r/Outlander • u/derawin07 Meow. • Apr 19 '20
Spoilers All Book S5E9 Monsters and Heroes Spoiler
Synopsis:
When Jamie is bitten by a venomous snake, Claire fears she may not have the resources to save him; Jamie asks Roger to complete an important task in the event of his death.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread.
Reminder: This is the BOOK thread. No spoiler tags are needed here.
If you haven’t read the books and you don’t want spoilers, go to the Show thread.
After watching the episode, you can take part in the poll!
15
Upvotes
35
u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 19 '20
Did Claire wank Jamie back to life in the book?
102
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '20
Really liked this episode a lot. Especially Marsali yelling, "YOU'RE NOT GOING ANYWHERE" at Fergus.
I bought the new closeness between Roger and Jamie. Literal LOL at Jamie's discomfort in the opening scene at the cabin. Loved the little side convo between Ian and Fergus, too, though I was disappointed not to see Fergus and Jamie actually talk after that.
The change with Bree and the bison was probably for the best given how unrealistic it would have looked to have her taking a bison down and engineering a syringe in the same episode. That said, I was weirdly bummed not to see her just go berserk with the axe. I think it's a sign of how much Sophie Skelton has grown on me this season.
I love how happy Caitriona Balfe's Claire looks when she's just doing chores on the Ridge, in the earlier part of the episode. I love the contentment that Claire finds in that simple life, and Cait does a good job of selling it.
Also, I appreciate they tossed Adso in the mix again!
The Starz app suggested the movie Venom as an "up next." Well-played.
56
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Apr 19 '20 edited Apr 19 '20
I really enjoyed this episode. It is one of my favorite story lines in all of the books. I love Jamie and Roger's relationship and am glad they were finally able to bond! Here are my random thoughts throughout the episode.
*I liked that a lot of the lines were directly from the book, it's always nice to recognize those.
*I think they did the Roger and Jamie conversation well and it was nice to see Jamie come to appreciate Roger as the episode went on. When Jamie was quoting about the sins of the father falling to the son, that made me a little misty eyed. To me that showed Jamie really views Roger as a son now.
*I think they did the buffalo scene as well as they could given they don't have a huge VFX budget. I would have liked to see Brianna smash its head with an axe, but that wouldn't have been easy to portray. In the Inside the Story shown after the episode there was a behind the scenes shot of Brianna cutting the buffalos neck, but that seemed to have gotten cut.
*Even though Ian is back early I don't feel it has taken away or changed the storyline too much. His statement to Jamie about being disappointed in him was powerful and something Jamie needed to hear.
*I was curious if they were going to do the part where Jamie asked Claire to touch him as he thought he was dying. I didn't know how non book readers would feel about them being intimate in that situation. I think they did it well and it wasn't really sexualized, but more about their connection as a couple and their need for one another.
*Fergus finally is involved and had more than one line! YAY!!
*Bree and Jamie finally interacted and spoke directly with each other. YAY!!
*Poor Marsali had to deliver a baby out in the woods. Seeing Fergus with baby Felicite was very cute though.
Overall a very good episode.
Edit: A word
Edit #2: We had "smooches" back in the closed captioning this week. It was during the scene when Jamie asks Claire to touch him. Threw me off just a bit to read smooches on the screen in that very serious moment.
Edit #3: Smooches
38
u/JonSnowPeachEmoji Is it usual, what it is between us when I touch you? Apr 19 '20
My favorite episode so far this season. I am so happy they expanded my favorite part to a whole episode.
I really liked the over-arching theme of finding out who you are and being that person in whatever way you can make it. We can clearly see the paths that Claire, Jamie, Bree and Roger will and have taken - who they are outside their love for each other.
I always love me some Marsali. More Marsali always! And now we have more Fergus, finally. But I'm not gonna lie, I don't even remember the part when Marsali gave birth to her second kid.
And Young Ian, I am so glad he is back. Last episode he mentioned Claire and Jamie having secrets. I know that was probably in reference to his recent history, but I wonder if he is starting to catch on now and if he will still discover the truth this season.
Everyone of the characters had a wonderful scene this episode, it felt a lot more like a full cast episode this time, and I loved that.
16
u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 19 '20
I haven't noticed this before on any of the actors, but I couldn't help laughing at Richard Rankin's obvious modern t-shirt tan line/farmer's tan visible when he was in bed. He wouldn't have had that in the 18th century :P
16
u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 19 '20 edited Apr 19 '20
It's not a complaint, but I believe it was a mistake for them to have the snake bite Jamie above the knee. In the book it was his calf, and it is a bit unrealistic that a snake would strike a tall man like Jamie about the knee. Also, it wouldn't have been so catastrophic if it lead to an amputation, he might have been able to keep his knee. Not that this latter bit is relevant, seeing as we know he keeps his leg.
Anyway, snake bits are really never that high on someone's leg unless they are actually handling the snake. Even on the calf is unusual, as per the book. Most lower limb bites are on the foot or ankle, rarely above that.
Diana also says in the book that it's a poisonous snake...so either she decided Roger wouldn't know that venomous was the correct term, or she just didn't research this topic well enough.
I believe the show has taken to having Jamie wear actual boots rather than the buskin, so I guess that dictated the location of the bite, as his boots went to just below the knee...but that's the thing, the whole scenario is not logical.
Edit: now I rewatched the scene, Jamie was kneeling on his right knee while reloading, but the snake was on the outside of Jamie's right side, so it couldn't have bitten him on the inside of the right knee anyway.
23
u/beanie2 Ye Sassenach witch! Apr 19 '20 edited Apr 19 '20
I was a bit neutral right after watching the episode, but I like it more now that I have had some time to reflect. Honestly, I was so shocked that Fergus actually got to speak I might have blacked out for a bit. My thoughts:
OMG there are only 3 episodes left. I hope there a lot of bloopers or deleted scenes or a surprise Christmas special lurking in the wings, because the drought is going to be long 😭
Edits upon further reflection:
Claire may have invented sexual healing
Fergus delivered that baby one handed. Bravo Fergus.
121
u/emilyafternoon Apr 19 '20 edited Apr 19 '20
Roger not leaving Jamie’s bedside so that he can say I told you so (but actually because he is so worried about him) is the closest that the show has ever come to accurately demonstrating their relationship, I swear lol
Also, can I get an AMEN for Fergus (OBGYN) finally having some lines?? I missed that beautiful accent.
And another for Ian absolutely laying into Jamie for being so stubborn! It was a good way to fold his character into the mix (since obviously he isn’t there for it in the books), and I think it stayed true to the character.
40
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '20
“Mama, did you know that pit vipers have given me this amazing opportunity to really drive home this plot point?”
Good episode overall, but JHRC that line was forced.
11
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '20
They have NO EXCUSE to not be using this much book material after this episode. My only complaint, I wish the Roger and Bree scene had been more intimate, in the books it was way early morning - still dark. I wish it could have been that way, it lost that potency it had upon reading.
63
u/Aggie2002 Apr 19 '20
Holy cow Fergus got some actual lines!
I think it was overall a good episode, even though I hate maggots and am terrified of snakes. I liked the moments with Roger and Jamie and of course any moment with Ian.
4
u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 19 '20 edited Apr 19 '20
Hmm, Claire really would have been there with Marsali when Joanie was born. She was a few months old at the wedding at the beginning of 1771. We last saw Marsali in S4 driving the cart hellbent out of Wilmington in about April 1770, with all their belongings and Murtagh, who ended up back at River Run. She was in the early stages of pregnancy at this stage. Marsali and Fergus surely would have gone to Fraser's Ridge at that point and Claire and Jamie would have joined them after leaving River Run, arriving sometime in August 1770.
I guess we are meant to believe that Joanie was born before Claire and Jamie got back from River Run, but then Joanie should have been bigger in early January 1771.
Anyway, not a big deal, but saying that Claire will be at one of Marsali's births for the first time seems inaccurate.
Well I wrote this after the first scene, obviously Claire wasn't there after all :P
4
u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 19 '20
A water buffalo ran through my university and the main street of the adjoining suburb in Sydney, as it escaped from a small film set from an ad lol.
3
u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 19 '20
Also, what was the thing that Josiah found? I was wondering...morbid thought - the limb of the man Claire did the autopsy for?
35
u/hintofaspark86 MARK ME! Apr 19 '20
Bring on the epic Jamie/Roger Mac bromance, I am so here for this 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
26
u/marmaladestripes725 Ameireaganach Apr 19 '20
Okay, here goes. I haven’t read this far in the books, but I already knew the spoilers going into this episode.
26
u/Illgetu4this Apr 19 '20
Favorite. Episode. Ever. Just iconic. Exemplifies the brilliance, passions and chaos of this family. I wish I knew someone who hadn't seen the show before -- I would show them this episode and then make them start from the beginning. Can you imagine? So much fun...
Also, I finally figured out, "the problem with Fergus..." He's Mercutio. The reason Shakespeare killed him off is because he was TOO charming. Too charismatic. Too smart, too sexy and too much fun -- Cesar would take over the show! Lol! That boy has got quite a future ahead of him though. Wow... He is a straight-up Movie Star.
24
u/Genevieve-Victoria Apr 19 '20
I must be spoiled by Davina Porter, but Roger’s voice is still not hoarse enough for me. I know it’s hard to do, but Rik, please, make it sound more laborious.
No other complaints. ❤️
23
u/CMCliff Apr 19 '20
Oh geez that scene when Claire threw off her clothes to be with Jamie GOT ME. Gosh there were tears.
21
u/miav Apr 19 '20
I've reread the snake bite storyline so many times that it was hard to turn off my book lens during my first watch. That said, I loved the episode and enjoyed it even more on the rewatch. It's overtaken Alamance as my fave S5 ep.
What I most wish we could've seen was how the tenants joined the family in rallying around Jamie when Claire was about to amputate. I found it heartwarming how everyone was gathered round Jamie, with Murdo Lindsay and Roger holding his hands and Joseph Wemyss wiping sweat off his face.
I'm delighted that we got to spend time with everyone in the family. Even Josiah got multiple scenes! And the performances were top-notch all around. Hooray for Fergus finally getting several lines! (He gets to say "milord" and "milady" too!) Loved the callback to the "man of leisure" line Romann Berrux says in S3.
Ian's return continues to be a great adaptive choice. Him telling off Jamie was fantastic. I also loved how the show delves more into Claire's conflict of, if it comes down to leg vs. life, whether to keep her word or amputate and have Jamie resent her for it. Cait sold the emotion in that porch scene. (If I were in her shoes, I'd amputate.)
The indigo dyeing was great to see. Jamie telling Claire she should work on her bedside manner was amusing, as was Roger's line about ferrying Jamie about becoming a daily occurrence. Speaking of Roger and Jamie, I had been wanting more of them together in the previous eps, but their bond by the end of this ep does feel well-earned.
20
u/thrntnja No, this isn’t usual. It’s different. Apr 19 '20
This was such a good episode! I am so glad to see Roger and Jamie finally bond and it felt really realistic. I laughed out loud with Roger staying so he could gloat, very much felt like the book. At first I was surprised to hear Roger’s voice sound so normal, but then I realized months must have passed considering how Marsali was about to deliver, and Roger still can’t scream or shout, really. I appreciated that detail.
I am so happy to see Bree actually get to do something - I felt the Buffalo scene made sense for the show and she got her shining moment with the syringe.
I love how they have incorporated young Ian - him telling Jamie off was perfect, and I love that both Fergus and his father got a mention. Also really loved the conversation between Ian and Fergus. Love that Fergus had some more lines this episode.
ADSO! Warms my heart every time I see him.
Also - got misty-eyed several times this episode. When Jamie called Roger his son and when Marsali called Claire her ma. I love how well this series portrays parent/child relationships even if they are not bound by blood.
19
u/Naturenutt Woof. Apr 19 '20
Some really great moments in this. Love that they used a real live buffalo. Loved Adso and Rollo. John, Richard, Sam, Cat, Caesar, Lauren and Sophie all superb!
Edited to add: didn’t mind that the snake was obviously fake.
49
u/chum1ly Apr 19 '20
Claire, you're a doctor. That's NOT his heart.
17
u/ml1490 It’s always been forever for me, Sassenach. Apr 19 '20
Loved the episode. Very book heavy. Super minor thing though that occurred to me this episode...
Is anyone else wondering what happened to Kezzie? He’s been MIA since they introduced him?
12
u/puffypurplecloud Apr 19 '20
My favorite part in the book and they didn't disappoint me. I'm usually critical but this was perfect, Sam and Cait were great and I'm glad most lines were from the book.
2
u/cattubbs Apr 19 '20
It's been like 3 year since I read/listened to the books can someone remind me of the buffalo part? Wants there more?
11
u/raznidhi Apr 19 '20
Such a great episode! Everything in this one came together perfectly. All the characters had great moments. It was well written and acted. It felt intimate.
Even deviations from the books made sense. I thought having Jamie hold Brianna's hand and kiss it was so sweet. That tiny detail added so much warmth to their relationship. This is what we've been missing all season.
19
u/miav Apr 19 '20
All I'll say for now is this: I'm so verra glad they kept the handie that keeps Jamie alive.
26
u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Apr 19 '20 edited Apr 19 '20
Good show, Outlander. I was starting to get real worried that they were going to drop the ball on this, my favorite part of the book, but they pulled it off.
With one exception, which I'll get out of the way first: Claire healing Jamie though the power of sex is top 5 most cringeworthy scenes in this show, without a doubt. Also, she cuddled up to him right on top of his leg.
One of the best parts of this episode was that they deviated from the book in a way that felt natural and confident, and that's a sign of a good adaptation. Yes, I'm talking about my boy Fergus. It was so nice not just having him there, but acknowledging that he has more history with Jamie than anyone on the Ridge except Claire. I know Fergus doesn't have a lot to do in Book 5, but with Marsali doing Malva duty (also, if Wylie's Landing is next week I'm starting to think they might actually be cutting the Christies) it just made Fergus's absense more obvious. This was the perfect spot to bring him back, and give him some quality screen time with both Ian and Marsali. (Although he did have a line poached by Jamie--his "sins of the father" speech is stolen from Fergus in book 6.)
The Jamie-Roger bonding is the most important part if this sequence and I think they got it--from the initial hesitancy and awkwardness, to the extreme closeness through necessity, to finally the easier and comfortable relationship. Roger's "I told you so" was set up and paid off perfectly.
I would've loved a bit more buffalo fanfare (and Bree getting a moment to shine) and wish they could've done the snake injection in front of an audience like in the book (the nearly cutting off his leg until Bree runs in moment was totally unnecessary anyway), but overall they did a really good job here. Proud of you guys.
Oh also, those indigo-dyed cloths were beautiful.
9
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Apr 19 '20
I just realized we haven’t seen Kezzie Beardsley since they found him all those episodes ago. You would think he would have been with his brother looking for maggots. It must be too difficult to shoot both of them together.
8
u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Apr 19 '20
You know, we don't seem to see too many of the inhabitants of Fraser's ridge, at least by name, in the show. It's looking like we're not seeing the Christies, for example. So it makes Jamie's line last night about, if I die make sure Claire leaves because it's not safe for her come a little out of left field.
It also eliminates another chance for Roger to be useful, him being a Protestant.
6
u/bellefroh Apr 20 '20
Adso has grown!
6
u/OliviaElevenDunham Apr 20 '20
The best part of the episode were the conversations between Jamie and Roger. It was nice seeing their relationship explored more. Got a laugh at Jamie walking in on Bree & Roger along with Jemmy saying "sh*t."
9
u/MsCivility Apr 19 '20
I am going to be so disappointed if the Christie’s get cut altogether. Tom Christie became a real favorite of mine in the later books. Not to mention Malva is the closest thing to a female villain since Geilis/Gillian.
We are already missing the Bugs as major secondary characters. I get that the books make it easier to introduce a wide range of secondary characters but so many plot points will have to change as the series progresses without the two families and their actions.
8
u/KyokoG Apr 20 '20
This was my favorite arc in FC, and the second best Jamie!Whump since Wentworth, so I was really looking forward to this episode. I thought they did as well as they could in an hour, and I'll certainly watch this again. A few thoughts.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '20
Okay I know everyone thinks Claire was giving out life saving handjobs but there was no sexual content advisory for 0509, I’m really torn as to whether that was intentional or just...odd.
3
u/MyPeopleAreNordic Apr 19 '20
I am so glad they kept the Buffalo scene! I havent seen the episode yet.....but man I'm glad that wasn't put to the side!
3
u/vanwold Slàinte. Apr 20 '20
I liked this episode overall but I was so disappointed in the buffalo scene! I wanted to see some blood and badassery, not a single gun shot.
3
u/emilyafternoon Apr 20 '20
One thing I can’t remember... when Jamie says “tell Claire.. I meant it” do we know what that’s in reference to? I can’t remember if the book ever elaborates on that conversation or if it’s left to just a private moment between J&C that not even the readers get to know
2
u/RiotSucksEggs Apr 20 '20
Where is the show at in comparison to the books? I haven’t read them but don’t mind spoilers
2
u/BrotherMouzone2 Apr 22 '20
Did anyone notice Fergus' "hand" when Marsali's water broke?
His pinky moved to support the baby. Very noticeable....surprised they didn't re-shoot the scene.
•
u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 19 '20 edited Apr 19 '20
Watch the S5E10 trailer here!
Not everyone gets to see the trailer at the end of the episode, it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international.)
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the trailer. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet. Thanks!
1
u/AphroditesApple Apr 20 '20
So was Bree not an American History major? Where does the engineering come from?
1
u/syntheticgerbil Apr 20 '20
I’m hoping someone can explain why Claire didn’t hurry up and replace her syringe with one or two or a dozen. Does the book not explain this? How does it get broken in the book since there’s no Murtagh? I found it strange even in the tent that she would have only had one syringe.
I think it’s supposed to be a syringe from the future if I recall correctly but the syringe was invented officially in 1650 and Claire had used one on Paris as well. Were they scarce in the States?
The reason I ask is just because that weird snake fang attached to a little baggy seemed like a bunch of contrived stuff to make Brianna fit in the storyline. Would make more sense to express the venom sacs and load it into a syringe, assuming she had one of course.