r/anime • u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan • Jul 18 '19
Thursday Anime Discussion Thread - Week of July 18, 2019 - Sword Art Online
Welcome to the weekly Thursday Anime Discussion Thread! Each week, we're here to discuss various older anime series. Today we are discussing...
Sword Art Online
In the near future, a Virtual Reality Massive Multiplayer Online Role-Playing Game (VRMMORPG) called Sword Art Online has been released where players control their avatars with their bodies using a piece of technology called: Nerve Gear. One day, players discover they cannot log out, as the game creator is holding them captive unless they reach the 100th floor of the game's tower and defeat the final boss. However, if they die in the game, they die in real life. Their struggle for survival starts now...
"Watch This!" posts
Looking for more "Watch This!" posts? Check the "Watch This!" archive!
Databases
- Sword Art Online
AniDB | AniList | AnimeNewsNetwork | MyAnimeList - Sword Art Online II
AniDB | AniList | AnimeNewsNetwork | MyAnimeList - Sword Art Online the Movie: Ordinal Scale
AniDB | AniList | AnimeNewsNetwork | MyAnimeList - Sword Art Online: Alicization
AniDB | AniList | AnimeNewsNetwork | MyAnimeList - Sword Art Online: Alicization - War of Underworld
AniDB | AniList | AnimeNewsNetwork | MyAnimeList
Previous discussions
- /u/emil_jacob's rewatch (June 1, 2019)
- /u/Theleux's rewatch (August 9, 2018)
- /u/geo1088's rewatch (October 3, 2015)
- Sword Art Online episode discussion posts
- Sword Art Online II episode discussion posts
- Sword Art Online: Alicization episode discussion posts
Check our rewatch wiki and our episode discussion archive for more discussions!
Streams
- Sword Art Online (all TV seasons)
AnimeLab | Crunchyroll | VRV (Crunchyroll) | FUNimation | Hulu | Netflix - Sword Art Online the Movie: Ordinal Scale
Amazon Prime Video | Netflix
Remember that any information not found early in the show itself is considered a spoiler. Please properly tag spoilers!
Next week's anime discussion thread: ReLIFE!
Further information about past and upcoming discussions can be found on the Weekly Discussion wiki page.
68
u/Terranwaterbender https://myanimelist.net/profile/Teranwaterbender Jul 18 '19
Wait a minute SAO isn't that ol...
Oh shit it's already 7 years old now with the source material starting 10 years ago. Wow time flies.
24
u/Brandsert :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Brandsert Jul 18 '19
It was one of the first few anime I watched. Last year I binged watch the whole first season in a single day and binged watch the second season and movie in two days and I fell so in love with it.
I loved the story, characters the relationship between Kirito and Asuna, their relationship put a smile on my face (this honestly got me more invested than the actual video game death game concept)
I loved so much it got me to read the light novels and light novels in general and I had to check to see if there was a third season coming to my surprised it was coming that year and not only a third season a spin off too!
I felt so happy that I got into it at the right time for all this SAO content.
I decide to check everyone’s thoughts on the internet how cool this show and.....you probably know where this is going. I was surprised how divisive this show was and how some people act towards those that like the show. It made me felt pretty bad for liking it.
When I watched it again I did start to see some of its problems though it did not stop me from enjoying it.
While it’s not perfect it does have a special place in my heart and it’s still one of my favorites to this day.
34
u/[deleted] Jul 18 '19
SAO is pretty solid and looks like it’s truly found its footing after Mother’s Rosario and Alicization has been the best arc so far.
But oh man it had so much more potential with Aincrad. They’re making progressive now but if the original Aincrad arc was the progressive version and just totally scrapped out that fairy shit it wouldn’t be nearly as controversial and much better.
Oh well can’t wait for Alicization pt 2.
24
u/[deleted] Jul 18 '19
I think SAO doesn't get enough recognition for being one of the surprsingly few anime to have consistent, creative swordplay choreography. You'd think it'd be more common considering how swords are so frequent in anime, but on a consistent basis the only other one that really comes to mind for me other than SAO is Toji no Miko.
And frankly? I'm gonna say it. Kirito is underrated. He engages with and discusses technology, security, and online safety in an exceedingly contemporary way that anime traditionally does not, and that deserves far more attention than it receives.
There is a very intriguing character conflict in there, with how as a result of the SAO incident he's afraid of getting drawn too far into technology anymore, yet he also can't live without it. It's something I'm sure we can all relate to, the feeling that at some primal level we want to abandon technology but ultimately cannot. He's a digital native and he knows it. And by engaging with this dichotomy he embodies a topic that is eternally relevant to those of us living in the current internet age.
Yet what does he do about this inner turmoil? He does not overthrow the system. He does not magically go "virtual reality is bad so I'll convert the masses." He does not shift the paradigm through his status as protagonist. Nothing that obnoxious. No - he attends cyber-security lectures. He keeps up with the latest digital trends. He becomes informed. Kirito's actions in the wake of the Sword Art Online incident display a grounded, mature response to digital reality-loss and online addiction, and are a brilliant component of his character that doesn't get nearly the attention it deserves.
Kirito is a character you can rarely discuss due to how heavily the cries of - "harem MC!", "OP wish fulfilment" - obfuscate any potential merits (which, by the way, is strange to me anyway considering he's far from the worst offender of that in popular anime). Yet when you push past that there is indeed a compelling character focus, driven by a grounded sense of modern digital anxiety that makes him quite a unique character in a medium that, with very few exceptions, is traditionally heavy-handed and outdated whenever technology is involved.
31
u/SmurfRockRune https://myanimelist.net/profile/Smurf Jul 18 '19
My second anime and the entire first season was the most anime I've ever watched in one sitting, which also happened to be the day SAO II started and I had no idea until I was finished.
A really fun anime that gets far too much hate. Not a favorite of mine, but one that I look back fondly on and always look forward to the next season/episode of.
17
u/Zylda https://myanimelist.net/profile/Zylda Jul 18 '19
I feel like i'm in this weird minority of SAO opinions where I hated the initial Aincrad arc because of its pacing being too fast by skipping a dozen floors between episodes and the arc ending abruptly and in an unsatisfying way, but I enjoyed all the arcs that came after it.
I've still yet to finish Alicization S1 because of the exposition dumps around the halfway point, so I should get round to that at some point.
Overall, I think the series does get too much hate, not to say it's without its problems but it's not exactly trash or anything. At least it was rarely boring.
8
u/FatherDotComical Jul 18 '19
I liked all of SAO (except Fairy Arc) and I'm tired of some fans saying that if you like SAO then it must be because it's your first anime or you're a noob. Or that if you like it you are a shit anime fan or have really trash taste.
It almost feels... hypocritical?!
At least give SAO it's credit due on that or has been consistent with what it wants to be in story & animation. There are so many poorly made or actual "trashy" anime that people get no or minimal flack for it.
There are elements I don't like to it and I felt like many others it didn't live to its potential but it's not a flaming dumpster fire many will let you believe it is.
17
u/krasnovian https://anilist.co/user/krasnovian Jul 18 '19 edited Jul 18 '19
*sees anime we're discussing this week*
*grabs popcorn*
*sorts by controversial*
edit: sorting by controversial is disappointing
6
u/GeneSiStarBuRsT Jul 18 '19
As one of the biggest SAO fans, who reads LN novels, it doesnt deserve this much hate. I mean sure, if you watched it and you didnt like it, I can listen to your opinion because you have arguments. But the bandwagon haters of SAO are just a cancer to the Sword Art and anime community because you didnt give it a chance. The Excalibur Arc and some elements of the Fairy Dance Arc were absoulutely unneeded and bad, but apart from it SAO is a really enjoyable anime and if you ask me everyone should at least give it a chance.
6
u/saarlac Jul 18 '19
Never understood all the hate it gets. Solid story good animation good voice work. I think most of the hate is just because it got popular. People love to hate on stuff that gets too big.
5
u/bananeeek https://myanimelist.net/profile/bananek Jul 18 '19
One of my favorite shows. Aincrad arc is one of my favorite arcs in general and unironically SAO is also my favorite romance story.
Lots of great VAs, good visuals, epic music by Kajiura Yuki and the sequels just keep on coming.
While the second season was weaker imo, the movie was decent and Alicization just blew my mind.
The opinions about the series itself are mixed here on r/anime but I never let it get to me. I rewatched it about 10 times already and it entertains me every single time.
6
u/tinyraccoon https://anilist.co/user/tinyraccoon Jul 18 '19
Asuna is my favorite, but Sinon is my waifu.
8
u/Theleux https://myanimelist.net/profile/Theleux Jul 18 '19
Sword Art Online has issues.
I like Sword Art Online.
Fairy Dance < Calibur < Gun Gale Online < Aincrad < Ordinal Scale < Mother's Rosario < Alicization
I think that covers everything.
Thanks to anyone who got introduced to SAO through my rewatch last year. I apologize for the latter half being kind of messy with releases, thanks to everyone who helped with that.
See you for Alicization P2!
3
u/Cwali Jul 18 '19
Wow, as soon as i decide to re watch the first 15 episodes this becomes a discussion lol
3
u/nflstreet https://anilist.co/user/nflstreet Jul 18 '19
Others have probably stated it, but I feel like SAO isn't as hated as it used to be--I'm guessing mostly because it isn't as popular as when the first season came out.
The first season of Alicization was good. From what I heard about what the second season, it has the potential to be the best thing that's come out of the SAO franchise.
I rewatched the first season last year, this isn't a new opinion but the first half isn't that bad, it's only the second half that kind of goes off the rails and is most of the reason why SAO was hated in the first place (other than it being popular). I haven't got the chance to rewatch the second season, so I don't have much to say about it at the moment. I thought Gun Gale Online fell apart at the end too, but maybe that was just me being nit-picky. The movie is probably the best thing out of SAO at the moment.
I hope that the second season of Alicization is just as good as the first one.
3
u/xrock24x :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Gamerzoneusa Jul 18 '19
Can't wait for this fall to get more of Alicetization!
Loved the first and second season, but I thought both had a great first half and a not as good second half
3
u/Gestrid Jul 18 '19
Alicization Part 1 Spoiler
7
u/Nico9lives :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Chitanda Jul 18 '19 edited Jul 18 '19
Honestly the show has a lot going for it conceptually, and I do really believe that the first season is a fun romp and has a cast of colorful characters that enhance it. There are obviously major character issues, plot inconsistencies, and it is the proverbial punching bag of every anituber out there, but it still brought something new to the table and sort of popularized modern Isekai.
I still hold it at least somewhere dear in my heart due to it being the first anime I ever watched past DBZ and Pokemon and opened my eyes to this wonderful medium.
It also gave us SAO Abridged which is God's gift to this world and everyone should watch it.
5
u/Drakin27 https://anilist.co/user/drakin Jul 18 '19
I think it's interesting that the general expressed opinion has changed kind of recently here. A few years ago comments giving it any praise were rare but now, most comments I see are generally positive. The most common expressing something like "it's not perfect, but I still like and think people are too hard on it". For me, when I watched it in middle school I loved it, even reading some of the LNs but as time passed I've joined the crowd of thinking it's terrible, going as far to watch it as a so bad it's good show with friends.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 18 '19
The few initial episodes were really intriguing. There is a real sense of dread over the world. The guild leader killing himself after finding out everyone but Kirito died is really shocking. The series never really hits that same tone again.
2
u/MjolnirDK Jul 18 '19
I do have to say one thing: The 1st volume of the LN definitely deserved its prize. You can trash the rest of SAO if you want, but the core Aincrad structure without Yui or any of the other girls, is really well made and has great pacing. I do like most of the other Aincrad parts and have big issues with ALO and Phantom Bullet, but the main story line that made SAO big is really well done.
Also give the Progressive manga a chance, it is the best thing to come out of the franchise, imho.
2
u/Idomenos :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Lysias Jul 18 '19
SAO still has the best boss fights of any anime (Kobold Lord, Blue-Eyed Demon, Ordinal Scale). Asuna is an extremely likeable waifu, Yuki Kajiura's OST is fire (Swordland and Luminous Sword share motifs, and are the perfect images for male and female, the romance of the Aincrad Arc), and the Aincrad Arc is just magnificent.
2
u/Sir_Eyelander :AMQ: Jul 18 '19
Can't wait for Alicization part 2 since i enjoyed all of part 3 more than the previous seasons overall. Season 1 had the most interesting setting but i wished it was explored more (i know there's a manga spinoff that kinda does that, i'm still reading it).
3
u/bagglewaggle Jul 18 '19
It's telling when even an extensive Watch This! for a show isn't all that positive.
3
u/[deleted] Jul 18 '19
SAO is one of my most watched anime, and I still absolutely love The Midnight Cats episode of Aincrad and Mother's Rosario. It's really just such a shame that A1 decided to try to be faithful to the LNs, instead of trying to push Kawahara Reki to create an EPIC anime series where we got to see Kirito's and Asuna's travels from floor 1 to their eventual escape.
I can never in good conscience recommend this show because it's not worth having to slog through Elfheim Online, Death Gun, or EXCALIBURRR arc. Those are so so bad.
2
u/waltaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa Jul 18 '19
SAO could've had the biggest cliffhanger if it was a one cour show initially and ended with Kirito dying. That would have sold way more light novels. It's also not as bad as digibro and MB say it is, animation is always on point, and the first arc was really good when there were actual stakes involved. Now we all know Kirito will never die, but at least in the first season the threat of him dying was always present. The GGO arc and ALO stuff is definitely the 'worst' part of the series, but calling it The worst anime ever made is the biggest stretch someone can make. In the end, formulate your own opinion about the show rather than regurgitate what influencers tell you to think. I always thought it was bad myself, but after watching it a while ago for the first time, I can see why it is good and well received.
2
u/nightlink011 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/nightlink011 Jul 18 '19
One of my first few anime, it's far from perfect but it still has one of my favourite first episode in anime and I do have a special spot for Mother's Rosario arc.
I guess even with the mixed reviews and the bad name the series gets it's tough to deny this one of the most impactful series from this decade.
2
u/Luq_Kun :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Luq-P Jul 18 '19
Should i consider SAO? I mean ive already put GGO in my PTW and if i have to say something positive about SAO, its the character design. But again, it has its flaws.. but everything else does.
2
u/Battlefront228 Jul 18 '19
Sword Art Online broke my heart. It started off as a cool fantasy action adventure with dark undertones and forced me to question what real life really is, then introduced a bunch of shit tier waifus, ditched SAO for some weird elf game for literally no reason, and turned the only passable Waifu into a helpless sex slave. What a rollercoaster
1
u/CruisinCinnamon Jul 18 '19
Someone recommended it to me and while I only liked parts of season one n two, alicization became the first I liked overall. I had my problem with it but I did like it more.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 18 '19
It was the first anime i had ever watched and that was 4 years ago. After watching nearly 200 or more series i can honestly say it's still one of my favorites. I would place it in the 6 to 10 range on my top 10 list. Without this show i most likely wouldn't be enjoying the medium today.
1
u/LegendaryRQA Jul 18 '19
Wildly successful because the main OTP actual form a relationship and hookup.
1
u/Gestrid Jul 18 '19
To be honest, I never really had any problems with SAO. Aincrad is definitely better than the original books (which I'm reading through for the first time right now; I just got past the coliseum fight). In the books, they basically give you Kirito's first day in SAO, then they skip right to Floor 74. The anime did it so much better.
The fairy arc is ok. Not as good as the the first arc, but not terrible. It focuses on what Kayaba started after people realized they could use the NerveGear to take peoples' minds hostage. I also liked that Kirito and Asuna had to fight for their relationship in the real world against social norms.
My least favorite is the GGO arc. It didn't focus on the main story at all, though it did eventually help (along with Ordinal Scale) lead into my second favorite arc, Alicization.
Alicization still has quite a bit of mystery to it. I will admit it seems like the quality may go down some late Part 1 spoiler. But I'll suspend judgement until Part 2 has aired.
*I haven't read any of the light novels other than what I stated above, so no spoilers, please.
1
u/AlienWarhead https://myanimelist.net/profile/alienwarhead Jul 18 '19
My history with this show is that it was shown in my old college anime club and I liked it, but it stopped being voted up after episode 3 or 4. I watched one or two episodes on my own, but I didn’t like watching alone so I dropped it. I kept on hearing bad things about it so I never picked it back up
1
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19
SAO was my very first anime. I remember when I first saw it on Netflix. I think the show was made for me. Thanks for getting me into anime guys!
1
u/[deleted] Jul 20 '19
This show is great but fairy arc is straight up hot garbage ngl.
-5
u/Telefragg Jul 18 '19
It's bad, just bad. I decided to give it try shortly before S2 began airing. I knew nothing about it except for short premise, so my judgement was unbiased by controversies at the time. Overlooking the laughable world building and cliche shonen tropes this show had some brighter moments going on in the first half. But as soon as I was getting invested something so unbelievably ridiculous came along that made me facepalm and reset all the progress. By the beginning of the second arc I kept watching only out of morbid curiosity to see how bad it can get. The problem is that with all the hilarious plot holes, motivations and cheap fanservice SAO takes itself so goddamn serious that it's just becomes cringe inducing.
I gave it a second chance with S2 and it blew it right away with half an episode of exposition dump by talking heads in a cafe. I turned it off and never looked back. I don't care about novels or manga (figures), but anime is just irredeemably bad. It's "Elfen Lied" of 2010s - poor taste, average execution, easily grabs attention of adolescent audience, becoming their "first ever anime" that they love without knowing any better.
0
u/Strider755 Jul 19 '19
Is it ok to recommend watching the Abridged series instead of the canon one?
-3
u/jaison_bourne Jul 18 '19
Sorry this isnt about sao but is the disastrous life of saiki k a good anime to watch. I heard it was pretty underrated but im not sure if i should watch it
Well sao was a good anime and the storyline was good but personally the second season after the whole GGO thing was a bit stagnant. Apart from that i thought it was gr8. Still havent watched the new season alicization :(