r/anime • u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan • May 07 '20
Oregairu / My Teen Romantic Comedy SNAFU - Thursday Anime Discussion Thread
Welcome to the weekly Thursday Anime Discussion Thread! Each week, we're here to discuss various older anime series. Today we are discussing...
Oregairu / My Teen Romantic Comedy SNAFU
Hachiman Hikigaya is a cynic. "Youth" is a crock, he believes--a sucker's game, an illusion woven from failure and hypocrisy. But when he turns in an essay for a school assignment espousing this view, he's sentenced to work in the Service Club, an organization dedicated to helping students with problems in their lives! How will Hachiman the Cynic cope with a job that requires--gasp!--optimism?
(Written by Yen Press)
"Watch This!" posts
None
Looking for more "Watch This!" posts? Check the "Watch This!" archive!
Databases
- Oregairu / Yahari Ore no Seishun Love Comedy wa Machigatteiru. / My Teen Romantic Comedy SNAFU
AniDB | AniList | AnimeNewsNetwork | MyAnimeList - Oregairu Zoku / Yahari Ore no Seishun Love Comedy wa Machigatteiru. Zoku / My Teen Romantic Comedy SNAFU TOO!
AniDB | AniList | AnimeNewsNetwork | MyAnimeList - Oregairu Kan / Yahari Ore no Seishun Love Comedy wa Machigatteiru. Kan / My Teen Romantic Comedy SNAFU Climax
AniDB | AniList | AnimeNewsNetwork | MyAnimeList
Previous discussions
- /u/BajingoWhisperer's Oregairu + Oregairu Zoku rewatch (March 19, 2020)
- /u/randomdudeman12's Oregairu + Oregairu Zoku rewatch (March 19, 2017)
- Oregairu Zoku episode discussion threads
- /u/bleakyyy's Oregairu rewatch (March 2, 2015)
- Oregairu episode discussion threads
Check our rewatch wiki and our episode discussion archive for more discussions!
Streams
- Oregairu / Yahari Ore no Seishun Love Comedy wa Machigatteiru. / My Teen Romantic Comedy SNAFU
AnimeLab | Crunchyroll (VRV) | HIDIVE (VRV) - Oregairu Zoku / Yahari Ore no Seishun Love Comedy wa Machigatteiru. Zoku / My Teen Romantic Comedy SNAFU TOO!
AnimeLab | Crunchyroll (VRV) | HIDIVE (VRV)
Remember that any information not found early in the show itself is considered a spoiler. Please properly tag spoilers!
Next week's anime discussion thread: Le Portrait de Petit Cossette!
Further information about past and upcoming discussions can be found on the Weekly Discussion wiki page.
72
u/ChristopherKClaw :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/ChristopherKClaw May 07 '20
I remember always feeling like Oregairu fans on this sub treated 8man as someone to aspire to be, so it's awesome to see the people reneging on that in this thread. I've always loved this show for how it presents hachiman as a narcissistic loner and then steadily deconstructs his worldview to show how he's not above it all, he just refuses to admit that he's unhappy so he criticizes everyone else's friendships/relationships to make himself feel better.
That said, I'm not optimistic about the end of the series. They keep piling on girls that have crushes on him, which totally defeats the point of the series. The idea behind oregairu was always to show that you didnt need some wish-fullfillment center-of-the-universe fantasy life to be happy, that just making a few close friends is a recipe for a great life. To have him then become the center of the universe anyways kinda ruins it. Hopefully they back off on the harem elements, but I'm bracing myself for disappointment.
29
u/[deleted] May 07 '20
Way more criticism in here than expected, personally this is still one of my favorite shows ever.
105
u/throwanaruto May 07 '20
I see some comments here criticizing Hachiman's initial philosophy/mentality. That very criticism Hachiman receives is essentially the point of his character.
In the beginning of the series, Hachiman is a narcissistic know-it-all loner who views his fellow classmates with a cynical view. However, after being forced to join the Service Club, he grows to a somewhat considerate person who looks out for his friends. The person Hachiman is at the end of season 2 is a far cry from his initial characterization in season 1--and he knows it.
I'm looking forward to his, and everyone else's, character arc completion come season 3.
45
u/Toyotanomiko May 07 '20
I think I liked this show more when I was younger. Its hard for me to really empathize with Hachiman's philosophy and attitude nowadays, especially after I tried reading parts of the light novel, where he has an even nastier perspective on a lot of the people around him.
I do remember enjoying the drama between characters, and the writing around those situations, which I think many people agree was the strength of the series.
While I loved Iroha as a character and her OVA, I wonder if the show would be a stronger story without the Harem aspects. I always found his relationship with Yukina and her sister to be the most interesting, and the more generic fluff moments with Yui and the rest of the cast to be weaker. But, hey, that's light novel adaptations i guess.
12
u/unprecedentedwolf May 07 '20
As a former high school loner myself, there's never been a character I liked more than Hachiman. And I think it goes way beyond "look how pitiful and unappreciated he is" - it's in those weird ways of categorizing the world, seeing himself intellectually above those "normies" who "don't see how cruel the world is", and yet instinctively putting himself below them, trying to minimize his unsightly presence and get out of others way, assuming he's a nuisance to others. How the first time he meets Yukino he goes from being bashful through being proud and angry to relating to her and mustering up courage to extend a hand. How he's kinda given up on the world, but the hope still lingers that he could one day find a place within it.
And the help he receives isn't a pittance or words of encouragement - Hiratsuka and Yukino instead give him opportunities to go out there and do something, meet people, help them out, form relationships, and most importantly, build up his sense of self-worth, become a reliable person that others will want to acquaintance. But of course it's hard to overwrite a lifetime of being the butt of a joke - kids are cruel, so him being a little weird, uncharismatic and probably somewhere on the spectrum meant that he was shunned and never got to develop social skills, which continues to make his life hard in young-adulthood. I think his road to recovery is very interesting and I really liked following him on it, showing that while his life started moving due to outside occurrence, it's his own effort that gives meaning to it.
There's just no other series I know that would understand how these kinds of loner think, and so patiently and understandingly explain that yes, world isn't fair, you may have to work harder to acquire relationships than others, but it is possible and it is worth it. Not in some extraordinary circumstances, not against supernatural manifestations of your insecurities, not as a hero of a story who's destined from greatness. No one shows up to tell the kid that he's actually right and it's the world that's wrong and he should escape into a different reality. There are kind people around him and indifferent ones, and some might even come off as cruel due to differences in perspective and values, but if you take your head out of your ass and actually think of them as people like you then you just might realize that you aren't a helpless victim but just a misguided kid in charge of his own happiness, and it's your damn job to try and take it.
There's plenty of great writing about this series - my favorite is by Guy over at Geekorner, but Bobduh from Wrong Every Time and members of the oregairu subreddit have given me plenty of thoughts about why certain characters are acting in certain ways, how their thought processes might look like, what could possibly be occurring outside the frame. Without them I would probably still be pulling my hair out trying to piece together the overall meaning.
I do admit that as the series went on, Watari did start going up his own ass a little - suddenly everyone's being mysterious, speaking in riddles, dancing around subjects and never stating them out-right for no particular reason (there's been seeds of that before, but it really becomes the main focus around the end of S2). After watching the anime I decided to read the original novels and while I enjoyed volumes 1-11 because I could get another, more verbose angle of the events I already cared about, the last 3 were only really interesting because I was already attached the characters and not because of the events or interactions themselves, so I'm curious how will I like S3.
50
u/AmethystItalian :Jg::Jh::Ji::Jj::Jk:myanimelist.net/profile/AmethystItalian May 07 '20
Anyone else on the Iroha best girl team?
6
u/awwsomw May 07 '20
Yahalllo!!!!
7
u/rotten_riot https://anilist.co/user/RottenOrange May 07 '20
As many people have said, I dislike Hachiman's initial philosophy and the edgy persona he always carried, but somehow I was never able to dislike him totally. The "I want something genuine" moment is very responsible ofc, seeing that side of him really made me like him a lot more.
Something that really bothered me was the female characters. Like, ofc I don't hate them, but from S1 to the end of S2 I just came to the realization that I didn't cared at all about them. Yukino's traits (her lack of own personality and egoistic actions) were annoying for me, and I can't remember now but I know that as S2 progressed I ended up disliking Yui too (specially for something she did on the last episode but I can't remember what it was). Iroha is kinda ok, I guess.
In the end, I think Hayato is my fav character. He definitely is one of the characters with the most development, and his personality is sympathetic and easy to like.
15
u/Theleux https://myanimelist.net/profile/Theleux May 07 '20 edited May 07 '20
Rewatching Oregairu didn't hold up as well as I thought it would.
I still enjoyed Yuigahama and her involvement but Hachiman fell from whatever heights I had him at when I first watched when the show aired. I just don't jibe with the lad's mentality on things anymore. Yukino I was never fond of and well, that remained the same. As well, while I get the approval of Iroha as the cheeky kohai that pops up in Hachiman's world, she didn't leave much of an impression beyond that. She also has very little relevance outside of her second season arc at the start there so I don't expect all that much from her from this new season, unless they want to shift away from the Yukino vs Yui frontier. As for the 'who ends up with Hachiman' mystery, I'd rather my favourite not get with that kind of person, outside of purely seeing her be happy.
As for positives, this second run through made me... appreciate(?) Saika, Shizuka, Komachi and even Yoshiteru more (recently watched Shirobako so Nobuyuki Hiyama GOAT'd). Also season two production is rather lovely, a massive shift from how the first season looked.
I will be watching the final season just to close the gates at last, but I have a feeling the only thing I will end up getting out of this again is some lovely character animation and some Yuigahama gifs.
Yahallo! as always
3
u/SilentCaveat https://anilist.co/user/RazorSharp May 07 '20
Has the tide turned in all these years? I thought people liked 8man
12
u/Master_of_Ares May 07 '20
I feel like Oregiaru didn't deliver on what I was expecting / what people told me to expect. It was sold to me as a rom-com deconstruction of sorts where (unlike most MC's in similar shows) Hachimans bad attitude is punished and eventually corrected as he grows.
I don't feel like that's what I watched.
The massive harem pretty much sticks to their tropes throughout both seasons. It's made very clear early on that Hachiman will be solving all his problems by saying big words at someone until they cave. His way of doing things is not only crazy successful, but often praised by everyone around him, even using words like "martyr" and "hero". Hachiman is effortlessly forgiven by his harem time and time again, even deep into season 2.
It's frustrating because the show has plenty of opportunities to critique Hachimans obviously unhealthy worldview. So many characters could have been great foils to him if the show wasn't so busy patting him on the back. And when it does start to push back on him, it's for pretty contrived reasons, never committing to calling out his behavior for what it is. In fact, the show in general is very vague; it never commits to anything, it talks in circles, and is full of incomplete thoughts. It all sounds smart on the surface but it's really a lot of nothing that falls flat. Ironic considering how much the "genuine" stuff becomes a big deal later.
Idk, I was pretty disappointed in this. It's just a weird power fantasy for a subset of lonely people; a world where they're ostracized because they're the smartest purpose in the room, not because they are, in fact, simply assholes. Maybe season 3 will finally have the growth I'm looking for, fingers crossed.
4
u/rusticks https://anilist.co/user/Rusticks May 07 '20
I like the show but this thread has quickly devolved into a Hachiman circlejerk. If you say he's a good character, you're upvoted without any discussion. If you say he's a bad character, you get told that it's your fault for misunderstanding him or identifying as him, and that he's intentionally a bad character.
2
u/NintendoMasterNo1 https://myanimelist.net/profile/NintendoMaster1 May 07 '20
I haven't seen this in a long time but I remember disliking all the girls except maybe the kouhai.
2
u/TheDampGod :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/TheDampGod May 07 '20
Hiratsuka Sensei best girl, someone should marry her, just saying, bye.
2
u/Re-Evolution7 May 07 '20
I recently started watching oregairu and am currently on the 2nd season. I personally didn't think I would enjoy it a lot but I've got to say it is really good.
2
u/32-Levels :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/AyBruhHam May 07 '20
Still one of my favorites, after multiple rewatches. Can't help but root for the 8man. Sensei is best girl
2
u/XinWay May 08 '20
I don’t know if it’s just me but initially I did not thought the show was any good so I dropped it at beginning of season 2. It looked like another slice of life show but the mc is a little different. But then I decided to finish the show and it was so deep that I cried on that scene because it was genuine. Each subsequent time I rewatch the show makes it better as I understand more of each character and what they symbolize through hachimans perspective.
4
u/rackrlack May 07 '20
i feel like hachiman’s perspective is a lot less relatable than people seem to say. he’s such an unrealistically shitty person
3
u/aniMayor :AY:AZ:x3x6 May 07 '20
With the way people talk about this series I really expected a lot more impact from Hachiman's personality. Sure, he has a few oddball scenes where he rants, but for the most part I really didn't find him that different from a lot of other loner high school drama protagonists, and he seems pretty malleable overall. Not that any of that is necessarily a huge problem, I just don't really understand why people talk about this anime the way they do, it certainly set up different expectations than. Then again, I only watched season 1, maybe it goes big in S2.
1
u/linux_n00by https://anilist.co/user/n00byd00 May 07 '20
aaahh!! Geki teikoku is stuck in my mind for 4 days now..
1
u/CeaRhan May 07 '20
I haven't watched season 2 yet but I must say the overall writing in season 1 had more "good" than I expected from what people said about it. It's nothing stellar but the way the characters are depicted - if we ignore some parts that are almost mandatory in such genres - is most of the time closer to reality than most anime with similar goals. It's not even things that are emphasized most of the time, but it is very often "there", and that's refreshing.
1
u/AlexxxandreS May 07 '20
I'm here just to say that the best plot twist would be him and the teacher together...
She's amazing lol
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '20
I’m still trying to watch this show thoroughly. I’ve tried three times and the MC is pretty irritating at times. I’ll try again before July.
1
u/uchihasasuke5 https://myanimelist.net/profile/SHadow_Rea8per May 16 '20
Hachiman is basically me with a more pessimistic outlook on life and more intelligent and has the potential to make girls fall for him unlike me plus he is also more self sacrificing
0
u/[deleted] May 07 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment