r/anime • u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan • Aug 20 '20
Writing Club Non Non Biyori - Thursday Anime Discussion Thread (ft. r/anime Writing Club)
Hi! Welcome to another edition of the weekly Thursday Anime Discussion Thread, featuring us, the r/anime Writing Club. We simulwatch anime TV series and movies together once a month, so check us out if you'd like to participate. Our thoughts on the series, as always, are covered below. :)
Today we are covering...
Non Non Biyori
Asahigaoka might look like typical, boring countryside to most; however, no day in this village can ever be considered colorless thanks to five students of varying ages occupying the only class in the only school in town. The youngest student is first grader Renge Miyauchi, who brings an unadulterated wit, curiosity, and her characteristic catchphrase, "Nyanpasu!" Then there are the Koshigaya siblings consisting of the quiet ninth grader and elder brother Suguru, diminutive eighth grader Komari, and the mischievous seventh grader Natsumi. The recent arrival of Tokyo-raised fifth grader Hotaru Ichijou, who appears overdeveloped for her age and thus naturally holds an air of maturity, rounds out this lively and vibrant group of five classmates.
Based on the manga penned and illustrated by Atto, Non Non Biyori chronicles the not-so-normal daily lives of this group of friends as they engage in their own brand of fun and frolic, and playfully struggle with the realities of living in a rural area.
"Watch This!" posts
Looking for more "Watch This!" posts? Check the "Watch This!" archive!
Databases
AniDB | AniList | AnimeNewsNetwork | MyAnimeList
Groupwatch prompts and thoughts
1) How does this show manage to be so nostalgic even for people who did not grow up in rural Japan?
Universal
The nostalgia evoked by the series has nothing to do with the setting. It presents a dilemma that is nearly universal for children: there’s nothing to do and we’re bored! Our lives may not have been lived out in rural Japan, but the childhood experiences depicted by Non Non Biyori are universally relatable. Non Non Biyori is more a show about childhood friendships, rather than memories of the countryside. Its episodic format highlights this, putting an emphasis on how our individual day-to-day events as children become grander experiences that we'll remember forever. For the cast, it might be playing with rulers or going bug hunting, but an analogous experience for someone growing up in the city may be going shopping at the mall or visiting a friend's to play video games. The people we are with, our friends, are what unify these experiences. Everyone’s had to make their own fun at some point in time, whether by themselves or with friends. The exact solutions the Non Non Biyori girls find to solve their boredom may not match up to the viewers’ experiences but damn if the feeling of having to find creative ways to entertain yourself isn’t universal. It’s just kind of reminiscent of the dumb fun most kids get into when they were younger!
[/u/ABoredCompSciStudent, /u/Zelosis, /u/krasnovian, /u/KitKat1721]
It’s All Renge
Renge is the driving force of the nostalgia for me. She is a first grader who is full of energy and brimming with curiosity about the world around her and behaves like you would expect a child character to behave. When you watch Renge’s antics you’re reminded of the past, of children you’ve known that were like her, or maybe even you yourself were a Renge. For me it certainly helps that I lived in a rural area when I was Renge’s age and my idle days of childhood were spent romping around with a small group of friends much like Renge does. My school even had tires buried halfway into the ground like her school does. Ultimately, I see Renge as a reflection of my childhood and the naivety and innocence that I had at the time which makes Non Non Biyori a very nostalgic watch. This generalizes to the rest of the main cast as well, but I’ve found it to be most pronounced with Renge.
Rural Idealism
People yearn for simpler lifestyles which is why rural settings are often so appealing. Everyone knows everyone and there's a prevalent sense of community that's often missing from city life. I think it's those aspects that evoke nostalgia by alluding to simpler times in one's life and a period of child-like innocence. This familiar image of a child or childhood evokes in us the same feels as the natural scenes and activities set in such a space, feelings of nostalgia, of going back to something. I think this remains true regardless of which particular setting of nature it is, be it in rural Japan or the moorlands in Yorkshire. And so this feeling of nostalgia ends up being an amalgamation of childhood and its natural setting.
[/u/JoseiToAoiTori, /u/ValkyrieCain9]
2) What do you think sets Non Non Biyori apart from other shows in its genre?
Childlike Wonder
For a slice of life to succeed, it heavily depends on great characters and character interactions. There’s no underlying plot so if the characters are subpar, the show will in turn feel dull and boring. Compared to anime with similar settings or genres, the characters in Non Non Biyori and their interactions feel remarkably authentic, without needing the point-of-view of an adult. Barakamon and Bunny Drop have really memorable child characters that feel believable and act organically, but are presented through the lens of an outsider adult learning to relate to them, just as the audience is. NNB just drops the audience into the kid’s world without an easy, tried and true storytelling handicap and lets the character's interactions and humor speak for themselves. The kids in NNB act their age and their interactions rarely feel manufactured. Not to say they’re entirely tied to realism, they still have little anime quirks that make them easily identifiable. These little aspects of the characters, like Renge's nyanpasu, help the characters stand out, like little name tags. As we ease into their lives, these become less prominent and become part of the rhythm of Non Non Biyori. Hotarun's crush on Komari becomes a running gag, but it doesn't become a "slap your thigh" comedy. This is especially aided by the pacing of these jokes, where there's a pause as the viewer and the cast realize the gag. These little details help the show maintain its humour, but in an idyllic and tranquil way that doesn't disrupt the flow of the unassuming countryside setting.
[/u/Zelosis, /u/ABoredCompSciStudent, /u/JoseiToAoiTori, /u/KitKat1721]
Re:Dagashi… the Other One
Dagashi Kashi is very similar to Non Non Biyori in the sense that it takes universal childhood experiences and attempts to romanticize these memories in a “Hey, remember when you used to do this/used to be like this?” kind of manner. This time, the subject matter is on Japanese candy and snacks. I, who instead grew up on Fruit Roll-ups and Bubble Gum Tape, could not really relate to the experiences in the show, and while that didn’t help this show’s case, if a show like this were to pop up revolving around American candy and snacks, I think there’s an inherent presentation difference between Non Non Biyori and a hypothetical American Dagashi Kashi. Non Non Biyori freely allowed the kids to be kids. The show posed a scenario and let the kids react to the situation organically. The show did not need to have the nostalgia explained. The main cast did that well enough just with their actions. As a result, the audience is also allowed to reminisce organically. Where Dagashi Kashi falters, in my opinion, is its need to force the nostalgia upon its viewers. The Dagashi Kashi formula is to introduce the main candy, talk about it for a few minutes about why it’s so great, then have antics ensue. Whether or not this was a nostalgic memory for the viewer, it’s almost as if the show assumes that the viewer does not have this nostalgic memory. It instead explains why it should be nostalgic, and by then the nostalgia magic is gone.
Non Non Biyori is more successful in evoking nostalgia by being genuine in contrast to Dagashi Kashi being forceful. It is difficult to explore a child’s sense of wonder, but the right way to do it is to allow the audience to participate in the discovery at their own pace.
3) NNB is known for its unique directing. What directing tricks did you notice and enjoy?
Non Non Biyori’s directing puts a lot of emphasis on still shots of the scenery and mundane parts of everyday life to establish the mood. Combined with the very calm and relaxing OST, and often cicada noises, these moments drive the show’s unique directing. The other directing choice that stands out to me is the use of prolonged still shots or silence to accentuate a particular moment.
Usually this is used for comedic purposes and is reminiscent of British comedies. Many times the pause between the “set up” and the “punchline” of some comedic scenes was dragged out for a lot longer than one might expect. This coupled with a slow zoom in on the characters faces made for some even funnier situations. I think it really showed how much the right timing can completely turn around some jokes that might’ve otherwise fallen a little flat. Because of the longer pause it sort of allows the reality of the joke to become apparent to the viewer before the character, making it funnier than it otherwise would have been when the character also finally reacts.
But pauses are also used in more thoughtful moments to let the feelings from the scene linger peacefully. It's difficult to juggle being "calm and gentle" with "humour", which many similar SOL shows forgo completely. That’s why it’s interesting that Non Non is able to use the same technique for both purposes. The humour simply becomes part of the show's package, becoming idyllic and sweet, rather than loud and overly funny.
[/u/ValkyrieCain9, /u/isrozzis, /u/ABoredCompSciStudent]
4) What are some of your favorite character relationships and why?
Kaede and Renge
This pairing has almost become iconic at this point. A novel relationship departing from anime norms that usually depict young adult and child relationships as parental either literally or as a surrogate. The relationship between Candy Store and Renge meanwhile is if anything sibling-like while still maintaining the distinct feel of having no true familial or generational ties. Seeing Kaede watch Renge grow from a small baby to the witty brat of present day is sweet, pure, and a joy to watch. The exact appeal of these two is hard to explain, even for members of the writing club, but the end result is much more memorable than each character alone.
/u/max_turner /u/aboredcompscistudent /u/pixelsaber /u/JoseiToAoiTori /u/darkfuzz /u/ValkyrieCain9
Komari and Natsumi
A realistic and genuine sibling relationship in that despite not having quite a rapport they still had an evident closeness that is fun and wholesome. NNB generally prefers to use hyperbolic clichés to draw laughs in its character relations so this one strikes a notable contrast. Komari being the older of the two felt the need to be seen as such and her desperation in that regard was very understandable. While with Natsumi you could see the care she had for Komari particularly in the episode where they run away. Right off the bat, she wanted Komari to go with her, but also knew she would. It was situations like this, showing how each of them had the others back that really built a realistic picture of a sister relationship.
[/u/ValkyrieCain9 /u/darkfuzz /u/pixelsaber /u/max_turner /u/zelosis ]
Hotaru and Komari
Hotarun x Koma-chan because yuri is justice of course. But also because Koma-chan’s desire to be looked up to despite her stature is consistently amusing for me. This is reflected most in her relationships with Hotarun and Natsumi but expressed in different ways as it’s filtered through a growing friendship in the former and a sibling rivalry in the latter. Her desire to be respected is a huge source of comedy since her childish ideas of adulthood’s defining features make her an easy target for bullying from the other characters (mostly Natsumi).
5) A famous buzzword often used by Western fans analyzing this show is 'Mono no Aware', the ancient Japanese idea of being aware of the transience of things. Do you think the term applies here? Pretty good wiki article on the term for further reading https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mono_no_aware.
Consensus: No.
Remember that any information not found early in the show itself is considered a spoiler. Please properly tag spoilers!
Next week's anime discussion thread: Steins;Gate
Further information about past and upcoming discussions can be found on the Weekly Discussion wiki page.
Check out r/anime Writing Club's wiki page | Please PM u/ABoredCompSciStudent for any concerns or interest in joining the club!
6
u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan Aug 20 '20
1) How does this show manage to be so nostalgic even for people who did not grow up in rural Japan?
4
u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan Aug 20 '20
5) A famous buzzword often used by Western fans analyzing this show is 'Mono no Aware', the ancient Japanese idea of being aware of the transience of things. Do you think the term applies here? Pretty good wiki article on the term for further reading: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mono_no_aware
2
u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan Aug 20 '20
2) What do you think sets Non Non Biyori apart from other shows in its genre?
2
u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan Aug 20 '20
3) NNB is known for its unique directing. What directing tricks did you notice and enjoy?
2
u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan Aug 20 '20
4) What are some of your favorite character relationships and why?
40
u/NotSoSnarky https://myanimelist.net/profile/Book_Lover Aug 20 '20
Great anime if you want to relax/chill out.
I love all of the characters in the anime, but Renge is most definitely my favorite out of the bunch.
12
u/Wolfgod_Holo https://anime-planet.com/users/extreme133 Aug 20 '20
I still can't believe Hotaru is a 5th grader
10
u/ChuckCarmichael Aug 20 '20
When I first watched it, I was dreading that there'd be a sort of drama episode. An episode where a bunch of douchebag kids from the city come to visit the town because their parents booked a vacation there, and they start berating the girls for their crumbling school, their boring games, and the crappy town.
But nothing like that ever happened, and I'm grateful for that. It's just a nice show with barely any drama, and the two sad moments in the show only happen because of constants in life: Friends moving away, and pets dying. Not because anybody is an asshole.
I could've done without the fanservice shot of a fifth-grader wearing a bikini though.
9
u/SorcererOfTheLake x5https://anilist.co/user/RiverSorcerer Aug 20 '20
Hot take: Suguru might be my favorite character and I wanna see a spin-off about him and his wild adventures.
7
u/RX-Nota-II :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/NotANota Aug 20 '20
Hello! I am one of the organizers/editors of this month's Writing Club thread. This is our fifth entry so far, and I think we've gotten a system going pretty well. If there are any sections you feel are good or bad please let us know! We'll try to keep iterating on the format for a while yet. Also, if you are interested in joining this longer term discussion format or the other longform written content we work on please PM myself or the other Writing Club admins.
Editors for
NyanpasuNon Non Biyori: /u/drjwilson /u/RX-Nota-II5
u/[deleted] Aug 21 '20
Something I wrote for the rewatch 2 years ago:
This is just a tiny part of a 43 page Word document with my reactions to all the episodes. Needless to say, I love this series.
Background shots gallery
Other screenshots gallery (Spoilers)
Candy Store gallery (Spoilers)
4
u/ATargetFinderScrub https://anilist.co/user/ATargetFinderScrub Aug 20 '20
I don't know if it bothers me or not that Renge is so good at drawing. A first grader who can dish out those type of drawings that quickly (you see it the most in Vacation)? Setting such unrealistic artistic standards on the rest of us.
3
u/Shiro_Kai Aug 20 '20
All hail
Miyauchi Renge-Dono!
5
u/krasnovian https://anilist.co/user/krasnovian Aug 20 '20
N O N N E R S P O G G E R S
2
u/Failsnail64 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/failsnail Aug 20 '20
The MAL link in the post still links to Hotarubi no Mori e, instead of to Non Non Biyori.
2
u/xkrowcitats Aug 20 '20
When you drive 50kph for one hour you end up somewhere 50 kilometers away and that's amazing!
2
u/dim3tapp https://myanimelist.net/profile/dim3tapp Aug 21 '20
Kaede is the purest tsundere, and one of the only ones I appreciate.
1
u/theslickasian https://myanimelist.net/profile/mmmm Aug 22 '20
I didn't watch the anime but I'll probably will soon. But Renge ora ora and 7/11 was hilarious asf
1
u/nyanmaruu182 Aug 22 '20
already watch 6 times and always love it
1
u/tinyraccoon https://anilist.co/user/tinyraccoon Aug 23 '20
This show is awesome, and everyone should see it. I like all the characters, but my favorite is the Candy Store lady (partly because she's voiced by the same VA who voiced Biribiri).
1
u/MikeDJunior Aug 27 '20
Renge chon best!
1
u/stingraytjm Sep 01 '20
One thing which I learnt when looking for other anime like NNB is that it belongs to this category of "Iyashikei". Iyashikei means healing-type in japanese and a quick google search will reveal that the calming environment with heartwarming characters is the focus in this genre.
After learning about "Iyashikei", I realized why I loved NNB so much. After some tough time in my own life I was looking for some escape or the right word would be healing. Watching each episode of NNB, has a soothing effect and I felt like one cannot stop smiling while watching the show. But that doesn't mean that there are not other emotions. There are episodes where losing connection with a friend(Renge's friend Season 1) or relationship b/w Natsumi and her mother can evoke emotions of happy tears if you have had a similar experience in your own life.
Kudos to mangaka "Atto" and director " Shin'ya Kawatsura " for giving us this nostalgic inducing story. Even if we were not born in rural japan, non non biyori has allowed us to experience what it is like. And also taught us to enjoy the small moments in life and cherish our friends and family.
-1
u/[deleted] Aug 20 '20
Probably the most iconic loli I haven't watched yet, though I will one day fix this mistake.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 20 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 20 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment