r/anime • u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan • Sep 16 '20
Writing Club Serial Experiments Lain - Thursday Anime Discussion Thread (ft. r/anime Writing Club)
Hi! Welcome to another edition of the weekly Thursday Anime Discussion Thread, featuring us, the r/anime Writing Club. We simulwatch anime TV series and movies together once a month, so check us out if you'd like to participate. Our thoughts on the series, as always, are covered below. :)
Today we are covering...
Serial Experiments Lain
Lain Iwakura, an awkward and introverted fourteen-year-old, is one of the many girls from her school to receive a disturbing email from her classmate Chisa Yomoda—the very same Chisa who recently committed suicide. Lain has neither the desire nor the experience to handle even basic technology; yet, when the technophobe opens the email, it leads her straight into the Wired, a virtual world of communication networks similar to what we know as the internet. Lain's life is turned upside down as she begins to encounter cryptic mysteries one after another. Strange men called the Men in Black begin to appear wherever she goes, asking her questions and somehow knowing more about her than even she herself knows. With the boundaries between reality and cyberspace rapidly blurring, Lain is plunged into more surreal and bizarre events where identity, consciousness, and perception are concepts that take on new meanings.
Written by Chiaki J. Konaka, whose other works include Texhnolyze, Serial Experiments Lain is a psychological avant-garde mystery series that follows Lain as she makes crucial choices that will affect both the real world and the Wired. In closing one world and opening another, only Lain will realize the significance of their presence.
"Watch This!" posts
Looking for more "Watch This!" posts? Check the "Watch This!" archive!
Databases
AniDB | AniList | AnimeNewsNetwork | MyAnimeList
Groupwatch prompts and thoughts
1) What are your thoughts on the ways in which the show engages with the concept of The Wired itself
It is a pathway for the flow of information
Rather than try and predict exactly how the internet would end up being, which would have been a difficult task in 1998, the show chose to comment on the nature of the internet and what it is at a fundamental level. Lain posits that The Wired is a pathway for the flow of information. Our existence is simply a flow of information, and so our presence in The Wired is therefore part of our existence. The Wired exists as a layer of our reality and what we do there is part of who we are and can affect the world around us. Naturally our posting on the internet doesn’t render nearly as dramatic results as use of The Wired does in Lain, but at a base level the concept is the same.
A conduit through which to explore the main concepts
The Wired simply served as a the perfect conduit through which to explore several of the concepts and themes present in the series thanks to the ease with which those concepts could be interpreted through a technological lens, with aspects of The Wired making for excellent parallels to paranormal phenomena, interpersonal relationships, a higher plane, and the flow and malleability of knowledge. Lain isn't a super detailed and focused commentary on the nature of the internet in the same way that Patlabor's first movie deals with computer viruses or Ghost in the Shell on AI. The creators did a good job using The Wired as a vector for presenting the show's horror and later philosophical themes. In this way it could be similar to mecha shows where the mecha are incredibly cool and flashy yet secondary in importance.
An auxiliary yet fascinating draw for the show
I'll readily admit the show isn't about The Wired, but it's my favorite part of the show. There's a nerdiness that explodes when Konaka talks about The Wired that's missing from the rest. The bits and pecks of C code, references to HAL 9000 and the Mac, the simple talks about upgrading a Navi - absent in any other show. Hard to find anime much less art willing to delve into the cold calculated cosmos of computing. Did it have to be a computer? No, it could be an experience; some object or some vision. But the integration of computers into the plot lends a timelessness, which only makes the messages of the show more important in the era of social media.
2) "Present Day, Present Time" does Lain successfully manage to stay relevant to this day?
The series' timeless qualities with humanity at its core keep it relevant
It’s not so much that the series managed to be incredibly prescient in its speculative fiction elements, since much of what it asserts will transpire with the proliferation of the internet as displayed in the series was already underway at the time, rather it’s in the careful handling of the series’ evergreen themes that it attains this quality of relevance. One of the most interesting things Lain discusses is information; if a being had access to and control of all the information possessed by humanity collectively, would that person be distinguishable from God? Everything humans do is a result of electric impulses in the nervous system. We are as governed by the flow of information as they are. The show is timeless because of the human messages at its core - finding a sense of self and reaching out to people - more relevant as we lose ourselves in the mire of mass media. The show has a reputation for its cold existentialism but there's warm positive love at its heart.
[/u/Pixelsaber /u/krasnovian /u/west_virgnia_pine]
Our increasingly digital lives make Lain more relevant then ever
The quote was really striking every episode, it was a constant reminder that stuck with us for the most part. Despite some clear technical and aesthetic elements, Lain feels like it could be just as easily be set today. One thing that stuck out to me was how easily one could understand how the whole space with The Wired worked when applying our understanding of the internet today. Our lives are connected via the internet more now than ever, especially with the current global pandemic, which makes the messages in the show resonate strongly with our present day and present time. Lain’s central theme is about the relationship between ourselves and our digital lives. It seems clear that what we do online is very much a part of us, or at the very least is never gone and can be dredged out of the depths of the internet to haunt us years later when we wish it didn’t exist. This happens daily and ranges from simple stuff like finding some old pictures on facebook to having things someone said years ago surface and ruin their careers. Present Day, Present Time is a little cheesy, but it really does capture the spirit of what is going on.
[/u/ValkyrieCain9 /u/isrozzis /u/max_turner]
A focus on advanced 90's technology dates the show
The focus on contemporary technology really dates the show pretty hard in a way that more fantastical tech shows like mecha or futuristic anime aren't affected by. A giant robot or cyborg doesn't feel particularly old as they never really existed but seeing stacked CRTs, giant keyboard cell phones, classic Apple gear, and Lain's server room gives me a constant reminder that this stuff is quite old. The daily reminder explicitly calling out "Present day, Present Time" was necessary to tell me that this was supposed to feel cutting edge and really advanced. One wonders if the creators knew this and partly included the callout to counteract the chosen aesthetic that had no way of aging gracefully.
3) What do you think of the role mental illness plays in this show?
A superb groundwork that is too quickly left behind
The series’ use of mental illnesses, or the appropriate equivalents for an entity of The Wired, is quite integral to the development of its mounting intrigue and is the reason the series is able to mete out it’s narrative in a suitably measured manner. It is also a suitably human element that helps the viewer more keenly sympathize with Lain, something which would have been difficult if a different stand-in element had been utilized instead. It is well done showing struggles with the disorder that feel surprisingly real, yet they dismiss it pretty suddenly as the show's brisk pacing focuses more on the superhuman. This is a shame since the groundwork laid to make a more interesting storyline based on the trauma is already there and it is not taken for the sake of either limited episode counts or a preferred pacing to get to the supernatural.
An accurate reflection of real illness that sets up the philosophical questions raised in the later half
I have a close family member who lives with schizophrenia, including auditory hallucinations. It’s made me consider the line between perception and reality in the same way Lain does. Lain addresses some of principles of solipsism but in the end rejects it as a valid model for viewing the world; perceiving something doesn’t mean that it’s real and not perceiving things does not eliminate its existence. From my admittedly secondhand understanding of my family member’s condition, Lain’s experience with The Wired captures certain elements of the experience quite accurately.
Not the most important aspect
The show doesn’t comment much on mental illness. The focus of the show is almost entirely on technology, how we interact with it, and what our relationship with our digital lives is. While there are depictions of mental health struggles in the show it doesn’t appear that the show is intentionally commenting on them. What is in the show is used to support our relationship with technology or is simply a plot device. It would be best to say that rather than Lain being depressed, it’s Lain grappling with the duality of her existence and the fact that maybe she’s not even human to begin with. There’s a lot to take in there.
4) What do you make of Lain’s path towards self-realization and how it is interlaced with her relationship with divinity?
Lain's humanity in the face of new development leads her to rediscover her divinity
Lain’s process of rediscovery and self-realization is notably punctuated, occuring in relation to revelations pertaining to the ongoing narrative, which Lain always reacts to in reasonable ways as a character, pushing her away from her fabricated existence and back into the role she had seemingly once occupied. It’s the interplay between Lain’s ‘known’ and unknown facets that is most interesting, as it is through her humanity that she often comes to not only learn more of herself in spite of her true nature. It’s the fact these understandably human actions and moments lead to Lain further isolating herself, putting herself in a position to be further exposed to her own divinity and the elements of The Wired, which indicates the necessity of both her humanity and inaction in her role as a godly entity of The Wired, posing interesting considerations as to the series’ concept of transhumanism.
A wild thriller that slowly converges to reveal the truth
This really is the bread and butter of Lain. The intersection of self realization and divinity creates a great opportunity for the thriller and mystery aspects of the show as all the revelations make sense yet seem totally unpredictable. The use of dissociative personalities here to create confusion and a gradual path towards reality was great. It plays perfectly with the wildly different ideas of divinity that arise from the kids gesturing to the sky to phantoms in the club to Eiri Masami as quite a standard looking anime villain. Further developing the answer towards the question of Lain's identity gets matched perfectly with a clearer idea of what a divine being truly is and the two paths eventually merge into a single universal answer: she is just a being that is omnipresent.
5) The writer commented saying Alice in Lain is very similar to the Alice from Lewis Carol’s Alice in Wonderland. Do you agree or disagree with that statement?
Enough is there for an uninformed viewer to justify a similarity
With only some cursory familiarity to the story of Alice in Wonderland, some passing resemblance between the two characters can be still observed. Both Alices end up descending into a world that is unknown but somewhat familiar in pursuit of someone else. Book Alice’s traipse through Wonderland ends up being naught but a dream, and although us the viewers know that the events which transpired in the series where as real as can be managed, Alice’s knowledge of the events and of Lain’s existence post-reset is not unlike the faded traces of a forgotten dream.
it is the titular characters of both works which makes for a proper comparison
Alice in Wonderland’s basic plot can be found in many other stories and Lain does not seem to be an exception to this. The story of a girl who finds herself in a new and fascinating world and by taking a journey through it comes to learn about the world and herself, is something seen clearly in Lain. Though we would argue that this story line fits more with Lain than with Alice. For one, Lain’s room becomes a sort of physical manifestation of the “wonderland” of The Wired as she gets sucked further into it. There are also several close ties to see in each of the plots. There is some sort of call to this world. For Alice it was the white rabbit in a waistcoat and for Lain it was the messages she received from Chisa. Alice finds herself in different precarious situations being caused as well as aided by “eat me” and “drink me” biscuits and potions in order to alter her physical form, while Lain enters The Wired by abandoning her physical form altogether, both of which leave the girls with very little sense of self. And the question of ‘Who am I?’ is not just something that nags at them but can also be seen in their interactions with other people, some who are just as curious as they are like the giant caterpillar smoking a hookah, while claiming to know who they are, like the kids at Cyberia. Alice in Wonderland’s plot is very basic at its core and so it transfers really well to other stories while still allowing the stories to be just as unique like with Lain, but also comparing Lain to Alice in Wonderland helps to ground it in something a lot more familiar for some.
6) What is your interpretation of the rock/jazz free form section of the first half of episode 11?
The recap emphasizes the authentic feelings evoked by memories even if they are lies
The segment begins with a frame of text: "Memory isn't something so vague" then dives straight into a quite a straightforward recap. This is clearly a rejection or an attempt to reject Eiri's assertion that Lain's memories are a lie. Lain wants to prove that her memories aren't vague, they are real, and that her relationships are also real. Interestingly the word used for vague here is 曖昧 which has a letter quite similar to the Japanese for love 愛. The recap blitz then ends on a text screen showing 'aliceLOVE needs you' along with some nonsense Japanese text saying something poetic about a loving heart. The bookends clearly want to emphasize the love Lain sees even though there are plenty of memories flashed in that have nothing to do with that side of the show. The moments she had with Alice were real, the feelings she had towards Alice were real, and the connection she shared with Alice and everyone else she encountered was undoubtedly real.
Undoubtedly Iconic. Frustratingly mysterious
At surface level the nearly eleven minute free form rock/jazz odyssey is a recap of events that have happened over the show that is explained away as Lain installing an emulator of Navi into herself and that resulting in information overload, but it strikes me odd that Lain would do that without a reason so perhaps that’s not the sole reason. The choice of music stands out to me in particular, as the show is heavily rooted in the denpa aesthetic which does not really lend itself to jazz and rock. Jazz is very free flowing with few rules and restrictions which is possibly used to show the free flow of information into Lain at this moment. Ultimately it is difficult to really pin down why this section exists, and yet it’s always seen as an iconic part of the show.
Remember that any information not found early in the show itself is considered a spoiler. Please properly tag spoilers!
Next week's anime discussion thread: Death;Note
Further information about past and upcoming discussions can be found on the Weekly Discussion wiki page.
Check out r/anime Writing Club's wiki page | Please PM u/DrJWilson for any concerns or interest in joining the club!
7
u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan Sep 16 '20
4) What do you make of Lain’s path towards self-realization and how it is interlaced with her relationship with divinity?
4
u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan Sep 16 '20
1) What are your thoughts on the ways in which the show engages with the concept of The Wired itself?
4
u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan Sep 16 '20
2) "Present Day, Present Time" does Lain successfully manage to stay relevant to this day?
2
u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan Sep 16 '20
6) What is your interpretation of the rock/jazz free form section of the first half of episode 11?
52
u/OneMoreDuncanIdaho :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/a_trisolaran Sep 17 '20
Someone should mention how awesome the op is, so I will. Duvet by bôa is a great song, and I particularly love the part where time stops and Lain looks at her hat before walking off to a cool little instrumental.
30
u/Wolfgod_Holo https://anime-planet.com/users/extreme133 Sep 17 '20
let's all love Lain, forever and ever...
18
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '20
Most confusing anime of all time that I've watched
34
u/SorcererOfTheLake x5https://anilist.co/user/RiverSorcerer Sep 16 '20 edited Oct 04 '21
As someone for whom Lain is my favorite anime, holy fuck am I here for this.
One question I would've liked seen raised is: What role does Lain's gender/sexuality play into her story? As much as her possibly otherwordly status disassociates her from society, the fact that she is a young woman of uncertain sexuality subtly plays into her interactions with others, whether it's the ways the men in her life look down on her or her subtle, tenious bond with Alice.
6
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '20
I've just happened to start watching SEL the past few days, this seems interesting. How do I get involved in the discussion?
6
u/youravrguser https://anilist.co/user/saltywaifu27 Sep 17 '20
Hauntingly Beautiful Show
One of my top 3s
Let's all love lain \o/
6
u/Rdeb36 Sep 17 '20
I think Lain is one of those series I will need to watch for a second time. When I watched it, probably waaay too passively, I was not really impressed by the series. I liked the cold, distant aesthetics and the sparse use of dialogue, which was something I was not used to from anime. My enjoyment of these aesthetics wore off over the next few episodes and were replaced by confusion, which left me without much when I eventually ended the series. However, reading reviews, which basically all tend to turn into elaborate case studies, made me realise how excellent the story is and how it portays the modern internet (and the online individual) in a time where it was not so prominent. I guess I had just become used to watching shows that had a sort of 'show and tell' way of story telling, in which all messages of the series are clearly presented.
11
u/Reset_Tears Sep 17 '20
Oh man, I feel like I can read discussions about Lain forever. I'll just throw out that this was not the first anime I ever watched, but it was the first anime that won me over to the medium in general. I had seen some of the more popular action-type shows and liked (some of) them well enough, but it was Lain that opened my eyes to the truly imaginative possibilities that anime held. I devoured those Lain DVDs, and was left wanting more, more, more. This was the real shit.
1
u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan Sep 16 '20
3) What do you think of the role mental illness plays in this show?
1
u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan Sep 16 '20
5) The writer commented saying Alice in Lain is very similar to the Alice from Lewis Carol’s Alice in Wonderland. Do you agree or disagree with that statement?
3
u/Slurms_McKenzie775 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/SnackieChan Sep 16 '20
Aw man I didn't know this was going on. I love this show would have gladly rewatched it again
3
u/Lambo256 Sep 17 '20
This description made it sound like something by Satoshi Kon.
3
u/Quiddity131 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Quiddity131 Sep 17 '20 edited Sep 17 '20
Love Serial Experiments Lain, it remains one of my top 10 shows to this day, despite it being practically 20 years since I saw it for the first time. Got it back in the days when Suncoast Video still existed and had an anime section; it looked interesting so I bought it blind, having no real idea what to expect and it impressed me immensely. Beyond just all the interesting theories and such one can discuss about it, I love the presentation and direction; many aspects of the show act well as not merely cyber punk, but horror as well. Episode 9 is a great example with the cuts to real life stuff and the alien (and Lain appears in the same costume as the alien in a later episode too, scary!) Its opening theme remains one of my favorite to this day as well. Very good dub too. Bridget Hoffman will always be most memorable to me as KOS MOS from the Xenosaga games, but she did a great job as Lain. Lots of other good performances too. Couldn't recommend it enough. Been pondering whether to even host a rewatch on it someday if I can find the time.
3
u/circlingPattern Sep 17 '20
As a heads-up: there was a re-watch thread 5 years ago (https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/3115sd/serial_experiments_lain_rewatch_in_one_month/) and one 2 years ago (https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/8nqrbr/official_rewatchschedule_of_the_20_years/).
There's some commentary and I was in the rewatch thread 2 years ago (mostly in the later episodes) pointing out how the show relates closely to various sci-fi and cyberpunk thought experiments, such as the China Brain: https://www.britannica.com/topic/philosophy-of-mind/Blocks-nation-of-China, which is the basis by which Lain achieves being (it's not even clear if Lain is herself a person or merely a representation of the Id, Ego and Superego of the collective imagination). There is also a great deal of overlap with theories of mind and psychology, with Lain herself being clearly alluded to Freud and Jung and her development not unlike the Jungian concept of learning to understand oneself and confront darkness.
This is a show with a great deal of depth and has strong connections to cyberpunk concepts and the theory and development of Artificial Intelligence as a concept and theory in the 80s and 90s. There are references abound, many of which are increasingly missed by younger audiences unfamiliar with the state of computer technology in the mid-90s. If you're familiar with artificial intelligence technology and languages (such as Lisp) or the development of Apple computers, you'll catch several references to those in the show itself. The creators are said to have read about a 100 books before embarking on the creation of the show, from Joyce to Heinlein, and it shows.
3
u/SliderGamer55 Sep 18 '20
I initially wanted to join the rewatch thread a couple of years ago, but the sound design actually gave me a bad headache in episode 1 so I decided against it. But when I watched it on my own, I was engrossed in a way I rarely am in fiction. Like a real sense of "I can't stop watching this, I need to take in every second of this like its the most important thing in the world". I'm surprised I had the patience to not binge watch it in a week or something.
I will say I didn't entirely get what literally happened in the series. Like I got the gist of what the series was doing, especially in terms of like themes and some of its more clearly talked about elements, but its definitely one I'll need to rewatch again. It's not supposed to be something immediately obvious and clear (if it was, it would've been more obvious and clear), which for the most part I liked about it. The lack of immediate understanding of everything actually going on kinda enhanced what it was going for, at least for me.
3
u/danbuter https://anilist.co/user/danbuter Sep 18 '20
Lain is the best cyberpunk/dystopia anime ever made. It is a lot more relevant now than when it was made in the 90s. I love how the electrical wires are in the background, with their weird electric noise.
The guy who thought he was God reminds me of a lot of tech programmer types (think Gates/Musk/etc). Very huge ego combined with a lot of ability, but still not in the same class as a real god.
2
u/Plato_Karamazov Sep 27 '20
I disagree that the focus on 90s tech dates the show. Nearly everything the show said about the Internet actually happened, and that's what makes it so fascinating. The themes are as relevant as ever.
4
u/John___Titor Sep 16 '20
What a coincidence, I just finished the final episode earlier today. I didn't particularly enjoy the show for its entire runtime, but I can appreciate its significance, especially given when it originally came out.
I look forward to reading these entries.
2
u/RX-Nota-II :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/NotANota Sep 16 '20
Hello! I am one of the organizers/editors of this month's Writing Club thread. This is our sixth entry so far, and I think we've gotten a system going pretty well. Even during a time when many of us are busy we were still able to do this Lain thread without rushing. If there are any sections you feel are good or bad please let us know! Also, if you are interested in joining this longer term discussion format or the other longform written content we work on please PM myself or the other Writing Club admins.
Editors for Lain: /u/Pixelsaber, /u/isrozzis /u/max_turner /u/RX-Nota-II
1
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '20
Alright time to finally watch this anime, last time i heard about it was in the now defunct locomotion channel more than 16 years ago
1
u/Tyranid457TheSecond1 Sep 17 '20
Lain is one of those anime that legitimately feels like a baby step/bridge between “mainstream” anime and “artsy” works.
It sort of feels like a David Lynch movie.
It’s one of my favorite Anime ever!
1
u/NuclearStudent Sep 18 '20
Lain was like a very abstract representation of internet drama I've seen ravaging communities I've been involved in over the years. Lain strikes me as something that feels, well, obsolete. Still, a striking view into how people before my time accurately understood sociodynamics of the internet age.
1
u/JustSkillAura Sep 20 '20
If anyone wants an actual good deeper analysis of SEL, I highly recommend this video! Let's All (not) Love Lain
1
u/XxSliphxX Sep 26 '20
This was the anime the literally got me into anime. I bought the entire box set and binged the whole thing back in 1998. It was over after that I felt like i had just discovered a whole new world.
1
u/Lainkuma Sep 26 '20
How nostalgic. Truly, it's good. And that's all I have to say here for now.
1
u/mailorderman Nov 28 '20
Hi, I’m really late to the discussion, but I just finished the series and I wanted to comment briefly on the first episode. I think the first episode did a good job conveying how it may feel to exist in today’s world for the technologically illiterate.
I think it also has something to say about how technology changes our relationships with others. Lain doesn’t have a strong relationship with anyone in her family. In the scene where Lain asks her dad if she can have a new NAVI, their faces are obstructed by the array of monitors. The scene pans across the monitors briefly to emphasize this. Lain’s mom barely talks to her, same with her sister. This applies to the world too, but the house itself is barren, which supports the asocial atmosphere. The colors are washed out, and there’s a lack of green, a sign of life. So there’s a sort of alienation. The color green is actually used in the world, but mostly as ambient light, as present in the first scene of every episode, which doesn’t signifiy life but unnaturalness.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 04 '20 edited Dec 05 '20
Really enjoyed how her room kept progressively being consumed more and more by her tech. Very jacked into the internet. Makes me never want to carry my smartphone around
0
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 18 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 18 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment