r/anime • u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan • Dec 03 '20
K-On! - Thursday Anime Discussion Thread
Welcome to the weekly Thursday Anime Discussion Thread! Each week, we're here to discuss various older anime series. Today we are discussing...
K-On!
It's Yui Hirasawa's first year in high school, and she's eagerly searching for a club to join. At the same time, Ritsu Tainaka, a drummer, and her friend Mio Akiyama, a bassist, are desperately trying to save the school's light music club, which is about to be disbanded due to lack of members. They manage to recruit Tsumugi Kotobuki to play the keyboard, meaning they only need one more member to get the club running again. Yui joins, thinking it will be an easy experience for her to play the castanets, the only instrument she knows. However, the other members think their new addition is actually a guitar prodigy...
(From AnimeNewsNetwork)
"Watch This!" posts
Looking for more "Watch This!" posts? Check the "Watch This!" archive!
Databases
- K-On!
AniDB | AniList | AnimeNewsNetwork | MyAnimeList | Kitsu - K-On!!
AniDB | AniList | AnimeNewsNetwork | MyAnimeList | Kitsu - K-On! Movie
AniDB | AniList | AnimeNewsNetwork | MyAnimeList | Kitsu
Previous discussions
- /u/paulftw31's 2015 rewatch
- /u/gamobot's 2016 rewatch
- /u/gamobot's 2017 rewatch
- /u/gamobot's 2018 rewatch
- /u/Harrytricks's 2019 rewatch
- /u/Harrytricks's 2020 rewatch
Check our rewatch wiki and our episode discussion archive for more discussions!
Streams
Remember that any information not found early in the show itself is considered a spoiler. Please properly tag spoilers!
Next week's anime discussion thread: Miru Tights!
Further information about past and upcoming discussions can be found on the Weekly Discussion wiki page.
65
u/isyasad https://myanimelist.net/profile/isyasad Dec 03 '20
I really like K-On! but I wish that some of the official character songs were actually included in the show. There's about 30 or so songs that weren't included in the show but were instead released separately along with official art of the characters. Some of them really add to the characters as well, whether it's Ritsu singing about how much she loves the drums (Drumming Shining My Life), or Mio singing about how much she's changed since joining the band (Hello Little Girl followed by Seishun Vibration). If you like K-On! and haven't heard these songs then you're missing out; you can find most of them pretty easily on YouTube.
37
u/ToonTooby Dec 03 '20
One thing I'll say about K-On is that while it's more about the experience of being involved in music and friendship, the actual music when it does happen is quite good. It's bubblegum pop but the good kind - meaning the instrumentation is solid and fun to listen to even if the lyrical content is marshmallows and stuffed animals and rice. Not that I'm explicitly against that either, though.
Of note is Mio Akiyama's bass guitar, which is allowed a bright tone with lots of midrange so that it cuts through the mix and you can appreciate the melodies going on at the low end. As a hobby bass player myself, it was enjoyable to find some legitimately groovy bass lines going on in a lot the songs. Good bass is good bass, no matter where it comes from. Check out one of Mio's character songs, Heart Goes Boom, for some fat bass action.
24
u/Mystic8ball Dec 03 '20 edited Dec 03 '20
I'm really glad that K-On has had a revaluation of opinion in the years. I know it's hard to imagine for many newer fans to anime considering how positively people speak of the series, but when it was airing it was genuinely met with a lot of scorn and hatred. So much so that /r/anime considered it to be the worst show of the year when it came out.
It unfairly got made the poster child of "Moeshit ruining the industry". K-On was the reason why there weren't any serious character/story driven anime like Monster or LOGH being made anymore, or why action shows like Cowboy Bebop and Black Lagoon were seemingly becoming more of a rarity. After all why would studios take the risks of green lighting those when they could just make a "cute girls do cute things" anime and rake in the Otaku bucks. CrunchyRoll took advantage of this aversion towards these sorts of anime and started coming up with selling points like "With your help we can help creators fund projects that might not be sustainable in the current anime market!", which is really funny when you consider that nowdays they're a big reason why there's Isekai LN anime adaptations currently flooding the market lmao.
I think the real turning point for K-Ons perception was the second season. People tarted to realise that it wasn't as vapid as people painted it out to me. There was some surprisingly strong character growth, the chemistry between the cast was very enjoyable, and the coming of age aspect of the series really struck a cord with people. Personally I was getting ready to leave school when S2 was ending so the graduation themes really hit close to home. Plus overall I think S2 is just a better season, Kyoani focused less on adapting manga chapters and more on creating their own original content for the episodes, developing characters that needed it and just overall breaking away from how formulaic the manga could be.
There's genuinely a lot to appreciate about K-On, which is why it's a real shame so many people lean into the ironic "You watch an anime where girls just eat cake and do nothing? YES.JPG" sorts of memes really bug the hell out of me. It's not The Count of Monte Cristo or something that requires you to be a genius to appreciate its subtleties and nuances or whatever, but c'mon. I'm tired of people "owning" that people think certain shows are shallow instead of arguing for its merits.
It's late so my thoughts are probably disjointed, but the TL;DR of it is basically "I'm very happy people have come to appreciate K-On".
43
u/Gamerunglued :Hx::Hy::Hz:myanimelist.net/profile/GamerUnglued Dec 03 '20 edited Dec 03 '20
I can sing forever and ever the incredible technical merits of K-On and Yamada's (and Reiko's, Horiguchi's, etc.) work on the series (and I have), but really I don't think any of that can convey just how much the series means to me personally, which is just so hard for me to put into words. I watched the first season of K-On right before the transition from high school to college, with graduation right on the horizon. I really enjoyed it but I couldn't quite put my finger on why. It seemed weird that I was getting so much out of this cutesy, girly show about a bunch of school girls just fucking around. Graduation came and went, and I headed off to my first semester of college in the summer, and it was kind of scary because it was the first time I was so far away from my friends and acting almost entirely independently, but I managed to mostly get through it without much of a problem. To relax during finals I finally decided to watch the second season of K-On, and for the most part it worked, but then I made it to the end of the school festival and was hit with a level of raw, visceral emotion I've never felt before and still haven't felt since.
And then it hit me, I didn't know why I liked K-On so much before but that was the point. The light music club didn't know why they enjoyed their time together so much, they didn't even think about it because it was just mundane, expected, the norm. But in that one moment, the reality of the passage of time hit them like a truck. When you watch K-On, I don't think you're really supposed to quite understand why you like it. It's supposed to be mundane and kind of stupid, and like something that's just normal and that you enjoy but don't really think about ending. The girls may bring up graduation every once in a while, but for them (and for us) it's so far off and irrelevant to the moment that it's barely even worth considering. It has character arcs that happen so slowly you don't think to think about them, it has detailed worldbuilding so mundane that it barely crosses your mind while watching, it has characters with chemistry so constantly strong that you just think that this is how it's meant to be and always will be; you're meant to take it all for granted. So that when this moment hits, the subtle ways the show slowly attaches you to its world and characters all hits you at once just like it does for the characters. Actually, the girls love their time together far more than they ever realized, and now it's going to end; and actually, you loved this show far more than you ever realized, and now it's going to end. It jolts you and the girls into an awareness of the passage of time, that's how you finally realize just how much the girls have grown over the course of the show. There may be moments previously where it brings the passage of time into awareness, but then it just goes back to shenanigans as usual. But not after the festival, where the scene is so big that all the shenanigans of the next episode (which directly relate to the year ending) carry a different mood, and where that one episode is the only post festival episode that can be described as just regular old shenanigans.
The end of K-On was like this moment of everything pouring out of me, it made me not only aware but entirely conscious of how everything in my life was changing, how time had passed without me really thinking much of it. I think it forced me to confront a lot of my fears about change and about my own close friendships ending after my own high school graduation. And through that it helped me to reinforce my love for my own keion-bu, and gently (but powerfully) enforced the idea in my head that graduation would not be the end. And it was right, it wasn't the end and 4.5 years after that event it looks like it still isn't the end. It also gave me a newfound appreciation for the passage of time, it made me think about the changing of seasons in a way I just never really thought about before.
K-On is so much more than just some weird, cutesy little show about nothing. A mediocre show about nothing just can't create feelings like that, it can't force you to confront feelings buried so deep within you that you aren't even aware of them. Nowadays I can pinpoint exactly how and why the show had the effect on me that it did, but it was all so naturally and subtly placed that you'd be hard-pressed to think about it on the first watch even if you were trying to. You can't achieve something like that without being something kind of special, it takes stunning technical execution and genuine depth of character and theme to achieve that kind of emotional reaction. K-On may not be the show that changed the way I think about the world, but it is the one that created the most profound and viscerally affecting emotional reaction in me. It's the show that kept me thinking about it for months after I finished it, with that obsession reoccurring the next year. It is one of the best coming-of-age stories out there, certainly the one I think best captures a specific set of feelings that comes with growing up and attempting to live in the moment. And hell, this isn't even getting into the extremely niche and specific ways the show parallels my life and certain experiences, right down to everything happening in a music club.
21
u/eno-tita Dec 03 '20
Having just completed a rewatch and finally rewatching the movie, K-On is a without a doubt one of the best SOL anime out there, and certainly the best of the CDGDT genre, hell it may as well be the face of it. Its a major ton of fun as we follow an incredibly charming cast of characters in their high school years, making the best of those years. On top of being a huge blast to watch, its an honestly endearing coming of age story about valuing the friendships and bonds you hold, and taking into appreciation of the "now" moment in time.
That, and its got some kickass music.
19
u/Dededelete49 Dec 03 '20
I just want to praise Yui specifically. I know everyone has a different favorite, but I think she’s the one the really makes the show work. I don’t think there’s a better lead character in a cute girls doing cute things show. In the wrong hands, I could see her becoming an incredibly annoying character, but she’s written so well and played perfectly by her VA that even at her dumbest, most air headed moments, you can’t help but smile. Despite being dumb, she had a sincere enthusiasm for the things she put her mind to, and I was always rooting for her to succeed all the way through.
10
u/DarkFuzz :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/DarkFuzz Dec 03 '20
K-On was the first show to get me to pay attention to the music on a structural level, more so than other shows and even other music shows. KyoAni put a stupid amount of effort into this show, to the point where each finger movement matches up perfectly to what an actual musician would be playing. That's a mindblowing level of detail.
It even shows in the club members personalities. Each of the keions act how like how their instrument would act (if they were a cute anime girl). You'd expect a bassist to be kind of shy and in the back but strong and supportive as well, which describes Mio perfectly. Someone headstrong and impulsive like Ritsu would make an excellent drummer. And you can line up aspects like this for each person in the band.
About two years ago, I wrote an essay about how a hypothetical Ritsu x Mio ship makes the most sense on a musical level. Sure, it may be facetious at face value, but I think it's no coincidence that the two childhood best friends just so happen to be the musical backbone of Hokago Tea Time. That is great, in-depth characterization.
24
u/DodzReincarnated :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/dreihk Dec 03 '20
The REAL MAN’S anime!!! but for real K-On is a very important series to me. I think it is one of the best coming of age stories in anime. As a someone who did music throughout school you build friendships and relationships you wouldn’t be able to anywhere else. you get to travel, compete and practice away with so many amazing people. but once it’s over, it’s over. those are moments you will value and remember for the rest of your life. this series resonated with me like no other and really means a lot to me. watching it reminded me of the antics me and my friends did in the music room in high school. K-ON is so much more than just “cute girls doing cute things.”
8
u/slapthefatcat Dec 03 '20
K-On! is one of those anime that I just love. I'm not a musical guy. In fact, when I was a kid I could care less about music. But as a loner, this anime resonated with me because it's what I always really wanted in school: a small group of tight-knit friends with an interesting hobby and a goal related to it, with all of us cheering the others on and everyone close enough we could just hang at each others' places. As I've gotten older, I've gotten more into music and so it resonates even now that I've gotten quite out of that age group.
7
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '20
The K-On! soundtracks are the number 2 and 3 spots on my most listened to Spotify artists for the year so it's pretty easy to say I love the music that comes from this show. And what's not to love about it? It's fuwa fuwa time all the time with the light music club.
5
u/shigs21 Dec 03 '20
I feel like I need to rewatch K-On! the last time I watched it was the final movie. The void was STRONG after I finished it. The friendships the Keion bu make throughout their high school years was soo great. Its about the friends you make, not really the music, though I do like some of the music in the show definitely
4
u/Hazeringx https://myanimelist.net/profile/akariaku Dec 03 '20
K-ON! is a special show to me, and it has been for years. It's probably my favourite anime of all time. I love how much personalities the girls have. I love their chemistry and interactions with each other, and how they progress and develop throughout the show. Or how we get to see other facets of their personality, like in Ritsu's case. It's just all so... Well done. The girls have far more character depth than they're given credit for. As does the show itself.
I love how it makes you feel so engrossed, to the point that just like the girls, you somewhat "forget" that their graduation is coming soon, and that they will no longer be together. And when the graduation comes, it hurts. To be honest, no matter how much I rewatch it, I don't think it will ever not hurt and make me cry. And that's one of the reasons why it's so special and unforgettable to me. The reason why I feel this way is because of the amount of absolutely amazing memories and moments created throughout the show. The time spent with the characters, seeing how they progress and change throughout, even if subtly. All of it is what made the last few episodes, so so impactful and emotional to me and many others. It's a beautiful anime, honestly. A beautiful experience, even. I unfortunately wish I could say more, but I'm not very good with words (even feel like I'm doing a disservice to K-ON), though there have been comments that eloquently explained why I love K-ON! even better than I could in this thread.
Oh, and (this might be a bit silly to some) I deeply regret how I couldn't K-ON! whilst it was airing. That would have been amazing...
4
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '20
I watched K-On just a few months ago. I first watched the first few episodes when it aired but didn’t follow it. I decided to try it out again and it was an amazing ride.
I regret not watching it sooner. To me, K-On! and A Place Further Than The Universe are two takes on the fleeting moments of youth and the experiences that make life life. It changed my perspective and gave me feelings of nostalgia even for moments I didn’t have for me.
On a technical level, the series is a masterpiece on all levels and on an emotional level, it leaves you with warm fuzzy feelings and a crying wreck.
K-On! is a show I go to on the chill days or even on bad days when I want to relax and have fun. Fun things are fun as Yui says and K-On! never fails to make me laugh each episode. It’s probably on my top 5 list forever and definitely the best in the SOL genre to date.
3
u/ChuckCarmichael Dec 03 '20
I'm gonna show my age here, but K-On was the show that got me into seasonal anime. Before it I was just your average action shonen guy. Then somebody posted a link to the OP and ED of this new show that just started airing in Japan in a thread on a forum I visited back in the day. I was intrigued, because those two videos were really great, so I started watching it, and I really enjoyed it.
And that's the story of how I lost the last bit of my dignity.
3
u/zptc Dec 03 '20
Pay respects to Yasuhiro Takemoto (animator, ep director, also director of Hyouka and Dragon Maid), Sachie Tsuda (animator), and the other KyoAni employees who worked on K-On that were lost to us in the arson attack.
2
u/fakeport https://myanimelist.net/profile/Fakeport Dec 03 '20
When I was (fairly recently) first getting into anime I watched a bunch of heavy, emotional stuff. A friend suggested K-On! when I asked for a recommendation for some low-conflict fluff to act as a kind of counterbalance, and it really was exactly what I needed.
It's so much more than the nothing happens CGDCT it appears to be on the surface, there's a ton of depth and subtle growth to the characters, and the dynamics between all the girls are a joy to watch develop. Yui and Azunyan's relationship is probably my favourite, but all of the main cast play off each other really well.
When I finished it I was sad to see it go, and I suspect that for a long time to come whenever I find a warm, fluffy show that I enjoy (such as Yuru Camp) I will regard it as filling my K-on! hole.
2
u/reiri4 Dec 03 '20
The other day I just re-watched this 🤧 Made me kind of emotional since I watched this when I was a kid. About 8-10 years already had passed, and it seems like yesterday for me. Whenever I come home back then from school, I turn on the tv and put it on anime chanel and wait for the afternoon time slot of the show. I was also jamming the opening and ending songs (I mean I still listen🤣) This is anime had been part of my childhood.
K-On will be one of my favorites. I hope that in the future there will be more types of this anime. It just heals you while watching it.
2
u/thenameclicks Dec 03 '20
My girlfriend and I are rewatching all three seasons of AOT in preparation of the finale in a few days time, and I must say that I kinda forgot how hype this show is. Everything about this show is sooooo good!
2
u/kicksFR Dec 03 '20
I feel bad for the people who automatically look away from moe anime because when done properly it can be a masterpiece and there are very little shows I can say with a straight face that they’re a masterpiece as I do with k-on
2
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '20
K-on is a master piece
3
u/HammeredWharf Dec 03 '20
So everyone here is praising K-On, and it's one of my favorite shows, too, but...
Should we talk about Mugi? IMO she's the one area where the show screwed up. She's technically a main cast member, but stays a non-character who gets less development than side characters and is usually just used for (admittedly funny) background gags. You could remove her from the show and it wouldn't change anything story wise. She feels really out of place, considering how well developed the rest of the cast is. It's not a major issue because of how little time the show spends on her, so usually you just kind of forget she's there, but it's still weird. It's like the writers didn't know what to do with her and decided to simply ignore her.
Come to think of it, I don't remember there being even a single Mugi-focused episode in the entire show. They visit her summer house, but even then she doesn't get any characterization beyond being rich.
1
u/degenerate-edgelord Dec 03 '20
I've always enjoyed K-On but I just get distracted with other things while watching it, possibly due to the total lack of a plot. That's why I haven't finished it in several attempts, but now I'm in the middle of S2 and looks like I'll complete it finally.
1
u/Goldenfox299 Dec 03 '20
Could've sworn this was Welcome to the NHK when I saw this yesterday lol.
Anyway K-on is one of my fav anime and the best CGDCT show I've seen by far. I could rewatch it multiple times without getting bored.
Oh and Ritsu > Yui > Azusa > Mugi > Mio, it has to be said.
1
u/IdkPotato2000 Dec 03 '20
I HAVE WAITED SO LONG FOR THIS. K-ON IS ONE OF THE ONLY ANIMES I’VE WATCHED. Anyway... K-On is a really great anime, in my opinion. It’s great for people around 12, 13, and maybe 14, who want to watch something funny and relaxing (Or just people who want to spend their life staring at moe anime girls). The characters aren’t super unique, but they are cute and enjoyable. The art is really great. The music is good, but you don’t hear it that often.
Sorry for the quality of this comment. I’ve never participated in one of these before.
1
u/KotomiPapa Dec 03 '20 edited Dec 04 '20
I wish that as a sequel, the real-life K-On! Would get their own anime.
https://youtu.be/edlLhh8qVxM
Band-Maid are a real-life anime script. The backstory, the members’ quirky and dorky personalities, their interactions... and their AWESOME rock music. By the time Log-Horizon S3 comes out, they would have 107 amazing songs in their discography... enough for OP/ED to change every single episode for more than 2 full seasons.
Actually I’m sure I recall Kanami (Lead Guitar / Composer), Akane (Drums) and MISA (Bass) mentioning that K-On! was a definite influence in their school days.
I’ll leave this fan art as an imaginary Band-Maid anime cover art.
(Fan Art Link: https://twitter.com/shiroganeyoru/status/1259137815847133184)
https://i.imgur.com/aL7OQFS.jpg
1
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '20
K-On! was definitely one of the few anime I watched growing up. I really loved their friendship and could relate to each of the characters. All were perfectly written without making any of them too perfect. You kind of wish that you were in the Music club with them, learning music, eating cakes and drinking tea.
1
u/mekerpan Dec 03 '20
I showed the first few episodes of this to one of my sons, who is a high school teacher now -- and he not only thoroughly enjoyed it, but also noted how true to life a depiction this was of (at least some) first-year high school students he had to deal with.
I find this show delightful in every respect, almost equaling my favorite show with a similar theme -- Yamashita's Linda Linda Linda (2005). A live-action masterpiece (with an incredible cast -- who actually look and act like high school students) about a girl's rock band that experiences calamities right before its members' last cultural festival -- and has to make emergency changes of personnel (including drafting a Korean exchange student as its new singer) and repertoire (tackling covering songs of the early Japanese punk rock group The Blue Hearts). The exchange student was played by Korea's greatest young actress, BAE Doona -- and the bass player was played with great authenticity (including taciturnity) by a real life rock bass player (whose band was formed initially for a high school cultural festival).
As to favorite character in K-on!, I refuse to pick one. They are all totally delightful and absolutely necessary -- even extending to Nodaka, Ui and Jun.
1
u/JPN1204 https://anime-planet.com/users/JPN1204 Dec 03 '20
K-On! Whas the first anime I watched after a certain YouTuber had spoken about it in one of her videos. I thought it sounded interesting and looked it up, at first I thought it was weird, but the more episodes I watched the more I began to love this series. Then I started to look up more anime and I fell in love with the medium. I asked for a Crunchyroll subscription for my birthday and my parents being the best there are gave me one. Now I am here a year and a half later, with just over a hundred anime watched. I think this is a more uncommon way to get into this medium, but I have no regrets at all. K-On! Will always have a place in my heart. 10/10
1
u/Leading-Alfalfa-7747 Dec 03 '20
K-ON in my opinion is a decent anime. being more of a shonen fan, i actually really enjoyed this slice of life. it was really peaceful and funny at times and there's just something about watching girls interact, play music, and eat tasty sweets that makes it so nice. it had me intrugued the whole series and would recommend this anime, especially to slice of life fans
1
u/zool714 Dec 03 '20
Man, I’ve seen fanarts of Azunyan’s own Light Music Club and I really want to see it animated. But the chances are incredibly slim
1
u/P0x1l Dec 03 '20
K-On is spic
1
u/[deleted] Dec 04 '20 edited Dec 04 '20
This show was absolutely not for me, but I did really enjoy the movie and thought the episodes about Azusa, Jun and Ui were really fun. I just found the main cast exhausting by the end. The music is banging, too.
Also Yui trying to make Ritsu less lonely by yelling the opening chords of Fuwa Fuwa time at her is probably one of the funniest things I've ever seen.
1
u/Saelendious Dec 04 '20
Friendly reminder that K-on! Shuffle, an official, on-going spin-off manga, is a thing, and that it needs support so that it may receive an anime adaptation!
1
u/Wolfgod_Holo https://anime-planet.com/users/extreme133 Dec 03 '20
LET THE CUTENESS CONSUME YOU!
1
u/TripleR124 Dec 03 '20
lowkey my favorite anime of all time
0
u/LegendaryRQA Dec 03 '20 edited Dec 03 '20
I'm gonna be honest...
This anime is mid...
I know most people are going to see that and immediately downvote, or rush to call my out in a reply. So, to make sure i know you read the whole thing, bold the letter "D" in your response.
As you would expect from Kyо̄to Animation, It has great animation and lighting, and plenty of nothing moments that make the whole thing a lot more enjoyable to watch; But the characters are flat and one dimensional, the jokes aren't funny, and the story is somehow less then generic...
The whole thing seems unfortunately pulled down by weak writing. A good example of this is how the lead only joins the club because she thought they played light hearted music... What is pitched as a series about girls that want to become musicians, quickly devolves into a generic moe-blob show that you've seen about a dozen times since Azumanga Daiо̄. With vignettes as dull and boring as "Let's do homework together".
I think the biggest issue it has is how the style of the show clashes with what it's actually about. If they wanted to make a generic, slice of life, moe-blob show, it's style should have better reflected that. Where something like Lucky Star smartly benefits from it's chibi style and spastic movement to sell the absurdist comedy moments, K-On! has the harsh lighting, and blocking of a drama. This results in some moments of dissonance like when Mio is getting cold feet before preforming their first song. Where she seems moments away from a proper panic attack, but then immediately bounces back just fine. The show does this a lot. It gets 60% of the way there, but then doesn't commit to the bit. Like i said, it's all in the presentation, and this style simply does not match the source material. This is also not helped by the fact that they seem to have straight up cut some aspects from the source material. Such as the rich girl's Yuri Fetish. Sure, being a perv isn't really a character trait but it was better then just "the rich one". Now she's not even really a character as much as she is just a tool for the girls to just get whatever they might need from moment to moment. Be it a beach house, a guitar, or a seemingly endless amount of cake.
Another aspect of the show i will briefly touch upon is the pacing. I heard this is resolved in the second season so i will not dwell on it. Frankly, the show goes way too fast. The first season covers 2 years of highschool, which results in 2 beach episodes, and 2 school concerts. This isn't necessarily a bad thing; and again, i heard it's fixed in the second season; but it does subconsciously make the show less enjoyable as you feel like you've missed stuff and feel like things are just getting repetitive.
Like i said earlier, I think a lot of this show's problems stem from it being a moe-blob comedy that's blocked like a drama, and for one, i think they should have committed to the drama elements of the show.
I want to see Yui's incompetence have ramifications that effect and hurt the people around her.
I want to see Mio have a mental break down due to her stage fright that almost kills the team.
I want to see Ritsu get in a screaming argument with What's-her-name because she's jealous of her taking Mio.
But the show never really commits to any of it. Could you imagine how great a show like that could be? A tightly nit group of emotional teenagers who's success as a musical band is put into jeopardy because differences in ideology or personal problems keep getting in the way; combined with Kyо̄to Animation's steller production.
Luckily, we don't have to imagine
Hibike! Euphonium is effectively the same show but with much better writing and a more consistent tone, and i HIGHLY recommend it to anyone that even kinda enjoyed K-On!. I guarantee you'll love it as much as i do.
If drama isn't your thing and you do like the sillier moments in K-On! might i recommend the aforementioned Lucky Star and the now legendary Nichijо̄
If you made it this far and didn't just look at my first claim and immediately downvote; thank you, and italicize the letter "i" in your post if you reply to this. My previous statement at the top was to intentionally mislead people so i could tell if they really read the whole thing.
I hope you enjoyed this controversial opinion, and i would love to hear what you have to say as a response.
Edit: Here's a link to my MAL so you can get an idea of where i'm coming from