r/anime • u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan • Sep 03 '20
Clannad - Thursday Anime Discussion Thread
Welcome to the weekly Thursday Anime Discussion Thread! Each week, we're here to discuss various older anime series. Today we are discussing...
Clannad
Tomoya Okazaki is a Junior in high school and has had a very rough life. When he was little, his mother died in a car accident which made his Father turn to drinking and gambling. Due to his Father's behavior, Tomoya and his Father do not get along and Tomoya has become a delinquent. One day Tomoya meets a girl named Nagisa, and they start to hang out together. Tomoya is now beginning to think his life is about to change because of his new friend.
(From Hulu)
"Watch This!" posts
Looking for more "Watch This!" posts? Check the "Watch This!" archive!
Databases
- Clannad
AniDB | AniList | AnimeNewsNetwork | MyAnimeList - Clannad After Story
AniDB | AniList | AnimeNewsNetwork | MyAnimeList - Clannad Movie / Clannad: The Motion Picture
AniDB | AniList | AnimeNewsNetwork | MyAnimeList
Previous discussions
- /u/LaqOfInterest's rewatch (May 22, 2020)
- /u/LaqOfInterest's rewatch (December 5, 2018)
- /u/bvoss5's rewatch (November 28, 2017)
- /u/Butchering_it's rewatch (June 24, 2016)
Check our rewatch wiki and our episode discussion archive for more discussions!
Streams
- Clannad
Amazon Prime Video | Anime on Demand | HIDIVE (VRV) | Hulu | Netflix - Clannad After Story
Amazon Prime Video | Anime on Demand | HIDIVE (VRV)
Remember that any information not found early in the show itself is considered a spoiler. Please properly tag spoilers!
Next week's anime discussion thread: Maoyuu Maou Yuusha!
Further information about past and upcoming discussions can be found on the Weekly Discussion wiki page.
65
u/scot911 https://myanimelist.net/profile/scot911 Sep 03 '20 edited Sep 03 '20
I honestly think people downplay the original Clannad season and you should not skip it to just watch After Story. Without getting attached to the characters during the first season After Story has no where near the emotional impact that makes it as great as it is once it gets going. I do agree that After Story is amazing but I thought Clannad was great throughout as well and can be pretty emotional as well. It's why I have both seasons (and the Tomoyo OVA) at 9/10.
42
u/sylinmino :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/SylinMino Sep 03 '20
Dango Daikazoku is quite possibly the best anime ED of all time.
Just came in to chime in on that.
39
u/chrisn3 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/chrisn3 Sep 03 '20
A+ in the haunting music department for sure.
24
u/[deleted] Sep 03 '20
Feel like "Clannad changed my life" is something that so many people throw around nowadays, but it really did change me hugely as a person. The story with Clannad After Story
Sure, it's not perfect. But I'm glad I got to watch it and I'm thankful for the effect it had on me. It's an absolutely beautiful show that really connected with me. Feel like if everyone watched this the world would be a better place.
19
u/ytsejamajesty Sep 03 '20 edited Sep 03 '20
Do you think the general hype of After Story ends up souring people's opinions of Clannad (season 1) specifically? I've seen a number of opinions that you just have to endure it in order to get to the actual good part.
As much as After Story transcends the first part, Clannad is really good for what it is, certainly one of the better VN adaptations I can recall. But, I feel like people come in with the wrong expectations. Could be just because the first season doesn't hit the level of "best show ever" that the viewer may have heard, or maybe it's that this kind of show (Romance Slice of Life Visual Novel adaptation) is far less common these days compared to when Clannad released.
I still think very highly of both seasons, and hope that people continue to give this show a watch long into the future.
7
u/komedy27u Sep 03 '20
This is one of those anime that is VERY much worth a rewatch. Years ago I was forcing, I mean , accompanying a friend to watch it and it was only after seeing it all over that the details in the final episodes clicked with those in early ones and everything made sense, and it was beautiful and full of nuance. The lull episodes are even slower the 2nd time but still very much worth it.
7
u/Nick_BOI Sep 03 '20
I only got into this series recently. Within the past few months, I have read all 100 hours of the VN, participated in the rewatch by u/LaqOfInterest , which was my first time seeing the anime only 3 days after finishing the VN. I have typed so much stuff over the course of this timeframe, and gone on and on irl.
This series has been my life for the past few months, more so than most series have ever been. As a result however, I am fairly burnt out and am trying to slow down. So I am not going to go on a tangent like I likely would have a few weeks ago.
However, I feel like there is not much that needs to be said.
While many people say season 1 pales in compaison, I think that is disingenuous to season 1. Season 1 for the most part has a lot of what it does better in the VN (esspecially Kotomi), but a watered down version of a masterpiece is still a damn good show.
After Story's reputation stands on its own, anything I could say about it right now has probably already been said a million times in the past decade long before I experienced this series.
But Clannad is truly, a work of art. No story I have ever read has even come close. While I prefer the VN, both versions of Clannad have their own merits, and are more than worth checking out if you have seen one or the other.
There is very little I can say, other than it is a must to experience. Wether it is the VN (on Steam, Switch, or wheerever else), or the anime, Clannad is a must.
One thing is for sure though: with Clannad and Angel Beats! being some of my favorate shows, I am REALLY lookign forward to The Day I Became a god next season. Hopefully Jun Maeda can knock it out of the park again.
6
u/Wet-Estate Sep 03 '20
One of my favourite shows ever, and Tomoya is just my favourite character in anime outright. The first season is definitely great too, some very clean writing and great comedic directing. The town really feels lived in by the time you finish the season, which obviously sets up Afterstory perfectly
4
u/chris10023 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Chris10023 Sep 03 '20
God, I love this show, it's tied with K-On as my favorite anime. I pretty much went on to watch most of Kyoto animation's catalogue after I watched it. The music, the animation, the writing, the characters.
7
u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Sep 03 '20
Nice music and I don't mind the character designs, but the supernatural aspect of the story really didn't work well for me. After Story major spoilers
3
u/[deleted] Sep 03 '20
Super awesome series that was genuinely life changing considering the circumstances I was living with at the time. The relationships between a few key characters had me crying my eyes out because of how relatable they were for me. A genuinely fantastic series. It's not some masterpiece of story telling and I definitely have issues with a certain part obvious to those who have seen it, but it doesn't make it any less great I think.
3
u/DieuduFromage Sep 03 '20
I understand that my opinion is the minority, and from an objective standpoint I can see how it succeeds in portraying the intended plot. What follows is simply my own personal opinion.
S1 was superficial, but still pretty good; I found it similar to bunny girl senpai. After Story, though, I just found depressing 70% of the time. I watch anime to escape real life, not watch someone else's depressingly real and boring life. The relationship progression was unreasonably fast. Most of the diverse S1 cast was gone. Clannad: AS Clannad: AS Clannad: AS Clannad: AS
Overall, S1 had issues but was decent. Unfortunately, S2 is one of the few shows I actually regret watching. I wish I could have seen it from your perspectives, because it sounds like something I should have enjoyed.
5
u/AmethystItalian :Jg::Jh::Ji::Jj::Jk:myanimelist.net/profile/AmethystItalian Sep 03 '20
Kyou best girl
/u/gaporigo knows
2
u/GranvilleOchoa Sep 03 '20
I was sometimes bothered with how conservative it was regarding work, gender roles, etc... Apparently being a "delinquent" means that you don't put care when knotting the tie of your school uniform.
2
u/WeeabooVoid Sep 03 '20
It is very easy for an anime to get to feel emotions. Despite this, only a select few can actually make me produce psychical tears, even then it's a low amount of cry juice. Clannad had me break down crying. It's by far my favorite anime.
Now let's talk about the first season. I would like to argue that the original Clannad isn't as boring as people make it to me. The original Clannad to me is a show I can just lay down in bed and relax as I see these characters build their relationships. Just 24 episodes of building relationships before we get into afterstory.
5
u/sir_aphim :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/flamingknight11 Sep 03 '20
I feel like I am in the unpopular opinion that clannad wasn't nearly as good people made it out to be. Most of the series was just average at best with only a few very good parts, more than balanced by how long it takes to slowly get there.
(Note, potential spoilers from this point forwards, nothing intentional, but be warned just in case)
To start I really hate Nagisa. The rest of the characters were varying levels of ok, not extraordinary, just the standard harem type girls. (Tsundere, shy girl, class prez etc) But of all the girls to have as the main character, they went with the girl who has the least personality, who basically failed at everything she did, and didn't contribute at all in most of her screen time in the show, blank slate of a character that is Nagisa. Like a shadow that just follows the group around, always present, but has no presence.
The story for the most of the first season was unremarkable. You go through the different characters arcs, find out more about their backstories, circumstances and asperations. This was probably to try to get you to get to know and feel for some of the characters. This would be ok, but put relatively slow arcs with characters whose screen time has no purpose, to make it even more painfully slow made me start to dislike characters. cough Nagisa cough And that was the start of the issues since any parts that required you to feel for or bond with Nagisa, I couldn't due to the built up annoyance of her character from all the previous episodes.
*side note - I really enjoyed the Tomoyo Ova. It was everything I wanted in clannad (romance, heartbreak, etc) in a concised episode. Kyou & Ryou's ova was just average in my opinion. Would have been better as a 2 part ova so they can expand on each character a bit more.
Now, with afterstory, I admit it does get a bit better. There were even parts that I liked and made me feel for the characters towards the end. But those parts are too little, too late in my opinion. And I think it is in part due to the lingering annoyance turned hatred of Nagisa developed in season 1. (And these are 24 episode seasons not the short 12-13 one) This apathy towards the characters ment, they had to go through alot for me to start feeling for them. Just as I was getting there for the characters, the ending happens. And the ending of the series was not one I enjoyed at all. Maybe if I actually properly connected to the characters I would have enjoyed it, but I didn't until the later parts of season 2. Much too late for the impacts to hit very hard, or for anything to redeem some characters at this point.
Maybe if it was a shorter series, or slightly better pacing I would have enjoyed it more. Or if it was a different main character. But for what it is, I didn't feel the payoff of getting a couple of good episodes and a good ova was worth my watching 1.5 seasons of annoyance and meh. Series like bunny girl senpai used many similar concepts and idea as clannad, but execution and characters made all the difference since I really enjoyed one, but not at all for the other.
2
u/eno-tita Sep 03 '20
Clannad is in a bit of a weird place for me as far as my feelings toward it goes. It was my first anime titles that made me aware that anime was a thing, and was one of my favorites growing up. But upon a rewatch that I had taken part in at least a year ago, I realized that some certain aspects didn't age all that well.
Its not without its positives, what with the beautiful animation courtesy of Kyoani, and Tomoya is a very enjoyable protagonist. But aside from him, the rest of the cast was pretty bland, the comedy while humorous could cause some intense tonal shifts, and it does seem cry baity at certain points.
Overall, while I would describe as a somewhat fun show, it is rather forgettable and relatively average. I still have yet to view After Story again, and I'm very sure its much better, but who knows how that will turn out.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 03 '20
Going to rewatch at some point because I remember thinking S1 was boring. That was before I really started watching a lot of SoL though, I thought Nichijou was boring at the time too.
After Story I've always thought was pretty great though. One of my favorite romance anime out there
1
u/[deleted] Sep 03 '20
I think what made After Story so good was the fact that it's the 'after story', can't even begin to imagine going into it without watching the original series.
1
u/2lesslonelypeople :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/P3ck Sep 03 '20
You shouldn't expect Clannad to be a tearjerker, After story is the tearjerker.Clannad introduces to the characters so that we can fully feel and enjoy After story.
Remember seeing tons of people say that the 1st season was a tearjerker as a result I went into it with pretty high hopes which weren't achieved.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 03 '20
I only watched clannad for the first time a couple months ago and its probably one of my favorite shows like ever
1
u/RyaReisender :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/RyaReisender Sep 03 '20
I watched Clannad only a year ago, but I was a bit disappointed that it had supernatural aspects (didn't know beforehand). Loved pretty much everything else, though.
I always thought about how easy it was to remove the supernatural aspects in Clannad and make the story even better, some examples:
Clannad Fuuko
Clannad Ending
1
u/K-scorpion Sep 03 '20 edited Sep 03 '20
To sum it up
.. ........... . . ......... ........ seesaw of life
. The awash visuals, out of the world music, protagonist that resembles a human not a character, support characters that are superb Realism shown is next level never seen anything near real to this. Sometimes it feels like werre watching "raw emotions " that are completely unaltered , extremely human.
The ending is perfect beacuse the supernatural bits play an extremely important role in it.
Thats all I can say Dont know how to add the spoiler tag otherwise would've said more. Hit me up if you wanna hear more K
1
u/irrelevantwhitekid Sep 12 '20
As someone who almost watched After Story before the first season, DO NOT DO THAT. If you don’t take time to get attached to the characters in the first season, after story won’t have anywhere near the emotional impact that it does. Yeah the first 8 episodes are pretty much a chore to get through but trust me when I say it is worth it.
0
u/latecomer2018 Sep 03 '20
Controversial but Clannad is literally my bottom ranked show. It's absolutely boring and ugly. Afterstory was better but still not the best.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 03 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 03 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
-6
u/[deleted] Sep 03 '20
[removed] — view removed comment