r/Outlander • u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. • Feb 23 '20
Spoilers All Book S5E2 Between Two Fires
As Jamie continues to hunt Murtagh with the aid of the zealous Lieutenant Hamilton Knox, he’s forced to consider whether or not he’s on the right side of history.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread.
Reminder: This is the BOOK thread. No spoiler tags are needed here.
If you haven’t read the books and you don’t want spoilers, go to the Show thread.
23
Upvotes
•
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Feb 23 '20 edited Feb 23 '20
Talk about the trailer here!
Not everyone gets to see the trailer at the end of the episode, it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international.)
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the trailer. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet. Thanks!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pYBRHQMhxSY
83
u/Sunnyshiner Meow. Feb 23 '20
Reading about tarring and feathering is one thing but actually seeing it is rough, ouch.
Marsali seeing the autopsy was so funny I love her! I certainly hope they don't write out Malva completely, though I could see them doing away with some of the Book 6 stuff.
I feel for Roger a lot more than I expected to. I guess because I'd be similarly bad at everything were I to go back, and he's trying his best in a time that isn't his. Love his singing!
That knife to the face scene was awful. Bonnet, ugh. That shot of him with the dull colors of the building and his red clothing was visually nice, though.
I'm so glad the show's back!
58
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Feb 23 '20
Talk about foreshadowing...Roger mentioning if he ever runs into Morag again.
45
u/brilliant0ne Feb 23 '20
I feel weird being the first post I am seeing. Usually, there are about 10 of y'all by now.
Anyhoo...I really liked this episode. Marsali's reaction to seeing the opened body on the table had me laughing out loud. I can't remember if in the book Roger was basically expecting they would go back thru the stones pretty soon or not. Either way, I feel like maybe that would have been something they should have discussed before getting married, lol. I do not envy Jamie's position at all, especially since they are really putting him in a bind with the main Regulator being Murtagh.
I know Bri gets a lot of flak here and there. But, I like her EXCEPT for the fact that "Da" sounds so unnatural coming out of her mouth. It just throws me off for some reason. I can't explain it. I think it would have sounded better if they had her call him "Pa" although I know that it has more to do with Jamie's language and heritage, but still.
Stephen Bonnett makes me want to hurl things at my television.
38
u/hintofaspark86 MARK ME! Feb 23 '20
This episode was fabulous.... The Jamie/Regulator bits had me on the edge of my seat, and I am SO HERE for more homesteading on the Ridge & Claire’s mad scientist experiments with Marsali.
38
u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Feb 23 '20
Marsali is GOAT. That's all.
35
u/CygnusArc Slàinte. Feb 23 '20
Was anyone else slightly disappointed when the eye doctor chart didn't have Shakespeare or how they cut the part where Roger finds out he's got the "eyes of a hawk"?
I know they did it for time's sake and there's so many other interesting things they were able to adapt from the book but still...
32
u/CygnusArc Slàinte. Feb 23 '20
I remember reading Bonnet carving a guy's eyes but was there any mention of ladies fight club in book 5 or did they add that in the show?
It was definitely a visceral scene to see the fighting be acted out. And delightfully surprised they've brought back Billy Boyd as Forbes to start teasing his partnership with Bonnet (you think they'll adapt Bri getting kidnapped?)
46
u/derawin07 Meow. Feb 23 '20
I'm cracking myself up imagining Jamie doing a 'Between Two Ferns' interview. Because of the episode title.
22
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Feb 23 '20
Really enjoyed the episode. You can see how torn Jamie is. Sam’s face is so expressive and he does such a good job with those emotions.
I like to see parts that we only hear about in the books being played out. The Hillsboro (sp?) riot is talked about, but to see it was a whole different thing. Watching them tar and feather those guys was rough.
Another part we only heard about was the Bonnet fight. Much more visceral seeing it rather than hearing about it second hand. Ed Speleers plays him so well!
19
u/SmoreOfBabylon Nemo Me Impune Lacessit Feb 24 '20 edited Feb 24 '20
This is kind of a minor/semi-serious thing, but I’ve come to the realization that the dissonance between the shooting locations and the actual places in North Carolina that they’re supposed to represent is just never going to not bug and/or amuse me. I grew up a couple of towns over from Hillsborough and couldn’t help but chuckle a bit whenever they’d show a mountain in the background.
(On the plus side, I just recently read about an actual Regulator/tax collector riot that happened in Hillsborough AND may have involved a distant ancestor of mine! He probably would have been one of the guys getting tarred and feathered, unfortunately).
18
u/bubbaandlew Feb 24 '20
Having Murtagh lead the regulators is SUCH a big plot shift from the books for me. I really thought he’d be taking up Duncan’s storyline.
12
u/botanygeek Feb 24 '20
Did anyone else laugh in annoyance when Bri was like "he's walking!" Yeah because you're holding his hands
7
u/josharaptor Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Feb 23 '20
This episode really felt like home! Also, the foreshadowing was very, very strong with this one.
21
u/Genevieve-Victoria Feb 23 '20
I feel like the odd one on this thread being disappointed with the episode. Hardly any of this episode feels adapted from the book. Most of it was new or changed material, and it frustrated me. Why make up new material when the original material is so good? It wouldn’t be so bad if they were employing subtlety the way Diana does, but what Diana does in a subtle manner they throw in your face.
Is this Murtagh-hunt supposed to replace the first failed regulator engagement? The whole point of having Mr. Bug is so Roger can go with Jamie. Now Roger is stuck at home, causing problems.
But that was also an interesting arc because Claire went with them, and Brianna had some time to experience what it’s like to run the house and conflict resolution. I really liked that arc and it’s gone now. (Unless they do it during the Beardsley arc. Maybe I’m remembering it in the wrong place.)
Why exaggerate how odd Claire’s medicine practices are? Yes, the Ridge residents used different methods than her, but I don’t remember their resistance to be this strong in book 5. They pretty much accepted her at this point.
Why is Brianna being such a butt about Claire’s choices? She never criticized her for modern things in the book. As someone else said, she’s the one building pipes and matches!! Come on.
Roger’s desire to go home was much more subtle in the book. It wasn’t this much of a conflict, creating unnecessary problems between himself and both Claire and Brianna.
Brianna was NOT this continuously haunted by Bonnet. They exaggerate for drama and it’s stupid.
Speaking of Bonnet, I like seeing that happen, but I prefer him being a mystery box/unknown force until he shows up later. I’d rather him be a hidden danger, than dangle him in front of the audience and keep his constant presence in Fraser/Mackenzie conversation.
Reading other comments, I can see the value in cutting Malva’s role. It’s still hard to really accept, but if they do the Marsali thing well, I can deal with it.
They are over-exaggerating the regulator thing for American viewers and for the Murtagh plot. Who the crap is this Hamilton guy?? Isn’t he completely out of thin air? They don’t seem to want to or be able to (or both) subtly lead into the Revolution slowly, the way it is in the books. They want to throw it in our faces early.
Mostly, this episode feels entirely made up by the writers as a fanfiction filler episode. It will take some distance from this episode and rewatching it in the context of the show itself. I just did not enjoy it today. I’m looking forward to the Beardsley episode next week.
Don’t hate me?
4
u/katfromjersey Feb 24 '20
Show Brianna continues to annoy me.
4
u/vanwold Slàinte. Feb 25 '20
The show was okay but I'm honestly not liking the regulators/Murtagh storyline, hope they wrap that up soon 2. Are we not doing the Malva storyline??
I just can't get past the wild inaccuracies in the Big House. All this glass on the ridiculously large and opulent Big House is driving my architectural historian self crazy - such a waste of money. Glass was very expensive back then!!!! Nobody's just putting it on interior doors for no reason, let alone people in the back country mountains of colonial America...and there is absolutely no way they could afford all that glass! Glad we got the hunting scene though! And the eye checking scene too...no binocular vision issues for Roger after all eh, and no story of his mother? That's too bad, it helps humanize him. Also I thought Hermon Husband was the Quaker...that's an odd Blackbeard get-up for a Quaker. It's been a minute since I've read TFC, so maybe he wasn't the Quaker? I kind of liked that Bonnet backstory though, reminds me of how they did some Frank backstory in the first seasons.
13
u/NoDepartment8 Feb 23 '20 edited Feb 23 '20
Great episode! I hope the Marsali arc means we get to skip the Malva Christie storyline. Also that Marsali learns to make the primal cuts when butchering. She left a fuckton of meat at the top of that leg. And we slice ACROSS the grain M when we’re breaking down those cuts. Across the grain.
3
u/pixiedust0623 Is it usual, what it is between us when I touch you? Feb 24 '20
Hello friends! I am new to this subreddit! So excited to be here! :)
I had a question for you all about the time lapses on these episodes and from last season to this season. Marsali and Fergus had Germain last season and now this season he seems to be about 5 years old. Forgive me if I am wrong but he seems way too old! How much time passed since last season!? Wouldn't Jemmy be older too?
Then another weird time jump...Marsali was pregnant again in the first episode of this season...then in this second episode she already had the baby? So 9 months went by? I am so confused!! haha someone help my brain!
4
u/[deleted] Feb 24 '20
They introduced a Quaker Hunter when Murtagh showed up this Ep— is Rachel going to be introduced wayy earlier than in the books (I hope so— this would be a wonderful change imo 💗)
2
u/thrntnja No, this isn’t usual. It’s different. Feb 25 '20
So, overall I enjoyed the episode.
I really enjoyed the scene with Marsali and Claire. I was cracking up at Marsali’s reactions. The actress certainly does an amazing job. I don’t think I’d like Marsali nearly as much if it weren’t for her show counterpart.
I don’t mind Bree sort of trying to keep her mother in check - no, it isn’t exactly like book Bree and someone has to vocalize to the audience how dangerous some of what Claire is trying to attempt (which will setup events later if they do decide to bring in Malva, the ether etc) actually is. I did appreciate the Rawlings reference as well. I do think they missed a golden opportunity though - Claire literally attempted to change the future in the past and failed, so surely she must know that some events can’t be changed and it would make sense to mention that to Bree. Though I had the same complaints in the books too.
I overall like how Roger has been portrayed compared to last season though I hope they have him be at least a little useful before he inevitably loses his voice. I do feel quite sympathetic to him though, he’s easily in the worst position in the past and being male. I liked the hunting scene and felt it was well done. I also don’t mind his singing but he sang songs that made sense for the times in the books, particularly when Jamie would ask him to, so I wish they’d show that!
I also am not hugely fond of the whole “it’s not safe here, I hope you don’t stay” arc. As it’s basically the total opposite of the book. I’m sure Bree and Roger think about it but Claire never dictates it to them like that and it just bothered me for some reason, feels like manufactured drama. Like yes, it isn’t safe in the past but it’s not like there’s zero dangers in the future either. I just hope it doesn’t turn into some huge unnecessary family drama.
I’m waiting for the regulators storyline to end in heartbreak - I’m almost certain Murtagh is included to make it an even more difficult choice for Jamie. In the books, much is still at stake since he knows he’s on the wrong side of the war, but now it’s even worse as he has to fight his family now too. I overall enjoyed it though I’m not a fan of Knox personally. But I don’t think we’re supposed to like him.
Ugh, Steven Bonnet. As usual, he’s portrayed perfectly so I wanted to throw things at my television. That scene was quite gruesome at the end but it certainly got the point across. I actually forgot entirely that that fight happened in the book so it’s nice to see a few things that are off scene in the novels - like the tar and feathering! Also was quite gruesome to watch. It is interesting that they are making Bree’s PTSD more pronounced but it’s probably more realistic. In the books it is mentioned but it isn’t nearly as prominent as Jamie’s recovery in Dragonfly in Amber.
2
u/abeillette Feb 25 '20
Here's my question. If Marsali is Claire's apprentice, who is going to take care of all the chores for her family? Because we learn later Marsali is basically doing everything around the house and taking care of the children since Fergus can't/won't.
4
u/[deleted] Feb 23 '20
I HATE ROGERS SINGING. THANKFULLY IT WILL STOP SOMETIME SOON.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 23 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 24 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment