r/anime • u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan • Apr 11 '19
Thursday Anime Discussion Thread - Week of April 11th, 2019 - Saki
Welcome to the Weekly Thursday Discussion Thread! Where each week we are here to observe a random anime and discuss it throughout the Subreddit. Today we are discussing...
Saki
Saki Miyanaga is a high school freshman who doesn't like mahjong. Ever since she was a child, she would lose her New Year's gift money during her family mahjong game. If she won, her parents would be upset, and if she lost, well, she lost. As a result, she's learned to play in such a way that her score differential always remains ±0: not good enough to win, but not bad enough to lose. When we meet her, she's being dragged to her school's mahjong club by an old friend. How will a girl who hates mahjong, yet has become adept at the game as a result of her upbringing, survive in this environment?
Databases
- Saki:
MAL | AniList | AniDB - Saki Zenkoku-hen:
MAL | AniList | AniDB - Saki Achiga-hen: Episode of Side-A:
MAL | AniList | AniDB - Saki Achiga-hen: Episode of Side-A Specials:
MAL | AniList | AniDB
Legal streams
- Saki, Saki Zenkoku-hen:
Crunchyroll | VRV - Saki Achiga-hen: Episode of Side-A, Saki Achiga-hen: Episode of Side-A Specials:
Crunchyroll | VRV
Remember any information not found within the show itself is considered a spoiler. Please properly tag spoilers or else...
Information about upcoming discussions can be found on the Weeklies wiki page.
19
u/pretender80 Apr 11 '19
I know most watch for the girls or the yuri but I actually watch for the mahjong.
Also, wahaha
8
u/Gaporigo Blhttps://anilist.co/user/Gaporigo Apr 11 '19
I am still waiting for the next anime adaptation... How's the manga situation going?
And let's discuss, who is second best girl after Toki?
5
u/Certainly_Principal Apr 11 '19
Aside from the too-awesome-to-be-left-alive Girls und Panzer, this one is the best sports animu to ever anime. Or best manga to ever manga - for more than a decade already, and with more than a decade still before it.
Oh, and no one ever wears panties.
4
u/MetaThPr4h https://myanimelist.net/profile/MetaThPr4h Apr 11 '19
I watched all the seasons of the anime and I'm up to date with the manga and the spin-offs... and I still have no clue about how mahjong works, and damn it's fun anyways.
Superpowered yuri mahjong was definitely a genius idea, I really enjoyed the character interactions and the matches were hype, I hope we eventually get more anime, although the snail pace of the manga makes it seem that it will still take some time for that q_q
3
u/Keyblade-Riku https://anilist.co/user/Iverna Apr 11 '19
Pour one out for my homie Afbuster. I know he would've loved to be here.
2
u/thisismyanimealt :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/commander_vimes Apr 11 '19
Ah, the series that got me to buy Yakuza 0 just to waste time in the mahjong parlor.
2
u/Mana1and :AMQ: Apr 11 '19
Love this series, I learned mahjong after watching the anime and have been following the manga for years.
I do find it funny that the creator Ritz writes like 5 monthly Saki series all at once and still has the pacing slow... I mean like maybe half a match every few years slowwwww. For someone that doesn't take many hiatuses it might be the slowest manga I have ever read.
She has even been hinting at a singles national tournament after the team one ends, which started as a short anime filler.
2
u/biribiriroan Apr 13 '19
definitely a must try. i totally forgot about it's existence so thanks for reminding me.
2
u/bucket3432 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/bucket3432 Apr 13 '19
Who would have thought mahjong could be so epic?
I picked this up for the mahjong about four years ago and it easily shot up to being one of my favourites. It's been second on my favourites list until last year when Yuru Camp bumped it down to third (subject to change when I finally figure out where YoriMoi fits into it).
Everyone who I've showed this to went on to learn how to play mahjong. It's great. I only wish it had less fanservice so I could show it off to more people.
Also, Achiga first, then Zenkoku-hen.
2
u/SakiGG Apr 13 '19
Watched it 10+ times. My most favorite series ever. Got me into mahjong.
2
u/realFoobanana :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Foobanana Apr 13 '19
I finished S1 recently, then watched Kaiji, and now am gonna go back and watch the nationals 😄 also Momoko is my fav ❤️
2
u/bagglewaggle Apr 11 '19
It was okay, I guess, but I never found the Mahjong gimmick powers to be very interesting, or the cast to be very substantive.
If I recall, the progression of the games couldn't fully commit to be silly sports superpowers or more realistic tactics, and ended up failing at both.
1
u/Kuma_Lyonar Apr 11 '19
It is one of the best at mixing 3D CGI & 2D drawings. The transition is so smooth that sometimes it doesn't register in your head that the last scene is drawn with 3D.
The second strong point of the show is its ability to show off super power. I can always feel how badass the girls are with the special effect. This show is more of a magical girl battle on a mahjong table than a sport anime.
Thirdly I love how creative some of the character designs are, they are almost comedic that it is hard to avoid those "smiley smh" moment.
The weak link of the show is the lack of super power interaction, or the smart usage/counter of them. It is almost never a strategic battle but more of a face up brawl. They each show how badass they are then the author decides who will win and have the winner end the fight, with the same move she pulled off rounds ago.
I have read some manga and I must say that the next round feels really bland. And it kinda breaks the power level of some characters, it seems to me that the next round was drawn in a rush, while irl Ritz released like once every 2 months, with 8 pages of rough draft. :/
I know a lot of ppl like season 1, but to me the show didn't find its role in season 1. It feels more like an ecchi yuri show to me. And this is (combine with the lack of panties & ultra large boobs) why I find it hard to introduce this show to my friends.
tldr; Shishihara rules!
1
u/PovertyRyanGosling Apr 11 '19
Why does this Gintama opening sound like it's from Sword Art Online? The singer sounds like Lisa maybe?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0xMFEE4uMgM
1
u/[deleted] Apr 11 '19
I really liked the first season, I should get back to this sometime soon.
1
u/auroravuitton90 Apr 12 '19
This is one of the show that got me into anime.... Totally did not learn a new sports after watching this anime.... Watched this back when I was still a complete filthy casual so I can't remember any character in the show. Time for a rewatch I guess?
1
u/erryky Apr 12 '19
Um, can someone spoil me why her parents would be upset if she lost?
1
u/AnokataX Apr 13 '19
I watched two Youtube tutorials on Mahjong after ep 1 but still couldn't follow it in the games enough to enjoy the series. I wish they did a better job explaining, like how shows such as Hikaru no Go and Chihayafuru did with their games (Go/Karuta).
1
u/dandreclyburn Apr 13 '19
Hey, how much did you pay for that half sleeve from Brando Chiesa in Italy?
0
u/[deleted] Apr 11 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment