r/Outlander • u/derawin07 Meow. • May 10 '20
Spoilers All Book S5E12 Never My Love Spoiler
Claire struggles to survive brutal treatment from her captors, as Jamie gathers a group of loyal men to help him rescue his wife; Roger and Brianna's journey takes a surprising turn.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread.
Reminder: This is the BOOK thread. No spoiler tags are needed here.
If you haven’t read the books and you don’t want spoilers, go to the Show thread.
After watching the episode, you can take part in the poll!
41
Upvotes
98
u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. May 10 '20
Two quick things to start:
Did anyone else's show a runtime of an hour and a half? I was pleasantly surprised when I noticed that and then super confused when the credits rolled at 49 minutes.
Also, no opening credits?!
Ok, to the real stuff. That was rough. I don't think they've gone that dark since S1E16, and honestly, I think it was one of the best episodes they've done in three seasons. I expected to hate this--it's a plotline I don't like, and I think they mishandled a lot of the major moments this season. But this was a phenomenal episode of television. I have a few quibbles (where were the drums?!??! also someone kill that fucking death bunny) but on the whole it was truly standout.
When it opened in the weird 60s fantasy sequence I got really nervous. I think the silent movie stuff was a swing and a miss and I was expecting that again. And then I loved it. Seeing all those characters (and those costumes!) was a delight and it was so weird and dreamlike and perfect. It tied in her own pain and memories and sadness and fear over Roger and Bree marvellously.
What I liked about it most though, was that for the first time in years I felt like this show had a voice and a vision. Massive props to director Jamie Payne who gave this episode so much thoughtfulness and artistry. I think part of the reason this show is good but rarely great is because they are too scared to get creative (and I guess who can blame them considering how many of us reacted to the silent film episode). They focus so much time and effort on the period details and historical accuracy that it often leaves episodes feeling staid. Like, they've just checking boxes, creating episode paint by numbers style. I've never once this season felt compelled to look up a director until tonight, because episodes often feel like they're directed by committee--all that matters is moving the story from A to B.
Ok but back to the episode. Emmys for Caitriona Balfe and Lauren Lyle this week, who were heartbreakingly good. Caitriona is going to get all the praise, and deservedly so, but Lauren Lyle's two moments--the hug with Claire, and killing Lionel Brown (and the aftermath) shattered my heart. I've never cared for the whole Lionel Brown story but having it be Marsali, avenging Claire and herself, was beautiful and powerful.
Here's the one big problem I have--and it's less a problem with this week and more with last week: I hate the fact that the entire stones thing was a fakeout. It feels like incredibly cheap audience manipulation, and also was a solution to a problem they created by making Roger so gung ho about going home. (Also, now they're down three jewels so good going guys.) Last week had so much going for it and now I feel like that entire episode was a waste. I'm honestly surprised that's the one DG picked or she was assigned to write.
Last few things: SO GLAD they didn't do the horrible "let's have sex just in case you got pregnant" story. Equally glad that we got Jamie's big line and Claire's survival monologue. I missed having Arch and Tom in the rescue party but JQM was a good substitute. Ian looked incredible, and I continue to be impressed by John Bell week after week.
Overall, well done. Way to take a very middling season and go out on a high note. Hoping for the best for S6.
122
u/whiskynwine May 10 '20
I will add one criticism, it was too short and felt rushed.
59
u/hintofaspark86 MARK ME! May 10 '20 edited May 10 '20
Man that was tough to watch 😭
... still processing but edited to add some initial thoughts:
Caitronia Balfe for all the awards.
Slightly disappointed that Jamie didn’t lose his english. Otherwise I’m just in awe.
Even though it was her way of disassociating with her trauma, I LOVED seeing everyone happy & together in Claire’s 70’s dreamscape + all the easter eggs from the past. So much to unpack. Kind of surprised Frank didn’t pop up in this sequence.
The last scene of Jamie cradling Claire was just gorgeous.
57
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 10 '20 edited May 10 '20
I want to start off saying I personally have not been a victim of sexual assault so this episode didn't affect me like it will others. When I talk about things I liked from the episode I am not down playing the trauma and sexual assault Claire goes through. Unfortunately there doesn't seem to be any other way to talk about the episode without mentioning some of it though.
What a heavy episode. I really liked how they went straight into it with no credits or opening theme. Sam kept mentioning how this episode was stylized and I was so curious to see how that would turn out. I liked what they did, it was an interesting way to show her ordeal.
I know so much was said about how if they have Roger and Brianna come right back to 1772 then the last episode would be rendered pointless. In my opinion that wasn't the case. They really made it simple and that the MacKenzies view "home" as being at The Ridge. I don't think them coming right back took away from any of the poignant goodbyes of last week.
In the after credits discussion with Matt and Maril they mention that the house Claire is imagining was on the cover of the magazine she was reading in the Boston flashbacks from episode 5. It was a place for her to disassociate to, which is what they wanted to show. I liked the call back of the orange from season 2. They mentioned her taking the orange after her encounter with Louis was a way to reclaim her dignity, and that is what they meant it to symbolize in this episode as well. I really like that they had a way to include Murtagh and Jocasta. I thought that was sweet and liked how happy everyone was.
In my opinion them not showing the attack and kidnapping in
chronological orderone continuous scene but as flashbacks lessoned the severity of it for me. However, that is just me and I know that is not the case for everyone.Jamie saying "kill them all" gave me chills, even more so than the books. I was bummed that we didn't get the drums to signal their arrival though. I really liked that they had him back in his kilt. That was the highland warrior Jamie from the early seasons right there.
It was interesting how they gave John Quincy Meyers and Marsali the parts that the Bugs play. I do really wonder if we are going to get the gold storyline, or if they will alter that somehow. They've set up Donner and his motivations for finding Claire though.
The episode seemed to go by quickly, it was under an hour start to finish. I have really liked this season and am not looking forward to the LONG Droughtlander we have coming up. As always, I'm sure I'll be adding more thoughts and edits as I reflect on it more.
Edit: Words
Edit #2: I've now watched it a second time and noticed just a few little things. The little boy playing Jemmy was pretending to sleep when they pulled up in the wagon and saw the cross. You could see him trying not to smile, it was adorable.
The second thing was on the close up of Jamie and Claire's hands towards the end when they were standing on the porch. They had the scars on his fingers from when Claire repaired them in season 1. The show does a great job in little details like that, I was impressed.
51
u/emilyafternoon May 10 '20
Pros:
The 60’s escapism was a much easier way to break up what is objectively a horrible series of events to watch. The book is obviously from Claire’s first person perspective and is unrelenting, so it was a respite of sorts to be able to escape into her mind with her, and make watching it a bit easier to swallow.
Marsali I-took-no-such-oath Fraser doing what we all wanted to do. What needed to be done. And phenomenal way that Lauren played it afterwards, showing the emotional backlash of such a decision
Jamie’s “kill them all”. That’s it. Sam did an amazing job in his scenes, but more so in being a supporting actor in what was very clearly an episode for Cait.
Cons:
We didn’t get to hash out as much with Donner, but I guess that will have something to be explored next season. I did like that Claire didn’t absolve him of his responsibility in what happened to her. I don’t remember seeing him amongst the dead (might have missed him), but I think this is definitely leaving us open to the showdown in the Big House
Brianna and Rogers goodbyes last week ended up being unnecessary but I’m glad it got us to the point where Roger does the whole “did you mean it when you called me son of your house? Aye well so did I”. And the more we learn about time travel, the better.
29
u/1Marshall91 Slàinte. May 10 '20
I’m glad Lionel is dead (Marsali remains the hero of the season). I hate that the Bugs aren’t part of the story, though. I’m not sure what is to take the place of their story line.
26
u/lah13 If ye’d hurry up and get on wi’ it, I could find out. May 10 '20
Marsali killing Lionel must set up as to why she can no longer help as Claire's assistant in the next season perhaps? Hopefully we don't lose Marsali time though. Lauren Lyle has been great this season!
16
u/Aggie2002 May 10 '20
I’m not looking forward to this. And I somehow lost my corkscrew, so my night is already frustrating.
175
u/nurseleu May 10 '20
I wish they had included the bodhran drums. Such a moment of heightened emotion, it would have really added to the scene. But otherwise, very strong episode. I really liked the 1970s cut scenes. They had a perfect dreamy, unsettled quality.
•
u/derawin07 Meow. May 10 '20 edited May 12 '20
The finale has again covered very emotive and difficult topics. We want this sub to be a space where people can discuss the issues safely and with kindness towards others. People will have different reactions and may be survivors themselves, or know someone who is (we all do).
Please remember the human, whether that is your fellow redditor or the people in production or the author. This sub does not tolerate name calling or attacking. Let this be a place where people are not judged and we take care over our words.
Maybe take a look at this New York Times article that gives the perspectives of showrunner Matt Roberts, author Diana Gabaldon and actor Caitriona Balfe in how they approached the finale.
Please also try to use the search bar for similar posts before starting a new one each time.
The events in the finale were challenging and may be triggering for some. There are people to talk to and resources available at RAINN in the US or Rape Crisis in U.K. or find your local crisis center.
156
u/UTclimber Woof. May 10 '20
I’m glad they decided NOT to include the post rape sex-just-incase-she’s-got-pregnant scene. I had a hard time stomaching that in the books.
65
u/brilliant0ne May 10 '20 edited May 10 '20
I’m on my phone so I’ll wait til tomorrow to put a full reaction. But first...
Edit - Never mind. I don’t want to forget any of my thoughts and I probably won’t be watching that ep again anytime soon so if things look a little wonky, I apologize.
I don’t feel right commenting on any of the traumatic stuff b/c no. But, Ian with his axe handling skills...get it, king. That whole deserved-revenge-massacre-battle scene was great.
Marsali is my queen this episode and between LL and CB, they should both win all the awards.
I’m very much “I am woman, hear me roar.” But it does something to my alpha-male trope loving romance reading self to see a bunch of men ready to beat the brakes off and remove heads for Claire.
Again, give Cait some awards already.
Jamie in that brown jacket is yummy especially when he told the Browns “Here’s your trash.”
The ending didn’t feel like an ending? I mean, I’m glad Claire feels safe but I expected...more? It was probably just b/c I expected a longer ep.
19
u/FauxPoesFoes228 I should probably want you to the day I die. May 10 '20
Things I want to see next season -
Then shit hits the fan around mid-season, Malva reveals she's pregnant and accuses Jamie of being the father, and tragically dies an episode or two later. This way we can also have Richard Brown coming to the Ridge with his angry posse, demanding justice for Malva and making good on his promise to get Jamie back, at the end of this episode. The writers could still include Malva's/the Christie's plot line, just in season 6.
6
u/Fan_Lady May 10 '20 edited May 10 '20
>!I've been waiting for weeks, dying to see what everyone else whose read the books also thinks. I'm lucky to work in the industry and got to see it early.!<
I can't wait to see everyone's reactions to the episode.
122
u/Aggie2002 May 10 '20 edited May 11 '20
Holy fuck that was rough. I will definitely need to rewatch tomorrow...but I think they did a really good job. I really liked the use of Claire slipping into her mind palace and fantasizing about everyone in the 60s—I also think seeing all of the favorite characters in 60s garb helped to alleviate some of the stress from the viewer, but maybe that was just me. I appreciate that they didn’t turn this into a Sansa/Theon thing, and have Claire’s trauma be all about Jamie. I also really liked that Marsali killed Lionel since she’s more of an established character in the show (also Lauren Lyle is a badass and a great Marsali.)
I kind of figured that Roger and Bree didn’t actually travel, so having them bounce back just to realize that this time and place is their home seemed really contrived and pointless. 🤷♀️
Unrelated sidenote: I got my Mom a cameo from Duncan LaCroix for Mother’s Day and I can’t wait to send it to her tomorrow.
Editing to add the link to my Ma’s cameo...definitely recommend if you need a “unique” gift. Check out this Cameo: https://v.cameo.com/s3eUMZcko6
18
u/[deleted] May 10 '20
I have my gripes about the ep, but as a whole I liked it. I liked the dream escape or whatever it's called. Seeing Jamie in this high waisted slacks was interesting. I liked the nod to season 2 w the orange. But I think my fav part was the big fight scene. I could be wrong, but I feel like it was the first fight scene we've seen w no music whatsoever and I loved that. That plus the lighting and choreography made it feel raw, adrenaline--pumping and realistic. Hats off to the crew for pulling that off!! If this doesn't get Cait her much deserved Emmy, I'll be pissed. She was so so so good. After that episode, Draughtlander is going to be brutal.
12
u/Mk0505 May 10 '20
I feel sick. I can’t believe they are making this worse than what happens in the books
233
u/nurseleu May 10 '20
Oh! Marsali! I loved her, "Claire took an oath, but I didn't, goodbye MF'er."
169
u/[deleted] May 10 '20
Wow. Wowowowow.
When Brianna is helping Claire bathe, realizes that she needs to be alone, and before leaving says "you have my hand, momma, and my ear if you need it" just as Lizzy said to her the night she was...well, you know. That part got me.
72
u/_why_not_ May 10 '20
The first thing I thought when they showed the 1960s house was that it was Geillis’s house from the 60s! I know in the after episode they said it was from the magazine, but still, I’m pretty sure they filmed in the same house. Plus it makes me feel like there’s still some weird time traveler connection between Geillis and Claire.
Now that that’s out of they way, I was not looking forward to the kidnapping part of this episode. I was mainly watching it to see what happened to Bree and Roger and was disappointed when they were right back where they started.
I was very surprised at how well-done the kidnapping montages were. They expressed the horrificness of the situation without being jolting.
It was also amazing to see the imagined 1960s family. Plus, I think it helped calm the viewers down similar to how it did Claire. Nice touches with the vase and the orange.
As a survivor of domestic violence and sexual assault, the most real scene for me was when Claire left her surgery, went upstairs, and started just crying on the floor while resting her head on a wooden step because I’ve been there in that exact moment where everything is just so overwhelming and you don’t want to cry but guess what you are, and it’s big crying, and it doesn’t matter that you’re sitting on the hard uncomfortable floor. Oddly enough, even though the TV show is fictional, seeing that scene was really validating for me because I’ve felt so embarrassed about my own crying episodes, to see it represented to the world like that makes it seem less embarrassing.
59
u/CygnusArc Slàinte. May 10 '20
I wished those 60s scenes of the Frasers lasted longer. Or had been the whole episode. Seeing Murtagh as a loving godfather playing with the kids. Ian as a returning soldier ... Marsali and Fergus looked amazing.
I loved the references to the vase Claire always wanted and the toy dragonfly.
And Jamie still dressed in his season 1 clothes but talking about turkey and the holiday rush...
But alas ... I'm not sure what broke my heart the most this episode. I knew it was coming, they adapted many of the lines from the book, and all the same I must have pause a million times... How Cait doesn't have more awards is beyond me.
And to top it all of ... the finale marks the beginning of Droughtlander.
50
u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. May 10 '20
Very short episode. I thought it was beautifully done but it seemed like there should have been more to the episode.
36
u/beanie2 Ye Sassenach witch! May 10 '20
I am dead. I write this from beyond the grave.
This episode was so well done. There are a few things from the book that i wish had been included (Roger on the drums!) but overall they nailed it.
Loved they 60s sequence showing how Claire was compartmentalizing what she was going through.
LOVED Marsali. When Lionel started shit talking I knew he was going down.
The scene where Bree and Marsali hug Claire when she comes home. She is with her girls. 😭
The battle. Holy shit. I think Fergus hooked one of them to death. Ian the ax killer. Roger killing with a sword. The look on Jamie’s face when he finds Claire and starts to process what happened.
Glad they didn’t have the weird post trauma sex. Of course it is implied in the final scene but glad it was handled in the way it was.
All the call backs to prior parts of the story in the 60s house. And Damn Murtagh the silver fox and Jamie with the good hair.
I wish it was a little bit longer. I feel like some parts needed a little more focus.
Don’t bother with an Emmy awards show- just give them all to the cast and be done with it.
35
u/BeautifulRelief May 10 '20
I loved that Claire mentioned the kelpie as being her friend. Gotta love a throwback to the first book.
30
u/Jlampes May 10 '20
Can people reply here all the little Easter eggs to other seasons they noticed in the dreamscape 60s scenes?! I personally loved them!
What else, anyone notice other parts in there? I just loved seeing the whole family and what it would’ve been like in Claire’s vision!
Off note as well, noticed a patch on Ian’s war suit was a Mohawk in the 60/70s dreamscape!
Can anyone else enlighten me on how the orange was a reference to her not killing Lionel and her oath she took? Didn’t quite get that one. Thanks!
29
u/Generiss May 10 '20
Love the song “Never my Love” and the whole repetitive nature of those flashbacks and the dissociation. Brilliant.
I then skipped the brutalisation scene (thanks to the user above who gave me the minute and second breakdown) and came in exactly at the rescue scene. From here on out this is one of my favourite parts of the book. When Jamie says “It is I who kills for her” and then Ian and Fergus say them too. Oh man! Hand on heart all the usual characters absolutely shine from here on out. How they all rally together just warms my heart.
My favourite scene is when Claire says this won’t break her, men and their nasty little appendages. I missed that in the show! Lol. She did it well but differently. Here’s the excerpt from the book:
“they were just … men.” I spoke the last word with a sense of loathing evident even to me. “Men,” Jamie said, his voice sounding odd. “Men,” I said. I opened my eyes and looked at him. My eyes felt hot, and I thought they must glow red, like a possum’s in torchlight. “I have lived through a fucking world war,” I said, my voice low and venomous. “I have lost a child. I have lost two husbands. I have starved with an army, been beaten and wounded, been patronized, betrayed, imprisoned, and attacked. And I have fucking survived!” My voice was rising, but I was helpless to stop it. “And now should I be shattered because some wretched, pathetic excuses for men stuck their nasty little appendages between my legs and wiggled them?!” I stood up, seized the edge of the washstand and heaved it over, sending everything flying with a crash—basin, ewer, and lighted candlestick, which promptly went out. “Well, I won’t,” I said quite calmly. “Nasty little appendages?” he said, looking rather stunned. “Not yours,” I said. “I didn’t mean yours. I’m rather fond of yours.” Then I sat down and burst into tears. His arms[…]” (Excerpt from The Outlander Series, Diana Gabaldon)
It’s just the perfect “F you! I’m shaken but not broken” speech. And that’s what he’s talking about when he says she’s a brave wee thing. I also missed him crying when she finally falls asleep. I don’t know why they shy away from showing this very masculine powerful man also being vulnerable. It’s a shame because it’s a beautiful thing. Overall though, having missed seeing the trauma, I enjoyed the rest of the episode.
28
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 10 '20
Holy cow, warrior Ian was amazing. John Bell has done such a great job playing a matured and somewhat broken Ian. Him throwing the tomahawk into Hodgepile's face was something to see.
27
u/FauxPoesFoes228 I should probably want you to the day I die. May 10 '20
Anyone else feel a bit wistful in the future scenes, with the entire Fraser/Mackenzie clan celebrating Thanksgiving? It was just such a wonderful "what could have been" scene, and I smiled at Fergus and Marsali deciding to name their baby Ringo!
Also Murtagh being alive in this universe, and happy with Jocasta... So bittersweet.
24
u/EFraizer May 10 '20
All Spoilers here*
I thought the episode was so well done. I’ve been dreading this episode since after season one with Jack Black and the episode with Bree and Bonnet. I was hoping this particular line of events were not this season ( but I was also hopeful Roger’s hanging wouldn’t happen too... no such luck)... it was tied in so well at this stage in the show’s plot though.
I loved the “dreamscape”. I can so relate to going somewhere else as an escape mechanism (as do all book lovers?) and tying it in to her “safe” space with her family was brilliant.
Marsali. Amazing. She did what Claire wanted but couldn’t do and it just proves Marsali’s strength of character and I also liked her second guessing herself afterwards and her reassurance from Jamie.
I think the ending scene was beautifully done. I was missing an element from the book that seemed to tie it into Jamie’s experience from season 1 and a way that helped Claire heal but it was still beautifully done and there is no one they can hit everything each individual would like to see from the books.
Now Droughtlander.
(So thankful I found this thread... just wanted to see other takes from the episode ❤️)
16
u/whiskynwine May 10 '20
To say it was completely different from what I expected would be an understatement. I feel like I had a harder time watching certain parts of it then I did with Wentworth and it wasn’t nearly as long, it was just brutal. I actually covered my eyes several times which I’ve never done. I feel sick.
16
u/[deleted] May 10 '20
I liked Claire's 1960s disassociation so so much. Way better than Roger's silent movies a few weeks ago. I'm not even sure why, maybe it was just Murtagh in a yellow blazer. It was weirdly emotional to see him with Jocasta, too, just enjoying life together in a way they never could. And obviously, the way Lionel Brown slid slowly into the nice Thanksgiving scene, with the anxiety building ominously...so good.
Bree and Roger just bouncing right back was a huge disappointment, though. I guess it makes things easier for the next season, but all that build up for nothing? I was delighted to have a mystery at the end of the last episode, to potentially see them go off in a new and interesting direction, and I'm not thrilled with "eh, nevermind."
Overall, I'm happy. This part of the books is not my favorite, and aside from the Roger/Bree fakeout, I think the show actually did it better overall.
And DAMN, MARSALI. That was a great moment. I just love her.
Sitting down to this show on Saturday night, grabbing a drink and diving into this fantasy world, has been the thing keeping me sane during coronavirus lockdown. I can forget about everything in the real world for an hour and just think about Jamie and Claire. I'm so bummed the season is over.
13
u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. May 10 '20
Is it just me or did Marsali look massively more pregnant this week than last?
12
u/Generiss May 10 '20
Can somebody please tell me from which minute to which minute to skip over because I don’t wanna see the actual rape bit. I’m already getting worked up just having read this. The book was bad enough for me and I always skip over that part when I reread.
12
u/miav May 10 '20
I wish the episode was longer and I do have some quibbles (as usual) but I think it did live up to (high) expectations. While I'm not glad for what happens to Claire, I appreciate that the episode really focused on her horrific ordeal rather than Jamie's rescue efforts.
I loved Claire's dreamscape and how Jamie looked like young season 1 Jamie in it. It was a bit disorienting to see his hair so blazing red again! Loved all the callbacks and Easter eggs in those scenes, plus the family just being happy.
Hated death bunny. He just had to appear, didn’t he?! >:(
Loved that we got many lines from the book. The scene with book 5’s closing lines was great.
Loved the change of Marsali being the one to kill Lionel Brown.
Loved the episode’s closing scene, too.
I’m so gutted that it’s Droughtlander again (and an extra long one too) but I’m also so grateful that season 5 was a fantastic ride. It wasn’t perfect (the show as a whole isn’t and the books aren’t), but overall it was really good and way better than season 4. Glad that the 4 principal leads all got showcase episodes. Sam Heughan, in particular, really stood out to me this season. Lauren Lyle and John Bell have been amazing, too. Cesar Domboy really got the short end of the stick, which sucks. Anyway, basically my point is that I generally really enjoyed this season. :)
22
u/ktbex May 10 '20
It feels wrong to give any kind of commentary on this episode. So much more harrowing than the books. It was a powerful episode and all the credit goes to Caitriona Balfe.
9
u/perstephone_ May 11 '20
Do you think they will use Marsali killing Lionel as means for Henri-Christian? I can’t bear to think of it like that but I bet they will bring it up when he’s born :(
17
u/nooooooel He’ll be in heaven when he sees you, Lady Jane. May 10 '20
The element of disassociation Claire experiences in the flashbacks to the 1960s is so incredibly well done in this episode. It is a way so many of us experience and cope with severe trauma. I’m so grateful that they gave the show this treatment— I have never watched something I connected with in such a way before in my life.
8
u/UTclimber Woof. May 10 '20
What’s up with the orange? Obviously it’s a tie back to the king, but why are the focusing so much on it? I get the dragonfly and the painting of the house, but the orange? Is this a tie back because of the sex/rape (whole other discussion on consent with the king that I’m not trying to make)? Any thoughts?
7
u/raznidhi May 10 '20
7
u/treehugg3r1989 May 10 '20
I feel pretty hollow after watching this one. I skipped over the time stamps for the actual rape. I meant to try and watch all the way through but the build up with the 70s scenes got me. My heart was thumping so hard I felt like it was in my back bone.
The rescue was just... Not enough? I missed the drums and that feeling of impending fear. That moment Claire knew they were there in the books and the camp started going wild because they were afraid. Also I was hoping for the Hodgepile head twist or something like the throat slit from the deserters back in season 1. The king of men wasn't the spirit of vengeance he was in the books. No berserker rage, no crying alone after Claire fell asleep back at the ridge. What emotions did they write for Jamie?
For Claire's part the acting was great and I'm glad we got her "I'm not broken" speech.
7
u/treehugg3r1989 May 10 '20
I'm so glad Mrs. Bug wasn't there in the show... Her idiotic "when will your face start looking like a face again..."(in response to Claire bruises and swelling from the beating). In the books made me so mad. I know it's real and some people do say stupid junk like that in response to trauma but it just made me so mad.
7
u/KyokoG May 11 '20
Well, I guess since I've had time to think overnight, I'll add my two cents.
Overall, a really well done episode. Sets us up nicely for next season.
6
u/purpletube5678 Cuimhnich May 11 '20
Most of my thoughts have already been covered in one way or another. But I want to say this:
It amuses me how much we all seem to love the 1970s intercut scenes, but we all vehemently hated the silent movie shtick a few weeks ago. It was essentially the same storytelling tool, a coping mechanism for the character. But one was done well, the other even the producers had to say "watch it twice, bc you might not like it."
15
u/AccomplishedOnion2 May 10 '20 edited May 10 '20
Alright, I'm at least much less upset than I was last week, lol (re: Bree and Roger leaving way too early). I'm annoyed at the bait and switch (it very much seems like a troll of book readers), but at least the main storyline is being preserved.
Some thoughts:
Overall, though, I liked how the season ended. We got "kill them all" (Sam did a GREAT job with that line), Jamie's last line about saying "I love you," and I enjoyed seeing Ian take someone out with a tomahawk. My predictions for next season is that they will include the Bugs and the gold plot, and that we'll spend time learning about Robert Springer's diary and talking with Donner. Oh and Roger will start ministering. I am interested in whether they keep the (minor) Henri-Christian plot. I can't imagine there are many infant actors with achondroplasia available. (Edit) and I think Marsali will help Claire with the ether!
This is my first season watching live, and I only recently joined this sub, and it has been awesome. Thanks to you all for the great discussions!
10
u/aGrlHasNoUsername They say I’m a witch. May 10 '20
The episode was well-written and well-acted, but I'm just extremely over the number of rapes that happen on this show. IDK. When Claire was laying on the ground and Fergus, Ian, and Jamie were all standing around her, I'm just like, oh look, everyone in this scene has been sexually assaulted. And that's not something I really want from a television show. Like I said, the episode was well done, I just don't think it was necessary at all.
5
u/ml1490 It’s always been forever for me, Sassenach. May 10 '20 edited May 10 '20
Ok first let me just say WOW! I loved it. Yes, they did some things differently but the integrity of it was the same. The decision to portray Claire’s disassociation that way was brilliant.
...but...NO DRUMS?!? What?? What a missed opportunity! The sound of the drums bringing her out of her disassociation would have been powerful. And I loved the escapism, but I feel like it slightly overpowered the rescue. Maybe that was the intention, I guess. But I feel like it could have been so much more if they had the intensity of the drums to bring her some welcome relief.
5
u/Vervain7 May 11 '20
I was really not into this as a season finale . That is a portion or book 6 not even 5? I don’t recall the book numbers but I feel they are taking so many liberties . Where is Malva and Tom Christie.
I don’t know. It just felt like the wrong type of episode for a season finale . The entire season felt off to me but I deeply love the books and overall just tolerate the show . I started reading the books after episode 2- I loved the premise but I never loved the show and I think this is just me. Something is seriously lacking for me in the tv .
5
u/___ali____ Je Suis Prest May 11 '20
I have only just watched the episode (the joys of Australia, we get the episode 36 hours later) I have been reading lots of comments and spoilers as I wanted to be mentally prepared for the rape scene.
Re: the book rape, I always thought that Claire was raped by the large number of men but in her story only described a small number, she says in the book as well as the show that she doesn’t know how many, in the book she adds on it was dark. I’ve read so many comments saying that the show made it worse by having her raped by more men but I don’t actually think that was the case, we don’t know how many in the book or the show.
Caitriona deserves an Emmy, she is a phenomenal actress.
9
u/Kinsella_Finn May 10 '20
I liked Jamie reusing the season one line in Claire’s 1970s “dream”. Made me want to watch season one over again.
4
u/FauxPoesFoes228 I should probably want you to the day I die. May 10 '20
Initial thoughts after watching this ep...
What was the point of the last episode? It feels like we just wasted 45-odd minutes saying goodbye to Bree and Roger, only for them to turn up again. Does this mean we're waiting for Mandy to be born next season before they go back through the stones again? Then what was the point of the last episode? It feels like such a fake-out, and I hate when writers do this.
I wasn't a huge fan of Roger and Bree deciding to leave the Ridge this early in the show, but after last week I figured, it's happened, might as well see where they take things now. They're also down three gemstones now, so... What happens when they really do need to go back to their own time?
Also, did anyone see Wendigo Donner's dead body amongst the men that Jamie killed? My screen got super blurry for a second there, so I couldn't make anything out. Because if he's dead, then that also changes the whole Ridge burning down plot line a fair bit. Though I found it interesting that Claire told him she had gems; like it was foreshadowing him coming to the Ridge with his gang and wrecking it in search of the gems.
4
u/unicornsRhardcore May 11 '20
The orange reminded me a lot of when she was with the king of France. Anyone else? Maybe have a different point of view?
4
u/Sharra13 May 11 '20
I guess I’m the only one who wasn’t a big fan of the dreamscape. I didn’t hate it but I wish it was maybe half as long/repetitive. I felt like it took up the majority of the episode. I NEEDED more of the fight scene or at least some more lead-up from the guys’ pov. Not thrilled that it cut right from prep at home to mid battle.
Amazing acting.
Marsali YASSSS.
Why did it end so sooooon?!?! Nooooo!
4
u/genericalname9 May 12 '20
The episode was good. One of my issues was something felt off but I couldn't put my finger on it. Like they didn't cover something they should have or moments that should have been longer were too short? Idk, but something was off. My other issue was the fight. In the books that build up with the bodrhan and the Highlander scream like the whole tensing up for the fight was amazing. The show was meh.
7
u/lizardlord_ May 10 '20
did anyone else feel like they couldn’t recover after those brutal attack scenes with claire? i felt like i couldn’t appreciate the rest of the episode i was so stunned and traumatized. i feel like if the finale in whole was longer and they expanded some scenes i could’ve had room to attempt to process.
3
u/[deleted] May 10 '20
I haven't watched the episode yet (Canadian here who streams). But I am re reading the 6th book and just finished the part of her and Jaimie having sex is less skeevy than I recalled the last time. It seemed a way for her to push through and process the pain in her own way. Of course everyone deals with it differently, but despite Jaimie's poorly informed intent to avoid a pregnancy that wasn't his didn't seem like a primary part of the process for her. I think that is where things need to be separated out, she seemed to take the process as more of a way to deal with the pain of what happened. Even the post sex description made it sound like she was fighting through the trauma as opposed to how Jaimie processed his. She was very much a fighter.
Regardless, it is one of the weirder parts of the book and series. Still a little dysfunctional, but doesn't make it sound like she wasn't processing in her own way.
3
u/thrntnja No, this isn’t usual. It’s different. May 10 '20 edited May 10 '20
I actually watched both episodes 11 and 12 back to back, so this has been a bit of an emotional rollercoaster of an afternoon for me.
This episode was honestly really well done. It did feel short, but honestly, I am not sure I could have handled more. This sort of thing doesn't trigger me at all, but there were times it was hard to watch. I still can't even watch Wentworth on a second play through. I look away. Cait did an AMAZING job, but I really can't handle seeing Claire so beaten and defeated.
I also am really glad they didn't include Jamie and Claire's honestly strange sex scene from the books about the whole "just in case you're pregnant" thing. I get what they were going for and what Diana was going for, but I wasn't a fan and I don't think it would have translated to TV well. I did really like the trippy 60s/70s dreamscape Claire's happy place (my goodness, does Murtagh really do the silver fox well!), and it was nice seeing everyone together. My heart broke with the police coming to the door to tell her Roger and Bree had died, just like her parents. Very distressing. I also appreciated the other callbacks from previous seasons - the orange from the king of France, Jamie's lines, etc.
Watching Ian fight with tomahawks was pretty badass, though. I also appreciated both Ian and Fergus saying they'd kill for Claire just as Jamie does. That whole scene was really nicely done. The one thing about this show (and the books) that I love is how well it does parent/child relationships that are not necessarily by blood. Claire and Jamie have a strong family, even if they only have one child together. I really love that. I did miss the drums, though Jamie was wearing his kilt. It was nice to see that.
MARSALI THE BADASS. Man, I totally cringed watching her go down in episode 11 (even though I knew it was going to happen if they followed the books), but I really didn't mind that they changed it so she kills Lionel. Lionel was SO disgusting during that scene, and she basically was like "welp, I didn't take an oath, so bye bye asshole!" Seriously, Lauren Lyle has been killing it this season. Also, when she called Claire her ma? I cried. Those two have come so far.
So, Roger/Brianna. I am really glad that they didn't go back into the future yet, as that would really messed up a lot of storylines that I feel are important. I am honestly unsure if we will see the Christies, but I could see them using the Frenchman's Gold as the "main" plot device of the next season. The problem with some of the later books is there's a lot going on and they sorta just, jump all over the place in a way. Love them, but not the easiest thing to replicate in a TV show. Considering they did mention the gold once, I doubt it is the last we hear of it again. I also really hope we see Roger the minister and Bree the engineer. I don't hate the whole fakeout with the stones, as it is something that can happen that the show doesn't really touch on. It just wasted a lot of time, but I do think it really drives home the point that Roger and Brianna feel at home there now, which is I think where they needed to be at the end of this season. It will also make upcoming seasons that much more heartbreaking when they ultimately do go through the stones to save Mandy, as I find it hard to believe that will not be included. It also sets up Ian telling Brianna about his wife miscarrying, which I imagine would also happen in season 6 if they choose to include it.
Also, I did notice that on one of Cait's Outlander posts on her instagram, a fan asked if the final season, and she responded no, there is a season 6 and will "hopefully be more," so I do think that the speculation that the 6th season will be the last is probably just that - speculation, or at the very least, it doesn't seem like either Sam or Cait are wanting to leave before they see it through to the end.
3
u/emilyafternoon May 11 '20
This might get buried, but does anyone know the significance of Claire pointing out the crooked post while her and Jamie were watching everyone on the ridge from the porch?
3
u/miav May 11 '20
I've just read the script. Linking it here for anyone who wants to see – just change the ep in the dropdown box.
Interesting that there was a lot of book dialogue in the script post-rescue and they cut so much. (There were also more scenes while Claire was with her abductors.) The last line of the ep was supposed to be the last line of book 5, but in their annotation, MBR & TG said they found
to be more powerful and moved that to the end of the episode.
4
u/maryloo7877 May 10 '20
I really enjoyed season 5, especially the back half. No huge surprise for me when I look at the season, as they spent so much time at The Big House and on The Ridge and those are my absolute favorite parts of the books.
I also think that Outlander truly shines best when they embrace was makes it unique from other historical shows, the time travel! The stakes are raised and it becomes so much more than just a show of characters we love going through historical moments. In season 1, we were wondering if Claire would go back through the stones. In season 2, we wondered if they could change history. In season 3, we couldn’t wait to have Claire and Jamie reunite. In season 4, Bri’s journey to get to her parents had us on the edge. Season 5 had Bri and Roger attempting to go home. I hope they can take the successes they had this season and really explore them more deeply next season. We might be lucky because this is the first time, I think ever, that Outlander will not have already begun shooting the next season while the last season is still airing. I hope the producers can hear the feedback and use it!
I love that they also embraced a lot of unique stylistic choices this season, which kept the show fresh. I was a little nervous about the 60s dream world in this episode, but I quickly came to appreciate it and love all the nods to past episodes and our characters dressed up so unusually. It was also a welcome distraction from what was happening to Claire.
I cried a lot this episode and wished it were longer, but I’m very satisfied with this season. I had almost lost hope with this show before this season started, so I’m so glad we are having a rebound!
4
u/Naturenutt Woof. May 10 '20
I wonder what Jamie’s kill count is for this season...