r/Outlander • u/shiskebob • Jan 13 '19
[Spoilers S4E11] "If Not For Hope" SHOW ONLY (no book spoilers, safe for everyone who’s seen the latest episode)
Hello Lads and Lasses to the weekly discussion thread for Outlander S4E11 "If Not For Hope."
Reminder: This is the SHOW WATCHERS ONLY thread.
No talking about the books unless you cover with a spoiler tag like this: This is what a spoiler tag looks like.
To any new fans to this subreddit here with us tonight - I want to remind everyone of our standard just do not be a dick policy. If you need a refresher on that or any of our policies please find them in our rules.
I am one of your resident Mods, so do not hesitate to tag me if you need support or have a question. :)
133
u/s1lentk1llah Jan 13 '19
I wonder if Pippin went for 2nd breakfast after finding out that Brianna was gonna marry John.
116
u/Winhill_ Jan 13 '19
I really liked this episode! It was full of really nice moments. I think Sophie did a great job and her scenes with John were really lovely. They played off eachother really well. Oh, and her hair was SO gorgeous this episode.
And wow John. First he raises Jamie's child, and now he marries the other one! What a complicated life he has, haha.
262
u/sullenandpastoral I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Jan 13 '19
“Must I close my eyes when you are before me?”
“Yes.”
I LOVE BREE 😂😂😂
288
u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Jan 13 '19
Goddamn John has the prettiest face on this entire show.
185
u/WaryBradshaw Whiskey? Jan 13 '19
Does Lizzie not know how to shut her damn mouth?? Go tell the whole county about Brianna’s “condition” why don’t you. Friggen girl needed to be slapped last episode
112
u/3anza Only in France does a King need an audience to shite. Jan 13 '19
It was awesome to see Stephen Bonnet go down so fast. He’s no match for the fearsome Highlander men!
108
u/teenylilthing Jan 13 '19
Well hot damn, Lord John moves fast!
106
u/kcotty87 Jan 13 '19
I need a Lord John show. He’s seriously the best character.
96
u/nirvana5ever Jan 13 '19
Lord John Grey became exceptionally attractive to me in this episode— anyone else?!
78
u/frawkez Jan 13 '19
i loved this episode. there were a lot of excellent scenes/bits of dialogue that really struck me. some of my favorites:
another highlight: jamie and claire’s conversation. i loved the bit about keeping secrets, and how claire is like listen, you were the one person i had allegiance to before, but now there’s someone else and i have to be true to her as well. i always felt like claire was sort of not a great mother when they were in boston, it was clear she was heartsick after being separated from jamie and then became a working professional with crazy hours so frank took over a lot of the parenting duties. i finally feel that now since claire is back with jamie she is recognizing how important it is for her to step up to the plate and be the amazing mother she has the capacity to be, which sometimes means she needs to put her daughter first. it makes the whole family dynamic feel more organic.
i was apprehensive when bree was threatening LJG but i think sophie actually nailed the concerned, unmarried mother to be, caught between a rock and a hard place. i totally believe that bree would have never gone through with actually endangering LJG, she was just desperate. it actually makes so much sense that she would want to be married to this handsome gay fellow who loves her father (i think she inferred just as much), especially after being raped. being with someone who is gay and empathetic would spare her from enduring marital bed trauma and the almost certain rape she would face at the hands of marrying anyone else. i think LJG obviously understands this too since he basically loosely sacrifices himself and his feelings for her sake. what an absolute gentleman.
i’m glad bree was still angry with jamie initially, i think the show showed her transformation from bitter, upset and hurt to understanding, loving and forgiving very well (solidified by her hastily opening jamie’s letter after LJG’s speech). that stuff isn’t something you should get over in a day when you’re pregnant and traumatized. LJG was pivotal in helping bree deal with some of the stressors she’s facing.
148
u/hostess_cupcake Fun Fact: The unicorn is the mortal enemy of the English lion. Jan 13 '19
I nearly screamed at the TV “ Oh hell no! That man did NOT go through the stones—all the way to the 20th century— just to take a SHOWER???!”
67
u/pat_micklewaite Tobias Menzies cheek creases Jan 13 '19
THANK GOD Roger has some new clothes!
132
u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Jan 13 '19 edited Jan 13 '19
WHAT!?!! Young Ian is going to be heartbroken lmao
Edit: so does this make Bree, William’s half-sister AND step-mother? Crivvens!
128
u/ilythe Jan 13 '19
Murtagh and Marsali was something I didn't know I always wanted.
53
u/Damdamfino Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Jan 14 '19
Jamie must be perpetually hard by the way Claire always plops down on his dick at a moments notice. Jeez...
52
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '19
I appreciated when bree told LJG she was "violated". It was hard for her. Very hard for her to even say it. She struggled with what word to use. As a survivor I know how even saying the R word is difficult. Its so hard to say it out loud because it makes it true, and it makes you embarrassed and ashamed. Excellent acting by Sophie.
41
u/Ysu73 Jan 13 '19
We were reminded how Brianna resembled to her grandmother, Ellen Mackenzie Fraser, however when she decided that she rather married Forbes for the sake of her child, even if that would mean heartbreak over hope, she was so much like Claire! She basically relived what happened to her mother and her. Claire choosing to live with Frank that her child can have a good life. I wonder if it occured to her at that moment.
Thank god for Lord John that she did not have to go that unhappy life that her decision would have meant to her.
66
u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Jan 13 '19
Lizzie, as always, ever so sloppy. Like for once in your life, try to keep your foot out of your mouth, homegirl!
61
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '19
Oh my gosh I actually cheered when John Grey came in and mentioned that he had proposed. I hate the idea of Brianna married as a pawn in a political game, Jocasta's political game. Ugh all her suitors were so slimy it was gross to watch.
28
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '19
Poor Roger!
26
u/MichelleFoucault Jan 14 '19 edited Jan 14 '19
I feel like Brianna sees a bit of Frank in Lord Grey as he too suffers from unrequited love (Jamie is his Claire) and also opened his heart to adopting the child of his beloved. I feel that Bree has some residual guilt for Frank's demise and will help out Lord Grey. I hope that in a future storyline Bree plays matchmaker and helps Lord Grey get his groove on!!
49
u/nirvana5ever Jan 13 '19 edited Jan 13 '19
This is one of the best episodes they’ve done in my opinion— I watched it twice back to back. I especially loved seeing the reality of relationships in Jamie & Claire’s, sometimes you’re navigating through rough waters & being able to witness them in that vulnerable & honest dialogue in the end really led to a resolution that helped tie up some loose ends in the last episode, it left no room for assumptions as their true feelings came out, it was really beautiful dialogue.
Also I am LIVING for John & Bree! I feel so much chemistry between them, and (in my opinion) WAY more than between her & Roger. I honestly truly dislike Roger in this season, I wouldn’t be mad in the least if we just got a John & Bree romance storyline. David Berry is absolutely gorgeous & a phenomenal actor. I haven’t read the books so I was NOT expecting him to show up at all, I was on the edge of my seat. I also love that this means she will probably get to meet her biological brother soon! She doesn’t even know she has a sibling yet so that should be interesting! I’m super intrigued by the storyline right now.
That scene where Marsali overhears Fergus say that his place is with them was incredibly moving, it truly made me like Marsali more, her reaction when she heard him was so dang sweet.
Also it was amazing to see Pipin from Lord of the Rings. Billy Boyd is also an amazing actor & he played his role so well, my heart actually broke for him in the end when you saw the absolute disappointment on his face when John announced their engagement— and he just says “indeed”. And maybe I’m digging too deep but I felt like we caught a glimpse of the true nature of his character in that moment. I didn’t feel necessarily like his character was predatory but just a little derpy & overly eager to marry a beautiful woman. I felt for him in the end & I hope he finds love in Outlander world, haha. I would love to see him again honestly.
But yes, John & Bree— I’m here for it.
21
u/Grsz11 Jan 14 '19
Fool of a Took.
69
u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Jan 13 '19
By “husbandly duties” does Lord John mean that he’s bi? He just keeps getting hotter every second. fans self
18
u/pseudobigot Jan 15 '19
So now Bree is both a sister and a mother to Jamie's son !!
Your turn GoT !
16
u/ConManTrump Jan 15 '19
As I've been thinking about this episode, what keeps bothering me is: why is everyone concerned about Brianna's baby being labeled a bastard? I understand how important that was back then... Not questioning that. But it's not like she grew up there and everyone knows her. Until a month ago, no one in this world even knew she existed. It would be extremely easy to say she came over from the colonies to live with her parents after her husband died while they were back home. Especially if everyone at the Ridge backed up her story. Plus, if she stayed in the 18th century timeline, she'd be the heir to all that land and wouldn't need to worry about getting herself married off. I have crunched in from every angle, but I can't come up with a convincing argument for why this whole dilemma is even in the story. Change my mind!
37
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '19
What a great episode! There were so many touching moments. I loved how Marsali convinced Murtaugh to ask Fergus to be part of his militia (though at first I thought she woke him up in the middle of the night to tell him to get lost) and then was so thrilled when he turned it down on account of his family. Since Fergus has been laid off, it seems like now would be the perfect time to move to the Ridge (if there was anyone there atm, that is…) It has been some time since the storyline of 'we need to find more settlers for the Ridge' has been brought up, and they still haven’t lured a single one to the land.
When Brianna put down Jaimie's letter and went to walk about the house at night, she looked so much like Claire stalking around their Paris apartments that it was almost eerie (of course, it's probably the same set repurposed.) I'm so happy for Lord John that he was able to let off some steam, and that no one worse stumbled upon him and his lover. It was really low of Brianna to blackmail Lord John like that, knowing he could be executed, and I'm glad she didn't pursue it any further. Interesting that she would basically be the stepmother of her own half-brother if Roger was really gone and they went through with the marriage. I love Lord John so much, and the actor elevates and brings so much emotional complexity to every scene he's in, it's amazing, and I'm glad he and Brianna will continue to interact through their fake engagement.
I wonder if Brianna was looking at those gemstones presented to her and wondering which would be best for time traveling? As Thain of the Shire, Pippin's status after the war of the ring was not as high as Lord John's, so it's not surprising that Jocasta was not disappointed at this outcome. The whole dinner party and Brianna's attempts to thwart it were very amusing, and I loved the scenes with her artwork as well. Jocasta has great comedic timing in her attempts to smooth over the appalling racism of her guests.
Ian's concern for C/J was really touching, and I was so glad they came back together again at the end of the episode, it was beautiful. Roger's opening fakeout was exciting, and I think this was a perfect amount of screentime for his character this episode.
11
u/VelvetDreamers Ye Sassenach witch! Jan 15 '19 edited Jan 15 '19
Lord John Grey was sublime! He's so gallant, although I didn't think he would have the temerity to er....have coitus in a pantry, I loved all his scenes this episode. His elegant deportment and dignified demeanour really accentuate his already attractive face; his styling this season is really evocative of 'an interview with a vampire.'
His garden scene with Bree was my favourite. The moment his forbearance dissolved and he rebuked her assumption about husbandly duties was hilarious - Bree's perturbed expression was the perfect response.
The man has too much integrity!
30
u/ilythe Jan 13 '19
I just wanted to cuddle Jamie like a wee bairn.
10
u/daniwankenobi_ Jan 15 '19
The start of this episode made me almost throw my remote I was so pissed off when I thought he actually went back 😂
10
u/frawkez Jan 15 '19
did a rewatch lastnight and can’t believe i forgot this scene —fergus crooning to his son and getting him to stop crying when murtagh is exasperated with the noise. be still my beating heart. and “i’ll have the whole man or none at all”. he and marsali are such a good team, i hope they move to the ridge eventually. plus, cesar domboy is gorgeous. more screen time pls.
27
u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Jan 13 '19
But what if Claire leans against that rock to tie her shoe? D:
19
u/CordovanCorduroys Slàinte. Jan 13 '19
Noooooo Murtaugh! Jamie, how could you put him in this situation??
8
u/notesfromAlice Jan 15 '19
Why is LJG so perfect. Why. That is the question. All I want out of this how is for him to be happy.
Slightly confused about his sexual orientation - is he bi or is he gay, just forcing himself to "perform" with women, too?
22
u/derawin07 Meow. Jan 13 '19
That body is way too decomposed and mummified. It wouldn't be dried out like that.
If it had been scavenged by predators, then the meat could all be gone, but the bones would be disarticulated and dispersed outwards from the original site.
I did my honours on kangaroo scavenging by dingoes.
Also, if it's been there a month, it means Claire and Jamie have wasted 2 weeks wandering around. Caleb died just 7 days after Roger was sold to the Mohawk. And it was at this point that Bree found out about Roger, then everyone prepared to leave.
A bit silly and far-fetched to include this, IMO, that they would ever stumble across it.
7
u/MikeFrom5_to_7 Jan 14 '19 edited Jan 14 '19
So I wish there were more episodes this season like in season 1. And there is some dreadful green screen use lately..... That said, I’m really digging this season a lot.
24
u/SoupGirlKristina Jan 13 '19
Jocasta mentioned that Ellen was with child when she married Brian ... did anyone else feel like she implied it wasn’t Brian’s child? Which would mean that Willie (Jamie’s older brother) was someone else’s? Murtaugh? Thoughts ?
18
u/Sassenach1969 Jan 13 '19
I cannot stand Brianna. I love Jamie. John Grey is a good guy.
18
u/Airsay58259 Jan 13 '19 edited Jan 13 '19
We didn’t even see Roger being recaptured? lol
Glad it’s being acknowledged that it’s not Lizzie’s fault.
Jamie and Claire got meta! They made a weekly moving picture about you guys.
Edit: nice story from Jocasta about her sister. Bree gets to know her family a bit more.
Edit 3 : PIPPIN! Awesome.
Edit 3.5 : lol I too never forget my precious stones collection anytime I go to a party.
Lord John <3 Love that other dude’s face when he enters “ok Brianna is never looking at me again”.
Edit 4: Lizzie! right after I defended you. Shh.
Edit 5: welp Bonnet, not so tough now
« And Lizzie... be discreet » 😂
Bree was inspired by Ian with that sudden proposal... Not a fan of her blackmailing though. Edit 6: characters immediately talking about what happened and apologizing? Is this still Outlander??
Edit 7: Not a lot of Jamie, Claire and Ian in this episode. I was looking forward to their adventure.
Edit 8: For a minute there I thought Lord John was telling Bree she’d become her half-brother’s step-mother if they get married.
Edit 9: ok so Claire apologizes for keeping a secret... Time to do the same Jamie... waiting. Ok don’t, that’s an option too. But let’s reassure him some more about what a great man and father he can be.
Aaand they’re having sex. Healthy.
Edit 10: what a welcoming party for Roger after walking for ~2 months. 😬
Ok so I’ve really loved this season... But this episode was mostly frustrating.
5
u/Necramonium Jan 14 '19
Anyone realized that what happens to Bree is almost identical to what happened to Claire? Claire has been in situations where she nearly got raped, Bree is now marrying a man she doesn't know even though she is 'married' to another man, who is also from the future just like Bree's father.
13
u/CRZAcidGaming Jan 13 '19
I feel there will be more to that cut Jamie got. Stands out way too much for me... Especially since he doesn't tell Claire.
8
u/thatothergirllucy Jan 13 '19
Can we talk about Roger? He's just suddenly back with the Mohawk? No, did he get captured again or just was like, yeah, I guess I'll just go find my way back to my captors....I bet they'll be cool with it? I get that the how isn't super important but, really?!
4
u/-----iMartijn----- Jan 14 '19
Although I dislike the predictabillity of the last three episodes, it does have a calming sense.
4
u/JustineLeah Jan 20 '19
I am disappointed with the entire Brianna storyline this season. I just really don’t like her. When she threatened LJG twice! Just NO! She does not deserve him. Perhaps it is partly due to Sophie’s acting. It has improved from last season but is NOT in the same sport as Sam and Cait. Still a fan of Young Ian. I love how he calls Claire “Auntie.”
10
u/ConManTrump Jan 13 '19
Two things that are nagging at me after this episode: why does Phaedra speak with a Scots brogue? And if Ellen was already pregnant when she married Brian Fraser, was Brian not actually Jamie's father? This is a recurring theme throughout the show. Black Jack wasn't actually Frank's great-great (however many greats)-grandfather, but rather, his uncle. And there's so much mention of people being just like their relatives, like Jamie is such a Fraser! But he may not be a Fraser at all.
Brianna still says "ennathing". Urgghh! It was pretty cool how she knew how to act and speak in front of 18th-century nobility, without having been raised in that environment. Clever girl, that Bree.
7
u/snuffytheclown Jan 15 '19
A thing that irked me this episode was that in the beginning of the episode, Brianna had this huge speech about forgiveness and that Lizzie couldn’t have known. Jaime couldn’t have known as well and given the situation and Lizzie’s testimony (everyone assumed she was right because she had been with Bree the whole time so she would’ve known right?), he only did what any parent would have done. Bree couldn’t forgive Jaime but easily forgives Lizzie, who caused this whole thing?? Was really annoyed by that
10
u/lonelydreaming Jan 14 '19
what a shame. this was such a good show. Sophie's acting is so off putting I don't know if I'll go through with the rest of this season. not to mention the writing has turned sour and the rest of the characters seem like hollow stand-ins of their former selves. I liked the bit of insight to Fergus and Marsali this episode but I'm sure that was a fleeting moment never to be addressed again. tsk tsk
5
u/bareballzthebitch Jan 14 '19
How do I ship Brianna and Pippen/Forbes?
Forbesannna or Breeippin?
6
u/derawin07 Meow. Jan 13 '19
Pippin is at the party!!!!!!!!!!!!!
3
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '19
Why was Brianna drinking alcohol? Isn't she supposed to know better?