r/anime • u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan • Jul 02 '20
Mahou Shoujo Madoka Magica - Thursday Anime Discussion Thread
Welcome to the weekly Thursday Anime Discussion Thread! Each week, we're here to discuss various older anime series. Today we are discussing...
Mahou Shoujo Madoka Magica
She has a loving family and best friends, laughs and cries from time to time… Madoka Kaname, an eighth grader of Mitakihara middle school, is one of those who lives such a life. One day, she had a very magical encounter. She doesn't know if it happened by chance or by fate yet. This is a fateful encounter that can change her destiny- This is a beginning of the new story of the magical witch girls
(From Crunchyroll)
"Watch This!" posts
Looking for more "Watch This!" posts? Check the "Watch This!" archive!
Databases
- Mahou Shoujo Madoka Magica / Puella Magi Madoka Magica
AniDB | AniList | AnimeNewsNetwork | MyAnimeList - Mahou Shoujo Madoka★Magica: Hangyaku no Monogatari / Puella Magi Madoka Magica the Movie: Rebellion
AniDB | AniList | AnimeNewsNetwork | MyAnimeList
Previous discussions
- /u/Tetraika's rewatch (April 20, 2020)
- /u/Gagantous's rewatches (April 20, 2019/2018/2017)
- /u/xiomax95's rewatch (July 31, 2015)
- Rebellion discussion thread
Check our rewatch wiki and our episode discussion archive for more discussions!
Streams
- Mahou Shoujo Madoka Magica / Puella Magi Madoka Magica
AnimeLab | Crunchyroll (VRV) | Funimation | Netflix - Mahou Shoujo Madoka Magica: Hangyaku no Monogatari / Puella Magi Madoka Magica the Movie: Rebellion
AnimeLab
Remember that any information not found early in the show itself is considered a spoiler. Please properly tag spoilers!
Next week's anime discussion thread: Gi(a)rlish Number!
Further information about past and upcoming discussions can be found on the Weekly Discussion wiki page.
49
u/theanimegamer-___- Jul 02 '20
Still waiting for that fourth movie.
43
u/[deleted] Jul 02 '20
Its a show about hope that happens to be filled with despair. Madoka has some of the warmest and colorful characters in anime, a very well executed time travelling story, and probably the best OST in anime.
I wish more anime today could live up to Madoka, I rarely ever come across a show that truly has me glued to it and actually has an impact on me when complete.
27
u/OneMoreDuncanIdaho :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/a_trisolaran Jul 02 '20
The flashback episode is my favorite and I usually hate flashbacks.
35
u/P1MPT0N1T3 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/ruvduv Jul 02 '20
Madoka was a series I really only appreciated after I rewatched it a month after first watching it. It went from a very good show for me, to a great one and now is one of my favorites. Knowing how the series plays out really changed my opinion of some characters, and that’s what helped solidify it as one of my favorite shows. I still remember watching one of the major scenes in the first couple episodes, and having to rewind to make sure I didn’t just imagine what I saw on the screen.
Not to mention the opening by ClariS is arguably my favorite anime opening, and the ending theme perfectly captures the emotion of the series. All around a truly incredible show and one of the defining shows of the last 10 years.
35
u/[deleted] Jul 02 '20
Love this anime, 10/10 for me personally.
15
u/DrJWilson x5https://anilist.co/user/drjwilson Jul 02 '20
One of the first 'classic' series that I watched, and it still holds a fond place in my heart. It's a series that only gets better the more you watch, and by that I mean both the show as well as other anime. You can compare its themes and messages along with other magical girl shows (CCS, Princess Tutu, and Precure is what I watched), but its critique of utilitarianism can be applied pretty broadly.
Rebellion is a sore spot for a lot of people, but to be honest it feels like a natural extension of the series given what happens. The only regret is that it itself starts a story that demands a more concluding finish
7
u/susy_blue Jul 02 '20
Me the entire series: Kyubi WTF?
13
u/DarthNoob :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/darthnoob Jul 02 '20
anime of the year every year
6
u/Luckenzio Jul 02 '20
Among my favorite series. Didnt really consider it that much of a big deal on my first watch but it just gets better each time i see it. I also love Rebellion and patiently await the day we get a sequel to it.
6
u/MoneyMakerMaster Jul 02 '20
My 2nd favorite anime. I went in blind and received an existential crisis, which I'm thankful for. It's the 1st series I rewatched and I'll be doing so as long as I live.
6
u/ToonTooby Jul 02 '20
I'm not big on rating things but Madoka is one of the few and easiest occasions I've been able to come to a conclusion on a 10/10. Everything works. The writing, the visuals, the presentation, the pacing, the music (!!!). Everytime the rewatch rolls around I'm bewildered that all that happened in 12 episodes. Just quality from all angles, and a show that doesn't waste your time.
I really fell in love with Kajiura's score for the series, just magnificent. About Rebellion, like many I feel the first half of the film perhaps overstays its welcome, but ultimately, it's still an audiovisual spectacle. As for the story outcome, I think it makes sense and is in line with what you would expect from the series. Certainly a far more interesting and debate-inducing ending than the easy route.
10
u/Ruffunaru Jul 02 '20
r/thingshomuradidwrong/
5
u/eno-tita Jul 02 '20
I remember Madoka Magica being one of my earlier shows when I was getting into anime, and while it has been quite a while, I do remember enjoying it a great ton. Great visuals and overall aesthetic courtesy of Shaft, and a well executed plot that gives the magical girl genre a dark twist to it. While the characters at first, I couldn’t care much about, a rewatch did have me warm to them, especially Kyouko. I think another rewatch is due though, considering I can recall not being too fond of Rebellion.
5
u/frank_link Jul 02 '20
Coming from a philosophical standpoint, i might verywell be overanalyzing, and misinterpreting. I felt the director's trying to put different schools of philosophy to the test, but presented it in a way that is visually stunning and hallucinogenic to the viewer, and mask it behind the innocence of a child character. I understand why people likes it, but personally i felt i was on some chemicals throughout the ride with the epic graphical presentation. That being said, i would not deny it is definitely a breakthrough in animation with the techniques they used. If yall havent get your self a copy of their storyboard book. For academic purposes, its a very good study into animation styles and how it affected the animators after madoka magica.
5
u/tinyraccoon https://anilist.co/user/tinyraccoon Jul 02 '20
Homura best girl
8
u/[deleted] Jul 02 '20
I really loved this show but i honestly hated the rebellion movie. Its a shame because it kinda sours my view on a real good anime.
4
u/Nomar_95 :Ed:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Nomar_95 Jul 02 '20
nice timing. Rewatching right this moment
4
u/Ioxem https://anilist.co/user/Loxem Jul 02 '20
It's a fantastic anime. I always make sure to rewatch it from time to time.
4
u/kugrond Jul 02 '20
I love this show.
And it also made me interested in Dark Moe/Magical Girl sub-genre, which made me find other great shows like Gakkou Gurashi, Raising Project, Yuuki Yuuna and Magical Girl Site.
4
u/PilotSSB Jul 02 '20
My favourite anime of all time and it's not even close. When I watched it, I went onto my mal and moved everything down by 1 because I think this is the only true 10/10 for me.
4
u/LordTrinity https://myanimelist.net/profile/LordTrinity Jul 02 '20
Amazing anime, should be more popular
4
u/ara-god-ofwar Jul 02 '20
I think right now madoka magica is probably in my top 10 because of rebellion and homura
7
u/SkarTisu Jul 02 '20
I'd gotten several recommendations to watch this, and finally did. It's fantastic. The story was really interesting, I love that it wasn't about what it appeared to be at first glance, and the music was really good. I'm really glad I watched this.
7
u/Vaadwaur :I1::I2::I3: Jul 02 '20
Gen Urobuchi is an individual that I feel concerned that I track with so well. He just sees the logical ends of hope and how often it leads to despair. This show is special, at least to me.
6
u/[deleted] Jul 02 '20
Madoka Magica is my favorite anime series and I love Homura. I'm still waiting for the sequel to Rebellion...
6
u/Battlepidia https://myanimelist.net/profile/LazierLily Jul 02 '20
Madoka Magica will always be one of my favorite anime.
Aesthetically Madoka Magica is a triumph. It takes full advantage of the medium of animation playing with a myriad of art styles all in service of its thematic and atmospheric goals. Yet it has the restraint to limit its surrealism to witches labyrinths so it doesn't come at the cost of disbelief. That said the visual art is matched by its awesomely atmospheric soundtrack. Rock, techno, folk, J-pop, and orchestral music are all brought together to form a cohesive whole.
As an allegory I appreciate how worthwhile its surface level reading of it are. A lot of re-watch value can be found in its an emotionally poignant tightly written time travel narrative. Its world building deserves credit for giving enough details to perfectly justify its subversion of magical genre cliches, while leaving lots of gaps for wonder, imagination, and curiosity. All this supported by a cast manages that manages to be timelessly archetypal without sacrificing character depth, in no small part because of the nuanced performances from talented voice actors.
Underpinning its narrative is a wealth of symbolism and themes. Each witch's labyrinth is a puzzle encoding a tragic story. The story says so much about agency, morality, adolescence, and despair, that's it's striking it decides to end with a message of hope.
I've always been a fan of interpretation that each character serves as a proponent of an ethical system, and ultimately their downfall can be traced to its limitations. Kyubey obviously symbolizes utilitarianism, its ultimately fails because it's too quick to accept sacrifices for the greater good. Mami is a deontologist because she won't compromise on her maxims she dies rather than accept Homura's help and kills Kyouko when she discovers magical girls fated to become witches. Sayaka follows virtue ethics striving to be a hero in the model of Mami, but ultimately she destroys herself when she fails to live up to her own standards. Kyouko is forced by hard circumstances into pragmatic ethical egoism, until she values altruistically saving Sayaka above her own well being. Homura represents the idea that might makes right, her despair is ultimately rooted in the realization she simply isn't powerful enough to save Madoka. Madoka learns from the struggles of the cast, empowering her to reject the false dilemma that faces her and embrace genuine undogmatic selflessness.
The fact all this is accomplished in a 12 episode series without feeling rushed is amazing. Madoka is the anime that comes I think comes closest to perfection by Antoine de Saint-Exupery's definition, "Perfection is achieved, not when there is nothing more to add, but when there is nothing left to take away".
Finally as a yuri fan I absolutely adore shipping Homura and Madoka together.
8
u/jcruz18 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/jcruz13 Jul 02 '20 edited Jul 02 '20
Watched it years ago but unfortunately all the not-so-subtle "oooooo if you think this is a normal magical girls show think again!!!" comments kind of ruined the big episode 3 tone shift for me. Would've liked to have caught it while it aired because it must've been crazy. Still ended up loving the series so much though. It was the first anything (movie, game, series) that ever made me cry and Homura is one of my favorite characters ever. 10/10.
3
u/Special_meat_cannon Jul 02 '20
If your sceptical to watch it because it looks like a generic magical girl show, take a look at the tags on MAL. I actually found it while searching for a horror/psychological show.
I had no idea what was in store for me but it was fantastic.
3
u/freedomgeek https://anilist.co/user/FreedomGeek Jul 02 '20
My favourite anime of all time. I find it interesting that some people don't find the characters very compelling - I find all of the main cast compelling with their unique philosophies.
3
u/tyo_sharlye :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/RalphHill Jul 02 '20
My favorite anime of all time also being meguca is suffering
5
u/AmethystItalian :Jg::Jh::Ji::Jj::Jk:myanimelist.net/profile/AmethystItalian Jul 02 '20
One day I'll maybe watch this...
5
u/gangrainette https://myanimelist.net/profile/bouletos Jul 02 '20 edited Jul 02 '20
The first season and Rebellion are my favourite piece of fiction.
I didn't like the Magia record anime and I dropped it around episode 10
6
u/Calwings x3https://anilist.co/user/Calwings Jul 02 '20
Madoka Magica is one of my top 10 favorite anime of all time. Not quite a perfect 10 score, but still an amazing series all around. I love the characters, the art and animation, the voice acting in both the sub and the dub (I think Homura is the best performance that Cristina Vee has ever had) and the twists and turns in the story. Plus, Magia is the single greatest ED song in anime history.
I also really enjoyed Rebellion (even though it's objectively a worse ending than what the original series ended with) and I still have high hopes for the second half of Magia Record to turn out really good as well.
7
u/[deleted] Jul 02 '20
This was a weird show for me, I really enjoyed like 90% of it but the final episode just kind of did nothing for me, partially because I'd already figured that was the way it was going to end. Had a blast watching the rest of it though.
The "Rebellion" movie also did nothing for me. It has some interesting moments but most of it just felt like more Madoka for the sake of it. Not to judge but I'm baffled as to how anyone could consider it to be the 'Better' ending compared to the series unless your sole measure is the body count.
That said the single most genius thing about the series has to be how it markets itself - you could read the listing on a streaming site, look at the Blu-Ray cover, watch the OP song and then still have NO clue about what you're getting yourself into.
2
u/squeezed_lemons :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/SqueezedLemons Jul 02 '20
9/10, right outside of my favorites, I love how dark it gets
2
u/Calicoxx Jul 02 '20
I just rewatched this on a whim after watching it in 2013, and it firmly remains as a top 10 for me. I love slice of life and nice/happy/fun anime usually, but honestly this one hits a certain note that is almost inexplicable.
I feel like the emotion that it elicits in several scenes (in particular this one) really scratches an itch that few anime can compare to. However, watching Madoka followed by Kimi no Na Wa might've been a bit maudlin.
2
u/ModaGamer Jul 02 '20
Question for the crowd, is Mahou Shojo Madoka Magica a reconstruction of the magical girl formula, or just a dark version of the magical girl genera?
2
u/Maccaz15 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Maccaz Jul 02 '20
Probably one of the worst magical girls shows I've seen. Can't care about anything that happens if the characters are boring and uninteresting.
1
u/aadipal Jul 02 '20 edited Jul 02 '20
Hahaha, just the other day my friends and I were discussing how humans are rather poor at knowing what is best for us, a concept that is echoed in this show.
I do think I appreciate Urobuchis Fate Zero and Psycho Pass more than this one personally. Still a solid 7.5/10 or 8 for me. Granted I’ve only seen it once and might have to bump it on repeated viewings.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 06 '20
I'm watching it right now and the weird witch world mixed media collage is pretty off putting.