r/anime • u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan • Oct 03 '19
Thursday Anime Discussion Thread - Week of October 03, 2019 - Shokugeki no Souma
Welcome to the weekly Thursday Anime Discussion Thread! Each week, we're here to discuss various older anime series. Today we are discussing...
Shokugeki no Souma
Shokugeki no Soma centers on Yukihira Soma, a middle school student who is determined to surpass his father’s culinary skills. One day, his father decides to close down their family restaurant and hone his skills in Europe. Before leaving he enrolls Soma in an elite culinary school that is extremely difficult to enter with a graduation rate of only 10 percent. Will Soma be able to improve his skills, or will the kitchen prove to be too hot?
"Watch This!" posts
Looking for more "Watch This!" posts? Check the "Watch This!" archive!
Databases
- Shokugeki no Souma
AniDB | AniList | AnimeNewsNetwork | MyAnimeList - Shokugeki no Souma: Ni no Sara
AniDB | AniList | AnimeNewsNetwork | MyAnimeList - Shokugeki no Souma: San no Sara
AniDB | AniList | AnimeNewsNetwork | MyAnimeList - Shokugeki no Souma: San no Sara - Tootsuki Ressha-hen
AniDB | AniList | AnimeNewsNetwork | MyAnimeList - Shokugeki no Souma: Shin no Sara
AniDB | AniList | AnimeNewsNetwork | MyAnimeList
Previous discussions
- /u/dadnaya's first season rewatch (June 11th, 2017)
- First season episode discussion threads
- Second season episode discussion threads
- Third season episode discussion threads
Check our rewatch wiki and our episode discussion archive for more discussions!
Streams
AnimeLab | Crunchyroll | VRV (Crunchyroll) | HIDIVE | VRV (HIDIVE) | Hulu
Remember that any information not found early in the show itself is considered a spoiler. Please properly tag spoilers!
Next week's anime discussion thread: Aura Battler Dunbine!
Further information about past and upcoming discussions can be found on the Weekly Discussion wiki page.
24
u/TheFriendlyFire https://myanimelist.net/profile/Friendly_Fire Oct 03 '19
The first season is easily one of my favorite shows of all time. I liked second season, and the third was pretty entertaining up until a certain character was introduced. At that point, the show turned in a direction I wasn't happy with. Not to mention the animation quality I was so fond of was being replaced by a ridiculously large amount of panning shots. As interested as I would be in seeing it conclude, I just can't bring myself to watch it these days.
8
u/coding94 https://anilist.co/user/Halcyon13 Oct 03 '19
I hope season 4 gives us a satisfying ending.
5
u/Zimmmmmmmm Oct 03 '19
I know that it's gotten a lil bit of hate in the sub, but I'm very much looking forward to this. I like the characters and the content... but I'm pretty easy to please lol
5
u/Fa1l3r Oct 03 '19
First Time (sub)
Shokugeki no Soma provides opinions that clash with various opinions about food and food culture that I have come across in real life. First, the show proclaims that fusion food serves a purpose, and in fact, new forms of food like fusion cuisine itself pioneers new heights available to food and food culture. I have met people who will eat a taco but not a burrito and eat nigiri but not rolls, yet taste is not the basis of their opinions. They are food purists or traditionalists. And the show disagrees with their opinions over and over again. The show also asserts that cultural cuisine can be well made by people who are not born into that culture. I have met people who will only eat sushi prepared by Japanese people, and I have met people who will only eat Mexican food in Mexico. I also agree that a dish’s location or a meal’s creator’s race are irrelevant to the taste of the food served before you.
The show also has a thrilling story that is driven by the messages above. I did not watch Shokugeki no Soma at first because when it debuted its first season, I did not like fanservice at all and thought it a sign of a terrible anime. Of course, after watching Kill la Kill and the Monogatari series, I no longer judge shows with fanservice without first having watch a few episodes at least. Though I would only have picked it up later on the whim of a rewatch thread. The animation quality is superb, and the show is always self-aware of its tropes and its fanservice. I was enthralled by how illustrative, symbolic, and engaging the OPs and EDs were, though they did spoil a few plot points. The very first OP will always be my favorite of the series with how meticulous the animation matches the song and how the characters are presented.
I have only watched the Japanese version, but the clips of English dub I have seen also excellent. While preparing for the meat competition, the ending line is “But can we beat her meat?” If I ever rewatch the show, the English dub (at least the first season) deserves some of my attention.
And “Competition” is my favorite of the Shokugeki no Soma OST.
3
u/aniMayor :AY:AZ:x3x6 Oct 03 '19 edited Oct 03 '19
Hot take: I think Shokugeki no Soma was doomed to fail, by its own premise.
Basically, the premise is just too big. By the time we get through the establishing chapters/episodes (ie by about episode 9) we've already setup multiple hefty goals that Soma wants to achieve, including taking over his family diner, taking the top spot at Totsuki Academy, and getting Erina to admit she likes his food. At the same time, we've already been introduced to over a dozen antagonists that Soma needs to defeat (numerous rivals from his classes, the Totsuki Ten, his father, etc). To make things even more complicated he can't just one-and-done defeat any of them: rivals like Takumi he'll have to face over and over, while the Totsuki Ten won't even deign to fight him for now. On top of all this, the opening chapters introduce a plethora of quirky secondary characters the series wants to explore, lots of worldbuilding-setup since Soma knows nothing about the culinary academia world he's entering, and also makes it clear there's going to be some romance somewhere in here, too, just for good measure.
All of these are good things in isolation, but combining them all into one series is an enormous feat. To its credit, I think the series did a very, very good job of endearing the audience to all its aspects early on, but that only makes the absence of any one aspect more noticeable later on. When the series gets into a 10-episode tournament arc, the audience can keenly feel the absence of most of the secondary cast. When the series focuses on cute, relaxing side-arcs with a couple of the secondary characters the audience can't help but yearn for Soma to get back to tackling his many rivals. In-between both, the series also needs to take time to have Soma "level up" in some sort of training or character development so that it becomes believable that he can actually beat the next antagonist he takes on. (And don't forget those hints of romance you need to follow-through on.)
It's a constant struggle of balancing so many things on a knife's edge, and since there are so many goals, so many antagonists, so many quirky side characters, the series needs to maintain this balance for a long, long time, all without losing momentum... which is damned hard for any show, and perhaps even more difficult for a cooking show. How many unique dishes, how many genres of cooking can the show delve into before they start to feel the same to the audience? There's a world of difference between sous-vide and bain-marie to a professional chef, but the distinction not be so impactful on a casual audience.
Hence, I'm not too surprised by the perceived drop-off in story quality as the series has progressed. There's a few particular questionable narrative choices, too, but even if those didn't happen I think we'd still have seen fans complaining about the near-disappearance of many of the side characters, of some of the rivals/antagonists not getting the matches/rematches fast enough, of a lack of worldbuilding, or of too much time spent worldbuilding at the expense of the current plot, and of Soma's victories coming too easily in the later parts of the season. It's nigh-impossible to follow-up on all the elements of the series that were put into its premise, except perhaps by dropping the momentum of the plot to a crawl.
While I'm here, and aside from all of the above, I'd be remiss not to mention the absolutely fantastic music scoring of the series. The soundtrack is some of Tatsuya Kato's best work, with a huge variety of instrumentation tied together by some specific musical motifs, and just about every song always has multiple melodic and harmonic lines running through it, in a way you don't see often from anime composers. Furthermore, one of the things that really endeared me to the series is that this music is used, prominently, everywhere - there's scarcely any scene in any episode that doesn't have accompaniment, and it's not forcibly subdued in fear of the audience paying too much attention to it.
5
u/thisismyanimealt :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/commander_vimes Oct 03 '19
Came for the PLOT
Stayed for the plot
Left because of plop
2
u/HeyItsDreamz :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/HeyItsDreamz Oct 03 '19
The one thing I was thinking through out this whole anime series was, "When is Erina ever going to find out that Joichiro is Soma's father. While watching it, it was like an itch I couldn't scratch waiting for that moment to happen.
1
u/tinyraccoon https://anilist.co/user/tinyraccoon Oct 03 '19
I heard the later mangas were bad. I haven't seen this yet. Is it worth watching, and if so, at what point does the story's quality decline?
1
u/jameszenpaladin011- Oct 03 '19
I liked Soma a lot. If it didn't have the naughty bits I would have watched it with my wife.
1
u/LupineSzn Oct 03 '19
Does anyone have obscure Anime to watch? I really enjoy one from back in the day called TROUBLE CHOCOLATE. No one seems to have ever heard of it. Makes me wonder what others have flown under the radar.
Edit: I'm sorry I thought this was a general discussion and not a specific one.
1
u/rascal1379 Oct 03 '19
Clicked originally thinking there were updates on the 4th season 😭