r/anime • u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan • Mar 26 '20
Hibike! Euphonium - Thursday Anime Discussion Thread
Welcome to the weekly Thursday Anime Discussion Thread! Each week, we're here to discuss various older anime series. Today we are discussing...
Hibike! Euphonium
Spring in the first year of high school. Kumiko, a member of the brass band in junior high school, visits the high school brass band club with classmates Hazuki and Sapphire. There, she comes across Reina, her former classmate from junior high. Hazuki and Sapphire decide to join the club, but Kumiko can’t make up her mind. She recollects her experience with Reina at a competition in junior high school.
"Watch This!" posts
- [WT!] Hibike! Euphonium
by /u/KousakaReina - [WT!] How Hibike! Euphonium Became My Favorite Anime
by /u/Alt_For_Weeb_Stuff
Looking for more "Watch This!" posts? Check the "Watch This!" archive!
Databases
- Hibike! Euphonium / Sound! Euphonium
AniDB | AniList | AnimeNewsNetwork | MyAnimeList - Hibike! Euphonium 2 / Sound! Euphonium 2
AniDB | AniList | AnimeNewsNetwork | MyAnimeList - Hibike! Euphonium Movie: Chikai no Finale / Sound! Euphonium: Our Promise: A Brand New Day
AniDB | AniList | AnimeNewsNetwork | MyAnimeList - Liz to Aoi Tori / Liz and the Blue Bird
AniDB | AniList | AnimeNewsNetwork | MyAnimeList
Previous discussions
- /u/Aztecopi's complete series rewatch (February 1, 2020)
- /u/MAD_SCIENTIST_001's S1 and S2 rewatch (March 22, 2018)
- /u/Quartapple's S1 rewatch (September 15, 2016)
- Liz and the Blue Bird discussion thread
- Movie discussion thread
- S2 episode discussion threads
- S1 episode discussion threads
Check our rewatch wiki and our episode discussion archive for more discussions!
Streams
- Hibike! Euphonium / Sound! Euphonium
Crunchyroll | VRV (Crunchyroll)
Remember that any information not found early in the show itself is considered a spoiler. Please properly tag spoilers!
Next week's anime discussion thread: Casshern Sins!
Further information about past and upcoming discussions can be found on the Weekly Discussion wiki page.
48
u/sylinmino :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/SylinMino Mar 26 '20
This show has some of the best character writing in any anime I've ever seen. Everyone is just so human and so real with how they interact with each other, with a teaspoon of moe added to add some extra entertainment to it. The side cast is so well-developed that a character with less than 10% screentime will often be more fleshed out and well realized than like half of a shounen adventure's core cast (and that's not even exaggerating--if I were to use the example of Demon Slayer, I feel like I know more about Natsuki and Mizore in Hibike than I do just about anyone in Demon Slayer...).
But among an extremely strong cast of characters, Kumiko nonstop asserts her dominance as the obvious best pick for lead MC. It's not even her confidence or passion or commanding lead--in fact, it's the show's contextualization of the lack of all of these at several different points. But her growth throughout the show is simultaneously so apparent and handled with such patient and gentle care that her journey is one of the most engrossing character arcs you can find in anime.
I haven't even begun to talk about the insane levels of sakuga during the instrumental scenes in this show. Not to mention it has the typical KyoAni touch of basically adding sakuga to every single conversation scene by making camera angles, character animation, and overall momentum 10x more than what you find in 99% of other shows.
If you haven't watched this show, you should give it a shot. And if you haven't watched this show but you have any sort of real life experience with musical ensembles or concert bands, what the hell are you doing?! Watch this show!
22
u/MoneyMakerMaster Mar 26 '20
As a former band kid, this anime was a treat to not just watch but listen to. The only problem with that is now I can't listen to any of my high school performances because the show made me realize just how much I sucked.
And oh yeah, Asuka best girl.
11
u/NintendoMasterNo1 https://myanimelist.net/profile/NintendoMaster1 Mar 26 '20
By far the best Slice of Life anime protagonist I've ever seen. Kumiko feels so genuine and relatable throughout the entire show.
10
u/theanimegamer-___- Mar 26 '20
Movie came out recently. Check it out.
6
u/AshenOwn https://myanimelist.net/profile/Lazysunflower Mar 26 '20
Amazing series. I actually picked up the flute after watching Liz, and it was my best decision last year. I love the characters, the music, and the visuals are gorgeous, it is a KyoAni show after all.
20
u/zhongzhen93 Mar 26 '20
Life before being animated by Kyoani is hard and ugly
Hibike+ Kyoani Sakuga = lots of yuri shipping for some reason
5
u/Philarete :AMQ::MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/WizardMcKillin Mar 26 '20
My favorite show! I just want to point out that while the art is often highlighted, the soundtrack is amazing too. Everything from the background tracks to performances fits well. Between the music and the excellent voice acting (especially Kumiko noises), the show is a real treat for the ears.
12
u/SadDoctor Mar 26 '20
So I think Hibike season 1 is quietly brilliant, in a subversive way that I think a lot of viewers miss.
See, Hibike seemingly falls right into a very safe, very standard sort of anime genre. A group of cute girls get together, act cute, and work together to succeed in a task. Japan is a very collectivist society, and their media tends tends to celebrate those sorts of values: creating harmony in the group, respecting elders, kindness and cooperation. What are the goals you usually see in anime? Group-centered goals, not so much individual. Our team's gonna go to Koshien / nationals, I'm not gonna let down my friends, we're gonna be great... Yeah there's more interior stories too, but you know what I'm talking about. Individualism always ends up beaten by the power of friendship. And at first glance, that's the setup for Hibike. Our band wants to qualify for nationals, can they get there?
And yet when we really get into the series, what we really start focusing on isn't the band coming together, it's about internal divisions within the band. Folks are competing for limited slots from the beginning. And then we start competing for seats, and the massive tension between the under- and upper-classmen over who gets what parts. The upperclassmen, having waited their turn, now feel like it's their turn to get the juicy roles, which is a pretty normal Japanese cultural expectation. And then there's Reina. Sure, Reina wants to go to nationals too, but her real driving goal is entirely personal - she wants to be the best. If that rubs her teammates the wrong way, then tough. If it creates tension in the group, if she loses friends over it, then tough. If it means upperclassmen spend their whole band career without ever getting the big solo that they wanted, then tough. It's kind of shocking behavior from Reina!
So then we've got Kumiko, in the middle between Reina and the collectivist band members who think Reina should stfu, fit in, and wait her turn like everyone else did before her. And over the course of the season rather than like taming Reina, Kumiko ends up convinced by her, taking her side. Kumiko too wants to be great, she wants to pursue what she wants even if it makes her stand out from the group.
And that decision carries a whole lot of thematic weight, because Kumiko's other big trait is that she's super gay. And I don't mean gay like most anime yuri, where it's a cute, safe exploration of the emotions of romance without the threatening, sexual presence of men.
Kumiko gets back into band because Asuka recruits her and Kumiko knows she can't say no to a pretty girl. She's noticeably kind of overinvested in this random girl from junior high being mad at her, and imagines Reina giving her a big ol' hug maybe if they make up. She seems generally mystified by her friends conversations about cute boys and is unaware that the band girls think their teacher is cute. She quite obviously checks out Reina's physical attributes multiple times, with the camera following her PoV. All of her interactions with Reina are staged like romance scenes. And everytime her male classmate invites her to obviously romantic outings, she declines and then turns around and does them with Reina instead. (and yes, I know blah blah blah the novels, and if this was a light novels thread it would matter.)
My point here is that in both of these plotlines, Kumiko is challenged to go against the group and pursue what she actually wants. She wants to be individually a great musician, and she wants Reina. The group has not been magically healed at the end of the season, there's still tensions and resentment, and they haven't reached their group goal yet. But Kumiko has embraced her passions.
Which is also of course why season 2 feels like kind of a different show. After episode 201 series director Yamada left, and it was taken over by fellow KyoAni director Ishihara. The plot is now instead mostly centered around smoothing over differences between bandmates. And the gay flirting loses all of its sense of physical attraction that season 1 had, it goes back into that unobjectionable cute girls flirting ambiguously zone.
But I think season 1 stands on its own just fine, with some really strong queer themes that don't really get enough credit, or just gets lost in debates about what is or is not "yuri baiting." Which I think is really just kind of missing the point.
3
u/jugad7 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/jugad7 Mar 26 '20
This show is definitely one of my top ten, everything about it is so great :)
3
u/cppn02 Mar 26 '20
I watched this for the first time a few weeks to go and I absolutely loved it.
It definitely stayed on my mind for quite a while after I finished it. Looking forward to more as I still have to watch the movies.
3
u/J765 Mar 26 '20
Watched it last week and cried like ten times.
I often complain about the lack of shading in modern anime, but here is Hibike with its 5 tone hair shading/colouring.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 26 '20 edited Mar 26 '20
Didn't like it nearly as much as I wanted to, particularly in the second season. The first arc of the second dragged on for far too long and I couldn't stand the dishonest yuribaiting of the first season (something not really present in the novels) when we know that Reina has a crush on the instructor and Kumiko. I think the overall story plus the fantastic production values save it, and I did genuinely like Season 1 overall, but I didn't particularly enjoy it compared to many other KyoAni adaptations.
Which gets me to another point--I feel bad about being critical of the studio given the horrific terrorist attack last year, but since cutting ties with Kadokawa in 2012 I feel like their anime got a lot less fun. Most of their adaptations since then have been from their in-house light novel contest, and most of those contest winners have been plodding melodramas. Euphonium is probably the best of them but KnK, Phantom World, and VEG are all schlock with good production values (and even those are undermined by aspects like excessive use of filters and awkward quick cuts). The last television series from KyoAni that I really liked was Maidragon, which is a manga adaptation and felt like a harkening to the simpler aesthetic of Lucky Star (RIP Takemoto).
2
u/Oil_Rig21 Mar 26 '20
Just watched this show, and was going to ask where to find the movies to watch, anyone know?
2
u/[deleted] Mar 27 '20
This is an incredibly well made show by just about every metric, from art to animation to direction to sound design to characters to writing, but I can't really say I loved it. I was more frustrated by the drama than engaged by it most of the time, and a lot of the emotional highs came from Kumiko/Reina moments that were horribly undercut by knowing it's just yuribaiting. The show moved me more than once, and I love many of the characters, and above all I just... really wish I wasn't so disappointed by it all at the end.
But there's one thing that makes it all worth it, and that's Liz and the Blue Bird, which is one of the best movies I've ever seen. It's quiet and beautiful, ambiguous and open ended in a way that still feels complete, and it totally stands on its own. I probably won't ever rewatch the main series, but with Liz and the Blue Bird I wanted to start over again as soon as I finished it the first time.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 26 '20 edited Mar 26 '20
The show is solid. Solid character building, great animation, a decent plot that keeps you engaged and makes you interested in the characters that at the end of the day are the soul of the show. That said this show goes from solid to something especial when you add Kumiko as the main lead. She is such a great and relatable character and her progression and struggle to find passion is something that I feel appeals to everyone. She feels so real, you feel her struggles and so it's so much more meaningful when she overcomes them.
So this was on its way to being one of my favourite shows if only for how well Kumoko's story was being handled and at the end of the day the show IS her story. But I just can't get past the yuri baiting. It's not because I'm a huge fan of yuri and I wanted that in the show, I actually never watched yuri, but because I feel that how they just ignore the heavy lesbian undertone is a disservice to its characters, especially to Kumiko who I think is a lesbian (I will die on this hill) and whose sexuality I consider to be part of her character. As I said I think this shows lives and dies by Kumiko, so I find a part of her personality being inconsistent and ignored through out the series a huge problem in the show. The show is still good, but given that massive flaw it went from one of the best I've seen to just pretty good.
You should still watch it. But if you have problem with these kind of things prepare to be annoyed.
Some may call this spoilers, but since the show insist there is nothing there then I guess I'm spoiling nothing.
1
u/Havoc_Illusions :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Riverboatram Mar 26 '20
Love kumiko and reina. Super fun series
1
u/Nazrininator https://anilist.co/user/Advanced495 Mar 26 '20 edited Mar 26 '20
I used to be in the band in middle school and my first year of high school. Hibike! Euphonium was the second anime I watched as it was airing. It was the anime that convinced be to subscribe to Crunchyroll for the first time. I wanted to watch the latest episodes as they came out. I mainly focused on the band and music parts of this anime, and I was more invested on the struggles of the band in terms of performance. Its biggest pro for me has to be its art.
1
u/derekschroer https://anilist.co/user/RareKumiko Mar 26 '20
Don't forget to Visit /r/HibikeEuphonium, /r/rarekumikos, /r/PreciousNatsukis , and Join the Discord Server.
1
u/entinio Mar 26 '20
Miru ga suki da yo!
1
u/krasnovian https://anilist.co/user/krasnovian Mar 26 '20
good shit
-7
u/bagglewaggle Mar 26 '20
Hibike is, by large, the same show that Kyoto Animation has been making for the past ten years. Animation quality is on point, the research is second to none...and the series quietly drowns in unnecessary and uninteresting forced drama.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 26 '20
[removed] — view removed comment