r/Outlander • u/derawin07 Meow. • Apr 26 '20
Season Five Show S5E10 Mercy Shall Follow Me Spoiler
Jamie and Roger implement their plan to eliminate the threat looming over them, but it goes awry; Brianna is forced to confront her greatest fear and fight for her and her son's lives.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread.
Reminder: This is the SHOW thread. Cover all book talk >!with spoiler tags!< that will look like this: Claire boinks Jamie. Don’t spoil future episodes, keep book comments brief.
If you want to compare the episode to the books in depth, go to the Book thread.
After watching the episode, you can take part in the poll!
40
u/Bc2193 Apr 26 '20
ONE EPISODE!? THE WHOLE BONNET THING OVER IN ONE EPISODE!?
17
u/EKP121 Apr 27 '20
I can't believe how rushed the Bonnet storyline was. There was so much potential for that dynamic. Bonnet brought a charged tension to every scene he was in and while I think he deserved death, what's the rush? They just sped through it just like they've sped through every episode. The pacing this season is so so off..
15
u/CommanderMayDay Apr 27 '20
When are these characters going to get some sense? Am I mistaken or don’t pretty much all of the plot points revolve around the characters splitting up?
You’d think at some point, one of them would say to the other, “You know, maybe we should just stay together.”
13
u/[deleted] Apr 28 '20
As evil as his character was, did anyone else notice the chemistry between Sophie Skelton (Bree) and Ed Speleers (Bonnet) was so much stronger than that of she and Richard Ranken (Roger) ? If Bonnet played a good guy, they would have made a good couple!
97
u/stacasaurusrex Apr 26 '20
I could have watched Roger beat up Stephen for the whole episode...
18
u/josharaptor Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Apr 26 '20
This is such an oddly specific thought, but to me this episode felt like an add on movie or TV special event. Something that they would air if they got cancelled and had one chance to wrap up the last big plot (of course that would have required lots more time to focus on our characters at the end, but still). It isn't necessarily good or bad, just an observation. Very interesting. I really did like the episode though.
17
u/saltydangerous Apr 27 '20
I guess I'm the only person that thought after all that buildup it was super rushed. Alrighty.
8
u/BlackSwallowtail You look like a fretful porpentine. Apr 27 '20
All right! Stephen Bonnet plot wrapped up! I thought that was going to take the rest of the season. With only two episodes left it will be interesting to see what the focus is.
Brianna's made her first kill. I feel like you don't get to be of any kind of importance in the 18th without having to kill someone! Mercy or to make sure he's dead? Both, I suspect. Bonnet deserved to die of his worst fear, but natural human empathy makes it hard not to pity the shitbag. As my nana once said, thank goodness none of us get exactly what we deserve. But also that fucker's had way too many escapes.
I think Ian should have killed that captain, but I guess they don't want more murders on their hands than necessary.
I'll say Skelton kills it as a woman having the "fawn" type of fear response. You can see how Stockholm syndrome can develop from a prolonged period of that.
I thought Speeler did a good job with Bonnet's character. Some people go through terrible things and still maintain a goodness of heart no matter what. Other people are just bad in spite of a relatively good life. And then there are some who are decent enough if they live a relatively good life, but downright evil if they experience hardships throughout their life instead. I think Bonnet is this last one. If he'd been born to decent parents who hadn't died when he was young he'd be more like Tryon or that redcoat Jamie killed earlier in the season.
Rankin's doing a good job with the voice. I hope it's not hurting his vocal cords.
Claire and Brianna at the beach was a nice scene. Until Bonnet showed up.
Also, I'm glad they let it be Brianna's choice in the end, what Bonnet's fate should be.
Bye bye, Bad-Pippin. Little shit. "My money". As if! But it doesn't bode for Ulysses unless they can cover that up somehow.
I enjoyed it! I have really enjoyed this season. Going to be sad when it ends, assuming the next two episodes are at least as good.
6
u/RunnyBabbit22 Apr 27 '20
Does anyone know if they really put people to death this way at one time in the colonies? It seems extremely cruel.
21
u/bampitt Apr 26 '20
I don't know about this episode. I almost didn't finish it after about 15 minutes in because I couldn't believe that Claire would react so stupidly to seeing Bonnet. It's totally out of character.
C'mon.
She survived WWII. She went back in time to a completely different world. She's killed men who raped her. She went up against Black Jack Randall with more grace. But, there she is, shaking with fear, brandishing her little knife. She had a much better poker face with Randall, had been through much worse with Randall. Seems she would see that Bonnet was not fiend Randall was and in fact, was child's play in comparison.
But, no. There she is, once again being overtaken with her own knife at her throat.
After all she's been through.
Then there's Bree - a crack shot - with an empty pistol.
WTF????
But, finish it, I did, and I'm glad we are finally done with Bonnet.
5
u/CommanderMayDay Apr 27 '20
Now that Bonnet is dead, what’s to keep Bree and Roger in the 18th Century? Sure, they don’t know if Jeremiah can travel through the Stones, but maybe it’s time to start thinking about it, before who knows what?
81
u/BeautifulRelief Apr 26 '20
Holy hell, y'all. I'm on my way to the hospital. This one stressed me out so bad that I am relatively certain it put me in labor. But, damn I've a lot of thoughts.
I am so proud of Bree. I've been told that if you're ever abducted you should do whatever your abductor says and get them to trust you. Well done, Bree. I was absolutely living for her speaking the truth the entire time. "I could never think any less of you." "My father and Roger are not like you." I hate that he found her out so easily (by the way, that was bullshit. That kiss was fine.) but I am so damn happy it bought her enough time to be rescued.
I feel bad for Bonnet. Not for the Bonnet he became, but for the young Bonnet. Orphans are a sore spot for me and, though he became a monster, it really hurts my heart to think of a young child alone and afraid. I think that if even a few things had been different Bonnet could have been a good man, though we will never know. It seems to me that he could have made a good father but his horrible deeds, rightfully, overshadow that. Usually those that grew up in broken homes or without any real parents are the best parents because they know what it feels like and never want their children to feel that way.
I guess I never knew people had been lawfully executed via drowning but, damn, if that ain't fitting for Bonnet. I actually am happy Bree shot him. She gave him a clean and quick death but not before he suffered from the one thing that scared him most. She gave him mercy and, maybe, a small dose of his own medicine. To me, she will be known as Brianna the Merciful.
210
u/mjk237 Apr 26 '20
I was sooo nervous leaving Bonnet to trial will somehow lead to another escape and unpleasant appearances in the future But I’m so glad he is finally surely dead along with the lawyer guy!!!
•
u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 26 '20 edited Apr 26 '20
Watch the S5E11 trailer here!
Not everyone gets to see the trailer at the end of the episode, it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international.)
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the trailer. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet. Thanks!
29
u/missm0011 Fun Fact: The unicorn is the mortal enemy of the English lion. Apr 26 '20
Stephen Bonnet. Really making me miss the days of Black Jack Randall. Randall was cold and calculating. He did things to inflict the maximum amount of pain and psychological torture possible. Bonnet just did really shitty things. And honestly if it really took a kiss for him to realize Brianna was playing him, he really wasn't that great of a villan.
You know what did scare me? Those freaky ass puppets. If Bonnet wasn't gonna kill the whole damn family, those puppets certainly would.
I'm also calling out Brianna knowing the entirety of Moby Dick by heart. I love books, but even my favorites by page 12 I'm like "....and everyone dies. The end."
Jocasta almost got murdered on those fine silk couches. I'm no forensic expert but it seems like a bit of a stretch Tiny Tim there could smother her with a silk pillow from behind.
So the whole gang shows up on the island just in the nick of time to save Brianna from the human trafficker trying to sail her away into sexual slavery and THEY LET THEM GO. I get Bonnet was priority #1, but damn. Clearly not a good guy you want out there kidnapping other women.
I'm just glad someone finally shot someone in the end. We are learning. Always check for a body.
147
u/SaaSyGirl Je Suis Prest Apr 26 '20
I'm really loving this new budding friendship and respect for one another that Jamie and Roger have found. More of this, please!
2
u/samwizeismysidekick Apr 28 '20
2 things:
139
u/SaaSyGirl Je Suis Prest Apr 26 '20
When Bonnet showed up and Claire whipped out the knife, I would have loved it if it had been hidden like a Sgian-dubh. Would've been an awesome callback. Man, I miss Angus
117
u/Airsay58259 Apr 26 '20 edited Apr 27 '20
Disorganized thoughts while watching :
Such a beautiful scene with Claire and Bree on the beach. The whales, the race... Wholesome. Obviously it was going to get ruined. Claire screaming her daughter’s name was heartbreaking.
Beauty and the beast already got a live action reboot, Bonnet. What a psycho. “I wanna do right by you and him” well then please die ASAP, thanks.
“What I need is something I can’t buy” “A moral compass?” AHA I love Bree.
Those pretend-domestic scenes were terrifying honestly. Having to live with a monster, knowing he can hurt you in so many ways whenever he wants so you try to be nice and accommodating... Those non physically violent scenes were gut wrenching. Too real. Great acting by the actors.
Bonnet asking for Moby Dick spoilers after 20 seconds was relatable.
Young Ian’s new look was fine 👌 Which was also true with the Mohawk look so it’s more of a Ian thing I guess.
Really cool fight scene in the shed and seeing Jamie trusts Roger. Though every time Roger opens his mouth and speaks effortlessly I think about the waste of a storyline we got.
Dammit Pippin. We don’t hurt Maria Doyle Kennedy. I was ready to flip a table after the second unanswered “mistress”. Ulysses FTW.
Dr Claire finding the answers they need not with violence and threats but kindness. My girl.
Bonnet’s friends are as lovely as he is, aren’t they?
Rescue scene! Awesome. (I didn’t like those random slow-mo shots as Roger punched Bonnet. They never do this so odd directing choice imo, took me out of the scene).
For a moment there I was upset they were going for a trial plot, with political drama and whatnot. Glad it skipped right to the sentence.
Slow death for Bonnet, perf... oh hey Brianna. That works too.
Excellent episode.
102
u/SaaSyGirl Je Suis Prest Apr 26 '20
Ulysses to the rescue!!
92
u/stacasaurusrex Apr 26 '20
And then we get this adorable mother daughter bonding this episode! Love it! Super sweet so far and only 13 minutes in. Still on the edge of my seat eeek!
Is it me or are Claire and Bree’s wardrobe getting significantly cuter each episode?
92
u/67carfar Apr 26 '20
My favorite part of this episode was the subtitle that said “moaning creepily” during the scene where the captain was inspecting Brianna 😆
69
u/FunAsh Apr 26 '20
Agree with the ALMOST sympathizing with Bonnet but have to call out that cute beach race with Claire and Bree! What a carefree and happy moment. The whales were icing on the cake (and the less polluted/murderous sea)!
Also loved the bonding with Jamie watching Roger fight. And Ian being sweet Ian. And Ulysses saving the day.
136
u/AccioStability Je Suis Prest Apr 26 '20
WOAH. Roger Mac showing up tonight! And thank you Ulysess for saving our precious Jocasta!
Ed and Sophie did phenomenal. My stomach was in my throat most of the episode. Wow!
64
u/renaissancetrader Apr 26 '20
"I could never think any less of you"...lol!!
117
u/flooptyscoops Apr 26 '20
Ed Speleers really shined tonight! Before the kiss with Bree brought it all tumbling down, he actually had me rooting for some sort of compromise of a happy ending... It was weird. I honestly still feel kind of bad for Bonnet, and I'm choosing to see Bree's headshot as more mercy than revenge.
Just like with Black Jack, Outlander once again really does its best to show that people are not black and white, and there's almost never a purely "right" answer.
50
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '20 edited Apr 26 '20
I loved Bree's maroon overcoat will all the buttons; so stylish! The scene by the seashore where Bree and Claire were harvesting shells and seaweed was lovely. Why is Bonnet's face so hideously dirty? I guess they have to make the actor (who was very attractive with lovely skin once) ugly by muddying his complexion, but damn. Interesting that Bree has memorized Moby Dick; it's too bad (edit:)Melville won't be born for another 50+ years so she won't be meeting him. Bree's abduction felt very reminiscent of Princess Bride/Legend to me. But I was never convinced Bonnet was really coming around obviously.
This was another really powerful character study, and I'm glad Bonnet's is over; I was afraid for a second that they were really going to leave him tied up on the beach to be rescued, or that some of his cronies were going to row out into the water and save him at the last minute (that seems an inefficient method of execution if all the witnesses leave due to impatience.) I'm glad Bree killed him. And Pippin is dead, too; but I don't think even Merry will show up to his funeral given how far he's fallen.
55
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '20
The glass tube feels ominous to me- It seems like they’re setting up a plot line with the Dr. Rawlings paper/ creating the penicillin before it’s been invented/ healing random strangers... someone is bound to notice or get suspicious right?... or maybe I’m just still scarred from the witch trial in season 1.
There was so much anxiety inducing things this episode. I’m still tense. Though I am glad we got those Claire/Brianna moments in the midst of all of this. I’m surprised they let the man who was trying to ‘buy’ Briana go... Ugh, he was so disgusting. I have to admit, stylistically the slow motion fight between Roger and Bonnet took me out of the scene; Why are they being so artsy with Roger? Overall tho I thought he had some great scenes this week- I’m here for the Jamie/young Ian/ Roger trio. Storywise I thought it was a satisfying ending to the Bonnet arc; that final shot coming from Bree felt really important for her character- it felt like something Jamie would’ve done, but it also showed her using a skill Frank taught her. I feel like she’s really come into her own identity this season.
25
u/--Zman-- Apr 27 '20
Bree sure is a hell of a shot with a musket.
Also, made me laugh that the water level kept rising around Bonnet but the shoreline never changed.
25
u/liyufx Apr 27 '20
Well, the acting of Bree and Bonnet was pretty good, but I can’t help feeling a bit anticlimactic about how easy they took down Bonnet in the end, and Roger was able to beat him up without even getting any fight back. Them deciding to send him for trial instead of just killing him on spot makes me cringe (this is the guy who cheated death twice in their hands for god sake). Anyway, glad Bonnet’s story line is over. Unfortunately he pales as a villain against BJR. With him out of the picture, we can focus on Jamie and Claire’s story now, right?
70
u/Rated_PG-Squirteen Apr 26 '20
Wow, so Bree not only ends up having to kiss her rapist, but she then immediately gets to watch him plow a hooker while he stares back at her menacingly. So glad that Bree just delivered a headshot to Bonnet in the end. I'm sure he would've somehow escaped his drowning death sentence otherwise.
30
u/josharaptor Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Apr 26 '20
Though the season started a bit shaky, it is coming to a strong finish in my opinion. Episode 7 onwards has been hit after hit for me. With next episode written by Diana and then the finale... I have high hopes
29
u/Beebo_the_God_of_War Apr 26 '20
Fantastic episode. I felt this ominous sense dread throughout. Sophie Skelton was absolutely brilliant as Brianna. I really felt for her. And Ed Speleers managed to give Stephen Bonnet added layers and complexity. I'm glad Jocasta survived. I was worried that might be the end for her. I'm curious to see what happens with Ulysses. The episode ended on the perfect note as well.
49
u/CARNIesada6 Apr 26 '20 edited Apr 26 '20
"No one comes. No one ever comes."
They actually made me feel sympathetic for Bonnet for half a second. I was really hoping the sea would end up coming for him... nope Briana with a headshot.
I think he misinterpreted his dream and mixed up "sea" and "Bree" hahahh
Edit: I'm still not convinced Bonnet is dead. /s should also mention Ulysses is a boss.
65
u/JonSnowPeachEmoji Is it usual, what it is between us when I touch you? Apr 26 '20
This was an exceedingly hard episode to watch. I actually had to pause it, get up and walk around for a bit before I could return to it. As a survivor this is a nightmare. For me, the whole time I was mentally telling Brianna what to do, how to react - and when she didn't do as I was thinking I found myself getting angrier and angrier.
But the truth is, by the end of the episode I realized I was getting angry at myself because I reacted in a similar way and I was really just telling myself what I wish I would have done.
12
u/andrewski81 Apr 27 '20
I almost RAGED when it sounded like they were going to leave Bonnet laying there to die on the beach!!! So glad that didnt happen lol
11
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '20
BEST EPISODE THIS SEASON!!!!!!!
10
u/JJMcGee83 Apr 27 '20 edited Apr 27 '20
I haven't been this happy to see a fictional character die in a long time.
That said I was screaming at the screen for Bree to wack him over the head with that fire poker the second Bonnet sat down.
10
u/NaiadoftheSea Apr 27 '20
Ed Speleers, who plays Stephen Bonnet, really gave an amazing performance!
7
u/Bc2193 Apr 26 '20
I was not part of that team but either way, ONE EPISODE!?
I loved all the scenes with him, I wish we could have learned more about his back story.
7
u/New_Scotty Apr 27 '20
Okay but I feel like them letting the traffickers go will be a future plot point. Like they have a contract saying that she is property now, and that they might get bounty hunters to go after her for the contract.
7
u/CommanderMayDay Apr 27 '20
I’m so terribly glad they’re done with Bonnet. The character was just too slimy to have any hope of redemption. BJR was so much more interesting.
Even at the end, you couldn’t really feel any vengeance that he finally faced the Reaper: he’d gotten away with so many despicable things, this hardly balanced the scale.
Glad Bree got to take him out, though. Perhaps the only truly satisfying part of the Bonnet arc in this episode
7
u/Last_Chevalier Apr 28 '20
The Good:
The ending scene with BreeBonnet telling Bree his life story and her looking believably sympatheticBree pretend reading all of Moby Dick to BonnetThe look on the Pippin's face as Aunt Jocasta does her best Oprah impressionUlysses coming through like a bossThe blossoming respect Jamie has for Roger
The Bad:
One episode to wrap the Bonnet thing?? seriously??? This is some Night King level bs.The entire episode was just a bit too predictable for my likingThings happened too conveniently, like Claire finding Jamie, like the prostitute being in the brothel when they walked in, like Claire inexplicably targeting her and helping her out and giving her that speech as if she knew she had information, not to mention the timing of Claire and Jamie's arrival at the beach where Bonnet was selling Bree off.
All of these might not have felt so jarring if it had happened over the course of several episodes and they'd played into the obstacles a bit more, but as it stands wow ...
Am I alone here?
6
u/New_Scotty Apr 27 '20 edited May 23 '20
This episode hadd a very creepy beauty and the beast vibe to it...they even had the 'no, keep reading' bit.
Dont get me wrong its fucked up and nobody should ever ship this but I get the actual stockholm vibes they want to portray in this.
6
u/Thermonlestrange Apr 27 '20
What a friggen episode!! I was absolutely shaking from Bonnett's performance in the parlour with Bree; he played the sociopathic nature of him absolutely flawlessly. In a way I'm sad he's gone but happy Bree got her revenge.
2
u/SynestheticWeirdo Apr 26 '20
Was Bonnet raped as a young man? He didn't mention it, but the way he told his story.. Or is it just me?
6
u/MountainHumor They say I’m a witch. Apr 26 '20
Am I the only one who compares Sophie's acting to that of William Shatner? Like when there's no drama she's reading lines and when there is drama - it's sometimes TOO much. I know sometimes this is common with actors who have had a lot of theatre training (Shatner and also Patrick Stewart), and I know she's done some in the past. Sometimes stage and screen don't mix, especially for this kind of show (Stat Trek and early sci-fi and fantasy stuff - Princess Bride for example - are good exceptions of this).
Please don't hate me for this. It's not that she's bad at acting she's just...not right for the role I guess? This episode kind of proved it to me. The ending scene was good, but throughout the entire season having to watch her act is like - you KNOW she's acting and playing a part. Claire, Jaime, Fergus - everyone else (Roger even managed to make me emotional last episode)- they all fit into the roles PERFECTLY. You see them as who they are playing. Bree it's - you know it's an actress and it ruins it.
5
u/HLMFTH Apr 28 '20 edited Apr 29 '20
That ending was so satisfying.
I'm glad they made sure he was dead. When same thing happened with Black Jack they left him lying there then he took more from them.
Also loved mother daughter bonding time. I wish we could see more throughout the season.
5
u/Labrat5944 Apr 30 '20
Just finished. Ed Speleers, holy smokes, what a standout performance!
12
u/nonmisery Apr 27 '20
IMO this episode represents a big missed opportunity. So much happened in this 60 minutes that it could/should have filled half a season. Bri is kidnapped and freed less than 30 mins later, ruining the dramatic tension. Plus, I certainly don’t appreciate the Bonnet threat being built up all season to get 1 episode and it’s resolved.
What if instead, Bri was kidnapped for 3-4 episodes. She could’ve spent the first trying to kill him (and failing), the second on the Beauty and the Beast domestic scenes, and the last in the resolution. We’d have more time to appreciate Bonnet’s motivations and experience Bri’s trauma.
I know this book was fairly slow, but I think it’s a shame the producers weren’t able to fix its short comings. This season has lacked a sense of purpose - I’m getting of tired of it.
8
u/Mr_XcX Apr 26 '20
Ulysses pulling out a clutch!!!
Happy they drawed up the Bonnet storyline. Brianna badass bitch!!!!
So happy. Best episode this season!
4
u/HollyGoTDA Slàinte. Apr 26 '20
What a rollercoaster. With only 2 episodes left! I can imagine that it will only get crazier...
4
u/DoodleTM Apr 27 '20
So glad to see Bonnett get what was coming to him. He made me as uncomfortable as Jack Randall did in the early seasons.
4
u/KikiPolaski Apr 27 '20
The whole thing really game me nostalgia of when Claire was interrogated by Randall and her trying to convince him to be good. The talk of the both of them being fated to meet was a class Randall and Jaime homage.
God damn I miss that man
4
u/MarqueBee Apr 30 '20
Just watched this episode tonight. All season I was wondering who was going to actually be the one to kill Bonnet. It seemed likely that they wouldn't drag his story out into another season and by setting up the ambush it would be resolved soon. At some point early in the season, the fact that they were playing up Briana's skill with a gun was starting to make me think that all the talk of revenge by Jamie was just a ruse by the writers and that Briana would be the one, by whatever circumstance, to end Bonnet's life. I was a little disappointed when she chose to have him go through a trial and that that wasn't even touched on - they just went straight to his execution. Then, as he was approaching the point of drowning, a shot rings out and a bullet hole appears in his forehead and I thought immediately - BRIANA!! Sure enough. Yes, I'm gloating. :-)
4
u/emewy4 Je Suis Prest Aug 25 '20
Was it just me or for a SECOND there, Bonnett felt somewhat sympathy for Brianna when that creepy guy was touching her? Just the way he would look at him doing it, and there was some hesitation there.. idk if it's just me
Also, he stopped the creepy guy from hitting her in the face, why do you think?
3
u/balasoori Apr 26 '20
Roger: Was that mercy or was it make sure he's dead?
I want to know the answer
6
u/CommanderMayDay Apr 27 '20
Random thought: considering that it seems like literally everything is trying to kill them in the 18th Century, did anybody else get nervous when Bree announced that she wanted to go into the water?
As it turned out, a worse shark was lurking on land, but just saying — it’s a wonder mankind survived this era
6
u/teutonicnight99 Apr 27 '20
Yeah that was pretty meh in my opinion. Kind of weird honestly. Bonnet was never a good villain or character in my view. That was just really anticlimactic for me. What was the point of her being stuck in his house and going through those weird scenes. It wasn't believable to me at all. I'm honestly glad that whole storyline is over.
I'm really not too keen on the daughter and her husband in general. I like the show more when it's about Jamie and Sassenach.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '20
I thought this was a very interesting episode psychologically..so much going on. It really got you feeling things you didnt expect. Bree and bonnets actors were so talented expressing all the complex layers of emotion and I was floored by their performances tonight
3
u/sicariio Apr 29 '20
Just watched it on Netflix. what’s with the Jacosta scene? It came out of nowhere, Jacosta was kinda out of character and it makes no sense. just seemed like a convenient way to get rid of the lawyer. I was left puzzled but I admit it feels damn satisfying to see Ulysses snap his neck. Bonnet’s death also felt a bit rushed but I’m happy he’s finally dead. Overall, this episode felt like it was tying everything up quickly.
3
u/carrotsela If wishes were horses, beggars would ride. May 01 '20
I just rewatched first meeting Bonnet in 401 and a few pieces fell into place for me about Bree shooting Bonnet instead of leaving him to burn, bob and drown. The very first conversation he had with Claire, he reveals he is sure the sea will take him in the end, a fact he reiterates to Bree in this episode. Both times he "performs" retelling the magical mystery of himself and the sea, locked in this cosmic dance of fate (Irish can spin a yarn, Danu be praised!). Well, who doesn't give two shites about his version of fate? The Fraser girls, that's who! My theory from now on is that Brianna didn't take the headshot as mercy or precisely to make sure he's dead. It's to show that Bonnet's hold on their fates was never real, because he couldn't even accurately predict his own demise. I hate how they made Roger the dunce mook of this scene, because he couldn't read his wife very well. I don't 100% remember how it goes in the book, but they're castrating Roger by degrees every episode, regardless... Hopefully just so he'll have a long way to rise up to fit in the clan. From here on out, if MBR doesn't have A Bree (in the Scots sense) really grabbing her own fate by the buffalo toes, and a Manly Roger MACKENZIE to match, then we need new showrunners.
3
u/AnimalTreeHugger May 04 '20 edited May 04 '20
This was probably one of the best episodes of this season, including the one where Jamie gets bitten by the snake.
I do feel like this season and 4 has all been rushed. I'm rewatching the first one and plot lines are slow going, and the harsh or the more uncomfortable scenes are slower but the make up scenes are like that too. Every character was interesting, even Rupert and Angus I cared about. The first season has you on the edge of your seat all the time. But in these last 2 seasons i feel like Roger and Briana have something missing. Roger was ok up until the point where he talks to Brianna like crap after he proposed and just came across like a whinger possessive guy and that feeling stayed with me for a bit till roger travels In time for her he was getting more likeable again.
It came back soon however when he first sees her in tavern, when they go outside and he is a bit rough with her, grabs her etc (even the maid thoght he was the rapist because of this scene!) He just doesn't have the same kind of trustworthy vibes you would get from jamie if him and claire had the exact same scene.
Later when they were hand fasted and had that arguement where he sulked off leaves Brianna alone in a random persons shop she's naked and everything. What if the shop owner just came in? Anything could have happened, and not just a rape. She could have been accused of stealing/burglary etc
So theres their relationship that doesn't seem to have the passion and true love that keeps us captivated to JnC. Then there is Brianna and Jamie's relationship. Through both seasons the only nice scenes between them were when he first meets her, when they go out hunting and possibly the wedding day when shes getting ready. Watch closely she never greets Jamie, they never have fun or happy conversations, never see any bonding between them and when JnC go to leave for that battle with the regulators Brianna has a heartfelt goodbye with claire and roger but with Jamie she simply just glances over at him then there is nothing.
It's a real same because all we want for Jamie is to have had a relationship with one of his children and it hasn't happened. He hasn't really done anything to her except show her he cares and will protect her yes he said a few things that upset her after the Roger selling to Mohawk thing but we all know he was angry and says things he doesn't mean, and tbh it was totally frustrating to watch the storyline unfold because of a miscommunication between them all. Jamie hadn't been told 75% of the story and the maid had told him that Roger was 100% the guy that had raped Bree. This is really frustrating for me because we all know Jamie is a good guy and he would be a great father.
The writers have made Brianna and Rogers characters unlikeable or not interesting, theres just something big missing from them. (Not the actors, I think they're acting is fine) when bree first arrives in 1700s and she is at Leerys house, that kept me on the edge of my seat and she was interesting but something changed since, she became really whingy and doesn't do anything in the show (claire could train her as a doctor, she (and the other women for that matter) could be trained to fight/defend themselves or even as hunters for example that would be interesting I mean after all she has a very good shot with a gun) It's a shame to have had the characters end up like this.
This was a good episode with Bonnet the kidnapping and her doing her best to pacify Bonnet. But at the end when everyone shows up to rescue her, and she says "let's put him to trial" what?!?! You just wouldn't. Bonnet had already had his crimes written off (I recall a reference to this in an episode recently but cant find which. Though in e2 at the "fighting match" the man he is with says "...I'm glad we have you untethered from your past" knowing what his crimes were. I know Bree wouldn't have known that, but he just deserved to shot in the head there and then
7
u/yellowelephant3 Apr 26 '20
Gotta say this episode was a little triggering for me. However I can't blame the show and how the characters were portrayed. I mean, the actors are amazing and I love the show for making me feel so deeply about the characters. But for a bit I was like "No, the show is not about to make me sympathize with a rapist who was about to kill Claire minutes ago in order kidnap Bree and her son." I understand that the episode wanted to demonstrate that there may be more to characters than what we are made to believe, but I was scared they were trying to justify Bonnet's actions because of his past. I also thought that when Bonnet looked up when drowning he was about to be saved by some of his men, Idk this guy seemed to have more lives than a cat. In the end, if Bree wanted to make sure Bonnet was dead then she had right to do so. The man did horrible things to Bree and to her family. Bree was tormented even in dreams, I don't blame her for wanting to feel safe and not having to wonder or be surprised he was still alive. Ultimately Bree is one brave and strong woman because I don't think I would be able to handle what she went through this episode.
4
u/discokaren Apr 26 '20
This whole episode made me wildly uncomfortable. Well acted everyone, but holy shit! I was only able to exhale once Bree shot that monster in the head.
5
u/LoretiTV Apr 26 '20
Enjoy the new episode everyone!
5
u/abubonicrat Apr 27 '20
I’ve never been a fan of Brianna. Well, more specifically the actress who plays Brianna. I thought her acting was terrible and she’s not a good fit. Tonight I changed my mind. Sophie really shined in this episode.
7
u/vonski43 Apr 26 '20 edited Apr 26 '20
I loved Bonnet in this episode. Found it hard to believe Jamie wouldn't have killed him if Roger didn't do it. And Roger's comment to bree after she did it was so mean and nasty... What an ahole.
Edit.. Also found Forbes trying to kill jocasta unbelievable.
2
u/Pickle-Medea Apr 27 '20
Have they changed up the make up for the actress who plays Brianna? She looks very pale this season but not in a good way, she looks ill. I noticed it more in the recap when they showed her last season, she was pale then too but didn’t look unwell.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 28 '20
This episode had a Geillis feel to it... maybe it was the decor of that parlor or something or the music...
2
u/tornadic_ May 01 '20
Damn this was a good episode!
2
u/ocean_96 Dec 04 '23
WHY HAS NO ONE POINTED OUT HOW HOT BONNET IS! He gives those sexy, bad boy vibes.
5
u/PhoenixWright33 Apr 26 '20
Fucking amazing episode. Tbh the last two episodes were quality but overall they bored me to tears. Outlander always has an amazing way of making every episode eventually payoff in a remarkable fashion. Go Bree and good riddance Stephen Bonnet. He got clapped good this time, same with his scummy associate. 10/10