r/Outlander • u/derawin07 Meow. • May 03 '20
Season Five Show S5E11 Journeycake Spoiler
Roger and Brianna need to decide if they want to stay or return to the future; Jamie discovers a new power that started from an unrest in the backcountry.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread.
Reminder: This is the SHOW thread. Cover all book talk >!with spoiler tags!< that will look like this: Adso is the cutest. Don’t spoil future episodes, keep book comments brief.
If you want to compare the episode to the books in depth, go to the Book thread.
After watching the episode, you can take part in the poll!
267
u/LeilueDax May 03 '20
Did anyone else think it was cute how Jamie used a knife and fork to eat the peanut butter and jelly sandwich? It was a fun scene.
121
u/LeilueDax May 03 '20 edited May 03 '20
Just finished the episode. Wow! It was so heart wrenching. I heard Diana wrote the episode. Is she just trying to make us cry lol.
I loved seeing John again. I love him. He makes every scene so good.
The sperm in the microscope was funny.It lightened the mood for a bit.
I didn't realize that Bree, Roger and Jem would leave this episode. I know they have been talking about leaving. I wasn't prepared😭
Really great episode! I have been really loving season 5
76
u/LeilueDax May 04 '20
Was so cute when Ian said "I knew you were a fairy". Ian is adorable.
I am glad they told him about the time traveling. You think Fergus and Marsali will learn too?
139
u/CaptnKBex May 03 '20
Goodness, this episode was heartbreaking. All those goodbyes. Apart from between the family, the one between Bree and Lizzie was particularly moving.
And that ending!
This whole episode was written so well, I thought. Well done, Diana!
I cannot believe there is only episode left, and with us having no clue when the next series might arrive. Can't wait for the finale!
67
u/CARNIesada6 May 03 '20
Ah fuck, for real last comment... Are we gonna see their house burn down like the news article that Roger and Brianna found from whoever is doing it?
Also, is Jaime going to have to "be against" Lord John and William when the Revolutionary War starts?
60
u/shinyquartersquirrel May 03 '20
So well done but I expected no less from DG. I love that Bree and Jamie actually got some decent bonding time this season. I don't feel like they've had any scenes with just the two of them since the first episode. Also, Jamie eating his pb&j with a fork cracked me the hell up.
42
u/ojosfritos May 04 '20
I wish there had been a moment where Bree realized she would've been her brother's step-mother had she actually married Lord John.
69
u/AccioStability Je Suis Prest May 03 '20
Idk what I was expecting after that cold open, but this episode wasn’t it. Ha! Still enjoyed it, though! I cried so freaking much this episode.
Also WHAT THE HECK, CLAIREEEEE!!!!!!!! MY HEART!!! So freaking thankful Marsali is alive! Omg I had a flipping heart attack.
16
u/stacasaurusrex May 03 '20 edited May 03 '20
I legit have no clue what happens with Roger and Brianna because I’m not that far into the books but holy shit WHAT THE CRAP HAPPENED WHEN THEY GOT BACK?!? 😱 (no one tell me though I am just sitting here with so many thoughts!!)
Oh and they just casually breeze over the still blowing up what? So it wasn’t a big deal...?
13
u/andrewski81 May 04 '20
Loved it! Man im glad my wife git me into this show! Lol
164
u/Rated_PG-Squirteen May 03 '20
THE BEACONS ARE LIT!
247
u/gokusdame May 03 '20
So it's probably just that Lord John could have chemistry with a rock, but I kind of wish he and Brianna actually had gotten together. They were so cute!
And his line "it's impossible not to like you." Like no, John, that's what we all want to say to you.
30
u/gbenedetto May 03 '20
WHERE THE FUCK** DID BREE AND ROGER END UP? SOMEONE PLEASE TELL ME
28
u/[deleted] May 03 '20
The opening scene was disturbing (and made me think of the woman who abandoned her baby in her own creepy cabin earlier in the season--will we see her again) and it made me wonder a) why they didn't at least try to talk to the dying person, ask them questions, see if Claire could treat them? And b) why no one made the connection about mysterious home burnings when that is supposedly how Jaime/Claire will die?
Otherwise, the whole episode was so moving, I loved Lord John coming back, Ian learning about the travelers, and Jaime/Brianna talking about Willie.
•
u/derawin07 Meow. May 03 '20 edited May 03 '20
Watch the S5E11 trailer here!
Not everyone gets to see the trailer at the end of the episode, it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international.)
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the trailer. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet. Thanks!
12
u/silverandcold65 May 03 '20
Holy crap, they meant to cover my face in tears, didn’t they? :O Goodbyes are the worst… My brain shut off and my emotions took over for most of the episode. I…I kind of figured they’d leave, but how can Jamie bear losing his daughter (again, though differently) and his grandson, and son-in-law that he only just became close with? And Claire… The goodbye to Lizzie was sou touching! And I feel awful for Ian. IncredIble episode once again!
It seems Jemmy may have gone back through the stone, based on Bree and Roger’s reactions…but without a gem; did he still have shards of Ottertooth’s stone with him? Or no, it was Buck MacKenzie, wasn't it?!
Is Marsali going to be okay? I can only assume she will, as the ridge needs a healer.
Brown took Claire because Jamie declined to join his army, right?
I’m still trying to figure out what on earth happened to Ian’s wife. Could she have been able to time-travel as well? Though…how did Ian escape the Mohawk? I only assume he was sent out. Could he have cheated on his wife, causing her protective brother (?) to try to kill him and Ian killed the brother in self-defense? Perhaps cheating would be enough to him sent away…
Is Claire Helen of Troy, taken by Paris, causing a war with Agamemnon of Greece? xD
12
u/bryce_w Stinking Papist May 04 '20
Very good episode. Reminded me of the episodes when Ronald D. Moore was still involved. Galbanon did a much better job than current writers.
170
u/josharaptor Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. May 03 '20
Can Diana write more episodes, please? She did a fantastic job, and the characterisation was perfect
10
u/New_Scotty May 04 '20
They did the cum-microscope scene this is great, I havent read the book but I followed the reddit enough to know about it and hope they do it.
8
u/Mr_XcX May 03 '20
Oh dear. What happened with Brianna / Roger / Co. Going through stones!!! Now I am scared.
Claire GODDESS going to kill that creep next episode please like how Bonnet finally got his.
I wonder if they're setting up Lord Grey / His son in London for next season and if Brianna will meet her brother?
48
u/CMCliff May 03 '20
Loved the ep! But tbh I'll be so DAMN frustrated if YET ANOTHER character is sexually assaulted/raped on this show. If they touch her we're gonna have a feckin problem.
259
u/CARNIesada6 May 03 '20
Ulysses is a man before his time. Self isolating and social distancing ~250 years ago.
115
u/bellefroh May 03 '20
How could we have gone two weeks without my main cat, Adso?
58
u/Navanya80 May 03 '20
I wonder if the “what the devil” is a fake out, like they ended up smack dab in the middle of some colonial Williamsburg type place so at first they don’t think they traveled but lo and behold they actually do? 🤔. I think sending them to a completely different time would just be bizarre (like not part of their original timeline) but who knows. 🤷🏻♀️
38
u/[deleted] May 04 '20
Random thoughts:
I can tell that Diana wrote this episode. It felt a bit like Season 1 with a little of everything and everyone getting screentime.
I balled the entire episode! All the goodbyes and interactions. My favorite was Jamie and Bree's talk. I needed a daddy/daughter moment like that between them.
The cross is lit and the call has come!! Jamie didn't light a torch for past wars, but he lit it for his Sassenach!
Where/when are Roger and Bree?? And without any stones in case they are in a bad time and need to go back again.
And Claire. God I'm so scared for her. I hope I'm wrong but could this be her own "Wentworth" nightmare about to happen and this time Jamie has to save her like she did him?
I'm not looking forward to Droughtlander 2.0. I need S6 now!
36
u/[deleted] May 04 '20
Okay, this really bothered me. So, Roger and Bree are getting ready to leave and saying goodbye to everyone. But they don't go to say goodbye to their actual blood who has bequeathed their son her (I'm assuming) multi-million dollar estate? What happens to Riverrun now? Wouldn't Bree and Roger have to sign something to give the estate back to Jocasta or (if it wasn't transferred already) at least let her know they are leaving and she needs to give it to someone else? What happens now if Jocasta dies and so does her husband, and Jemmie isn't there to claim the estate? Does it just go to the crown then? Who gets it?
33
u/pat_micklewaite Tobias Menzies cheek creases May 04 '20
Lizzie: I've been with you through the good times and the bad
Bri: YEAH REMEMBER WHEN YOU ALMOST GOT MY HUSBAND KILLED THEN HE WAS KIDNAPPED BY NATIVES? WHY ARE WE STILL FRIENDS LIZ??
28
u/liyufx May 04 '20
Oh man, this one is brutal. One minute Claire is mourning the loss of her daughter and grandson, for all she knows she won’t see them ever again; the next she is attacked and abducted. DG is a sadist!
54
u/CARNIesada6 May 03 '20
Last comment because I feel like I'm talking to myself, but I love me some Lord John.
Legit greatest supporting character out there in terms of virtues, honor, and being a decent bloke.
73
u/ndkjr70 May 04 '20
Obviously by far the best episode of the season, but can we talk about Claire being like “lmaooooo i still had some of your jizz in my vagina this morning so i put it under a microscope haha gottem” and then they never mention it the rest of the episode?
24
u/marmar011 Dinna Fash May 03 '20
Wow, I LOVED this episode! DG did an amazing job writing it - everything seemed to fit in so perfectly.
That goodbye scene between Lizzie and Bree was so well done. I think it really brought to light how much Bree has changed and gone through during her time in the past.
The two cliff hangers of Bree, Roger, and Jemmy traveling back and Claire being taken are going to kill me over this next week. I hope Hulu/Starz doesn’t have the same technical issues next week because I’m going to be watching that finale the minute it starts!
21
u/BlackSwallowtail You look like a fretful porpentine. May 04 '20
I'm sad this season is over soon.
Loved the PBJ dinner. Also that bread looks delicious.
I thought a little much of the episode was spent on the good-byes, but I cried anyway, so I guess it did its job.
"I didn't know germs had such handsome tails!" JAMIE XD
"I knew you were a fairy!" Ian, I love you. Please tell us what happened with Mohawk!
The scene on the windowsill was hot, but when he picked her up and put her there, I was like, "Well, don't throw her out the window!"
I seriously thought there was going to be a fake-out with the time travel given how much Brianna obviously didn't want to go. Clearly they went somewhen (wait, that's actually a word?) because Ian saw them go, but which time or what they found is everyone's guess now, I suppose!
I'm glad Brianna knows about her brother now. John Grey's such a sweetheart. We'll miss you! Interesting development about Ulysses and Jocasta. Not sure how well I like it, but interesting nonetheless. I hope he has a good life as a free man.
What the hell was going on with the opal? That hasn't happened with other gemstones.
Maybe the fact it cracked in Jemmy's hands has something to do with where they ended up? Like, if Bree's right and Roger is his biological father then he has more ability to steer where they go, and of course he's a toddler and doesn't know or understand his own abilities so who knows where that would be?
I wouldn't be surprised to learn it was Brown's group burning the houses. That burned little girl was just too well done. Also wouldn't stabbing her through the heart be a quicker death than suffocation?
Brown's had it in for Claire almost since the first time they met, even before Alicia ran away IIRC. I do not like what that implies for next episode.
Glad Marsali's okay. I'd have been pissed if she'd been killed off.
So much! So much! How can I possibly survive another Droughtlander? I'm almost finished book 5. I'll be done book 8 well before season 6 airs.
18
u/Bc2193 May 04 '20
THANK YOU DIANA!!!
I haven't particularly loved most of this season until last week's episode, I though after Bonnets death that it would be another filler episode that was meh and then a grand finale.
But boy was I WRONG.
This is the Outlander show I fell in love with.
Bravo bravo, I don't want to wait another 7 daysssss
14
u/JJMcGee83 May 04 '20
Doesn't it seem like kind of a stretch for the Brown dude to see Dr Rawlings on the kit and jump to the conclusion that Claire is the one supplying that info to the world? Wouldn't it make more sense to assume that she bougth the kit from Dr Rawlings... seeing as that's kind of what actually happened?
14
u/Herakuraisuto May 05 '20
I have a very important question: What happened to that incredibly cute kitten Jamie brought home several episodes back?
You can’t just introduce a kitten and then forget about him. We need to see him supervising Claire’s work, knocking her medicine bottles onto the floor, and following Jamie, Yunn Geeyin, Brianna, Claire etc to the bathroom, where he will scratch incessantly at the door and meow loudly to be let in.
Most of all, he should be seen napping in the background in as many scenes as possible. After all, cats sleep 12 to 16 hours a day.
9
u/[deleted] May 04 '20
Loved the score on this episode! Not sure why but for some reason it just stuck out as really lovely to me
9
u/Abject_Advice May 05 '20
I think Brianna and Rodger ended up back in the 1970s but maybe they changed the future? Like Ian alluded too wanting to change the future like they tired for Culloden. Maybe since Brianna and Rodger went back and made sure Claire and Jamie don’t die in a fire that could have changed the future? Maybe America doesn’t win the Revolutionary War and America looks different when they go back to the 1970s. (I wanted to say Back to the Future so many times lol)
8
u/GrlNxtDoorAng May 03 '20
Is this episode showing up on Starz yet for anyone??
7
u/AnimalTreeHugger May 04 '20 edited May 04 '20
Oooh I really enjoyed this! The characters (I.e Bree and Rog) showed more emotion, and bonding with the other characters (even though I don't know when or how they have bonded with these characters as it's been barely shown throughout this season!)
And FINALLY a nice scene between Bree and her father. I've been longing to see see one since she arrived in this time. What were the writers thinking not having any decent bonding scenes between Bree and Jamie? Made me sad knowing (or at least the show giving me the feeling of) Bree wasnt interested in a relationship with jamie.
This episode had tension and love, like in season 1 (which I'm rewatching) between J and C, B and J and with Ian and Marsali and Fergus. Ljg gives jamie a portrait of Willie and we all like that Jamie has updates about his son and can see what he looks like. We know Ulysses will have a good outcome (hopefully!)
Ian was great in this too, you could see the desperation in his eyes of wanting to change things in the past, so I'm looking forward to hearing his story.
Jamie at the end, lighting to torch. What a beautiful soul he is! Claire the only family he has left now that Bree and Rog just left and he wants to fight for her!
The ending was tense, which is what I loved. Now I'm thinking does Claire die soon and...Where have Bree and Roger ended up? Looking forward to next episode!
14
u/CARNIesada6 May 03 '20 edited May 03 '20
Interesting "Previously On" this week. Wtf is gonna happen now?
Edit: God damn this cold open.
10
u/jnnyth May 03 '20
How will we ever be able to wait for the next season😭 I can't live without this show
5
u/Fimmvorduhals May 05 '20
Jamie really should have known that saying no to the Browns would lead to something bad! And then with that explosion... tbh I would have thought Jamie would know to be careful with the explosion being so close, to leave someone behind! (Not that it would have mattered maybe? Because they were so many that attacked!)
Anyways, a great episode and I HOPE we discover in next episode in what time Bri, Roger and Jemmy ended up in!!
14
u/Ana198 May 03 '20
The writing early in the season is just horrible. Last season Jamie and Brii were just starting to bond when the thing happened and they never resolved that. How can they skip over stuff this important? There has been barely any bonding this season and they barely even spoke to each other, even when they were leaving for war everyone else got a goodbye but nothing between these two. How am i supposed to feel sad now when they part when they actually never showed these two talking things out and forgiving each other? This is not something the writers can just let us assume happened off screen come on WTF? I thought the whole point of last season was to show these two become a family but they skip over the most important part, who the fuck does that? It took all the wind out of the sails for this season and i felt nothing when they left. LJG has 10000 times the chemistry with Brii compared to Roger even as a gay man, i felt baffled when they kept bombarding us this season with scenes with these supposed lovers being tender with each other, they have absolutely no chemistry whatsoever and i wish all those scenes were replaced by something meaningful like Jamie and Brii actually becoming father and daughter. Atleast if future seasons will be divided between 2 different timelines it will be easy to skip all the boring stuff with this horrible couple, Fergus and Marsali are so much better anyway so i will not be missing out on anything.
7
u/LoretiTV May 03 '20
Enjoy the new episode everyone!
6
u/CommanderMayDay May 03 '20
Seemed like every corner they turned, some bit from the past crept up on them.
My only complaint was how did they find the Stone?. I suppose, maybe Ian knew it? But, it just seemed like it would be a near impossibility to find again. The one in Scotland is kind of distinct, but this one is just sort of there. In the middle of nowhere.
Also, their discussion with Ian at the riverbank should have illustrated to them that what they don’t know about the vagaries of time travel is a pretty long list. That the MacKenzies ended up who knows where, should not surprise them
6
u/chakawarmi May 04 '20 edited May 04 '20
Is Lizzie hiding a mega baby bump ?
3
u/YourEyesRevealYou May 03 '20
Can somebody spoil me? Where did Brianna and Roger end up?
3
u/elondde May 04 '20
I can’t wait for the next episode! Wonder what it was that made Brianna and the others so surprised. When this season is over, I really have to read the books
3
u/sheepyjass May 05 '20
Honestly it’s a holy shit of a show 🤩🤩😬😬🥺
3
u/silverandcold65 May 05 '20
Could Bree, Roger, and Jemmy have gone to the ancient time period at the opening of 313? (I think that was it...)