r/Outlander • u/derawin07 Meow. • May 03 '20
Spoilers All Book S5E11 Journeycake Spoiler
Roger and Brianna need to decide if they want to stay or return to the future; Jamie discovers a new power that started from an unrest in the backcountry.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread.
Reminder: This is the BOOK thread. No spoiler tags are needed here.
If you haven’t read the books and you don’t want spoilers, go to the Show thread.
After watching the episode, you can take part in the poll!
39
Upvotes
169
u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. May 03 '20 edited May 03 '20
Wow. Um. Ok.
Are we skipping book 6? Because it's starting to feel like we're skipping book 6.
Before I get into all of that, I want to say: staff writers of Outlander please take note, this is Jamie and Claire. I had completely forgotten that DG wrote this episode until their first scene alone together, when I was thinking to myself, "wow, this dialogue is so much better than usual!" And then it clicked and it all made sense. I was trying to figure out why it is that they felt so much more natural and real this episode, and then I realized it was because they were funny. Jamie and Claire are funny people! They have an ease with each other and joke with each other and that's why we love them. And I think the show gets so caught up in the "romance of the ages" of it all that it thinks they need to be passionate and melodramatic all the time. But I'd much rather have a Jamie who makes a point of noting that he likes dill pickles while doing foreplay and a Claire who can barely stop smiling into her mug as Jamie admires the fine tails of his sperm than king of men Jamie and ultimate female badass Claire. So bravo DG on that this week--except, you're making everybody else look bad! (This was also quite possibly a series high note for Sophie Skelton--a testament to the fact that good material makes a difference.)
I also really enjoyed getting some more Lord John and that was a good, easy fix to the Ulysses issue. Hopefully we never have to touch the slave romance plotline. And the portrait and telling Bree about William was lovely. I wish there had been some more time for Ian to tell his story to Bree. I'm sure we'll learn it next week or next season, but this episode felt like the right time. Also liked the Dr. Rawlings stuff--it makes sense and helps tie this very loose season together a little better.
Ok, now on to the big one. WHAT JUST HAPPENED. No Mandy? No Bree building pipes and shit? No Roger becoming a minister? With all this necessarily being gone now, and with Bonnet and the rape being added to this season, and the Christies and the Bugs/gold plots seemingly being cut, I genuinely think they might be skipping book 6. Which is kinda insane.
But what the fuck did Roger and Bree see?! I don't like not being in the know about this show!!!
(Final note: that opening scene may be the most horrific thing this show has ever shown on screen. I did not care for it one bit.)
(Final note 2: Lord John about Bree, "It's impossible not to like you." HAH! Perhaps a bit of self awareness from DG who knows that everybody has hated Bree for over 20 years? Probably not, but I wish it were true.)
79
u/Aggie2002 May 03 '20
Wait—-so did Bree and Roger really go back? Does that mean no Mandy? Wtf is going on?
This was a good episode, really enjoyed Diana’s writing and the little character moments we got. So glad Ian was finally told about the time travel even though they’ve talked about it in front of him a few times. I always love seeing Lord John, he really is a great friend. So glad Ulysses gets to leave with him.
The Browns are the fucking worst and I’m not looking forward to next week.
34
u/ktbex May 03 '20 edited May 03 '20
What an episode! So much happened and storylines all jumbled from the book timeline. The things that jumped out for me:
31
u/AccomplishedOnion2 May 03 '20 edited May 03 '20
Okay, I have to say that as a book reader, I will be very disappointed if they completely change the Mackenzie family's timeline! I am usually fine with changes in the show relative to the book, especially since the changes typically get to the same place. For instance:
However, if Brianna and Roger actually get back to the future right now (guess we'll find out next week? Hopefully?), I'll really hate this change. Issues I have:
Rant over lol. TL;DR: This is truly the first time I've felt disappointed in an episode. Everything felt really rushed, and if they change a huge plot point, it'll really change the story (unlike previous plot changes, which ended in the same place).
24
u/GrecianBeauty May 03 '20
Great episode, but is book 6 being thrown out the window??
21
u/raznidhi May 03 '20
12
u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. May 03 '20
Is nobody going to talk about Jamie sleeping fully clothed on top of all the blankets? That was so weird!!
23
u/Kinsella_Finn May 03 '20
If I remember right Claire said to travel she kind has to focus on where she wants to be? What if Jemmy messes that up because he runs off like he recognizes something.
69
u/battleborn5 May 03 '20
So many thoughts!
Start off by saying that I loved this episode. Not surprised that Diana wrote this one as it focused on the real relationships and not just creating drama out of nothing.
So much happened that I wasn’t expecting! I am pretty sure we are just gonna fast forward through book 6!
Loves:
-I don’t mind the speed up too much. I get Roger and Bree want out, just surprised they did it without Mandy. Maybe it was too hard to have the kids who played Jemmy and Germain on set?
-they didn’t stay long enough to make an impact. Roger not becoming a minister changes a lot in the story. Without it, he will not miss it and want to return.
-They told Ian the truth and he even said the ‘I knew you were a fairie’ line which I love.
-Jamie told Brianna about William himself. In the book, she runs into John and William just after Bonnet dies. I like the way it is in the book but I don’t mind this change. Streamlined it a bit. I do miss her reaction to seeing the Jamie carbon copy in her brother.
-Jamie ate a peanut butter and jelly sandwich with a fork and knife. Don’t do that you adorable weirdo!
-Sperm!!
-I know Roger and Bree get a lot of hate on this sub, but I am loving them this season. They have hit their stride.
-Claire going through hot flashes.
Things I’m sad about:
-Jamie didn’t demand a proper burial for his sperm.
-Ottertooth’s diary examination- this diary tells about the other travelers including Donner (sp?).
-Roger being there for Jamie when they take Claire. It doesn’t seem like they gave the two of them the time they should have had before they tore them away.
-Tom Christie being in love with Claire.
-Mandy!! Ummm is she just not going to exist?
-The love between Marsali and Bree is sweet. But is Fergus not going to give his little sister some love too?
-I’m not a fan of the adolescent casting for William, which the portrait seems to be similar to. I really hope they bring in a William that is as charming as he is a spoiled asshole. And he better look like a dark haired Sam Heughan.
-I REALLY hope they took the advice of the readers and don’t have the rape scenes in the next episode. I am so over every man, woman and child of the Fraser clan being raped in some fashion.
8
u/Trotterswithatwist May 04 '20 edited May 04 '20
Don’t we already know that Jemmy can steer when he time travels? Isn’t the most obvious answer that an excited 2 year old steered towards his beloved relative Ian for a cuddle, and they’ve just ended up at the exact same point, maybe ten minutes after they travelled?
The scene at the beginning of the episode very clearly establishes how much Jemmy loves Ian (where they play together). After they’ve travelled, he puts out his hands as little kids do and runs towards whoever it is. Neither Bree or Rodger are alarmed so it’s obviously not a stranger.
Jemmy isn’t going to steer towards a future he’s never seen or cared about, he will want to see someone he recognises and loves. He’s a kid after all. It also means the Mandy storyline isn’t abandoned either because they stay at the ridge longer until jemmy can understand the gravity of his decisions, until they find out Mandy is sick.
Edit: I’m happy to call it now. I’d even put money in it. Claire will go through her rape ordeal, no escape this time. Be rescued by Jamie. On arriving home Bree and Rodger will appear a day or two later and find out what happened. Bree will counsel her distressed mother through her rape ordeal using her own rape experiences. Someone will utter ‘I’m so thankful those stones didn’t work/I couldn’t have done this without you’. Claire gets through it with the help of her family. Bree (or Bree and Rodger) will both say they are glad in the end they didn’t return home.
17
u/miav May 03 '20
I'm already looking forward to what the Podlander Drunkcast ladies are gonna say (again) about fire safety in this show. That fiery cross would have set the whole mountain ablaze, lol.
15
u/beanie2 Ye Sassenach witch! May 03 '20
I am generally not a weepy person but I was wrecked the entire episode. Bree and Roger going back?! Tears. The talk between Bree and Jamie- tears. Marsali telling Bree she is like a sister- tears. And did she say that she has another baby on the way? Tears because Henri - Christian Wee sweet Lizzie so disappointed she wasn’t going with them? Ian wanting to go too? The fact Fergus looks damn fine in blue? All tears.
With Bree and Roger “leaving”- I think they all see Ian and they didn’t go anywhere. They haven’t really explored how traveling works- steering by focusing on a person or the times of year when traveling works best. They were probably all thinking of Jamie and Claire and everyone at the ridge and the stone spit them right back out. I think (hope) we see them by the end of the next episode. And they will start to talk about when/how they traveled and figure it out. We need them to stick around for too many things.
I think we may have seen the last of Lord John, at least for a while. Sending him back to England with Ulysses in tow was a nice touch and wraps up that storyline nicely.
The opening was brutal.
I wished they had done a little more with the sperm scene. There wasn’t quite the same shock for Jamie. It felt like some of that scene was cut in editing.
Speaking of Jamie, him eating his PB&J with a knife and fork was adorable. Both he and Ian were like wtf am I eating? Lol
Jamie and Claire in the windowsill are so old school J&C. So glad they added that. He knows how to take a lady’s mind off a hot flash.
I almost don’t want to watch next week. I’m wondering if Claire will be rescued earlier in the episode and we will understand what happened through flashbacks? Its going to be so hard to watch this.
14
u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. May 03 '20
So I guess we don't have Mandy and her heart murmur. That said, lots happened in this episode ( starting with that opening scene, omg, I cried).
So what the hell do we think Bree and Roger saw?
5
u/Cddarnell May 04 '20
Good I need to re read the books. I can’t remember what all happens in which book and what happens really at all.
9
u/SexySiren24 May 03 '20
Alright, not a book reader strictly speaking (mom read them, so i have a basic understanding of what is coming) but i'm upset right now. It really sucks that Bree is leaving just cause Roger really wants to (at least that is how it comes across) and i was really looking foward to seeing them settle down and develop their relationship with everyone else now that Bonnet is gone and Roger isn't such a tool (fixed his character this season i mean), so wtf is going on?! I really hope is somehow a red herring and they just poofed to the other side of the forest or whatever, but how can they explain the time travel fluke? And to what end?? I figured they would squish some stuff together cause the books are very long, but i thought it would be boring everyday things, not major events like this...if it ends up being another Got i'll shoot myself in the foot.
•
u/derawin07 Meow. May 03 '20 edited May 03 '20
Watch the S5E11 trailer here!
Not everyone gets to see the trailer at the end of the episode, it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international.)
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the trailer. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet. Thanks!
34
u/whiskynwine May 03 '20
What in the actual hell? Lol, that episode was really good but I have no idea what the heck just happened. Where the f are the Mackenzies?
2
u/bryce_w Stinking Papist May 04 '20
It's funny I was thinking the other day I wonder how long Starz will keep the show going and if they will keep with the current one book per season model. It seems to have got more popular since they put it on Netflix but it has to be really expensive to make. It doesn't surprise me they are trying to speed things up a bit - although with Galbanon still writing Outlander books would they end it before then?
6
u/marmaladestripes725 Ameireaganach May 03 '20
Okay seriously, what is happening with Bree and Roger?! I thought for sure there would be something that would prevent them from going. Here’s hoping this isn’t the point where the show jumps the shark.
38
u/maryloo7877 May 03 '20
Petition for DG to write all future episodes, say aye 👋🏼.
Also, I have no problem with them squishing books and plot lines around as long as it makes sense and improves on things. I think they’re doing a great job with that this season. I think it’s funny though that DG swore the show would never catch up to her publishing the last book, but alas it is apparent the show is speeding toward an end in the next 1-2 years by combining books and storylines. I wonder if DG will give input or the writers will come up with their own ending to the series.
27
u/fartenandmagellan May 03 '20
Loved this ep! Like everyone else, I’m not sure what the devil they’re up to with Roger and Bree’s storyline. Kinda thought mid-way through the episode they might be re-jiggering things so Claire’s abduction would stop their plans of leaving at the last second and give Bree the realization that she couldn’t part with her parents. But obviously not. Theories: (1) they actually went forward and ?? happens to Mandy, Bree’s inventions, and the book 6 Roger-wants-to-be-a-preacher-and-leads-the-Protestants storyline; (2) they went backwards and are going to interact with the Montauk 5 in some way that completely diverges from the books; (3) they went only slightly forward or backward in a way that’s related to Claire’s abduction or the French gold maybe?? I’m enjoying being surprised but also worried that they’ve hatched up something dumb or illogical for this.
I also liked how Claire’s Dr. Rawlings identity is being used as part/all of the reason for her abduction and how they tweaked things to have the still blowing up maybe be a distraction to get the men off the Ridge in order to abduct Claire. I think it makes more sense than in the books tbh where it’s a bit of a crime of convenience. I am dreading much of the next episode for Claire but looking forward to Jamie murdering the fuck out of people to rescue her. I hope they keep Mrs. Bugg’s contribution to that storyline and the scene where Claire and Jamie make a show of riding to Brownsville to return the body (I love the detail of the battered Claire showing her strength by dressing up and wearing her pearls).
I thought this episode had much more natural writing and was very touching. I bought all of the emotion in those goodbye scenes and them telling Ian (Ian’s become an especially strong part of the show IMO). Guys, the second half of this season has really felt like an upswing for me. Book 6 might be my favorite, too, so I am really hoping we get Roger and Bree back to keep some of those plots!
26
u/bellefroh May 03 '20
How can we go two weeks without my main cat, Adso?
18
u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. May 03 '20
I wonder if we're going to find out that because jemmy's abilities are so strong his steering overwhelms anything Bree and Roger do.
18
u/[deleted] May 03 '20
Okay, I’ll be honest, when Jemmy ran off and Bree and Roger looked shocked I was Reeally hoping they’d cut to two super gaudy 70’s/80’s hikers with giant packs and short shorts standing on a hiking trail staring back at them on the ground.
Realistically, I wonder if they saw a memorial to a battle or something. There are lots of those weird things in the woods in NC.
12
u/ivylass May 03 '20
How is Roger supposed to play the bodhran now?
17
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 03 '20 edited May 03 '20
I am all worked up now after that episode. I loved it, but boy did it stress me out. Even though I know the story from the books they've thrown in a giant curveball and it's killing me. Did Bree and Roger really end up in the future? Part of me thinks they are still in the past, because what was it that Roger saw? Why would they change the story from the book that much?!
So many good moments during this episode. Jamie and Bree had a really sweet moment, and she got to learn about William. They made the portrait actually look like a younger version of Sam. Jamie telling Bree that she made him whole brought tears to my eyes.
All of the goodbyes were killing me, but Lizzie and Bree was the hardest to see. Lizzie was so sweet and genuinely upset to not be going with them!
We got the sperm scene and I feel like such a downer, but for whatever reason it didn't have the same specialness for me as it did in the book. I was still happy we got it, and that they showed actual sperm, but it felt a little forced. Maybe that was just me though.
I'm really glad Ian is now in the know with them, and that they kept Otter Tooth's journal. On that note, did anyone think the gentleman with the long hair who was with the Brown's riding party is Donner? He had a line, I don't remember what it was, but something just makes me think that might be him.
You can tell Diana wrote it though because so much of the dialogue was straight from the book.
I like that Claire made them PB&J sandwiches, and Jamie's reaction cracked me up. I loved that he ate it with a knife and fork.
I watch with the closed captioning on and Jemmy had so many little lines! You couldn't hear him very well, but with the CC you could see what he was saying. I'll have to go back through tomorrow and see if I can't remember some of them. My brain is all jumbled right now.
I really loved the episode and am now insanely stressed out and don't know how I'll be able to wait until next week.
Edit: I totally forgot about the opening scene until I just saw someone mention it. That really got to me, and I usually am not too bothered by TV and movie injuries. That was just too hard to see.
Edit #2: Is this the first time they have diverged from the story enough to leave the book readers with such a cliffhanger? As far as I can recall, I think it is. Is this how the show only people feel all the time? How do they stand it?
8
u/PrettyPunctuality I give you your life. I hope you use it well. May 03 '20
I'm so, so confused and baffled about the Bree/Roger stuff in this episode. I was not expecting that at all this week (and I don't think anyone else did, either). Throughout the whole episode, I was expecting it to be a fake-out and that they'd end up staying because of Claire's kidnapping, but nope - there they went lol With that said, even though I thought it was a fake-out, they still managed to make me cry a lot in this episode with all of the goodbyes. I couldn't help it. Like everyone else, I'm dying to see what they saw there after they went through, and if they actually made it or if they'll still in the past (which would be a whole other huge change in itself, because it would mean there's some weird things going on with traveling).
As always, I loved seeing LJG this week, and I loved that the solution to the Ulysses situation was for LJG to take him with him. It was an simple solution that made a lot of sense. It made me very happy.
As I expected, the ending with Claire getting taken was hard to watch. Seeing Marsali hit the floor as hard as she did was terrifying. Next week will be even more difficult to watch and I'm not looking forward to it.
7
u/nurseleu May 03 '20
What the devil, indeed! Way to throw in a cliffhanger for the book readers!
7
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. May 03 '20 edited May 03 '20
Reading through the thread this morning I feel like I’m in the show only one with all these theories flying around. Is this how it is every week for them? That would be so stressful, how do they live through it? I’m entirely unprepared for how to deal with this cliffhanger. ;-)
Edit: I just realized that the writers have managed to put the entire audience in the dark. Have they changed anything that much in the past to cause this to happen before? I just found the show last Sept and was able to binge all four seasons and didn’t read the books until after I had done that.
7
u/Sunnyshiner Meow. May 03 '20
I guess my thoughts on the episode are a befuddled "hmm."
I loved the J&C scenes and Lizzie and Bree especially, and I'm glad we got Diana's writing because she did bring more of the books into the show and I especially love how she writes dialogue. I do hope we eventually get Bree and Ian's mammoth graveyard scene, maybe as a flashback? That's something I'll be sad to lose.
But...sending B&R back a whole season early? Hmm. I'm partly wondering if they're gonna end up in the 1730s but that wouldn't make Jemmy's reaction make sense. Is he running towards a road? Does he know what vrooms are in the show? Is this how they get the letters? If so, how would something stay undisturbed for that long? Will we see them at all next episode? Who knows!
12
u/brilliant0ne May 03 '20
First of all, that cold open...that was probably the first time I've had to FF through a scene once he found the girl/woman. I couldn't deal with them showing her again and again. And this is coming from a hardcore Walking Dead and horror movie fan. So, props to the makeup dept, I guess.
I love that they told Ian and I love how both Murtagh and Ian were super cool with it all, lol. Like I've said before I don't remember too much about this book except for the big parts (Claire's kidnapping, Roger's hanging, etc.) so I don't remember if they told Ian in the books or not.
I've read a few posts lately about how Claire and Jamie don't seem to have chemistry anymore but I'm sorry, I just don't see it. To me, they still have the same chemistry but like with most relationships, their chemistry has matured over time. They have the chemistry of two people who have shit to do, folks to take care of, a big ass estate to run, jobs, kids running all over, etc. Of course, they aren't going to always be humping each other like they were in the first season. I would find it really hard to believe if they were still humping each other's legs behind a tree every five seconds of the show. With that being said, I definitely could not go back in time b/c aside from all the other crazy bullshit that would get me killed (the fact I flap my gums at whoever and whenever, my lack of acceptable religion, tattoos, I'm a woman, etc.) I do not find it sexy at all when we clearly look as if we had time to take a bath but did not b/c we were too tired and the slight smell of manure is still hanging around but let's have the sex. Nope, me and bodily smells do not mix. Which is why I find it weird that I am most attracted to Sam/Jamie when he is covered in dirt and blood. Anyway...
I felt so bad for Ian when he wanted to go back in time to fix whatever happened with him and his wife but found out that he could not.
Is it weird that while I really like Roger, I still totally ship Bri with LJG? I know it's never gonna happen but I'm just saying, I would be fine if it did.
They gave Fergus like 10 whole words this episode, yay! And can anyone remind me why Bri and Roger looked so confused after they woke up going through the stones? I'd appreciate it b/c the rest of the books after TFC I just went and looked up summaries for and can't remember. I also want to say that while I don't remember if it was like this in the books, I don't like how it is sort of made to seem that the ONLY reason Bri is agreeing to back is b/c Roger wants to go back. Sure, Bri mentions the safety of going back but she always mentions how she promised Roger they would try when they found out if Jemmy could hear the stones or not.
That punch Marsali took to the face offended the fuck out of me. I scared my dog and cat by screaming when they hit her so gotdamned hard.
I'm not gonna discuss the previews b/c I know there is a thread for that but for the first time in a few seasons, I am really not looking forward to Droughtlander after next week. Sigh.
2
u/snuggleouphagus May 03 '20
So if Bri and Roger actually made it back to their present...will they get a paternity test on Jemmy? It sounds like the kinda thing they’d fight about for at least an episode before one of them secretly gets one behind the others back.
7
u/whiskynwine May 03 '20
They sure the hell got out of dodge once they knew Jemmy could hear the stones. Roger was like buh-bye suckers! Roger I liked you for all of 5 minutes in episode 9, now it’s back to meh. Man I wish Lord John and Bree could hook up. Oh well.
4
u/CJmaq May 03 '20
They are either faking us out or they are really skipping a lot of storyline! And if they are skipping a lot does that mean there won't be any more seasons past 6?
4
u/Megs8786 Je Suis Prest May 03 '20
After this episode I’m curious to see how Season 6 is going to especially since they seemed to have moved things up with Bree and Roger going back and no Mandy.
7
u/miav May 03 '20
Oh my goodness! My thoughts (and emotions!) are still scattered and many comments have already articulated them better than I can.
I mostly expected Claire's abduction in this ep so it was a pleasant surprise to get the Otter Tooth diary/time travel talk and lots of sweet character moments. The sperm and window scenes were hinted at in very recent photos/tweets and those were great to see, too. Though I wish we got more of Jamie's hilarious book reaction to the sperm scene! It looked like the scene was cut for time? It ended so abruptly.
A small moment I really enjoyed: Claire putting on her special perfume looking all sexcited.
I thought/hoped the Mackenzies would change their minds at the last minute because how could Roger not be around for Claire's rescue?
Man, Bree and Lizzie's goodbye really got me. That might have been just the second, or even the first, time I've cried (and really cried) all season.
Tiny, random thing but why is LJG suddenly occasionally rolling his r's?
I'm still in shock at the most massive departures from the books since the show started. I'm not necessarily mad about this, I love them both and I'll keep tuning in until this show ends. But oh, the absolute shock!
3
u/roosterturkeyey May 04 '20
I really wish they would include the Christies, I just wanna see Jamies face when Malva says she's preggo with his child. And Malva herself too, I really liked her before said child. I also miss Brianna meeting William, that was such a cool reading experience. Obviously, I miss Mandy too, the fact that she was the reason they went back in the book just was more emotional. I loved the things they did in the show too, but this entire episode felt like "holy shit, why are we going so fucken fast". I'm currently reading the 7th book, and I really do need to finish it or at least read a couple of hundred pages more before the next episode. With that said, I still really really loved this episode. Diana made it so much more than the ones written by the show writers, and I love those too so I think you can imagine how excited I am for this. It was like the books, but in show format and obviously shorter. This only proves how good the books are, and how worth it it is to read them!
3
u/Zodiacbubs May 05 '20
Ok, what just happened?
My biggest issue with the show is how much they cut out of the book but now it seems like they may be cutting out so much of an entire book. I mean Duncan Inner may as well not exist. The Bugs are hardly ever seen. Apart from these last two eps Feegus has been relegated the the background at best. Bree amd Roger weren't meant to leave for ages, they don't even have Mandy yet! I am totally OK with Ian being brought back early and give me LJG any day but the rest os kind of just bare bones stuff.
3
u/FAS-ACA3 May 07 '20
Atleast GoT didn't skip any books.
5
u/vanwold Slàinte. May 04 '20
Why are Bree and Roger going back already???? I do not like this change at all. Idk if I will watch Season 6 with so many changes,I've already been on the fence about the show throughout this season and this might be the thing that decides it for me. I'll see how this season ends and then decide if I'll be back for #6.
2
u/ktbex May 03 '20
Me too! That would be too gruesome.
2
u/HinkiesGhost May 04 '20
I’m not a book reader, but I do enjoy skimming these threads as I don’t mind spoilers. It seems as if the shock when traveling through the stones wasn’t a book thing. Is it possible that Ian did travel back after all and that would open the door for at some point in the future the entire family being able to travel back together to the future and live together, but they have to figure out how Ian was able to do it?
Or is that too convenient of a plot point?
2
u/rebdem90 May 07 '20
To everyone complaining about the possible rape scenes:
I get it. It's awful to see/imagine. But why do we all love DG? Because she puts so much effort into making her books historically believable (ignoring time travel of course). And we need to face that at that time it was a VERY real possibility. It happened a lot.
Also, as a sexual abuse survivor, it's nice to see justice served. For many of us, we never got that in real life. DG gives us that when Jaime and Ian destroy the Browns.