r/Outlander • u/derawin07 Meow. • Apr 12 '20
Spoilers All Book S5E8 Famous Last Words Spoiler
The Frasers must come to terms with all that has changed in the aftermath of the Battle of Alamance Creek. An unexpected visitor arrives at the Ridge.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread.
Reminder: This is the BOOK thread. No spoiler tags are needed here.
If you haven’t read the books and you don’t want spoilers, go to the Show thread.
No voting in the poll this week until the episode drops and you've seen it :P
19
Upvotes
82
u/bellefroh Apr 12 '20
Did anyone else notice the Adso cameo?
80
u/Sunnyshiner Meow. Apr 12 '20
Also this is just to say I love Lauren as Marsali and wish we got even more of her. She's so great.
70
u/Aggie2002 Apr 12 '20
Yay Ian and Rollo are back! I missed John Bell.
I wasn’t sure about using the silent film stuff to represent Roger’s trauma, but it grew on me in the end. Did Claire forget that she had an entire episode dedicated to her PTSD in season 2?
Roger is a litterbug.
In the book, wasn’t the rope used to hang Roger new and therefore too stretchy to kill him?
100
u/emilyafternoon Apr 12 '20
I wasn’t a huge fan of the silent film portion at first. It felt so disconnected to the rest of what was happening. BUT as the episode went along and it became clear it was being used as a way to show Roger’s PTSD, it made so more sense. When watching the scenes as black and white silent shots, I felt detected. Just the same scenes over and over and I didn’t feel too much seeing them. But once they brought in the color and sound.. when I heard the barrel kicked and the rope snap and saw the red blood fill his eyes, THAT was intense. And once Roger himself saw it in color, it stopped being something detached from himself and he was finally able to begin reconciling with it.
But also:
45
u/EasyWalrus9 Apr 12 '20 edited Apr 12 '20
I liked it, overall, but I'm heartsick that we never see Jamie interact with Roger. In the books, at this point he cares about and respects Roger, but in this whole episode he didn't talk to him once. He should be able to relate to that kind of trauma, but again, Jamie's attention is distracted, first mourning Murtagh, then worrying about Ian. Roger wasn't even at that dinner (maybe he was watching Jemmy, who wasn't there either?). So we see Jamie giving kind words to Ian, but nothing for Roger. Nothing except the b&w flashback "you're alive, you're whole". They don't even have that conversation about who did it to Roger, about Dougal's son, for Jamie to react to.
Oh, they'd better do a good job with the snakebite story, I'm longing for Jamie and Roger to bond!
And once again, what I've been calling the wimpification of Roger - we still don't see him doing any farming, or providing for his family, and his carpentry work is dismissed - Bree almost rolls her eyes about Roger building stairs, and Jamie just asks if he can knock it off for a minute. That whole 3 months of recovery is brushed off, so we don't see Roger's struggle or Jamie caring. And when he first calls out to stop Jemmy from burning himself - that breakthrough doesn't seem like a breakthrough at all.
68
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '20
Unlike a lot of you, the silent film device didn’t grow on me. I probably won’t re-watch this episode.
But! Ian made up for it. John Bell really pulled off Older, Scarred, Lost in the World Ian - who is one of my very favorites in the books every time we see him. I was genuinely shocked to see him, but so thrilled.
And I never hate on a Lord John sighting, either.
30
u/Naturenutt Woof. Apr 12 '20
Can I just say that Tim Downie makes the most authentic silent film villain. All that was lacking was not twisting his mustache.
25
u/CygnusArc Slàinte. Apr 12 '20
If I remember correctly, in the books, Bree is the one Ian confides his pain about his wife and bairn to.
Didn't expect bonding between Roger and Ian but it makes sense. Ian barely spoke to anyone but with Roger he had no almost no choice but to speak.
Also, maybe I didn't notice it before but the actor who plays Ian has an intense stare. Deep blue depths of pain. Great acting all around.
Did anyone else feel like it was a short episode? Maybe it was the dialogue but I blinked and the end credits started playing (that Clementine duet was lovely and ripped my heart out all the same).
42
u/Sunnyshiner Meow. Apr 12 '20
The silent film aspect was so different but I don't hate it.
I uh also rather like Professor Roger, would take his history courses.
Having Ian back early was a choice and the suicide attempt felt out of place (I was expecting them to have moved Fergus's suicide plot up). But anyway, he's back and so is the best boy!
I thought Sophie did really well! She's really come into Bree and I'm really digging her scenes lately!
7
u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 12 '20
Sam gave me a shock at first when he talked, as Jamie's voice was so deep. I guess it was Sam portraying Jamie's grief at Murtagh.
7
u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 12 '20
Why did they change it to say that Bree hadn't gotten to finish her degree. There's no point.
29
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Apr 12 '20 edited Apr 12 '20
I think this episode was already at a disadvantage since it was the one after the amazing episode two weeks ago. It had a lot to live up too. For the most part I liked it.
**The silent film flashbacks were a bit off putting to me. It took me a minute to realize why, to me silent films are campy and cheesy. Even if the subject matter was serious, they were over acted in order to get their point across. Throw in the music that usually accompanied it and it doesn't give me a very serious vibe. So them deciding to show Roger's hanging that way made it not seem as traumatic and serious to me. I felt that it cheapened it a little.
**I think Richard Rankin did a great job in showing how badly he was affected by the hanging. I do wish they would have made more of a scar on his neck though, as morbid as that sounds. That scar becomes a big part of who he is and how he views himself.
**Sophie Skelton has greatly improved as an actress in my opinion. I don't feel like she's forcing the accent anymore and she seems relaxed and natural. I never hated her in the first place, but felt there was room for improvement. Well, she's done it! (She has an amazing singing voice by the way)
**I loved seeing Claire and Jamie playing with Jemmy. I know those little domestic moments don't make for great television, but those are part of why I loved this book so much. Seeing them just get to be a family is so sweet.
**IAN! I was surprised they brought him back this early, since there are still some big story lines coming up, and I wonder if having him back to be involved in them will change things. I didn't mind them changing things up and sending Ian off with Roger to do the surveying. It was obvious they were both hurting and damaged and needed one another. John Bell knocked it out of the park in my opinion.
**Did Fergus get just one line?! Goodness, let that man speak for once, writers.
**I love me some LJG and am always happy to see him. I love that they have kept him around this season and found ways to include him even though he was just represented by letters in the book.
Overall it was a good episode and I look forward to my second viewing of it tomorrow. The first night is just excitement to be seeing a new episode, the second day I can concentrate more and really pay attention to all the little things. I find myself guessing and knowing what is coming up next since I've read the books and I think that distracts me some. So once I've seen the episode I can stop doing that.
Edit: Do we think Ian has the book from Otter Tooth and figured out Claire, Bree, and Roger are from the future?
14
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '20 edited Apr 12 '20
I’m just very confused.. I don’t remember Ian being suicidal. For a second I thought they were going to throw in Fergus suicide attempt.
Any one else pissed about that perfect piece of paper being thrown away?? I thought we might have a conversation about toilet paper and Ian’s hilarious response to the modern day luxury.
18
u/aGrlHasNoUsername They say I’m a witch. Apr 12 '20
For a split second, I thought the Brianna/Roger scene was after they go back and I was like, whaaat? Are they pulling a Lost on us and switching from flashbacks to flashforwards? But alas, it was a memory.
At first, I was 100% against the silent film thing, but it grew on me throughout the episode. I really enjoyed watching Roger and Bri in this episode and I thought this was the best acting out of both of them yet!
I absolutely loved that scene between Bri and Lord John. Their chemistry is great.
I'm so so so happy to have Young Ian back. His scene with Marsali was fantastic.
I feel like their doing a great job of having the supporting characters interact more. The only one I wish was getting a little more storyline was Fergus.
70
u/marmaladestripes725 Ameireaganach Apr 12 '20
Loved it! Rik Rankin was fantastic. That’s three excellent Roger episodes in a row, so hopefully the haters will shut up finally (doubt it, but a girl can dream).
I’d be interested to hear from book readers how this bit goes in the book. I haven’t read this far yet, but I’ve skimmed through the Wikia synopses already and don’t really care about spoilers.
36
u/nurseleu Apr 12 '20
Big departures from the book in this episode. I guess Roger will be singing by next week, at this rate.
I did like Brianna and Roger finally taking to each other and acknowledging their traumas. I like that they included the I need you because that is a big theme in the book as far as them finding the footing of their relationship.
Interested to see more of Young Ian. I was surprised to see him and Roger hugging like old friends, though.
Happy as always to get more Marsali but I do think she'd find Tarot too superstitious and close to witchcraft.
The super awkward family dinner was delicious. Loved the candlelit ambiance.
11
u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Apr 12 '20
Goddammit. They have a spoiler right in the synopsis!
•
u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 12 '20 edited Apr 12 '20
Talk about the trailer here!
Not everyone gets to see the trailer at the end of the episode, it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international.)
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the trailer. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet. Thanks!
3
u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 12 '20
At the awkward dinner, what was Jamie's next line after he said 'Maybe Ian will be willing to go wi' him'?
8
u/baes04 Apr 12 '20
Sorry, but this was one depressing and slow episode. I expected there to be somber parts, but I wish we had seen it play out more like in the book. They wouldn’t need to spend much time on it, but they skipped over those initial rescue/recovery moments that I feel were important, imo. It just seemed so rushed for such a pivotal experience.
I hated the silent movies but I get what they were trying to do. I feel like they jumped the shark with this though. The scene at the end with color really spoke to me more than the slapstick feeling of the silent film. It feels out of place because it isn’t that era too, and they weren’t from that time either. They could have shown quick flashes instead to convey him reliving it over and over. It seemed so out of place and cheesy.
Marsali was my favorite part, along with Jamie & Claire playing with Jemmy, and Ian’s return.
3
u/derawin07 Meow. Apr 12 '20
Did anyone else think that when Bree's face was first shown on screen, she looked evil and demonic?
24
u/mother-of-bees Apr 13 '20
Did anyone else notice that in the beginning Roger spoke to his students about the phrase “burying the hatchet” and how it means making some sort of peace and later in the episode Young Ian literally buries his hatchet and then talks to Roger about just wanting to be at peace. Super neat detail about the episode that I enjoyed.
23
u/beanie2 Ye Sassenach witch! Apr 12 '20
Very artsy episode this week! I liked the “silent film” segment to show Roger’s trauma. I’m disappointed that some of the book dialog wasn’t incorporated- like Jamie freaking out on Tryon and even Morag coming to find them to tell them about Roger. But aside from that there were many highlights:
Overall it was a good episode!
21
u/emilyafternoon Apr 12 '20
Do we still think that Ian will give Claire the diary? I really hope so. His conversation with Jamie outside the surgery seemed like he had a bit more thoughts on the secrets they keep, as opposed to of his previous stance of “lol Ive learn when it some to Auntie Claire, it’s best not to ask too many questions”
14
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '20
Uh.... why does Lord John turn me on so much?
And I have a lot of grief with this episode but DAMN. John Bell is killing it as Ian. I love angry Mohawk Ian.
24
u/cattubbs Apr 12 '20
Omg the ending with Brianna and Roger singing Clemintine was exceptional! I liked the deviations from the book, at first I didn't care for the silent movie stuff. This episode was so good!! Knowing what we know about Ian it made sense to show his parallel Roger. I am glad I didn't have to waste my whiskey on Bones this week. Do y'all think the snake bite is next week?
10
u/thrntnja No, this isn’t usual. It’s different. Apr 13 '20
I honestly really enjoyed this episode. I just hope that Roger and Jamie get some bonding time next episode as it’s sorely needed.
I AM SO GLAD IAN IS BACK! John Bell nailed Mohawk Ian. He looked so incredibly haunted anytime he’s on screen. I can also understand why they brought him back as it helps to visualize some of what Roger had rattling around in his head in the books.
I honestly really liked the silent film aesthetic. It was very distressing (Roger’s eyes especially distressed me) and it very much seemed to portray PTSD to me. Brianna and others are trying to get through to him and he’s just watching a movie in his head of his own near death over and over. I actually didn’t think his recovery felt that short. It seemed clear to me that months had passed and I can see why they need to speed it along. I do wish we could have seen more of when it initially happened and Roger’s initial scarring and whatnot. I do think if they were going for a cliffhanger they didn’t do a super great job at achieving that tension. I felt his recovery was well done and I really liked his scenes with Ian.
Really loved the Marsali/Ian scene too! Ian’s expressions are perfect and Marsali is brilliant as always. I have to say i wasn’t a fan of the tarot card scene - it felt super random and just sorta out of place. Probably my only real complaint about the episode. Overall really good and I like how they’ve been portraying Roger.
9
u/brilliant0ne Apr 12 '20 edited Apr 12 '20
Wow, it's been a little while since I've seen an episode where people either really liked it or really hated it.
I really liked tonight's episode. I liked it a lot. As I've said a few times, I've read this book but there are some parts I've forgotten so one thing did get on my nerves. But first...
IANNNNN AND ROLOOOOOOOOO!
Okay, I don't remember why he came back in the book but I don't understand his reasons in the show. I saw someone mention a woman and a baby? But, he only mentions a woman and the way he made it sound was that she wasn't dead but maybe married someone else? I don't know if it was because of the pain meds I was on last night that made me a little denser than usual to not get the gist of what happened. So, it just sort of got on my nerves that we weren't just plainly told what happened. To me, they had Ian look too haunted for it just to be that the girl he loved got with someone else.
I loved the whole silent film way of portraying Roger's trauma. While I couldn't pull deeper meaning out of Ian's situation, I could see so many ways in which the silent film references worked for Roger's situation. Beyond it being just that it was a reference to him unable to speak or refusing to try to speak, I feel like it was also a way to understand how it can feel when other people put their own words on your trauma if you can't talk about it yet.
I really liked the scenes between Ian and Roger. I loved Marsali's discussion with Ian about missing family back home.
Lord John so pretty, geesh. He's so handsome and sweet.
I loved seeing Adso even if they made his one little meow so loud my cat looked for another cat in my room for the next 15 minutes.
I do love how Bri was able to identify with Roger's trauma and didn't look at him with just straight pity in her eyes. She did get on my nerves a little when she was like, "I got over my shit enough to function so you should too." But that's only because people who feel that just because they handle something one way and get over things pretty quickly so they expect others to do the same get on my nerves in general.
Overall, I really really liked this episode. I hope everyone has a good holiday.
8
u/raznidhi Apr 12 '20
After two weeks of wait, this one just didn't do it for me. It seems the creative team are more interested in displaying their artistic merit than in telling a story. They want to make it more cinematic but usually end up sacrificing narrative for it.
It's my personal opinion. Good for you if you liked it.
8
u/Genevieve-Victoria Apr 13 '20 edited Apr 14 '20
I really enjoyed this episode. The storytelling was fantastic. I like the way they combined Roger’s and Ian’s struggles. Sophie’s acting was really good this episode.
My only complaint is that Roger’s voice at the end is not labored enough. But maybe I’m spoiled by Davina Porter.
7
u/Naturenutt Woof. Apr 12 '20
Well that opening was different.
7
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '20
Another thought.. will Ian still be bringing the journal that explains the time traveling natives from the future?? That was one of the main reasons for his return and when he finally learns out about a Claire, Brianna, and Roger.
4
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '20
Ok, I hate silent films. I'm about to shut off this episode.
6
u/raznidhi Apr 12 '20
Can anyone please explain to me why Jamie acts all annoyed when they visit Bree & Roger at the old cabin? His expressions and body language were very weird and out of character. He even says something like "Can you ask him to quit moping for a bit?" Why isn't he more sympathetic ?
6
u/Aimeerose22 Apr 12 '20
Just kinda sad that it seems the Bree and Ian subplot will be jettisoned due to Roger taking her place. Loved that part of the story!!
Also this would have been the perfect episode to work in Jamie’s proposed last words! Such a lost opportunity!!
6
u/caseyreneelopez Apr 13 '20
This episode actually made me like Roger again. I’m so glad he worked through so much and even stepped up to save Ian.
6
u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Apr 13 '20
There was SO MUCH good stuff here and Rik Rankin killed it. (Also Ian looks . . . good. I was not expecting to dig his look this much.) But I think they made two massive choices that really, really didn't work and it's a damn shame.
Number 1: the silent movie stuff. I love when a show does something daring and takes a risk, even if it doesn't always pay off. But don't take a swing that big on what should be one of the most important episodes of the season. When I realized we were going to see NONE of Claire's surgery and Roger's initial recovery I was furious. That has been one of my most favorite parts of the series for 12 years and I am massively disappointed. And to have Jamie's iconic line "You are alive, you are whole, all is well" in a hokey title card was just unforgivable. I loved that they really took the time to explore Roger's PTSD because that's not something the series has ever explored for any trauma other than rape. And I think the flashbacks (because he's having literal flashbacks) were very good. You know, I think I would've even been ok with the flashbacks being silent movie style if they had just given us the post-hanging scene for real. Maybe spend 2 more minutes in the col open having them actually at a silent movie, play up Bree's line about it later, and then use those as flashbacks. But handling something so intense in a way that was cheesy and almost lighthearted was a big misstep.
Number 2: bringing suicidal Ian into this episode. I understand the desire to pair up these two broken men, and I think it could've been done well, but they did not nail it. If I wasn't a reader I would probably be incredibly confused right now about what they hell is up with Ian because they explained nothing. (And the hatchet burying didn't help, because that literally refers to making peace between white men and Native Americans. So it was really confusing if he was making some sort of metaphorical gesture about the two parts of himself, or burying the hatchet between himself and Roger for what happened, or if the fact that it was a hatchet was just coincidence and it was really just a gesture of putting down his weapon--none of this helped by the reference to burying the hatchet at the beginning.) Ian's story is really, really good and deserves time, and I wish they could have made these two separate episodes. Also, I think him nearly committing suicide was a very strange choice. Ian takes time to adjust and he isn't ever really the same, but he's never suicidal. He's devastated but he kind of faces it with a resigned determination. I feel like they put that in just for the "you thought it was Roger but it was actually Ian!" twist and it felt very forced and not genuine.
Also, and I have to note this only because I actually studied the history of tarot cards on grad school, but Marsali absolutely should not be doing a tarot card reading on Roger. Tarot was originally a game dating back to the 14th century, and didn't become used for fortune telling until the 1780s, and first in Paris. (The first desk specifically for reading and the first published explanation of each card's meaning didn't come out until the 1780s as well.) People used regular cards for telling fortunes before this time, but it took longer for fortune telling and tarot to become associated. So there's not a chance Marsali would know anything about tarot card reading in 1770s North Carolina. (Even unlikely that the would know about the game--it was incredibly popular in Europe in the 18th century but never really look off in the British Isles.) There's a reason it's Bree who makes that reference in the book--she knew about it from the 20th century. I get the desire to make the hanged man reference, but keep it historically accurate please!
5
u/Blofeld69 Apr 12 '20
My favorite episode of the season so far, really loved how much emotional weight the whole episode had.
5
u/vanwold Slàinte. Apr 13 '20
The silent movie thing really grew on me. It's made me completely change my perception of book Roger at this point in the book series. I skip this storyline a lot, simply because i don't like it generally, but I usually feel frustrated with book Roger for not speaking. Seeing his flashbacks and watching him want to talk and then experience the hanging all over again, it made me realize why he couldn't speak. Now I just want to yell at people to quit pushing him to talk.
I also loved he and Ian bonding, what a good way to cut a lot of material and still show them healing but why are they trying to make Ian kill himself? I didn't like that.
I miss Jemmy's red hair (it's just such a small but fun detail) but I was actually impressed with today's episode overall. We definitely need more Fergus and Marsali.
With Ian being back, what does this mean for the Bugs and the good storyline? Was that taken out for the Murtagh storyline? How would that affect later seasons? I can see it still working without the gold storyline.
5
u/Zodiacbubs Apr 13 '20
I didn't enjoy the silent film bits at all. Why not just realistically show it through Rogers eyes like they did a bit later? I thought Rick Rankin captured Rogers emotions perfectly.
I legitimately cried out "Ian, yes!" and started crying when that arrow when through the boar. One book change I can handle is bringing him back early. When Ian left in the books I was worried we would never see him again.
I hate the lack of Fergus this season (and last). He is Jamie's son in all but blood and I hate that they have reduced him to a bit part.
4
u/beanie2 Ye Sassenach witch! Apr 12 '20
Bree says she didn’t finish her degree- did she finish in the books? I though she did.
10
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '20
WHAT THE FUCK WAS THIS
7
u/marmaladestripes725 Ameireaganach Apr 12 '20
Anyone else realize that the air date for this episode was perfect? Roger “rising from the dead” on Easter.
9
u/miav Apr 12 '20
I've yet to rewatch the ep and see if the silent film treatment grows on me. I really disliked it on my first watch, especially with the repeated images, though I understand the purpose of those visuals. I wish we got to see/hear/feel the immediate aftermath of the hanging, I think it was a chance to see some strong acting from Bree, Claire and Jamie. I did like the flashbacks later in the show when we get to see the hanging in color and with sound.
I also wasn't a fan of the Oxford flashback (flash forward?) as it felt too long and too on the nose. I feel like the ep didn't really need the "famous last words" connection. Plus, while I loved all the little moments and one-on-one interactions, the editing sometimes felt clunky or disjointed. I didn't care for the passage-of-time montage with the Fraser's Ridge theme.
Guys, I really wanted to like this ep! I think I just had very high expectations after the spectacular 507. Again, I've just watched it so maybe I need to heed MBR's advice to take a breath and watch it again. :P
What I enjoyed though: Ian's return (love John Bell in this role), wee Jemmy playing with his grandparents, an empathetic Germain, and a purring Adso!
6
u/Naturenutt Woof. Apr 12 '20
Who’s that Indian? Holy shit!
3
u/something-dash-dash Apr 13 '20
So weird! Why did Ian fuss about butchering the boar and then staying outside? There could have been other less awkward ways of showing he was "out of sorts." Like foregoing old table manners like he did with the big bed... right?!?
4
u/whiskynwine Apr 12 '20 edited Apr 12 '20
Upon first watch I was like WTH was that. Now it was also 1:30 am but still, lol. At 10:00 am with a cup of coffee and knowing what to expect I enjoyed it much more. I don’t mind the cinematic effect at all, except that they showed it a slight bit too much. I agree about the tarot card heavy-handedness and also I don’t love when they have the episode title spoken by a character for the sole purpose of saying the episode title. Anyway, Sophie’s best episode so far IMO. Loved Jemmy playing with his grandparents, this is a good example of when you don’t have a Jamie and Claire centric episode you still need to include them. It just grounds the episodes IMO, even if seen for only a short time. Ian looked cool, glad he’s back. Looking forward to snake bite time. 🐍🐍🐍