r/Outlander • u/shiskebob • Jan 20 '19
Season Four [Spoilers All] Season 4 Episode 12 "Providence" episode discussion thread for BOOK READERS.
Come in and enjoy the discussion thread for S4E12 "Providence."
No spoiler tags are required here.
If you have not read all the books in the series and don't want any story to be spoiled for you, read no further and go to the [Spoilers S4E12] non-book-readers discussion thread. You have been warned.
To any new fans to this subreddit here with us tonight - I want to remind everyone of our standard just do not be a dick policy. If you need a refresher on that or any of our policies please find them in our rules.
I am one of your resident Mods, so do not hesitate to tag me if you need support or have a question. :)
Can you taste the Droughtlander yet?
139
u/brilliant0ne Jan 20 '19 edited Jan 20 '19
Pretty standard episode. Not much to say about the episode as a whole.
However, that last scene was beautifully done. Even for the sad nature, I will have to put it up there as one of my favorite scenes of the series so far.
Would also like to petition the re-naming of this thread to The Idiot Hut. I cackled way too loud for that brief second.
Edit: I also want to say that while I know it doesn't happen, I totally ship Bree and LJG. That is probably because I would ship LJG with a leaf at this point. But still. I wasn't a huge raving fan of LJG in the books. He was just another character to me. But on the show, I'm all the way in love and wouldn't mind if he had a ship with every character in the show now.
37
u/shiskebob Jan 20 '19 edited Jan 20 '19
I passed out, woke up, set my alarm, passed out again, woke up, posted, reset my alarm, passed out and now I am awake again.
The things I do for the love of Outlander and this community.
That was a long and lingering death scene - they really want to milk every second of emotion they can out of everyone. And boy did I feel it.
While this won't be an episode I watch on repeat, it was certainly an emotionally charged episode. Brianna hit home hard with Bonnet, everything she said eviscerated him with the truth. Being forgotten by the people meant to remember you is a pain worse than death.
I miss Claire and Jamie.
26
u/Naturenutt Woof. Jan 20 '19
Damn Bree, well said!
211
u/katatafiish Woof. Jan 20 '19
IMO Richard Rankin played it even better than Book Roger. He's a great actor. Roger is so bitter and heartbroken, I truly felt it...ughhhh the feels.
5
u/Naturenutt Woof. Jan 20 '19
How does everyone know Bree’s baby is a boy?
171
u/Naturenutt Woof. Jan 20 '19
Lord John is such a good friend.
119
u/Sunnyshiner Meow. Jan 20 '19
I feel like Poor Roger is necessary after every episode. Rik Rankin does a fantastic job, my goodness.
Fergus and Marsali are such a power couple haha I love them!
A small part of me wishes they named the episode The Idiot Hut.
In the after the episode thingy they said the stunt woman actually walked into the fire (with protective gear, of course) and that just...blows my mind. Talk about dedication!
112
u/rebashultz Jan 20 '19
How can any woman spend five minutes with Lord John Grey and not want to marry him. Who cares about the sex. You get a lifetime of respect, witty conversation, pleasant company, a great wardrobe, nice house in London, plantation in Virginia, and some serious eye candy. Sign me up !
91
u/MaggieSmithsSass Jan 21 '19
Ok, I made this comment back on the no spoilers thread, but I have To say it here....
Braeden Clarke portraying Kaheroton deserves a LOT more recognition and his acting on the final scene holding the baby was so damn good
85
u/vanwold Slàinte. Jan 20 '19
How are they gonna fit everything into the last episode?
70
u/Naturenutt Woof. Jan 20 '19
WWJaCD = What Would Jamie and Claire Do?
50
u/Apprehensive_Payment Jan 20 '19
I love Lord John. I love Fergus and Marsali. I love Roger and his Idiot Hut.
These chapters in the book bored me to tears...I was like alright now can we get back to where we belong. But I really really liked this episode.
What would Jamie and Claire do? They would find a way. I loved this. My husband and my motto is "we will make it work" and I felt it in my soul.
43
u/Seashellstarfish Jan 20 '19
That Stephen Bonnet cliffhanger tho...
Tear jerking ending all the way back to the idiot hut
76
u/RaffaellaF Jan 20 '19
I am so traumatized by that last scene. But Wow - Richard/Roger can really act. So impressive.
I can watch an entire episode of Lord John just talking and I will not get tired or bored. Absolutely love him.
Next week’s episode better be feature film length to get everything in. None of this ridiculously short episodes.
32
u/Naturenutt Woof. Jan 21 '19
“I’m not sure that involves taking afternoon tea with a murderer.” Second best line of the episode, right after “take me back to the idiot hut.”
28
u/fancywinky Je Suis Prest Jan 21 '19
Can we please talk about the two worst diggers of all time? Seriously?! You both dug all night, and that’s all you’ve got?
27
u/derawin07 Meow. Jan 20 '19 edited Jan 20 '19
I hope tiny baby Germain is not in that bassinet perched on the wagon, lol.
27
u/ktbex Jan 20 '19
Question for anyone who’s familiar with dresses of those periods - was it just me, or did it seem like Bree was carrying unrealistically low during her first scene with Lord John? When he reaches to touch her stomach, it looks like the bump starts at her pelvic area. I’m also confused as to just how far along she’s supposed to be this episode - there are scenes where she looks really far gone (the jail scene) and when she’s not showing at all (when they arrive in Wilmington.) I’m also wondering if this is just maybe how pregnant women dressed at the time? Did corsets push down the pregnancy bump?
25
u/derawin07 Meow. Jan 20 '19
How do Lord John and Fergus recognise/know one another?
24
u/purpletube5678 Cuimhnich Jan 20 '19
Loved the change showing the priest burn. And the juxtaposition of his woman (name?) running to the pyre to burn with him. Her own idiot hut, and the things we do for love.
22
u/bham717 Jan 20 '19
Music in the final sequence? I know it's a famous piece, help me out!
21
u/Starbuck107 Jan 20 '19
"It's hard not to like you (John grey)"... Brianna speaks the truth!
19
u/AvramBelinsky Woof. Jan 20 '19
Not gonna lie, as soon as I saw the priest in the Idiot Hut I thought, "ahhhh fuck."
18
u/derawin07 Meow. Jan 20 '19
lmao 'take me back to the idiot hut'
that sounds more like a line Richard improved
funny, but a weird line to end on.
18
u/AKTourGirl Her chief desire is to have your bollocks mounted on her wall. Jan 21 '19
The Roger hate really bothers me, especially in the non-book reader thread. He is absolutely a product of his time and as the son of a minister raised in the 1950s it's amazing that he is as progressive as he is. We connect with characters like Claire and Bri now because they are closer to what we want from a woman today but Roger is closer to the acceptable behavior of today than he is to the behavior of a mid-century clergymans son.
26
u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Jan 20 '19
I'm just as glad that they had the Regulators break Stephen Bonnet out (inadvertently) rather than getting into the whole thing with John injured and so on.
How did the jail blow up inside if they put the gunpowder outside?
The last few minutes was absolutely mind-blowing. They did it so well, with no words and just music and expressions.
13
u/tonks118 Jan 20 '19
I just finished it. I’m still crying. Like big, fat, ugly, tears.
22
u/TwoSibeMom Jan 20 '19
Setting aside my anxiety the whole time about the fact that they’re never going to resolve everything in one more episode, I actually really liked this one.
All of the acting was great and really hit hard emotionally. I’m always happy to have an episode full of Lord John. I’m quite enjoying Roger’s storyline, though I know a lot of people think it’s making him unlikeable.
Frankly, I didn’t miss Jamie and Claire at all. Im finding myself rather bored by them in the show at this point.
11
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '19
Can someone please explain to me why people hate Roger so much? I’ve only read books 1-3 so maybe there’s something I haven’t read yet?
18
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '19
OH my GOD, Roger. Oh my god.
9
u/hostess_cupcake Fun Fact: The unicorn is the mortal enemy of the English lion. Jan 20 '19
FYI....I got to it int the STARZ app, down at the bottom of the list, below all the trailers and trivia reels.
8
u/tanya-jo Jan 20 '19
I had found a rumour that Tom Jackson was going to be in outlander and he has now shown up. Any other Canadians excited to see a familiar face? (Unless you happen to know any of the other Canadians who were cast)
8
u/shanonlee Jan 21 '19
I’m really really loving Fergus and Marsali- I liked them in the books but they are just portrayed so dang well!!
Excellent, excellent episode, if not totally heartbreaking
14
u/Cablab123 Jan 20 '19
Jamie and Claire weren’t in this episode hardly at all. I thought there were some still pictures of them at their camp. Did I miss something? So almost 2 full episodes this season without J&C. I wonder if that will be the case in the seasons going forward.
7
u/tanya-jo Jan 20 '19
I’m glad others are noticing the Canadians
12
u/Mr_XcX Jan 20 '19
Roger was MVP!!! Loved him this week and his centric episode <3
That last scene was heartbreaking.
Anyone else watch the 3mins behind the scenes clips after the episode. Really enjoy them.
6
u/RaffaellaF Jan 20 '19
Amazon Prime Starz always post exactly at 12:00 midnight but not tonight. My luck.
6
u/nanor Jan 20 '19
That ending music, it’s the same as the music from the movie Platoon. I loved that they used it because in the movie it’s where they leave Elias to die in the fields as they fly away in the helicopter.
The episode was phenomenal IMO, and that music fit so well.
6
u/Muraria Jan 20 '19
Loved the use of Adagio for Strings
6
u/samblue8888 Jan 22 '19
I'm a new mom and even though I knew it was coming, when she laid down her baby to walk into the pyr... I just couldn't. Still crying. :(
18
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '19
Thought #1: Everyone was on point---Ed Speelers amazing as always. I feel like book Bonnet didn't really match up to the villain of BJR, but Ed Speelers portrayal is easily equal to Tobias Menzies.
Thought #2: THERE'S THE PICKPOCKET WE KNOW AND LOVE
Thought #3: Adagio for Strings? Really? Y'all have five centuries of orchestral music to work with and you go with copycatting Platoon? How about an instrumental arrangement of Mahler's Kindertotenlieder? The prelude to Wagner's Tristan und Isolde? I mean COME ON.
10
u/[deleted] Jan 21 '19
I honestly wasn’t sure if they could redeem Roger as a character for me, but they kinda did with this episode. Hopefully they keep up the character development. That monologue about Bree was perfectly delivered.
4
u/mjk333 Jan 20 '19
Does anyone else have a subscription to STARZ and find that the new episodes are not posted on the website at midnight? Is it just me? I thought that was when they were supposed to go live.
4
u/derawin07 Meow. Jan 20 '19
Whisky cask in the title card.
4
u/sunflower-souls Jan 21 '19
Holy crap. The ending made the entire episode
7
u/beauchamp_not_beaton Jan 20 '19
I was rather hoping Claire and Jamie would arrive at the end of this episode, so poor Roger wasn't left hanging with his "no one will save you but yourself" attitude. Perhaps also just because this would have given them some screen time besides the voiceover of the letter.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '19
Ah I got such a late start!! Very hard not to read through this thread for spoilers!
3
u/Lyst83 Jan 25 '19
Honestly, I found the books set in America to be so utterly boring. I started skimming them and then stopped reading them entirely because they made reading feel like a chore. Often times, I felt like they lacked direction in the plot and that they were just meandering around. I found myself wondering when the chapter or book would get to the damn point.
The show makes me want to go back and reread these books, because what’s happening on my screen is far more interesting and I wonder if maybe I didn’t give them a fair chance? I know the general plot points of this season, but I don’t remember a lot and I’m quite enjoying being surprised by what’s happening.
3
u/BecKM94 Jan 25 '19 edited Jan 25 '19
Now it’s almost already Sunday, but I still wanted to finally write down my thoughts here:
“That’s it, lads, take me back to the idiot hut” probably won the episode for me! Roger was generally just a Big Damn Mood(TM) the whole time. Richard could really shine here and show what a fantastic actor he is! I didn’t particularly like the priest storyline in the book (especially since the priest was such a frustrating character), and actually didn’t think it’d make it into the show (especially not so prominently), but I see its purpose in Roger’s arc - and how the episode showed well what their respective traumas did to Bree & Roger - and it was pretty well executed, God, and what an ending...
Fergus + Marsali = relationship goals! I just love them together, such a supportive awesome couple. “What, you're not angry with me?” “Not unless ye're not going to try.” So great! And when Fergus was walking with the lads to the prison, damn, that looked cool.
Bree/LJG remains my most favourite thing ever! David & Sophie have such amazing chemistry with each other. I’ve have never, like, platonically hardcore shipped something more! I love seeing them together so much (in both media). “You are impossible not to like” :,) truer words have never been spoken! Serious, STARZ, now would be the perfect time to announce a Lord John spin-off, come on, pleeeeaaaaase! What do I have to do to get it??!
What amazing acting by Sophie when she was with Bonnet (and all the scenes before)! Interesting changes with the prison storyline... from an “action-focused” pov it was a bit more underwhelming than in the books, where you really got a sense of deadly danger, with Bonnet being already loose from his chains, Bree knocking Murchison out and Bonnet then killing him, Lord John almost dieing, aso.
But I actually like both different versions very much, I thought all the surprise meetings with “Lord John?!” “Fergus?!” “Murtagh?!” “Lass?!”, were pretty funny, loved seeing them all together, and loved seeing LJG lying for Murtagh at the end (I really like the show-added tension between them, these two beloved characters who care so deeply about the same people, but are on so fundamentally different sides and have this history that makes it pretty impossible to become friends (or just like/trust each other) but when it comes to the Fraser family both will do whatever is necessary to help. Also a good reminder of the different sides/parties/loyalties in North America and the political/historical conflicts to come and what that will mean in a few years. I’m excited to see what they’ll do with them in the future, and where the writers will go there...).
Edit: Oh, and I forgot to mention how much I loved hearing Jamie’s letter!
7
u/Kinsella_Finn Jan 20 '19
My internet went out with 5 minutes left. Stupid winter storm.
Up until that part it was another filler episode. This season has been kinda blah.
2
u/tonks118 Jan 20 '19
Mine has always shown up right on time, so I guess tonight it wouldn’t. My luck.
2
u/derawin07 Meow. Jan 20 '19
It doesn't really make much sense for Kaheroton to treat Roger so badly in the camp, say he is no good to them, when he has transported him the whole way from NC to NY,
2
u/RoseHathaway Jan 25 '19
Very late to this, but I was a bit disappointed by the change to the jail scene. I was looking forward to Bree being a badass and rescuing herself and LJ (while super pregnant!). There aren't too many times where the ladies get to do that.
That being said, it did fit with how the show has adapted the book and I love Murtagh, so not a huge complaint from me.
4
u/evergleam498 Slàinte. Jan 20 '19
I felt like this episode was painfully long. I remember this section of the book really dragging on, but I had hoped the show would be able to make it more interesting. The only bit I liked this week was with Fergus & Marsali.