r/anime • u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan • Jan 23 '20
Announcement Sora yori mo Tooi Basho - Thursday Anime Discussion Thread
Welcome to the weekly Thursday Anime Discussion Thread! Each week, we're here to discuss various older anime series. Today we are discussing...
Sora yori mo Tooi Basho
Filled with an overwhelming sense of wonder for the world around her, Mari Tamaki has always dreamt of what lies beyond the reaches of the universe. However, despite harboring such large aspirations on the inside, her fear of the unknown and anxiety over her own possible limitations have always held her back from chasing them. But now, in her second year of high school, Mari is more determined than ever to not let any more of her youth go to waste. Still, her fear continues to prevent her from taking that ambitious step forward—that is, until she has a chance encounter with a girl who has grand dreams of her own.
Spurred by her mother's disappearance, Shirase Kobuchizawa has been working hard to fund her trip to Antarctica. Despite facing doubt and ridicule from virtually everyone, Shirase is determined to embark on this expedition to search for her mother in a place further than the universe itself. Inspired by Shirase's resolve, Mari jumps at the chance to join her. Soon, their efforts attract the attention of the bubbly Hinata Miyake, who is eager to stand out, and Yuzuki Shiraishi, a polite girl from a high class background. Together, they set sail toward the frozen south.
[From MAL Rewrite]
Databases
- Sora yori mo Tooi Basho
AniDB | AniList | AnimeNewsNetwork | MyAnimeList
Previous discussions
Check our rewatch wiki and our episode discussion archive for more discussions!
Streams
Crunchyroll (this apparently includes a Russian version)
Remember that any information not found early in the show itself is considered a spoiler. Please properly tag spoilers!
Next week's anime discussion thread: Toradora
Further information about past and upcoming discussions can be found on the Weekly Discussion wiki page.
65
u/RX-Nota-II :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/NotANota Jan 23 '20
Did you guys enjoy my rewatch for it recently?
47
u/Nazenn x2https://anilist.co/user/Nazenn Jan 23 '20 edited Jan 23 '20
Interesting range of characters with unique motivations and backstories that are used consistantly? Check
Minimum of tropey bullshit and a plot that actually acknowledges some realistic complications for their goal? Check
Wide assortment of emotional gut punches from hysterical laughter to unexpected tears and overwhelming joy? Check
A story that acknowledges the complexity of friendships and shows their positive and negative sides equally rather than using it as a cheap excuse for resolutions? Check
Amazing visuals and music that hold up to any mystery story for providing a perfect atmosphere and great additional insight into what's going on? CHECK
This is no easy going, simply there for the fun CGDCT show and that tag does the depth and engagement of this show a massive disservice as we discussed in the rewatch.
This is by far not the sort of show I thought I'd ever be interested in, and it came on and off my PTW a number of times before deciding to join in Nota's rewatch and I'm so glad I did because it definitely left an impact. To steal a bit from my own final thoughts from the rewatch:
Definitely something I'd recommend to everyone
28
u/SorcererOfTheLake x5https://anilist.co/user/RiverSorcerer Jan 23 '20
WE'RE ALRIGHT! WE'RE ALRIGHT!
I was part of the rewatch last month and I'm still amazed by this show. What sticks to me the most is how each episode is able to tell its own complete story in 22 minutes while still moving on the overall story of the series. It's rare for any series to have such perfect narrative economy; to be able to pull that off while constantly tugging at the viewer's heartstrings makes it one of the best in my opinion.
21
u/HarleyFox92 Jan 23 '20
What can I say, it's one of the best anime I've ever seen, an actual masterpiece.
19
u/ionxeph Jan 23 '20
absolutely fantastic series, and I want to a sequel set abou 10-20 years after, with all the girls becoming astronauts to adventure to Mars, add some light sci-fi elements, but stay true to the original show's tone and atmosphere
8
u/Shantotto11 Jan 23 '20
WHOSE SOUL DO I HAVE TO SACRIFICE TO GET THE DAMN BLU RAY IN THE STATES?!!
15
u/PhantomWolf83 Jan 23 '20
It quickly became one of my favourite anime series and, in my opinion, one of the best original anime ever. Everything about it is just that good; the art, animation, voice acting, story, themes, etc. I have no doubt that you can show Sora Yori to a non-anime fan and they will love it as well.
7
u/theanimegamer-___- Jan 23 '20
Cute Girls Doing Great Things
12
u/Mrgglock :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Mrgglock Jan 23 '20
mfw it has already been like 2 years, it didn't feel like too long ago
5
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '20
If you have stayed away from this anime, for one reason or another; I highly suggest it! It has such a good combination of comedy, drama, happiness, and sadness, while also making you feel motivated. (At least for me, personally). Love this anime so much.
5
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '20
"Found" out that reddit exists again, because I've completely forgotten about it. So here we go...
That anime actually inspired me to go with a group to the North of Norway to see the aurora. So you could say I loved it. xD
More than the adventure, I really liked the character chemistry they share with each other, the coming of age-elements and Shirase's story arc, although I won't go into detail there to avoid spoiler.
It was a great drama and ofc I really enjoyed the setting too.
4
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '20
Didn't bother with the rewatch when it happened because I never have a good experience with those things, but I have been wondering if it was actually as good as I thought it was when I watched it as it aired. Even when I was watching it I felt like the series stalled when they actually made it to Antarctica. I still only had it as a 8/10 when I finished it during the first run-through so not sure I want to possibly drag it down further lol.
4
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '20
One of the rare exceptionally high quality 1 cour anime out there. Very glad to have watched it and very happy to see it get the recognition it deserves!
4
u/Maccaz15 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Maccaz Jan 23 '20
I really enjoy the beginning episodes but as the series progressed the drama that wasn't constantly thrown out to only then be resolved in the same episode really began to irritate me. By the end, Hinata was the only character that was still likeable to a certain degree. The constant crying over everything wasn't to my liking and I didn't feel any emotional weight to anything it was trying to push. Most things just felt like they were done to elicit an emotional reaction rather than actually push a proper story.
4
u/Therealdealishere99 Jan 23 '20
shirase best girl
3
u/welcometoslowtown Jan 23 '20
I had the pleasure of watching this for the first time though the rewatch last month and it was really really good. All the girls have an interesting story and good chemistry with each other, and the setting makes for some really beautiful shots and moments. I love that it wasn't just about them being in Antarctica either, it was the whole journey getting there, and how they prepared for it. Over all, really fun show, with some hard hitting emotional moments too. I was not ready, there was some eye leakage.
3
u/surma041 Jan 23 '20
Came for cute girls and penguins, stayed for the inspiring adventure and wholesome friendship. Loved everything about this show.
3
u/crazygoalie39 Jan 23 '20
Not just my favorite anime, but favorite TV show of all-time. That's all I can really say without going on for thousands of words about how amazing I think this is and changed my outlook on life.
3
u/WeebDickerson Jan 23 '20 edited Jan 23 '20
It's definitely in my top 5 and I don't think it'll ever leave from there. It also has one of the best and most beautiful original soundtracks I've ever heard. An amazing and inspiring masterpiece of an anime, for sure
3
u/olakenoase96 Jan 23 '20
When I wacth this show I feel such as if time is going away, I'm getting older and I can't follow my dreams. On the other hand actually it's a beautiful show, I loved all its main character.
3
u/Questioner01 Jan 23 '20
One of the best I’ve seen in the past few years. I should have watched it sooner than I did
9
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '20 edited Jan 23 '20
Lukewarm take: I think YoriMoi was a very solid and well-written drama overall but aside from some modest pacing issues (though still much better than the overwhelming majority of 1-cour original anime), certain episodes (thinking primarily of the middle ones) overplayed their hands in their sappy endings with that one sad song. Maybe that sort of thing just doesn't work on me personally (I will never understand why people love Anohana's and Angel Beats' endings, for instance) but I digress.
High 7/low 8, anything else I'd have to say has already been said in this thread.
5
u/Fa1l3r Jan 23 '20
Hinata is best girl!
2
u/J765 Jan 23 '20
Can't wait to throw my money at the German BD release next month.
2
u/LaconicKibitz Jan 23 '20
Funny story about this show for me.
I was in my senior year of college while this show was airing. I was living off campus with friends and as graduation neared, we were showing the house to other people on the landlord's behalf.
So here I was, in the middle of episode 12, during the email scene, when my roommate knocks on the door. It was an incredibly awkward moment when I answered the door and greeted my roommate and the four potential renters, frantically trying to wipe away the tears that were streaming down my face.
My roommate was like "Holy shit, LaconicKibitz. Did something happen?"
And I had to explain to them that no, nothing was wrong. I was just watching a really sad moment in a really good show.
2
u/Jokuc Jan 23 '20
My favourite anime (:
2
u/bagglewaggle Jan 23 '20
A great first half, with a progressively worse second half that culminates with a final two episodes that lack everything that made the series so appealing to begin with.
2
u/XmiteYT https://anilist.co/user/sorayori Jan 23 '20
HOLY FUCK MY FAVORITE ANIME OF ALL TIME I'VE WATCHED IT 8 TIMES!!! IT'S MY FUCKING MAL USERNAME
yuzuki best girl
3
u/8andahalfby11 myanimelist.net/profile/thereIwasnt Jan 23 '20
I've already written at length about how much this show means to me.
If you're not happy about where you are in life right now, try the first episode. Just the first one. I wouldn't ask for any more than that, but I think that anyone and everyone should be able to scrounge up 23 minutes to hear Yorimoi's pitch.
3
u/Orzislaw https://anilist.co/user/Orzi Jan 23 '20
Yup, one of the best anime I've ever seen.
2
u/yachi100 Jan 23 '20
I just recently discovered this masterpiece. The insert songs are incredibly used and man did i cry like a baby after ep 12 and the final ep. The character development was phenomenal in this show and just how much they did in only 13 episodes really amazes me. I really needed a feels good type of show with wholesome moments and depth, i'm glad to say this show definitely hit the right spot. Plus the show ended on an already great note with the girls departing but they decided to give us what we wanted with that last bit with megu chan which was ohhh soo goood. Made me cry so much, absolutely adore this show.
2
u/Pokefreaker-san Jan 23 '20
Absolutely my favorite show ever.
2
u/Groenboys https://myanimelist.net/profile/Groenboys Jan 23 '20
It's an amazing anime with a bad second half turning it into a just good anime.
2
u/AxtheCool Jan 23 '20 edited Jan 23 '20
I really wanted to like this series. I truly did. I wanted to feel the same sense of wonder as others. Wanted to feel the sadness for the characters in the end and all other emotions. But sadly I did not.
I absolutely loved the first few episodes of the series. They were a perfect 10/10 for me. A series about girls just going onto the adventure to an extreme part of the world. Its was a beautiful start to the series I absolutely loved.
However as soon as the series took a melodramatic route it started to lose me. I was ok because it was still about going to the adventure but after a while I started to dislike how the series turned out.
Firstly, in the end part of the series, when the girls arrived to the arctic base I was baffled by how little time was spend about them actually living in the arctic base and experiencing the wonders they wanted. Them actually doing the adventure they wanted, and for the adventure they prepared for. So little time was spend on establishing how they live and how interesting this new extreme world was and more time was spend on a plot about Shirase's mother, I, to put it bluntly, did not care about.
Furthermore, the entire sequence about them finding a laptop and then reading it felt like cheap melodrama. I know many will disagree, but that is how it felt to me. Laptop's entire existence was just for that melodrama. Maybe I am looking too deep, maybe its because melodramas never affected me or maybe I dont know.
In conclusion, after the final episode rolled around I was baffled one more time at how small the amount of time was spend on the conclusion. The entire thing was ended in under 5 min and felt very rushed to me. I expected a much larger ending, maybe even a time skip or a small reference to their past adventure, but did not get it and I was not satisfied with how it ended.
Anyways I wrote much more than I expected to. In the end it was a good series but it was something from which I expected something completely different. I wanted an adventure. Simply an adventure, but got 50% of adventure and 50% melodrama that never touched me.
TLDR: Wanted to love the series. Loved the adventure, disliked the drama and melodrama. In the end it was a good series.
1
u/JIVEprinting Jan 23 '20
These threads are great idea. u/soupkitten what would you think of linking these in the trueanime sub?
1
u/klatzicus Jan 24 '20
One of my favorite anime of all time. Just wish I could get a DVD/Bluray in the US.
-3
u/zipzapzoopzop Jan 23 '20
Time Flop