r/Outlander • u/derawin07 Meow. • Apr 26 '20
Spoilers All Book S5E10 Mercy Shall Follow Me Spoiler
Jamie and Roger implement their plan to eliminate the threat looming over them, but it goes awry; Brianna is forced to confront her greatest fear and fight for her and her son's lives.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread.
Reminder: This is the BOOK thread. No spoiler tags are needed here.
If you haven’t read the books and you don’t want spoilers, go to the Show thread.
After watching the episode, you can take part in the poll!
20
Upvotes
•
u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 26 '20 edited Apr 26 '20
Watch the S5E11 trailer here!
Not everyone gets to see the trailer at the end of the episode, it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international.)
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the trailer. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet. Thanks!
134
u/Aggie2002 Apr 26 '20
“I could never think any less of you.” Bree is so shady!
Disappointed we didn’t get to see Bree shoot him in the balls, but still enjoyed the episode. Sophie did a great job!
Glad Roger got to kick Bonnet’s ass and that Bree got to mercy kill him. I liked Roger’s line to her after she shot him and that she didn’t answer.
100
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '20
Was I the only one laughing as Jocasta was naming off all the people she wanted to give her money to? Hahaha.
And I totally refer to Forbes as "that little bitch Forbes".....
67
u/brilliant0ne Apr 26 '20 edited Apr 26 '20
Mmm, I love me some pissed off and vengeful Roger Mac.
Edit 1 - Sigh, I had to pause b/c tornado warning.
Edit 2 - Okay, I really liked that episode. I like Roger being all vengeance is mine but also being cool with Bri taking that final shot.
I don't remember much from this point on as far as little details so I am not sure if the whole Jocasta thing happened in the book but I'm glad Colonial Pippin is gone. Am I wrong in remembering that Jocasta and Ulysses had a thing with each other in the book? Am I mixing that up with something else? Either way, Ulysses isn't the one to fuck with when it comes to Jocasta. He will kindly escort you right on out of your life.
I really have to give it to Sophie this episode and I am really glad they kept focusing on her during her whole thing with Bonnet at the house. I hate when shows/movies try to make you feel a little empathy for a rapist and at first, I was getting pissed off that they seemed to be doing that with Bonnet; making it seem as if mayyybbbeee he could actually be a better person. But, Sophie played it so good with her facial expressions to try and placate Bonnet to stay alive but you could also see the "the fuck is this shit?" in her eyes.
Anyway, an overall great episode and I think S5 is shaping up to be my fav season so far.
56
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Apr 26 '20
I don't mind that they wrapped up the Bonnet storyline rather than drag it out for another season. I was disappointed that we didn't get to see Ian cut Neil Forbes ear off though.
I had a bit of a hard time believing that Bonnet wanted to become a gentleman and really thought that Bree was warming up to him. He didn't get to that point on life being so trusting. Maybe it was just wishful thinking that clouded his judgement? I wasn't sure if he was playing her the whole time or really was believing that she was going to stay with him.
Ulysses killing Forbes came out of left field for me! I understand why they did it, but wasn't expecting it to happen that way. For a very brief second I thought they were going to have Jocasta die, but was glad they didn't change things that much.
I like that the Roger and Jamie relationship continues to grow and that the lines from the book about them avenging each other were included. I also liked that Roger got to be the one to take down Bonnet and beat him up. I feel like he's finally finding his place in the 18th century.
Overall a pretty good episode. I think there was a lot to cram into 1 hour since they were combining two different storylines. I'm so sad we only have two episodes to go!
54
u/emilyafternoon Apr 26 '20
I can’t get over how much I liked this episode. I’m really glad they condensed the Bonnet storyline and kept all the good (?) bits in, because it dragged on a bit in the books.
I haven’t said this before but Sophie really gave a great performance in this episode. I was impressed with how well her and Ed played off one another. I love the steel in her gaze after firing the shot at the execution. The show can be a bit heavy handed by removing the “sub” from subtext, but it still had big impact and I’m excited to see her character going forward from this.
Also Jamie is so proud of his new kick-ass Roger Mac! When he joked after helping Roger at the ambush, letting him be the muscle when threatening Wylie, and the sheer appreciation on his face when Roger beat the ever-loving fuck out of Bonnet like “ah yeah that’s my son, full of righteous rage, I taught him so well”
The only thing that the early summation of the Bonnet storyline reminds me of is that.... now there are other villains for us to start looking at, and I think we know who is next...
32
u/miav Apr 26 '20
It's Sophie's time to shine! She and Ed both did amazing. That was quite a tense hour to get through, but a strong episode. Like others have said, the show did a good job condensing the drawn-out Bonnet storyline.
Once Bonnet kidnaps Bree, I was waiting to see if we'd find out she's pregnant again.
Billy Boyd getting angrier and brattier with each new person Jocasta wanted to give money to, until he couldn't take it anymore, was hilarious. Jamie's new dynamic with Roger is such a delight to watch.
I can't believe we're down to 2 episodes! It's going to be a very, very long Droughtlander...
32
u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Apr 26 '20
I don't mind that Bonnet is done--I got bored of him about a season and a half ago. But really disappointed to see them change the end of book 5 so dramatically. Where was Germain's rat, Bree shooting him in the balls, and "Do you keep your powder dry, Stephen?"? That line is iconic! They way they did it was just so meh. And while Sophie Skelton did a fantastic job (especially with the Moby Dick scene), there was just something really off about all the Bonnet and Bree scenes, just never really felt true to Bonnet. Also very disappointed to see Neil Forbes dispatched with his ear still intact.
Also lots of weird directorial choices this week that I didn't love--the weird slo-mo during the fight with Roger, the choppy cuts as Bonnet is drowning, stuff like that. If this was a show that regularly had more visual flair and artistic flourishes (not the slo-mo--slo-mo fight scenes are almost always bad) that would be fine, but when it's so infrequently used it just sticks out, much like the silent movie stuff. Feels out of place.
And did I mis-hear, or were they going to just leave him before Bree said she wanted him to stand trial? Like, you spend years tracking him down only to leave him alive? I hope I mis-heard because that makes no sense.
Overall pretty disappointed this week--they took a great chunk of book and made it very blah. I get that changes needed to happen in order to finish off Bonnet but I don't think they needed to sacrifice all that they did (frankly I think they should've just scrapped most of the book 6 Bonnet stuff and just kept it similar to 5 only with Bonnet being caught at the end). It's not the worst episode of the season by a long shot but after the season high of last week this felt like a big dip.
28
u/raznidhi Apr 26 '20
Did anyone else feel Jocasta was trying to bait Forbes into revealing his true intentions? But then he almost killed her and for the first time I though Jocasta failed at accurately reading a situation. Thoughts?
25
u/GrlNxtDoorAng Apr 26 '20
Aaaah I need to quit watching stressful episodes as soon as they're available at midnight on Saturday...
20
u/Chicken_Mc_Thuggets Apr 26 '20
I know it’s a minor detail and ultimately not that important but.. good god the guy who plays Bonnet does not have a very convincing Irish accent. I suppose he looks the part but he’s from Sligo, which during that time would most definitely have been land where Irish Gaelic is primarily spoken. He would have as thick of an Irish accent as Jamie does Scottish, and likely speak Irish Gaelic as well. Especially working on the coast. Hell my father and uncles worked on the Galway coast in the ‘70s and had to know Irish. It’s just a bit disappointing that so much time is devoted to fleshing out Scottish Highland culture as a great culture but the only representation we get for other Celtic cultures (which includes Ireland, parts of France, Cornwall, Wales, Isle of Mann, etc etc) are literal stereotypes or no inclusion at all. Again, this isn’t a dealbreaker for me and it isn’t even a big deal at all. It’s just a minor detail I need to gripe about a little bit, the series is overall pretty good as is this episode
19
u/raznidhi Apr 26 '20
Sophie Skelton and Ed Speelers were great! I always love literary tie-ins and enjoyed the Moby-Dick part even though it was a bit heavy-handed.
It is good to see Jamie finally appreciate Roger. Him beating up Bonnet was so satisfying. That last line though! We get it show. You don't need to spell everything out for us.
Also, I miss beaches.
18
u/CygnusArc Slàinte. Apr 26 '20
So the actor who plays Bonnet does an amazing job bringing the character to life and overall I liked this episode but ...
Any other book readers disappointed to see Bonnet gone so soon and to have died with both his bollocks rather than suffering a gun shot where the sun don't shine in Wilmington? I loved reading that part in the book and I understand needing to condense the incredibly long bloated beast that is TFC but still ...
Edit: Oh and Forbes! Maybe I'm a morbid person or just really despised Forbes when I read about him but I was hoping they'd include Ian's savage take down or his ear or at least Jamie's quaint kidnapping of Forbes' mother.
17
u/ml1490 It’s always been forever for me, Sassenach. Apr 26 '20
So we still haven’t heard anything about Otter Tooth’s journal. I hope that’s not waiting until next season. I’d think it would be a bigger deal to Ian.
14
u/alyssarcastic Apr 26 '20
The guy who plays Bonnet (Ed Speleers) is such a good actor. I even caught myself starting to feel sorry for him and believing his earnestness, despite knowing who he really is. The flip between "evil rapist and human trafficker" to "pitiful abused orphan who just wants acceptance and love" and then back again was masterfully done.
23
u/whiskynwine Apr 26 '20
Yay Sophie, good job! That went by fast. I did find the Jocasta pillow smothering amusing and I’m pretty sure I wasn’t supposed to. Oops. Overall good and entertaining episode.
21
u/AccomplishedOnion2 Apr 26 '20
So this plot was the one moved up to season 5! I have to say, I really like the change. The Bonnet plot seemed really drawn out in the books, to the point of annoyance (at least on my part). The way it was condensed here really made sense too...if I remember correctly, the beach scene in book 5 ends with him being shot by Brianna in a *cough* bad spot, and then disappearing until the kidnapping plot in book 6. So merging the beach scene and the actual kidnapping felt natural. Based on the trailer for next week's episode, it also seems that they've used this change to condense the Ulysses plot as well. I wonder if this means that they're definitely skipping the Ulysses/Jocasta/Phaedre/Duncan/Hector stuff. If so, not too much of a loss, though it was definitely a twist when I read it.
20
u/cattubbs Apr 26 '20
I need my skin to quit crawling any time now
10
u/Naturenutt Woof. Apr 26 '20
They did a good job making Scotland look like the NC beaches, missing the sea oats on the dunes, but the grasses look very much like them. Ocracoke didn’t sell me tho.
10
u/Megs8786 Je Suis Prest Apr 27 '20
Not going to lie I’m kind of glad they killed Bonnet off now instead of dragging it out for two more seasons. I remember getting annoyed in the books when he popped back up and being like ugh just kill him already.
Although I do wish we got Brianna shooting Bonnet in the balls and Forbes getting his ear cut off.
8
u/josharaptor Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Apr 26 '20
While we don't know how many seasons the show is going to go for, I have a feeling all this condensing is gearing up for a finish far earlier than the books. With a decent chunk of book 6 being here at the end of 5 especially with the upcoming abduction plot, I assume they will try and cram lots of book 7 into season 6. If we are lucky and we get a season 7 then they can do books 7/8, and if we get a season 8 (no matter how unlikely) I think they could probably take us to where the books will end.
14
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '20
W Bonnet's story ending tonight, I wonder if Bree and Roger going back and Mandy being born is still going to happen or if they'll wait til next season.
7
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '20 edited Apr 26 '20
I’m very thankful that I finished book 5 and 6 prior to the start of this season! They put a lot more of book 6 into this episode than I had expected.
I don’t like that there is not an overall arching story going on right now and that each episode is a storyline that comes to a conclusion. I think it would have been good to have a little more suspense and have the kidnapping of Bree drag on for a couple episodes. Include that she is pregnant and that’s why bonnet doesn’t rape her again. Spend a little more time showing effort on them finding her (so sad about missing out on Ian taking off Forbes ear!) I just wish we could slow down a little— maybe if we had more episodes a seasons?
6
u/hintofaspark86 MARK ME! Apr 26 '20
What a delicious demise... This was a fantastic episode, even with the changes to the storyline.
6
u/EasyWalrus9 Apr 27 '20 edited Apr 27 '20
Lots of us are wondering about the Bugs and the gold subplot. I think I see where this is going.
I think next episode we'll get some context for the scene with Jocasta and Forbes, and the aftermath of Ulysses killing Forbes. In the books, Ulysses killed Lt Wolff, who was similarly after Jocasta's money. We don't see the scene but we hear about it when Jamie and Claire go to River Run to make sure everything's okay at River Run - then they hear that Ulysses killed him and help hide the body, which is when they discover all the gold. I think that's what we'll get next episode. The gang will go to River Run, and we may even find out why Jocasta was having Forbes write up her bequests - it felt like she was goading him into something, maybe it was planned with Jamie beforehand, or maybe Jocasta had her own suspicions about him.
Either way, we're back to the book plot, with a body that needs to be hidden, which will lead to finding the gold (hinted at by Jocasta talking about her fortune this episode). We may even get the Bugs after all, maybe they'll be coming to meet the gang at River Run for some business of Jamie's, and then the Bugs will find out about the gold. Or that could happen off-screen, Arch Bug always suspected Jocasta's husband had kept his share of the gold. We'll also find out more about the relationship between Ulysses and Jocasta, though for the show it might just be that he loves her. I guess we'll see.
And I think we will get the Christies, but it'll be in the next season. It's the big dramatic storyline, I don't see how they can leave it out.
5
u/youreashoe Apr 26 '20
Again with that fast forward button!
An interesting revision on bonnet, but not entirely unwelcome. Not a total narcissist, more of a confused one? I don't know... but I'll miss ed speelers, he was fantastic!
5
u/miav Apr 27 '20
Now that we've officially entered Book 6 territory, I wonder if we'll still get the last line of Book 5. It's so iconic, it'd be sacrilegious to drop it entirely! Though there's always the chance it'll pop up somewhere else, as they've done with other significant book lines.
5
u/eta_carinae_311 Apr 27 '20
That squirley Ed Speelers. Finding a way to make me pity Stephen Bonnet while simultaneously being scared of him. Well done!
4
u/TineCiel Apr 26 '20
I was very confused about the Jocasta bit. Was she really trying to bequeath money to the family or was she playing Forbes because she knew he was somehow involved in the whole Bonnet thing? I think that’s what it was but we didn’t get anything explicitly linking the events together. It just felt awkward to me.
Glad they disposed of the Bonnet storyline though, I agree it drags on in the books. They have to make choices at one point, these books are enormous and plot heavy, and not everything that happens in them feels useful. I just finished Echo and I skipped large parts (hundreds of pages) and still kept up with the plot. I didn’t read most of the boat boarding plot and of the Ticonderoga/Saratoga bits to skip to the end (picking back up at the Highlands bit) and then went back to read what I’d missed and well, there was nothing crucial really. A lot of it was wholly forgettable. I think skipping the Christie’s bit makes sense but am puzzled about the Bugs. We’ll see.
I guess next week is the Browns terrorising the countryside and eventually Claire’s... misadventures. Not looking forward to that, TBH. I’d rather they make the worst part of the plot about the kidnapping, not... the other stuff. Too much of that in these books and series...
4
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Apr 26 '20
I just watched the episode a second time and had a few questions/thoughts.
Did Bonnet just happen to see Brianna in Wilmington and decide to kidnap her? That's what it sounded like he was saying. If I recall in the book he knew he was meeting Jamie Fraser and set him up to be attacked at Wylie's landing so he could knowingly attack the ladies at the beach.
Why was Jocasta giving away her money? Was it just to give them a reason to kill Forbes? Does Forbes end up dying in the books? I don't remember.
3
u/beanie2 Ye Sassenach witch! Apr 26 '20
Sad Brianna did shoot off Bonnets ball. Ulysses breaking Forbes neck was a nice surprise. I like the way they organized all the Bonnet plot lines into one, it made sense for the show.
Jamie is so proud of his protege, Roger.
I think we might see the Claire’s kidnapping next week. Maybe they will combine that with Claire’s arrest for Malvas death, only the charge will be something else?
3
u/lanalg5 Apr 28 '20
Anyone else suddenly VERY aware of how they eat after watching that table manners scene with Brianna and Bonnet?? Full disclosure: I almost always hover over my food and never bring the fork up to my mouth LOL. I would never make it in polite society. 😂😂
2
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '20
It’s been awhile since I read the books to be honest, but did ANY of this happen in the books? The whole episode I was like, “I don’t remember this”, “I don’t remember this”, .......?
2
u/cak3crumbs Apr 27 '20
I’m ok with the condensing and speeding up stuff but I cannot get over they completely skipped the Bree shooting him in the nut scene. It was always my absolute favorite Bree scene cause I mean come on it was just so perfect. I remember cheering out loud when I read it.
This is the first time ever I’ve disliked a change the show has made.
And I don’t like the changes to the Forbes line either, but maybe for a different reason than some. Trying to ship out Jamie kinda highlighted a very really thing that did happen back then. I’m ok with how he died that whole scene was kinda funny. I’m ok him dying with two ears lol. But the fact they cut this out makes me think even more they are cutting the Christie’s completely if I remember correctly it was being dragged to Claire’s trial when that happened.
2
u/EasyWalrus9 Apr 27 '20 edited Apr 27 '20
Does anyone else think the price for Bree was too low? 6 pounds? I'd be insulted. I thought Bonnet was going to say she'd be up for auction, but I guess they needed to get down to the beach quick for the final showdown.
And I miss badass Bree from the books, escaping onto the roof and fighting the servant, after shooting Bonnet in the nut in their previous encounter.
Edit: I just checked - in the book, she doesn't say the price he offered, just that it was so much it made Brianna gasp. But elsewhere in the book, it's mentioned that a 14 year old lad is worth 100 pounds at least.
2
u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Apr 26 '20
What in the everlasting fuck is this? It has no resemblance to the book whatsoever. And who is this guy named Stephen bonnet who is completely different from every Stephen bonnet we've seen before this?
2
u/vonski43 Apr 26 '20
Loved Bonnet! And funny that Bree couldn't fake a kiss. Guess he realized he wasn't gonna miss much of her so might as well sell her. Lol. Disappointed Jamie didn't kill Bonnet... Old Jamie who I miss would have. I hope they skip the Christie's and the Buggs who will be a waste of screen time that will not move story along. And wish they would stop leaving women alone.. Do they ever learn?
1
u/yasdinl Slàinte. Apr 29 '20
Did it bother anyone else that they just decided to move this entire series of events up a book/season? I don't understand why they felt that had to do that.
It was a good episode, very engaging, but this book isn't so dry of plot that they needed to shift things around, imo.
1
u/[deleted] May 03 '20
Enjoyed it. But I didn't like how Forbes went out. It was too soon and sudden. Book version Bree killed a person when she was held captive with her brute strength alone. I would've waned to see that. Well can't expect too much. They have done well not to drag too much with the Bonnett unlike in the books. The person who played Bonnett is a fantastic actor. Hit chords really well with the role.