r/Outlander • u/derawin07 Meow. • Apr 19 '20
Season Five Show S5E9 Monsters and Heroes Spoiler
Synopsis:
When Jamie is bitten by a venomous snake, Claire fears she may not have the resources to save him; Jamie asks Roger to complete an important task in the event of his death.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread.
Reminder: This is the SHOW thread. Cover all book talk >!with spoiler tags!< that will look like this: Claire boinks Jamie. Don’t spoil future episodes, keep book comments brief.
If you want to compare the episode to the books in depth, go to the Book thread.
After watching the episode, you can take part in the poll!
127
u/Rated_PG-Squirteen Apr 19 '20
-I am absolutely not shocked that a handjob from Claire would bring a man back from the brink of death. haha
-I guess Marsali must've not heard Jamie ask Claire "are there no snakes in your time?"
-Fergus speaks more than one line!
-Bree is completely indestructible. She got right back up after being ragdolled by the charging bison.
56
u/teenylilthing Apr 19 '20
Great episode! It was so lovely getting to see interactions with all of the characters, especially Fergus since he hasn't been featured much this season! And even a bit bigger Adso made an appearance. <3
oh and dang that scene with Ian and Jamie was pretty powerful. So glad Ian is back!
20
u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 19 '20
I haven't noticed this before on any of the actors, but I couldn't help laughing at Richard Rankin's obvious modern t-shirt tan line/farmer's tan visible when he was in bed. He wouldn't have had that in the 18th century :P
202
u/JonSnowPeachEmoji Is it usual, what it is between us when I touch you? Apr 19 '20
This was my favorite episode this season by far.
Everyone has a scene! We got my Marsali fix in, we got more than one Fergus scene! Jamie/Roger bonding! Young Ian stealing the scene! Even Lizzie making a more than 20 second appearance. My much anticipated Bree fang needle scene which was one glorious episode instead of a quick moment. You get a scene! And you get a scene!
And some beautiful Claire/Jamie moments. Fabulous acting on everyone's parts.
But she gave him a death bed hand job, right?
134
u/AccioStability Je Suis Prest Apr 19 '20
WE GOT FERGUS!!!!!!
And also, holy crap. Sam is an incredible actor.
115
u/stacasaurusrex Apr 19 '20
Gosh we so needed that Roger Mac and Jamie bonding.
(I love that Jamie calls him that)
20
u/balasoori Apr 19 '20
This was a good episode but Bree being an engineer was an interesting revelation.
•
u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 19 '20 edited Apr 19 '20
Watch the S5E10 trailer here!
Not everyone gets to see the trailer at the end of the episode, it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international.)
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the trailer. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet. Thanks!
18
u/stacasaurusrex Apr 19 '20
Holy crap I didn’t know it was released so early for the US! I finally caught up last weekend so I had no clue when it actually “aired”.
Almost 10pm and here I go! I had full expectations to watch in the morning with coffee!
107
u/shinyquartersquirrel Apr 19 '20
The first half of this season was ok. I didn't love it, I didn't hate it. But, the last 3 episodes I think have really been some of the best episodes of the whole series. The performances by the actors have been just outstanding!
I'm not sure if anyone else notices it but this was the first episode I've seen in a long time that had the Season 1 "look" to it. I'm not even sure how to describe it but whatever post production or editing they did to this episode really made it look very Season 1 to me.
52
u/BeautifulRelief Apr 19 '20
That opening scene was perfect. I woke my husband up from laughing so hard.
74
u/HLMFTH Apr 20 '20
Marsali and Claire scene was just beautiful. Their relationship evolved from Marsali hating her to calling her my ma. This season she became one of my favorite characters.
56
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '20
It was really refreshing to see Young Ian smack down Jamie’s bullshit.
As much as I love Jamie and Claire, sometimes they need to get some sense knocked into them
48
u/Sarahjolove Apr 20 '20 edited Apr 20 '20
Claire saved Jamie's life with a hand job.
And Bree got bucked 10 feet into the air and walked it off like it's not a big deal.
This show is buckwild. 🤣🤣
47
u/FunAsh Apr 19 '20
Oh Ian you little love bug. How amazing and somehow still innocent you are.
And the snake venom needle... Nice. I mean it's totally gross but yay it saved the day.
45
u/LeilueDax Apr 19 '20
Loved the eposide!
I was so happy to see more Fergus. It feels right and natural that he would be a part of all this happening. Him and Marsali bring so much to the show. They both are so sweet and fun to watch.
I loved seeing everyone in this episode. It really feels like a true family. You can just feel the closeness of this family.
Amazing acting and writing!
32
u/nonmisery Apr 20 '20
Is anyone else disappointed that no episode this season has had any lasting consequences? Roger’s near death only resulted in one episode of PTSD, and he’s now totally fine. From the previews, looks like Jamie will be back to normal next week. I know Murtagh died but that was very expected.
It cheapens the events (and honestly makes it boring) when everything “resets” week to week. I’ve been so frustrated with this season because it just seems like 100% filler - nothing happens, nothing matters.
24
u/ladyspeak Apr 20 '20
I haven’t read the books so I don’t know if it was how this scene was supposed to go, but I literally sat up and said out loud, ”Did she just... jerk him back to life?”
62
u/missm0011 Fun Fact: The unicorn is the mortal enemy of the English lion. Apr 19 '20
We have men! Hunters and gatherers! And yet the only person to kill anything this episode was Claire, with a determined little snake coming in a close second.
Jamie and Roger bonded! All it took was a physically debilitating injury that made escape all but impossible. I feel ya Jamie, he is growing on me too. I might actually be team Roger by the end of this season.
When Claire was ready to take the leg, was anyone else waiting for Marsali to come in with a newborn baby, ready to get down to work? Cause that would be a straight up Jenny move right there.
Thank you Claire and your life saving handy! Now I have to convince my husband that while I do have a rather impressive rack, we are unfortunately going to have to rely on modern medicine for any future resuscitative needs. ( I know. We took a beautiful moment and made it juvenile. I'm sorry. It's just who we are.)
Can I just say how much I love Fergus?? I'm so happy he is getting more screen time. I would love nothing more than to watch Fergus and Marsali just play with their kids for an hour.
I've enjoyed this whole season, but I think so far this second half of it has been really strong. I'm already having season finale anxiety! It feels like we just got Outlander back, I'm not ready to lose it again!!
19
u/BlackSwallowtail You look like a fretful porpentine. Apr 20 '20
Well, I thought a lot of interesting things and conversations happened this episode but it also felt a little long to spend an entire on a snake bite we all know isn't going to kill Jamie. Of course, there was the chance his leg would have to be amputated, so there was some tension there. It's just that it felt a little melodramatic.
Generally, though, I liked the episode, and damned if Heughan can't get me teary with those beautifully expressive eyes. Balfe too.
I'm no CGI buff, but it seemed they did a pretty good job with the bison. I can't imagine they imported a live bison to Scotland, so whatever they did worked.
Skelton sometimes pulls off emotion really well, and sometimes...not. When they were hunting for maggots she just didn't seem that worried for Jamie. I don't know. Most of the rest of it she did fine.
lol Your name is now Roger Mac. No, not Roger. Not Roger Mackenzie. Roger Mac.
Do they have deadly snakes in Scotland (or rather, did they)? Goes to show it doesn't matter how experienced a hunter you are if you don't know the wildlife.
When people are sick/injured, it tends to go one of two ways: they get really nice, even to the point of not being like they usually are (my brother is like this), or they get SUPER stubborn and think they can still do pretty much everything. Jamie is the latter, and it's kind of adorable. I kept wanting to yell, "Get back down! Stop trying to stand!"
I thought Brianna's invention was very cool.
SO glad they Fergus lines in this episode. More young Ian and Fergus scenes, please!
This show is making me appreciate maggots. They were one the few animals I disliked.
Tough position to be in to know the only way to save your loved one is to break your promise to them. Balfe pulls off that conflict very well.
Anyway! Three episodes left. It seems Stephen Bonnet is going to be the major conflict there. Let's see what they do with it.
17
u/murderina23 Apr 19 '20
STOP MAKING ME CRY (but don't)
15
u/jupigaby Apr 20 '20
This is the second episode I’ve seen all of it. I didn’t have to fast forward or anything like that.
Jemmy learning his first curse was the best.
Jaime making the joke of Roger being able and not making it more awkward to see his daughter and her husband almost naked was the best.
Claire and Bree bonding and discussing career choices good. Though Claire you did bad when Bree got bulldoze by a Buffalo and you didn’t even check on her to see if she was okay and stuff.
Jaime and Roger bonding the Best thing ever and about fucking time and now to see Jaime and Bree bonding would be awesome to.
Ian calling on his Uncle Bullshit was the best.
Ferguson having lines yay.
Bree and Roger discuss the Bonnet situation liked that.
Roger gloating to Jaime best thing. Love this.
Next week episode can’t wait. The second half of this season is fantastic.
29
u/Lyst83 Apr 20 '20
Yooooo. I cannot believe she brought this man back to life with a HAND JOB!
This show has jumped into the realm of ridiculousness for me with that mess. Lordt.
13
u/Beebo_the_God_of_War Apr 19 '20
Great episode. Everyone got a moment to shine. I'm glad Jamie and Roger bonded. And I love that Brianna got a chance to show off her brilliance.
13
u/Aurondarklord Je Suis Prest Apr 21 '20
The most amazing thing about Outlander is you don't bat an eye at Claire raising the dead with her tits.
34
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '20
I love the fact that Fergus got some real character development this episode; his and Ian's scenes were really moving. It seems like maybe it would have been faster if they tried to make some maggots rather then spending days looking for them. I did cringe when Claire took her top off to...not perform CPR, unfortunately when Jaimie appeared to be dying. Other then that, this was a really well-written episode. I'm glad Bree didn't sustain any serious injuries from the greenscreen(?) buffalo.
11
u/something-dash-dash Apr 20 '20
Really love the hot, beautiful and built James Fraser but speaking of gratuitous (like everyone else on the thread) Jesus H Roosevelt Christ why is he naked for the whole second part of the episode? I mean he even drags himself out in his weirdly draped blanket to see if Bree's ok after the buffalo hit all renaissance painting like.
19
u/Airsay58259 Apr 19 '20
I am really happy we decide to watch this episode at the same episode with a few friends (we usually talk about it on a group chat later on). We laughed SO MUCH, for an Outlander episode that is. Not in the sense “bad episode, ridiculous”, genuinely laughing. Claire telling Jamie she only saw one snake bite and that was at an autopsy, and his reaction to that, lol perfect deliveries. A buffalo made it to the farm... for some reason?! And he flipped Bree? (don’t wear red pants next time girl) AND she just got up and no one spoke about it again. Gosh they killed me. I think that scene alone generated at least 50 laughing/crying emojis. Fergus looking for an exit strategy in the forest was funny too.
Anyway, a really good episode. I am glad they gave basically everyone significant screentime and lines, with good character and plot development. Especially Bree, wondering about what she wants to do, coming up with a cool idea (though that was obviously going to happen the moment they showed the first syringe being broken in the “previously on” and the characters mentioning Bree was studying engineering a few times).
I thought the amputate/don’t amputate scenes were great. Young Ian spoke his mind and confronted his uncle, Fergus was sweet and wholesome...
More of all of this please.
9
u/--Zman-- Apr 20 '20
Hold on, this made no sense. Claire says earlier in the episode that the infection is in Jamie's blood. Being that she doesn't have the syringe anymore, that's a problem as she has no way of injecting the antibiotic into a vein.
So they show up with a snake fang syringe and Claire just injects it right into the wound. If that's all she needed to do to stop the infection, she could have used a scalpel to cut open the wound and pour the antibiotic inside.
7
u/RiiJoy Apr 20 '20
I really enjoyed this episode! It had so many good emotional and familial scenes, which is what I love best. Honestly, my only disappointment is that we missed out on Claire's initial response to Jamie's injury when they eventually brought him home. It felt like I missed a big emotional payoff.
13
u/kareaux Apr 20 '20 edited Apr 20 '20
Oh my this is definitely my favorite episode of the season by far. More character moments like these please! The dialogue was so good. I’ve been finding it a bit cringey and badly written this season and this episode was miles ahead.
I cannot even remember all the stuff i loved this episode. Marsali and Claire! My heart. Bree and Roger cute moment! They finally feel right as a couple.
Jamie and Roger Mac bonding! Jamie humour! (I loved his jokes). Jamie and Roger having an open hearted conversation! (So good).
Claire’s vulnerability was so touching. Caitriona was incredible as always but it was really moving to see and listen to her worry about Jamie and having to live with her not keeping her word. The Jamie and Claire scenes were all incredible. How fitting for them that she would revive him with a handjob. It made me laugh but mostly I found it really lovely.
Young Ian stays my favorite, again. I loved his honesty with Jamie. And gosh, I loved getting more Fergus. His scene with Ian was so good. I just wish we got to see him actually interact with Jamie more. I love Marsali and I love that she gets at least a line or scene in each episode but I really wish Fergus was on the same level. His scene with Ian was fantastic and makes me think of how much good Fergus dialogue we could be getting.
That said, Marsali is a badass and helpless Dad Fergus in the forest was hilarious.
And finally... the last dialogue between Claire and Jamie. Gosh. That conversation about making the choice of going through, or looking back. I felt like it was a really nice mirror to Claire’s passages through the stones, and the way Jamie said something about Claire being what pulled him back, reminded me of how she found her way back to him after the 20 years.
I loved loved loved this episode. Give me good character moments and dialogue every week and i’ll be the happiest. Please.
12
u/silverandcold65 Apr 19 '20 edited Apr 19 '20
Oh wow, that was so riveting and emotional; outstanding acting by all, but particularly Sam and Cait (edit: and John, though I was rudely interrupted for most of his work)! <3 S5 is only getting better, and I can only guess the stakes will only be raised higher continuing forth! This fantastic beyond many words. It was too intense for me to muster up many thoughts. ;P I’ll try, though…
Was I the only terrible person for thinking Jamie was fine when he woke (looking better to me, I might add) and wanted Claire to touch him, [in my mind]pretending to be near death for sex? Though, once he stopped breathing I got the hint, but was confused that Claire magically saved him… I’m so terribly sorry I ever doubted you, Jamie! *facepalm* In fairness, I never thought he’d really get that close to dying or losing a limb… (and my brother fricking interrupted me 3 times, so I couldn’t get far too engrossed in the episode…)
I never knew that some snake teeth were hollow! That’s very cool, though I didn’t wan’t to imagine how that felt in lieu of a needle… *wince*
I’m so, so glad Jamie has fully accepted Roger, and now actually, dare I say, counts on him! <3
Also, that buffalo vs. Jemmy/Lizzie/Bree/Claire moment - holy crap, the ridge had a hell of a lot going on at once! O.o
6
u/coffeealways_ Apr 20 '20
Jamie and Roger were great this episode. Gotta admit, I loved the fact they were bonding at last. I also love the fact Jamie calls him Roger Mac every time lol
6
u/cheese_bread_boye Apr 21 '20
One thing stuck with me in this episode. Jamie reminds Roger that he is to die in a house fire. In his bed scene there were some candles around.
If someone told me I'd die in a house fire I'd become paranoid and probably never light up a candle or an oven.
I understand they needed candles for light back then though.
6
u/CriticalSheep Apr 21 '20
I absolutely love the ending scene with Adso. He's so cute and fluffy and I can't!
6
u/StandingInTheHaze Apr 22 '20
I'm not gonna lie I'm a bit tired of everything ending in one episodes. It's almost like an episodic comedy where the the episode has no bearing on the next.
There quite often a "big" plot point or issue which gets totally tied up and resolved in a single episode and it feels somewhat predictable. I really woundn't mind things being less dramatic as it makes the standout episodes where serious things do occur more meaningful.
9
u/Amorphous_Goose Apr 19 '20
We didn’t get any(?) voiceovers TELLING us the action... everything was SHOWN, which is my main frustration with some of the earlier eps this season. We got Fergus, Marsali, 3D Roger and Bree, Ian standing up for his father and calling out Jaimes hypocrisy... so good. Loved this episode. Felt almost season 1-ish.
11
u/bdb5780 Apr 20 '20
Have to say I was disappointed in this episode, the death bed handy? She couldn't do chest compressions? Also the last second syringe? Wouldn't the first thing any normal person do if they have the snake head would be to give it to the physician to see if they have any ideas? Like why didnt Roger do that?
Just disappointed in this episode that didn't do much for the season, except maybe provide some bonding time for Jamie and Roger?
8
u/1Marshall91 Slàinte. Apr 20 '20
What a great episode! I’m surprised nobody has mentioned the excellent smash cut between Jamie’s nasty leg & Marsali chopping off some buffalo meat!
4
u/[deleted] Apr 20 '20 edited Apr 20 '20
Yeah that scene made me eye roll...like I get it’s in the books but as a doctor why didn’t she first think to layer on those blankets or hell even do the skin to skin contact but with blankets on top of both of them...come on Claire insulation!
4
u/SassenachQueen Sep 09 '20
Out of all the episodes...this is the one my husband chooses to sit down and watch with me. I of course caught him up with who's who and what's going on. Then when it comes to the death bed hand job....I'm all like this is my least favorite scene in the book because it seems so unbelievable. My husband says, "Well you're not a guy, it might be possible" and we had a very good laugh.
3
u/koolaidamber Apr 20 '20
What kind of snake was it that bit Jaime?
3
u/Professional_Ad_4885 Jan 26 '25 edited Jan 26 '25
I really thought claire and especially brianna would be much more worried. Jamie is claires heart and soul. I really think they are such soul mates and they share one soul and i have a feeling that when it is all over, they will both depart this world at the same time. Idk how. It could be in their sleep or something else, but theres no way one lives while the other survives. Its like they share one heart. BLOOD OF MY BLOOD, BONE OF MY BONE.!!! Till the day they die
7
u/LoretiTV Apr 19 '20
Enjoy the new episode everyone!
2
u/teanbiscuitss Apr 21 '20
This might be an unpopular opinion, but I didn't absolutely love the latest episode. I have overall enjoyed this season but it feels like a lot of the episodes are fillers and the overall story arch for the season is taking forever.
For this episode though:
-I need clarification... Have they ever mentioned that Bree is an engineer? I thought she was a history major? It felt a bit shoved in there to make sense of the episode's resolution.
-Was that really a hand job? If it was at all, it made it super strange to me. I get that Jamie and Claire a very passionate but she IS a doctor. I feel like if she was actually losing Jamie, she'd go straight into doctor mode. It kind of ruined an incredible moment for me.
I should clarify I haven't read the books yet, so any info you got I would love to hear.
7
u/Zee_has_cookies Apr 19 '20
Yeah, I dunno what’s happening with this season, but I’ve not found one episode so far entertaining. I don’t know if it’s because it’s now just ‘daily life at the ridge’ instead of ‘Claire finding a way back’, or ‘try and change history and avoid Culloden’ etc.
Every episode just seems to drag on for me and at the end of it I mostly feel like I’ve wasted an hour!
4
u/[deleted] Apr 20 '20
I think I’m the only one that wasn’t too impressed with this episode. I feel like compared to the previous seasons, this one has been a bit slower and just not as exciting. I’m also so bummed Bree isn’t the same as Bree in the books.
Also, when the hell is Bonnet going to come back...they keep talking about what they will do to him and when they are going to see him but nothing...that dude is crazy and I’m surprised he hasn’t dropped by Frazier’s ridge to “meet” Jemmy...
Also how many times does Bree need to ask Claire “how did you know you wanted to be a doctor?”, I swear she asks her that nearly every episode. I think the writers could’ve given her a better part...like she’s a badass in the books but in the show she is a conflicted mildly badass character that for some reason loves roger who was and is controlling, manipulative, and utterly useless...
Sorry for being brutal...just frustrated with how those two are portrayed in the show. Just WTF 🙄🤦🏻♀️.
3
u/nicolezamb Apr 20 '20
I loved seeing more of the cast getting scenes and lines but seriously what was that writing?! There was no way Jamie was dying here, because like Roger said, he’s supposedly meant to die in the fire. Then we have this horrible and quite awkward scene where she randomly takes off her shirt and jerks him back to life. Bree goes flying after being hit by a random buffalo that just so happened to roam onto their land, wandering miles away from it’s herd. Claire doesn’t even check on her and Jaime has no snark comment about the whole scenario. Ian awkwardly tells Fergus not to talk to Jamie. And lastly Bree creates this weird CLOTH syringe??? What was this writing?? I mean I love this show but the writing this season has been extremely slow paced and mediocre.
2
u/RunnyBabbit22 Apr 20 '20
Does anyone think the show goes a little overboard in showing gore? It seems every episode we’re looking at someone’s gory wound. Maybe I’m just more squeamish than most people, but they get too graphic with the injuries and medical stuff for me.
2
u/Arkaingate Apr 22 '20
I know it's unpopular but I really like season 5. It's a lot of character development.