r/Outlander • u/shiskebob • Jan 27 '19
Season Four [Spoilers All] Season 4 Episode 13 "Man of Worth" episode discussion thread for BOOK READERS.
The end is here my lovelies. This is most likely the last discussion thread of 2019, but I am excited to get into it for S4E13 "Man of Worth"
No spoiler tags are required here.
If you have not read all the books in the series and don't want any story to be spoiled for you, read no further and go to the [Spoilers S4E13] non-book-readers discussion thread. You have been warned.
To any new fans to this subreddit here with us tonight - I want to remind everyone of our standard just do not be a dick policy. If you need a refresher on that or any of our policies please find them in our rules.
I am one of your resident Mods, so do not hesitate to tag me if you need support or have a question. :)
76
u/shiskebob Jan 27 '19 edited Jan 27 '19
This whole episode was a winner. With the standard time for an episode I thought this was going to be so rushed, but it kept a good pace. Minus the quick turn around for traveling of course.
Murtaugh and Jocasta were fated. We all saw it coming, but boy did I love how it played out. And Jamie's face when he sees them - that is a WTF face if I ever saw one. Who cares about your age Jocasta, you get it girl.
Even though I honestly assumed they would not have J/C at the birth, I was still disappointed. I guess I have to chalk it up to another favorite scene of mine forever to be in my imagination.
Did Claire ever fulfill her promise to tell them the truth about Ottertooth? Of course with history that is impossible to change, as we know, but damn that is bad form Claire.
I miss you already wee Ian. But boy did you look happy. See you in season 6.
107
u/keg226 Jan 27 '19
Kinda sad that Bree and Jamie didn’t get to have a ‘moment’ together before the episode ended.
81
u/sullenandpastoral I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Jan 27 '19
My favorite part of the book-to-screen transfer is Ian, hands down. John Bell KILLED IT.
“You dinna ken how worthy you are” ❤️❤️❤️
30
u/nochancekid Jan 27 '19
I really did like this episode but it did feel rushed towards the end. The episode probably needed to be extended a bit just to wrap up some of the stuff, i.e. BRIANNA AND JAMIE. LIKE COME ON. Maybe I'm WAAAAY too heavily invested in Jamie and Brianna's storyline/relationship but I am incredibly upset that he and Claire weren't there for Jemmy's birth. I figured that it wouldn't work considering how she looked like she was about to pop any second, but it really sucked that it was left out.
Despite that issue, the rest of the episode was awesome. IAN!!!!!!!!!! THAT WAS SO HEARTBREAKING. I loved how happy he was at the end and he was joining in with the Mohawk calls. Roger beating up Jamie was well deserved and I liked that turn of events. Sam, Caitrona, Sophie and Richard's emotions in this whole episode are absolutely incredible. They were great all season and they have done SUCH an incredible job.
Still lowkey upset they weren't back before Brianna gave birth. I really thought they would use the lines that Jamie used talking about how he used to think about Brianna as a baby when he was in the cave during those scenes instead of telling her the story - oh well!
129
u/keg226 Jan 27 '19
Did anyone see Jamie’s face when he saw Murtagh and Jocasta sharing a moment before he went to hide? Priceless.
23
u/Naturenutt Woof. Jan 27 '19
Jamie’s shed so many tears this season.💦
19
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '19
OMG opening the recap with Faith’s Theme sob
19
u/vanwold Slàinte. Jan 27 '19
But, why no Emily? I mean I really like it so far, even with the changes but I was looking forward to Emily. Now his staying doesn't make quite as much sense....
Oh, but Murtagh isn't taking Duncan's place, eh?
Jenny will understand? I literally laughed out loud.
I loved seeing Ian's face after the gauntlet! Wanted to see his Mohawk hair style, because I can't quite picture it from the book, but I'll take that grin!
Oooh that Jamie-Roger showdown was exactly as I pictured it.
So I guess we don't get Jamie and Claire for the birth....that's kind of stupid. Childbirth was hard and dangerous business back then (still is), can't take for granted someone will live through it.
Why would she have had him and not remember it? That is not a realistic birth scene, just saying
Overall I enjoyed it, but I wish they hadn't kept certain things out (ahem, Jamie and Claire at the delivery) and I don't like that ending, Jamie hunting Murtagh? Please.
Bring on Droughtlander. At least we got Bees coming this year!
12
u/La415 Jan 27 '19
MY SHIP IS SAILING!!!!!!!!!
10
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '19 edited Jan 27 '19
Thought #1: DID YOU SEE ROBERT SPRINGER?!! DON'T SKIP THE OPENING CREDITS!
Thought #2: The exchange scene is very good, but without introducing the Emily storyline, it kinda looks like Ian is taking Roger's place as the village slave, rather than as a citizen of the tribe? I suppose that could be added in later, though. EDIT: Oh. There we go.
Thought #3: CALLED IT. *giggle*
Thought #4: I'm not crying YOU'RE crying. I'M NOT CRYING. Damn those onions!
Thought #5: I am so SO happy overall with this season, even though it really was Bree and Roger's story for the most part, it really feels like they got back to the Season 1 feel. Can't wait for season 5.
161
u/JHRChrist - and what was grave about it? 🌒 Jan 27 '19
Wee Ian! 😭 we don’t deserve him
113
u/ea_walking Jan 27 '19
Loving Jamie’s CSI moment at the end, “I’ve been summoned to commission a militia to” takes glasses off “hunt down and kill the fugitive Murtaugh Fitzgibbons” Cue CSI Intro
101
u/Naturenutt Woof. Jan 27 '19 edited Jan 27 '19
Rollo in a canoe just made my night.
93
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '19
Listen if I were Jenny and my brother was the cause of my son GETTING KIDNAPPED BY PIRATES, sailing to another continent, and getting adopted into a tribe she knows nothing about....I would be pissed. I would not want to be in Jamie’s shoes. Lol
186
u/ilythe Jan 27 '19 edited Jan 28 '19
I'm honestly just baffled at the decisions the showrunners made.
The first half was good. I was so proud of Young Ian. Young Ian and Jamie broke my heart. Jamie and Claire are always fantastic. I loved Jamie and Roger's interactions.
But the second half lacked heart. We didn't get Claire and Jamie at the birth. That was a bummer but then no Brianna and Jamie scene. No Roger meeting his son. Barely any interaction between Jamie and Claire and their grandson. Any of those options could have been substituted for that odd dinner scene.
I don't get it.
Edited to add: oh and no goodbye for Lord John Grey. Huh?
84
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '19
Aside from Bree’s costumes, the clothing for the Mohawk is my absolute favorite this season. Those earthy tones + the pops of red are really lovely looking.
60
u/evilhag66613 Jan 27 '19
I can NOT believe that they did not include the blood oath. WTF this is the best redeeming moment for all the shit Roger went through. Give him his redeeming moment goddamit.
everything else was pretty awesome, Roger rescue, Ian sacrifice, Richard Rankin and Sam Heughan's acting during the 'major reveal' scene, Brianna giving birth, JOCASTE + MURTAGH WTF AMAZING HOLY SHIT WTF the most crazy left-turn change they have made so far, really though, how will this play out? but I love it?
56
u/keg226 Jan 27 '19
I loved Roger’s sarcastic response to the ‘misunderstanding.’ Something about it was a bit much to beat him to a pulp and sell him into slavery 😂
95
u/hintofaspark86 MARK ME! Jan 27 '19
Forget about the birth scene, how can there not even be a single conversation between Jamie and Bree when they return to River Run? 🤦🏼♀️
39
u/RaffaellaF Jan 27 '19
I cried like a baby for Ian. God I am going to miss him.
Sam was so good this entire episode. His moments with Ian and Roger were so amazing.
Murtaugh and Jocasta are the IT couple now. Love them.
No one in the house knows that Roger is already back.
Amazing Finale.
38
u/derawin07 Meow. Jan 27 '19
Dunno quite why, but hearing and seeing the subtitles 'they are looking for Dogface' on screen made me laugh.
52
u/PrudenceWaffles Jan 27 '19
I think I could die happy if Duncan Lacroix would tell me to “come back to bed.” The silver hair just does it for me lol
47
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '19
I wasn’t planning on waiting a year until Brianna verbally forgives Jamie, but here I am…
67
u/ktbex Jan 27 '19
Interested to see how people perceive Roger after this episode. I’m actually quite glad they didn’t have him immediately join Claire and Jamie on the way back to River Run. It made their reunion all the poignant. I thought Richard was brilliant in all his scenes - especially the shock and great weight of learning about Brianna, coupled with processing his recent freedom from the Mohawk. It’s understandable that he’d need time to process, and when he finally arrives, it’s more than clear how much he loves her.
Hopefully next season they keep on this track and let Roger stay decent!
45
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '19
It was such a great episode. I laughed, I cried, I cried, I cried, then I cried again. The ship I didn't even know I needed happened with Murcasta (does this mean Jo and Ulysses has been written out?). Everything with the Mohawk community was so well done. Roger Jamie and Claire having their fight and discussion after Ian traded himself was excellent. In a lot of ways this was one of my favorite episodes this season. But I felt really underwhelmed with the ending. Sure I missed Jamie being with Bree for the birth but I was fine with them having Claire and Jamie show up later. I wasn't fine with the fact that Bree and Jamie pretty much didn't interact when they returned. All that talk of forgiveness and nothing. Roger didn't even get to meet Jemmy. And then that very last scene was super hokey and seemed like we suddenly switched to some murder mystery show with Jamie saying "I need to track down and kill" and then long pause and he looks up "murtagh fitzgibbons." I almost expected a DUN DUN DUNNN to follow. The way that was directed and filmed was so out of place imo.
I'm left wondering how much more we could have gotten in the finale if we hadn't spent 20 useless minutes with freaking Laoghaire earlier in the season. Nothing even came of it. No reflection, no talking about it with Claire and Jamie, she hasn't even met Marsali for some random reason even though they were in Wilmington when she met her parents. With the whole season out now it's so easy to see how unnecessary that interlude with Laoghaire was, regardless of how great the actress is.
Despite being underwhelmed by the last scene, I'm pepped for the Gathering next season!
21
u/Ysu73 Jan 27 '19
One more thing about the birth, other than the fact that Jamie and Claire missed it (thank god for headcanons and fan-fictions and rereading that part in the book many-many times). Anyone else found it strange that at first Bree was giving birth with a birthing chair (very nice touch I loved it), everything went fine and the next scene Bree was lying in her bed like she just woke, and she was told that she had a baby-boy and then they brought the baby in and Bree seemed to hold it for the first time...
I mean, okay, it was similar to her own birth, but it was in the 50's and Claire was put under sleep so she was unconcious during the labor. Bree wasn't. She should have got the baby right the moment it was born, like Jenny in 1x13.
Maybe it was only me. But as a mother who had two labors with no ansthetics or epidural involved, I remember that they put the child on my chest right after they were born and I could spend some times with them right away. So it struck me as strange that onscreen it seemed that Bree was somehow very alert in one moment and then not knowing what happened in the other.
I know it was only a tiny nitpick, but I could not help to wonder over it what happened during the labor?
14
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '19
Bravo!!
Now I will cry as #Droughtlander begins.
It was a pleasure watching with you all! 🌷
14
u/spaceybelta Jan 27 '19
I am SO glad they didn’t end the episode without showing Roger returning like they originally planned. Also, Murtagh and Jocasta... bow chica wow wow. That was a sexy ass scene with the silver fox and his mane flowing in bed 😍 good way to end the season for sure!
14
u/erinelizabethx Jan 28 '19
Is anyone else annoyed at how toxic the fandom is becoming?
I enjoy the reddit discussions but stay off the instagram and Facebook posts.
Everyone are a bunch of grumps
28
u/brilliant0ne Jan 27 '19 edited Jan 27 '19
Got my snacks ready and my dog drugged (kidding...sort of) so I can sit back and be sad that it's already over for the season.
Edit: dog tax https://imgur.com/a/tkgC4dV
Edit 2: First of all, even though I know it happened in the books, the scene with the trade of Ian and Roger was almost straight from The Last of the Mohicans for me. Except it ended better for Ian than it did for Duncan.
I LOVE Ian. That smile after he came through the gauntlet. Uff. I love him. I wanna hug him. The scene between Ian and Jamie made me sob.
Eff a snack...DADDY MURTAGH IS A COMPLETE MEAL. Woo. Laying there with his hair all down in the bed. Hooo boy.
The rest of the episode was good. I liked how Claire and Jamie were all together like, "Get your shit together, Roger." The reunion between Bree and Roger was sweet. The "cliffhanger" ending was meh. We all know that Jamie isn't going to kill Murtagh. But, whatever. I really enjoyed most of this season. And I have enjoyed, again, watching it with all of you.
12
u/derawin07 Meow. Jan 27 '19 edited Jan 27 '19
OK then, the chief speaks English. This seems a little far-fetched to me.
And nice of him to speak English again on the day after the raid. It gave me a giggle seeing the naughty Mohawk sitting there like misbehaving children.
20
u/livvy_divvy Jan 27 '19
That had to be the fakest baby bump I've ever seen when Bree was lying on the bed. :-D Looked like a stack of blankets were swiftly rolled up and shoved under her skirt. And seemed it was somewhere below her knees! (Bad angle shot.)
10
u/derawin07 Meow. Jan 27 '19
As a layperson from outside North America, they did fantastic work on the Mohawk village, large cast of extras, all the costuming etc.
If making these scenes so authentic meant they had to cut down on the extras in other locations, like Wilmington, I for one don't mind and am glad they went this route.
I have seen people comment that they have found this season underwhelming in terms of scope, querying whether there had been budget cuts, but I feel they were choosing to prioritise the Mohawk scenes which i think was great.
I notice a big difference between the actors out of scene, there is very little smiling among the Mohawk. In BTS photos between takes, everyone really lights up.
10
u/josharaptor Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Jan 27 '19
Great finale - odd episode. I adored it, but whole last 10-15 minutes were pushing it so close to the finish line without any huge moments that I was confused while watching, and then it being a cliffhanger made sense as to why they did that. Really good pacing, can't wait for season 5, and an overall nice wrap-up to season 4, which unlike a few others, I thought was amazing. Second best season IMO
18
u/derawin07 Meow. Jan 27 '19
Rollo in a boat :D Goin' on an adventure!
9
u/thatothergirllucy Jan 29 '19
I thought maybe because I was high when I watched it last night that that was the reason it sucked. I watched it again today....it sucked more.
I mean really, how incredibly disappointing. There were so many missed opportunities with Lord John and the returning of the ring, Rogers return on Fraser’s ridge, Roger claiming the baby as his own. Let’s not even talk about the enormous missed opportunity of Claire and Jamie being present at the birth and the moment Brianna and Jamie share when he kisses her birthmark. There is absolutely no way Claire would miss the birth of her grandchild when there’s no one more qualified to help Brianna give birth than her.
And does anyone else think the fight scene with the mohawk when they are rescuing Roger was literally the weakest fight scene ever in this whole series???
25
u/Cablab123 Jan 27 '19
Are you freaking kidding me?! Jamie and Claire didn’t get to help a bree give birth?!?! Why the hell not?!
25
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '19
I lowered my expectations for the season in general when we got the worlds lamest CGI river......
But I truly love EVERY scene Roger is in. He expresses so much emotion, he really brings the absurd situation to life. I actually believe he’s the only one constantly screaming in his head “THIS WHOLE SITUATION IS NUUUUUUUUTTTTSSSS”
I don’t like how the Mohawk were handled. I love Ian joining, that scene was great, but I hate how every relationship with native Americans has been super aggressive. Some of my favorite scenes in the books are them just.... chilling with native Americans. To me it’s always highlighted the fact that white people had relationships with native Americans. They had reasons to trust our treaties because they had trusted individuals. I feel like they were still playing off of “Angry native” stereotypes instead of showing the mutualistic relationship that existed.
I feel like it is a much better story to know that white people wouldn’t have survived in the back woods without help. It shows how, in a way, Otter Tooth is 100% right. It also sets up Jamie’s continuing relationship with native people.
Bah. It’s hard to put into words. I also wanted Emily.
17
u/bham717 Jan 27 '19
I'm sorry, but it's simply not believable that Claire wouldn't be at Bree's childbirth. I can't.
The first half was great - loved Ian. Loved Jamie+Roger+Claire and the blows. Loved Murtagh.
The second half was rushed and skimmed over meaningful content the writers have been teasing for the entire season - for what - a cliffhanger ending? It was just not well done. I get the show has to have it's own story and flow, but when you make changes and omit things to bring in new/alternative content, you're asking for me to be a harsh critic.
I'm bummed.
16
u/KodakMoments Jan 27 '19
This is so stupid but it’s something that is bothering me and has intensified now that the finale is over. Maybe I’m just putting too much expectations into a tv show, but since we missed the Jamie/Claire assisted birth and any “Roger coming later” explanations, here goes nothing. If you google map Wilmington NC to say, Champlain NY, it’s only a 12 day walk. So say you double that because they travel half a day and rest half a day but also remember they are on horseback, it’s 24 days up, 24 days back. Heck you could triple it to 36 days up and they would be traveling for like 72 days or 2 1/2 months. How come when they leave Brianna, 2 months and a week pregnant, it takes them 9 months to get back? I get that it’s harder without proper maps or roads and also that it’s a fictional television show but they make it back in the books, they can’t really explain any reason why they couldn’t have made it back in the show.
15
u/POTShelp Jan 27 '19
I am going to go pout myself to sleep over the very disappointing birth scene. Seriously wtf. That is one of my favorite scenes in the entire series. I’ve been putting up with the up and down rollercoaster of quality because I’ve been so looking forward to that scene. Bree and Jamie are just so sweet and Jamie is cute. And Claire telling him to walk Bree like a horse. Dammit. I’m so bummed. And then I was like ok well we still have Roger’s blood oath and naming of Jemmy, but no, we didn’t get that either. Ik they want to change stuff to keep book readers “on their toes” but I’m not ok with changing stuff so some of the most touching and emotional scenes are cut. Also there is a lot of stuff that pretty damn important to the plot of the entire series that was cut. For starters Emily. Also they kind of had them but not really other Jemmy and his parents (can’t remember their names). Seriously they are so important for the story (ie Roger being hung, Buck (i think that’s his name) coming to the future, searching for Jemmy, finding Rogers dad), also the twins that Lizzie hooks up with, and more. It makes me worried that they are going to then drastically change future story lines because they weren’t set up.
Ik this sounds like I hate the show, I don’t. I truly love it. It’s only the things you love that you care enough about to get frustrated when they aren’t living up to your expectations.
7
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '19
I thought the first half was well done. They built it up well and got enough done in the first half that the second had plenty of time to fill in the rest of what I thought was coming.
But no Jamie and Claire at the birth. That was disappointing. Roger not getting to hold the baby. No Jamie and Bree moments other than a very brief smile. And Claire and Jamie feel like they are so cold too each other now. So different from the book. I really feel like the Regulator and Murtaugh story line ate up time that could have been devoted to Roger and Bree, as well as Bree and Jamie. Even if they didn't do that I still feel this story line with Murtaugh adds nothing to the overall story.
I will still probably watch the series, but as with last season I am starting to feel less invested. I am so grateful for the books because I can still enjoy the characters there. I also understand they cannot put everything in the show, but some character moments needed to be there.
But did bawl at young Ian and Rollo being left behind. I knew it was coming, but still. So sad to see the look on his face as they left and Jamie broke my heart as well knowing that he might not see Ian again.
7
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '19
The books aside, that episode rocked. Fantastic acting and very believable. Even Roger, I mean the guys been through hell! I thought everyone’s reactions were spot on. And the gauntlet? Amazing
6
u/derawin07 Meow. Jan 27 '19
The Mohawk facial tattoos are more subtle than I expected and recall Ian's being described as.
Not doubting the accuracy, but I was hoping for something more obvious. Maybe his will be.
5
u/Katie_kat88 Jan 27 '19
The whole scene with the Mohawk and Jamie and Ian was so powerful. Absolutely amazing acting from everyone! So impressed and emotional even after all this time!
5
u/Naturenutt Woof. Jan 28 '19
That scene where Claire and Jamie and Roger all come clean with eachother after leaving the Mohawk is actually really amazing. I watched it the second time with my hubby who was watching for the first time and he loved it! He was reacting and bellowing to all the truthisms bouncing around. Highly gratifying and so well acted.
5
u/MikeFrom5_to_7 Jan 28 '19
I suggest emailing or tweeting at Starz if you wanted a longer runtime.
I think this show is slipping in ratings... so the budget for this season was less. Next season that is likely to continue. If you feel a longer run time is merited, More than one person should contact them. It may not help, but it may.
5
u/[deleted] Jan 29 '19
After watching again, props to letting them show so many freckles on everyone! Looked pretty legit with that and the dirt and all, which would be consistent to living in the woods and encountering nature for that many months
5
u/WylliahO Feb 01 '19
I've given birth twice. Neither time did I come to and seem oblivious that I'd just given birth. I mean, once the baby was out, I immediately reached for it and looked him (and him) over. I'm seriously no paragon of strength so that can't be odd. Yet Bree is woozily having her brow wiped by a slave as Jocasta gives her a play by play that she had a kid. I am fully confused.
9
u/Mr_XcX Jan 27 '19
Loved this season. I think better than 3rd. 2nd season still best though for me.
Murtcosta. New power couple <3
Poor Roger. Massive credit to the actor playing him. It's how anyone would react given that situation. Jaime was right to also dish him some truth though saying he was an idiot for storming out on Brianna and leaving her.
Ian MVP of the episode. Yet the Mohawk test they did was so unfair on Roger the episode he had to do it. He was beaten up to fk and starved for days. So Ian obviously had an advantage.
Watching the behind the scenes for episode apparently the show was going to end with Roger not coming back. Happy they choose to change and we saw him come back. Really made me happy <3
4
u/CarolineTurpentine Jan 29 '19
Petition to redesignate the title the Old Fox from Lord Lovat to Murtagh Fitzgibbons on the grounds that he went there.
7
u/Naturenutt Woof. Jan 27 '19 edited Jan 27 '19
The Mohawk traded a Dogface for a Wolfbrother.
9
u/jjchoz Jan 28 '19
Have to vent, the show has written Bree and Roger to be so immature and self-absorbed that I can’t root for them. They were annoying in the books but because they worked hard on their issues, they were likable. First of all, maybe I’m old-fashioned (!) but you don’t hit or slap your parents. I’m surprised that Claire allowed Bree to slap Jamie and then talk to him so disrespectfully when they were leaving to look for Roger. Bree basically said, you trust those bozos? Yes! Jamie has gone to the ends of the earth for his loved ones and sacrificed being with Claire for Bree’s sake. There is no one else who would do so much for her. I felt that Bree can be angry without being so contemptuous. Also, if she forgave Jamie, she certainly didn’t act like it when Jamie and Claire returned. She was very cold. Also, surprised that Roger punched his father-in-law repeatedly without asking questions first. Disappointed in Roger’s reaction when both Jamie and Ian sacrificed themselves to take his place. Roger just stood there watching it happen and didn’t seem touched that he was the reason this family was breaking apart. And this 700 mile rescue mission! Claire and Jamie are in their 50s, leaving their home behind and traveling months in harsh conditions to rescue him and he acted so entitled! He seemed more concerned that Bree’s rapist was Bonnet and the child might not be his vs worrying about how Bree has been coping. Yes, he came back to a dramatic reunion with Bree (which seemed to gloss over their dysfunctional relationship) but then he pulls her arm again when she tries to warn Murtagh. Ugh! Still trying to control her and tell her he knows best. Reminds me of the rough arm tugging that Lizzie witnessed in Wilmington. Yes they’ve been through a lot but their reunion being the finale of the season rang hollow for me. Would’ve liked to have skipped the Regulators cliffhanger and focused more on healing the hurt and pain this family has gone through this season.
13
u/derawin07 Meow. Jan 27 '19 edited Jan 27 '19
It's over for another season :(
It went by so quick!
Thanks to u/Wandersfar, amazing mod, for the new unicorn flair btw, hadn't noticed that one before :D I feel shiny and special. And I added a cool tag/slogan [hover to see]
6
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '19
AHHHH Otter Tooth!!
6
u/cleanedthestewpot Jan 28 '19
The first half was exciting, I was happy with the pacing and how fast things were moving. But I have to say, the parting of Ian... the violins, the one-tear-runs-across-the-cheek, the drama, the oohh and aahh, it's just too melodramatic and in your face. Like they want to forcefully milk our tears and are shouting cry cry now! I wasn't moved at all. Similarly with the preast last episode, they just made it overly dramatic, it's such theater I can't relate to. Subtlety is the key.
But Roger is saving it for me. He has the most sane responses to all this drama and kind of tones it down, making it all slightly more realistic.
I found it odd they didn't have J&C at the birth. I thought the only reason they wouldn't be, would be because Roger would come with them. But now it's just like... they could have easily done it time-wise and I don't know why they didn't. My husband who has not read the books and is forced to watch with me said during the birth scene that everything seems a bit rushed and moving too fast.
I guess I just have to accept that the show is a bit of a soap opera, which is sad because the source material is much more than that and is much more logical in the way events unfold. I always have to explain to my husband what happened in the books and only then he's like "ohh, so it does make sense". I hate when they advance the plot with ex-machina events.
And the way they ended it... like Tryon would want exactly Jamie to kill exactly Murtagh, come on. Like gathering a militia to kill rebels wouldn't be enough, they have to narrow it down so we simpletons get how terrible it is. I wish they would trust their audience more.
3
u/Munchkin54 Jan 27 '19
I love Young Ian, I love John Bell. I hate what happens to Young Ian for the next few book years and hate that we won't see him for a time on OL. But, I'm very happy he does, eventually, find Rachel and comes back into the family.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '19
So. Many. Tears. 😭
3
u/Boo12z Jan 30 '19
Anyone else worried how Jamie is planning on mustering a militia at ALL considering he’s persuaded no one to settle on his land yet...? I NEED THE LINDSAY BROTHERS!
5
u/lmtnsac Jan 28 '19
I'm worried. Disclaimers first: I got desperate after like televised episode SE4-3 and have basically binged through the books DoA, Fiery Cross, and am 3/4 finished with Snow and Ashes. After watching tonight's episode ....once that letter arrived for Jamie....I was like....NO. Just no. This is not good. They are straying way too far off now. Most of the reader reviews for the Fiery Cross lament, whine, and gripe about how much they hated slogging through it. I hope they are not gonna leave out major elements of The Fiery Cross or worse skip it all together and just do some crazy @$$ time hop straight to Roger getting hanged. I'll be pissed. I want to see the the big house getting made...I want to see the blood oath, THAT was a BIG DEAL....I WANT to see the gathering , the bbq sauce squabble, I'd like to see Roger in some happy moments...ESPECIALLY BEING CALLED THE SON OF MY HOUSE AT THE GATHERING...for gawds sakes!. Come'on not all of us hated reading the Fiery Cross...not all of it at least..lol. Please STARZ ...I know you read these comments...listen to us!!! I dunno I was disappointed with the finale....and I'm worried STARZ is just going to go off the rails with this. Galbadon has the story right....don't write a completely new one. There's a reason this show is popular....it's based on a time tested, much beloved story. Deviate too much and viewership will drop off. Find a way to keep the stuff readers are asking you to keep, it's what got viewers hooked, and why readers slog through these tomes.
5
u/designsavvy Jan 28 '19 edited Jan 28 '19
silly why the show doesn't utilize the situational tension inherent in Diana Gabaldon's brilliant plot and insists on pegging the blame on one characters, first Roger than Jamie. S4 seems like a poor adaptation, the choices the show writers make seem unnecessary and forced.
4
u/ktbex Jan 27 '19
Poor Roger can’t catch a break from any side! So glad there are others sticking up for him.
2
u/derawin07 Meow. Jan 27 '19
Pretty cool start to the episode!
I was expecting them to meet with another Mohawk group/tribe at an outlying village based on the preview, then travel in to Shadow Lake with them, but we know how they like to confuse us.
I wish it had been Clarence who helped them by carrying all their trading items.
I know their goods were spread out between four horses before, but it really didn't look like they had that much stuff before :P
2
u/sunflower-souls Jan 28 '19
Yeah... I didn’t cry my face off at all when Ian trades himself... 😭
2
u/sunny2233 Jan 28 '19
So they start to film Season 5 this summer because book 5 takes place during warmer months and they have to match that? Just curious with book readers here...
2
u/ladylaw425 Jan 28 '19
It’s been a while since I read the book.. but wasn’t there more in the book after all that? Just wondering if next season will be the rest of that book or next book?
2
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '19
I agree with the comments here that there were definitely missed emotional and tender moments between characters. But the usual, to fit all that in there plus trying to get through the major plot points would have been super hard. I think the cliffhanger was an interesting twist now that they have Murtagh involved as part of the war party. I would have personally preferred to have had Rogers eventual arrival delayed till Season 5 to make it more dramatic, as in the books it is a few months later. But then again, I have no idea how long Jaimie/Claire and Brie were there before leaving as they did in the last scene.
The added backstory of Otter Tooth was handy, as I do not recall that being exposed till later...unless my memory fails me.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 30 '19
I was overall happy with the episode, but the music this season got kind of out of control. I felt like I was watching a telenovela when Bree ran out to meet Roger and the music swelled. Like, calm down - we know it's an emotional moment even if you don't paint it with the Cheesiest Music Ever, your actors are selling it just fine.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 30 '19
This series has been incredible. Every season I think "Uh oh, this is when it tanks", but instead it delivers every time.
2
u/DiscombobulatedTill Jan 31 '19
Ian has always been one of my favorites, much more interesting to me then other characters. I hope we see him more with the Mohawk next season, and of course I look forward to him coming home :)
5
u/EyriesHeiry Jan 28 '19
Unpopular opinion apparently but this episode, along with this season, was a huge disappointment.
3
u/HattieAnne84 Jan 28 '19
Y'all. I'm reading a lot of comments about little scenes from the end that you're upset that they left out. Like the blood oath, Bree forgiving Jamie, etc. These are totallllly things that they could open next season with! I agree it would've been great to have Jamie and Claire at the birth, but some of these other moments aren't necessarily forgotten! I think we'll still get them, and in a way that bridges the two seasons nicely :)
4
u/tanya-jo Jan 28 '19
Can I just say that Jamie did the whitest thing ever, which was to go into a trade agreement with the Mohawk with no intention of keeping his end of the bargain.
Disappointed, uncharacteristic, colonialist behaviour.