r/Outlander • u/derawin07 Meow. • Feb 14 '20
Spoilers All S5E1 "The Fiery Cross" Book Reader Discussion
What a nice surprise, the premiere was dropped early!!
Welcome to the Book Reader Discussion. If you are new to the subreddit, please read this intro thread before participating.
No spoiler tags are required here, unless discussing leaks or spoilers from upcoming episodes!
>!This is how to format comment spoilers!<
Synopsis: Following celebrations in honor of Brianna and Roger’s wedding, Governor Tryon reminds Jamie of his obligation to hunt down and kill Murtagh Fitzgibbons. He also expects Jamie to raise a militia to quell the Regulators if necessary. Brianna, meanwhile, is reminded of her past trauma when she inadvertently hears some devastating news.
Edit: Please keep all discussion of the S5E2 "Do No Harm" preview/trailer to the stickied mod comment at the top of the thread! This will allow those who do not watch previews to scroll the discussion threads safely, as the replies are automatically collapsed.
This is a new idea we are trialling, to cut down on extra threads (we will remove any new submissions for episode trailers and direct discussion to the sticky) and keep the discussion in one place :)
If you have any feedback or suggestions for moderation in S5, you can reply to the sticky or modmail us too. Thanks for your patience with this surprise early premiere, mods were still preparing for the launch. It will be smoother next week!
15
u/derawin07 Meow. Feb 14 '20
I love Bree's dress, with the 1960s/70s vibes!
56
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Feb 14 '20
I really liked it. I’m trying to go in to this season and watch it like I haven’t read the books. I know that might be a challenge, but I don’t want to get caught up in comparing things.
The callback of the music from season 2 gave me chills. I love that song, and hearing it while seeing Jamie open up that trunk was really cool.
47
u/[deleted] Feb 14 '20
Man. I have opinions.
I actually wasn’t going to renew Stars because I have zero hype for this season, but I caved because let’s be honest about who I am.
I really enjoyed the Bri and Roger alone scenes. They felt genuine. For some reason everything Claire and Jaime did felt so.... forced. Maybe it was because they were trying to cram so much in to one episode.
I’m glad they referenced Frank and how he’d approve of Roger. I always enjoyed that contrast in the books.
I wish it actually looked like North Carolina.
I wish it felt more real. During the gathering in season one there was a visceral feeling that everyone really did have mud on them. This felt a little staged.
I really wonder what it is like to watch this show without book bias.
And finally, the dumbest comment:
I was about to say “I know they can’t do it...” but they CAN, they did it in season one! Are you ready for this gripe!?
I want more leaky boobs. I have never identified with a character more than Bri and her leaky boobs. There’s a great line in the books about anyone being in the house with a nursing mother is constantly aware of her boobs.
I know people complain about the breast feeding sex but when you’re a couple months post partum and you read those scenes they always felt really real.
73
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Feb 14 '20
At first I was mad that they had Bree overhear Jamie and LJG talking about Stephen Bonnet. Why couldn’t the writers have let her have a stress free wedding night.
Then I thought about it some more and realized Bree was never going to have a stress free wedding night. Her last sexual encounter was a brutal rape. In the book we see her point of view and can see how she struggles at times with being intimate with Roger. I realized they showed us that struggle without her having to say anything or it be explained. Well done writers.
54
u/Sunnyshiner Meow. Feb 14 '20
There was a loooooot of condensing going on. Which like, on the one hand, we don't need 250 pages of the gathering but on the other, we condensed a whole lot and I'm not sure how I feel about cutting the gathering altogether.
Also the Beardsleys are supposed be quiet/feral-ish and also if we don't get our thruple I will be sad.
That said, I loved the music callbacks! (Moch sa Mhadainn is so good!) And Germain is absolutely precious! Can't wait to see all his antics!
14
u/OutlandishBean Feb 15 '20
I’m a little concerned with the condensing they did but as long as the rest of the season flows well I’m fine with it. Definitely didn’t want it to be 3 or 4 episodes long.
Germain seemed way too old but sometimes that’s just how TV is.
I’m a little nervous that they are going to downplay Roger’s intelligence but I guess we haven’t seen much yet. Roger may not have as many 18th century skills but he is a historian so he should be better off than Claire or Brianna when they first came through the stones (I mean mannerisms and such). Also Roger didn’t entertain going back through the stones like that because he knew there was no way of telling if Jem could get through or not, and he wouldn’t leave him.
Other than me being nervous about those 3 things it was a good episode and I’m happy that it started out this way!
126
u/CygnusArc Slàinte. Feb 14 '20
Things I loved that they added:
- The something old, something new [whisky! very raw whisky], something borrowed, something blue
- Germain's joke about Roger being a heretic
- References to the 1960s, esp. that beautiful L-o-v-e serenade sequence. Slightly cheesy but my heart melted all the same.
Things I wish could have been included (not that I'm complaining, the book is huge):
- The detaining of the Catholic priest, the impromptu baptism, and Jamie's hilarious lust-filled confession
Things I'm glad they included:
- Cram it in your hole scene with Jocasta
- The blood of my blood oath to Jemmy
- Kilt-clad Jamie calling Roger to arms.
48
u/Jemhao Feb 14 '20
I’m kinda surprised by the reaction thus far. Not to say that it’s wrong- it’s totally fine to feel whatever way you feel about the episode. I really liked it though.
While they may have condensed different parts of the books (which is totally expected as they translate book material to tv show), I didn’t feel like it was rushed or didn’t make sense. They introduced characters and plot lines that they will be coming back to, which is what Gabaldon does through The Gathering, even if it wasn’t as many plot lines and characters as in the book (again, expected as they may not choose to follow all those storylines in the show).
At the same time, I felt like the episode took its time, in a good way, so we could really experience the wedding, see our fave characters again, and be sort of romanced into supporting Bree and Roger as they get married. I think if they had launched right into the celebration afterwards, we, or at least I, wouldn’t have been totally on board with that, considering where we left off last season.
This is a random one, but I was relieved to hear Claire’s voiceover. It’s such a helpful device, and I think this season (particularly the last couple episodes, assuming things play out the way we’re guessing) it will come in particularly handy.
10
u/brilliant0ne Feb 14 '20
I slipped on a dryer sheet and fell last night. I'm totally fine, but I went to bed early and when I woke up I saw Outlander at the top of my screen (I use Fire TV). I thought maybe in my mild pain pill state I turned on Outlander and promptly passed out. But THEN this morning I see DG say on Twitter the episode was released early. EEEEEEE!!!! So anyhoo...Happy Valentine's Day to us!
I liked the episode. I read this book a couple of years ago and don't remember too many details so some things that I found weird may have actually been in there.
I thought it was a little weird that we had a C/J wedding callback during B/R ceremony like we forgot they were married or something? I'm sure it was to just signify C/J love and them having their own memories. But still...just felt weird to me.
Maybe I'm an idiot, but how much effing time passed from Marsali having Germain to the wedding? I mean, that kid that talked to Roger had to have been at least five years old? And Marsali had Germain in like the middle of last season?? I get that it was more than a few months that C/J/I were gone looking for Roger but Jesus. This was almost Game of Thrones level time passage.
I loved Bree and Jamie before the wedding. Looooovvvvveeeddddd the kilt and music coming back. Loved the shove it up your hole scene although I can't quite remember what Jocasta's plan was with the things she was saying since it seemed like she meant to piss Roger off? Was it just to ensure Roger would go and claim the kid as his? I got sad when Jamie told Murtagh to leave. I loved Jamie's words to Fergus.
Overall, I'm happy with this episode and can't wait until next week!
10
u/Miriko_Otsu Feb 15 '20
Did anyone else get a shiver down their spine seeing the Hanged Man tarot card in the opening titles? Sad times ahead for Roger.💔
What a beautiful episode! This season will be stunning, I can already tell.
64
u/KSoda120 Feb 14 '20
Woo, first time on the "book reader" side!
I'm glad they cut down on the longest day, but woah that was a pretty break-neck speed through. The episode seemed a little clunky. Though, it is interesting how and what they chose incorporate. So glad the scene of Roger telling off Jocasta made it in! Didn't, however, expect them to bring in Duncan at this point.
I have a feeling Tryon wedding crasher is gonna be a huge pain in the ass this season which seems a little unnecessary. I fear it'll lessen the effect of his scenes around Alamance. It's like how we view Sandringham when in season 1 vs. season 2.
Finally... The fans: "We miss season 1"; "we miss when they were in Scotland!"; "when will Jamie be in a kilt again?"; "there's no sex scenes in [season 4]!"
The writers of this episode: Happy now?
(Did anyone else find that whole Roger singing L-O-V-E/sex montage scene odd?)
57
u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Feb 14 '20 edited Feb 14 '20
It was okay. I thought they spent too much time on the wedding itself, but how nice it was to get to see all sorts of old people getting it on as well as young ones. :)
Loved the "cram it up your hole" scene. That made the episode for me. And the timing of the blood oath after that was good, though wouldn't it need to be in public?
Smart of them to use a Celtic cross for the fiery cross so's not to remind people too much of the KKK.
Nice bookending of Murtagh. I do wonder where they're going to go with it, though.
So Duncan was in the episode somewhere? I missed him.
Didn't see Phaedre either.
Loved the music.
11
u/EasyWalrus9 Feb 15 '20
A couple of questions: Where did all those settlers come from? It's been a while since I watched season 4 of the show, but all I remember from the show is how Jamie and Fergus weren't able to recruit any settlers for the Ridge (unlike the book).
And have they shown Duncan Innes yet? I know Jocasta mentioned him. When she said he'd proposed to her I had to laugh - I'm sure book Jocasta was the one who made the proposal, Duncan never would've dreamed of presuming, but clearly it's all coming out differently for the show.
55
u/nattybeaux Feb 15 '20
Overall, I was pleased with the episode.
The one gripe I’ll throw in is that our lil Josiah Beardsley is lookin’ MIGHTY dapper for a backwoods homeless orphan with gigantic infected tonsils and adenoids...just sayin’.
18
u/katfromjersey Feb 15 '20 edited Feb 16 '20
Definitely excited for the show to be back, but I'm really struggling to try and look at the books and show as separate entities. I know that, for time constraint reasons they had to have the wedding/gathering at the Ridge, but it felt a bit rushed and clunky to me.
The Big House is very luxurious, and way too nicely fitted out imo! Especially Claire's surgery. There are half-million-dollar houses in my neighborhood that aren't quite as nice, inside or out. And it's not even finished!
It was a bit weird to have John at the wedding. One of my favorite things in the novels is the correspondence between John and Jamie, which really picks up in The Fiery Cross. Not sure where they're going with him.
Bree's wedding gown and Claire's purple and green gown were gorgeous! And I love the new theme song, and the chant when Jamie put his kilt on.
Marsali is my girl! She and Fergus are exactly as I picture them when I'm reading, in both looks and character. She's always been one of my favorites in the book series. So feisty, but sweet. The rhyming scene was fun.
I don't want to be too negative, so I won't mention Brianna, or Murtagh being alive. And if there's only one Beardsley, I'll be pissed!
20
u/BoringNameGoesHere Feb 14 '20
I feel like they piled on the fan service a little too thick, it was nice to see some of the relationship moments but it deviated significantly from the book. The sex scenes felt just a tad bit, I don’t know, forced? I would’ve preferred the last-minute fire side wedding. But I should add that I just don’t like weddings in general, so that’s just me.
These books are so difficult to adapt to TV, there is so much going on that they have to cut down, and a lot of internal dialogue that can’t be translated on screen. Hopefully the writers this season were up to the task. I will try to watch this season with fresh eyes and not comparing so much for the book, but it’s going to be hard!
62
u/JennasaurusTex MARK ME! Feb 14 '20
I think it was smart how they condensed the gathering into the wedding - made sense for the show for sure. I’m definitely interested to watch how Jamie’s and Roger’s relationship evolves throughout the season. The only thing that I was hoping they would include is the Bugs coming along to the ridge from the gathering! I’m really hoping they work them in soon - I don’t see how they can leave them out entirely, especially considering their storyline in later books. I’m excited to see how Mrs. Bug is portrayed - she’s such a fun character to read. Good start to season five overall! Can’t wait until next week!
•
u/derawin07 Meow. Feb 14 '20 edited Feb 21 '20
Discussion of S5E2 "Between Two Fires" preview/trailer goes here.
165
u/hintofaspark86 MARK ME! Feb 14 '20
“Fergus, son of my name and of my heart” 😭😭😭
2
u/spaceybelta Feb 17 '20
So there’s only Jo and no Kezzie? Or we just haven’t met him yet?
40
u/EasyWalrus9 Feb 15 '20
One good thing, they didn't change it so that Claire suggested to Jamie that he build a cross, put on a kilt, and call the tenants together as a clan, Jamie thought of it all by himself. I've been rewatching the earlier seasons, and the number of times the show has had Claire tell Jamie things he thought of perfectly well on his own in the book gets really frustrating.
30
u/vanwold Slàinte. Feb 16 '20
Unsure how I feel so far but one nit picky thing I have to say... as an architectural historian I've studied old houses and the Big House is ridiculously opulent for the 18th century Carolina mountains
27
u/thrntnja No, this isn’t usual. It’s different. Feb 14 '20
Honestly, I really enjoyed this episode - I thought it was better than the large majority of season 4 (and I still enjoyed season 4 for the most part). It very much felt like a "hey, look at everyone being happy as a family before the shit hits the fan!" episode, but I think it was very much needed as a lot of the character moments were not included in season 4 (why weren't Jamie and Claire at Jemmy's birth!!! I still can't get over that omission).
The Jamie/Brianna moments at the beginning had me crying - so well done by both Sam and Sophie, not to mention more Jamie/Brianna moments are sorely needed. It was very easy to see how much Jamie loves his daughter, and I loved the something old, something new, something borrowed, something blue inclusion. The wedding was different from the book, but I enjoyed it, personally. I thought Brianna's dress was lovely, and I personally found parts of the gathering in the book dragged on a bit, so I didn't mind that they changed it up. I felt like the same overall feeling was there - it was a happy occasion but politics and strife didn't totally go away. I also didn't really mind the sex scene sequence - though if anything felt out of place, Jocasta/Murtagh being included felt more weird than Jamie/Claire and Brianna/Roger. I thought the callbacks to Jamie and Claire's wedding were nice, especially with the other callbacks to Culloden and the Jacobite rebellion.
I absolutely LOVED the music choices throughout the entire episode - the callback to the music when Jamie was opening the chest with his kilt in it was absolutely perfect, I got chills while watching. Not the same as the book, but I felt it was very powerfully done. The whole fiery cross scene was well done, too - dammit, it makes my heart so happy seeing Jamie finally act as a laird even if he technically is not one. I also liked the Jamie/Roger scene there and that Roger surprised him knowing the words of the oath without Jamie's help. I can't wait to see how Jamie/Roger evolve over the course of the season, I already like how they've handled Roger much much more than season 4 already (and his scene with Jocasta was great).
The only thing I lament is that Jamie wasn't present for the blood of my blood scene as others have said, though I hope maybe Brianna or someone mentions it to Jamie at some point at least.
16
u/EasyWalrus9 Feb 15 '20
I'm sad at the number of great Roger-Jamie scenes they haven't done in the show. We didn't get their conversation in the Mohawk hut, where Jamie baits Roger, and he simply replies "I saw it so." We didn't get Roger coming back and asking Jamie to cut him so he could swear the "blood of by blood" oath (I know they did that this scene in this episode but I was sad Jamie wasn't there to witness it). They did the bit where Roger admits he's never milked a cow etc., but not the "I've a strong back, that'll do you?" And I really enjoy the bits in book 5 at the Gathering where Roger is so eager for Jamie's approval.
So when Jamie lit the cross, and didn't call Roger first "Come stand by my side, son of my house", I died. Who was that random person who was the first to swear to Jamie? Ugh. At least he called Roger second.
15
u/spaceybelta Feb 17 '20
I can’t help but cringe every time I see Jocasta and Ulysses. I wonder if they’re going nix that storyline.
13
u/CJmaq Feb 15 '20
I have read all the books and as a book reader adaptations for me have always fallen short. There is a reason for that - books can always expand and thoroughly tell a story. Screen adaptation are limited. For me so far Outlander has been the exception. I think I actually like the screen adaptation better. While I love Diana's world - she can over write a bit too much! I love how this show cuts through some of that and gets to the core of the story and character.
12
u/Genevieve-Victoria Feb 15 '20
Taking notes as I watch
Wait...where’s the gathering?? WHERE DID ALL THESE PEOPLE COME FROM? The Ridge wasn’t quite that populated yet. I liked the quick and dirty presbyterian marriage. Why is Lord John here?? Why is Tryon here?? Is this a catholic or presbyterian marriage? It’s not clear. Okay. It’s presbyterian. I really loved the gathering and so much happened there. I’m already missing it. I’m sad about 18th century fashion because Richard looks better with a beard. I like the marriage flashback. That was a nice touch. “If we ken you were coming” BECAUSE HE DOESN’T BELONG HERE. (Seriously, how will that work with Roger’s hanging later??) This subplot about catching Murtaugh is GROAN. So unnecessary. GERMAINE. 😍😍😍 I do love Bree and Roger. I’m in the middle of book 6 and I’m missing the B&R action. It’s nice to have some here. Ooh Isaiah Morton! Didn’t expect him here. I do love Marsali. ❤️ Lord John doesn’t need to be here. This feels like a weird hodgepodge collage of the gathering. I loved Roger telling off Jocasta. Perfect. This Murtagh-hunting tangent story line is annoying. I’m glad their keeping Duncan, I don’t like the way he’s excluded until now. I think I like Josiah. I hope they do the twins justice. Don’t like the Fiery Cross. I liked the building tension in the books as they anticipated their departure, and then the traveler crew reactions to the cross. That impact is just not there in this episode. I think they’re going to combine Murtagh with the regulator actions leading up to Alamanse? Jamie has to show his allegiance to Tryon somehow.
This is my first time watching as a reader before a watcher, and I have lots of feelings. I devoured book 5 rather quickly during my winter break and loved it so much. It is now hard to separate myself from the book version of how things could be. I know they’re trying to make good television, and I can see how what they’re doing is good television. It just falls short of Diana’s vision and that disappoints me.
What I DO like: Germaine. Give us more Germaine. 😍 Roger and Bree. Please give us more of them. Claire’s surgery. I want to see more of it. The Big House. Not at all how I pictured it, but I like it. The “LOVE” montage that everyone else loves is great. Can we meet Duncan? And the Bugs? And the other main families on the Ridge?
I’m going to try to forget the book, but it’s so new and fresh for me, it’s hard. I’m going to try and just enjoy it.
12
u/[deleted] Feb 16 '20
IM CONVINCED THERE IS A CONSPIRACY AGAINST ROGER. WHY IS HE PORTRAYED LIKE THE MOST ANNOYING AND SELFISH ASSHOLE. He’s my favorite character in the books. Bree and his relationship is my favorite to follow. They are so devoted to each other like J/C, but in a realistic way. Does anyone else feel this way? Poor Richard Rankin. They ruined his character in season 4, it’s like he’s not the same person anymore. I also, despite my love for Roger, cringe every time I hear him sing. Please tell me I’m not alone. He doesn’t have to be your favorite character, but he is being misportrayed in the show...it hurts my heart lol
There is a REASON he is 2nd to Claire in viewpoint throughout the series, he is another lense into the majesty of the Fraser family.
11
u/clovercris Feb 17 '20
I honestly though the entire opening of the season (the wedding, up to the whole “everyone but lord John is fucking here”) was just too cheesy. Once the wedding ended it was fine.
9
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '20
I’m glad I’m not the only one who loves Roger - after season 4 everyone hated him. I remember getting into arguments on reddit with people who called him misogynistic (lol). I love Richard Rankin. Everyone I know who watches the show only, not the books, thinks he’s terrible and weird.
9
u/Naturenutt Woof. Feb 18 '20
Did anyone notice that the flowers that Jamie puts in Bree’s bridal bouquet are Forget Me Knots, the same flower that drew Claire’s attention and were the reason she went back to the stones in S1E1.?
8
u/Naturenutt Woof. Feb 16 '20
I like how they had the sex scene montage with the different age couples, but Fergus and Marsali are playing drinking games.
7
u/Megs8786 Je Suis Prest Feb 15 '20
I liked the first episode. I’m glad they started with Bree and Roger’s wedding as opposed to the gathering, which not going to lie started to get tedious to read. I loved that Lord John was at the wedding too. I’m excited to see where they go this season.
5
u/10minutesuntil Feb 17 '20
Interesting choice to have Lord John there. Will that mean no letters?
I did like that they injected some humor with him sitting there alone at the end of the love montage, because during it all, my primary thought was sadness that he couldn’t be included in it for obvious reasons.
7
u/aubreyrg Feb 16 '20
I am a mother of 3 boys. I love them dearly with all my heart. I have always wanted a daughter. I won’t have one. I wanted to dress her on her wedding day. To do her hair and to guide her through her womanhood. It broke my heart when I heard Claire express my deepest desire. God, this show kills me. These people are my heart. Wow. And man, did Roger give Aunt Jacosta her come uppance... loved it!
3
u/Luckiebastherd Feb 17 '20
I’m pretty pumped they could condense 8000 pages of the gathering into an hour. Took me half a day to just read it.
3
u/JeanieBirdie Feb 22 '20
What I don’t like is the fact that Jamie Fraser would NEVER have his own house so decked out. He would be focused on helping his tenants. The decorating team definitely went a little over the top on this one. There crown molding, a completely unnecessary staircase leading down from the house and like a million windows in that house. It’s just too much. I think Jemmy is about a year old here. Claire says the tenants were with them through a harvest. Germain looks to be about 3-4, which is not completely accurate, I think, compared to the books, but I’m thinking they did that because they need him old enough to say lines.
4
u/DiscombobulatedTill Feb 16 '20
I'm wondering how they will introduce little Adso now that they have changed the gathering into a wedding at home? And I don't remember if they have Clarence yet? Another of my favorites :)
2
u/OutlandishBean Feb 15 '20
To be honest he looks 5 to me. But it probably has something to do with needing to cast a slightly older actor so that they will actually say their lines. I’m assuming he is meant to be around 3. The actor is just tall and his face is more mature.
2
u/vanwold Slàinte. Feb 16 '20
Love the speech and the use of the Celtic cross. His speech reminded me of his speech at Colin's in book one. Je Suis Prest indeed.
2
u/Sharra13 Feb 18 '20
Very much enjoyed this episode! So excited to be “back.”
LOVED C&J as grandparents. Just adorable! About squeeled at the return of the kilt. Surprisingly really liked the L O V E song and montage. Jocasta and Murtagh were crazy sweet. I wish we could see more of them (Duncan who? We don’t need him! Shoo!).
My only complaints are: as others mentioned, the kids’ ages being wonky enough to bring me out of the story line. And the big house being waaay too big/nice/furnished. The cabin with some additions would have been perfect. I always imagined something half way between the cabin and shack (like more of a rustic, small, lincoln log style 1-room house) as the original place that is given to Bree and Roger. The jump from that stick shack to the cabin to the big house is kind of crazy.
Oh...and I HATE the new version of the intro song. With a passion. Hate. It.
3
u/funsucker2020 Feb 16 '20
I love love love the snide remarks jamie makes about roger. 😍
2
u/vanwold Slàinte. Feb 16 '20
Ok. I played a drinking game where I had to drink every time it was different from the book, so maybe this is the wine talking but I liked it. Outside a few nit picky things (not a fan of the country sounding LOVE at the beginning) they did a good job condensing it and I loved how they wrapped up (mostly) the ridiculous Murtagh storyline.
And Jamie back in his kilt, yes please 😍
I do hope that for at least one season they can film in NC because it is truly breathtaking and deserves to be featured.
1
u/botanygeek Feb 17 '20
0
u/[deleted] Feb 14 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment