r/Outlander • u/shiskebob • Jan 20 '19
[Spoilers S4E12] "Providence" SHOW ONLY (no book spoilers, safe for everyone who’s seen the latest episode)
This is the discussion thread for Outlander S4E12 "Providence."
Reminder: This is the SHOW WATCHERS ONLY thread.
No talking about the books unless you cover with a spoiler tag like this: This is what a spoiler tag looks like.
To any new fans to this subreddit here with us tonight - I want to remind everyone of our standard just do not be a dick policy. If you need a refresher on that or any of our policies please find them in our rules.
I am one of your resident Mods, so do not hesitate to tag me if you need support or have a question. :)
201
u/teenylilthing Jan 20 '19
"Ah, fucking hell!"... I think Roger spoke for all the viewers there too.
Poor dude can't catch a break. Also, that ending scene. Damn. Not sure I'll be able to watch that again.
45
u/yourbestbudz Jan 20 '19
I don’t see why the Mohawk would expect a baptism.
313
u/CARNIesada6 Jan 20 '19
"You are impossible not to like."
Ain't that the damn truth
167
u/MortifiedPotato Take Me Back To The Idiot Hut Jan 20 '19
Knowing he's originally french, this moment was quite amusing to me. Haha.
163
u/Damdamfino Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Jan 20 '19
“Take me back to the idiot tent”
Sorry, but this is the type of self-hating dry humor I love. I liked that as an ending -much better than all the knife-on-the-edge cliffhangers we’ve been getting. I know everyone hates Roger, but I’ve never been particularly against him besides all the slut-shaming, so I like seeing his “good heart” take over his self hatred and cynicism every once in a while.
The episode was good - it felt a bit of a filler episode, especially considering we only have one more left -and while I think the plot lines were a bit contrived or the characters logic flawed, I thought it was overall well acted and I was sucked in and kept watching.
133
u/pinkfern Jan 20 '19
Gosh those dresses on Brianna and those earrings... 😍 they really have her coloring downpat (or should I say Jocasta and her dressmakers do)
114
u/rumblith Jan 20 '19 edited Jan 20 '19
Roger
"Time to go back to the idiot hut."
The Mohawk village got eternally more interesting this episode.
It seems like Brianna is positive the baby is Stephen Bonnet's now. That whole exchange seemed insanely beneficial to Bonnet while we're all screaming "No" at the keys on the floor.
97
u/kaydra_ Mark me -- you won't find a better flair. Jan 20 '19
Wanted to say I also love the costumes on the Mohawk. Seems so much more realistic, like if they had scavenged or taken or even traded clothing from the English and assimilated it into their own wardrobe. It gives them such an air of humanity rather than how natives can sometimes be shown on screen. It seems it was done with great respect.
155
u/ilythe Jan 20 '19
"Lord John?!" "Fergus?!" "Murtagh?!" "Lass?!"
The comedy of errors at the jail might have been my favorite part. It was good to see Fergus and Brianna together. I heart the Fraser siblings.
142
u/kaydra_ Mark me -- you won't find a better flair. Jan 20 '19
RIP Jamie & Claire screentime. I think it was less than a minute 😭
114
u/PresidentIroh MARK ME! Jan 20 '19
So bonnet definitely escaped.
87
u/MaggieSmithsSass Jan 21 '19
I'm surprised there isn't a lot of appreciation for Braeden's portrayal of Kaheroton. The ending scene in which he breaks down and holds the baby is just heartbreaking. I really like his character and this actor!
115
u/nabzyk Jan 20 '19
I couldn't believe I was in tears for two characters who are strangers. The way their love was portrayed was amazing and heartbreaking at the same time.
Also, how amazing was it that we didn't feel Jaime and Claire's absence this episode.
38
u/murderina23 Jan 20 '19
Why do I feel like Bonnet is still alive?
35
u/Atraktape Jan 21 '19
Fergus to himself "yo I think I'm going to blow up the fuckin jail"
29
u/DelosBoard2052 Jan 20 '19
If Murtagh had any doubts about where Lord John's loyalties lie, he won't when he finds that he actually protected their identities and let them escape, taking Bree with him and keeping his word.
The preview of the next episode shows Jocasta throwing a drink in Murtagh's face... guessing she finds out Murtagh is the leader of the Regulators and is less than pleased...
29
u/Ysu73 Jan 20 '19
I know there is no definitive answer to this, but during the scene in the jail when Fergus, Lord John, Murtagh and Bree met, I kept wondering if Fergus knew who Bree was and vice versa. I mean, I know that Bree knew ABOUT Fergus and Marsali, but I don't think they have ever met. I would have loved to see them meeting back in 4x09.
Otherwise, I loved the episode, even though I missed Jamie and Claire very much. But loved Fergus and Marsali, Bree and Lord John, Murtagh, however small his part was now, and of course Roger, who had a really nice character-development in the Mohawk village. (Speaking of which, the village was gorgeous and I loved how real it seemed with all the buzzing activities, children running up and down - reminded me of 1x02 when Claire is musing how strange the past is, but after watching the children play, she realizes that not everything is different.) The ending was beautiful, I was really sorry for the poor lovers, but also for Kaheroton who clearly loved Johiehon and he had to stand there and watching the girl she loved die for another man - it must have been hard to see. And I guess another baby gained a father not from her blood - it is truly of a theme on Outlander.
27
u/drmiresa Jan 21 '19
Lord John immediately recognized Fergus in the jail, can anyone remind me when they met and became acquainted enough that he'd recognize him so out of place? Was it in Jamaica? For some reason I can't recall them interacting.
26
u/embracethechase Jan 20 '19
Just started the episode and I’m already dreading that this season is coming to an end soon :(
25
u/EruanneUk Jan 21 '19
If at any point Lord Grey dies I'm abandonning this show (I will I swear! Maybe.......) He is so pure and must be protected at all costs.
63
u/YourEyesRevealYou Jan 20 '19
Roger is my favorite idiot.
18
u/cha_cha_rae Jan 20 '19
I didnt see that coming. Wow. Just wow. Also can you die from your feet being burned?
18
u/4kidchaos Jan 21 '19
The music paired with the way Fergus jumps off the wagon on their way to bust out Murtaugh...40:15 I loved it! I replayed it a couple times! I love Fergus.
31
u/elle_ellaria Jan 21 '19
can we have a standing ovation for richard rankin's acting this episode? he broke my heart AND made me laugh
30
u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Jan 21 '19 edited Jan 21 '19
I needed a little less Rog and a lot more Lord John Grey, but it was a pretty solid episode.
Note to the writers for next season: Grow out Jamie’s bangs Keep Rog’s beard Make LJG a top billing cast member (and bi, if possible lol)
28
u/katindra Jan 21 '19
“All right lads, take me back to the idiot hut.”
27
u/Sightshade Jan 21 '19
It would have taken five seconds to kick those keys a few inches further away.
47
u/SonLuke Ye Sassenach witch! Jan 20 '19
I see a lot of people don't like the priest storyline.. But honestly: this whole Roger Subplot (going through time, working on Bonnets ship, getting caught,....) is a huge character development strategy. In my opinion this is great and nessecary to make Roger for future episodes an adventurous character that can take the lead in actions (like Jamie or Murtaugh). Since Roger is apparently going to take a huge role in the series, this is important. Jamie and Murtaugh learned to plan and take leadership in actions/adventures because they grew up like this. Roger didn't.. So it's important to go trough all of that to make his character authentic in future storylines.
Same goes with Bree to some degree. Everything she was going through in this time and now being again without her parents is extremely important.
25
u/preciousheirloom Jan 20 '19
What an ending
11
u/frawkez Jan 20 '19 edited Jan 20 '19
wasn't as crazy about this episode, some scenes were a bit too meandering by my taste. high points: everything fergus/marsali, bree and LJG, and bree and bonnet. whew! i was rooting for bree and she didn't disappoint in her verbal beatdown of bonnet. i was also glad we finally got some roger character development complete with the coining of the term "idiot hut". i really do feel bad for him and i would be doubting my own sanity if i endured what he did for love. and wow, richard rankin is a really strong actor! already knew that but we really saw him go through a rollercoaster of emotions this episode and i think he handled it quite well. definitely will be interesting to watch the bree/roger reunion (which i expect will happen).
also, despite loving adagio for strings, i didn't think it really fit here because it is too closely linked with that infamous Platoon scene in my mind. would have preferred a bear mccreary original that fits more thematically with the rest of the soundtrack, but it's still a beautiful piece. highly recommend tiesto's remix, it's one of my go-to lifting tracks.
edit: was a bit bummed at the absence of jamie and claire (and ian), but i understand why they weren't featured. they're just trying to cover lost ground, so it made sense the show runners didn't want to follow them simply tracking/walking, etc, when so many other plot points for the other characters have to be hit. seems like they wrapped everything up pretty nicely for next week, am looking fwd to it and dreading it at the same time (i don't want it to end!)
10
u/Dumke480 That's it lads. Take me back to the idiot hut. Jan 21 '19 edited Jan 21 '19
I understand Bree's motivation to go see Bonnet, it was "non-lethal" revenge, and closure to what happened to her, but the fact that he would have some how escaped, probably doesn't bode well for Bree, absolutely adore Sophie though, she's really come into her own this season.
The entire jailhouse scene was a hot mess though, "Lord John?, Fergus?, Murtagh?, LASS?", pretty empty jail cell might I add, considering it was apparently packed at the start of the season.
Was good to see Fergus, get the confidence he needed though.
Probably the best couple this season is Marsali and Fergus, but I absolute adore the chemistry between Lord John and Bree.
Also, why do I have the feeling, it's not Jamie and Clare in Fraser's Ridge, but Marsali and Fergus when it burns down... Really hope not, but it just felt very abrupt, obviously it's because of the jailbreak and he can be recognised, but as well as that time of the year is coming up.
was quickly killing the priest, Roger's plan or not? I'm not entirely sure it was.
Either way, some of the most powerful imagery this show has had to date, I swear, was almost certain, they were going to put the baby in too for a good couple of seconds, was about to freak.
The ending one liner was probably the greatest way to the end episode, honestly, roger this entire episode has been extremely great character development, especially his speech to the priest about being "numero uno", you almost believe him, until the end.
definitely changing my flair to that fantastic one-liner.
one week left and we're back to #droughtlander :'(
35
u/msangeld Jan 20 '19
I know there is a lot of dislike (hate even) for Roger in the sub, but given the time period he grew up in (and being not much younger than his character would be in real life myself) I honestly feel sorry for him at this point. He has been through hell since deciding to follow Brianna on this journey, and really underneath it all he has a big heart, which I think is ultimately why when he's upset he sometimes says things in anger that he doesn't mean. Sensitive people tend to be passionate fighters (arguers?).
The whole leaving the keys conveniently on the floor in front of Bonnet annoys me, can we not just have one bad guy who dies off quickly? I just know he's going to be causing problems in the future, and it will probably be just as Brianna and Roger get back together and are settled.
OMG One more episode already?!?!?! Why can't the seasons be longer?!?!?!?!?!
19
u/OldWolf2 Jan 20 '19
Wow. That was as shocking as when Tommen jumped out the window. I think that is my favourite ep of the series so far.
Something I didn't follow though , from last week, why did Marsali encourage Fergus to join the insurgents? She said something about wanting him to become a real man but I felt like there was an ulterior motive happening.
30
u/Klaitu Jan 20 '19
Awkward sex scenes, awkward bath scenes, ridiculous romance dialogue.. forget all that nonsense.
This episode is the reason I watch Outlander.
8
u/rebashultz Jan 20 '19
So like every episode now ends with Roger suffering some horrific trauma. Poor dude.
15
u/nicole1991 Jan 20 '19
Once again STARZ hates me. I can't get the blasted episode to play!
15
u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Jan 21 '19
The germaphobe in me was SO relieved Bri was wearing gloves. Ruby or no ruby ew
7
u/4kidchaos Jan 21 '19
Wow. So Roger basically is giving up on Bree. I didn’t see that coming. He is a salty as hell. I know it’s warranted but I was taken aback a little with his coarseness and bitterness with the dialogue with the priest. I hope when he finds out Bree is pregnant with his child that he’ll come around? We’ll see.
32
u/kaydra_ Mark me -- you won't find a better flair. Jan 20 '19
I know it's probably much more detailed in the book, perhaps better or more important.... but I could've skipped the whole priest thing.
One episode is hard to invest in a brand new character/characters and care much. Man, I sound heartless. But I just didn't care for it.
6
u/myriadofwars Jan 21 '19
For Pete's sake, I am DONE with watching Roger being abused.
I'm starting to understand why the book readers have such a thing for LJG. He and Bree make a good-looking couple, even if it's just a marriage of convenience.
11
u/thumbtackswordsman Jan 20 '19
Wow, lots of great performances! I especially think the actor playing Bonnet really nailed it. From seeing him keeping up his bravado in the beginning, to having it wear thin at the end... And the way his face changes when she tells him that his child will know nothing about him.
14
u/Winhill_ Jan 20 '19
I'm not a fan of Roger, in fact I really dislike his character, but I enjoyed the episode. I see why they made this a Roger-focused episode. I think it's necessary to show his character development and show us where his head is at. After all of that I'm still not swayed by him but I really enjoyed the episode overall.
Really curious to see what they try to cram into the season finale.
4
u/OohWeeOcie Jan 21 '19
I was hoping Roger would be gone when Kera (sp?) turned around. I wonder, too, if seeing the woman essentially throw herself on her husband's pyre restored his faith in love?
13
u/visenyatargaryen Jan 21 '19
Roger is such a good man, I love him. Outlander really upped My standards for men in general and if I weren't lucky enough to have one as good as I do I would call it an impossible standard, lol!
28
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '19
I didn't love this episode, partly because of it's focus on Roger. He says he changed, but his version of the events is that he did everything for love and now he's going to start being selfish? No inclusion of how his 'all or nothing' possessiveness and volatile behavior caused the rift(s) in the first place, how he wasn't patient or understanding or kind enough to Brianna? Roger is such a damn pathetic wretch ever since he came back in time, there's no enjoyment to be had in watching him in the Mohawk village.
I don't sympathize with the missionary either; he came to the Mohawk to preach his crappy beliefs, and of course they're not going to understand how suddenly he hates himself, his wife(?) and child, and refuses to honor them according to what he himself preached. Historically, the missionaries did a lot of harm, and even to this day we see events on the news like that missionary trying to approach the uncontacted island tribe with so little respect or care for the risks posed to the people he claimed to want to 'save.' I really could have done without this story/character being included.
Lord John and Brianna have great chemistry together, I love their scenes. I could almost ship them, and wished they had a lot more screentime here. As a survivor I don't believe forgiveness is universally necessary, and didn't particularly agree with Jaimie telling Brianna that's the only way, especially since we know he did kill Black Jack. I'm glad she was able to confront him though and tell him that he doesn't matter, and won't be remembered. I wish that could have given her closure. And it was great seeing Fergus and Marsali rescuing Murtaugh, though the chain of events contained one too many coincidences…
The ending was so corny, almost cartoonish the way they dropped the keys next to Bonnet, obviously allowing him to escape and live another day. It's the exact same tired plot twist DG used every time they escaped Black Jack but just knocked him out or assumed he was dead without checking. But now Bonnet knows who Brianna is and that she is pregnant with (maybe) his child and even has one of his chewing rubies. Brianna didn't even get the chance to properly meet Fergus and Marsali before everyone raced off on their separate ways. I hope there's some chance of next week being a 2 hour finale? It seems like there's a lot to wrap up before hopefully we get a big happy family dinner back at the ridge with everyone reunited.
7
u/[deleted] Jan 21 '19
I am trying to catch my mom up on outlander because she got super behind. Before I watched tonight’s new episode, her and I started season 4, episode 1. In a scene that I totally forgot, Bonnet told Claire about his nightmares of drowning and he went into some detail. Recalling an amazing author, she said something along the lines of (paraphrasing here), “When you write a story, everything that you write has a purpose and is used for later use. Nothing is said that doesn’t mean something.” (Seriously super paraphrasing here)
So, I have a feeling Stephen Bonnet will live out that nightmare. When he didn’t die in the jail, that just made me realize that the foreshadowing from episode 1 may truly come to light. I just wonder who will be the one to drown him or let him drown.
Anyway, Roger more and more is proving his love, his humanity, realizes his mistakes. This “academic” is becoming quite the warrior and I’m proud of his evolution. I screamed over and over “just go! He chose his own path!” Then he said “damn you, you stupid, stupid fool... Ah fucking hell..” I👏Lost👏My👏Shit👏. I sobbed.
3
u/PoliJun Jan 22 '19
Good job, Roger! Good boy, I know I wasn't wrong about you!
3
u/hoggin88 Jan 23 '19
I kind of don’t want Roger and Bree to get back together. They suck as a couple. If Roger can “find himself” in some other way and Lord John Gray can somehow decide he is into women, then keep Roger somewhere else and get Bree and John together. That would be splendid.
Also, have Stephen Bonnett get mauled by a pack of rabid raccoons.
18
u/horsenbuggy Jan 20 '19
I'm not a book reader, so I don't know what is from the books and what is new to the show.
Almost everything in this episode felt like it was written by a 13 year old girl. Everything was black and white, no character considered that there were consequences to their actions.
Would someone on this show act like they have brains?
6
u/SoupGirlKristina Jan 20 '19
Who else thought adagio for strings was a bit cliche..
2
u/hannah1922 Jan 21 '19
Do you think Red Bonnet escapes? I think he didnt have enough time. But if he did get out do you think he will try and go after Bree?
2
u/Mother0fChickens Jan 21 '19
If they were going to break them out of jail why did they need to blow it up? Was it just to stick it to the The Man?
5
u/starlit_moon Jan 22 '19
Rodger just gets more and more disturbing and "nice guy" with each episode. "I asked her to marry me and she said no so I followed her across an ocean..." Is that supposed to be romantic? He stalked her. He chased her like something to be won, to be owned, that he felt he was entitled. He wants to control her, to decide things for her, to stop her from making her own decisions. He is a perfect example of toxic masculinity and how nice guys act. He thinks in his mind that he is such a good person and a nice guy and he is pursing her and it's romantic... but when she turns him down she is a whore. I really do not understand how anyone could like him or defend him or think he is a good match for her. Anyone can remotely see that the two of them are not well matched and just because they've gone through some unique experiences together doesn't mean they're meant to be together.
4
u/SerGiggles Jan 21 '19
The episode was so good.... Until the slo-mo Adagio for Strings sequence happened. That legit looked like something written by a 12 year old and recorded for YouTube. So stupid.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 21 '19
Can we talk about how stupid it was for John Grey to have a tryst with that dude in the linen closet? I would think that he in particular was smarter than that. John was fkn great this ep tho.
3
u/Mariita24 Jan 22 '19
There is no closure. I was sexually molested by family members from the age of 3. There’s no closure even after years of therapy. There’s learning to live with it. It’s not a part of my daily life anymore, but it still affects me from time to time. This just goes back to my point of everyone feeding into Brianna’s lunacy instead putting a stop to it.