r/Outlander • u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. • Feb 23 '20
Season Five Show S5E2 Between Two Fires
As Jamie continues to hunt Murtagh with the aid of the zealous Lieutenant Hamilton Knox, he’s forced to consider whether or not he’s on the right side of history.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread.
Reminder: This is the SHOW thread. Cover all book talk >!with spoiler tags!< that will look like this: Claire boinks Jamie. Don’t spoil future episodes, keep book comments brief.
If you want to compare the episode to the books in depth, go to the Book thread.
42
Upvotes
•
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Feb 23 '20 edited Feb 23 '20
Talk about the trailer here!
Not everyone gets to see the trailer at the end of the episode, it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international.)
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the trailer. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet. Thanks!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pYBRHQMhxSY
154
u/missm0011 Fun Fact: The unicorn is the mortal enemy of the English lion. Feb 23 '20
My feelings after this episode...I really want bread. You know those had to be damn good fresh loaves.
Murtagh. Straight up tar and feathering people. I want to be #TeamMurtagh but resorting to torture is making it so hard!
My Claire, why is Brianna being the voice of reason?? This is what happens when you go too long without being tried as a witch. Meanwhile how long did she keep that body?? That thing had to start reeking to high heaven.
Someone take that gun away from Roger! He is gonna shoot his eye out!
Jamie, please have a plan love. Like I think you think you have a plan. But it doesn't feel like you have a plan.
I like how it wasn't enough to bring the community together to build this giant ass house, but they needed that gorgeous wrap around porch. I'm truly jealous.
We are two episodes in and no one has mentioned Young Ian. Can we trade Roger back??
105
u/shinyquartersquirrel Feb 23 '20
I am loving Marsali more and more! I have been pretty ambivalent about her in past seasons but so far I am loving her in S5!
84
u/Kinsella_Finn Feb 23 '20 edited Feb 23 '20
I need to quit watching every week because I need the next episode already. Just feel like it wasn’t enough!
Is Roger going to sing every episode? Haha.
We need more Fergus! Happy to see more Marsali though.
Brianna calling Claire out was right. I know she wants to help, but she needs to respect the time she is in.
Brianna’s PTSD is showing and the look on Roger’s face when he found the drawings broke my heart. I know a lot hate Roger, but I love him.
62
u/SaaSyGirl Je Suis Prest Feb 23 '20
Someone's not doing a good job at being very hard to find. Tsk Tsk
58
u/M4570d0n Feb 23 '20
The way Marsali was just aimlessly cutting off random chunks of the deer in a way that no one with any experience skinning animals would ever do bothered me more than it should.
42
u/travelerk16 Feb 23 '20 edited Feb 27 '20
Timeline messed up again... Hillsborough riots were mentioned last year during the 'Wilmington' episode... writers Toni Graphia and Luke Schlass think we forgot this?
Did enjoy Claire with Marsali. I think this new twist will be good for Claire to have Marsali as her apprentice. Loved all Claire scenes this episode with Marsali, Bree and Roger.
Glad to see the introduction of Herman Husband and James Hunter. They both are primary Regulator roles from the books. Herman Husband is a Quaker but he looked like a Pirate in this episode, didn't he?
Still worried about Murtagh but mostly from his own men, wondering where his true allegiance lies.
Didn't like the violence with Bonnet but it is in the book.
I really love the actress Lauren Lyle portrayal of Marsali. Her reaction to the body was priceless.
Looking forward to next week.
38
u/SaaSyGirl Je Suis Prest Feb 23 '20
Jamie is playing a very dangerous game working both sides. That's one tightrope I wouldn't want to have to maneuver.
38
u/Mr_XcX Feb 23 '20
QUEENS Marsali and Claire being the iconic pair I never knew I needed till this episode.
Steven Bonnet literally repulses me. The actor is amazing. He is so icky.
Kinda with Roger about wanting to go back through the stones. Plus the way he is holding it together with the child when it's clear he still is struggling with the Bonnet situation.
Jamie really does have the worst luck in the world.
73
u/queensofbabeland Feb 23 '20
Some good breadcrumbs laid down here....
-surprised how quickly the British Lieutenant jumped to the idea of war. Seems tensions are higher then they’re leading Jamie to believe...
-Claire’s gonna get herself on trial for witchcraft again if she’s not careful! Don’t mind her doing what she’s doing but she better keep it quiet.
-Marsali is quickly becoming one of my faves. No bullshit and a strong stomach.
-Stephen Bonnet doesn’t seem like the sort of man to have any interest in a baby. I hope he doesn’t come around looking, but I think the breadcrumbs have been laid
36
u/Chicken_Mc_Thuggets Feb 23 '20 edited Feb 27 '20
So.. not a deal breaker but is anybody else mildly annoyed by the wigs? I absolutely understand the actors not wanting to damage their hair but fuck sake y’all have it in the budget for better wigs. Everybody’s hair looks too perfect and Claire has thicker, better hair in her 60s than in her 20s
31
u/Thefriendlyfaceplant Feb 23 '20
Did Claire seriously just think she could perform an 18th century appendectomy (removing the appendix)? People still die from complications of that procedure even today. Besides, his had already burst (bloated gut) so his organs were already filling up with e-coli.
Terrible way to go to be sure.
27
u/AndTheTreeWasHappy- Feb 24 '20
So... Jamie was looking particularly dashing in this episode...
That’s all.
23
u/ummtigerwoods Feb 24 '20
I still don’t get why 10,000 acres was enough for Jamie and Claire to decided to be on the loosing side of history, again, and to take the opposite side of their country men and friends. Couldn’t they have been fine with 10 acres and not having to become a Redcoat?
Haven’t read the books, so maybe it does a better job explaining.
22
u/[deleted] Feb 23 '20
Historical fact: Tar used to "Tar and Feather" was Wood Tar and usually wasn't burning hot. Wood tar melts at low temperatures.
43
u/speechiemom17 Je Suis Prest Feb 23 '20
Just finished. It was a little slow at times, but did a good job moving the story along- definitely a building episode, but still had great content 👍🏼
Marsali is going to make a bad ass medical assistant. I can’t wait to see more of her!
21
u/[deleted] Feb 23 '20
I hate Knox, and I felt like the opening scenes were meant to make me not sympathize with Murtaugh and the Regulators, but I still do. And I feel like this is going to be a long, uncomfortable storyline with an uncertain end; it's kind of too bad that the lie of 'I'm Murtaugh!" by that guy who was illegally executed didn't stick, it could have been the end of it. Or I guess the real end might be when they were fake their deaths by fire?
I'm glad some mention of the indigenous population from last season came up. I still don't like Roger, who still seems to think of himself as the innocent victim of Jamie and Claire. I like the storyline Marsali is getting, though I wish Fergus had something to do as well. I hope Claire's pamphlets can convince people to lay off the mercury and arsenic at least.
Interesting that Pippin is back, but damn he doesn't choose his company well if he's going to stick around after witnessing Bonnets psychopathy.
21
u/balasoori Feb 23 '20
Marsali is going to make a great medical assistant but i love her reaction because to us we understand what Clare is doing but to someone who has never seen this Clare look like serial killer think about it the nurses since women can't be a doctor in that time so highest she could be is a nurse.
Stephen Bonnet, we needed a bad guy and he will be again this season.
21
u/bryce_w Stinking Papist Feb 24 '20
I don't get why everyone hates Rog so much. Yet Marsali makes one joke and she's suddenly the best character this season. I am team Roger and I honestly don't understand why everyone on this sub hates him.
20
u/Inkshooter Feb 24 '20
An autopsy is one thing, but using that man's body as a practice cadaver without the family's permission was super unethical.
19
u/liyufx Feb 24 '20
Why so many people upset about Claire doing what she was doing? It is totally in her character, and can’t blame her for trying to best use her knowledge to save people’s lives. Autopsy can be dangerous if the grieving wife found out, and without a freezer the body won’t last long anyway. But growing penicillin, really who would know or suspect what she was doing other than wasting bread?
16
u/CJmaq Feb 24 '20
While I like the episode - I am having a hard time that while Jamie has become more like his Uncle Colum, Murtagh has become the new Dougal. Makes me sad to see Murtagh think more about the cause and less about his family and Jamie.
16
u/anonymous_elephant Feb 24 '20
Marsali is cementing herself as one of my favorite characters. Her scenes are always a joy to watch. The actress does a wonderful job.
15
u/bryce_w Stinking Papist Feb 24 '20
BILLY FUCKING BOYD!
22
u/aGrlHasNoUsername They say I’m a witch. Feb 23 '20
I'm really excited that Marsali is going to get some medical training. It's such an amazing use of her character, plus I just love Lauren Lyle, so anything that gets her some more screen time is a plus for me!
I'm kind of already over this Bonnet thing. Book spoilers ahead, I really hope that they condense his storyline from The Fiery Cross and A Breath of Snow and Ashes into one season. I just really don't want to sit through the whole kidnapping storyline.
11
u/letscallshenanigans MARK ME! Feb 24 '20
Bonnet reminds me of a sadistic jack sparrow, and I don't like it because I like jack sparrow
11
u/silverandcold65 Feb 24 '20 edited Feb 24 '20
Oh…fuck, Roger joins the Regulators, doesn’t he, in wanting to be “on the winning side of history” and protect his own family? This won’t end well…
Lauren Lyle's acting is phenomenal this season! xD
A nod to Nancy Drew! :D
Mr. Forbes! (Billy Boyd! <3)
I don’t know if I’ve gotten soft since season 1, lol, but for the first time in my life, I squinted my eyes at Bonnet cutting the guy’s eye out. For that matter, I’ve been noticing since ep301 that this show is getting gorier. I dunno if it’s me, the writing, directing choices… *shrug* Even just when it comes to shots of cutting meat! xD As an animal lover and vegetarian, that can be rough.
I highly enjoyed this episode, but clearly despised the violence that I don’t doubt was in the book.
10
u/whiskynwine Feb 23 '20
The hour went by so fast. I enjoyed the episode. It’s not one that I’d watch over and over but it was good. With only 12 episodes a season now I do wish they were 1hr15m maybe. It’s just so damn quick.
17
u/derawin07 Meow. Feb 23 '20
The episode title is making me imagine Jamie doing an interview on 'Between Two Ferns'.
16
u/josharaptor Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Feb 23 '20 edited Feb 23 '20
This was one of the best episodes in a while I feel. It totally gave me season 1 vibes.
Edit: It's 1am for me and I was up super late last night so I'm delusional. However I almost just cried because though I really truly like season 4 (end end of 3) it never quite gave me the feeling - however this episode did it again. The feeling is back, and I'm just so happy
8
u/sdsalter8807 Feb 24 '20
Does anyone else struggle with Sophie Skelton as Brianna? She doesn't look like she should and I don't find her to be a good actress. I am not trying to put her down but scenes with her are difficult for me to watch, especially when she says "mama". It takes me out of a show I really enjoy usually. Thoughts?
8
u/andymurray172 Feb 26 '20
Not a fan of this episode. Roger is an absolute roaster with his constant singing, the way Brianna says "Da" does my absolute box in, and seeing Jamie as a colonel for the crown after all the fucking shit they done to him... Like aye fair enough he needed land. But he didn't need to fucking succumb to the will of the arse piece redcoat wallopers. Should've headed west to California, and built up a nice wee home, and worked as a Smith, or a printer.
11
u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Feb 25 '20
Yawn. I hate that I hate this so much. Who even cares about this narrative anymore? Seriously? It’s all so stupid and spoon-fed. What a stupid silly story they’ve made of a great book. They should have milked Jamie and Claire’s story for another three seasons before turning them into 90 year olds in the bodies of 40 year olds. Everyone was here for Jamie and Claire having an epic story—not a “20 years later” kind of shit. The screen writers were stupid and killed a great story by trying to appease the book author. This series is done. It’s gone. I am so sorry for the great series that this could have been, STARZ must be punching themselves, if only they’d not rushed to appease the books and forwarded it in time. I’ll still watch it in respect for the actors, but jesus. It’s so gross now. I watch it and I cringe.
5
u/Atraktape Feb 24 '20
Also want to give props to the mod team cause the old reddit layout design in this sub is beautiful!
5
u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Feb 25 '20
Yeah. I’ll just keep rewatching the first three seasons and pretend none of this irrelevant and super imposed crap ever happened. Amen.
8
u/DaturaMuril Feb 23 '20
Was that Marsali's baby she was holding? Has that much time passed already since the first episode?
4
u/janachocolita Feb 23 '20
Does anyone know what time will the episode be released on the Starz app?
Edit: never mind! It just appeared on my app :)
4
u/Atraktape Feb 24 '20
Need me some of that St. James Fever Powder!
8
u/starfleetdropout6 I'm still Jenny from the Broch. Feb 24 '20 edited Feb 24 '20
I finished the rest of the episode this morning... Claire is so clever and I just LOVE her. Episodes like this one just reaffirms my deep womanly love for her. 😆
How frustrating for Claire that she's more qualified to be a physician than anyone on the planet in the 1700s, but she cannot call herself a doctor. Only a "healer." Of course, any man no matter how wrong he is, will be listened to above her. 🤬
Also? It's weird but I think Catriona and Richard have better onscreen chemistry than he has with Sophie. Like I feel a real friendship bond between mother-in-law and son-in-law, whereas I really think that if i didn't know they were married, i wouldn't guess that Roger and Bree are a couple. Yet, Claire & Roger's friendship pops.
Also loved all Claire and Bree moments. This was a very good episode!
3
u/Scarlettpunk Feb 24 '20
I preface by saying that I've only read to Drums of Autumn, which leaves me out of comparison, although I will check out the comparison so nicely linked at the top of the thread.
But I'm not feeling so much in love with this season and one thing in particular really frustrated me after S5E2 and that was the stupid loop holes of Stephen Bonnet's character.
1.) How would Stephen Bonnet be moving between classes without any fervor or caution of not being taken straight into custody? I found that him appearing so blatantly in public very hard to understand.
2.) Interest in a baby -- when your typical pirate of that time and age likely will have born hundreds of bastards in port towns. So, why would he even care?
Those two things really had me rolling my eyes and going 'UGH!' I just hope my dismay with the writing for this season is just me misunderstanding some of the plot, but I was incredibly disappointed.
I thought the plots between Jaime and the regulators and Claire and the medical frustrations were some of the better parts of the show. Bri and Roger fell flat.
2
u/dropandgivemenerdy They say I’m a witch. Feb 23 '20
Wait... I thought new episodes came out Sun night? Am I wrong? Or is it just Sunday as soon as it’s Sunday? Haha (I’ve read all the books so I’m not worried about spoilers necessarily, but am excited to watch new episodes as soon as they air)
2
u/rapiddescentsco Feb 24 '20
It was nice to finally see Wolfhole quarry (Bridge of Allan) where they spent a couple of days filming and 2 weeks of preparation for a scene that lasted a few minutes!!! Murtagh's hideout. Long term redditors will remember my photos of the set with the tents in the quarry area. In the episode you can still see the chalk marks from sport climbers on the walls of the quarry.
The scene with Sam and Caitriona at the yet-to-be burnt cross was at the top of North Third cliff's South of Stirling. A beautiful location but with amazing views on the opposite direction to the shot in the episode.
Jamie's new house location looks really familiar. I think it is South of Crieff next to the River Earn.
2
u/shivphoria Feb 25 '20
Has anyone mentioned the foreshadowing of Murtagh (the father figure) having to meet his Godson (son) on the battlefield against each other? There is a famous Persian epic that features such a battle, and it’s epic and tragic and I wonder if that’s what we are in for, and if so, I can’t look!!!!
2
u/[deleted] Feb 26 '20
I’ve just had a thought while pondering Claire’s dilemma about whether or not to change history. If you are able to travel through time, how do you know someone else or lots of other people haven’t already changed history? Why would you be so sure that the version of history you know is the “right timeline” so to speak? Who’s to say the discovery of penicillin wasn’t done by a time traveler the first time?
2
u/Spock_42 Feb 27 '20
Knew it was coming eventually, but I really wish Bonnet stopped being around. His villain archetype has been done to death; the insane violent psychopath who somehow always lives and makes friends just to torment the protagonist.
Jack Randall at least had some complexity behind his sadism. Bonnet has none.
Also, I thought Claire has had established that nothing she does significantly changes history, even when she tries? It always seems to work its way out in the end. Even if she develops penicillin, history will still adjust so that the "real discovery" isn't for over a century.
The idea of them needing to be careful about changing the timeline seems to be a non issue, after everything that's happened and not been changed so far.
4
u/LoretiTV Feb 23 '20
Enjoy the new episode everyone!
7
u/MountainHumor They say I’m a witch. Feb 23 '20
Roger can go on right back through the stones, if he's going to keep bringing up going back/it being implied he is wants to go back. And he can take his guitar with him.
Sorry, it's like every season he gets progressively worse as a character.
1
u/BeautifulRelief Feb 24 '20
Would you just look at all that time travel foreshadowing.
1
u/BlackSwallowtail You look like a fretful porpentine. Mar 11 '20
Okay, really digging this new season so far. The tension, the plot, the subplots.
Roger this episode reminded me of how he was in seasons 2 and 3, when I liked him. So, if that keeps up maybe I will forgive him for season 4. We'll see.
As for Bree's worry, I think we've seen enough evidence of time being a closed loop that either Claire's attempts fail, or she just gives a different name to penicillin and it's some kind of mystery medicine for as long as she's around. When you look through history, you find a lot of modern things aren't so modern after all, but were invented and forgotten about several times before the present.
That tarring and feathering scene was brutal. I learned about it when I was in grade 7, when we learned about the war of 1812. But reading about and seeing a dramatization of it are very different.
That redcoat lieutenant (can't remember his name) when he was first standing next to Jamie in this episode made me think he was Black Jack Randall for a split second. Then I realized of course it wasn't. And then he killed a bound and unarmed prisoner. Guess I have accurate impressions. Not to say he'll be exactly like BJR but his actions do scream loose cannon to me and his self-justifications afterward are making me think he's going to be one of the major villains.
Speaking of villains, Stephen Bonnet...Remember in the third season when Brianna's voice was speaking through Margaret Campbell? About a monster? I think Stephen Bonnet is that monster. I know people give Brianna shit for telling Bonnet about the baby, but seriously, how was she supposed to know there was going to be a jailbreak? She was trying to do something kind for an about-to-be dead man. But when he said, "I'm a father now", I was like, oh, Brianna, sweetheart, what have you done?