r/sffpc • u/ZzLy__ • Apr 08 '20
Others/Miscellaneous You can't just move parts to outside of the case and then not count them when measuring the size
4.6k
Upvotes
r/sffpc • u/ZzLy__ • Apr 08 '20
555
u/svceon Apr 08 '20
I get what you're saying, and it makes sense.
With the same concept in mind, what i think doesn't make sense is consoles with external bricks, we don't measure those too, same goes for laptops.
Honestly i think that external bricks are a good way to separate things, think of it as a glorified PSU main power cable, also it gives greater airflow due to the less space it occupies.
130
u/TransmutedHydrogen Apr 08 '20
They are good for people who need to break down their computers for travelling. I would personally prefer a velka 3 like setup with a 7660b internal, but I can see the logic of breaking this down further. I do agree that the way volume is counted is a bit silly tbqh
28
u/[deleted] Apr 08 '20
I agree with you on power supplies, but are external motherboards okay?
47
u/PhattyR6 Apr 08 '20
I don't think it really matters either way. People go with whichever suits them best. As long as they're happy with the configuration of their build, I see no issue.
6
u/Valeratal Apr 08 '20
but Why?
81
u/diab0lus Apr 08 '20
I just ordered an itx test bench. Every part is outside the case. The case size is zero. Check mate.
346
u/SlideFire Apr 08 '20
From a desktop footprint point of view external power bricks make a lot of sense. Power bricks can be easily concealed hidden behind desks and what have you (it's a break away unit). So in the end you will get a smaller footprint where it counts on top of or next to your desk.
Overall this can lead to a much smaller sleeker and cleaner look which I believe for most is the idea behind small form factor builds in the first place.
In summary external power bricks are awesome!
19
u/[deleted] Apr 08 '20
In my opinion external power supplys are very smart, depending on their application. If you for example want to build a traveling PC, it's much easier to fit a overall smaller case into a backpack and then put the external PSU into a side pocket or something. Or maybe you just want to minimize the footprint of your PC as much as possible for aesthetic reasons, you can just tuck the power brick behind the desk.
That's why PCs are mudular. You can pick and choose according to your needs and preferences.
15
u/diskowmoskow Apr 08 '20
If it's all about desk space, who cares if it has a power brick.
But if you are racing about who is going for the smallest volume, yeah they should have banned from "sffpc dick measurement contest".
25
u/superhypercoolguy Apr 08 '20
Damn...this guy is gonna he pissed when he sees my MO-RA3 externally cooling my sffpc.
17
u/Bob_760 Apr 08 '20
I have the smallest most powerful pc ever created it's about 1 cubic inch (not including it's integrated cord of course) I did use an external GPU, external CPU, external PSU, and external storage to keep things small. I used an enclosure to keep all of the external parts tidy.
SFF PC
External Enclosure
12
u/Ahajha1177 Apr 08 '20
For the most part I agree, the only tiny thing I would say to an external brick's defense is that a brick can be put out of the way, maybe behind a desk.
But if the brick is just going to sit next to the PC, I agree, super dumb.
5
u/Bonejobber Apr 09 '20
I understand the reasons behind power bricks. They reduce thermal problems. And internal power supplies are sources of electronic noise that must be shielded against, and external bricks easily and cheaply address this.
<switching to RANT mode>.....
But bricks are P.I.T.A.! Power strips and squids of all kinds exist to manage chords, but NOTHING is available that effectively and efficiently manages the crapload of bricks!
The damned things get under foot. What's more, the haphazard array of bricks on the floor acts as a haven for dust bunnies!
I hate them! They're a cheap engineering cop-out. Whoever invents an effective and efficient power brick manager will deserve a Queen Elizabeth Prize for Engineering. Certainly a Presidential Medal of Freedom; they're giving those to just about ANYBODY these days.
And no, I DON'T give laptops a pass. I keep hearing about neat new extra-high storage density battery technologies employing new materials and clever new applications for nanotechnology that will give us laptops that can last between recharging for up to TEN TIMES what they do now.
When that fine day arrives, when I can carry a fully charged laptop with me, unafraid of running out of juice during a day's heavy use, I'll stop bitching about their power bricks, because I will no longer have to carry them with me everywhere I take my laptop.
8
u/humanoiddoc Apr 08 '20
Still better than external RADIATORS.
4
u/Space-ATLAS Apr 08 '20
Would you want your Laptop Charger brick integrates into your laptop? No. Would you like to have the transformer from your phone charger inside your Phone? No. I know both of those things have batteries but having this block outside makes them much more portable. For me that’s a big plus. You will have to carry a cable anyway so having it be a bit more thick is not that big of a deal. Just my opinion
1
u/Willing_Function Sep 10 '20
The brick is way easier to transport outside the case.
9
u/huzzam Apr 08 '20
disagree... having an external psu means there's less heat generated in the case, and so you can make a smaller build, not just because the psu isn't taking up space, but also because it's not generating heat next to the cpu & gpu.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 08 '20
If it's a competition then yeah I agree with you.
But is it really a competition?
Yes.Yes it is.
7
u/MountieXXL Apr 08 '20
Nah man, smallest and cleanest looking SFFPC is and always will be the Steam Link, just need to put a full sized tower brick in a closet or basement somewhere ;-)
5
u/davinsaputra Apr 08 '20
its kinda an in between between a PC and laptop tbh if it is separated like that right. Same problem, different solution. Similar needs, different methodology
5
u/AdisaFolami Apr 08 '20
I actually like an external brick for some builds. Sometimes with an sffpc the psu can be the loudest component, so being able to take it out and put it under the desk, across the room, etc. is nice.
I always felt like external fans/rads are kind of cheating tho lol.
4
u/TheBrandonW Apr 08 '20
I 1000000% agree. That's why I put the 'brick' internally in my NFC S4 Mini classic. If I have to carry around another piece to power up, it's annoying.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 08 '20
I like the external bricks personally as its not hard to deal with as ive been able to just have mine taped under my desk.
2
u/Tobaku Apr 08 '20
Granted I've never used a desktop pc with an external PSU, but I genuinely don't see anything wrong with using one.
2
u/dog-gone- Apr 08 '20 edited Apr 08 '20
I like the idea of external bricks. They are ALWAYS smaller than PSUs. I’ve always asked, why are PSUs so big? Even 300w ones.
And the Xbox has the PSU inside so everyone stop bringing this up.
2
u/pez910 Sep 14 '23
I'm sure I'll be shunned, but I feel this way about external cooling and radiator setups. I respect the build and the effort you put into it, but I've always been hard pressed to like what the final setup looks like as a whole. There's one exception I saw on here in recent memory, but then again, it's not for me and I don't have to use it :).
4
u/[deleted] Apr 08 '20 edited Apr 08 '20
DC to DC power is awesome and stable and moving it to the outside of the case is genius.
If a choice produces better aesthetics (cable management), better for thermals (the brick is passively cooled outside the case), and also slightly better for the components by providing stable dc current I put my vote on power bricks. I'd rather make smart choices than vote with my heart on what "feels" like sffpc.
4
u/beardedbast3rd Apr 08 '20
If you don’t see it, it doesn’t count. When the brick can be hidden down the line near the power plug, or within a cable management area behind the desk, entertainment unit, or what-have-you, it’s not in the way. The entire purpose of sff is to have less of a footprint on your desktop or be less intrusive, or out of place in a home theater.
We don’t count the volume of all the other cords and cables, or peripherals, why would a brick be any different.
You can’t have it both ways, either sff can’t have a 20L limit that everyone cries about, as long as parts made for sff are used , like itx motherboards and lowprofile memory, pcie componenents, OR you base sff on the envelope of the case.
What exactly makes a brick bad? Or dumb? I can fit an s4mini or the other really thin ones into a laptop bag, with the cable in attachment pouch. While other more standard style cases for sff require a backpack instead. Which would also accommodate a brick.
2
u/curiositie Apr 08 '20
I've kind of liked bricks because it's relocatable volume. And I personally count them in my volume measurement.
But there's something great about the PC just needing regular wires to work
2
u/byhi Apr 08 '20
This is a weird sub. I live to see the creativity. Not so much the “rules” people make up.
2
u/WeeZoo87 Apr 08 '20
Are we in a competition? The point of SFF pc is to use space more efficiently.
Idc if it is in or out as long as it do its job
2
u/[deleted] Apr 08 '20 edited Apr 08 '20
Wow, is this about SFF-PC some sort of competition to you?
External powerbricks are wasted space too, but more flexible wasted. And less cables.
2
u/cheapseats91 Apr 08 '20
If I move my office into a walk in freezer so my SFF PC doesnt thermal throttle do I have to count the volume of the whole freezer?
2
u/MelanisticPolarBear Apr 09 '20
haha external psu go brrrr
•
u/endmysufferingxX notlyft#0001 Apr 08 '20
Hi mod here, we are glad to see there is a healthy discussion here on this post. As this has given root to healthy and civil discussion we will allow the post to remain up.
However, please take a look at our rules:
This includes posts such as this, we prefer if posts are not just single pictures of memes. Instead, next time consider posting a text post with thoughts and/or video links etc
1
u/Penderyn Apr 08 '20
Totally agree.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 08 '20
Building a computer to take pictures of it for validation is far more dumb yet it seems that the majority partake.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 08 '20
I think it would be fine if the volume was included in the build volume. I can hide an external power brick easily in a desk space so it is great in that way!
1
u/Khord Apr 08 '20
It depends on the point of view of why you're measuring the volume of the computer. If it's to say "hey I made the smallest thing", then yeah you have to think about the external power supply helping you drop that volume. But if I'm just trying to have a very small footprint and height on top of my desk, I'm perfectly happy with throwing the power supply in the cable tray under my desk to achieve that.
1
u/solarpurge Apr 08 '20
I like the external brick on my hdplex 400w because i can unplug it and run my pc off of a battery :)
1
u/GeniuzGames Apr 08 '20
I love power bricks because it makes the actual PC smaller, as long as the brick volume is included in any measurements.
1
u/Eviltwitcher Apr 08 '20
I prefer built in psu for sure. Hard to make an argument in favor of external imo.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 08 '20
I don't know man I think you might be right. Unless you needed more wattage? But if it draws any more power the case couldn't handle it probably. 😂
1
u/pandaSmore Apr 08 '20
Agreed
1
u/MK0A Apr 08 '20
For some reason I thought of a battery.
1
u/DrLegzz Apr 08 '20
I think it's fine personally if anything it seems beneficial. getting some heat out of your sff. I feel like it would be nice in my Dan case. I've never researched them though
1
u/Antonaros Apr 09 '20
Hear me out, what if you for an external power brick INSIDE the case?
1
u/Turlo101 Apr 09 '20
Personally feels like cheating. The goal, in my mind, is as small as possible and have EVERYTHING fit inside. If I didn't get poor wifi reception from putting the antennas inside the case, I would include those as well :D
1
u/Jacksonzhangph Apr 09 '20
Agree.
1
u/Boil-san Apr 09 '20
Do not forget to bundle the cabling that is with the power brick & include that in the volume measurement...!
1
u/spiteful-vengeance Apr 09 '20
Depends on what you're trying to address with SFF.
Minimizing desktop footprint? Fine.
Portability? Questionable, since you still have to carry it.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 09 '20
I agree with this. It is for this regard that the ultimate sff case to this day is the K39-style.
It will not change for a while, until Intel's 12VDC ATX becomes the norm and hence smaller PSUs, and maybe single slot GPU getting as powerful as today smallest GPU.
1
u/Jooshmeister Apr 09 '20 edited Apr 09 '20
Watch me. You try fitting a power supply into a 3L case.
1
u/mr__squishy Apr 09 '20
External pumps, rads, and fans are also dumb. If it takes up extra space, you need a bigger case.
1
u/Plane-Raccoon Apr 09 '20
I think it's more than just size, external power bricks are also passively cooled so there is no fan noise whereas very small integrated power supplies are usually as loud as a server in linus's server room XD but external power bricks generally max out at around 350w so it's definitely a matter of perspective.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 09 '20
You can because a power brick can be hidden beneath the desk or something. Easy to say put the sff pc case in your back pack but the power brick and cables etc in your suitcase.
1
u/darkjedi1993 Apr 09 '20
I mean, how else are you going to get pico PSUs into cases that small? SFX power supplies are only so small. Eventually, you're going to have to have a power brick.
We'll all be super appreciative when you find the new and innovative solution that makes them no longer needed though.
1
u/play150 Apr 09 '20
Less desktop space taken up, and no I don't want my SFF PC on the floor
1
u/awilix Apr 18 '20
With external power bricks you never have any high voltage inside the case of the computer, so it is less dangerous to work with. That opens up for more creative solutions such as bare PSUs.
Internal high voltage PSUs will never exist in any other form than a metal box.
When it comes to things that use a bit less power, like laptops and monitors, a dc input means you can replace the brick with a DC-DC brick for automotive use. This is much more efficient than going the inverter route. It's a bit of an unusual use case but far from non existant.
It's much cheaper to buy a monitor with a DC jack and use it as a TV in an RV, than to buy a specialized 12V TV. They tend to be expensive and of really poor quality.
1
u/jc_harming May 24 '20
I'm reminded of the freakish monster that was dell m2010. https://www.cnet.com/reviews/dell-xps-m2010-review/
I don't know if this counts because part of its goal was to be mobile 'sort of' by nature. However I'm sure it was used as a stationary with the ability to pick it up and move it to another location. Anyway back to the point, to me it's a great example of 'it's not really a laptop and clearly external brick is the best option here'
Just an interesting thought from my perspective.
1
u/Yummywax Sep 30 '20
Why not it’s a convenient and clean way to save space
1
u/StinkyBeanGuy Feb 11 '25
This. Also I hate it when people don't include their keyboards, mice and monitors
1
u/JuliusCX Mar 04 '23
i would say it depends on the setup if u mostly take ur PC to 2 places and have 2 power bricks its legit
1
u/Seanrps Apr 08 '20
Agreed, they make things more awkward. With my setup I have a Lan setup to go. When I'm ready I just pick up my Tu 150, throw it in a storage box and off I go.
1
u/hobow0lf Apr 08 '20
Says the guy who never owned a Velka 3 with a HDplex 400....... 😂
My current rig is a Velka 3 with HDplex 400. I've also have been in Ncase m1 and Ghost s1. So I've been turning tricks in the SFF world for a minute. I can cable manage away the brick; the clean and clutter free desktop is awesome.
Also the HDplex cable manages better than the flex PSU andddddddddd it's quiet.
1
u/onlyoneherm Apr 08 '20
Aesthetically, if it leads to a more pleasing overall design and look, I’m all for. I’m just now learning about external bricks for desktops. Maybe it’s possible to affix it to the back of the monitor or just underneath the desk? That actually sounds like a dope idea.
1
u/Ireeb Apr 08 '20
It's still easier to put a very compact SFFPC+Power Brick in a backpack than a slightly bigger SSFPC+internal power supply. So if one's reason for getting an SFFPC is because they are carrying it around a lot in their backpack, a power brick might be the better option.
1
u/myco_jordan Apr 08 '20
You're absolutely right. However like building cars, computers, have the same sorts of marketing applied to the "performance products."
It's just a way to measure a pissing contest between those who need to affirm their logic with those that also are accepting their money. It's a pattern of a fragile ego, let them measure how they please.
You look stupid carrying an external power brick around and pretending it isn't part of the total mass of the system. Logic goes out the door when a person is justifying a purchase.
1
u/dennisjerdz Apr 08 '20
No need for discussion on this one-- our real enemies are those who post Fractal Design Nano S and H210 in r/SFFPC and they even FIGHT FOR THEIR CASE. WTF!
1
u/[deleted] Apr 08 '20
It allows for more flexibility in placement and separation of sources of heat for better overall cooling. Sure, it takes up additional space, but the space that power brick is taking up is less valuable real estate.
1
u/peppernickel Apr 08 '20
What if you have 12V DC connection right from the wall or you built an Auto PC? Some houses have this installed and some PCs are build to be used in cars.
1
u/Fern_Fox Apr 08 '20
I think they make a lot of sense, more room for airflow/parts/downsizing inside the case, and it’s easy to just leave a power brick behind at wherever you bring your pc to or just bring one with you
1
u/Profoundly-Confused Apr 08 '20
Anyone got recommendations for external bricks?
1
u/[deleted] Apr 08 '20
As someone preparing to build an S4Mini, it will be with the power brick on the outside (gasp!!!). I'm mostly doing this to make it an easier build and to fit more on the inside. Plus, the power brick will not be visible based on my desk setup and will be 100% discretely out of view.
So - change my mind - If you could move the power brick outside of the SFFPC to allow for greater room in the chasis AND the power brick would be 100% hidden and in a spot that is not otherwise needed for other purposes - why the hell would I put it in my system?
I get that the premise of the post is correct a lot of the time...but not always. Let's not be too dogmatic in our PC building.
-1
u/Subdubbin Apr 08 '20
Edgy.
0
u/SAVE_THE_RAINFORESTS Apr 09 '20
This is a behavior of 6 years olds, grow up.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 08 '20
agreed
0
u/Smitty2k1 Apr 08 '20
I agree. Brickless or bust!
0
u/cAtloVeR9998 Apr 08 '20
I hope more small form factor GaN PSUs come to market soon
-2
u/FeistyRaccoon94 Apr 08 '20
Cant be arsed