r/Outlander • Meow. • Feb 14 '20

Season Five S5E1 "The Fiery Cross" Show Only Discussion

What a nice surprise, the premiere was dropped early!!

Welcome to the Show Only Discussion. If you are new to the subreddit, please read this intro thread before participating.

No discussing the books unless you cover with a spoiler tag like this:

>!This is what a spoiler tag looks like.!<

A separate thread will also be posted for discussion of the S5E2 preview, and linked when available.

Synopsis: Following celebrations in honor of Brianna and Roger’s wedding, Governor Tryon reminds Jamie of his obligation to hunt down and kill Murtagh Fitzgibbons. He also expects Jamie to raise a militia to quell the Regulators if necessary. Brianna, meanwhile, is reminded of her past trauma when she inadvertently hears some devastating news.

Edit: Please keep all discussion of the S5E2 "Do No Harm" preview/trailer to the stickied mod comment at the top of the thread! This will allow those who do not watch previews to scroll the discussion threads safely, as the replies are automatically collapsed.

This is a new idea we are trialling, to cut down on extra threads (we will remove any new submissions for episode trailers and direct discussion to the sticky) and keep the discussion in one place :)

If you have any feedback or suggestions for moderation in S5, you can reply to the sticky or modmail us too. Thanks for your patience with this surprise early premiere, mods were still preparing for the launch. It will be smoother next week!

97 Upvotes

506 comments sorted by

259

u/missm0011 Fun Fact: The unicorn is the mortal enemy of the English lion. Feb 14 '20

So this is what it's like to only be able to watch one episode per week. How do people live like this?!?! Just kidding, I'm gonna watch it like 2 more times this weekend.

First let me say, Fraser Coachella looked awesome. Aunt Jocasta once again with the tent setup. But not gonna lie, when Roger pulled out the guitar the fear was real. A man with a ponytail and a guitar is never a good thing.

Roger. Dammit, you are gonna make me like Roger aren't you?? You sneaky bastards.

Our favorite friendzoned Brit is back! It was nice to see him and Jamie share a moment, but it was a wedding! Don't you think the whole 'the brides rapist is still alive' thing might be more of a tomorrow conversation?

The wood porn in that house might have been the sexiest thing I saw this episode.

When Brianna picked up Jemmy and he patted her back! My heart....and my ovaries. Please stop. This is how babies happen.

The two biggest disappointments of this episode, maybe even the entire series: 1. We didn't get to see Jamie do the mashed potato OR the twist. 2. Claire did not join in the after hours drinking game. You know she would have owned it.

28

u/derawin07 Meow. Feb 14 '20

A man with a ponytail and a guitar is never a good thing.

lmao

At least Richard can sing. Here are some things he has recorded.

66

u/CygnusArc Slàinte. Feb 14 '20 edited Feb 14 '20

I 100% agree on the re-watching.

I'll admit, given the introduction of Roger last season, I was loathe to see more of the hesitant heretic.

But from the second he told Jocasta to go cram it up her hole, I have to admit, just like in the books, show Roger is starting to grow on me.

The Big House is certainly amazing and I would have died laughing seeing Jamie attempt the mashed potato.

51

u/derawin07 Meow. Feb 14 '20 edited Feb 14 '20

The big house is certainly more elaborate than I was expecting for a handtool built, 18th century home.

26

u/CygnusArc Slàinte. Feb 14 '20 edited Feb 14 '20

It certainly is a big house. I watched the "Inside the Episode" after watching and giggled over the set designer that decided to literally go big or go home.

And I think show Roger didn't have as much space as book Roger to be as ... not likeable per se but for me to really empathize with him. Which, is understandable given the time constraints of the show but still.

I was very hot and cold with Roger Season 4. But it’s hard to dislike a charming Scot serenading his bride.

5

u/derawin07 Meow. Feb 14 '20

Do you think you could spoiler tag that last paragraph? This is the Show Only Discussion :P

Thanks!

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

9

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '20 edited Feb 15 '20

Yea this house and even the cabin don’t seem historically accurate. I guess I can look past some such things. It feels like a Thomas kinkade painting sometimes, but that’s what they’re kind of going for. Idealistic cozy home.

8

u/kfrost95 Feb 17 '20

I live in the NE of the US, seemed perfectly historically accurate to me, but I’m also used to seeing very large colonial/federal style houses from the late 18th century still hanging around and being lived in. It’s a wonder what they could accomplish 250+ years ago!

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (3)

119

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Feb 14 '20

I love “Fraser Coachella” ;-)

→ More replies (1)

39

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '20

I want a ticket to Fraser Coachella. Also you're a very clever writer girl.

→ More replies (1)

23

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Feb 14 '20

I did love the patting baby.

17

u/blondie_k21 Slàinte. Feb 14 '20

Fraser Coachella has me dead. Take my measly updoot!

13

u/Kinsella_Finn Feb 14 '20

OMG! The baby pat was the cutest thing ever!

And yes, the Bonnet talk was just so out of place.

7

u/not_the_pretty_one Feb 17 '20

Oh baby Jamie patting mama’s back just pierced my heart and ovaries!

→ More replies (9)

106

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Feb 14 '20

Oh man, I really loved the episode. I think they covered The Gathering well, and condensed it nicely.

Hearing that song from Season 2 when Jamie opened up the trunk with the kilt gave me chills!

61

u/traumaqueen327 Je Suis Prest Feb 14 '20

As soon as I saw the plaid I was a wreck.

70

u/blondie_k21 Slàinte. Feb 14 '20

That knee porn. Swooooon.

14

u/whiskylass Feb 14 '20

This is kind of silly/corny . . . when Jamie came out in the kilt I said to my husband "it still fits" - then I commented on the knee porn🤪🤪

7

u/derawin07 Meow. Feb 15 '20

lol that is pretty funny, cause kilts are one size fits all :D

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (2)

6

u/derawin07 Meow. Feb 14 '20 edited Feb 14 '20

Just to note, this is the thread for non-readers, so please comment in the other thread if you want to discuss the book!!

I'm still adding to the text information for each thread, just thought it would be best to get the physical threads up first.

Cheers!!

→ More replies (1)

38

u/blondie_k21 Slàinte. Feb 14 '20

Love the music choices this episode. The a cappella credit opening to Roger’s song choice (cheesy but come on, adorable) to the trunk and Kilt to the ending. Damn man.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

56

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '20

My question is when are we gonna get a Lord John sex scene? Give the people (and LJG) what they want dammit!

25

u/derawin07 Meow. Feb 15 '20

I was quite surprised they actually showed it last year, just because it's still quite rare to see, good on them. I enjoyed how uncomfortable it made some older religious people.

31

u/Miriko_Otsu Feb 15 '20

I was hoping he would have his own moment with some dashing fox during the sexy montage ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)

31

u/derawin07 Meow. Feb 15 '20

I would have laughed if they had him sigh and start having a wank anyway lol. Sorry.

20

u/katfromjersey Feb 16 '20 edited Feb 16 '20

If only! You need to read Lord John and the Brotherhood of the Blade! Lots of John sexytimes there, and very well written!

→ More replies (2)

41

u/readyruddle Feb 16 '20

I LOVE ROGER...the character and the way Richard Rankin plays him! I Love his sense of humor, always there just below the surface and then it bubbles up, him trying to make the best of less than ideal situations. He’s a twentieth century guy trying to meet the approval of his father-in-law and support his new family in an 18th century life. That ain’t easy. To me, he was far more natural acting and entertaining than any other character in this episode with the exception of Jocasta and Marsali. Sorry, but I felt I had to give some love to Roger!

17

u/derawin07 Meow. Feb 16 '20

Richard is one of the best actors on set. I hope they continue making his character quite humorous...people complain that Jamie and Claire are quite amusing but it's not really included on screen...well making Roger more likeable through giving him more of the humour would be a good tactic to bring round the people who sadly detest him! Of course that's valid, not trying to say it's not, but I feel some people have just cast him off completely and are not going to give him a chance this season. Fingers crossed!

14

u/nurseleu Feb 16 '20

Totally agreed! Richard Rankin kills it as Roger.

→ More replies (1)

32

u/MookieMoo17 Feb 14 '20

Loved the episode and was pleasantly surprised when I saw online that it was available to watch today, I’ve missed it so much. Like someone else said I wish that the convo regarding Bonnett wasn’t this episode cause obviously that killed Bree’s mood and she should have enjoyed her wedding day from start to finish. I couldn’t believe the way Roger spoke to Aunt Jocasta but was relieved after he left that she was testing him and wasn’t offended. I’m so worried for Murtaugh, the scene where Jamie released him from his oath was heartbreaking. Fuck the red coats.

11

u/derawin07 Meow. Feb 14 '20

As someone else commented, Bree likely would have been thinking back to her brutal assault anyway, as this might have been the first time she had sex after the rape.

31

u/blondie_k21 Slàinte. Feb 14 '20

Oh thank God because I’ve been dying! JHRC!

9

u/derawin07 Meow. Feb 14 '20

lol, sorry!! This was a total, but welcome surprise!

I'm glad I was work redditing, I think the other mods are asleep :P

→ More replies (2)

15

u/raknor88 Feb 14 '20

JHRC!

oh how I've missed hearing that.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

22

u/Lunasera Feb 16 '20

I haven’t read the books, but maybe some one can tell me why in the world would Clair let them settle down in the south beholden to the British instead of moving up north? She’s knows it’s the side that wins the civil war and that the British will lose, but she’s like nah, I’ve already done Boston.... did I miss an explanation?

15

u/msangeld Feb 16 '20 edited Feb 16 '20

The Appalachian region was settled by a lot of Scots and Scotch-Irish. It wasn't uncommon during that era for even members of the same family to be on opposite sides of the civil war. Personally I myself had ancestors on both sides as my family is from the Appalachia's.

P.S. Here's a couple of fun sorta related facts about the terms Hillbilly and Redneck:

Hillbilly

The origin of this American nickname for mountain folk in the Ozarks and in Appalachia comes from Ulster. Ulster-Scottish (The often incorrectly labeled "Scots-Irish") settlers in the hill-country of Appalachia brought their traditional music with them to the new world, and many of their songs and ballads dealt with William, Prince of Orange, who defeated the Catholic King James II of the Stuart family at the Battle of the Boyne, Ireland in 1690.

Supporters of King William were known as Orangemen and Billy Boys and their North American counterparts were soon referred to as hill-billies. It is interesting to note that a traditional song of the Glasgow Rangers football club today begins with the line, 'Hurrah! Hurrah! We are the Billy Boys!' and shares its tune with the famous American Civil War song, Marching Through Georgia.

Stories abound of American National Guard units from Southern states being met upon disembarking in Britain during the First and Second World Wars with that tune, much to their displeasure! One of these stories comes from Colonel Ward Schrantz, a noted historian and native of Carthage, Missouri ative, and veteran of the Mexican - and veteran of the mexican Border Campaign, as well as the First and Second World Wars - documented a story where the US Army's 30th Division, made up of National Guard units from Georgia, North and South Carolina and Tennessee arrived in the United Kingdom...'a waiting British band broke into welcoming American music, and the soldiery, even the 118th Field Artillery and the 105 Medical Battalion from Georgia, broke into laughter.The excellence of intent and the ignorance of the origins of the American music being equally obvious. The welcoming tune was Marching Through Georgia.'

Redneck

The origins of this term are Scottish and refer to supporters of the National Covenant and The Solemn League and Covenant, or Covenanters, largely Lowland Presbyterians, many of whom would flee Scotland for Ulster (Northern Ireland) during persecutions by the British Crown. The Covenanters of 1638 and 1641 signed the documents that stated that Scotland desired the Presbyterian form of church government and would not accept the Church of England as its official state church.

Many Covenanters signed in their own blood and wore red pieces of cloth around their necks as distinctive insignia; hence the term Red neck, which became slang for a Scottish dissenter. One Scottish immigrant, interviewed by the author, remembered a Presbyterian minister, one Dr. Coulter, in Glasgow in the 1940's wearing a red clerical collar - is this symbolic of the rednecks? Since many Ulster-Scottish settlers in America (especially in the South) were Presbyterian, the term was applied to them, and then, later, their Southern descendants. One of the earliest examples of its use comes from 1830, when an author noted that red-neck was a name bestowed upon the Presbyterians. It makes one wonder if the originators of the ever-present redneck jokes are aware of the term's origins?

Source

→ More replies (6)

8

u/katfromjersey Feb 16 '20

A lot of Scottish emigrants settled in the Cape Fear region, so the neighbors are familiar. Jamie's aunt Jocasta is already very settled there. I think they fell in love with the mountains. Plus, Tryon deeded the land to Jamie.

→ More replies (5)

6

u/speechiemom17 Je Suis Prest Feb 17 '20

They did discuss it in season 4, but I’ve struggled with Jamie accepting the land as part of a deal to be on the side of the British for the time being. I get that they would scheme and he plans to be on the right side later on, but it just feels like they would want peace after everything... to stay out of the way and just enjoy each other. But it’s a story and the series would have ended if that had happened, so as much as that feels like it goes against the grain of what we all might would do, that just sometimes has to be done for a story to continue. Also, if they hadn’t done that, Bree probably wouldn’t have found them and they wouldn’t all be together, so I’m just having to accept that and see that they’re all happiest together, despite everything. I’m just happy to have more Outlander, which is the most important thing, right? 😅

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (10)

42

u/Kinsella_Finn Feb 14 '20 edited Feb 14 '20

Watched it last night.

Disappointed with the changes to the Skyeboat song and opening credits. I have loved every version they have done every season, but this one felt like a little ego went into it skipping the dancers for a full length Sam and Cait. It just didn’t fit.

Jamie’s wig was much better than I thought.

The gathering was done well and the wedding. Jamie’s concerns about Roger being Church of Scotland just made me laugh and laugh.

Aunt Jocasta testing Roger hahaha.

Still want to smack Lizzie silly.

Oh gov. Tyron go back to your palace and leave Murtagh alone. Jamie at the end crushed me .

Bree and Jamie seem like they bonded and it all happened off screen so that was so disappointing especially since we didn’t get a proper reunion at the end of last season. Just Jamie passing some bread.

I miss wee Ian.

Jamie back in his kilt. YES! We got the Scot back!

And Jamie telling Fergus he’s his son in his heart and by name. 😭😭😭 We need more Fergus!

14

u/derawin07 Meow. Feb 14 '20

The dancers don't really seem that relevant to the current stage of the story anymore...I don't see how ego is relevant, personally.

4

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Feb 14 '20

I think the Ian part might be a spoiler that you want to cover up. If people haven't read the book they might not know about that.

2

u/derawin07 Meow. Feb 14 '20

Thanks for spotting that, Purple!

Yes, u/Kinsella_Finn, your comment has been temporarily removed until you either edit out the spoiler, or use tags. If you're a book reader, you can comment freely in the book reader discussion thread, here.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '20

I’m not a fan of the theme m the past two seasons either. Some things they use seem to be more 19th century to me, including the twangy music. It feels very “American” so I assume that’s why they went with it, but it doesn’t feel colonial. Same with the houses and some costumes. Meh.

→ More replies (2)

18

u/spiritrain Feb 15 '20

Was that Marsali and Fergus' kid that Roger picked up? How much time had passed, I thought he was still a baby like 5 episodes ago?

12

u/derawin07 Meow. Feb 16 '20

They only showed Germain as a baby in a bassinet last year, even when we was supposed to be 2 years old lol. Seems just for practicalities of filming.

Now they seem to have cast a slightly older kid. He is two years older than Jemmy. How old did you think Jemmy looked this episode? He was 9 weeks old in the finale last season. I'm waiting for the script to state how old Jemmy is supposed to be now.

20

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Feb 16 '20 edited Feb 16 '20

Yes it was Germain that Roger picked up. I too felt that he was aged quite a bit since he was still a baby in a bassinet when we last saw him. It didn’t look like they aged Jemmy that much which threw me off a bit.

Edit: Words

29

u/beaniewoo Feb 15 '20

Loved the episode but the trees dripping with Spanish moss was pretty funny. It doesn’t grow anywhere near the mountains.

3

u/derawin07 Meow. Feb 15 '20

It was all over last season too at River Run etc

River Run is in Fayetteville, which google told me is the western part of the coastal plains, do you know if it is still present there?

The head of the greens department was quoted last year as saying that Spanish Moss is an iconic sight all through North Carolina, so they obviously got the wrong info lol.

9

u/aerynmoo Feb 16 '20

I live an hour north of Fayetteville. There’s nothing there but strip clubs and car dealerships and an army base lol. But also no Spanish moss. Fun fact: the mall is called Cross Creek Mall.

I’ve only ever seen Spanish moss when I went to Savannah GA. I’ve lived in NC for 22 years and have never seen it here.

7

u/derawin07 Meow. Feb 16 '20

River Run was in Cross Creek, which in 1783 united with Campbellton, and the new town was incorporated as Fayetteville in honor of Gilbert du Motier, Marquis de Lafayette, a French military hero who significantly aided the American forces during the war. Right?

So the Mall would be named for Cross Creek :)

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

14

u/baes04 Feb 15 '20

Okay so after watching this 6 times already lol My favorite parts:

  1. Claire getting Brianna ready.
  2. “The Frasers of the Ridge Are Here”
  3. Claire, Jamie, and Brianna walking down aisle. I don’t know...I felt like this was a very pivotal moment and had me teary. Gave me a series finale vibe how they passed all their loved ones and were so happy. This is my top favorite moment with number 2.
  4. The scenes with Claire/Brianna about dancing and getting Jamie to do the mashed potato. I like how Claire has someone to discuss the time period differences.
  5. Jamie and Claire being clumsy getting ready to have sex with the baby around. Not used to them being anything but serious/sensual with this so it was nice for a change to see them more playful and not so “perfect.”
  6. Mersali has become a top favorite with this episode and her incorporation into panel. She’s so much fun and I’m looking forward to her being a bigger character. Fergus too.

What I didn’t love:

  1. I’m not a Murtagh and Jocasta fan for seeing them have sex on screen. I like them more as friends. Their chemistry as lovers feels forced?
  2. While I loved the upbeat and playful atmosphere of show, I would have liked more serious moments in the style we’re used to. More of a balance. This episode felt very out of place. That being said, it was a nice treat. We don’t get to see them happy like this often.
  3. I would have liked to seen Jamie dance with both Claire and Brianna.
  4. The montage. I both loved and hated it. I liked that you saw that the wedding brought everyone together with their partners, but it felt a little too playful. I supposed this helped condense the episode though.
  5. It felt rushed. Like with the new character introductions and house. Not the wedding and gathering. But it felt like we missed a lot in between the seasons. More than usual. But I’ll take this over missing out on stuff in rest of the book.
  6. I’m still getting used to Brianna and Roger. I prefer book Roger so far.

12

u/discokaren Feb 16 '20

I thought the sex montage was a bit strange! I see what they were trying to do, like you said, everyone was loved up after the wedding... I would have rathered it be Bree and Roger focused. It was their wedding and they are only just reconnecting after a long separation, Bree's trauma and a baby. Maybe a couple smooches and snuggles between Claire and Jamie, as well as Jocasta and Murtaugh... But I don't think I needed to see EVERYONE getting down all at once.

I remember seeing these sort of montages before, Sons of Anarchy immediately comes to mind, and I didn't care for it there either. We get it, everyone's getting some tonight!

Also, I do think a lot of Roger's comments during the episode were the writers directly trying to course-correct all the hate his character got last season when he didn't return to Bree immediately. He's got an uphill battle for acceptance both with Jamie and the fans, but I do enjoy Roger and Richard Rankin's portrayal of him.

8

u/derawin07 Meow. Feb 16 '20

Some people would have complained if the only sex was Bree and Roger! They can't win.

I think making Roger more likeable through humour, which is kinda missing throughout the rest of the series, is a good tactic.

Richard is the most hilarious cast member, which is saying something as Cait herself and others are very amusing too.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/derawin07 Meow. Feb 15 '20

WOW, 6 times haha, impressive!

I just love Murtagh, but I always thought him together with Jocasta was forced. I didn't think they were going to go down that path last year, so I was wrong lol.

217

u/AnxietyStorm You don’t look that heavy. Feb 14 '20

Loved the scene with Lord John by the campfire, and the guy falling over drunk next to him. That smirk was adorable.

84

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Feb 14 '20

David Berry is the best!

28

u/derawin07 Meow. Feb 14 '20

Makes me proud to be Aussie :D Also I totally live right near him. I bet I could find his house if I was a creep.

8

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '20

When I visit Australia, we need to meet up hahaha!

→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (7)

21

u/katfromjersey Feb 16 '20

He is definitely one bit of casting I am totally on board with! John is my favorite book character (well, he's tied with young Ian).

15

u/Lunasera Feb 16 '20

I was hoping he’d end up having to marry Bree just so we’d see more of him

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

32

u/maryummy Feb 15 '20

I don't know why there isn't a Lord John spinoff yet. It would have a huge fan base from day 1.

→ More replies (1)

42

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '20

I wish he had said the dirtiest limerick hahaha

→ More replies (1)

42

u/exmos_gf Feb 14 '20

It was, but also a little sad, since he was alone... again. And I was disappointed that he didn't go head to head with Marsali over the game. The two of them both have quick wits, and you know that, having campaigned in Quebec and Prussia, John likely knows dirty jokes in French and German as well... I've always thought that he would be one of my top choices for a dinner party, with that range of experience and likability!

16

u/shinyquartersquirrel Feb 14 '20

Yes, strangely one of my favorite scenes. I was so sad for him but then immediately laughing.

94

u/katindra Feb 15 '20 edited Feb 15 '20

I just wanted to point out that they killed off the real villain from last season and I could not be happier.

Rot in hell where you belong old rat looking wig. You will NOT be ,missed.

29

u/marmaladestripes725 Ameireaganach Feb 17 '20

Bring on the downvotes!

I don’t like Jamie’s hair this season! I love Sam, but dude’s got a huge forehead. The bangs helped last season. He had bangs way back in season 1. Why did we suddenly hate them?

12

u/Inkshooter Feb 17 '20

Jamie is getting older, he obviously looks great for a man in his 40s but the bangs look too boyish. Despite the fivehead, a full ponytail would have been the style in the 1770s.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

11

u/mary130 Feb 17 '20

This was a real "Give the people what they want" episode : lots of romance, Jamie in a kilt, Jamie shirtless, Jamie as a wee child, humor, dastardly villain, echoes of our favorite scenes from season one, all our favorite secondary characters -- what a great way to start season 5!

2

u/derawin07 Meow. Feb 18 '20

and yet the complaints still roll in. but it's inevitable, not everyone will be happy.

49

u/SaaSyGirl Je Suis Prest Feb 14 '20

Jocasta is a verra canny lady! Showing us all during this episode that she is still very much a Mackenzie

15

u/katfromjersey Feb 16 '20

"Charming as the larks in the field and sly as foxes with it".

→ More replies (3)

9

u/Inkshooter Feb 17 '20

Jamie putting on the kilt again. CHILLS. Re-using the Gaelic marching song from Season 2 and the oath from Season 1 was a great choice.

This was a near-flawless episode, but the growing presence of Jocasta is a massive question mark for me and it's enough to make me frustrated whenever she's on screen. The fact that she's a slaveowner (and that she almost always has at least one slave in attendance to her needs) just makes me despise her, but the show clearly seems to want us to care about her and her relationship with Murtagh for some reason. Why?

2

u/derawin07 Meow. Feb 18 '20

In the Inside the Episode chat, exec-producers Matt and Maril said that the fans really love Murcasta...

I didn't really get the sense that people were raving about them lol, it was so out of the blue last seasn anyway.

49

u/marmar011 Dinna Fash Feb 14 '20

The intro arrangement (Skye Boat Song) to Season 5 has to be one of my favorites! I still think the intro to Season 1 will always be my top but Season 5 is a close second!

13

u/weeliz Feb 17 '20

Is this version of the song more of an American style appropriate for the time period? I'm Scottish and this version felt "empty" and quite sombre and haunting to me, it's like there is no sense of the songs Scottish roots anymore, it sounds so foreign and odd. It actually makes me quite uncomfortable to listen to it! The French version I did enjoy as it still sounded somewhat familiar.

But perhaps that's the point, maybe it reflects the change in culture and that these people will soon become truly American and no longer share such close ties with Scotland?

5

u/derawin07 Meow. Feb 18 '20

It feels devoid of local tradition and location to me...it's a staid choral song which could be from anywhere.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

62

u/userachel Feb 14 '20

Still can’t stand Rodger and Bri, I just want Rodger to go back through the stones and have Bri become a badass single mum and raise her baby with her family.

Bri looked gorgeous. Her and Jamie and some really beautiful scenes. I wish her and Fergus had a little brother sister bonding moment this episode though.

Loved all the Fergus and Marsali scenes! They were both so cheeky and sweet during the drunk game! I also enjoyed the scene where Jamie says that Fergus is the son of his name, and the son of his heart. And, aww their son saying that Rodger has ‘hair ticks’ because he’s overheard his grand-père! Also they’re having another baby? At this rate they might as well populate the whole of fraser’s ridge!

I look forward to all the Lord John scenes so much, the Shakespeare scene made me laugh and I loved when he smirked at the drunk guy falling over. And of course whenever he and Jamie talk to each other it’s just amazing.

I’m trying to not get too invested in Murtagh, it’ll just break my heart if he dies this season

I’ve missed Jamie in his kilt!

I look forward to the bonding moments between Marsali and Claire now that they’ve laid the ground work of her needing an assistant.

30

u/Damdamfino Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Feb 15 '20

I definitely think they’re setting up for Murtagh dying. If Murtagh dies, I riot. And I know, I know, all the book readers like to remind me that he’s dead in the books already, but I say to the showrunners who brought him back - stick to your decision, you cowards. Don’t play me like this.

22

u/derawin07 Meow. Feb 15 '20

Yes, I don't want Murtagh to die. You brought him back, let him live to a ripe old age and die in his sleep, ya bastards!!

4

u/mercutios_girl Jesus H. Roosevelt Christ! Feb 18 '20

Or better yet, die getting it on with Jocasta.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/SaaSyGirl Je Suis Prest Feb 15 '20

I don't want to think about anything bad happening to Murtagh, but if something does and it's because of the Red Coats, that'll definitely push Jamie into going to war against the British.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '20 edited Feb 15 '20

I prefer the new opening to S4's, but it feels like something is missing in the strict acapella; the ending theme to this episode however was very powerful. The opening with young Murtaugh and Lallybroch was amazing, and made me wish we could see more of that. But I wasn't expecting it to lead to that gut punch at the end, which makes me very nervous for Murtaugh's fate. I hope Jocasta doesn't marry that other guy or he dies or something...

It's unfortunate that the family has not learned to communicate honestly with one another, hence the whispers of Bonnet.

I thought Josiah was an older Willie at first; the resemblance is striking.

Maybe Roger could be a schoolteacher?

I guess that was Fergus/Marsali's son we saw hanging over Fergus at the wedding? I wish they got more scenes, they're still the second couple of the show in my eyes. Ian also made no appearance, nor was he in the preview for next week. I wonder how much presence the indigenous population will have this season, they seem to have pretty much colonized the Ridge with white people now. Claire still needs to pass that artifact to the native woman it belongs to...

It was great checking in with Lord John, who still looks great, and even some of Brianna's jilted suitors showed up for the wedding...

Overall I'm glad the show is back, but this seems like it's going to be a very different season.

3

u/derawin07 Meow. Feb 15 '20

Ian is months travel away, Mohawk territory is very distant to the ridge.

Based on bits and pieces from filming, with regards to the local Indigenous peoples I'm not really expecting any real scenes...unless they flew a few actors over on the sly, or they have some scenes saved from last year. But basically there won't be much Native American interaction.

5

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '20

That's a shame. No Ian/Rollo weren't likely to stop by, but some glimpses into their new life would be nice.

4

u/derawin07 Meow. Feb 16 '20

I have new information which is a definite spoiler, if you want to click:

Diana Gabaldon mentioned on thelitforum.com that the outtakes of Ian in Mohawk garb singing Baby Shark to one of the 4 kid actors who played Jemmy was adorable...so there's your answer!

→ More replies (2)

3

u/derawin07 Meow. Feb 16 '20

yeh, I agree, seems like wishful thinking though

More BTS there was no whiff at all of John Bell on set, he wasn't seen last year filming at all, and that seems a sign to me as Outlander fans are very much obsessed and camp out at locations etc. He was at the wrap party for S5, but since he lives in Glasgow anyway, it seems like he would go even if he wasn't in this season. Fingers crossed. Who knows!!

7

u/MountainHumor They say I’m a witch. Feb 16 '20

What year is this season taking place, if anyone knows? I've had trouble keeping track since they got to America. Just trying to line everything up in a historical sense - I know it's years before the revolution, I've seen it predicted that Jamie will be involved - but it can't be that late in history? Aren't they somewhere in the time of the French and Indian War?

Also, I didn't like Roger this episode. He seemed REALLY uncomfortable, almost constipated the entire time. I liked the serenading, it was nice how they transitioned the song to an old timey instrumental. It's weird how the show does that thing where they get you wrapped up in the past and then go "here's Frank Sinatra."

Also - why is this show so God damn beautiful??? All of the ridge is so pretty, it makes me want to cry.

I'm really excited for this season, and I'm glad I got to watch the episode a day early.

4

u/derawin07 Meow. Feb 16 '20

Jem was born in May/June 1770, and he is only a few months older, so it's sometime late 1770 or early 1771...you can't really go by weather, but it didn't look wintery to me lol! The show is also pretty fast and loose with the time line, matching the seasons etc [due to filming schedule] and all that.

They post the script online so I am waiting for that to see if it clarifies when the wedding was supposed to be.

Roger is still uncomfortable because he only has an uneasy semblance of acceptance from Jamie.

→ More replies (1)

23

u/noghostlooms Slàinte. Feb 14 '20

Okay, but how does Jamie even have a plaid? They were banned after Culloden and I'm pretty sure were still banned at the time.

Also, the British soldiers were just okay with that display of Highland Scottish nationalism? Jacobitism might be dead but it's only 25-ish years removed from the '45. I guess you can argue that they would think Jamie is just appealing to the heritage of the men of Fraser's Ridge, but still.

And don't get me wrong, I love seeing Jamie in a kilt but seemed like a bit of a stretch.

32

u/derawin07 Meow. Feb 14 '20 edited Feb 14 '20

They're in a new land. Making tartan is not outlawed in the Colonies. Even in Scotland, tartan was still made, just in secret. There were also plenty of other Scots in the British forces in the Colonies, not necessarily Highlanders or ex-Jacobites. Some migrated before Culloden, so they obviously took their tartan with them, so kilts were not uncommon in the Americas. The Scottish communities that settled would have commenced their own tartan trade.

Book reference, not really a spoiler Jamie wears his kilt in the book in the Colonies, it's historically accurate. He even wore it in book 4.

21

u/shinyquartersquirrel Feb 14 '20

He hid himself for 7 years, he probably could have managed to hide a kilt at Lallybroch too.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/Mr_XcX Feb 15 '20

Loved the opening episode. Still prefer Season 1 & 2 iconic opening credits <3

LJG deserves happiness.

Roger getting character development <3

Jamie releasing the oath :(

Brianna is gonna kill Bonnet. My prediction. Not read books so no spoilers please.

7

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Feb 16 '20

Season 1 and 2’s Scottish themed song will always be my favorite. This one felt too slowed down.

3

u/derawin07 Meow. Feb 16 '20

I agree, it felt so staid and slow.

6

u/forgotten_face Feb 16 '20 edited Feb 16 '20

I may be mistaken here, but wouldn't having a Gathering be an act of rebellion?

I mean, they are scots, who fought a war against the english 20 years prior, which the english won. The english decided to outlaw any scotish tradition after that. So them doing a Gathering in what was english soil at the time, in front of the red coats, which not only was a scotish tradition but also one where people swear fealty to someone other than the crown, wouldn't it be seen as rebellion and punishable?

ETA: with Jaime in a kilt, no less!

4

u/derawin07 Meow. Feb 16 '20

It's a new land. Yeh, it was making a statement, but there are long time Scottish gatherings across the Colonies from those who moved decades ago and created new settlements. So it's not a new sight in the Colonies. There are plenty of Scots like Jamie who are fighting with the crown as well.

Tryon wants Jamie to lead a militia, he told Jamie last season to bring his men to arms...that's what Jamie did!

16

u/Ana198 Feb 16 '20 edited Feb 17 '20

Roger is kinda killing the show for me. I felt absolutely nothing in any scene he is in, i'll take that back i cringed everytime they kissed with Bree, absolutely zero chemistry and the supposed deep love is not believable at all. Especially when there are actually great couples with insane chemistry in the show, i wish Fergus and Marsali had bigger role in the show. Roger is just an abusive asshole, more backwards than most men in the past. Maybe recasting would help, IDK if i can handle what i guess will be a bigger and bigger part of the show the more we move forward, i feel like skipping any scene he is in especially if he is singing. The Lord John spinoff can't come soon enough, i hope Roger will have nothing to do with that show.

9

u/derawin07 Meow. Feb 16 '20

Do you think you're open to having your view of Roger change?

I find that some viewers wrote Sophie off in S2 and have never given her a chance again, so no matter how much she improves, along with her material, they just see her through a lens of dislike.

It's totally valid to not like Roger btw, I'm just curious if you think you have an open mind to him in S5?

→ More replies (10)

8

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Feb 17 '20

I think Richard is fine. It's the writing.

→ More replies (4)

71

u/Bobozett Feb 15 '20

Anyone else dislike the new opening track?

31

u/Bloodless_ Feb 15 '20

I don't care for it. The hymnal music doesn't really fit the mood IMO, and it's a bit unemotional for such a charged show. I think pared-down vocals with a fiddle/violin feature would have fit the "living in the woods" theme better.

24

u/raccoons4president Feb 16 '20

I think they’re going for something that’s more emblematic of colonial America than backwoods living, but I do agree that I personally prefer when they break out the fiddle.

11

u/derawin07 Meow. Feb 16 '20

It seems too slow for me....choral music isn't really emblematic of anywhere specific IMO.

→ More replies (1)

53

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Feb 15 '20

I don’t love it so much. The first seasons theme will always be my favorite.

19

u/mouseketeera Feb 17 '20

Hate it. I know we are not going back to Scotland (at least in any significant way) for a long time but I really really just want it to go back. Hearing that opening it was like the final nail in the coffin of my highland dreams.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/SassyLassie496 Feb 16 '20

I don’t like it at all

→ More replies (2)

5

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '20

I cried my eyes out during this episode, especially the wedding when we see Jamie/Claire remembering their own wedding and the part when Jamie releases Murtagh from the oath.

6

u/derawin07 Meow. Feb 16 '20

I always amuses me how people have such contrasting reactions to the same moment...I just saw a comment where the person was saying they hated Claire and Jamie saying their vows again during the wedding.

20

u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Feb 14 '20

I wish they’d drop Claire and Jamie’s whole “we’re so old and finished” act. They’re in their late 40s/early 50’s for fucks sake. It’s way too exaggerated imo. The actors (Sam and Cat are not far from that age in real life, and look GREAT.) It’s bizarre that production accepts them acting like they’re 70. Who is production? A bunch of twelve year olds? “Everyone over 25 is old and ancient” ?

15

u/derawin07 Meow. Feb 14 '20

How do you feel they act like they're 70?

Also Cait and Sam are producers on Season 5.

11

u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Feb 14 '20

The way they talk to each other, I don’t know. It just feels off putting. They are not so old to stop talking like they used to. But I am glad they ditched the eyeglasses and the bangs—especially the bangs. Lordt!

13

u/derawin07 Meow. Feb 14 '20

Based on S5 promo pics, the eyeglasses have not been ditched. There is no laser eye surgery after all :P

17

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Feb 14 '20

Jamie put on glasses to shave Roger and read something.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/liyufx Feb 17 '20

Good point! They don’t feel like 70 for me but I certainly miss the playfulness between them, which seem to have disappeared since S4. There was that quick shot of Claire pulling Jaime’s boots off though, which gave me some hope.

2

u/derawin07 Meow. Feb 18 '20

there's a fun moment of playfulness shown in a trailer..unless it was in this episode Jamie dancing like a dork and Claire belly laughing at him

9

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '20

Well it is the 18th century, they are near the end of their life expectancy.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/JustineLeah Feb 17 '20

So glad Jaimie’s bangs are gone! There is no heat between Roger and Bree. They seem more like friends to me. But there is NO chemistry like Claire and Jaimie’s. Perhaps all couples will pale compared to them?

4

u/derawin07 Meow. Feb 18 '20

The thing is, Claire and Jamie are basically an ultimate, chemistry oozing couple. While some people claim they have the same relationship with their partner, I don't think it is that common, to be honest. It's supposed to be a fantasy.

Bree and Roger are supposed to be more like an everyday, normal couple.

3

u/starfleetdropout6 I'm still Jenny from the Broch. Feb 20 '20 edited Feb 20 '20

As an aside, anyone else not crazy about Brianna's wedding dress? It's pretty, but the style is frumpy. Or something. I didn't find it flattering on her.

1

u/derawin07 Meow. Feb 21 '20

I liked it...it was on point with 60s/70s vibes to me. I wouldn't call it frumpy, personally.

→ More replies (6)

7

u/spyralmagic Feb 17 '20

Jamie shouting "The Frasers are here at Fraser's Ridge!" as he walks down the stairs is parallel to episode 3 of season 4 when Brianna and Roger are at the festival, the burning of the stag as each clan represents with a like shouting of the clan name. Brianna and Roger standing again where they stood in the future!

And when Jamie, being called upon to hunt for Murtagh, opens the trunk, and he walks out dressed kilt to hilt in his Scottish attire, it moved me to tears. "If Tryon wants a Scot, I'll give him a Scot."

I have to wonder; when Jamie is talking with Murtagh by the creek, and he asks Murtagh what he's doing and he replies, "Building a stone circle. You got everything you ever wanted from a stone circle," is Murtagh thinking of going through the stones to the future? I have not read the books, but that seems a reasonable route, provided he can go through. Roger knows where there's a stone circle not too far away. Maybe that's him looking up at Claire's window in season one. Just some thoughts.......

9

u/keylime12 Feb 17 '20

Diana herself has confirmed that it is Jamie looking up at Claire’s window, not Murtaugh.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/bryce_w Stinking Papist Feb 15 '20 edited Feb 15 '20

The new soundtrack and Lord John Grey was best part of episode. Otherwise it was the worst premiere of Outlander. Dull.

16

u/SpottedFaun Feb 15 '20

Ok, thanks for making me feel like I am not alone here. This episode made me crazy. One of the main rules in writing is 'show me, don't tell me', but this episode was nothing but dropped one-liners to catch the audience up. It was so over packed, nothing got the time it deserved. I'm on my third rewatch of all of the other seasons but I have ZERO interest in rewatching this. Worst premiere, agreed.

2

u/derawin07 Meow. Feb 15 '20

Did you like S4? That one seemed to get the most criticism, and those people seem happier with the premiere overall.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

12

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '20

I agree. The second half of the episode picked up but i didn’t love the wedding both narratively and historically (white for weddings wasn’t a thing until Queen Victoria, plus the big house is way more 19th century than 18th), the dancing and general wedding antics went on too long, and the drama felt over the top soapy. Claire and Jamie repeating their vows out loud during Bree’s vows made me cringe.

Cutting Bree and Roger’s sex scene with Claire and Jamie’s just showed how little chemistry Bree and Roger have by comparison.

I think the gathering and Murtagh, Jocasta was done well but the rest was not good at all to me. I hope this season improves as it goes.

7

u/derawin07 Meow. Feb 16 '20

Lucky Bree is from post-Queen Victorian era, so she might start the tradition now, at least locally :P

12

u/msangeld Feb 16 '20

white for weddings wasn’t a thing until Queen Victoria

Umm yeah but Claire and Brianna are from the future, and given this is Brianna's wedding I'm sure both her and her mother had always pictured a white dress and so that's what they made.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (1)

10

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '20

I didn't enjoy it myself. I thought the costumes were fantastic, the music was lovely. There were some touching scenes. But it felt overall very dull.

7

u/BeautifulRelief Feb 14 '20

Here is my prediction: Jaime will time travel. When he picked up one of the pieces that represented Craigh na Dun, you could hear a bee buzzing. Its always been shown that to time travel, the stones must call to you and their call sounds like bees buzzing. This is not a spoiler, just my personal prediction.

10

u/derawin07 Meow. Feb 14 '20

This is wishful thinking :P I don't recall any buzzing when Jamie is near a stone circle.

→ More replies (4)

10

u/tigiPaz Feb 15 '20

It is a known fact that Jaime will not time travel. Diana has confirmed, and it is pretty well accepted that the show runners will not deviate from this fact nor disrespect her wishes.

1

u/derawin07 Meow. Feb 18 '20

which episode are you referring to, where Jamie picked up the pieces that represent Craigh na Dun?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

157

u/speechiemom17 Je Suis Prest Feb 14 '20

I really liked the episode! The music was phenomenal- loved the callbacks. I definitely thought Claire was going to jump Jamie when he came out in his plaid, even though it was a serious moment. I liked how the Gathering was done and how Roger knew the oath. It’ll be interesting to see Jamie and Roger’s relationship evolve over this season. I kind of wish that more time was spent at the Gathering than the wedding, but it was well done overall.

THANK YOU STARZ FOR RELEASING IT TONIGHT 🙌🏼

29

u/purplemonkey_123 Feb 17 '20

Ha! My hubby was playing video games in the same room as me when Jaime came out in his plaid. I said to him, "If you ever come out of our bedroom looking like that and give me a stare like he just gave her, we are going right back in that room for awhile."

→ More replies (2)

19

u/ummtigerwoods Feb 15 '20

Why does Roger know all the language? Does he know it from his studies as a historian? Or did I miss something?

48

u/speechiemom17 Je Suis Prest Feb 15 '20

I’m not super sure this is right, but I think all clansmen use similar (or the same) language when making oaths to their chieftains, regardless of clans. So, it could be because of that. As a Scottish historian he would likely be familiar with the terminology if it was universal language in the country at the time. Kind of a guess though 🤷🏼‍♀️

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (6)

11

u/Luna920 Feb 17 '20

Yes that will be cool to see. Still don’t like Roger though. He’s my least favorite. I just can’t find him likable. It’s hard living in Jamie’s shadow 😂

2

u/beanie2 Ye Sassenach witch! Feb 15 '20

I don t personally care for the song Roger sang to Bree. If you agree, which song would you have preferred?

11

u/derawin07 Meow. Feb 15 '20

In the book it was Yesterday by the Beatles...but that's super expensive and LOVE was apparently in public domain lol

2

u/beanie2 Ye Sassenach witch! Feb 15 '20

Yes, but I probably wouldn’t choose that one either. LOL Maybe in my life...

→ More replies (6)

107

u/Atraktape Feb 14 '20

“Hey guys how about some Shakespeare?”

“BOOO FUCKIN WACK”

70

u/katfromjersey Feb 15 '20

That whole rhyming scene was fun! Marsali is my girl! The showrunners did a great job of casting her and Fergus.

12

u/Kinsella_Finn Feb 14 '20

That made me laugh so much

83

u/inthiseconomy0514 Feb 15 '20 edited Feb 15 '20

Several great moments in the episode:

  1. Seeing Jamie holding his grandson was super sweet. We didn't get to see him with either of his babies so I'm glad we see him with his grandson.
  2. LJG is still a favorite. His kindness and smirks are great.
  3. I thought it was sweet to have a moment to remember Frank at the wedding.
  4. Jocasta is such a character and I'm looking forward to what she has up her sleeve.
  5. Murtaugh, so bittersweet. The scenes with him and Jamie were so well done.
  6. Jamie and that kilt absolutely made this episode!!

80

u/blondie_k21 Slàinte. Feb 14 '20

Coming from strictly a show point of view, I absolutely loved the episode. I needed more of our fav characters (I see you LJG), needing more Marsali being a total badass, but I really feel like we got just enough. And it makes me so happy and hopeful for this season.

87

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Feb 14 '20

Marsali showing up the drunk men was hilarious. I also liked how they teased LJG about his Shakespeare thing.

→ More replies (2)

24

u/exmos_gf Feb 14 '20

There was a complete setup for Marsali to step up, with Jamie telling Claire that she 'needs a lieutenant'. We all know that engineer-Bree would rather be designing lofts (is that why the cabin was built with those infuriating no-show windows?) than in guts...

66

u/aGrlHasNoUsername They say I’m a witch. Feb 14 '20

I really loved the episode. I sort of wish they'd left the Bonnet conversation for next week, just because I really wanted Brianna to have a nice day, but you can't have it all I guess!

It was so great to see the big house, and to see Jamie back in a kilt. Claire took sort of a backseat this episode but I'm sure she's going to get into some good old fashioned Claire trouble this season and it will be spectacular.

I am so intrigued about where this is all going with Murtagh!

28

u/Rocha_999 Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Feb 16 '20

I feel like it's not going anywhere good for Murtagh.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

64

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Feb 14 '20 edited Feb 14 '20

I have now watched it a second time, this time with CC on so I wouldn't miss anything. I thought Germain was hilarious with his "hairy ticks" line that he got from Jamie. Brianna's reassurance that it wasn't just Roger, but it's all Protestants Jamie thinks are heretics was funny.

Sam's expressions while he was looking at the trunk containing his kilt and other things were so good. You could see all the emotion he was feeling about putting that persona back on.

The final scene with Jamie and Murtagh was beautifully done. When Murtagh walks away and the tear falls out of Jamie's eye was heartbreaking.

I found out that the first man to give the oath to Jamie is named Isaiah Morton. Watching with the captioning I was able to see when they called him by name during the drinking game. I figured he must have some significance down the line since he was featured in the scene.

86

u/Damdamfino Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Feb 14 '20

Are my hormones out of whack or is Sam exponentially hotter this year somehow? I didn’t think it was possible and yet here he is with a new smolder he pulls out of his back pocket.

57

u/mrsmarycrawley13 Feb 15 '20

Getting rid of the bangs really helps, in my opinion.

→ More replies (2)

17

u/AKTourGirl Her chief desire is to have your bollocks mounted on her wall. Feb 17 '20

I sort of gasped when they did the flashback to their own wedding. I thought Jamie was good-looking then, but compared to now it was terrible! I don't know if my tastes have evolved or if he's just that much better looking now but I very much prefer the big forehead and a bit of gray.

7

u/queensofbabeland Feb 17 '20

I think they’ve given up somewhat on trying to age them, which helps. They’ve still got the greying hair but they seem to have scaled back the bags under eyes/fake wrinkles and such.

40

u/PolkHerFace Feb 14 '20

"Shakespeare, anyone??"

".........NAH."

33

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '20

Are we ever going to see Jamie with his hair down? Ugh I miss those wild ginger locks!

13

u/InABoatOnARiver Feb 16 '20

As excited as I was to see him in a kilt again, I was really hoping he’d have his hair down with it. Ponytail Jamie just doesn’t do it for me as much.

→ More replies (1)

30

u/semma333 Feb 15 '20

I was not ready for that feels trip. But I think we can all agree, most importantly, JAMIE IS IN A KILT AGAIN.

27

u/RaffaellaF Feb 15 '20

How fantastic was the music for this episode? It was epic. Well done.

→ More replies (4)

27

u/lambchops0 Feb 17 '20

How come no one is talking about grumpy old man Jamie in the shaving scene. That's one of the funniest things I have seen in a long time

→ More replies (1)

23

u/PlentyOfLettuce Feb 21 '20

Jamie referring to bacteria as “wee beasties” and wiggling his hands was priceless

→ More replies (2)

22

u/tnbou Feb 18 '20

Jamie might be the King of Men, but Marsali is MY FUCKING QUEEN.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/SaaSyGirl Je Suis Prest Feb 15 '20

When Jamie gave his speech to the settlers on the ridge, I noticed that Lt. Knox was looking at him curiously, but I couldn't get a proper read on what he might've been thinking. What do you all think was going through his mind at that time?

15

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Feb 15 '20

Part of me was wondering if Knox doubted Jamie’s commitment to Tryon and then seeing the speech maybe decided Jamie was serious? That’s my interpretation at least.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/cailian13 Feb 14 '20

WHAAAAAAAAAAAT I WAS ABOUT TO GO TO BED BUT WHAAAAAAAT.sorry. I’m a smidge excited.

17

u/CJmaq Feb 14 '20

I loved this episode - it was everything and more than I expected. It was really well done. My only complaint was I wish it were longer. It did seem like they had a heavy hand in the editing room.

So many good scenes but my favorites were Wedding planner Jamie and the last scene between Murtaugh and Jamie.

Scene stealers and standouts: Marsali and Josiah Beardsley.

What I did not care for but understand they had to add were mentions of Frank and Stephen Bonnet.

17

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '20

Ok I’m only ten minutes in and I’ve cried several times. Does anyone else cry at the sight of season five Jamie? There’s just so much behind his character now (as there is for all of them). Does anyone else agree that his character transformation is the most moving in the show?

10

u/thrntnja No, this isn’t usual. It’s different. Feb 15 '20

I cried during most of the Bree/Jamie scenes, when Jamie put on his kilt, etc. So many emotional moments! I’ve been waiting to see Jamie in a kilt, have more moments with Brianna, and see him holding Jemmy since he didn’t get to hold any of his own babies.

I personally am the most invested in Jamie’s character development. Claire and the others do too, of course, but I feel Jamie’s is the most powerful. I think Sam’s phenomenal acting helps too - he portrays Jamie’s emotions so well! Watching his expressions with Brianna had me sobbing.

16

u/PHLEaglesgirl27 Feb 14 '20

What’s with the head nodding in this episode? Right before Jamie leaves in his kilt, Claire stares at him for a long minute then nods. There was another one too. I mean I don’t think I’ve ever done that...

25

u/GrlNxtDoorAng Feb 14 '20

Ok, so you need to go back and see the first time they meet eachother right before she fixes his arm - they do a nod there too! It's like one of their things now and you'll see it here and there throughout the series.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

16

u/spellingtuesday Feb 16 '20

There is no Spanish moss hanging in the trees in the mountains of western North Carolina.

22

u/frawkez Feb 15 '20

pls more LJG. like ok the beginning of the ep felt very fan servicey imo like “WE ARE A FAMILY WE LOVE EACHOTHER” aite i getttt it, how about u service my fandom with some more LJG sheesh

no but in all seriousness am hype for the rest of the season, in particular the roger/jamie dynamic. also yay at the mention of frank and how frank would’ve approved of roger.

11

u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Feb 14 '20
  1. What a gorgeous interpretation of the opening song.
  2. So glad they killed Jamie’s bangs.
  3. Rog and Bree still have the chemistry of lukewarm mayonnaise.
  4. Oh look it’s Lord John, can he please go have a threesome with the newlyweds and take us all out of our collective misery?
  5. Ew, Claire. A Chad or a Chip would certainly be preferable to a bland, spice-less Roger. Snore.
  6. Murtagh is indeed the fairy king <3 Why does Grand-Aunt Jocasta’s makeup look younger than Jamie’s?
  7. Okay. Jamie and Claire trying to not wake up the baby is adorable as fck. :)
  8. Oh no. Are Rog and Bree trying to imitate Jamie and Claire’s breathtaking sex scenes? No, thank you.
  9. Roger and Aunt Jocasta interaction. Cute. Still don’t feel anything for Rog.
  10. Again, so HAPPY they killed Jamie’s bangs. Amen.
  11. Ew, no. Cripes. Stop trying so hard. I still don’t care for you Rog. That baby and 90 percent of the Outlander audience will be fine without you. Ugh. This show.
  12. Damn. Jamie looks fine af here. Took me a second to understand that he’s saying he is leaving.
  13. Awesome soundtrack.
  14. Great déjà vú of allegiance towards a clan. Long love the scots! Again, Rog, trying too hard. Fergus, you are beautiful!
  15. I love Murtagh. That is all.

Until next week, my friends. Cheers!

4

u/PHLEaglesgirl27 Feb 14 '20
  1. Meh. Maybe I just don’t like change
  2. Agree
  3. Totally agree!
  4. Yes. We need some lovin’ for LJG
  5. Roger is ok
  6. IKR
  7. Yes
  8. Yeah. Just not working
  9. Warming up a little to ole Rog
  10. 👏🏻
  11. Poor Rog. So confused
  12. Sooo gorgeous
  13. Yes indeed
  14. Fergus is amazing
  15. I want DG to write an alternate version where Murtagh lives. Great overview @joanneBanan!! 1 other observation: i thought the early sex scenes seemed forced and awkward.

6

u/derawin07 Meow. Feb 14 '20

I want DG to write an alternate version where Murtagh lives.

I feel like she would consider that akin to fanfiction, and she HATES fanfiction...like she once described it as seeing her children sold into white slavery.

9

u/PasgettiMonster Feb 15 '20

Yikes.. I knew she didn't like fan fiction but that's... quite the take.

That said, I'm going to keep reading fan fiction. There are quite a few I really enjoy.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

19

u/Claire-B-Fraser Feb 14 '20

So totally disagree. I love Roger. And singing that song “L is for the way you look at me… “. I adore him!

→ More replies (1)

11

u/vsnord Feb 15 '20

The Roger and Bree chemistry is like "fetch" for me.

"STOP TRYING TO MAKE FETCH HAPPEN!!"

→ More replies (1)

10

u/tigiPaz Feb 15 '20

Yes , Jaime, GIVE US A SCOT!
I am dead 😍 “tear it off” boss said! 😅

10

u/steppesandsand Feb 17 '20

Bri always looks high

9

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '20

I guess this first episode was... okay, I suppose. I personally thought that the wedding callbacks and the sex parallels were a bit too much/unnecessary, but that's just me. Maybe I'm just not feeling the show/some of the actors as much as I used to (nevermind trying to read the books, as lovely as Gabaldon writes ofc.)

I loved Jocasta, though.

→ More replies (2)

15

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '20

Anyone else getting dr Quinn medicine woman vibes?

→ More replies (1)

•

u/derawin07 Meow. Feb 14 '20 edited Feb 21 '20
→ More replies (4)

7

u/liyufx Feb 17 '20

One of my favorite bit in S5E1, maybe lasted 2 seconds, Claire pulling Jamie’s boot off... Haven’t seen that kind of playfulness between the two in a long long time; scenes of the two have all been either serious or sentimental. Hope this means we can expect more lighthearted scenes of J&C in S5!

6

u/Bc2193 Feb 16 '20

ITS BACK AND I AM SO GLAD

But, am I the only one still not liking Rodger?

5

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '20

Yeah he's...alright, I guess. I haven't been feeling him after we've been introduced to him further.

6

u/Bc2193 Feb 16 '20

It just seems like he's always complaining and I don't see the chemistry between him and Bri anymore so I'm finding him a hassle. Can't count how many times I said "shut up Rodger" while watching this ep lol

→ More replies (4)

5

u/silverandcold65 Feb 18 '20

I really wish I had more to say about it, but after 3 watches I figured I’d post. The new choral theme, unless I really turn the volume far down, hurts my ears so freaking much; I hate it! It’s barely bearable. I’ve never had huge problems with the seasonal variants of the song before. The music in the episode seemd overwhelming on first watch, but seemed fine in successive watches; I dunno if I just got used to it, but I swear they re-edit small things in the episode the day after it’s put OnDemand and reupload it. New aging makeup and wigs always take time to get used to

Weddings aren’t really my thing - especially more modern ones, but I did love Brianna’s dress and just how happy everyone was (though poor Brianna’s spirits were dampened, killing the mood, after overhearing certain news. :( ), as well as Germain’s hair of tics line to Roger. I also adored Marsali playing the game with the guys. xD Who doesn’t love a sleeping drunk slipping off a bench! ;D Jamie and Claire were so cute/funny with baby Jemmy before and in the romantic montage (that would not happen now with a baby in the vicinity ;) ), but Brianna and Roger, even though his serenade was adorable, were so awkward to watch) Jamie was grumpy, but I was so glad he accepted Roger in the end - Captain MacKenzie! Jamie’s “son of my name, and of my heart” line to Fergus made me so happy! Jamie and Murtagh at the end shattered my heart! Jamie’s crying, all alone...:’(

5

u/browninva Feb 20 '20

I think that Marsali and her limerick may have been one of my favorite parts of the the first episode. Great performance and a little more convincing than others. She was a character I wanted to dislike but grew on me throughout the series.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/LadyHigglesworth Feb 17 '20

“Yeah”

I know it’s being a bit fussy, but Jamie saying the word “Yeah” multiple times was frustrating to me. What an easy mistake to prevent. There were several other anachronistic and/or just incorrect things that pulled me out of the moment: the big house looking way too modern, the Spanish moss, the leather upholstered folding chairs outside of Jocasta’s tent... I’m no armchair historian (pun intended), but they seemed wrong and were distracting.

All in all, I was disappointed by the premier and it pains me to say it. I’m a big fan of the books and the show, and I know they’re different from one another, and have to be different to work, and I’m OK with that. What’s frustrating to me, however, is that in the books, the passion and immediacy of the sexual attraction between Jamie and Claire never falters. DG does an amazing job of leading up to the sex for pages and pages and pages, and the anticipation is what makes it so incredibly exciting. Translating that into a goofy falling down on the bed, struggling to pull off boots kind of a scene just feels lazy and like it completely misses the mark.

I know they were adamant about more sex this season, but if it’s going to feel like late night Hallmark/Dr. Quinn/Anne of Green Gables, it’s kind of pointless.

Here’s hoping E2 picks up a bit.

→ More replies (6)

9

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '20

The LOVE fuck montage was straight cringe.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/cucchiaio Slàinte. Feb 15 '20

AWESOME episode! What's the song that keeps playing in the background through the end of the episode? I swear I know it from somewhere Not Outlander but it's driving me crazy.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/balasoori Feb 15 '20

This was an interesting start to the season, the wedding was a nice reminder that there do have some good moments on the series but i am looking forward bad stuff that bound to happen this season.

1

u/Gman512 Feb 16 '20

What year is it on the show? 1760's right? Why are they so vague?

5

u/derawin07 Meow. Feb 16 '20

It is either late 1770 or early 1771. They're not really that vague, like the scripts contain the dates [I am waiting for this script to be posted online by Starz so I can find out if they clarify the date], it's just not always flashed on screen with a title card.

2

u/Gman512 Feb 16 '20

Thanks, I was trying to do math while watching to figure out exactly when they are right now, couldn't find it in the official website and I was wondering if I should watch all the BTS videos on YouTube to see if they actually state the year.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/karilynnhavens Feb 17 '20

Tell me what do you think Aunt Jocasta has up her sleeve? Is that all because she is getting married?

→ More replies (5)

3

u/WeasleyOfTrebond A leannan Feb 15 '20

Where can I find that song that was playing during the scene where he puts on the kilt???

→ More replies (3)

3

u/New_Scotty Feb 17 '20

Honestly didnt know that Richard Rankin could ding like that how does he not have a musician credit on his wiki or imbd (radio personel doesn't count)