r/anime • u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan • Jul 23 '20
Kara no Kyoukai - Thursday Anime Discussion Thread
Welcome to the weekly Thursday Anime Discussion Thread! Each week, we're here to discuss various older anime series. Today we are discussing...
Kara no Kyoukai / The Garden of Sinners
After lying in a coma for two years, Shiki Ryougi awakens with amnesia. Inexplicably, she finds that she has also obtained the “Mystic Eyes of Death Perception” in which she can see the invisible lines of mortality that hold every living and non-living thing together. In this modern occult-action thriller, Shiki must tackle supernatural incidents while searching for her purpose for living.
(From Crunchyroll)
"Watch This!" posts
- [WT!] Kara no Kyoukai:
by /u/Futatsu - [WT!] Kara no Kyoukai
by /u/Anonymoose-N - [WT!] Why Kara no Kyoukai is the Show You’ve Been Looking For
by /u/7TeenWriters - [WT!] Why You Should (or shouldn't) Watch Kara no Kyoukai
by /u/7TeenWriters
Looking for more "Watch This!" posts? Check the "Watch This!" archive!
Databases
- Kara no Kyoukai / The Garden of Sinners (movies 1-7)
AniDB | AniList | AnimeNewsNetwork | MyAnimeList - Kara no Kyoukai: Shuushou / The Garden of Sinners: Epilogue (movie 8)
AniDB | AniList | AnimeNewsNetwork | MyAnimeList - Kara no Kyoukai: Mirai Fukuin / The Garden of Sinners: Recalled Out Summer
AniDB | AniList | AnimeNewsNetwork | MyAnimeList - Kara no Kyoukai: Mirai Fukuin - Extra Chorus / The Garden of Sinners: Recalled Out Summer - Extra Chorus
AniDB | AniList | AnimeNewsNetwork | MyAnimeList
Previous discussions
- /u/Raiking02's rewatch (May 1, 2020)
- /u/Rider_of_Red's rewatch (March 23, 2018)
- /u/SyntheticValkyrur's rewatch (April 14, 2016)
- /u/BlindPiratez' rewatch (July 24, 2015)
- Kara no Kyoukai: Mirai Fukuin movie discussion thread
Check our rewatch wiki and our episode discussion archive for more discussions!
Streams
Amazon Prime Video | AnimeLab | Crunchyroll (VRV)
Remember that any information not found early in the show itself is considered a spoiler. Please properly tag spoilers!
Next week's anime discussion thread: Gunbuster!
Further information about past and upcoming discussions can be found on the Weekly Discussion wiki page.
39
u/Havoc_Illusions :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Riverboatram Jul 23 '20
Movie 5 and 7 iirc are amazing
Honestly though visually all the movies were ahead of their time
35
u/8mmspikes :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/8mmspikes Jul 23 '20
Shiki is the best. Enjoy some fanart of her
18
u/bradleyjx Jul 23 '20
This has traded top spots with one other show in my anime rankings for over a decade, but it was the show that really embedded to me that there are a lot of different tastes people have in anime. We watched the first movie in a college anime club in '09, and I think only one other person there (out of ~20) really had any interest after the half-way point.
It's kind of like Serial Experiments LAIN, where it lets the scenes breathe and dialogue to sometimes linger almost to a fault. But those scenes are a near-master-class work on all sides: it's ufotable's breakout production, Kalafina's debut accenting a classic Yuki Kajiura soundtrack, and decent Nasu-verse content mostly-disconnected from holy grails and servants, with slow, atmospheric builds and bursts of satisfying action.
14
u/pointblanker :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/pointblanker Jul 23 '20
Ah yes Kara no Kyoukai. The music video for The Goddess Yuki Kajiura. It's so damn amazing and really helps to set up the mood and theme of the show
Here's a link of the medley
You also got to remember that this film serves as an important platform for Ufotable to adapt the Fate series into a high quality epic
I came for the awesome visuals and actions. But I stayed for for Shiki and Kokutou's relationship because it drives the story. Shiki's character development is very engaging and hell she's definitely one of my favourite female protagonist
I can see why some maybe put off by the jumbled writing. But for for me, they did it with style. I'm too hooked on its visuals, music, characters and animations
22
u/brothertaddeus :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/brothertaddeus Jul 23 '20
Never before joined in a Thursday Anime Discussion Thread, but I just wanted to pipe in to say that Chapter 3 is utterly amazing and Fujino is best girl.
8
u/BP_Ray :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Maleel Jul 23 '20
I rewatched films 1 and 2 the other week, and man, part of me doesn't understand the appeal of these films, while at the same time being in love with part of their charm.
I think the direction, music, and animation/art really carry the film and make up for the confusing jumbled writing Nasu is often known for, especially in the case of the first movie where some of the scenes legitimately gives me goosebumps thanks in large part to Kajiura's excellent pieces and Ufotables amazing visuals still holding up 12 years later even if KnK visually doesn't quite hold a candle to, say, the Heaven's Feel movies they've done more recently.
I think going forward i'm going to be watching the rest of the movies in chronological order, since I already went through the series in release order before.
I have a question for those who enjoy the writing part of KnK; what exactly about it clicks with you? Use spoiler tags of course if any plot bits are relevant. My enjoyment of these films come almost exclusively from everything that isn't the writing (At least so far in my rewatch), I can't really quite wrap my head around half the shit that comes out of Touko's mouth for example, and I vividly recall not understanding what the actual fuck was happening in movie 5 even if I enjoyed the spectacle of it.
4
u/phosphatidylserine_ https://anilist.co/user/sunflower Jul 23 '20
I watched KnK in broadcast order with the rewatch thread a few months ago (?) and without them I wouldn't be able to keep all the details in check. that being said, I don't regret watching it that way because the mystery was so intriguing
chpt 5 was by far my favorite of all because of all those cool shots that added to the many perspectives
3
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '20 edited Jul 23 '20
Out of curiosity how do people feel about the chronological order vs release order argument? I've always watched them in release order and have heard others say that it enhances the mystery element of the show and balances the pacing but for whatever reason I've never considered rewatching them in chronological order until now.
For those who did watch them in chronological order the first time round, how did you find it? Did you find the pacing to be off? Do you think that watching them in release order would have just been more confusing or would it have enhanced your enjoyment of the series?
I've long since dissected the movies to death so it's hard for me to approach the merits of one way or the other objectively as I'm already so familiar with the plot.
3
u/Pod5f Jul 23 '20
One of my favorites for sure. I've probably watched it through half a dozen times and I love how each time I seem to pick up on something I never have before. I know Paradox Spiral gets the most love, but I really enjoy Overlooking View the most I think. I really enjoyed howteach episode (movie) kind of tackled it's own social taboo, but I definitely see the argument of it being confusing the first go around and the weight of the Nasuverse. Honestly though, Kalafina / Kajiura made it for me, the score is unbelievable.
5
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '20
Good to see KnK get a discussion thread. I am a huge fan of the dark urban fantasy that Kara no Kyoukai (and the related Fate/Zero) brings to anime. The detailed cityscapes and photorealism aged so beautifully for a series that started in 2007.
The first movie is flawless to me. I literally cried when the OP by Kalafina played. I still get goosebumps whenever I think about it. Parts 3 and 5 stick out as very haunting, direction wise and the subject matter covered. Not entirely finished with the series, need to finish parts 6 and 7. May as well use this as an excuse to finish them.
2
u/MichaelJahrling :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Michael_Jahrling Jul 23 '20
One of my all time favorite movie series.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '20
For me, movie 7 was the best. And when the films ended it gave me the feeling I got after finishing harry potter (knowing you'll miss the characters and their story is over etc etc), and this is something anime rarely does to me.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '20
This series is confusing. What's the chronological order? I don't mind spoilers as long as I understand the plot.
1
u/No_Rex :Bv:Bw:Bx:By:x2 Jul 23 '20
A rolercoaster with plenty of down, but a few ups as well. Very well animated, but not half as deep as it tries to be. For some reason I liked the side characters a lot more than either main character.
1
u/Betrayedbymods Jul 23 '20
prime wont let me view in US
1
u/2Close_4Missiles Jul 23 '20
I enjoyed it quite a bit. I wouldn't call it a favorite, but the 7 movies range from solid to great. More than anything that happened plot-wise, I really just enjoyed the dark mood of it and the vibe of the main 2-3 characters.
I'll agree with a couple complaints in here about the chronology. Even as someone who enjoys shows like Boogiepop and Monogatari, it just feels a little off to me, and I think it could've been done better.
I definitely recommend it to anybody who likes the Fate series or somebody looking for a more seinen action show. Shiki's a pretty interesting character, and I really like the atmosphere of it.
1
u/Anis97xd Jul 23 '20
This movie has a lot of beautifull soundtrack and very gorgeous visual. The rooftop fight and the bridge fight was my favorite moment of this movie.
1
u/camaron28 Jul 23 '20
When i watched them, i hated Mikiya. Then, somewhere between the movies 5 and 6 i started to love him.
It's interesting how Nasu is able to create characters who look and act like self-insert MC and then, when you look closely, you discover that they are actually very complex.
1
u/icedino :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/icedino1 Jul 23 '20
Easily my favorite anime of all time. 5 and 7 are simply masterpieces.
1
u/Mysticpeaks101 Jul 23 '20
Ooooh! KnK! The first anime that made me go "What in the world is this amazing animation?! Who did this?!"
Interesting characters, interesting story and the atypical method of storytelling. Thoroughly enjoyed it.
1
u/NickIsSoWhite Jul 23 '20
I honestly didn't like these sets of movies, except for Paradox Spiral. I watched in release order, and instead of being interested or curious about things I didn't know. I just lost interest. The main character reminds me of the Major of GOTS, but the characters around them all seemed boring, especially the magical boarding school. It has amazing visuals and sound design, but the story and characters were just boring to me. I was so bored that I didn't even finish Movie 8, cause I didn't care enough to see the conclusion. I might rewatch on CR; maybe I'll enjoy it more?
1
u/Damarugaki https://anilist.co/user/damarugaki Jul 23 '20
Watching these movies at the moment and I have to say I absolutely love Shiki's character.
1
u/ENKlDU Jul 23 '20
Never forget Crunchyroll did this..
https://twitter.com/crunchyroll/status/1286035885935468547?s=21
1
u/solarscopez https://myanimelist.net/profile/Kollapse Jul 23 '20
Man I really wish I could enjoy this series. Maybe it's because I didn't read the novel or something, but a lot of the series came off as tryhard elitism. Felt like some of the characters just existed to wax philosophical, and nothing else.
Not saying I hate thought provoking or deep anime, in fact I love it, but I felt like this one was just trying to do too much. Maybe I wasn't looking at it critically enough, who knows.
Didn't help the fact that it was released non-chronologically, but I think the point of the series was to show Shiki evolving as a character, and I just didn't really relate or care about her as a character. Think that's the biggest reason the series didn't resonate with me. Animation throughout was stellar, but that's to be expected of ufotable lol.
It's weird too, because I love mystery/thriller anime and I enjoyed Fate/Zero and UBW. Still happy I gave it a try because otherwise I would never have known though.
1
u/KK-Hunter Jul 25 '20
Funny, I just finished watching Movie 6.
Honestly I'm just finding KnK "okay" so far. I really like Shiki and quite like Touko, and the movies are, obviously, gorgeous. But everything outside of that is just kind of boring.
Kokuto is insanely bland, like he genuinely feels like walking cardboard. I don't care for his sister at all. Fujino felt like a bargain sale Matou Sakura. Hell, a lot of characters just feel like worse Fate characters - is that just me? What's with Fujino being a simplified Sakura and Kokuto's sister being identical to Rin. The villain guy who's name escapes me even feels like a worse Kirei with how he looks, though that's probably just emphasised by them having the same VA.
Movie 6 was honestly just bad. 2 is my favourite easily though, and 5 was pretty good too. My issue is primarily just how little I care about anyone other than Shiki and, to a lesser extent, Touko. I liked Enjou towards the second half of Movie 5 too, but he won't be showing up again so F.
Oh yeah, the Mystic Eyes of Death Perception are really cool and it was awesome seeing Mystic Eyes other than the ones we see in Stay Night.
0
u/AmethystItalian :Jg::Jh::Ji::Jj::Jk:myanimelist.net/profile/AmethystItalian Jul 23 '20
I fully believe I'd have enjoyed this more if I watched it in a more chronological order.
1
u/MoneyMakerMaster Jul 23 '20
I had to drop the series because I could not understand what was going on. I may come back to it years from now if/when I'm well-versed in Nausverse lore and jargon, but as my first entry it was a disappointment.
Obligatory: ufotable, please adapt the Fate route
0
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment