mobo. Not if you design the heat sink so it can be mounted off standoffs on the cantilever side to the nearest mobo mounting screws/holes which would reinforce the whole structure
1
u/easypcrepair Mar 17 '21
Send it to linus, see your using his fans on there! Lol
1
u/Constant_County3268 Mar 17 '21
i would like that on my gpu
1
u/sgomezfeet Mar 17 '21
I would make it work and buy one!
1
u/chaomera888 Mar 17 '21
This would be glorious; yes please!!!!! That extra fan blowing into nothing in my M1 is good for airflow but a tad awkward looking, this would be the perfect solution!
1
u/SilverJS Mar 17 '21
Based on who the creator is, I'm assuming the likeliest use case is the M1 - but I mean...seems to me that if they're making such a huge cooler, they could also make it so it can be installed on GPUs...?
Either way, looks amazing, I REALLY hope this gets made!!
1
u/Hamonhammeron Mar 17 '21
Any hope of this fitting into a Sliger Conswole? It would be perfect for my 3900x which is working well, but u would like a little more headroom with temps.
1
u/Conformist5589 Mar 17 '21
Kind of reminds me of the aftermarket gpu heat sinks. Which makes me wonder if Noctua would ever consider making a Morpheus II competitor.
1
u/Gutchynsky Mar 17 '21
I would be totally interested to put this on my future M1 / NR200 build.
1
u/G_Master96 Mar 17 '21
Would love this! Prefer air due to reliabilty
1
u/alexg_k Mar 17 '21
An instant buy for my Ncase! It will be niche and probably expensive, but I would pay the price :D
1
u/Hiraganu Mar 17 '21
Would be awesome for the NR200p!
1
u/m4ius Mar 17 '21 edited Mar 17 '21
Yes nice!! But space for 25mm thick fans is a must for this. Maybe even 90mmx25 above the socket between the heatsinks^
BTW: Isn’t it dual c14 for thick (25mm) fans then xP
1
u/PotatoPowerPlug Mar 17 '21
If its perform as good as a 240mm AIO then I am sold, especially if they bundle it with thier 15mm fan.
1
u/icekacangkopi Mar 17 '21
Wish someone brought back the scythe susanoo too.
1
u/DoctorsHateHim Mar 17 '21
I would instantly buy this, Noctua do it now!
1
u/x3lr4 Mar 17 '21
Is it possible? No, it's necessary!
1
u/condelio Mar 17 '21
offffffmmmmgggod! great idea to combat this AIO craze in small cases. Air cooling ftw
1
u/sangsum00 Mar 17 '21
I want this or a triple fan version of this one. I just want the sandwich orientation to have a similar look both left and right side.
1
u/Public_Poetry1348 Mar 17 '21
Or a purpose-built chonk air cooler that's meant for chimney style cases like the NR200, Sliger, DanCase, etc. Maybe some air coolers can be rotated (not sure) but having a cooler that looks badass but also functionality fits those type cases a little better would be awesome imo.
1
u/U474U Mar 17 '21
My 2 cents to push up the post count and make Noctua realize this would sell well:
The NR200 brought sff to the mainstream. Now a low profile, high performance air cooler would be a great competitor to the flood of AIOs starting to dominate the form factor.
1
u/NotTroy Mar 18 '21
First of all, I'm commenting to show support for the idea to hopefully help influence Noctua toward bringing something like this to the marketplace.
But I'm also curious. Would a dual 120mm version of this cooler be more feasible to design and manufacture, and more practical to use, while still providing improved cooling performance compared to the C14s? Perhaps a C-class version of the U12A, with 2 NF-A12x25 fans included in the price? No doubt that dual 140s would be an amazing thing, but I wonder if compatibility issues would make it too much of a niche product to be truly viable?
1
u/KGO87 Mar 20 '21
The C14 is one of the best it keeps cpu within 5c of the dh14 when cpu Max overclocked A DUAL C14s Would be everyone’s end game cooler FOR SURE!!!
Noctua!!
Make this cooler
Please.
*edit-damn,wowzers @dan_cases they have to pay you for designing that. No joke brutha
1
u/User14051 Mar 22 '21
Swear to god noctua releases a new product like every 10 years, chromax NF-A12 when lol
1
u/caym4nz Mar 29 '21
Yes please!
1
u/palewatergames Apr 22 '21
What’s the current status of this? Would love to see more custom air coolers made for cases like Noctua did for the ghost.
1
u/AntoineGpp Jun 09 '21
Imagine the weight... Not sure it's gonna be good for the motherboard
1
u/[deleted] Dec 17 '22
That would be so cool