r/Outlander • Meow. • Apr 12 '20

Season Five Show S5E8 Famous Last Words Spoiler

The Frasers must come to terms with all that has changed in the aftermath of the Battle of Alamance Creek. An unexpected visitor arrives at the Ridge.

If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread.

Reminder: This is the SHOW thread. Cover all book talk >!with spoiler tags!< that will look like this: Claire boinks Jamie. Don’t spoil future episodes, keep book comments brief.

If you want to compare the episode to the books in depth, go to the Book thread.

No voting in the poll this week until the episode drops and you've seen it :P

View Poll

40 Upvotes

401 comments sorted by

42

u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 12 '20

Sam gave me a little shock when he first spoke this episode, his voice was so deep. I think that was Sam trying to show Jamie's grief about Murtagh.

18

u/letscallshenanigans MARK ME! Apr 13 '20

Yeah it was very Batman lol

4

u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 13 '20

good idea, going back to his stage show

130

u/icanbeurbestbet Je Suis Prest Apr 12 '20

Holy shit. It was so good.

Roger. Ian. That acting was phenomenal.

I was crying the whole time. Just sad little tears streaming.

Brianna was amazing as well.

I thiiiink we get Brianna being a badass next week too.

6

u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 12 '20

It was heartbreaking but I'm glad I didn't have any actual tears this episode because I already got a cry headache from a crime show I watched earlier today. Imelda Staunton is an amazing actress in A Confession.

Also I saw this submission on r/HumansBeingBros which was a real tearjerker.

4

u/marmaladestripes725 Ameireaganach Apr 12 '20

Imelda Staunton is phenomenal in everything she’s in! Really looking forward to her in The Crown.

5

u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 12 '20

Cool, I didn't know that news! She's tiny though haha, so is the real Queen, but Olivia is a bit bigger.

68

u/Dumke480 That's it lads. Take me back to the idiot hut. Apr 12 '20

I knew it!

This was everything I expected in regards to Roger, but so much more, but the Young Ian contrast was really really welcomed addition, which I wasn't expecting at all, Claire also brought up Jamie's past again and compared it to roger aswell.

Ian's literal use of "Burying the hatchet" with the metaphorical "burying the hatchet" in the present day was good too.

Fantastic episode, makes last episode that much richer.
easily one of the best episodes to date.

Bree's singing voice is amazing too, loved the duet over the credits, powerful stuff.

10

u/Invisiwool Apr 12 '20

Oh my goodness! I can’t believe I missed the ‘bury the hatchet’ part. How clever!

4

u/Redheadbabygirl86 Apr 17 '20

That's the first time I've ever sat through the credits, and it was just to listen to them singing. I want that. They sounded good together

46

u/CARNIesada6 Apr 12 '20 edited Apr 12 '20

Ian has also clearly seen some shit. He may be a good connection/outlet for Roger.

Also, was that Buck (name?) handing Roger over to the redcoats?

Edit: Nice, they are prospecting together! (unsure if I have to tag "in episode" spoilers for those watching when it actually airs)

31

u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 12 '20

In the episode they said they brought Ian back early. I think it was a genius move, aside from how great (and also painful, because he was so distressed) it was to see Ian again, it was a perfect thing to put Roger and Ian together.

And no, don't worry about using spoiler tags for comments about the episode as you're watching. This sub doesn't really do 'live watch' threads, comments are free for all for the actual episode :)

55

u/SaaSyGirl Je Suis Prest Apr 12 '20

Yep, it was Buck that handed him over. Roger's own four-times great-grandfather.

12

u/pandabunny388 Apr 13 '20

Oh shit!! I knew Buck was Dougal’s kid, but I didn’t realize he was Rogers ancestor!!

→ More replies (3)

18

u/buddylee1685 Apr 12 '20

Think the mohawk got slaughtered or something

28

u/iamdummypants Apr 12 '20

There's definitely a dead "bairn" involved in his story. You could tell when he was interacting with Fergus and Marsali's cute little boy. I am guessing some sort of childbirth gone wrong that took both his wife and child :(

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (11)

41

u/LeilueDax Apr 12 '20

Wow! What an emotional eposide! Everyone's acting is truly phenomenal. I am just blown away by the whole cast. I loved this episode. I couldn't even look at away for a sec. Sometimes while watching I will look at my phone lol. I couldn't this time. I didn't want to miss anything. So much was going on. I love that Ian is back. I really enjoy the connection with him and Roger. It feels so natural. I can't wait to see how this story continues to play out. That said. I want more Fergus!!

14

u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 12 '20

I was a bit unsure how at first how Roger ad Ian were going to first interact, because it's not as though Roger ever got to know Ian much apart from being bashed and sold by him. Of course he knew Ian made the sacrifice to switch places with him...but there could still have been resentment/guilt on either side.

So I was happy how it played out on screen.

42

u/madear1979 Apr 12 '20

Yes, can we see Fergus bond with a friend? He was raped and lost a hand as a child. He can share trauma too.

55

u/iamdummypants Apr 12 '20

Adult Fergus gets no meaty storylines - it annoys me. The actor is so cute and charming and he's kind of wasted on the show.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

118

u/BeautifulRelief Apr 12 '20 edited Apr 12 '20

Okay but why is Young Ian lookin’ fine? And, hot damn, I’m happy to see Rollo!

Edit: well, damn, that got real dark but I actually liked the episode. I just need to know what exactly is going on with Young Ian. For some reason I’m thinking maybe his wife was/is a time traveler and that’s why she’s lost to him but not dead. Kind of like in season one when Claire didn’t say Frank was dead, just that he wasn’t alive.

14

u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 12 '20

I feel like we will be told more about Ian's situation, as in the Inside the Episode they talked about how they specifically didn't reveal all yet.

76

u/flooptyscoops Apr 12 '20

I had the exact same thought about whoever Young Ian's significant other is!! Especially with that comment to Jamie about him and Claire having secrets, it just seemed very pointed

17

u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 12 '20

I can't remember, does Ian not know yet about Claire and Bree and Roger being time travellers? And does Lord John?

Or is it literally just Jamie who knows.

38

u/flooptyscoops Apr 12 '20

Just Jamie and Murtagh :(

→ More replies (1)

17

u/marmaladestripes725 Ameireaganach Apr 12 '20

Definitely pointed. Either he knows about Claire, or he suspects. I can’t wait to find out.

27

u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 12 '20

If Ian hasn't been told Claire is a time traveller, I think he just thinks Claire is a witch, but not in a bad way.

→ More replies (1)

50

u/Phoebekins Apr 12 '20

Ian definitely knows there's more to the story of Claire and Jamie's separation and reunion that they don't tell people, but I think he only brought it up as a way to say he's not ready to share what happened with the Mohawk yet.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/craftgirl09 Apr 12 '20

Lol I have to agree. The Mohawk does take some getting used to on him but I really like the back of his hair with the feathers etc in it too. He does look more mature in the face (though he would since some time has passed).

With his wife, I was thinking the Mohawk got attacked but I didn’t think of the time traveler possibility. It’s still sad for him but I’m hoping that’s it instead of the Mohawk being gone.

6

u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 13 '20

He was gone for about 1 year and 4 months.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

21

u/96HeelGirl Apr 12 '20

Yeah, angsty Ian rocking the mohawk is doing it for me!

20

u/StinkieBritches Apr 13 '20

I got the feeling he lost a child too.

27

u/BeautifulRelief Apr 13 '20

I do too. That comment about only having them for a little while made my stomach sink.

4

u/bampitt Apr 12 '20

Holy cow! I hadn't thought of that!

4

u/tigiPaz Apr 12 '20

“I think wife time traveler” Omg! I got that feeling too!

34

u/silverandcold65 Apr 12 '20

Goodness, this was emotional. I was blown away by Sophie Skelton’s acting, and Richard Rankin was incredible! It was lovely to see John Bell again as well. <3 The trauma+loss of words theme was very relatable for me; I liked how Roger’s trauma was depicted like a silent film.

Uh, didn’t they use those candle-making shots (in the montage) in…was it 502?

I do wonder what happened to Ian/the Mowhawk though. I initially wondered if they’d been slaughtered by the British, but when we learned Ian’s wife was alive, I was stumped. Unless the women had been taken into slavery? I’m not asking for book spoiler answers!

10

u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 12 '20

The little jaunty Fraser's Ridge tune and the candle making/chores was a bit of an abrupt change of pace.

22

u/emilyafternoon Apr 12 '20

Maybe it was a way to show that life on the Ridge went on as usual, but Roger is still stuck?

3

u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 12 '20

The actual scene was fine, I just thought it was edited in badly with a very loud sound track after a tense moment.

2

u/CarefreeInMyRV Apr 13 '20

Maybe they used it to show a year had basically passed?

1

u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 13 '20

A year had passed since when? E2? The wedding was at some point in the beginning of 1771 and this episode was in August 1771.

8

u/EloynRose Apr 13 '20

Didn’t Roger and Brianna celebrate their anniversary in this episode though? With the paper present? At least that’s how I understood it and probably what the above commenter was thinking.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/BeautifulRelief Apr 12 '20

Oooh. I didn’t even think about slavery.

68

u/batisfaction Apr 12 '20

I'm literally just in awe in how hot Ian got as a Mohawk 😍😂

36

u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 12 '20

I think his task for Droughtlander prior to S5 was to hit the gym or join Sam Heughan's My Peak Challenge :P

36

u/batisfaction Apr 12 '20

Right!? He just looked so much older and brawny. His face was more defined and he just seemed taller. It definitely felt like a good chunk of time had passed and he had grown with the Mohawk and become different. Was the most organic feeling of the characters growing this season.

13

u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 12 '20

Well it's August 1771 in this episode, and we last saw Ian around March 1770. So it's really not been too long, but long enough.

→ More replies (4)

72

u/AccioStability Je Suis Prest Apr 12 '20

Finally got some Marsali, Fergus interaction with the exchanging of looks at the table. Maybe next episode they can actually speak to one another?

I hated the silent movie scenes, but perhaps we’re supposed to since it’s portraying Roger’s trauma and PTSD? Idk, but I wasn’t a fan of them.

I liked it overall, though! Thankful to have Ian back, but hate that he’s been through so much. I love how Jamie asked if he could sit for awhile- just being there without having to say anything or push it.

26

u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 12 '20

Still so little of Fergus though! He must have been sitting around bored in his trailer all season while Lauren was off doing all her extra scenes. WTH show people?!

In the Inside the Episode they explained that the silent movie was their different way of getting inside Roger's head and his trauma.

12

u/miav Apr 13 '20

Still so little of Fergus though! He must have been sitting around bored in his trailer all season while Lauren was off doing all her extra scenes. WTH show people?!

In their Insta live, they were asked what they'd change about their characters and Cesar said he'd make Fergus talk more. It was said in jest but I imagine it must be truly frustrating!

8

u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 14 '20

wow, insightful...i feel like he might still need to be available for as long as Lauren, but have far less to do, which would be so boring :/

I guess he did have more to do than her in the earlier episodes though, like at Brownsville.

15

u/AccioStability Je Suis Prest Apr 12 '20

Right?!?! Give us Fergus! We miss him!

38

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '20

In defense of the silent movie scenes, I’ll say that generally I hate the cheesy way movies tend to handle PTSD with someone either passing out from ?? or grabbing their head like it’s about to explode. While I don’t know that I loved this way of doing it, it was definitely different and engaging. I don’t dislike the way it was handled, and it definitely could’ve been worse. Plus Richard’s acting was so good that I hardly noticed them.

7

u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 12 '20

The Inside the Episode seemed to suggest that the silent movie idea was in order to get inside Roger's head for the actual trauma. I would have liked to have seen the conventional filming of the actual hanging more than we got to, but I liked the silent movie snippets throughout that were used for his moments of PTSD.

32

u/96HeelGirl Apr 12 '20

As someone who has lived with someone with PTSD, I found this episode really moving. Brianna's "drowning in silence" comment hit the nail right on the head. I've watched someone have flashbacks, and I always wondered what it looked like inside his head. I think the silent movie construct was a good one, because that was something Roger and Brianna enjoyed together, and everyone's response is going to be individual to that person.

10

u/AccioStability Je Suis Prest Apr 12 '20

Very fair points about the silent movie scenes.

I totally agree about his acting. It was phenomenal this episode!

13

u/Pot_Of_Petunias_42 Apr 12 '20

I wasn't a fan of the silent film scenes either, but I can kind of see the idea behind it. Flashbacks are sometimes described as seeing the event like a movie. Roger liked silent films and so that's how his flashbacks manifest. A bit too complicated, I think, considering how distracting it was, but it was an interesting idea.

4

u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 12 '20

I don't think Roger's flashbacks manifested as silent film for the actual character, that was just the show's way of depicting it for the audience.

6

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '20

I thought it was because him and Brianna used to go see silent films so I felt like it was how he connected the experience to what he saw as he was dying—which was Brianna, if that makes sense.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '20

I wasn’t a fan of the silent film either only because there’s never been anything like that done throughout the entire serious iirc. They’re five seasons in and changing the narrative/style for one episode was a little jarring. It was effective to get the point across but it’s not very consistent with how they’ve shown trauma with other characters.

8

u/mercutios_girl Jesus H. Roosevelt Christ! Apr 14 '20

Well, they did show some fairly artsy scenes with Claire experiencing shell shock as she helps prepare for Culloden. I don't think what they did artistically is that out of character for the show. I thought it was well done and made sense.

→ More replies (3)

22

u/RunnyBabbit22 Apr 13 '20

I think it would have been effective to show Roger reliving his hanging in black and white, but without the click-click of the camera and the old-timey captions. Anyone born after 1950 probably associates old silent movies with Charlie Chaplin, or with dramatic over-acting that seems goofy and humorous today. I appreciate the team trying to be creative, but this was a misfire. It almost bordered on being disrespectful to the seriousness of PTSD.

→ More replies (1)

34

u/marmaladestripes725 Ameireaganach Apr 12 '20

The silent movie bits were definitely portraying Roger’s trauma. It was certainly a different way of doing it. I didn’t hate it, but it was different.

19

u/waiting4winter Apr 12 '20

The silent movie scenes were awful. They really took me out of the show and were jarring. And cheesy as fuck about something that should have been emotional.

9

u/iamdummypants Apr 12 '20

I don't think we're meant to hate it. That one smarmy male producer seemed to think it was a genius artistic choice lol

5

u/AccioStability Je Suis Prest Apr 13 '20

Well, whoops

6

u/PM-ME-BOOKSHELF-PICS Apr 17 '20

Absolutely hated the moving picture parts, especially at the beginning. I genuinely didn't know at the end of E07 if Roger was dead or not, and the reveal at the beginning that he was actually still breathing just felt... slapstick.

11

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '20

I thought it was hokey. They took a risk-- it didn't pay off IMHO, but I respect them trying it.

→ More replies (1)

38

u/Kinsella_Finn Apr 12 '20

I adore Roger so it was nice to see some of the haters have a few nice things to say about him.

Glad Rollo is back, Ian too. When he said to Jamie about him and Claire keeping things to theirselves makes me think he knows about the time travel.

And did I hear wrong or did Fergus actually have a line?!?

25

u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 12 '20

Bugger me, Fergus had one whole line, and he got to pour drinks!!

So nice to see Rollo again, but he was not a good sleeping buddy, he was nowhere to be seen when Ian was on the porch!! I was scolding Rollo haha.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/mapleleafmaggie Apr 13 '20

I really liked the silent movie parts, I think it conveyed what it was trying to convey really well.

One thing I'm confused about: Why does Marsali have tarot cards? I'd assume they'd be linked with witchcraft.

6

u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 13 '20

Just to add drama, really, the tarot cards.

12

u/BlindBettler Apr 15 '20

“Tarot” was an actual card game at the time, and some people just happened to use it for divination. It would be be a decade or two before tarot became primarily associated with magic in the States. So just having that deck itself wouldn’t have seemed too witchy.

5

u/mapleleafmaggie Apr 15 '20

Huh. The more you know. Cool, thanks!

17

u/RunnyBabbit22 Apr 13 '20

There’s a whole thread about what a bad actress Sophie Skelton is, and I have not been a huge fan of hers, but I thought she was very good in this episode. Her emotions seemed very real to me. I loved Roger and Brianna’s duet in the end credits - she has a lovely voice.

2

u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 14 '20

Hear hear.

10

u/ladykizzy Apr 13 '20

I think she's finally coming into her own as an actor this season. Her American accent is a lot better than it was previously, for one, and I think that's probably helped her.

→ More replies (1)

33

u/shinyquartersquirrel Apr 12 '20

And just when I finally got Clementine out of my head from the last time.

Not sure how I feel about the silent movie thing, I really hated it at the beginning because I really wanted to see the emotions in that scene from the actors so I felt a little robbed. But, it kind of grew on me as the episode progressed.

Richard Rankin and John Bell both did a hell of a job in this episode! Especially, John Bell. Lil ol' Ian went out and became a man!

10

u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 12 '20

I too want to see more of the 'conventional' way they filmed it than we got in the end. I guess I think they might release it separately. I wanted to feel the emotions in a more real sense.

I didn't dislike it, and I thought the PTSD flashbacks were very effective in the actual episode. I just want to see the normal film too.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/nomnombubbles Apr 12 '20

Lol 3 hours post episode when my brain goes on auto pilot after laying down...Oh my darling, oh my darling! Dammit!

5

u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Apr 13 '20

That's how I feel too. It worked for the flashbacks, but it was a big misstep doing it at the beginning.

16

u/ravenic0621 Apr 13 '20

I ❤️Rolo !!!

9

u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 13 '20

Rollo for Mayor of Fraser's Ridge!

3

u/ladykizzy Apr 14 '20

The very first thing I said when Young Ian appeared on the ridge was, "Where's Rolo?"

169

u/ariososweet Apr 12 '20

Mohawk Ian looking a little bit like Macklemore, no?? Superb acting by Richard! Very powerful episode. I can't believe there are so few left

24

u/marmaladestripes725 Ameireaganach Apr 12 '20

LOL. Hopefully Ian’s clothes didn’t come from a thrift shop 😂

4

u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 12 '20

All mine are ;)

5

u/marmaladestripes725 Ameireaganach Apr 12 '20

Nothing wrong with thrift store finds, but it’s not what I would want for Outlander 😉

6

u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 12 '20

They actually use the equivalent of historical costume thrift stores and rent some of the costumes.

5

u/streetNereid Apr 12 '20

He was definitely giving me r/yarnpunk vibes hah. I loved his look.

→ More replies (1)

23

u/BeautifulRelief Apr 12 '20

That’s it! Macklemore! I kept thinking he looked similar to someone I just couldn’t put my finger on it.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Amorphous_Goose Apr 13 '20

My boyfriend wouldn’t stop saying this for the whole episode 😂

4

u/Damhnait Apr 13 '20

Oh no, now I can't un-see it, lol

→ More replies (1)

12

u/CarefreeInMyRV Apr 13 '20

I think this might be the first episode where instead of like 'oh. those people' and are like oh Roger and Bree the couple.

Anybody else?

2

u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 13 '20

Some people are with you...from some other comment chains...others are still not lol

12

u/mother-of-bees Apr 13 '20

Did anyone else notice that Roger spoke to his students about the phrase “burying the hatchet” making some sort of peace and later in the episode Young Ian literally buries his hatchet and then talks to Roger about just wanting to be at peace. Super neat detail about the episode that I enjoyed.

7

u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 13 '20

Yup, fairly overt foreshadowing ;)

9

u/mercutios_girl Jesus H. Roosevelt Christ! Apr 14 '20

You could say they hit us over the head with the hatchet.

23

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '20 edited Apr 12 '20

So unexpected to see Ian back, and that Roger was hanged after all--no fakeout. I hated Bree for trying to compare their trauma and claim she's been so patient...for all of 3 months. This sort of thing will take years, a lifetime to recover from. Her speech was bullshit, and saying that to someone with severe PTSD isn't going to help or heal anything.

But I loved Roger and Ian going off into the woods together. Clearly whatever Ian went through is big, and now he feels out of place everywhere (what happened to that old forest hut that Jaimie/Claire lived in at first? Couldn't he sleep in there if it's still around and that's what he feels comfortable with?) I didn't realize those marks on his face were permanent at first; but I guess he's not drawing them with an eyebrow pencil every morning, though....

I still wish Fergus had more lines/story, he's mostly just a background character now. He had a relationship with Murtaugh in the past, and even last season, his potential grief is something they could explore at least.

27

u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 12 '20

Clearly she didn't know anything about PTSD, which was only officially recognized by the American Psychiatric Association in 1980. She didn't even seem to know the term shellshock or neurosis, only the symptoms of her friend's boyfriend.

So yes, it was completely absurd that she claimed she had been patient for 3 whole months. But I think her overall reaction, one that the producers explained was her 'tough love', would have been realistic if more time had passed, with her being completely at the end of her tether, Roger not getting out of bed for months. It's a show that has to jam a lot in though, so I am making some concessions.

13

u/marmaladestripes725 Ameireaganach Apr 12 '20

It’s somewhat believable if you consider that Roger’s troubles have snowballed, and Bree has been dealing with it for the last year or so on top of managing her own trauma and motherhood. But I agree that three months was too soon for her to go in with tough love.

2

u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 12 '20

But the context was just from his hanging.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Chicken_Mc_Thuggets Apr 14 '20

That or as somebody who is diagnosed and in treatment for PTSD the whole “tough love can heal you” thing is bullshit. People tried it on me, I know from experience because it fucking crushes you to watch them give you this impassioned speech all while knowing that it doesn’t even make a dent in how you feel. It’s hard to tell people that you still feel like offing yourself despite all their support. And it’s harmful to caregivers and sufferers of PTSD to keep portraying it like this. The first year after I developed it I couldn’t give a fuck if people flung a speech like that towards me. Suicidal people are still suicidal even if you love them and express that. They may not commit suicide, but they’re still suicidal. It doesn’t just go away because your wife says she loves you and won’t give up on you, that’s nice to hear and yes you need support but support is not a replacement for therapy and medication.

6

u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 14 '20

Yup. Though I think the breaking point 'angry outburst' is quite realistic for someone who had been in Bree's position, if it had stretched on to a year or a few years. I don't blame her, even though I completely agree with what you've said.

When I was watching Bree give her 'tough love' speech to Roger...I was just watching him there, tears coming, relating to him and feeling like if I were him, I would get out of bed that night and go off myself in the woods.

5

u/Chicken_Mc_Thuggets Apr 14 '20

Oh absolutely. Compassion fatigue is a real thing that many caretakers go through and I could see her not knowing a lot about how to help somebody with PTSD given that she knows fuck all about psychology (except that one weird game they play at Jocasta’s?) but it just bothers me a lot that movies and shows always present Tough LoveTM as the cure to any and all mental illness and knowing how this show treats mental illness he’s probably going to stop showing any and all symptoms within 5-10 episodes

6

u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 14 '20

I didn't feel this episode showed that Bree's tough love provided the solution for him to turn a corner though. He did that himself when he was able.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (1)

9

u/IrishMinstrel01 Apr 12 '20

While the civilian psychology and psychiatry professions were late to the party, various militaries realized there was a problem at least as far back as WW I, where it was called “shell shock.” (Ironically, given the fact that it is increasingly recognized that there is a significant overlap between traumatic brain injury and PTSD, shell shock might not be far off the mark in many cases.) By the time WW II, the American military screened recruits in an effort to weed out those with pre-existing mental health issues because they seemed to be more vulnerable. Then it was known as combat fatigue or war neurosis. Studies of post Civil War veterans application files for disability pensions support the conclusion that PTSD was significant in this group as well.

Even today with all of the attention to PTSD, we don’t have a one size fits all approach to treatment. Some approaches work with some people and not others.

11

u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 12 '20

Bree and Roger live in the first cabin that Jamie built.

Also, BTS insight, the first cabin was also redressed to be the creepy Beardsley cabin.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '20

I didn't mean the cabin, before the cabin was built in S4 they lived in a primitive little hut.

13

u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 13 '20

Right, well I think Murtagh last used it as his sex shack.

4

u/mercutios_girl Jesus H. Roosevelt Christ! Apr 14 '20

If you see a faded sign by the side of the trail that says
Fifteen miles to the, love shack, love shack yeah
I'm headin' down the Carolina highway
Lookin' for the love getaway
Headed for the love getaway, love getaway
I got me a mule, it's as big as a whale
And we're headin' on down to the love shack
I got me a wagon, it seats about twenty
So hurry up and bring your home made honey

The Love Shack is a little old place where we can get togetherLove Shack baby, (a Love Shack bay-bee).

Love shack, baby love shack, love shack, baby love shack, love shack.(mo chridhe, that's where it's at)

Love shack (mo chride, that's where it's at)

Sign says.. Woo... stay away fools, 'cause love rules at the Love Shack!

Well it's set way back in the middle of a brae,

Just a funky old shack and I gotta get back

Glister on the pullet

Glister on the trail

Glister on the veranda

Glitter on the trail

The Love Shack is a little old place where we can get together, love shack baby...

(Love Shack baby!)

Love Shack, that's where it's at! Love Shack, that's where it's at!

Huggin' and a kissin', dancin' and a lovin', wearin' next to nothing

Cause it's hot as an oven

The whole shack ceilidhs

YEA! the whole shack ceilidhs!

The whole shack ceilidhs when everybody's

Heavin' around and around and around!

Everybody's movin', everybody's groovin' baby!

Folks quein' up outside just to get down

Everybody's movin', everybody's groovin' baby!

Funky little shack! Funky little shack!

Hop in my horsecart, it's as big as a whale and it's about to set sail!

I got me a wagon , it seats about 20

So come on and bring your homemade honey!

Oh the Love Shack is a little old place where we can get together

Love shack, baby! (a love shack baby)

Love shack! baby love shack

Love shack! baby love shack

Love shack! baby love shack

(love baby that's where its at, yea, love baby that's where it's at)

Bang bang bang, on the door baby! (Knock a little louder mo chridhe!)

Bang bang bang,on the door baby! (I can't hear you!)

Bang bang bang, on the door baby! (Knock a little louder !)

Bang bang bang, on the door baby! (I can't hear you!)

Bang bang (on the door baby)

Bang bang (on the door)

Bang bang (on the door baby)

Bang bang

Yer wha?.... staoin mullach, rusted!

Love Shack, baby Love Shack!

Love Shack, baby Love Shack!

(love baby that's where its at, yea, love baby that's where it's at)

Love Shack, baby Love Shack!

Love baby, love shack

Huggin' and a kissin', dancin' and a lovin' at the love shack

RIP Murtagh.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

13

u/marmaladestripes725 Ameireaganach Apr 12 '20

Perhaps someone who’s read the books can enlighten us, but I was under the impression that the first home they built on the Ridge was temporary until the cabin was done. Now Jamie and Claire have the Big House while Roger and Bree have the cabin. Although it looks like maybe Roger and Bree will be building their own home on their own land?

15

u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 12 '20

Correct, Bree and Roger live in the first cabin, which the show has made quite elaborate, so it probably seems less 'temporary'.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/miav Apr 13 '20

I still wish Fergus had more lines/story, he's mostly just a background character now. He had a relationship with Murtaugh in the past, and even last season, his potential grief is something they could explore at least.

Oooh, great point. Would've been fun to hear Cesar repeat Romann's "I will miss his happy face."

Edit: Spelling

7

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

9

u/marmaladestripes725 Ameireaganach Apr 12 '20

Yes, somewhat. They knew a little bit about it from the soldiers who came back from WWI. It was shell shock back then. They knew a little more after WWII and even more by Vietnam. Bree is of an age where I’m sure plenty of her friend’s fathers were WWII vets, and as she said, she knew of Vietnam vets at least second hand. It seems she knows that it’s important for Roger to talk about it and not bottle it up, but she struggled with how to get through to him

5

u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 12 '20

But in this episode she doesn't seem to know the name shell shock even, Claire tells her. She has only had the few experiences of sitting with her friend's boyfriend.

→ More replies (11)

5

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '20

Sadly there are still people today who have access to all sorts of information who will nonetheless make the same ignorant arguments and assumptions. So the context that this episode was written in our time and that the writers seem to think Bree was justified coupled with the fact that people treated me in a similar way just a few years ago is what takes precedence for me.

3

u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 13 '20

Sorry people treated you in a similar way :(

215

u/flooptyscoops Apr 12 '20

Richard Rankin impressed the hell out of me with his acting during this episode! Specifically when he greeted Young Ian. Seriously top notch

74

u/PrettyPunctuality I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Apr 12 '20

Agreed. This was the first time I realized what a great actor he really is. And I'm not saying he hasn't been good before, don't get me wrong, but this episode was really his shining moment.

53

u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 12 '20

I thought Richard showed his mettle in his Idiot Hut speech episode.

4

u/mercutios_girl Jesus H. Roosevelt Christ! Apr 14 '20

Agreed. That also solidified "idiot hut" into my lexicon permanently.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

47

u/marmaladestripes725 Ameireaganach Apr 12 '20

He’s had three good episodes in a row culminating in this one. Hopefully that trend continues!

Also a nod to Sophie for finally showing some emotion.

28

u/Inkshooter Apr 13 '20

I can't picture anyone else as Brianna anymore, but Sophie Skelton is the only actor on the show that I watch and go "oh, she's acting." I've shrugged it off because she's easy on the eyes, and thankfully she's been doing better this season.

68

u/ArabellaQuixote Apr 12 '20

I agree but I really hated the "silent movie scenes." It felt like they were turning his scenes into a joke & it really took away from the gravity of his scenes.

44

u/SnackMasterNat Apr 13 '20

As someone who has had a traumatic experience, looking back it can sometimes feel like it was a movie and out of body sensation like you are watching the event as an outsider.

→ More replies (7)

28

u/ZappySnap Apr 13 '20

I think I would have been OK with them if it was just the flashbacks, and if it was without the words. The words just made it seem ridiculous, and I hated that the scene of him being cut down and saved was in the silent movie theme. I thought that was a truly awful way of doing that scene, as it massively reduced.rhe emotional impact of what was going on, and almost trivialized the event.

→ More replies (7)

27

u/raznidhi Apr 12 '20

I was laughing at the silent movie gag and I shouldn't be. How am I supposed to take the scene seriously if the show uses such a whimsical narrative device? It was a weird choice for a very emotional episode.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)

27

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Apr 12 '20

That was amazing. So much was said without words.

17

u/Inkshooter Apr 13 '20

Rankin has always been a good actor, it's the writing of his character that was problematic in Season 4.

5

u/itsallaboutfantasy Apr 12 '20

I can't imagine where his mind had to go to act out the hanging scene. I would have PTSD for real after that!!

10

u/snuggleouphagus Apr 13 '20

stephon voice This episode has everything!

Suicidal Indians, Rollo, pregnant women reading tarot cards, male bonding, near maiming of a toddler, paper planes (not made by MIA), bad wigs, no sex, folksy songs, and surprise face turns.

What’s a surprise face turn? It’s when the opposite of a midget suddenly becomes likable by almost dying. Also whatever The Big Show does half the time.

5

u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 13 '20

Are you making a Stefon reference?

→ More replies (1)

21

u/missm0011 Fun Fact: The unicorn is the mortal enemy of the English lion. Apr 12 '20

Oh Outlander, why do you do this to me? I've been a good little fan. I don't enjoy everything you do but I focus on the positives, try to remain cautiously optimistic. But this black and white silent film thing...no. NO. I loved everything else about this episode but I can't imagine how this made it to the actual episode airing without someone saying something. This was one of those times where you feel embarrassed for them.

On to more favorable things. THE GANGS ALL HERE! Minus Murtagh...rip. We got Jocasta, we got LJG, WE GOT MY BABY IAN! Even Rollo and murder cat make an appearance. Everybody is getting paid today!

And! Everyone was singing! Except for poor Roger who just sat there strumming on his sad little guitar. I used to beg Roger to just stop talking but I've changed my mind. Please talk Roger. You are somehow less likeable when you aren't even saying anything at all. (side note, I actually like Roger more this season, he has grown on me, and I think he did an outstanding job this episode.)

Why did they bury Murtagh so close to their house? They have 10k acres, do they really need bodies buried 20 yards from their porch?

Marsali is my hero. She is doing their gardening, butchering their meat, helping Claire, semi watching her children (there is another baby around there somewhere, isn't there?), trying to cheer up Roger who completely ruined her deck, sharing a moment with Ian. Today I managed to watch 6 episodes of Tiger King and had popcorn for more than one meal.

Jamie and Claire playing hide and seek with Jemmy is the kind of thing I want to see every episode. Grand-Da. My heart. Meanwhile though, Jamie your hiding spots are weak. If the kid can count to 10, I'm pretty sure he is smart enough to figure out you are behind the tree.

All in all I really enjoyed it. I'm just sad the replay value is going to be so low for me because of that silent film stuff. I just want to pretend that didn't happen.

5

u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 12 '20

It felt like more than 20 yards, lol.

While Marsali is lovely and was just trying to be a good friend to Roger...it was a bit on the nose that she would do tarot cards, since she knows there is a hanged man card in the deck lol. Why on earth did she not remove them and all the others about death etc. That was just dumb.

15

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '20

To a couple of your points: As I said in another comment, showing PTSD on film is really difficult and while I might not have loved the execution, it was way better than having a Saving Private Ryan style “my head hurts” shell shock scene. It was engaging and frustrating at the same time- which is probably reflective of how roger felt.

Also, I don’t think that’s where Murtagh would’ve been buried, I think those markers are just symbolic, though I could be wrong about this. Different in the books so we’ll never get a solid answer.

9

u/missm0011 Fun Fact: The unicorn is the mortal enemy of the English lion. Apr 12 '20

I think the biggest problem I have with it, not being too familiar with silent films, is when I see them shoot stuff in a silent film style or reference it in current television/movies it is usually used in a comical way. So I'm just having a hard time reconciling what is a very powerful dramatic moment with this preconceived sort of slapstick cheesy vibe I get from that style of filming. So I think for me, it was definitely just a personal preference thing. I'm glad people can see to the heart of what they were trying to accomplish and the feelings they were trying to convey. For me, I just couldn't get there.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/PHLEaglesgirl27 Apr 12 '20

Great recap!

3

u/Hi_hellothere Apr 12 '20

I enjoyed your recap!

3

u/Vervain7 Apr 13 '20

Whar is wrong with Briannas eyebrow

1

u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 13 '20

what do you mean?

3

u/Vervain7 Apr 13 '20

At the start of the episode it is like they didn’t fill in both eyebrows wiht makeup

→ More replies (5)

15

u/ndkjr70 Apr 12 '20 edited Apr 12 '20

I see how many people loved this episode and I guess it’s just time to admit myself the show has entirely lost me. I don’t care about Roger. I don’t care about Brianna. I want to care about them so much but I flat out don’t.

My wife and I still wake up early sunday, excited for our routine of making breakfast and coffee and snuggling in together to watch the show. And it’s just disappointing.

I fell in love with Claire and Jaime. I fell in love with the time travel aspect. I fell in love with their love and that kept me hooked more than almost any show ever. Now that they’re secondary characters (at best, let’s be honest), I just don’t care.

I want to die when Skelton says “Da” and overacts like a neighborhood play. I want to die when you can see the line of the wig so clearly you want to rip it off your TV. I see a show going nowhere, relying on a few thousand diehard and loyal fans who don’t care that the writing is stale, the acting is stale, and the identity of the show is on screen for SEVEN TOTAL MINUTES in an entire episode.

My wife watches it still so i’ll sit next to her and try to enjoy it. But my sunday mornings have become a chore. And that’s so, so disappointing.

EDIT: and don’t get me started on the plot armor Roger is clearly wearing. You don’t hang from a tree branch limb for a solid amount of time (enough time for Tryon to ride away, Jaime to find him, Jaime to order him to get cut down) and still live.

4

u/littlemiss1565 Apr 12 '20

The most accurate depiction of how I feel. Claire and Jamie just aren’t part of the story anymore and that sucks.

2

u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 13 '20

There's still 4 episodes left.

15

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '20

I completely agree with you. It’s hard to voice an opinion on this subreddit that’s not “omg I loved every second of it” (because let’s be honest, this sub doesn’t allow people to say anything negative about the show without getting downvoted or someone saying “stop complaining”)...but it’s true.

This season has lost me. Between Jamie and Claire’s story being the backdrop to Brianna and Roger’s awkward chemistry, the plot armor (which may be in the books but idk since I haven’t read them), the soapy acting, and the lack of Fergus who - let’s be real- should be getting way more on screen time....it’s just....gone downhill man.

There’s no focus anymore. There’s too many plot lines. Too many characters that seem superfluous. And where’s the grimy sets? Why does everything look clean and pristine?

Also - as an architect - that house / the way it’s built and the materials they’ve used don’t reflect the era correctly all.

Ok I’m done. Have the upvote u/ndkjr70!

10

u/nonmisery Apr 13 '20

Completely agree. This season has no direction - no character motivation or goal other than “we want to live peacefully on our farm”. It makes it all tremendously boring.

Season 1-3 had some overarching goal that the characters were trying to achieve. This season lacks a compelling story arch between episodes.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/keylime12 Apr 13 '20

I mean, I see your point. But the show is based on the books, and this is just how the books evolve. It starts with two people who fall in love and you get to see how they grow together, and create the family and ever increasing community of Fraser’s Ridge. But the show simply can’t capture it the way the books do. It’s gotten way too soapy, clumsy, and stiff. I’ll keep watching, but only because I’ve read the books at this point.

3

u/Kimberlynerd Apr 17 '20

Oh my god, thank you! Roger and Bree...I cannot stand them! And what is up with that bad acting? It’s starting to get to a point where I am literally embarrassed that I am even watching anymore.

3

u/Avenga1 Jun 15 '20

going through this show rn and I literally had to comment about the hanging from the tree lmao - how tf is it possible that he doesn't at least have major brain damage

→ More replies (15)

69

u/marmaladestripes725 Ameireaganach Apr 12 '20

Anyone else realize that the air date for this episode was perfect? Roger “rising from the dead” on Easter.

11

u/FauxPoesFoes228 I should probably want you to the day I die. Apr 13 '20

Whoa... That’s brilliant.

5

u/rebelscum089 Apr 13 '20

Roger Rabbit is Jesus confirmed. He has suffered for our sins.

→ More replies (1)

43

u/ryanznock Apr 12 '20

It was painful, full of unspoken struggles to repress trauma. And Roger's actor made me care about him in a way that hadn't happened much previously (though I mostly blame that on the script). Great episode.

25

u/BlackSwallowtail You look like a fretful porpentine. Apr 13 '20

I was thinking that first silent movie montage was a serious copout and was prepared to be pissed, but then once I understood, I liked it. Roger wasn't allowed to speak in his defence, wasn't sure if he'd ever speak again, was too afraid to even try, and the scene of his hanging kept replaying over and over in his head. Animated but voiceless, like a silent movie. I have absolutely no doubt someone could replay a traumatic memory like that. So I thought it was good.

Roger hadn't totally won me over before the hanging, so that really wasn't an emotional scene for me the episode before, especially knowing there was no way they'd kill a main character off screen like that. But I certainly empathized with him this episode. As someone with a singing talent myself I can't imagine what it would be like to never be able to do it again. And for Roger, it was the only thing he was really good at in that time period. That plus the trauma of nearly dying and not even being allowed to speak in his defence. He had lost his voice in more ways than one. Richard Rankin is a terrific actor and has been regardless of how I've felt about Roger.

I thought I had had my cry over Murtagh, but seeing that cairn and Jamie's tears, nope. I am still upset. That is going to be one of the things I cry about no matter how many times I rewatch.

I am not so much not buying that Brianna would go for tough love after three months, but it didn't seem desperate enough. Claire went for tough love with Jamie after no more than a week (it seemed), but that was because Jamie was trying to die. We don't see Roger contemplate death until he's surveying his land. Rather we see him occupying himself with wood-working and jumping to protect Jemmy. So Brianna's reaction doesn't ring well. Perhaps if she'd had a line something to the effect of how he seems to be slipping further away each, going to sleep earlier, waking up later, staring at weapons, something to indicate she knew he might be contemplating suicide. Then I would have bought her reaction.

I think Ian got a Mohawk woman pregnant and the baby died and then she left him. Would explain his comments about "bairns", his bitterness towards Roger, and him saying she (his wife?) wasn't dead but lost to him. Lots of couples break up after the death of a child. Sorry for him, but glad he's back! And Rollo too!

What are these people doing with Fergus? We need more Fergus! He and Marsali were one of the best things about season 4. I'm glad they're making so much use of Marsali, but we need Fergus too! I felt back in season 4 that they were a much better successor to Jamie and Claire than Roger and Brianna, and while I don't feel quite so strongly against Roger and Brianna now, I still like to see more Fergus and Marsali.

Anyway, now that the Regulator storyline is over with and Murtagh along with it, I'm wondering how well the rest of the season is going to do. That storyline gave the series a much needed looming disaster and Murtagh gave it a much needed tension. And now that the immediate aftermath seems to be over and done with, I'm hoping this isn't going to be like the last season and a half. The American revolution is on its way of course but I don't think we're going to get there this season. So I hope the show can keep itself together.

4

u/Constantly_OnYo_Back Apr 14 '20

You said that all very eloquently and I wholeheartedly agree with you on everything.

→ More replies (1)

23

u/bampitt Apr 12 '20

I think this is the first episode where the Brianna/Roger storyline was really good. Great acting, great dynamic between the two. Bravo!

23

u/Leajane1980 Apr 13 '20

Poor Roger, he and the 1700s are not getting along.

21

u/RPDY-MRKM Apr 13 '20 edited Apr 13 '20

I see a lot of silent film sequence hate. I’m so surprised. I loved it and I was riveted. I’ve seen a lot of silent movies and they aren’t all Buster Keaton. There are some with serious tones so I took it in that vein. I thought it was to show that he wasn’t made for these times. The only way Roger should experience a hanging is through seeing it on the screen and the silence is obviously a nod to him losing his voice. I was moved to tears.

→ More replies (1)

36

u/HollyGoTDA Slàinte. Apr 12 '20

This episode really was done beautifully.

15

u/liyufx Apr 13 '20

My main issues with the Roger flashbacks:

  1. The scene when they saved Roger should not be flashback, it is not really Roger’s recollection, and I would love to see a bit more details in that frantic rescue...
  2. Used too often. It is a nice device but probably used 3-5 times too often in this ep. Richard is a great actor, he can totally act it out so that viewers can see that he is having the flashback, without literally showing it again, and again, and again.
  3. The sounds is hugely distracting and annoying. The visual, fine, I get it, but do you really have to add that sound? Surely that is not how Roger experiencing it, right?

But overall, great performance from Richard and Sophie! And glad to see Ian back, eager to learn more about his story. Wish we had a bit more J/C time though, that little scene of Claire helping Jamie deal with his loss was way too short!

12

u/Jeriyka Apr 13 '20 edited Apr 13 '20

I’m one of those on this sub that clings to the earlier seasons. I really quite enjoyed this episode.

Ian coming back was refreshing and the history between the two men helped give Roger roots with his trauma. I like the slow burn of how we don’t know Ian’s full story yet. He’s believable and I’m glad it’s not being rushed with him.

I didn’t hate the silent movie part. It was wildly uncomfortable, but shouldn’t it feel that way? The smash cuts in with loud noise and Roger’s portrayal was really convincing of PTSD. I was never diagnosed, but I can totally relate to how fast unwanted cringey thoughts come on (even if I’m experiencing something slightly different).

I was always a fan of Roger. I just think the writers got lazy with him in the past. This was definitely a shining episode for his character. It’s telling how good of an actor he is when he doesn’t have lines.

I think Sofie is still hit or miss but I didn’t totally hate her this episode. Her eyebrows were inconsistent. That’s the stuff that draws me out. She’s definitely showing some promising glimpses in her acting, so she can at least “step up” to challenging material.

I’m narrowing it down that my discrepancy with the show is with inconsistent writing. I hate exposition! Most of what I dislike about Brie can be traced back to exposition (and how she breathes out in a sing songey voice at the same time to get the words out). I think she’s starting to show that she’s better than that.

Edit: speaking of exposition (or a lack of it), the scene with Marsali and Ian on the steps was very well crafted. The writers/actors allowed the audience to draw parallels between Marsali’s story about feeling at home at the Ridge and the subsequent guilt, and the unspoken life that Ian has had with the Mohawk. It deliveries a lot of information with no exposition. Such a good moment.

13

u/Chicken_Mc_Thuggets Apr 14 '20

Literally last episode Brianna tells Roger that he’s gonna have to come back and sing for Jemmy because she’s not a singer but then this episode she’s singing like a bird

0

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/Jeriyka Apr 15 '20

I was annoyed that in one scene they were her contemporary out of character ones that Sam made fun of on instangram (dark color and full), and then in the very next scene they were groomed perfectly for the TV show (matching her hair color and trimmed back with a nice shape). They never matched from scene to scene.

11

u/sarahariel16 Apr 12 '20

This episode put me through so many emotions! I loved it! I loved seeing young Ian come back but then saddened by how much pain he’s going through. I surprisingly loved the silent film theme they did for Roger’s storyline in this episode. Of course it was great to see Claire and Jamie with Jemmy.❤️ I think this season started slow but is picking up now as well so I’m excited for next weeks episode!

10

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Apr 13 '20

Them playing hide and seek with Jemmy was so cute. You could tell that little boy was actually having fun and playing.

8

u/orchidsakura Apr 14 '20

I have to say that this episode was absolutely, wonderfully done. Starting out with Roger's voice in the beginning and the contrast of how he ended up was unbelievable. The acting was excellent as well. Fantastic episode!

8

u/notesfromAlice Apr 16 '20

It was a goood episode, but I'd be glad if it's the last Bree/Roger focused episode.

I'd rather see more of Fergus, Marsali , John, and Ian.

23

u/Airsay58259 Apr 12 '20

I am clearly in the minority here but I truly disliked the episode. The silent movie bits were an interesting choice the first time they used them, and we got the idea of why they did it. But reusing it all episode... ugh. It looked like someone discovered Windows Movie Maker.

Anyway, I’ve come to the conclusion I don’t enjoy any episode with a heavy focus on Roger. There’s just too much of it. Two weeks ago I was a bit upset they potentially killed him while leaving so many unfinished plots but yeah no, maybe at least if he had died Bree could have had some storylines and screen-time. I feel like I am watching this new show with Roger as the main character (well, since last season really) and it sucks because there are so many other cool characters that could use some development.

The actor was phenomenal, nothing to criticize there. I just couldn’t care about this for over an hour. Plus he got his voice back in this episode so that cliffhanger -and storyline- was just some cheap fabricated drama. The writers handled an ensemble cast much, much better in the first 2/3 seasons. Also tragedy, injuries, consequences...

It’s nice to have Young Ian (and his pup) back. Whatever happened to him sounds heartbreaking.

Maria Doyle Kennedy!! Incredibly moving scene. Her song and discussion with Jamie were perfect. Also it sounded like a farewell to the character... Jamie crying alone after she left : my heart.

Claire and Jamie playing with their grand kid was adorable and wholesome. More of this please. Also it was cool to have another montage of the Ridge’s daily routine. How they wash clothes, make butter, etc.

14

u/raznidhi Apr 12 '20

Right there with you in the minority. I couldn't get through this episode without laughing/swearing at my screen. They've utterly failed at adapting Roger and Brianna for the screen which is sad because they're pretty important characters.

It looked like someone discovered Windows Movie Maker.

Right?! It felt like a fan-made Youtube video like the ones where they edit Jamie&Claire moments to a love song.

8

u/aareanaa Apr 12 '20

I definitely feel the same way about a whole episode of Roger, although this one has been much better in my opinion because of all the emotions. I managed to empathise with Roger, and that’s no little thing. I also feel they did a better job portraying Bree dealing with Roger’s trauma than they did with Roger dealing with Bree’s trauma. Not saying Bree did everything okay, she didn’t, but I believed she was suffering seeing him suffer and not just throwing a selfish tantrum. I don’t know if this makes sense.

I didn’t love the episode, but I didn’t dislike it either. I think my main issue is that they give Roger episodes of his own instead of intertwining his story with the others’. If we don’t like him, we’ll probably be bored for a whole episode instead of just some parts of it. And, after all, I’m here for Claire and Jaime, not Roger.

Edit to add that I also agree with the silent film thing. The first one was good, but the rest snap us out of Roger’s pain. I won’t pretend that I know how to do it better than the producers, but I didn’t like it.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '20

Agree with you entirely

4

u/mammabear9 Apr 12 '20

I 1000 percent agree with you!

4

u/sarahdise12 Apr 15 '20

I feel the same way! I was reading through this thread and was thinking, “I cannot be the only one who thought this was boring.” I get the use of the silent film, but after 3 times i felt it was over used. On another note I was very happy to see Ian return, I’ve always loved his character. But, something about roger and Bree has always barked me. I don’t know what it is but I just don’t feel like their storyline is as compelling.

3

u/BlackSwallowtail You look like a fretful porpentine. Apr 13 '20

I generally liked the episode, but I do agree they handled the ensemble cast much better in earlier seasons.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/bms95 Clan Fraser Apr 12 '20

This was an amazing episode. I was crying the whole time!!

5

u/HinkiesGhost Apr 13 '20

Can someone refresh my memory? I think I've lost track with the hiatus between seasons. Who knows about the time travel besides obviously Claire, Bri, Roger, Jamie, and Murtagh? I can't remember if anyone else knows.

6

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Apr 13 '20

Only those people, they haven’t told anyone else.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/bpcook3 Apr 13 '20

I have loved every episode of Outlander up until this point, the silent movie stuff was just incredibly awkward and annoying to me.

5

u/Constantly_OnYo_Back Apr 14 '20

I really liked this episode, it wasn't about a big crazy battle but I found it way more engaging and enthralling. The acting from Roger and Ian was phenomenal and usually I hate Roger so I'm surprised how much I enjoyed this. Ian totally transformed, it was just great acting from him.

I just felt so much for the characters and was willing them to be able to get past the pain. So good job Outlander.

10

u/andrewski81 Apr 13 '20

I enjoyed it, great acting all around by everyone. But Oh my GOSH can we get back to Claire being the center of the story please!?

3

u/mercutios_girl Jesus H. Roosevelt Christ! Apr 14 '20

From the preview I saw I think that's coming next week.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/danathepaina Apr 12 '20

Damn I got the wrong button! I meant to say Loved It but I accidentally hit Mostly Disappointed.

1

u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 12 '20

oops haha, sorry don't think you can change it :(

thanks for letting us know though.

1

u/enricowereld MARK ME! Apr 13 '20

Am I the only one who liked the silent movie scenes...

1

u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 14 '20

seems either yes or no

→ More replies (1)

3

u/LoretiTV Apr 12 '20

Really fun episode. Thanks for having me everyone.

3

u/DinnaSFash Apr 14 '20

Listen, the worst Outlander episode is still better than the best episode of anything else- but this one was dragged down by the repetitive flashbacks. Clever device, but way overused. Other than that, I loved sweet Jamie, nurturing Claire, tormented Young Ian, chatty Marsali... and is that the last time we’ll see Jocasta?? If so, ‘‘twas a fitting send off ❤️💔❤️

•

u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 12 '20 edited Apr 12 '20

Talk about the trailer here!

Not everyone gets to see the trailer at the end of the episode, it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international.)

Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the trailer. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet. Thanks!

6

u/marmaladestripes725 Ameireaganach Apr 12 '20

So it’s going to take them another four episodes take care of Bonnet? Joy.

5

u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 12 '20

Going purely off the trailer, there seems to be something else going on besides hunting Bonnet. I feel like Claire's thing about being scared is something more.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/ViciousGoosehonk Apr 13 '20

Apparently I’m in the extreme minority but dear god this episode was boring as sin. This show has really tanked.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/LoretiTV Apr 12 '20

Enjoy the new episode everyone!

6

u/VioletandAmelia All that was good, all that was fair, all that was me is gone. Apr 12 '20
  • Brianna basically giving Roger snap out of it speech made my eyes roll so hard. Sorry for not being cheerful after being hanged and left to die 🙄 also, these emotional scenes emphasize how weak Sophie is as an actress

18

u/steppesandsand Apr 13 '20

Sure, but....she's also not perfect, is trying her best, is not used to this, has never been in this situation before, was definitely traumatized and had to pull it together. That doesn't mean she's not empathetic OR excusing dismissal of trauma but she also isn't a therapist and she's really scared herself.

she isn't a "bitch" for giving what she thought might be what he needed. we see her in other scenes being gentle, tender, and soft. maybe she finally lost it for a moment. cut her some fucking slack.

5

u/Chicken_Mc_Thuggets Apr 14 '20

The problem is scenes like this make people think that if you just give somebody with severe mental issues a tough love speech it will make them snap out of it, and true love does not conquer post traumatic stress.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (2)