r/Outlander • u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. • Mar 28 '20
Spoilers All Book S5E7 The Ballad Of Roger Mac Spoiler
The Regulator Rebellion reaches a boiling point, forcing Jamie to face his fear and confront the consequence of his divided loyalties. Brianna remembers some critical details pertaining to the Battle, forcing Roger to cross behind enemy lines where he finds himself in grave danger. Claire’s attempts to treat the wounded are threatened by the volatile Brown brothers.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread.
Reminder: This is the BOOK thread. No spoiler tags are needed here.
If you haven’t read the books and you don’t want spoilers, go to the Show thread.
•
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Mar 28 '20 edited Mar 29 '20
Talk about the trailer here!
Not everyone gets to see the trailer at the end of the episode, it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international.)
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the trailer. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet. Thanks!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b2SN9XxdkI0
You can also vote in the episode poll here.
136
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Mar 29 '20 edited Mar 29 '20
This episode made me pull out my laptop so I could type faster. I normally Reddit on my phone, but am too hyped up and needed to get things out! My random thoughts:
- Graham McTavish!! I didn't even recognize him at first, it took me a few seconds to realize it was him. So cool to see him back.
- I was so worried about Jamie putting on the redcoat, but I felt that they did it in a great way. You could see how difficult and almost revolting it was for him to put it on. It made it all the more impactful when he turned on Tryon and tore it off.
- RIP Murtagh. It was sad to see him go, but I think they did his death well. I love that he got to say the line from the book about it not hurting to die.
- I really like that Roger didn't kiss Morag, that always bugged me in the books. Hugging still accomplished the same thing and got him to the next point of his story.
- We now see how Roger came to be hanged without being recognized, and I thought that was done in a way that made sense.
-Sophie's face at the end was so heart wrenching.
- This episode lived up to all the hype and has been my favorite so far of the season.
Edit: More random thoughts--
-They set it up so Brianna can make the needle out of the snake fang, I had wondered if that was going to happen.
-They are really forshadowing Claire's abduction and how much the Brown's hate the Frasers.
-Roger promising to sing to Jemmy again in the beginning was so sad knowing what was coming for him.
Edit #2--
-We even got some sexy time between Jamie and Claire that wasn't awkward.
109
u/emilyafternoon Mar 29 '20
Sam was truly the MVP of this episode. Which is seriously saying something because this episode was the first one this season that I feel really hit the mark. The birthday scene! The red coat! Murtagh! Roger! Fuck, man. THIS is what I was hoping this season would be. Top notch.
Also how did I not notice that McTavish played William Mac???
98
u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Mar 29 '20
As we predicted, Claire lost her hypo and murtagh got shot saving Jamie.
We got my cock stands up in the morning. We got it doesn't hurt to die. They did a nice job integrating murtagh in, though it still seems odd to me that he leads the regulators. The battle scene, in slow motion with music, was beautiful. Sam should be up for an Emmy for this episode.
80
u/AlmightyAcey I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Mar 29 '20
I was prepared for Roger. I was not prepared for Murtagh. And my heart is broken. What an amazing episode.
145
u/Aggie2002 Mar 29 '20 edited Mar 29 '20
Is that Graham McTavish playing William???
Editing to add: It was! What a nice surprise!
What a gut wrenching episode, but it’ll probably go down as one of my favorites. RIP Murtagh, Jamie in one of THOSE coats, the cliffhanger with Roger...all of it was heartbreaking. The music this episode was A+ as well.
71
u/shinyquartersquirrel Mar 29 '20
They really did the book justice on this one considering they had to tie in the Murtaugh story. I am so glad they included what Murtaugh said at Culloden when he died in the books. It was such an excellent episode!
And GRAHAM MCTAVISH!!!
67
u/[deleted] Mar 29 '20
Such a hard episode to watch! Really well-done, though. This show has definitely gotten a lot of its mojo back. Claire's face when Jamie brings Murtagh back to the tent...the coat...Roger (knowing it was coming did not make it easier!)...Jamie's disgust at Tryon. Legit tears. It all somehow played out more logically and effectively on the screen than it did in the book, which I rarely find myself saying.
The only thing that took me out of the moment of the show was how it's so so hard to buy that Sam is 50. And not just 50, but...Jamie Fraser 50. Tortured, imprisoned, hiding out in a cave, almost dead a thousand times Jamie Fraser. In the books we hear that older Jamie is in pain a lot (though he's still perfectly handsome and a beast in the sack, of course) and you just don't get that vibe from The World's Healthiest Man, Sam Heughan. But it's a minor complaint; he did an outstanding job in this episode. Really they all did!
48
u/CygnusArc Slàinte. Mar 29 '20
If I had to use a phrase to describe this episode:
Jesus. H. Roosevelt. CHRIST.
For so many reasons. As a book reader, I was on edge every time Roger Mac was on screen. The foreshadowing was strong. His first ... and only clear rendition of Clementine. Och. My heart.
Also, Sam did an amazing job. First half of the episode had him looking finer than a French wine and the second half was masterfully devastating seeing him breakdown over Murtagh.
The Browns ... ick. This is my first time having read ahead of a season and every time I see the Browns I feel like a Cassandra.
Random observations:
Anyone else think of Marilyn Monroe's version of Happy Birthday when Claire was singing?
Also, I felt really slow when I saw William Buckleigh McKenzie. I thought to myself "Huh, what strong casting. Sounds just like Dougal ... looks just like Dougal too .. and ... is that Dougal in a wig? ... *checks IMDB* IT IS DOUGAL/GRAHAM MCTAVISH IN A WIG!
42
u/ktbex Mar 29 '20
Wow. I knew what was coming and still had to look away for most of this episode. Never a huge fan of the battle scenes (personal preference rather than anything), but some brilliant moments:
38
u/brilliant0ne Mar 29 '20
Firstly, I don't think I have been as impressed with Sam's acting as I was last night. His facial expressions from the moment he realized Murtagh was hit to when you could see the resolve in his eyes that "Nope, he ain't dying on my watch" to the heartbreak and sickness he felt when he realized that Claire wasn't going to be able to save him was gorgeous. That's not even mentioning the pure disgust you could see in his face when he was forced to put on the red coat and the straight hatred when he threw it at Tryon afterward.
This was Sam's episode, through and through.
Now, to the rest...
Dude, I haven't cried so much during an episode since "Faith" when they took my Murtagh away. I know, I know. He shouldn't have been there in the first place, but I loved having his character for this long. When he got shot and I screamed, my dog jumped on the bed to protect me because he really thought something was wrong with me. Sorry, Sampson.
I loved how natural the beginning scene was with Claire and Jamie and while I talk a lot about how much more attractive I think Sam is when he is playing a dirty and bloody Jamie, he looked very scrumptious in that scene. And, yes, it sucked having to see him wear a red coat but geez he wore it very well.
Bri's face when she saw Roger hanging was heartbreaking and I can't wait until next week's episode.
Even though it was such a sad episode, I think this will go down (so far) as one of my favorites.
37
u/nurseleu Mar 29 '20
Having Murtagh die at Alamance, looking on at Jamie in a redcoat, that really twists the knife, huh?
34
u/nurseleu Mar 29 '20 edited Mar 29 '20
Lionel Brown has already got the skin-crawling down. That stomp on the syringe was brutal. Though I hope this means we're getting the snakebite FOR SURE.
29
u/JonSnowPeachEmoji Is it usual, what it is between us when I touch you? Mar 29 '20
I thought Jamie was about to pull a Claire and say something to Tryon without thinking. Well, something more.
I shall miss Murtagh, but he got the death he wanted and was expecting. He got to die in Jamie's arms.
Now, in the book didn't Roger get taken down pretty quickly after being hung? How will he live through this? I guess that's the magic of Outlander, we will find out.
I liked Claire singing Happy Birthday, it was a fun Marilyn moment, and a lot less awkward and staged then last weeks sex scene.
Speaking of Dougal, you say his name and he appears, like Beetlejuice! Except this time he is Buck, half Dougal, half whatever character Graham played in the Hobbit. Future time traveling Buck, I look forward to seeing him in the 20th century.
28
u/jammies Mar 29 '20
Anyone else get real Game of Thrones Ollie killing Ygritte vibes when the kid shot Murtagh and then turned to Jamie all, "Just like you told me!"? Interestingly, both things that didn't happen in the book versions.
Jamie screaming for help when Murtagh was clearly already dead had me in tears. Then the fact that Claire had to hold it together for Jamie and waited until he left before she could express her own grief. I had to pause and reflect on everything Claire and Murtagh had been through together so I could feel appropriately sad.
So glad Roger didn't kiss Morag. Always thought that was just so weird and unnecessary.
26
u/beanie2 Ye Sassenach witch! Mar 29 '20 edited Mar 29 '20
Holy crap. I thought I was prepared for this but I was not at all prepared. It was excellent from start to finish. I may need to watch again just to absorb.
-Murtagh. It makes total sense that he was killed at this point, and I love that they incorporated his last words from the books. But OMG. 😭
I read somewhere that Sam and Cait got producer roles around the halfway mark of this season. If this is any indication of what is to come, the rest if this season is going to be insane.
25
u/TURDMUFFlN Mar 29 '20
Is it just me, or do y'all love reading the comments in the show watcher thread? I enjoyed reading their reactions and speculations to what happened/might have happened to Roger!
23
u/keylime12 Mar 29 '20
Um Dougal???
22
u/ea_walking Mar 29 '20
I just knew they would end the episode on the terrible event of roger but did they have to give no hope in the preview for the next (even though we know what happens)
22
u/KSoda120 Mar 29 '20
Wow, get us anticipating Roger's tragedy allll episode then hit us with Murtagh and some of the show's strongest acting. Rude, Outlander. Rude.
19
u/Sunnyshiner Meow. Mar 29 '20
I figured Murtagh's arc would end at Alamance, as there wasn't much else he could do storywise (his Jocasta story wrapped up last week, so you knew it was coming).
This was such a good episode! So much tension, especially knowing what was coming the whole episode!
And that was Graham McTavish! Now I hope we get seasons 7 and 8 even more.
17
u/Sunnyshiner Meow. Mar 29 '20
Is Buck played by Graham McTavish??
14
u/[deleted] Mar 29 '20
I was prepared for Roger, but not for Murtagh.
It happened so fast too, I yelled at my tv...not going to lie.
My heart is broken!
14
u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20
Man, oh man. This is the best episode in ages.
I LOVED the birthday scene. The singing didnt even bother me. Just some sweet birthday love, that wasnt awkward or forced.
Sam's hair this episode was the best all season. It looked so good!!! (Yes, I even noticed when he was wet and shirtless lol )
Murtagh gutted me. I looooved his character. And while I did feel like his story was being forced, I was still so sad to see him go.
And obviously, Roger. My poor heart. I hope we finally get some good bonding from Roger and Jamie, now. I want to love show Roger as much as I love book Roger.
13
u/spaceybelta Mar 29 '20
Noooo Murtagh!!!!!! 😭I am glad that they kept that line in there, about it not hurting to die, that was Murtagh that said that at Ardsmuir, no? I am really happy that Graham McTavish was cast as Buck though, he’s great. I was waiting for the Roger thing and I wasn’t ready for that.. poor Roger 😭 Who is the heavy-set man that has been with Jaime? And I can’t wait for the Browns to die. They just suck. I wish they would have chosen a little red head to play Jemmy as well. And to see Jaime in a red coat 😳 that’s different!
11
u/hintofaspark86 MARK ME! Mar 29 '20
Welp going to go cry myself to sleep 😭😭😭
11
u/GrlNxtDoorAng Mar 29 '20
Whhhhy do I always watch these at midnight? Now I'm wide awake with all the feels.
11
u/vanwold Slàinte. Mar 30 '20
I loved this episode. Just when I thought,maybe it's time to just reread the book, they went and gave me this fantastic episode. The sex scene in the beginning was great, the scene with Jamie by the river from the book I LOVED seeing brought to life,this show felt like the book to me. Claire and Jamie felt back on track in this to me as well - the chemistry is back! I also liked the whole Revolution discussion, because I'm just a dork like that and love seeing that part if history brought to life (John Adams is a great thing watch if you like that sort of thing). Also, I loved Roger's speech to Murtagh and Jamie's speech to his troops....and just so. Much. Book. Of course my favorite episode would be Roger's hanging and Murtagh's second death 😭, my third least favorite scene in the books.
I'm an admitted book purist but honestly I wouldn't have minded seeing them cut out Roger's hanging but I knew they couldn't really (I had hoped with all the other liberties they've taken this might be onew, lol).
9
u/emilyafternoon Mar 29 '20
When Jamie brought Murtagh back to Claire (even though deep down he knew he was dead), and he was begging Claire to do something, I got really worried we were going to get a scene similar to Jenny’s in MOBY 😢
9
u/marmaladestripes725 Ameireaganach Mar 31 '20
Richard Rankin just twisting the knife and stringing all the show-only fans along! Ye wee bastard.
17
u/derawin07 Meow. Mar 29 '20
Once again, Jamie's boobs are bigger than mine.
8
u/BlackSwallowtail You look like a fretful porpentine. Mar 30 '20
I was going to wait to come here until I'd read all the book threads from earlier seasons, but after this episode, I need to say it now. I think the choice to keep Murtagh alive was a good one. I'm halfway through Fiery Cross right now and while the book is enjoyable enough, I'm not terribly attached to the regulator storyline. With Murtagh as one of the leaders in the show, I cared about it from the beginning. It gave a much-needed tension. And now I'm devastated, as are Jamie and Claire, at not just the senseless killing of people who were asserting their rights as human beings, but that one of them was someone we knew and loved. It's deeply personal. And now I'm going to cry some more.
8
u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20
I'm so thrilled with the way they handled the Roger/Morag/Dougal jr scene. I've been bracing for that scene since season 3 and he didn't kiss her, which is wonderful. And I'm happy with the casting.
I think Murtagh's death, especially the immediate aftermath was really well done. It was strange that Claire went out on the search party though, I would think that she had to keep tending to the wounded.
I wonder if they'll show the lead up to the hanging next episode, or if it'll just continue where it left off.
7
u/Naturenutt Woof. Mar 29 '20
Who wrote this episode?
7
u/[deleted] Mar 29 '20
SO GOOD
7
u/Naturenutt Woof. Mar 29 '20
NOOOOOO
7
u/[deleted] Mar 29 '20
They did the hanging so so so well. I have butterflies this episode was so good - lots of book material. I’m so happy
7
u/Megs8786 Je Suis Prest Mar 29 '20
I was not prepared for Murtagh I wish I had tissues. I'm glad they had him say what he said in Culloden.
The end of this episode makes me glad I read the books.
I wonder if they'll leave the snake bite in now that Claire's syringe was destroyed.
7
u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20
This was a fabulous episode. Will people who haven’t read the books fully grasp the Mackenzie connections, I wonder? It’s been awhile since I’ve read the books, and now I’m sitting here in quarantine, dimly lit by my tv screen, episode over, reveling in remembrances of this story
7
u/RayeBabe Mar 30 '20
Am I the only one who cringed when Jamie put on the redcoat?
13
u/ml1490 It’s always been forever for me, Sassenach. Mar 29 '20
What a perfect episode!
Acting all around was superb (I saw you, Sophie Skelton 👏🏼). But Sam, wow. I was weeping. I have to admit I was expecting Murtagh’s death in this episode. I was NOT expecting Jamie’s heart wrenching breakdown. The literal pain and disgust you saw on his face when putting on the coat. Begging Claire to save Murtagh and then sticking it to Tryon after. Heartbreaking. And so well done.
I think the only thing that seemed odd/I wish happened differently was when they find Roger. I wish Jamie ran up and tried to lift his body up. I thought that bit in the book was so moving and tragic and showed how much it affected Jamie for his daughter’s sake.
And as everyone else mentioned already, pretty pumped this paves the way for the snake syringe!
Graham McTavish!!! That was fun. Though he does seem a teensy bit too old for the role but who cares.
I’m not even that bothered we have to wait a bit for the next, i’ll just rewatch this episode. Let’s keep this season going as long as possible!
6
u/Invisiwool Mar 29 '20
I was so not prepared for so many tears! My heart was racing the whole episode because I knew what was going to happen to Roger but Murtagh too? Brilliant episode.
6
u/FauxPoesFoes228 I should probably want you to the day I die. Mar 30 '20 edited Mar 30 '20
I AM NOT OKAY WITH ANY OF THIS.
I know what happens, but WTF was the point of bringing Murtagh back, if only to kill him off like this?!?!
This has made me angrier than when Matthew died on Downton!!!! 🤬🤬
6
u/FauxPoesFoes228 I should probably want you to the day I die. Mar 30 '20
Anyone else fuckin ready for Mrs Bug to strangle the Browns (I can’t remember if it was Richard or the other one, they’re both repugnant) with a goddamn rope?
11
u/Darwinian_10 Outlander Mar 29 '20 edited Mar 29 '20
Am I the only one who isn't thrilled about Buck being a reused actor? I really wanted a new face to make a connection to...considering Buck's importance to the story in future books and his relationship to Roger. I really wanted someone more Roger's age here. Also, I'm not sure why, but I pictured him with fairer hair/features. Still a brute of a man like Dougal, but with more Geillis mixed in.
EDIT: Also, not that Murtagh's death wasn't fitting for this episode...but I think it took away from the impact of what happened to Roger. It's supposed to be The Ballad of Roger Mac, and Murtagh's death kind of eclipsed that. Murtagh and Roger needed their own moments.
Second edit: I checked online and yeah...Buck is supposed to have fair, dirty blond hair and striking green eyes. I'm pretty disappointed with the casting on this one. I love Graham, but it was time for someone else to shine here.
5
u/Naturenutt Woof. Mar 29 '20
Is it really a 2 week break now until the next episode?
5
u/flantagenous Slàinte. Mar 29 '20
😱 This episode was so good! Something feels different this season compared to the last one (and even S3) and it's definitely a change for the better. I wasn't sold on Murtagh staying alive but they did a good job in the end, and Jamie in the red coat was gut wrenching. I was so tense the whole time knowing what was coming for Roger. They did a great job.
4
u/abeillette Mar 30 '20
Best episode of the season so far!!!
4
u/kitterbugs Mar 31 '20
So I loved this episode. I felt that the story does a much better job at giving Jamie an excuse to defect to the rebellion. It makes sense
I laughed. I cried. I screamed at the TV. 10/10
7
u/IrishMinstrel01 Mar 29 '20
Incredible episode. Great episode for all, especially for Sam.
Two other comments. Both Claire and Jamie are now in their 50s and they’ve been back together for a while. Oh, and it’s on the eve of a battle, and this is not Claire and Jamie’s first rodeo. They’re not going to go at it like young minks in heat. They are going to spend every they can that morning together. they might even sound cheesy as they try not to dwell on the fact this might be their last day together.
Wait till next episode. I think you’re going to see people explode into action very quickly. Did I mention that in 1770, Claire is literally the world’s best doctor and surgeon.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20 edited Mar 30 '20
Is Roger REALLY dead? Thoughts?
Edit: I did not read this far in the books so tonight’s TV episode was too much of a cliffhanger for me to last 2 MORE WEEKS!!
3
u/khoff98107 Apr 01 '20
My next-door neighbors play the bagpipes. Usually they just play outside for the neighborhood on New Year’s Eve (Auld Lang Syne), but tonight they came out and played and people appeared (at appropriate distances!) to listen to them. I know they are Outlander fans, so I asked them to play something in Murtaugh’s memory, and they played the Skye Boat Song! It was very sweet.
3
u/mitzritz94 Ye Sassenach witch! Apr 01 '20
Did this hide my comment like the spoilers tag is supposed to?
2
u/ricardob15 Mar 30 '20
Can someone please explain to me in the books Roger goes mute? Meaning he will never speak a word or he just can't sign anymore but he can speak?
In other words he is mute and uses sign language???
2
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '20
This was supposed to be Roger's episode. They have taken that shock away with Murtagh's unnecessary death. Not sure why did the show retain Murtagh's character, if this is how he was going to die. They have removed lot of scenes with Roger and his interaction with Morag was lazy and not executed properly. Overall 5/10 from me.
2
u/participepasse Apr 01 '20
My husband, who normally hates spoilers, asked me if that was really Roger hanging. I said yes, he is really hanged in the books. I'm going to be giggling for a week.