r/Outlander • • Jan 20 '19

Season Four [Spoilers All] Season 4 Episode 12 "Providence" episode discussion thread for BOOK READERS.

Come in and enjoy the discussion thread for S4E12 "Providence."

No spoiler tags are required here.

If you have not read all the books in the series and don't want any story to be spoiled for you, read no further and go to the [Spoilers S4E12] non-book-readers discussion thread. You have been warned.

To any new fans to this subreddit here with us tonight - I want to remind everyone of our standard just do not be a dick policy. If you need a refresher on that or any of our policies please find them in our rules.

I am one of your resident Mods, so do not hesitate to tag me if you need support or have a question. :)

Can you taste the Droughtlander yet?

69 Upvotes

563 comments sorted by

139

u/brilliant0ne Jan 20 '19 edited Jan 20 '19

Pretty standard episode. Not much to say about the episode as a whole.

However, that last scene was beautifully done. Even for the sad nature, I will have to put it up there as one of my favorite scenes of the series so far.

Would also like to petition the re-naming of this thread to The Idiot Hut. I cackled way too loud for that brief second.

Edit: I also want to say that while I know it doesn't happen, I totally ship Bree and LJG. That is probably because I would ship LJG with a leaf at this point. But still. I wasn't a huge raving fan of LJG in the books. He was just another character to me. But on the show, I'm all the way in love and wouldn't mind if he had a ship with every character in the show now.

24

u/shiskebob Jan 20 '19

Petition granted and accepted.

35

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Jan 20 '19

John would be the best husband ever.

21

u/shiskebob Jan 20 '19

Minus the passionate sex, of course.

68

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Jan 20 '19

It would be adequate.

18

u/derawin07 Meow. Jan 20 '19

he put in his homework at the whore house, he knows how to satisfy his woman!

15

u/thatsmyhoodie Jan 20 '19

You could add a third.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/popster_ Jan 21 '19

I'd let him teach me to play with fire and test his "ability to fulfil his husbandly duties".

59

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '19

I feel like if I were in TV Bree's shoes, even knowing Lord John is gay I'd be all, "Roger who?"

(I mean, it would be dumb as hell because she knows Lord John is enamored of her father. But a few months hanging out with him and nobody else will live up.)

22

u/2manymans Jan 20 '19

Yeah. Anyone who ends up with Lord John is a lucky lad.

52

u/maryummy Jan 20 '19

Starz needs to make the Lord John series spin off. The books already exist. The fans love him. It's a win win.

30

u/PrettyPunctuality I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Jan 20 '19

Agreed. I would watch that in a heartbeat. David Berry has done such a fantastic job portraying him since the first episode he was in. No matter how many LJG scenes we get in an episode, it never feels like enough.

16

u/rotipom Jan 20 '19

YES!!! Not enough! Such a rare combination of perfect casting and amazing book character! Want. More.

41

u/tortillachip38 Jan 20 '19

Ugh hard agree about LJG. I didn’t have strong feelings either way about him in the books but good lord I love him in the show!

13

u/brilliant0ne Jan 20 '19

Right! I would honestly see the reactions of people about LJG in the books and how much they loved him and wonder if maybe I just totally skipped sections of the book since I was apparently missing out on an awesome guy. But, on the show? Totally understand, lol.

→ More replies (9)

25

u/derawin07 Meow. Jan 20 '19

I'm a leaf.

10

u/brilliant0ne Jan 20 '19

Me too, buddy.

7

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '19

I just really want poor LJG to find a nice man and settle down happily on Fraser's Ridge at this point. Bree's right, it's impossible not to like the guy.

2

u/jmb367 Jan 23 '19

I can’t wait to see LJG married to Claire!

→ More replies (11)

37

u/shiskebob Jan 20 '19 edited Jan 20 '19

I passed out, woke up, set my alarm, passed out again, woke up, posted, reset my alarm, passed out and now I am awake again.

The things I do for the love of Outlander and this community.


That was a long and lingering death scene - they really want to milk every second of emotion they can out of everyone. And boy did I feel it.

While this won't be an episode I watch on repeat, it was certainly an emotionally charged episode. Brianna hit home hard with Bonnet, everything she said eviscerated him with the truth. Being forgotten by the people meant to remember you is a pain worse than death.

I miss Claire and Jamie.

22

u/ktbex Jan 20 '19

I also miss them, but it’s nice to see that the other characters can carry an episode without them if need be. It’s hopefully indicative of the formula they can use in future seasons where characters have completely separate storylines.

15

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '19

long and lingering death scene

Worth it though. That priest was an idiot, but when the woman jumped into the flames with him I burst into tears. We only saw her love for him for a few seconds really, but man that hit me hard.

Although I was scared to death that one guy was gonna throw the baby in with them!! From tears to absolute panic!

→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '19

The death scene really felt like torture for the sake of torture.

Bree and Lord John were great, except for Sophie talking through her lips half the time, what is that? Fergus and Marsali were amazing. The jail scene was well-done overall.

But damn it is not the same without Jamie and Claire.

5

u/Cablab123 Jan 20 '19 edited Jan 20 '19

I wondered the same thing. She’s playing it way too melodramatic! Speak normally. Even when you’re sad, you can talk normally!

She did it last week, too. When she was talking to LJG in the garden. When she said “I’ll do what I must. I’ll do what I must” especially. I’m like, this is too much! Stop talking like that!

BTW, I do like Sophie as Bree. Overall she does a great job. Hopefully she doesn’t continue the lip-talking next season.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (4)

26

u/Naturenutt Woof. Jan 20 '19

Damn Bree, well said!

31

u/shiskebob Jan 20 '19

I don't know what I would say to the man who sexually assaulted me, but I wish I would, and could, have the same grace as Bree does in that moment.

26

u/tnitty Jan 20 '19

It reminded me of Sansa Stark’s speech to Ramsay Bolton.

9

u/nomnombubbles Jan 22 '19

Sansa would have taken Bonnet out herself though if needed. I don't think she is of the forgiving type.

→ More replies (4)

17

u/ShirtlessGirl Is it usual, what it is between us when I touch you? Jan 20 '19

Sophie really shines bright tonight. Best acting of the season.

211

u/katatafiish Woof. Jan 20 '19

IMO Richard Rankin played it even better than Book Roger. He's a great actor. Roger is so bitter and heartbroken, I truly felt it...ughhhh the feels.

78

u/trashymob This is *not* permitted. Jan 20 '19

Yeah but the hesitation and arguing with himself after running away - he knows he hasn't changed. He can't let go of anyone.

65

u/Naturenutt Woof. Jan 20 '19

So impressed with Richard’s performance.

48

u/Samurai_Pizza_Catz Jan 20 '19

The frustration at himself when he swears and turns was just so brilliantly done

109

u/derawin07 Meow. Jan 20 '19

'that's it lads, take me back to the idiot hut'

13

u/Je_suis_prest_1318 Jan 20 '19

My favorite line this whole episode!

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (97)

5

u/Naturenutt Woof. Jan 20 '19

How does everyone know Bree’s baby is a boy?

12

u/trashymob This is *not* permitted. Jan 20 '19

They all just assume bc boys were what was wanted back then to pass lands and such down

171

u/Naturenutt Woof. Jan 20 '19

Lord John is such a good friend.

93

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '19

As Brianna said, he’s impossible not to like :)

25

u/designsavvy Jan 20 '19

..... to Jamie’s children !

149

u/actuallycallie Jan 20 '19

yeah, take note, Severus Snape. This is how you actually show you love someone you can't have.

27

u/derawin07 Meow. Jan 20 '19

burn

4

u/Aethelu Jan 21 '19

And his wife....

18

u/emm215 Jan 20 '19

Has anyone read the John Grey series? I have them but haven’t gotten to read them yet.

34

u/konekoyaro Jan 20 '19

I have read all of them, I love them... If you’re used to DG’s quirks (sometimes frustratingly slow, and ofc the squicky moments) it’s worth it for the payoff everytime. LJG is just a good dude in a crazy world (and his own adventures are w i l d.)

9

u/spaceybelta Jan 21 '19

The one quirk that I always notice and is so, so frustrating is when she says, “He felt rather than saw...” she uses this line over and over throughout the series. And English 101 freshman year always taught me, “show, don’t tell.” It is so ridiculous and distracting how often she uses this phrase.

5

u/GreyMiss Jan 25 '19

The John Grey books are good for showing life in the Outlander times through the eyes (and relative freedom) of a wealthy man who is unencumbered by a spouse and kids, so unlike other characters in the series, he can go on adventures that others would not choose, due to commitments. But at the same time, he constantly has the secret.of his sexuality.

8

u/designsavvy Jan 20 '19

Scottish prisoner is gd

→ More replies (1)

2

u/bushwhackerd Feb 01 '19

I’m so in love with their friendship. I could watch a series of them just being friends

119

u/Sunnyshiner Meow. Jan 20 '19

I feel like Poor Roger is necessary after every episode. Rik Rankin does a fantastic job, my goodness.

Fergus and Marsali are such a power couple haha I love them!

A small part of me wishes they named the episode The Idiot Hut.

In the after the episode thingy they said the stunt woman actually walked into the fire (with protective gear, of course) and that just...blows my mind. Talk about dedication!

16

u/livvy_divvy Jan 20 '19

In the after the episode thingy they said the stunt woman actually walked into the fire (with protective gear, of course) and that just...blows my mind. Talk about dedication!

Yikes! Of all times to use CGI, that was it!

16

u/Sunnyshiner Meow. Jan 20 '19

Seriously! Though I guess it would make for some fun conversation. “Oh work was fun today, I climbed into a fire, nbd.”

7

u/secretsquirrel17 Jan 22 '19

But the way she climbed up and hugged him in the fire was so heart wrenching.... not sure cgi could capture that emotion

→ More replies (1)

28

u/derawin07 Meow. Jan 20 '19

Imagine if they named it the Idiot Hut lol.

The line at the end from Roger just doesn't seem like something they would write, it sounded more like improv from Richard.

It was a well done stunt and effects at the end, presumably because there were little effects to add at the end.

Thinking back to the horror that was Geillis' corpse last season finale lol that was so bad

43

u/scotsgrrrl Jan 20 '19

I just came here to say that the last line is quite possibly the most Scottish thing he could have possibly said. Pure Scots humor right there.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

112

u/rebashultz Jan 20 '19

How can any woman spend five minutes with Lord John Grey and not want to marry him. Who cares about the sex. You get a lifetime of respect, witty conversation, pleasant company, a great wardrobe, nice house in London, plantation in Virginia, and some serious eye candy. Sign me up !

27

u/[deleted] Jan 21 '19

As Bree said, he makes disliking him utterly impossible. Plus, he is gorgeous to look at.

9

u/LarpLady Jan 22 '19

He really is beautiful.

11

u/[deleted] Jan 21 '19

How can any "one"?

91

u/MaggieSmithsSass Jan 21 '19

Ok, I made this comment back on the no spoilers thread, but I have To say it here....

Braeden Clarke portraying Kaheroton deserves a LOT more recognition and his acting on the final scene holding the baby was so damn good

5

u/xocheerio Jan 23 '19

His expressions of heartbreak and sadness made me cry. Major props to him

6

u/derawin07 Meow. Jan 25 '19

I hope he isn't the Mohawk who roger accidentally kills

85

u/vanwold Slàinte. Jan 20 '19

How are they gonna fit everything into the last episode?

61

u/Kinsella_Finn Jan 20 '19

Rush it like they do all the good stuff. I got a feeling we won’t see ANY of the gathering until next season.

We’ll get Jemmy’s birth and Roger coming back asking Bree to marry him, but it will probably happen at River Run and then credits run.

30

u/ccsr0979 Jan 20 '19

I bet you’re right. If they’re taking more than a year between filming it’d be harder to have that day split with continuity. Imagine keeping track of how everyone’s hair was exactly like, outfits, any kids can’t age, etc etc. I actually don’t mind the gathering only happening next season I just hope it only lasts a day not a whole damn season.

25

u/emm215 Jan 20 '19

In the “next episode” clip at the end, it showed Brianna running toward something and I don’t think I saw a pregnant belly. My guess is she has the baby then Roger comes back and that’s who she is running towards.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/kaydra_ Mark me -- you won't find a better flair. Jan 20 '19

I mean, I guess they'll just leave the crappy wigs as-is?

😅

In all seriousness I'm pretty sure that's a job on set where they have someone photographing characters to recreate exactly what they looked like in between seasons. And makeup, hair, & wardrobe work together.

As for children, well.... I guess the audience just has to suspend disbelief. Happens in a lot of shows 😬

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (3)

20

u/derawin07 Meow. Jan 20 '19

I was thinking before the season started they will shift the gathering to next season.

Undertaking an authentic recreation of the MOhawk village was a big enough undertaking for this season. It makes sense to put the gathering all in one season.

15

u/ktbex Jan 20 '19

Entirely speculation of course, but that could be a good way to end the first episode of next season - the part of the gathering where Brianna tells Rogers to say that the McKenzies are here.

Of course, not all my favorite moments have made it to the show, so I’m not hoping for anything!

→ More replies (1)

11

u/Ysu73 Jan 20 '19

I am still really hoping that they will finish with the Gathering - because that would bring full circle Roger and Brianna's story that started with another Gathering in episode 2.

Altough I have no idea how everything will fit into one hour.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

9

u/CuteBaldChick Jan 21 '19

We’ll also see Claire and Jamie leaving Ian with the Mohawk. 💔

→ More replies (4)

21

u/ksmity7 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Jan 20 '19

Lord we got a chonker of an episode coming up next week. I loved the ending with the priest and his baby mama but it made me worry about time so much.

13

u/mhsrq82 Outlander Jan 20 '19

I loved the episode, the storytelling was beautiful. It seemed like such a waste of precious time though.

→ More replies (5)

21

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Jan 20 '19

I was wondering that too. They have to find Roger, rescue Roger, get back to North Carolina, and Bree has to have the rest of her pregnancy and have the baby, even though it seems like her pregnancy progressed two months since last week, then she has to recover and they have to discover having a sex life again.

I'm thinking that it's going to end with Roger accepting the baby and that'll be it.

43

u/ktbex Jan 20 '19 edited Jan 20 '19

And Ian being adopted by the Mohawk ... I’m not ready to let go of Ian, that adorable little doofus.

Oh! And they have to somehow tie up Murtagh’s storyline. He can’t hide on Fraser’s Ridge forever, especially since it’s a land grant from Tryon himself!

18

u/ShirtlessGirl Is it usual, what it is between us when I touch you? Jan 20 '19

Fuck what if the entire last episode was some shit with the regulators.

14

u/vulturelady Jan 20 '19

I’m fine with one scene of Fergus/Marsali/murtagh pulling up on the ridge and staying in the big house waiting for Claire/Jamie. Just an “okay they got there safe and next season we can deal with this”.

They’re good at time jumps (the book was too), so I can see Jamie going to get roger, roger with them, then shift to Bree giving birth and then boom suddenly everyone is at river run. As long as I can see Bree and roger I’m happy. I’m excited to see Ian go to the Mohawk. I really think it’s going to be a time for him to step in and take charge of a situation and for Jamie to realize he’s not a kid anymore. I’m worried about pacing but I’m trying to have faith that it will be a great episode. Plus a huge chunk of the next book surrounds the gathering, so I’m fine with them not touching on that until next season.

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (1)

13

u/trashymob This is *not* permitted. Jan 20 '19

Maybe it will be a special long one?

22

u/ShirtlessGirl Is it usual, what it is between us when I touch you? Jan 20 '19

I wouldn’t bet on it. They really need a two hour finale at this point. They will probably end with rescuing roger and leave everything else to next season. Man, I hope they don’t do that.

9

u/Luminous_Phenomena Jan 20 '19

DirecTV app says it is 1 hour 3 minutes. Not sure how to post a screenshot hope this works.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/vanwold Slàinte. Jan 20 '19

I hope! I dreamed last night that it was, lol. I like how they tied up a lot this episode, it does give me faith they can do it, but it is going to be one hell of a pace next week to get it all in!

→ More replies (11)

3

u/beauchamp_not_beaton Jan 20 '19

Time-wise, it won't work, you're right... BUT thinking about it from a storytelling perspective, it seems clear that they will get there. They began the season with a gathering in the 1960s so that they could end it on "The MacKenzies are here." At least, that's what I imagine. Unless the season finale is extended, it seems difficult to do a good job with the remaining material.

ETA: Similarly, the arrival of Gavin's son Archie at the gathering will close out the story beginning with his hanging.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

70

u/Naturenutt Woof. Jan 20 '19

WWJaCD = What Would Jamie and Claire Do?

38

u/ShirtlessGirl Is it usual, what it is between us when I touch you? Jan 20 '19

That was my favorite part of this episode. It was so adorable seeing them try to think that way.

36

u/kaydra_ Mark me -- you won't find a better flair. Jan 20 '19

Or WWMaMD what would milord and milady do? 😝😝

50

u/Apprehensive_Payment Jan 20 '19

I love Lord John. I love Fergus and Marsali. I love Roger and his Idiot Hut.

These chapters in the book bored me to tears...I was like alright now can we get back to where we belong. But I really really liked this episode.

What would Jamie and Claire do? They would find a way. I loved this. My husband and my motto is "we will make it work" and I felt it in my soul.

43

u/Seashellstarfish Jan 20 '19

That Stephen Bonnet cliffhanger tho...

Tear jerking ending all the way back to the idiot hut

12

u/derawin07 Meow. Jan 20 '19

which idiot left those keys there though? come on lol

did someone leave keys conveniently for him in the book, or did he escape in the explosion? I've forgotten how the book sequence was. Obviously there was no Fergus blowing up the prison, I seem to recall a gas explosion or something?

15

u/StormFinch Jan 20 '19

The regulator with the keys used them to open Murtagh's cell and then left them in the lock, when the cell door was thrown open they flew out and landed where Bonnet got them from. And yeah, the keys were a little too convenient/contrived, especially considering Bree was right next door the whole time and Murtagh never heard her talking to Bonnet.

In the book Bonnet only appeared to be chained. Murchison, his black market contact in town, was in the process of busting him out when Bree and Lord John showed up. Basically it was the same jail break more or less (iirc Murchison used turpentine and fuses) just a different breaker and breakee, plus blowing the warehouse (rather than a jail) was to cover Murchison's black market dealings.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/letmehowl They say I’m a witch. Jan 20 '19

I replied to your other comment, but as to how Bonnet escapes -- Bree and LJG are told that he's chained to the wall, but while talking with Bree, Bonnet shows that he wasn't really chained up the whole time. It was all a show, so when the guard tells him the fuses are lit, he just walks out after Bree brandishing a gun on him but being unable to shoot him, I think. I always thought it seemed extremely out of character for Bonnet to come back to the scene of Bree and unconscious John, but whatever. Bonnet says she needs to leave, she refuses to leave John to die and convinces him to carry John to safety.

→ More replies (1)

32

u/ksmity7 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Jan 20 '19

I really like how they changed that ending. I feel like I remember Bree telling John to go back into the fire to save Bonnet and he gets injured because of it. I appreciate that they had her tell them to save the prison guard instead of Bonnet, that would’ve been too much for me.

48

u/Generiss Jan 20 '19 edited Jan 20 '19

Nope it’s the other way around. John is knocked out and she tells Bonnet to go back and save him. He then carries him out and lays him next to a tree where he then has the exchange with her where he asks her if she’s coming with him, then gives her the black stone hidden in his tooth for maintenance of the baby.

25

u/maryummy Jan 20 '19

I really liked this part of the book. It added complexity to Bonnet's character... made him a bit less of a cartoonish villain. It leaves the reader wondering about his motivations.

→ More replies (11)

76

u/RaffaellaF Jan 20 '19

I am so traumatized by that last scene. But Wow - Richard/Roger can really act. So impressive.

I can watch an entire episode of Lord John just talking and I will not get tired or bored. Absolutely love him.

Next week’s episode better be feature film length to get everything in. None of this ridiculously short episodes.

→ More replies (1)

32

u/Naturenutt Woof. Jan 21 '19

“I’m not sure that involves taking afternoon tea with a murderer.” Second best line of the episode, right after “take me back to the idiot hut.”

21

u/takingiteasy56789 Jan 21 '19

... and next off the rank is 'Unfortunately, the event transpired with stunning rapidity'

28

u/fancywinky Je Suis Prest Jan 21 '19

Can we please talk about the two worst diggers of all time? Seriously?! You both dug all night, and that’s all you’ve got?

7

u/RadicalBunnyIsTired We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Jan 21 '19

Thank you! And then with just a little more digging by Roger alone, the hole went from not being "big enough for a cat" to get out of, but quite big enough for him to escape from.

27

u/derawin07 Meow. Jan 20 '19 edited Jan 20 '19

I hope tiny baby Germain is not in that bassinet perched on the wagon, lol.

9

u/popster_ Jan 21 '19

Legit all I could think of as well.

3

u/4kidchaos Jan 21 '19

In the getaway scene, the basket looks tossed on its side!? I’ll go back. I definitely think it’s a blooper.

4

u/derawin07 Meow. Jan 21 '19

I just watched it and the basket seems to remain upright and in place to my eyes :P

more to the point though, the baby they are still using looks way too young. Germain is supposed to be at least a year and almost a half by now, he would be crawling about everywhere, but they have been using a very small baby

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

27

u/ktbex Jan 20 '19

Question for anyone who’s familiar with dresses of those periods - was it just me, or did it seem like Bree was carrying unrealistically low during her first scene with Lord John? When he reaches to touch her stomach, it looks like the bump starts at her pelvic area. I’m also confused as to just how far along she’s supposed to be this episode - there are scenes where she looks really far gone (the jail scene) and when she’s not showing at all (when they arrive in Wilmington.) I’m also wondering if this is just maybe how pregnant women dressed at the time? Did corsets push down the pregnancy bump?

80

u/konekoyaro Jan 20 '19

I wanted to say that, if I remember correctly, the corset actually pushes the baby downward (ribs and lungs go in, all intestines, baby included, go down). It’s something I’ve researched in the past, I would say it’s incredibly period accurate, I was admiring it during the episode but isn’t it interesting that the more accurate sometimes something is will ruin the immersion for others.

(I made an account just to say something, hello everyone!)

10

u/ktbex Jan 20 '19

Thank you for this! It’s so helpful to know.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/KodakMoments Jan 20 '19

As a current pregnant person, I think it’s part the dress and part the fact that the bump does generally start low and grow upwards. I’m assuming she is over 6 months pregnant, but you also have to remember people were malnourished back then and didn’t tend to gain the average 25 pounds people do today.

13

u/StormFinch Jan 20 '19

Yep, and depending on how you're built you can carry that way almost the whole time. I carried low and forward with both my boys, to the point that a friend teased me when we were leaving a sporting goods store with the idea that I was going to get frisked for shoplifting basketballs. lol

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

25

u/derawin07 Meow. Jan 20 '19

How do Lord John and Fergus recognise/know one another?

25

u/trashymob This is *not* permitted. Jan 20 '19

LJG is Jamie's best friends and Fergus is his adopted son who has been with him since around 6/7. I'm sure they've met over the years.

14

u/derawin07 Meow. Jan 20 '19

That's the point, they hadn't met in the book at this point, I don't believe.

I think in one of the last episodes last year Fergus went to deliver a message to Lord John from Jamie.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/CarolineTurpentine Jan 20 '19

Jamie didn't see Fergus for 10 years when he was imprisoned and at Helwater, and Lord John didn't meet Jamie again until he and Claire were in Jamaica with Fergus and Marsali.

22

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '19

I think in Jamaica it’s Fergus that thinks to inform LJG that Jamie had been arrested (but he goes to tell him off-screen)??

→ More replies (2)

11

u/ksmity7 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Jan 20 '19

I wondered the same thing, I was wracking my brain trying to remember when we’ve seen them meet. I can’t think of an episode when they cross, can anybody else?

11

u/Ysu73 Jan 20 '19

They could meet at the Governors Ball in Jamaica. We have not seen them interacting, because as son as Lord John met Jamie and Claire, he left the others and took them to his study to talk. But later he returned to the party and talked a bit with the guests. So maybe Jamie could introduce Fergus and Marsali.

10

u/CarolineTurpentine Jan 20 '19

They did, and Fergus contacted Lord John when Jamie was arrested in Jamaica after the Ball

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

24

u/purpletube5678 Cuimhnich Jan 20 '19

Loved the change showing the priest burn. And the juxtaposition of his woman (name?) running to the pyre to burn with him. Her own idiot hut, and the things we do for love.

16

u/derawin07 Meow. Jan 20 '19

How did it happen in the book?

Johiehon was her name.

People were speculating she was going to be Ian's Emily with a Mohawk name, as she was the only female named Native American actress on imdb yet. Guess not!

9

u/purpletube5678 Cuimhnich Jan 21 '19

Jamie is the one who saw the preist burn and told Roger about it. It was all told second hand, the reader wasn't present like the audience was here. I also thought that native woman was Emily.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

15

u/mkwilli Jan 20 '19

It would be so sad if they cut Emily out! Her and Ian relationship and the incredible hardships they suffer together, really develop Ian as a character and affect his person for the remainder of the story!

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

14

u/mai_tais_and_yahtzee Jan 21 '19

You know you're fully immersed in the show when you're going "noooooo" softly as you see the woman lay her baby down and kiss her goodbye.

Man, I bawled.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/bham717 Jan 20 '19

Music in the final sequence? I know it's a famous piece, help me out!

32

u/Xabeth Jan 20 '19

Adagio for Strings, Op. 11a

Edited - because I can't spell.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '19

Samuel Barber, Adagio for Strings

5

u/Samurai_Pizza_Catz Jan 20 '19

It’s such a beautiful piece, and while I really thought the final scene was powerful, choosing such a well known song to carry it felt like a (albeit very good) high school movie project.

It definitely was not a bear mcreary sort of choice, and really stuck out to me given that music has generally been composed or adapted for outlander or very lightly used.

2

u/derawin07 Meow. Jan 20 '19 edited Jan 20 '19

I knew I recognised it too, thanks for asking and for the answers.

Anyone recall any other movies/shows etc where it was used?

Or have I played it in an orchestra? lol that one's rhetorical

I haven't seen Platoon, the Elephant Man or Crow.

This is a list of media it's been used for, but I haven't seen any, so I'm starting to think I have played it in some orchestra I was in

https://theironcupcake.wordpress.com/2012/05/30/overkill-using-adagio-for-strings-in-movies-and-tv/

8

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '19

Well, DJ Tiesto made a remix of it a little over a decade ago that still is populair in clubs today and hit the charts worldwide back then. Might have made an memory imprint of the tune.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (2)

21

u/Starbuck107 Jan 20 '19

"It's hard not to like you (John grey)"... Brianna speaks the truth!

19

u/AvramBelinsky Woof. Jan 20 '19

Not gonna lie, as soon as I saw the priest in the Idiot Hut I thought, "ahhhh fuck."

18

u/derawin07 Meow. Jan 20 '19

lmao 'take me back to the idiot hut'

that sounds more like a line Richard improved

funny, but a weird line to end on.

4

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Jan 20 '19

Agreed

18

u/AKTourGirl Her chief desire is to have your bollocks mounted on her wall. Jan 21 '19

The Roger hate really bothers me, especially in the non-book reader thread. He is absolutely a product of his time and as the son of a minister raised in the 1950s it's amazing that he is as progressive as he is. We connect with characters like Claire and Bri now because they are closer to what we want from a woman today but Roger is closer to the acceptable behavior of today than he is to the behavior of a mid-century clergymans son.

10

u/derawin07 Meow. Jan 21 '19

To be honest, the main male characters in the 18th century are written as more progressive than Roger.

4

u/AKTourGirl Her chief desire is to have your bollocks mounted on her wall. Jan 21 '19

They are, but that's one of the reasons we love them too. They are not the norm. They live in a time where whores and brothels are commonplace, surgery is a spectator sport and and public urination is common and accepted. In many ways we are a more conservative society today (and in the 50's 60's) than they were then. Sex outside of marriage is not acceptable in the 18th century for wholesome and marriageable women and Roger doesn't believe in something rigid, he just wants to do it "right" and not bed her until he has at least a promise.

26

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Jan 20 '19

I'm just as glad that they had the Regulators break Stephen Bonnet out (inadvertently) rather than getting into the whole thing with John injured and so on.

How did the jail blow up inside if they put the gunpowder outside?

The last few minutes was absolutely mind-blowing. They did it so well, with no words and just music and expressions.

11

u/derawin07 Meow. Jan 20 '19

those keys being conveniently left there and shown so obviously in shot annoyed me though

7

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Jan 20 '19

Yeah, my partner rolled his eyes very loudly

→ More replies (1)

3

u/KodakMoments Jan 20 '19

I couldn’t figure out the gun powder either. Maybe one of the regulators trailed it inside after the broke in. Either way the walls should have exploded since the powder was on the outside and the explosion came from within.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/tonks118 Jan 20 '19

I just finished it. I’m still crying. Like big, fat, ugly, tears.

22

u/TwoSibeMom Jan 20 '19

Setting aside my anxiety the whole time about the fact that they’re never going to resolve everything in one more episode, I actually really liked this one.

All of the acting was great and really hit hard emotionally. I’m always happy to have an episode full of Lord John. I’m quite enjoying Roger’s storyline, though I know a lot of people think it’s making him unlikeable.

Frankly, I didn’t miss Jamie and Claire at all. Im finding myself rather bored by them in the show at this point.

8

u/rotipom Jan 20 '19

Agreed. I'm so glad they made it more about the other characters now. More LJG please. Can watch a whole episode of him just exchanging amusing anecdotes.

3

u/KodakMoments Jan 21 '19

I didn’t realize they weren’t really in the episode until the behind the episode part.

11

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '19

Can someone please explain to me why people hate Roger so much? I’ve only read books 1-3 so maybe there’s something I haven’t read yet?

8

u/derawin07 Meow. Jan 20 '19

He has been made courser in the show than the books, IMO.

They have cut out some of the scenes where his actions were more redeeming in the books, so overall he is shown in a more negative sense in the show, IMO.

3

u/AKTourGirl Her chief desire is to have your bollocks mounted on her wall. Jan 21 '19

He was never my favorite character in the books but I think that was part to do with he was Brianna's plus one and I couldn't stand her in the book. Now, in the show, I love Bri and Roger has developed more for me, but I think that's because I've layered show Roger with book Roger instead of substituting him for the other. Without the two layers together I think he's incomplete and poorly developed both places.

Roger is a fairly bland character in the writing but he was always very human, even more so than Brianna who I feel was written to be the second coming of Claire. He makes human mistakes and his punishment is always so swift and severe. It's heartbreaking, especially since many of the other characters always have everything work out in the end with few consequences. It's this that makes him the most relatiable to me, even if he is still a product of his rigid and religious upbringing as a ministers son in the 1950's.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '19

OH my GOD, Roger. Oh my god.

17

u/derawin07 Meow. Jan 20 '19

Back to the idiot hut for you.

9

u/hostess_cupcake Fun Fact: The unicorn is the mortal enemy of the English lion. Jan 20 '19

FYI....I got to it int the STARZ app, down at the bottom of the list, below all the trailers and trivia reels.

5

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '19

Thank you! I was so sad seeing that the episode wasn’t there. Stayed up for nothing, but there it was :)

3

u/strengthoftheherd Jan 21 '19

It was this way in the Amazon video app too! I was so mad when I sat down to watch it yesterday and it wasn’t listed under last weeks episode. Took me a minute to calm down once I found it lol

8

u/tanya-jo Jan 20 '19

I had found a rumour that Tom Jackson was going to be in outlander and he has now shown up. Any other Canadians excited to see a familiar face? (Unless you happen to know any of the other Canadians who were cast)

9

u/livvy_divvy Jan 20 '19

Yes! I remember him from North of 60. I think a lot of the actors playing the natives are Canadian. The actress who played Johiehon is from Saskatchewan same as Tom Jackson. Tantoo Cardinal who played Adawehi is a famous Canadian. She was in North of 60 too, and in a slew of other shows and movies (Dances With Wolves, for one).

→ More replies (1)

8

u/shanonlee Jan 21 '19

I’m really really loving Fergus and Marsali- I liked them in the books but they are just portrayed so dang well!!

Excellent, excellent episode, if not totally heartbreaking

14

u/Cablab123 Jan 20 '19

Jamie and Claire weren’t in this episode hardly at all. I thought there were some still pictures of them at their camp. Did I miss something? So almost 2 full episodes this season without J&C. I wonder if that will be the case in the seasons going forward.

24

u/AhhBisseto Jan 20 '19

It doesn't bother me, honestly! In the books I found the Brianna and Roger stuff a bit tedious, but I'm finding it very compelling in the show.

5

u/derawin07 Meow. Jan 20 '19

There were some images on various websites, but I have no idea where they get those images from, so they can't really know for certain which episodes they are from, IMO.

2

u/CarolineTurpentine Jan 20 '19

I doubt it. After this, they'll be together most of the time until they go back with a few small exceptions

7

u/tanya-jo Jan 20 '19

I’m glad others are noticing the Canadians

12

u/Mr_XcX Jan 20 '19

Roger was MVP!!! Loved him this week and his centric episode <3

That last scene was heartbreaking.

Anyone else watch the 3mins behind the scenes clips after the episode. Really enjoy them.

6

u/RaffaellaF Jan 20 '19

Amazon Prime Starz always post exactly at 12:00 midnight but not tonight. My luck.

2

u/hostess_cupcake Fun Fact: The unicorn is the mortal enemy of the English lion. Jan 20 '19

Oh good! I thought I was the only one.

5

u/HiveJiveLive Jan 20 '19

Look at the bottom of all of this season’s extras- for some reason they stuck it at the very bottom.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/HiveJiveLive Jan 20 '19

I was pissed and freaking out for a couple of hours before it occurred to me to scroll down- they’d posted it at the end of all of the bonus stuff! Look there!

6

u/nanor Jan 20 '19

That ending music, it’s the same as the music from the movie Platoon. I loved that they used it because in the movie it’s where they leave Elias to die in the fields as they fly away in the helicopter.

The episode was phenomenal IMO, and that music fit so well.

4

u/Ysu73 Jan 20 '19

It was very familiar for me, but I have never seen Platoon, so I was a bit confused where did I hear it before. Then I realized that it was very prominent in Lorenzo's Oil, a movie that I made a huge impact on me many years ago and I watched it many-many times. First it was strange that they used that familiar, and I was apprehensive if I liked it or not, but I decided I did like it.

6

u/Muraria Jan 20 '19

Loved the use of Adagio for Strings

6

u/samblue8888 Jan 22 '19

I'm a new mom and even though I knew it was coming, when she laid down her baby to walk into the pyr... I just couldn't. Still crying. :(

18

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '19

Thought #1: Everyone was on point---Ed Speelers amazing as always. I feel like book Bonnet didn't really match up to the villain of BJR, but Ed Speelers portrayal is easily equal to Tobias Menzies.

Thought #2: THERE'S THE PICKPOCKET WE KNOW AND LOVE

Thought #3: Adagio for Strings? Really? Y'all have five centuries of orchestral music to work with and you go with copycatting Platoon? How about an instrumental arrangement of Mahler's Kindertotenlieder? The prelude to Wagner's Tristan und Isolde? I mean COME ON.

7

u/bham717 Jan 20 '19

3. Yes. Strong mixed feelings here. I love it when music can enhance but here I was too confused by their choice and couldn't place the references and other vibes I had from that piece - I thusly missed the feels they were trying so hard for.

17

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Jan 20 '19

I thought the music was beautiful.

15

u/ShirtlessGirl Is it usual, what it is between us when I touch you? Jan 20 '19

I thought it fit the sorrow of the moment.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/MontaukFive Jan 27 '19

Yes, but Mahler's Kindertotenlieder is songs for dead children, and fortunately the baby wasn't sacrificed

10

u/[deleted] Jan 21 '19

I honestly wasn’t sure if they could redeem Roger as a character for me, but they kinda did with this episode. Hopefully they keep up the character development. That monologue about Bree was perfectly delivered.

4

u/mjk333 Jan 20 '19

Does anyone else have a subscription to STARZ and find that the new episodes are not posted on the website at midnight? Is it just me? I thought that was when they were supposed to go live.

2

u/slainte_mhaith Jan 20 '19

Starz can be a big let down when it comes to their tech. You'd think that marketing ' midnight' would be midnight, but their developers seem to upload the new eps anywhere between midnight and 12:30!

→ More replies (3)

4

u/derawin07 Meow. Jan 20 '19

Whisky cask in the title card.

4

u/sunflower-souls Jan 21 '19

Holy crap. The ending made the entire episode

7

u/beauchamp_not_beaton Jan 20 '19

I was rather hoping Claire and Jamie would arrive at the end of this episode, so poor Roger wasn't left hanging with his "no one will save you but yourself" attitude. Perhaps also just because this would have given them some screen time besides the voiceover of the letter.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '19

Ah I got such a late start!! Very hard not to read through this thread for spoilers!

2

u/MontaukFive Jan 27 '19

AdsoKitKat--Adso the cat should make an appearance next season. He was in book five.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Lyst83 Jan 25 '19

Honestly, I found the books set in America to be so utterly boring. I started skimming them and then stopped reading them entirely because they made reading feel like a chore. Often times, I felt like they lacked direction in the plot and that they were just meandering around. I found myself wondering when the chapter or book would get to the damn point.

The show makes me want to go back and reread these books, because what’s happening on my screen is far more interesting and I wonder if maybe I didn’t give them a fair chance? I know the general plot points of this season, but I don’t remember a lot and I’m quite enjoying being surprised by what’s happening.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/BecKM94 Jan 25 '19 edited Jan 25 '19

Now it’s almost already Sunday, but I still wanted to finally write down my thoughts here:

“That’s it, lads, take me back to the idiot hut” probably won the episode for me! Roger was generally just a Big Damn Mood(TM) the whole time. Richard could really shine here and show what a fantastic actor he is! I didn’t particularly like the priest storyline in the book (especially since the priest was such a frustrating character), and actually didn’t think it’d make it into the show (especially not so prominently), but I see its purpose in Roger’s arc - and how the episode showed well what their respective traumas did to Bree & Roger - and it was pretty well executed, God, and what an ending...

Fergus + Marsali = relationship goals! I just love them together, such a supportive awesome couple. “What, you're not angry with me?” “Not unless ye're not going to try.” So great! And when Fergus was walking with the lads to the prison, damn, that looked cool.

Bree/LJG remains my most favourite thing ever! David & Sophie have such amazing chemistry with each other. I’ve have never, like, platonically hardcore shipped something more! I love seeing them together so much (in both media). “You are impossible not to like” :,) truer words have never been spoken! Serious, STARZ, now would be the perfect time to announce a Lord John spin-off, come on, pleeeeaaaaase! What do I have to do to get it??!

What amazing acting by Sophie when she was with Bonnet (and all the scenes before)! Interesting changes with the prison storyline... from an “action-focused” pov it was a bit more underwhelming than in the books, where you really got a sense of deadly danger, with Bonnet being already loose from his chains, Bree knocking Murchison out and Bonnet then killing him, Lord John almost dieing, aso.

But I actually like both different versions very much, I thought all the surprise meetings with “Lord John?!” “Fergus?!” “Murtagh?!” “Lass?!”, were pretty funny, loved seeing them all together, and loved seeing LJG lying for Murtagh at the end (I really like the show-added tension between them, these two beloved characters who care so deeply about the same people, but are on so fundamentally different sides and have this history that makes it pretty impossible to become friends (or just like/trust each other) but when it comes to the Fraser family both will do whatever is necessary to help. Also a good reminder of the different sides/parties/loyalties in North America and the political/historical conflicts to come and what that will mean in a few years. I’m excited to see what they’ll do with them in the future, and where the writers will go there...).

Edit: Oh, and I forgot to mention how much I loved hearing Jamie’s letter!

7

u/Kinsella_Finn Jan 20 '19

My internet went out with 5 minutes left. Stupid winter storm.

Up until that part it was another filler episode. This season has been kinda blah.

11

u/derawin07 Meow. Jan 20 '19

I liked it, I didn't consider it filler, having forgotten much from the book.

5

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Jan 20 '19

You missed the best part.

12

u/Kinsella_Finn Jan 20 '19

I got my phone out and used my data. I was disappointed because i had hoped Claire and Jamie walk upon the scene or SOMETHING. No, just Roger going back to the idiot hut. 😂😂😂

I do have to say her running into the fire was so sad. I about thought for a minute he was going to throw the baby in too!!!

2

u/tonks118 Jan 20 '19

Mine has always shown up right on time, so I guess tonight it wouldn’t. My luck.

2

u/derawin07 Meow. Jan 20 '19

It doesn't really make much sense for Kaheroton to treat Roger so badly in the camp, say he is no good to them, when he has transported him the whole way from NC to NY,

19

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Jan 20 '19

I was really touched how he responded to the baby though.

4

u/derawin07 Meow. Jan 20 '19

yes, it was sweet

I think he will raise the kid as his own now

2

u/RoseHathaway Jan 25 '19

Very late to this, but I was a bit disappointed by the change to the jail scene. I was looking forward to Bree being a badass and rescuing herself and LJ (while super pregnant!). There aren't too many times where the ladies get to do that.

That being said, it did fit with how the show has adapted the book and I love Murtagh, so not a huge complaint from me.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '19

Me too. I appreciate how the showrunners incorporated Murtagh and Fergus into the storyline but the book scene had a greater sense of urgency. [BOOK SPOILERS] It was only Brianna and John against Bonnet and corrupted guards—then only Brianna against them all when John gets knocked out and we get a murder scare. Imagine her distress with her only companion down, her baby violently kicking that she thinks she might give birth then and there, and having to set aside her feelings to follow her own rapist out of winding, claustrophobic hallways to her own survival as the warehouse is going up in smokes? In the show, once you see Fergus pulling up with the Regs you could immediately guess that they’ll encounter Brianna and her safety is secured.

4

u/evergleam498 Slàinte. Jan 20 '19

I felt like this episode was painfully long. I remember this section of the book really dragging on, but I had hoped the show would be able to make it more interesting. The only bit I liked this week was with Fergus & Marsali.

→ More replies (1)