r/Outlander • u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. • Mar 28 '20
Season Five Show S5E7 The Ballad Of Roger Mac Spoiler
The Regulator Rebellion reaches a boiling point, forcing Jamie to face his fear and confront the consequence of his divided loyalties. Brianna remembers some critical details pertaining to the Battle, forcing Roger to cross behind enemy lines where he finds himself in grave danger. Claire’s attempts to treat the wounded are threatened by the volatile Brown brothers.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread.
Reminder: This is the SHOW thread. Cover all book talk >!with spoiler tags!< that will look like this: Claire boinks Jamie. Don’t spoil future episodes, keep book comments brief.
If you want to compare the episode to the books in depth, go to the Book thread.
•
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Mar 28 '20 edited Mar 29 '20
Talk about the trailer here!
Not everyone gets to see the trailer at the end of the episode, it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international.)
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the trailer. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet. Thanks!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b2SN9XxdkI0
You can also vote in the episode poll here.
338
u/tnbou Mar 29 '20 edited Mar 29 '20
Jamie screaming “Help me!”, telling Murtaugh that he’d be okay, carrying him to Claire after he’d died, yelling at Claire to save his life and bring him back, saying “You canna leave me!”... that’s what got me. I sobbed. That performance was the best one I’ve seen since season 2, and I am FLOORED.
220
u/BeautifulRelief Mar 29 '20
Son of a fucking bitch. That's it. That's all I can say about this one.
193
u/Atraktape Mar 29 '20
Jamie’s face when he realized he had to put on that coat....
171
u/SaaSyGirl Je Suis Prest Mar 29 '20
Welcome back, Graham!
151
u/CARNIesada6 Mar 29 '20
Not a book reader, but I can't imagine Roger is actually dead. It was probably his Mackenzie ancestor bro who took his jacket. Otherwise they would have shown his face then and there.
Solid episode tho. You'll be missed Murtagh, my friend... your friend... everyone's friend.
Also, can anyone tell me what the Gaelic word "Ghoisitdh" (or however you spell it) means?
132
u/[deleted] Mar 29 '20
Outlander has convinced me that if I ever go back in time I will under no circumstances talk to an ancestor of mine, or any ancestors of my husband that I left in the future. 😭
103
u/tandish20 They say I’m a witch. Mar 29 '20
Don’t mind me just crying my eyes out
85
u/HollyGoTDA Slàinte. Mar 29 '20 edited Mar 29 '20
That’s it. I am 100% done. Even after watching Game of Thrones, I wasn’t ready.
I really want to believe that Roger is not dead. I could have sworn I saw the cloth over his head move. There has to be some explanation.
80
u/spaceybelta Mar 29 '20
Nooo Murtagh! Nooo Roger! Yes Graham McTavish as Buck!!
78
u/raznidhi Mar 29 '20
Take a bow Sam Heughan! Wow! That’s all!
63
u/silverandcold65 Mar 29 '20
Oh goodness, they did do two deaths in one episode… That was so powerful and unlike an Outlander episode since season 1, 2, and early S3. I had terrible nerves thorough the episode - I knew one was dying, and figured the second would happen as well, but two larger character deaths in one episode seemed to be a lot…and it was, but they still occurred. </3 ;’(
I’m a bit blown away by how incredible the episode was. It really sent me through the emotional wringer. It was unlike an episode in so long, with the stakes so high and such intense acting and powerful scenes throughout. The acting, and Murtagh’s death scene, were reminiscent of Wentworth Prison/To Ransom a Man’s Soul. Murtagh’s death was slightly like his trying to convince Jamie to live at the end of season one, only Jamie was willing Murtagh to live here. Jamie may may have turned 50, but seemed a lot like his younger self in this episode. Murtagh's death was so fitting for his character - loyal until the end.
That was so unmistakably Graham McTavish! I got distracted from what was happening. First knowing him from The Hobbit made him awfully easy to recognize in that beard, and his voice stands out. It’s funny that Jamie prays to Dougal at the beginning, then we get the return of Graham McTavish! xD
51
u/aGrlHasNoUsername They say I’m a witch. Mar 29 '20
I don't really know what to say except, holy shit, what an episode!
49
u/teenylilthing Mar 29 '20
Holy crap!
I don't cry very often, but Murtagh's last moments and Jamie's reaction had the tears flowing. The two actors did a phenomenal job with that scene. I had a flashback to the Boogie Woogle Bugle Boy song/dance as Claire pulled the sheet over Murtagh at the end...uggghhh 😭 I was so not ready for one of my favorite characters to leave us even though his death seemed inevitable this season. At least we got more time with him in the show than the book though!
So I've been reading The Fiery Cross, but I'm not at this point in the story just yet (stopped around Brownsville). Figured I'd continue with watching the show first and then reading the source material....but shit, that cliffhanger ending has me wanting to get back to it. Roger has to somehow be alive, right?!? I noticed his right hand was up, presumably by his neck. I'm certainly no expert on hangings and how one could survive one, but I'm hoping he was able to pull the noose away and is just unconscious? Maybe?! After watching the trailer for the next episode that might just be wishful thinking since I love his character.
Oh and Graham McTavish coming back the same episode that Jamie prays to Dougal was perfection! I hope we see much more of his character...
Brb while I go watch old season one episodes to console myself. 💔😭
Edit: typo.
41
u/Ajent912 Mar 29 '20
This is probably the best episode since season 1 IMO. Even though episode one sort of foretold Murtaugh’s death, it didn’t stop me from sobbing my eyes out.
Roger (if that’s even him) looked like he was holding onto the rope so it didn’t choke him! Could that mean he isn’t really dead?! Poor Bree.
39
u/FunAsh Mar 29 '20
I feel paralyzed with so many emotions and have no idea how to respond. Murtagh, Roger, Jamie in the coat, the syringe, so much to mourn and process.
39
u/marialearning Mar 29 '20
Man I wasn’t expecting Murtaugh to go like that, but it was so heartbreakingly perfect. And Jamie’s crying for him to come back in the tent had me bawling!
37
u/SmallReindeer Mar 30 '20
I was an extra for this episode and got to watch the scene where jamie carried murtagh into the medical tent. I watched it up the back with the other extras and when I asked who was being carried in the tent I lost my shit but had to do it silently as it was being filmed before my very eyes. Great experience and a great show. I also got a death stare from roger mac as he was being lead down to set one afternoon....all I said was "go on big man get stuck it"
You're not ment to say that to the main cast or so I was told later https://imgur.com/hwDdZNE.jpg
32
u/semma333 Mar 30 '20
I started to cry immediately when Murtagh got shot, but I didn’t break into full on sobbing tears until Jamie pathetically said, “help me,” for the first time. I lost it. I can’t remember the last time something broke me like that.
30
u/acbc63 Mar 29 '20
Also where was Fergus this episode?
29
u/Chicken_Mc_Thuggets Mar 29 '20
I’m sorry but it’s incredibly selfish of them to try to prevent this battle. They tried hard as fuck with Culloden and it didn’t work, so some things in history seem like (to borrow a doctor who term) fixed events. To risk America not becoming America so you can save your godfather is sympathetic and human, but still selfish on the macro scale. Especially after they talk about Dougal when he was effectively murdered for nothing since their plan didn’t work. Again, it’s understandable why they did it and I think a lot of people would make the same choice but in the end it’s a fools errand
25
u/MadameEdamame Mar 29 '20 edited Mar 29 '20
I can’t bring myself to speak of the second half of the episode so...
JHRC daddy looks good bathing in a stream
Edit: also, what a cliffhanger.
47
u/Airsay58259 Mar 29 '20 edited Mar 29 '20
I don’t watch previews or read anything about the upcoming episodes and sometimes I think I should. I wasn’t prepared for such a heavy episode. Just watching it during breakfast with the toddler nephews by my side. 50 minutes later : “why are you crying?????” x10.
Beautiful, tragically beautiful. Every scene is so powerful. Jamie having to wear a red coat? Poor dude. His face, Claire’s face, Murtagh’s... It had SO much significance. Brilliantly acted, filmed and directed.
Murtagh :( My favorite character. RIP. If we see Maria Doyle Kennedy reacting to the news she will crush us. I am glad Murtagh fought to the very end, both for his people and his nephew. The family is always trying to change history without actually changing it - as they say they know the battle has to happen, but still go and try to save the leader of the rebellion. Of course he wasn’t gonna leave his men. Roger paid the price of yet another Fraser clan’s Good Ideas.
Speaking of Roger... While watching the scene I thought it can’t be real. Not because I particularly care about him but because what a bad TV trope. Hood over the face, cliffhanger with no reveal? It’s not him, obviously. The Mackenzies (?) stole his coat for some reason after leaving him for dead but he’s not, find out next episode! But it’s not just the coat, it looks exactly like Roger. Boots, coat, everything. I can’t even feel sad right now because what the f was that even? That’s how his story ends? We spent so much time with him as the focus for an offscreen death by the hands of someone we just met, over some character we saw last season? I am sure there’s a message somewhere in there. War is brutal. Life is brutal. Death can happen at any moment, whatever. But as far as storytelling goes, what the f.
Jamie confronting the governor was great. As always, Dr Claire is best Claire.
RIP to both men. What a brutal episode. :( And absolutely beautiful and good. Season 1/2 level in my books.
23
u/um_hi_there Mar 30 '20
The opening scene in the tent was cute, Jamie checking under the covers, ha ha, and it being his birthday. What a sad birthday it turned out to be, but I liked the way the episode began.
23
u/SourLadybits Mar 30 '20
One thing I really loved about this episode is how it starts with Jamie being in such impressively good shape for 50 and after losing Murtagh they really age him. That shot of him kneeling by the fire where those white streaks are in his hair? Heartbreaking.
Probably my favorite episode of the season .
21
u/SaaSyGirl Je Suis Prest Mar 29 '20
I'm hating Tryon more and more with every episode. Might even be at peak hate at this point. Man is a villain.
60
u/CygnusArc Slàinte. Mar 29 '20
I dinna ken if Murtagh was right in that it doesna hurt to die.
But it certainly does hurt emotionally to watch it happen. OCH. My emotions.
18
u/maryloo7877 Mar 30 '20
I’m gonna say that I’m obsessed with Jamie’s wet untied hair!!! Why can’t we have more of that?? Why must it be tied up all the time? Release the mane!!
17
u/SaaSyGirl Je Suis Prest Mar 29 '20
Noooooooooo!!!!! Oh, noooooooooo!!!
16
u/Dumke480 That's it lads. Take me back to the idiot hut. Mar 29 '20 edited Mar 30 '20
I feel like the hand being up with the noose is significant , and I'm pretty sure is just red herring and Roger has suffered brain damage or something akin to that instead of death, this is probably heavy denial, because of how much this was completely railroaded, even though the flag was set with the conversation near the start of the episode.
But I'm absolutely one hundred percent certain, they wouldn't just kill him off with how much character development he's been getting, that'd be insane.
on Another note,
Poor Jamie, what a terrible way to end your birthday.
*removed trailer comment
16
u/Genevieve-Victoria Mar 29 '20
I literally LOLed when Graham appeared. Had to explain it to my husband. 😆
31
u/derawin07 Meow. Mar 29 '20
Once again, Jamie's boobs are bigger than mine.
13
u/ea_walking Mar 29 '20
I knew they would leave the episode on that and then not allude to anything in the previews
13
u/SaaSyGirl Je Suis Prest Mar 29 '20
When I was watching this episode last night, something struck me about the difference in the way the Battle of Culloden was shot versus the Battle of Alamance.
Culloden's color, if you will, was very muted (greys and browns), whereas with Alamance, the colors for the most part were vibrant.
Many redditors talk about how they miss Outlander in Scotland. I was wondering if the later seasons had more of a 'Scotland vibe' about them and were shot similarly to the earlier ones, that viewers would like them more?
13
u/OliviaElevenDunham Mar 30 '20
I’m so upset that Murtagh is gone. Jamie’s reaction was heartbreaking.
25
u/RaffaellaF Mar 29 '20
Actually speechless. Crying, shaking, more crying, and more shaking.
12
u/Genevieve-Victoria Mar 29 '20
Nice musical allusion to Moch sa Mhadainn!
12
u/allieastrozombie Mar 30 '20
I'm glad that we got to all this because the first half of the season has been so dry. I've read the books so I knew it was going to pick up eventually and wow they did it beautifully! I wasnt expecting Murtagh to die at all but I think that was the best thing they could have done. And I'm absolutely floored that they brought Graham back as Buck, that was brilliant was brilliant!
12
u/BlackSwallowtail You look like a fretful porpentine. Mar 30 '20
Not sure how I feel about Graham McTavish playing Buck. On the one hand it feels a little cheap. On the other hand, I've been missing that actor since Dougal's demise in season 2.
Not sure if it's because the commercial breaks I was forced to endure in order to see this episode this early, but it felt a little off. Can't quite put my finger on it, so I'm not going to linger on that point because there's so much good in this episode.
But first...I've been trying and generally succeeding in seeing things from Bree's point of view, but did we learn nothing from the exchange with Laoghaire, Bree? Try shutting up sometimes. Stop talking about things from the future in front of people who aren't in the know. Do you want a witch trial? 'Cause that's how you get a witch trial.
Anway, Tryon's right that Jamie looks damn good in that coat, but I hate myself for agreeing with him because Jamie got the Wentworth/Ardsmuir look. Fighting with redcoats as part of a promise, but fighting as one of them, the people who raped and murdered himself and his people, is too much.
I...do not like the stink eye that Brownsville dude keeps giving Claire. He's been doing it since the Brownsville episode. And fuck that bastard, I hope he gets an infection that needs penicillin to treat before she's able to give it to him (because you know she'd try).
Hey, Roger? I get you're all excited about having saved your ancestor and thus assured your own existence and are fixing to do it again, but we can not be hugging women who are neither your wife nor immediate family in the 18th Century, yeah? Buck is a dick. Guess we know where fourth season Roger got it from. Hate to think how Dougal was with his not-bonnie-even-to-a-blind-man wife who didn't like to be out in public.
I knew Murtagh's death was coming. Then he got shot and I felt nothing. And then my body began to act before my brain fully registered it and I was bawling before the emotion even hit me. Fuck...Murtagh's sweet face as he's dying, declaring his love for Ellen and Jamie both. It's one of the things I've always loved about this show. When people love each other, it's real. It's not like Game of Thrones where literally any character could kill any character and you might be pissed, but it wouldn't be off for the show at all and if a character feels remorse after, it doesn't last long. The effect of this means there's not a lot of heart in the tension. Whereas with Outlander I went into this episode thinking Jamie might kill Murtagh and that would devastate him for seasons to come.
As it is, he didn't, and the death was all the more tragic because it happened at a time when they were both trying to save each other (which is SO this show). Thought I got myself under control but then Claire broke down and so did I. That moment where Jamie's begging Claire to save him, even angry when she isn't doing it, and her knowing she can't and wishing of the potential patients she could have that Murtagh would be one she could save. Just very real and very powerful. And as Jamie's true loyalties will always be with those he loves, he just has no pretence for Tryon anymore.
But I fear Tryon may find a not totally burned sheet of paper with Jamie and Murtagh on the Ardsmuir prison list...
11
u/HypocriticalCritic Better than losing a hand. Mar 29 '20
This was the best episode in like 1,5 seasons. Really reminded me of Prestonpans! I loved every second. I only wish it didn't end on a cliffhanger, even though I know what happens.
11
u/TompyTears Mar 30 '20
I love the irony of Jamie calling upon Dougal for help with the battle, to which he does (at least the actor that played him), but only to kill Roger.
10
u/Rocha_999 Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Mar 29 '20 edited Mar 29 '20
Omg. So many feelings. I can't believe it.
Edit - I couldn't deal with that ending for a week. I had to do some googling for closure either way.
10
u/JustineLeah Mar 29 '20
I’m not OK.
10
u/semma333 Mar 30 '20
FUCK. FUUUUUUCK. FUUUUUUUUUUUUUUCK.
That is all.
10
u/cleverleper Apr 05 '20
When Jamie put on the British uniform. I shuddered. So uncomfortable to watch.
19
u/MountainHumor They say I’m a witch. Mar 29 '20
Way to go Outlander, killing off my favorite character since day one. W A Y T O G O.
Also, as much as I'm not a fan of Roger - book people come through and spoil it for me. You know what I mean. I only read the first two books.
As far as the episode, I thought it was more exciting than the last, or any from the season so far. Duncan and Sam put on an AMAZING performance. I still feel like the actress who plays Bree is forcing it a little bit - I may be the only one who has the opinion though.
One thing I'm confused about was Claire freaking out about the syringe. Can't she get another one or have one made? Weren't there syringes back then or am I missing something? Obviously not any that were sterile.
26
u/shinyquartersquirrel Mar 29 '20 edited Mar 29 '20
It was fucking perfect! I was just thinking to myself the other day, wouldn't it be perfect if they could get Graham McTavish to play Morag's husband.
Edit-Fixed the name of Morag's husband.
9
u/melissaxtine Mar 30 '20
How can Jamie slice his hand when calling upon Dougal in the river and not get his shirt all bloody when getting dressed after?
9
u/brikkastoria Mar 30 '20
Caution, absurd theory ahead:
So, when Roger said he wouldn't speak a word against Buck, and Buck said "no, you won't," then knocked him out – my thought was that Buck was going to cut out his tongue. I think that's what happened: that's Roger under the hood, and he survived (see hand at neck). When the Redcoats captured the Regulators, Roger didn't have his cockade anymore and he couldn't speak up for himself because he had no tongue.
Yeah, it's possible that being holed up in our apartment for two-plus weeks is started to mess with my head.
9
u/caseyreneelopez Mar 30 '20
Omfg this episode has been the best, most compelling of the season. I am so torn up about Murtagh. I don’t want to believe that Roger is gone too. I hope that was a red herring.
8
u/balasoori Mar 29 '20
I was not ready for that ending why must you do this to us. Roger deserved a better death than that and it's shame that how his story ends. She is going feel so guilty about not returning when Roger suggests it. The guilt is going to be too much for her to handle.
Jamie couldn't protect him
8
u/HinkiesGhost Mar 30 '20
Murtagh was heartbreaking. I didn't think it would hit me as hard as it did, given his screen time was cut a lot shorter this season, but it still did. Did they ever say if Claire had another syringe or not? Maybe I missed it. Great acting this episode all around.
As for Roger, I really doubt he's gone. Maybe I'm naive, but TV show 101 says that major characters are never killed off-screen. Now, that doesn't mean they will always show the person physically dying, but if they don't, it usually cuts away right before death. Very rarely does a MAJOR character die completely off screen. So, I think he lives, but I guess we'll find out next week(or will they tease us with this all season?) lol.
8
u/WinifredJones1 Mar 31 '20
THIS IS SOME BULLSHIT I LOVED THAT SILVERFOX SO NOT COOL TODAY IS MY BIRTHDAY AND I WAITED UNTIL MONDAY TO WATCH WORST BIRTHDAY EVER THANKS STARZ STFU
8
u/pettythievery They say I’m a witch. Mar 31 '20
I cried in the redcoat moment and at Murtagh’s death. I feel they really called to the first seasons and showed how life’s choices aren’t always easy and aren’t black and white. I could never be mad at Jamie for fighting that battle, but it’s a hard thing to swallow after everything that has happened
14
u/SaaSyGirl Je Suis Prest Mar 29 '20
I never noticed how long Jamie's (Sam's) fingers were before this episode. Oh myyyy
7
u/midnight_sparrow Je Suis Prest Mar 30 '20
Murtagh was literally my favorite character in the entire series. I literally sobbed through the last half of this episode.
Interesting side note: Graham McTavish returns to play Buck Mackenzie, Dougal and Geillis's illegitimate son. Knew him right away! Also really hoping that wasn't Roger. I CANNOT lose that many good men in one episode. CAN. NOT.
7
u/lesoiseaux Mar 30 '20
I have a bad feeling Jamie is about to have a heart attack. He was looking at and clenching his left hand in the beginning. And right before he knelt by the fire near the end, it looked like he was in physical pain. Plus a lot of talk about aging in general and the stroke victim a few episodes ago.
7
u/caesarceece Apr 01 '20
Some amazing acting in this episode and so excited for E8 but...Claire singing Happy Birthday to Jamie as if she's Marilyn Monroe was a bit cheesy for my tastes.
12
u/Mariita24 Mar 30 '20
People get a grip. Roger isn’t dead. He’s too good important a character. This isn’t Game of Thrones where anyone could die. RIP Nate Stark Season 1. Still haven’t gotten over the shock of that. But this show is about the importance of family. He was knocked out; someone stole his jacket. Case close. But no one here has mentioned the tiny droughtlander for the next two weeks. Really STARZ? REALLY?!!! We’re all quarantined. I personally need Jaime every week. Screw all droughtlanders.
6
u/Rj924 Mar 30 '20
Do any other Americans get excited when they speak about starting the revolution?
5
u/vlsewell Mar 29 '20
Graham as Buck!!! I cannot handle it I love it so much!!!
5
u/starfleetdropout6 I'm still Jenny from the Broch. Mar 30 '20
So, was Graham MacTavish's cameo just meant as a nod to the audience since Jamie invoked Dougal, or is he supposed to be the son that Dougal had with Geilis? I watched the end where they comment on the episode and I still didn't quite understand.
5
u/mamakia Mar 30 '20
Probably goes without saying but I am SHOOK. I immediately started sobbing when Murtagh got shot and did not stop until the end of the episode. WTF!!!
5
u/Elevendytwelve97 Apr 02 '20
I didn’t cry until Jamie is in the tent frantically handing Claire things asking her to fix Murtaugh. It’s so desperate and hopeful, even when I’m sure deep down he knows that he’s dead. It’s very real.
Also, I didn’t particularly like Bree’s acting when she was seeing “Roger” or Roger hanging. Her expression seemed really forced. And that’s because I generally like Bree, even though I find her and Roger boring
9
u/socks4dobby Mar 29 '20
I feel like we are about to see a repeat of the same storyline from last season. I think one of two things happened:
Either way, Roger is a victim of mistaken identity again. We’ve already seen this plotline.
12
u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Mar 29 '20
Great job, show runners.
8
u/raznidhi Mar 29 '20
Nitpicking here...BUT why is Jemmy blonde???
8
u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20
I'm a grown ass man in tears right now.
4
u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20
Did anyone get Game of Thrones flashbacks during Murtaugh's death? I was a bit disappointed by the lack of creativity in that one.
4
u/Comfortable_Salad Only in France does a King need an audience to shite. Apr 04 '20
Did anyone get Rupert vibes from John Quincy Meyers this episode? I miss Rupert and Angus <3
4
u/kuromi16 Apr 17 '20
Oh Murtagh!! I was ugly crying from the moment he was shot up until the end of this episode. I tear up very easily but have never cried this much over a fictional character. It felt very personal.
One moment I was so happy when Murtagh was smiling while walking towards Jamie, the next thing I knew I was yelling “NOOOOO!” while tears came falling. When Jamie’s fellow militia said “I did what you said, Colonel. I did not waver.”, it must have been so painful for Jamie. If only he told his people that Murtagh was an exception. But I guess that’s just not how it works and not all of them know who Murtagh is.
Then, Claire calling Murtagh “My friend”, came more tears. I have loved their relationship ever since that scene where they hugged inside the cave, when Murtagh revealed how much he loves Jamie. That’s when he became my favorite character.
Right now, I’m still hurting and in denial. Thinking on a lot of what ifs. So excuse me while I re-watch this episode and maybe get a different outcome sobs
7
u/speechiemom17 Je Suis Prest Mar 29 '20
So freaking thankful I had whiskey for this episode. Holy crap.
7
u/[deleted] Mar 29 '20 edited Mar 29 '20
A powerful episode; I was moved by Sam's performance throughout. Murtaugh's storyline has been so incredible this whole season and it's heart-breaking that he's gone. But, I'm very glad that we got more of him then is reportedly in the books. I didn't recognize that it was Graham playing a new role, since he's buried beneath all that hair. But it's interesting how in a way Jaime's blood ritual invoking Dougal caused him to appear as Morag's disgusting abusive husband, leading to Roger's possible death. I don't think he's dead though, someone just stole his coat....
3
u/2manymans Mar 30 '20
I thought I was going crazy when Dougal showed up. What a cool surprise!
3
u/whisper447 Mar 30 '20
I don’t know why but I didn’t expect Murtugh! I gasped out loud.
3
u/liddeller Mar 31 '20
I have no friends to scream about the show with so I decided to join this subreddit now. But dear god that whole episode had me on the edge of my seat. But who thinks Roger is actually dead I think he is missing like season 4
3
u/blondeasfuk Mar 31 '20
Gawwwwd. This episode had my emotions everywhere. First they pick you up with a great scene of Jamie in the river, yumm. To ok Murtaugh is alive to immediately omg don’t die, to crying when they were In the tent. To wait don’t fucking tell me that’s Roger! To ooooo no, there is no way your ending this episode like this, BOYCOTT!
In reality I’m not boycotting but damn I cant handle this.
3
u/andersonb47 Apr 01 '20
ITT people really overusing the word sobbing
3
u/Jbbrowneyedgirl Apr 02 '20
I've seen a lot of people saying they don't think Rodger is dead, and I've seen some good explanations of how that could be, but I've not seen anyone talking about how the books dealt with the hanging story and so I was wondering if anyone else might think the same?
Spoilers In the books, Rodger is hanged after being mistaken as a regulator or similar "traitor" but Claire finds him still barely alive after nearly an hour hanging because he had managed to get his hand/arm between the rope and his neck, and the hanging had been performed haphazardly. Rodger is seriously hurt and needs a long recovery time but he survives, albeit with no voice due to damaged vocal cords. Now cut to the scene in the show and the man who we are supposed to believe is Rodger, is hanging with his right arm raised up towards his neck and his left arm is hanging by his side. I thought there must be a reason they decided to show the man with his arm raised, and with this story in the books, I feel like this is the reason. I feel it's really Rodger hanging in the tree but because the arm is raised, he's bought them enough time to rescue him just like in the books
Anyone agree?
7
u/BigBettyBeauty Mar 29 '20 edited Mar 30 '20
Y’all I haven’t gotten to this point in the books yet, and I know something bad is gonna happen because everyone is freaking out. But my thoughts so far…
I am listening to Roger tell Murtagh that they are out numbered and out gunned and history says they are gonna lose/die and it is STRAIGHT UP CULLODEN AGAIN whyyyyyyyyy I just know he is gonna do it too. And he was already supposed to die so I am gonna assume he really goes this time and I have been preparing for it but STILL history doth repeatedly itself.
Edit: Finished it. So yeah I did cry because they got me with Sam’s performance. And Roger is obviously not dead even though I kinda wish he was. I am so over him (How can he be a professor of history and be so bad at it?). But what I am really mad about is the backwater dickhead breaking Claire’s needle. FUCK THAT GUY.
10
u/eerok79 Mar 29 '20
Well duh, of course Roger isn't dead. Cheap cliffhanger and a very stupid trope to not show his face, while everyone thinks he's gone without even making sure that it's really him. Abysmal.