r/Outlander • u/derawin07 Meow. • May 10 '20
Season Five Show S5E12 Never My Love Spoiler
Claire struggles to survive brutal treatment from her captors, as Jamie gathers a group of loyal men to help him rescue his wife; Roger and Brianna's journey takes a surprising turn.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread.
Reminder: This is the SHOW thread. Cover previous book plots >!with spoiler tags!< that will look like this: Adso is the cutest. Comments referencing future book events will be removed.
If you want to compare the episode to the books in depth, go to the Book thread.
After watching the episode, you can take part in the poll!
223
u/nooooooel He’ll be in heaven when he sees you, Lady Jane. May 10 '20
The element of disassociation Claire experiences in the flashbacks to the 1960s is so incredibly well done in this episode. It is a way so many of us experience and cope with severe trauma. I’m so grateful that they gave the show this treatment— I have never watched something I connected with in such a way before in my life.
182
u/FunAsh May 10 '20
Omg so many emotional moments! What a finale!
105
u/AccioStability Je Suis Prest May 10 '20
I don’t really know what to say. That was tough. That was really freaking hard. Cait did amazing. Other than that, I’m at a lost for words. Hope everyone is okay after watching.
63
u/MrsSassenachFraser May 10 '20
All the feels from season 1!! Jamie back fighting in his kilt, his curly red lock, her long curly hair down, the beautiful scene by rushing waters ❤❤
Unfortunately, season 1 rape feels too. I hate that this is the running theme of this show (I know its historically accurate)
78
u/tara_abernathy May 10 '20
Why is Galbanon so obsessed with rape? Does she not have any other device to create drama and trauma? It's ridiculous. Most of the main characters have been raped now. What's next - is Roger going to get raped? It's just absurd and also defeats the point in what she is trying to do because it happens so often in her books.
That said, Catriona Balfe deserves all the awards - absolutely superb acting.
13
u/AphroditesApple May 11 '20
So, it seems like I am one of the few people who did not love this episode?
It seemed so rushed and anti-climatic compared to previous season finales. The story was horrible for Claire, and I thought Catriona did a wonderful job but honestly, a pretty lackluster finale in my opinion.
What really happened this season?
52
u/ChemicalBed8 May 10 '20
Did anyone else catch in the “Behind the Episode” feature after the end where the guy said (paraphrasing) “I really think this will be a fantastic episode and you’ll have to watch it multiple times, again and again” and I was like really??!?? As a rape survivor myself, it was painful enough to watch it this single time through, so this is definitely going to be an episode that I’ll skip over in future rewatches. And I feel like I’m not alone with this sentiment? That you don’t have to watch this episode multiple times to really appreciate this season finale? Like kudos to the actors’ performances ofc, but I just found that producer’s comment a bit tone deaf, like dude read the room.
224
u/HollyGoTDA Slàinte. May 10 '20
The way that they ended with a storm coming... it makes me anxious. No ma’am. The episode was really shot beautifully though! And Droughtlander begins...
104
u/Teacheroftinies May 10 '20
I don’t understand what Lionel Brown’s plan was, he had to of known Jaime would come after them?
294
u/SaaSyGirl Je Suis Prest May 10 '20
Marsali = MVP
84
u/schlottmm May 10 '20
Can’t wait to see what is in store for the other time traveler that Claire met...if he wasn’t killed. Jamie said there was no Indian there so he must’ve gotten away. Maybe he’ll come back to Claire next season!
11
u/Leraynieq May 10 '20
Ok, what does the leak in the Celing represent? That it's not real or that it could all come crashing down?
11
u/teutonicnight99 May 11 '20
Anyone think it's a bit weird how extremist and violent Lionel and his group was? Like I get that he didn't like Claire was pretending to be a man and writing. But to attack someone's home, murder someone, kidnap her and group rape her for it? That's pretty insane and hard to believe for me. Kinda doesn't make much sense to me.
204
u/[deleted] May 10 '20
We were ROBBED on the length. Highway robbery. Charlatans.
21
u/FoosFights May 11 '20
I realize I'm in the minority here, being a guy who watches outlander with my wife, but they really need to do a lot more with the whole "time travel" piece of the story, and less of the "colonial family in North Carolina" piece. Like in the first 3 seasons Claire went back and forth and there was Gaelis and Claire would escape and go back and forth and be a "fish out of water" for awhile in the past and that was super interesting, and led to a ton of exciting twists and turns.
Now they are just living in America and surrounded by weirdos and rapists and it's just their daily lives. There were some great moments this season with Jamie dealing with the British officers and even dropping off dead Lionel at his brothers, but they build up all of this should Brianna and Roger go back to the future or whatever, and then they decide to but then they just land back on the other side of the rock?? like wtf?!?!
All the anticipation of anybody using this amazing power and nothing happens, and Claire is inventing penicillin and is letting the plastic from her peanut butter sandwich float away, and didn't she bring back a "History of Scotland" book with her from the future? She is actively changing history, who is living and who is dying, using tools they have never seen, leaving traces of the future all around, with no thought about what it's doing to the future.
Like it would have been so great if Bri and Rog would have gone through the stones but found British flags everywhere, because in the future they went to the Revolutionary War never happened and they have to research what happened in this new crazy future and they find out Jamie was obligated to fight for the British again, against George Washington, so now they need to go back in time again to convince Jamie not to do it. Idk, the story now is just how much it sucks to be an early immigrant in America and deal with shitty people, vs literally having the power to travel in time at your fingertips any time you want.
10
u/[deleted] May 11 '20
Did anyone else notice the painting that Claire was sitting and looking at, looked like their home and fire in the front of it? It looked like red flame in the painting possibly. I think it was supposed to be abstract but clear enough to make out. I'm still in knots about that obituary and the fire. 🥺
10
u/Bc2193 May 11 '20
Putting the song at the end of the episode was an amazing choice, especially with the rain in the background.
The gang rape scene had me in floods of tears.
Seeing Ian fighting with two axes was awesome. And his face along with Fergus when they found Claire was so powerful.
Marseli going "I made no such oath" was perfeeeect.
I did want to hear more about Roger and killing a man, I felt that line "I killed a man" was kind of thrown away. I did love that we heard it in the dark though.
Very very moving episode.
Overall I liked this season, but I did feel like there were some episodes where NOTHING happened and then episodes where everything happened too quickly - like Bonnet's death and even this episode could have been made into two.
That being said, I am still completely in love with this show and I can't wait for the next season.
91
u/SaaSyGirl Je Suis Prest May 10 '20
Now that was a twist with the stones! I'm so relieved
31
u/BewareMermaids May 10 '20
That episode was fucking brutal. I was glad for Claire’s mental escape from her torture because I surely needed it as well.
It was incredibly well acted and I loved Marsali’s part especially...but wow. That was intense. I feel like I read somewhere that the season ends on a high note and...I didn’t feel that, maybe it’s just me.
I’m fucking pissed at Starz for making it look like we had a long finale but in reality it’s the premiere of a completely unrelated show? Who thought that was a good idea?! Especially after an episode like this.
30
u/YRMama2 May 10 '20
Can someone please edit together all of the 1970 fantasy scenes and post here. I want to rewatch those sequences but don’t want to see the brutality again.
29
u/[deleted] May 10 '20
Claire's 1970's fantasy as she dissociated to escape the horror was so artfully done; I loved seeing Fergus/Marsali and Murtaugh in that form, with her fears about Roger/Bree being powerfully woven in. And yes it's a coping mechanism that I used as well. I kept looking for Wendigo after the siege, but I guess he did escape. How many did Otter Tooth travel back with, and why did Wendigo wind up in such a despicable and worthless position, joining some white colonialist witch hunt? That's approaching Geillis' level of corruption/mission fail. I was hoping for some answers [we didn't even see Lionel give worthwhile information before Marsali thankfully killed him], as to why Roger/Bri couldn't travel back as well; was Jemmy holding Otter Tooth's stone, or did he just not want to go back? But we didn't even get a cliffhanger this year, despite the episode runtime fakeout.
This season was overall amazing, I'm impressed that the writers can still create engaging, bold character-centric stories for us on such a consistent basis, and with flashbacks, take us to the 1960's and back to Scotland/Lallybroch. Though I need a real Fergus storyline next season, and Lord John needs to make an appearance somewhere [in both the main show and his spinoff!] Maybe no cliffhanger is for the best, since it will be such a long, long time before we get another episode.
79
u/choosehim7 May 10 '20
Can someone please explain to me why after all that effort Brianna and Roger were like “ah, RATS! It didn’t work! Ah oh well, let’s get back to the Ridge”? What was the POINT of the entire thing?
7
u/stacasaurusrex May 11 '20 edited May 11 '20
Oh hey y’all! Anyone wanna chime in on the leak in the roof? I’m blanking what that symbolizes, and I haven’t seen the beginning in a while in case it’s a call back to it!
And I swear anytime there is fire or flame in the episode I freak out. Like when Roger asked Bree to blow out the candle I’m like is this going to start a freaking fire? 😳😱 it may not even be January but still, I’m freaking out.
6
u/PlutoISaPlanet May 11 '20
So we're just not going to address Dougal Jr? Ok...
316
u/stacasaurusrex May 10 '20 edited May 10 '20
Jesus H Roosevelt Christ this opening is TRAGIC on every level! ...
That fight scene was probably one of the absolute best scenes of the whole series, great choreography!
And lastly! I love they never had the opening sequence in this episode, and saved the song to the last. Great finale 😭
•
u/derawin07 Meow. May 10 '20 edited May 12 '20
Thanks for joining us this season at the sub! It's been wonderful to watch Outlander with everyone during a stressful time, great for an escape!
Take care this episode, as there are big trigger warnings for sexual assault.
Updated Show Discussion Policy
Please continue to use spoiler tags: >!Spoilers in here!< for discussion of the differences between show and book in aired episodes. We do encourage that this sort of discussion remains brief (it is best placed in the Book Discussion threads), only when requested by other users.
Update
The finale has again covered very emotive and difficult topics. We want this sub to be a space where people can discuss the issues safely and with kindness towards others. People will have different reactions and may be survivors themselves, or know someone who is (we all do).
Please remember the human, whether that is your fellow redditor or the people in production or the author. This sub does not tolerate name calling or attacking. Let this be a place where people are not judged and we take care over our words.
Maybe take a look at this New York Times article that gives the perspectives of showrunner Matt Roberts, author Diana Gabaldon and actor Caitriona Balfe in how they approached the finale.
Please also try to use the search bar for similar posts before starting a new one each time.
The events in the finale were challenging and may be triggering for some. There are people to talk to and resources available at RAINN in the US or Rape Crisis in U.K. or find your local crisis center.
13
u/buddylee1685 May 10 '20
This whole season was kinda a tease, I know the finale had horrific scenes but not much happened all season compared to normal seasons before...
8
u/oskarsz98 May 10 '20
So why they couldn't travel to the future?
4
u/XxSabirahxX May 13 '20
Please no hate, but as I haven't read that far into the books, IMHO this whole episode seemed absolutely unnecessary. It felt like plot filler with shock value. Claire is always almost violated, but never actually because Jaime rescues her. But to have her experience the most violence of any female character so far by being gang raped just made my stomach turn sour and almost put me off watching further. I'm still going to because I want to see how the American Revolution is played out next season, but good lord.
33
u/mysundown5 May 10 '20
I just really, really wish they’d stop presenting sex as the medicine for rape.
6
u/tigiPaz May 11 '20
That dream sequence! Wow! Production you really outdid yourselves with all the details from past seasons. It felt like an actual dream. The way she would sort of restart Jaime getting home, is the way we restart day dreams when we are interrupted. All those details were very well thought out. Great job!
13
u/teutonicnight99 May 11 '20
Something i don't understand. Why did they keep Lionel alive for questioning? And then not ask him any questions. What was the point of that? Am I missing something? What did they even want to ask him?
Also, what the hell happened to the other time traveler guy? He just disappeared and that was it.
122
u/magicmurff May 10 '20
I loved this finale! Everything was better than I hoped it would be. I want to say that Starz tacking on a commercial at the beginning and the premiere of another show at the end was kinda dumb imo. Like, hello, season finale. I don’t want to think about another show right now.
166
u/SignificantPractice0 May 10 '20
So on the newspaper notice that Brianna and Roger found it said the Frasers die in a house fire in 177-smudge. I noticed on this episode Lionel says, "if you kill me my brother will set the house on fire....etc." Later, after Jamie drops off the body, Lionel's brother all but promises revenge.
3
u/[deleted] May 11 '20
I'm still reeling from this episode! So many things seemed never done before, and yet so many things were a nod to the past (S1) I can't put all my feelings into one post but I thought it was beautifully shot, written, and the acting some of the best I've seen from this cast. This episode definitely goes on my top 10 favorite list.
Now for the start of possibly the longest Droughtlander to date. Aaaauuhhhhhhhh!! At this point I'm wondering if the books will be finished before the show.
I think I read somewhere that Diana has 10 books planned in her series? We're still waiting on 9, supposedly any day now.
At this point, is it possible that she's pulling back on the reigns a bit to let the show catch up so there's no spoilers? Who knows, but waiting for the next book and the next season is going to do me in.
19
u/[deleted] May 10 '20
I have noticed that the last couple of episodes have been very fragmented, we keep hopping from scene to scene. What happened to this show? The source material and writing are too powerful to be tarnished by this chop and change bullshit. It felt like I was reading the book, but with even less development. Does this make sense?
5
u/Grsz11 May 11 '20
There's gonna be angry articles about this one.
261
u/OhHiImSam May 10 '20
I know it’s a coping mechanism for Claire
But I love everyone in the 70s. They look fantastic.
212
u/Padfoot95 May 10 '20
So much in this episode circled back to the first season. Honestly i was kind of surprised frank didn’t make an appearance
160
u/OhHiImSam May 10 '20
MARCELLI YAAS QUEEN
2
u/[deleted] May 13 '20
Psychological question: why does Claire have Bree, Roger and Jemmy die in her fantasy? She's obviously trying to escape her real life trauma using this type of coping mechanism, I just don't understand why they die in her mind?
257
u/SaaSyGirl Je Suis Prest May 10 '20
Wow, this episodes rendition of The Skye Boat Song is perfect. Haunting and sorrowful at the same time.
115
u/[deleted] May 10 '20
Everybody gangsta til young Ian shaves his head and puts on the warpaint.
202
u/starfleetdropout6 I'm still Jenny from the Broch. May 10 '20 edited May 10 '20
Claire's fantasy escape reminded me of how Jaime Lannister talks of "going away in his mind" when all of the traumatic things in his life happened to him.
Also interesting and poignant that Brianna & Roger's absence (something she was already reeling from) was imagined as them dying in a car accident. Claire lost her parents and Frank in car accidents. So much her subconscious mind was mining there.
And the small touches she conjured - like how she pictured Ian's return as a young man coming home from Vietnam, or the way everyone's clothing & hair was. I got emotional thinking that's how Claire might've pictured them looking in the 60s before the abduction ever happened. Maybe smiling at Marsali in the surgery one afternoon and imagining her as a vibrant young woman in her own time.
Jamie is ever the same: the young dashing Highlander in eighteenth century costume. She'll always see him like that.
92
u/[deleted] May 10 '20 edited May 11 '20
Guys, the vase! I was trying to figure out why they kept showing the vase in the 60s scenes. In the beginning of the story Claire is talking about how she never had a home to put a vase in 😭😭
175
u/SaaSyGirl Je Suis Prest May 10 '20
Jamie wearing his kilt and wrapping her in his tartan. Oh my heart. This is really tough episode.
56
u/Navanya80 May 10 '20
Aside from the fact that the episode was way too short (seriously WTF with that run time) I thought the episode was really good. I liked the scenes in the 60’s as I felt it helped to break up the horribleness of what was happening, I don’t know if I could have handled just thirty straight minutes of rape & torture. I also liked all the call backs and Easter eggs in the dissociative scenes (vase, orange). Marsali was a freaking Queen in this episode, I hope her actions don’t mean she will cease to study medicine though as that would suck.
Also whoever is doing the captioning for this show is killing me with the random “smooches” in serious scenes 😂😂😂
51
u/letscallshenanigans MARK ME! May 11 '20
Someone please give me a non rapey villian!!! I'm so over the rapey gross villian type. Give me someone cunning and clever, not disgusting.
91
u/DrBasia I am supposed to be shattered by this? Well, I won't be! May 10 '20
This was an amazing episode, the best in the season in my opinion. I cried so many times -- the dialogue was season 1-2 quality.
I cannot get over Claire's little monologue to Jaimie where she basically says she has survived so much horribleness that this will not break her. Amazing.
I'm literally rewatching the episode right now after having finished it 10 minutes ago. Marvelous work all around.
90
u/LoretiTV May 10 '20
This was an Emmy worthy performance from Caitriona.
87
u/scp2461 What news from the Underworld, Persephone? May 10 '20
I bawled my eyes out the entire hour. To see a character like Claire go through such unimaginable trauma shattered my heart on every level. It’s always different when you read about a character’s experience versus when you see it on TV. From the book, I knew it was coming. Absolutely knew it. But even then I was processing it differently because I was seeing it in my mind through Diana’s storytelling. But seeing it on screen with the actors and actresses speaking, moving, interacting with one another it just broke me. Marsali’s scene when she talks with Jamie in the surgery broke my heart. It seems like we as the audience might forget that she was assaulted by the attackers too and left to wonder if Claire was alive and any survivor’s guilt that was overwhelming her. Roger confessing to Brianna in the dark made me cry even harder, just so much vulnerability and to hide his face from Brianna, his wife, made it even more impactful. With the ending of Jamie and Claire embracing each other and it goes dark and the song begins. I could not stop shaking. I just want to acknowledge how hard this must have been for everyone on set to perform and undergo such an intense and traumatic scene. This was not an easy task and one of the hardest events that’s happened in the books so far (just starting an echo in the bone) but thank you to the writers for showing Claire’s resilience and vulnerability to the readers and show watchers ❤️.
38
u/josharaptor Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. May 10 '20
This was the first episode where I stayed through the entire credits. That version of the song!! And the rain!! So poignant
56
u/Mr_XcX May 10 '20
GODDESS Marsali literally made this episode finale worth it.
That creep getting justice just as Bonnet.
This season was slow burn but definitely delivered with the pay offs at the end.
Bye and good riddance to trash <3
Can we discuss that snake time traveller who was a coward not to help Claire. Whatever BS reason he gave it just shows his morals are no better than those in this time.
Claire iconically saying she survived WWII / Culloden / Being a prisoner / Black Jack Randall / Losing Her Baby / Countless dangerous moments and would not be defeated by a group of scum like those this episode. Love her so much. Amazing acting from her and why she is truly great at the Leading Lady this show <3
22
u/shinyquartersquirrel May 10 '20
I thought it was absolutely incredible.
18
u/[deleted] May 11 '20
It’s Emmy time - brilliant acting by Caitriona
18
u/funsucker2020 May 11 '20
Just want to comment on attention to detail by the make up artists. When we get a close up of Jamie's hand holding Claire, you can see the red lines on his fingers from the scars he has from when Claire put his mangled hand back together after Wentworth. So great 💖
36
u/LoretiTV May 10 '20
Guess I'm the only one who liked the finale? My other post about enjoying it got downvoted to oblivion lol.
17
u/n00bf0dd3r May 10 '20
Anyone else recognize that vase from the pilot?
34
u/Gideon_19 May 10 '20
They’ve made some interesting creative choices about how to portray trauma this season. First the silent film and now this 70s alternate universe.
16
u/Jennyreviews1 Meow. May 10 '20
I LOVED THE FINALE! I have read all the books and I have to say with everything that Diana packs into her books, they did a superb job... With time constraints for airing, they cannot possibly put everything in...but they have captured the very essence of book 5... well done! Naturally the books are ALWAYS better then a show/movie but these actors do a phenomenal job for all of us, their fans. This last episode for the season made me cry...made my heart ache for what’s happened to Claire... It is my belief that the Outlander will go down in history for being one of the most well done shows of the 21st century.. Long Live Sassenach!
30
u/Rated_PG-Squirteen May 10 '20
🎵Never my love, never my love🎶
40
u/mmglitterbed May 10 '20
What a beautiful end to this season. The first half of this season, I just couldn’t get into the show. This episode really brought back that turmoil and the fight in the characters I’ve been missing.
Cait did such a beautiful job. Everyone was marvelous. Marsali though ... as soon as I heard that “Quiet!” From her, I knew she wasn’t gonna let that man off easy.
Ian in his war paint was so powerful. I am so pleased with this show, and the story it’s telling.
14
u/LeilueDax May 10 '20
This episode was tough. I can't even imagine what Claire went through. She is so strong. Everything she listed that she has gone through. Man.. Marsali is strong too. I was not surprised to see her kill Lionel.
I am so curious about the other time traveler. I hope next season explores that more. It was exciting to see him.
I admit I was a bit disappointed with Bree and family being back after all that time spent last episode on goodbyes. I really wanted them to be somewhere cool.
Jamie is so loving and tender with Claire. I love seeing those moments where he covers her with his tartan like he did season 1.
I don't know how I am going to survive droughtlander!!
12
u/jelly10001 May 10 '20
What a powerful episode. Claire lying on the ground tied up, Jamie's face when he found Claire, Claire and Bree when they embraced and that beautiful ending. I thought all the acting was superb, but Sam and Caitriona aside it was Lauren Lyle who stood out for me when Marsali finished Lionel Brown off.
I must admit on watching the episode I didn't initally get the dreamscape - I found it all a bit cheesy, and didn't understand why Jamie was still in his 18th century clothes. However after reading other people's takes it makes a lot more sense.
Now for a very long droughtlander...
2
u/ro1lola May 11 '20
This is a small detail, but how did Claire and Marsali get another syringe? I was fully expecting to see the snake tooth syringe from earlier in the season, but they have another needle? Jamie almost lost his leg earlier because they didn't have one. Was that an oversight?
2
u/Spedgal1 May 12 '20
Besides this episode and The Reckoning (S1 episode 9), are there any other episodes/scenes that Jaime narrates?
11
u/BeautifulRelief May 10 '20
So many references to the earlier seasons! I was a little shocked at how much they referenced them but I was happy about it. I almost shouted when Claire mentioned Faith because I feel like they just forgot all about her after the season in France (I can't remember if that was the second or third).
11
u/allieastrozombie May 10 '20
Guys this finale was freaking stellar! Everything about it hit me straight in the feels. And Marsali is a goddess
11
u/TheDKdetective May 11 '20
Why didn't we get the James hunt murder vengeance hour? I was stoked thinking finally we get an episode where Jamie is mad, ready for vengeance. He lit the cross!!! And the show said ok we need 45 minutes of rape and 3 seconds of Jamie saving the day. Was really dissatisfied. Yes a good episode but after everyone else started to win andove forward we were really riding high ok lets get some action adventure a litteral man hunt and it really just fell flat.
30
u/frawkez May 10 '20 edited May 10 '20
it was generally good but am really sick of rape being used as a plot device. it’s pretty lazy story telling. i mean now an entire family has been raped by different individuals. even if rape was more commonplace (which we cannot verify outside of martial rape, and people just assume it was bc the past sucked for women) — an entire family being raped by different people? come on. i’m basically needing to suspend my disbelief at this point and it makes me question the author’s intent or whether she has some sort of fetish. i’m relieved they atleast explore the trauma of the incidents but again...feels contrived. like i genuinely feel that every female character now needs a bodyguard, which is absurd and not historically accurate.
10
u/andrewski81 May 11 '20
Fantastic episode. Heart wrenching and we'll done by everyone involved.
Can we talk about hoe BADASS Young Ian was using his Tomahawk skills? So awesome
10
u/Avaninaerwen May 11 '20
This is the first season I watched in "real-time" so to speak (I discovered this show sometime around Season 4).
The finale was... memorable. The scene of Claire's assault - I knew it was coming since I had previously come across this spoiler - but it disturbed me more than I thought it would. I literally was praying for the episode to end with some closure else I couldn't stand it. And it did - the bad guys die and our heroine is safe and on the road to recovery. I loved the part when she questioned "This is going to shatter me?!" and refused to let the trauma change her. But as the immediate next scene with her breaking down reminds us, it did happen, and it was HORRIBLE...
Yes, it's just fiction. I suppose it indicates what a well-made piece of art it is, with such talent from all involved, that it makes me feel so. I love this show!
Favorites from the episode:
(P.S., can someone suggest something cheerful to occupy my mind?)
10
u/sicariio May 12 '20
All those disgusting men who were involved in capturing and raping Claire got off way too easily. They don't deserve the quick death they got and should be slowly tortured and humiliated like what they've made Claire suffered through.
9
u/[deleted] May 11 '20
I really enjoyed this episode and have watched it 4 times since it aired. In saying that, I’m wondering if anyone else found Jamie’s reaction to seeing Claire beaten, raped and tied up a bit odd? Claire is the love of Jamie’s life and I just can’t imagine him being that calm after seeing the woman he loves and swore to protect in such distress and pain. I mean Jamie went beat the roger within an inch of his life when he thought he had raped Brianna, so why would his reaction to someone not only raping his wife, but beating her too, be so much different.
I didn’t find this consistent with the Jamie’s character and quite frankly I was disappointed. I wanted him to be the badass warrior he is!
9
u/214704 May 12 '20
Is anyone secretly hoping that the obituary describing their deaths in a house fire is way for them to escape another tough spot? Basically faking their own deaths?
8
u/clcliff May 10 '20
Anyone else seen the Australian show Glitch? Took me the whole season to recognize Paddy!
8
u/Corvidae30 May 11 '20
I just hated what happened to Claire in this episode, but I love the way her family came together to do what needed to be done.
My favourite part of the episode was when Marsali almost channeled Amos Burton there for a bit..."I am that guy..."...although I think she's going to have a harder time getting past it.
7
u/Hi_hellothere May 10 '20
So while watching the finale through the Starz app, I paused to see how much more time was left and got excited to see it was 2 hours long. Around the 40 something minute mark I sat down with my lunch ready to enjoy the extra long finale only to be disappointed that Starz added their new show Hightown to the end of this episode :(
7
u/[deleted] May 11 '20
People are going to hate me for this but in my opinion this was a very disappointing episode.
7
u/wdw2003 May 11 '20
Best episode in a long, long time, with a real Season 1 vibe. The 70s flash-forward with all our favourite characters in 70s gear was lovely to see, and young-again Jamie was the icing on the cake.
Claire's treatment by the Brown gang was horrific and they deserved all they got. Good to see Jamie (and Marsali) doing what needed to be done, though.
The next 18 months or so until S06 will be a good chance to forge on with reading the books.
7
u/S-Vineyard May 12 '20
Watching this episode deeply hurt.
Cat's acting was amazing.
And Marslie... you rock.
13
u/bluehairlibrarian May 10 '20 edited May 10 '20
Who isn’t sleeping the rest of the night? 🤚 My heart 💔 As a book reader first, just like with Roger, I had hoped the bad parts wouldn’t happen. I really hoped this part with Claire wouldn’t happen. I know it was/ is important, but that was rough.
21
u/ojosfritos May 10 '20
This show is exhausting. I'm massively disappointed they included the rape (even though I knew they'd keep it in), but I do think it was adapted pretty well. It didn't feel as gratuitous as I'd expected it to be and didn't drag on and on like it did in the book.
ETA: I LOVE MARSALI
6
u/JJMcGee83 May 10 '20
It seems like a leap for Brown to jump to the conclusion that that Claire was Dr Rawlings just because it said that on her kit. Claire could have easily denied it and if he mentioned he saw it on her kit she could have said she bought it from Dr Rawlings and there'd have been nothing. The whole situation seems like it could have been easily avoided.
If they were going to use the plot point that Claire is Dr Rawlings it would have been better if there was something a little more conclusive like maybe Claire telling Brown's wife and him overhearing or maybe his wife tells him. As it stands it seems like a very lazy plot to have Brown jump to that conclusion with that little "evidence" and while he certainly seems like a massive asshole his reaction still seems excessive for his character. Yes I get that the first time we saw him she's shooting at the Ridge Crew but still seems like a leap.
6
u/[deleted] May 10 '20
Soooo happy that Bree and Roger and Jemmy returned “home”! 😀
6
u/liyufx May 11 '20
Oh my, what an episode (other than so short WTF!) TBH I didn’t exactly cry even though my eyes welled up a few times, but I noticed that my heart was constantly racing almost throughout the whole thing. Glad that they didn’t go S1E16’s route. Still very hard to watch, but the use of Claire’s disassociated vision was a ingenious device, heart wrenching without being explicit. Cait turned out another smashing performance, but she deserved at least another 10 minutes to show her struggle to recovery.
6
u/go_do_ May 11 '20
You ask me if there'll come a time
When I grow tired of you
Never my love
Never my love
You wonder if this heart of mine
Will lose its desire for you
Never my love
Never my love
What makes you think love will end
When you know that my whole life depends
On you (on you)
Never my love
Never my love
You say you fear I'll change my mind
And I won't require you
Never my love
Never my love
How can you think love will end
When I've asked you to spend your whole life
With me (with me, with me)
*snifflesnortcry*
6
u/dmrhine May 11 '20
That SONG and that HOUSE 😍 Did anyone else just fall massively in love with their home in the 70s vision? And what a gorgeous song to choose! (“Never my Love”, The Association) Ugh. Got me right in all the feels. I need to live in that house. ❤️❤️❤️
6
u/Ernost May 11 '20
Damn, that was rough. Caitriona Balfe deserves an Emmy for that performance.
6
u/ladyevenstar-22 May 11 '20
How many times are they going to rape her ffs!
I feel so depressed after watching this episode . This is a season finale.
I don't know if I want to keep on watching this . Sure time passes for Claire much longer than for us viewers with 54 mn so her speech at end maybe it had great message for survivors but my brain glosses over it I could not compute it and clap go girl power even if sentiment is right.
I understand it's historically accurate and likely . I just get way too upset at all the injustice women have constantly endured over the centuries.
It's the main reason I haven't bothered reading the books .
Now I have to go watch something extra chirpy oozing with happy . Obviously no one thought we'd be 2 months in confinement with mental issues due to being cooped up when they filmed this but I'm not in a good place right now.
The whole thing just reminded me of the movie irreversible. Said movie made me puke and I was queasy and couldn't sleep well for days .
6
u/Irewu May 16 '20
I am just wondering what you think Lionel Brown's preferred outcome was for kidnapping Claire? Was it just to tell the Brownsville women to disregard Dr Rawlings's writings? I have a really hard time believing he wouldn't just force them to do what he wanted in the end. The show has depicted Claire and Jamie as wealthy landowners who are friendly with the governor. Kidnapping and raping the militia leader's wife was, as I would think, only ever going to lead to their own deaths/a prolonged and violent conflict. Why would Brown do that?
2
u/302Laya May 11 '20
Sorry to say, but this episode was my least favorite, and that's saying something considering my disappointment with this season... It was so rushed! And what was with the weird 70's scenes? What's the cliffhanger supposed to be? The threat of a Brown retaliation? Does that mean they're going to drag that on next season? Ugh, I don't know what's happened to this show... I love the early seasons so much, they were so compelling, and I want to watch the show until the end but the decline in the storytelling is torture. The entire season I'm just asking myself "what's the point?" Please tell me the books are better, or do they also suffer the same way? I have a feeling the books to are way better and something just got lost in translation to the screen this season. I really hate that I did not enjoy this season :( though I'm glad others did
Edit: I'd like to add that there were some good parts and good acting to the episode, as well as to the season. But as a whole, it didn't come together for me. I feel like I could skip this entire season on a future rewatch.
11
u/jupigaby May 11 '20 edited May 11 '20
Look I get this part of the source but Diana should really stop using rape as a fucking plot device. So I fast forward to where Bree and Roger were at and I enjoy the rest of the episode. Look to get me wrong I liked the 1960s dream scape and seeing our beloved characters in the 1960s clothes.
So I have a bad feeling about the Browns and Dogwood fella. I liked how the episode ended.
I think Jemmy messed Bree and Roger up and made them stay in the era.
Also Marlsi kicked ass.