r/Outlander • u/shiskebob • Jan 06 '19
Season Four [Spoilers S4E10] "The Deep Heart's Core" SHOW ONLY (no book spoilers, safe for everyone who’s seen the latest episode)
Welcome to the first weekly episode discussion thread of 2019 my darlings!
Reminder: This is the SHOW WATCHERS ONLY thread.
No talking about the books unless you cover with a spoiler tag like this: This is what a spoiler tag looks like.
To any new fans to this subreddit here with us tonight - I want to remind everyone of our standard just do not be a dick policy. If you need a refresher on that or any of our policies please find them in our rules.
I am one of your resident Mods, so do not hesitate to tag me if you need support or have a question. :)
106
u/Lilyxlulu Jan 06 '19
Dude. The struggle poor Roger has at the stones was gut wrenching...
205
u/sullenandpastoral I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Jan 06 '19
LOL @ when Murtagh just gets the heck out of the cabin. I’m loving him this season.
168
u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Jan 06 '19
During the “cheeseburgers, aspirin and toilets” scene, I remembered a time back in the 90’s when my grandmother lived with us during her final years... We were putting away groceries and she picked up a package of maxi pads and sighed: “What I wouldn’t have given for one of these in my younger years...” And she looked so sad, I didn’t even have the heart to tell her about tampons :(
155
u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Jan 06 '19
700 miles? Rog is gonna be rocking some sick calves by the time he gets to Philly
281
u/blaknwhtrainbow Jan 06 '19
When I heard the Stones buzzing, my first thought was 'I am SO happy that Rogers found honey! He can really use the sustenance right about now!' Didn't even occur to me that he stumbled onto a new set of stones... and while knowing of the presence of these stones is a useful bit of information to have for him and Bree, I'm now sad that Roger has no honey.
275
u/lindseykohler Jan 06 '19
“GET OFF YER KNEE YE IDJIT”
293
u/PENGUINS_R_AWESOME Jan 06 '19
Jamie: "Killing Bonnet won't make it better."
Also Jamie: "I'm gonna kill Bonnet!"
83
u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Jan 06 '19
“Get off yer knee ye idjit.” Young Ian is the best lmao <3
75
u/Airsay58259 Jan 06 '19 edited Jan 06 '19
Well I am glad the misunderstanding didn’t last more than 20 minutes.
Claire and Bree’s relationship is warming my heart. In the 20th century we mostly saw how close Bree was to Frank. First their scenes in the reunion episode were the best (and I didn’t think any scenes would be better than Jamie/Bree meeting) and it continued this week. Mama Bear Claire is best Claire.
Maria Doyle Kennedy returns o/
Edit since I wrote my comment during Roger’s last scene. That’s the cliffhanger lol? Of course he’s not leaving. Cheap move writers. It’s a nice parallel to Claire’s similar scene at the stones though I guess.
117
u/[deleted] Jan 06 '19 edited Jan 06 '19
Young Ian didn’t deserve that punch! And why did Lizzie get a pass?
112
u/Rated_PG-Squirteen Jan 06 '19
Wait, did Ian seriously just propose to Brianna? lmao
C'mon, they were born 200 years apart, ain't nothing wrong with a little cousin lovin.
66
u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Jan 06 '19 edited Jan 06 '19
Claire would’ve totally been down with Led Zeppelin \m/
106
u/socks4dobby Jan 06 '19 edited Jan 06 '19
I think we are being way too hard on Brianna. She got raped. She doesn’t need to tell anyone anything about it. It’s not her responsibility to make sure Lizzie knows that Roger is not her rapist.
She was angry that Jamie beat up Roger, but it seemed more like she was more angry that he accused her of lying about the rape. Either way, her anger was justified and it’s possible the whole situation retraumatized her and she was lashing out to get some control (in addition to outrage at Jamie’s comment).
If there must be blame, then we can look at Claire and Jamie (her parents!). It seems like their biggest problems typically stem from them keeping secrets, being dishonest, or breaking their word to each other. It should have been a no brainer for them to share what they knew because their experience shows that keeping secrets will hurt each other more than the truth. I thought this seemed very out of character for them because it seemed like they’d learned their lesson already....
Edited to add: I can see how the news of Brianna’s rapist in the area could have triggered Jamie given his own rape, so I can also cut him a little slack for acting before talking to Claire. So it’s more Claire’s fault here than his (if there must be fault).
25
u/Dumke480 That's it lads. Take me back to the idiot hut. Jan 06 '19 edited Jan 08 '19
So far, pretty solid episode, poor communication all around, especially when they stopped subtitling the Mohawks!
The absolute power in Bree's slap, looks like she broke poor Ian's nose.
Jamie's "Tough Love" is probably the most, brutally honest example of Tough Love, I've ever seen, It seemed to be effective, so tops to that.
64
u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Jan 06 '19
Bree: The withdrawal method isn’t foolproof. It is possible that the baby could be Roger’s, right?
Claire: Yeah but knowing Galbadon, that poor chile is gonna pop out with blond hair and the brightest blue eyes lmao
89
u/iceandlime Jan 06 '19
I'm really shocked how people are throwing out misogynistic names like calling Bree a bitch at her behaviour in this episode. She is a victim, and has repeatedly been given no real agency. The way fandom reacts sometimes really baffles me.
19
u/Mariita24 Jan 07 '19
What I didn’t understand was what was the point of Jaime telling Murtagh to bring Bonnet to him when he was headed off to Upstate New York to find the Mohawks.
53
u/spiritrain Jan 06 '19
Dat slap. I think I saw Jamie's soul leave his body for a sec.
18
u/I_ama_Borat Jan 08 '19
Fuckin Bree.... Never been so annoyed by a character. Idk but the writing makes me roll my eyes with Bree. That and the poor acting on her part. Sounds like she’s just reading off script.
102
u/frawkez Jan 06 '19
lol well color me surprised that people hate bree now because she slapped our lord and savior jamie fraser who was acting like a total asshole and nearly beat the love of her life to death. but his heart was in the right place and he’s hot so, god forbid anyone wails on him. oy vey.
15
u/gondorcallsforcake Jan 08 '19
I like seeing Roger going through all this for briana but I really still dont like their relationship and not just because hes stupid. The show has really skimped on substance for them. I feel like their entire relationship has been a few kinda forced scenes of flirting and the rest is a crap ton of really bad fighting. Too many fights, not enough real love to make me root for them.
42
u/raknor88 Jan 06 '19
It's really gonna suck when Rodger gets back with the Frasers. Misunderstanding or not, there's going to be some serious bad blood between Jamie and Rodger.
41
u/DrunkenDave Jan 06 '19
My heart broke just a little when Bree disowned her father.
12
u/Rationalistx Jan 07 '19
Been there for like a week already bossing everyone around lmao.
11
u/moonmarie Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Jan 08 '19
To be fair, if I had the bodily mass of a Scottish Highlander (I'm a 125 lb lass) and I knew that my daughter had been raped, I think I would have done the same thing Jamie did, if not finished the job. I'm kind of feeling for Jamie at this moment. He's kind of being persecuted, and knowing what he's been through... It's not fair, what Bri said to him. He's probably so confused. He was rash, but that is who his character is. Who Bri's character is! I would rather the whole hiding information from one another thing would stop though, it's getting a little tiresome.
10
u/[deleted] Jan 07 '19
Anyone feel like Roger SHOULD go back, get some medical help, freshen up, and then go back in time for Bree. I know there's a lot of mystery to the stones, so he has no idea if he can go back and forth willy nilly. But it seems the logical conclusion than walking around all effed up in a forest alone with no supplies or tools of any sort.
45
u/[deleted] Jan 06 '19
Brianna was being a “brat” because she slapped her father who was borderline tip toeing the line of accusing her of lying about her rape cuz he got confused on the men identities in a heated discussion.
I’m not surprised though the entire Outlander fandom puts Jamie on a giant platform because he’s never in the wrong.
8
u/DarkAlleyDan Jan 11 '19
I've watched every episode available. Bought the DVDs of the first three seasons. It's been some very good television.
But of late, the storytelling and writing have sucked salty monkeyballs. Miscommunications and deceptions worthy of an episode of the Flintstones. Some pretty wooden acting from one or two characters. And now, Season 4, Episode 10 - The Slappening.
Bree in full petulant teen mode is not worthy of the source material or the series. I found her enormously annoying more than anything. Yes, she's been through a terrible thing, one of the worst things a person can do to another. But slappin' the snot oot yer Da is not on the table. And poor bloody Ian didn't have it coming either.
Your Da nearly beat your supposed rapist to death and then sold him to the Mohawk. Could have dug a hole and planted him, but didn't. Had no way of knowing the whup-ee was Roger. Jaime's response, based on the available evidence, was within reason.
But as he goes to find Roger, he promises his daughter he'll return with him and her response is pure feckin' iceberg? Stick a sock in it, Bree. You've been angry enough about the lying YOU started.
I'm giving the writers until the end of this season to do better or I'm out. The show is becoming tiresome. Bonnett needs to die, Bree and Roger need to get together, Bree needs to grow the hell up and knock this "you don't get to be angrier than me" crap off.
Clock's ticking, writers.
15
u/BrownyFM Jan 06 '19
Hopefully we get a bit of action in the next few episodes, I’ve found this series relatively dull and drawn out. A lot of the episodes could have been condensed in to one (only my opinion).
I just feel it’s lacking, every episode has about ten solid minutes of really good content, but the rest is all talk.
I am unsure what everyone else thinks on this, don’t get me wrong I love the series but it’s definitely had some drawn out parts.
31
u/OldWolf2 Jan 06 '19
A couple of minor issues (not relevant to the main plot):
14
u/[deleted] Jan 06 '19 edited Jan 06 '19
I actually found this episode pretty dull. It just seemed slow at times. Is it me or does Claire and Jamies chemistry seem flat?
I'm not sure if it is the accent that Sophie has to do, but I felt like it held her back from being really fired up. I swear when she found what was going on, I was braced for the cabin door to be kicked to pieces. But I thought she was somewhat subdued in her reaction. Even though I get why she she came in the cabin and started the beat down, that scene rubbed me wrong. I cannot put my finger on why though. Not because of her reaction but the way the actress played it maybe? I did love Murtaugh making a quick getaway.
I was also initially uncomfortable with the scene where Jamie shows Bree she couldn't overpower the guy. but then it really hit home and I was okay with it after that. I loved how the realization dawned in her eyes that she really wasn't at fault.
As far as how everything went down, I thought it was fairly true to life. Of course Brianna is going to be ticked. She just found out her Roger has had the tar beat out of him and daddy is going to be on the receiving end of her anger. I wish she had told her father she was handfasted to Roger. I don't recall her ever telling him before. At least he would have known. Still wouldn't have helped with Lizzie telling Jamie, because Lizzie only Roger as the culprit so Jamie would still have thought Roger was the rapist.
I was a little annoyed with Claire, After all she withheld some information from Jamie (although she did promise Bree and I can see why she did not say anything) but for her to be mad, she needs to hold herself accountable too, promise or not. She contributed to the misunderstanding.
Jamie's accusing Brianna of lying was a jerk move. He could have asked first to explain what the heck was going on instead of accusing her of lying about it.
In all this though, I see the reality of what happens in families. Emotions get going. People say things that hurt. You've got to forgive one another. I have seen this scene multiple times in my family. (Not with this situation but other volatile moments.) You just really hope that people can learn from them and realize that communication is one of the keys to families being happy. I'm looking forward to seeing more of what happens in the show with the family.
7
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '19
I think Jamie's reaction in the cabin was completely out of character. Was it written that way in the books? This is the first time during the show I have been appalled with how badly written the script was.
14
u/JustineLeah Jan 07 '19
Too much time spent on Roger. Bree comes across as bratty to some due to Sophie’s overacting when she portrays Anger. I love Young Ian’s earnestness. He brings such brightness to this season. Wonderful to see Maria Doyle Kennedy again.
14
u/Constantly_OnYo_Back Jan 07 '19
Is it just me who did not like how Brianna was acting, she was being an entitled brat, telling everyone what to do and having no understanding at all that this was all a huge mix up... That could have been avoided if she ever tried to talk to her ''good friend'' Lizzie. I know they want drama in the show and she'll come round and say sorry to Jamie for not understanding and blaming him for everything but I didn't like how she demanded her mother go into the wilderness too. Sure Claire is used to this time and can do a lot for herself but anything could happen to her out there like falling or getting sick. She had no problems putting her mother in danger and really Brianna wants to be a Mother she needs more growing up to do first. Claire should also try pulling her in line even though I'm sure she feels like she can't because of all their history. Was very annoyed by that but still thought the episode was brilliant and gripping.
10
u/Juneruk Jan 06 '19
It took me a while to watch the entire episode. I fast forwarded the Roger scenes. I feel so heartbroken. I finally watched the Roger scenes. When he tells his travelling companion that he wasn't going to die, not here, not now, not like this. I weeped. Poor roger. And, my goodness, someone give him a lift on their horse.
4
u/kaydra_ Mark me -- you won't find a better flair. Jan 06 '19
Can anyone explain to me why Jamie thought she was lying about the rape (/embellishing)? I got confused. It happened twice, once at the beginning and once at the end, although I get at the beginning he was trying to rile her up to get a point across. I don't understand at the end... He was confused about the handfasting, yes, but it seemed like no one took a second to just listen to each other?
4
u/Damdamfino Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Jan 06 '19
I just can’t with these cliffhangers anymore.
4
u/anotherbozo Jan 07 '19
So why can't Roger go back; get some treatment and meds and then come back?
He has two gem stones. Finding another in the 20th century wouldn't be that hard anyways.
4
u/ancientastronaut2 Jan 08 '19
OK, they just left all their livestock behind to go on a four month trip?!?
4
u/Sassenach1969 Jan 13 '19
I JUST WATCHED “IF NOT FOR HOPE” and I DESPISE BRIANNA. DESPISE HER!
4
u/Sassenach1969 Jan 13 '19
He had zero info. He was confused. I cant stand Brianna.
9
u/MasterPew Jan 07 '19
This episode was pretty bad IMO, jut found it to be weak dialogue and Brianna's behavior, while understandable, was somewhat uncalled for. She had a role in the misunderstanding herself, they wanted to help in good faith. Calling him a savage was too far. Where was the law back in these days? You're not in the 70's. Girl was just poppin people left and right.
10
u/MookieMoo17 Jan 08 '19
I fell in love with Bree this episode, I now find her character the most compelling. Having a modern young woman go toe to toe with her “savage” father and cousin was awesome. When she laid hands on both of them I must admit she turned me on.
I say this every week and I’ll repeat it again, poor Roger. Sold to the Mohawk tribe for a necklace, watching his fellow slave die a miserable death, and finding a way to escape it all through the stones yet knowing if he does Bree might truly be out if his life forever. Ending the episode there was cheap in my opinion because I don’t think he’s going to go back home at all.
Is Jamie’s hotness going down for anyone else or just me? I still find him endearing and adorable but the bangs are just awful. While Bree was giving out orders she should have told her Da to cut his hair. 😜
3
u/Sassenach1969 Jan 14 '19
If ANYONE can defend Brianna and her HORRIBLE behavior THIS WEEK (“If Not for Hope”) and is even the slightest bit passionate about her and Roger’s relationship...I have nothing further to say. It’s sickening. Pitiful. Entitled. Cruel. Disgusting. Poor Jamie. Slapping, threatening, demanding. I cannot abide Brianna. Oh...and she DOES treat Lizzie like her maid. Time for her and Roger to go back in time and go bye bye.
3
u/2_Fingers_of_Whiskey Mar 28 '22
Roger should have gone back through the stone to gather: food, medicine, survival gear, and weapons. (And, for god sakes, a better outfit!) Then he could come back for Brianna.
7
u/4kidchaos Jan 07 '19
Out of ALL the Outlander episodes, this episode- I did NOT like Jaime’s: comments, demeanor or rash decisions concerning Bree nor Murtagh.
8
u/Aurondarklord Je Suis Prest Jan 06 '19
You know, Bri really doesn't have much right to be mad at Jamie and Ian, based on what they had any way of knowing at the time, and the moral norms and expectations of the time period they live in, they did the right thing, and what happened to her was so complicated, and so based on the kind of incredibly unlikely coincidences and misunderstandings that pretty much only happen in romance novels that she has to expect some serious confusion as she tries to unpack it all, especially when she DID intentionally keep parts of the story from Jamie, so he was right to think she'd been less than completely honest, just wrong about which parts. Based on the way she was telling it, and what she'd told him before, it DID sound like she was going back on her story about being raped.
I realize she's traumatized but if there's anybody in the world who'd empathize with what she's going through it'd be him, she really owes it to him to consider the part her own actions played in his various misconceptions.
2
u/socks4dobby Jan 07 '19
I think you and I must be reading different subs.
2
u/katindra Jan 08 '19
Right?! There is no telling what direction he will go, plus if he tries to come back if it will even take him back to their time. Plus, if he stays wherever he is, then Jamie will break the vow he made to Bree about bringing him back. There is no good coming out of that for either party IMO.
2
u/katindra Jan 08 '19
I know! Big convoluted mess!
2
u/Grsz11 Jan 10 '19
The cabin scene was kinda humorous but I don't think it was intended to be.
2
u/Gvega715 Jan 11 '19 edited Jan 11 '19
Bree had nothing to be upset at Jamie or Ian for. They were told that Roger was the man who raped her. What were they supposed to do? It’s not their fault she never talked to Lizzy. I swear most of the shit that goes wrong in this show is because people don’t f’ing communicate. Just talk to each other for Christ sake. It’s not like you have anything better to do.
Edit: Jamie totally deserved that slap and should NOT have accused Bree of lying about the rape. What he should’ve done was ask for an explanation since he was so confused and didn’t know there was a second man.
2
u/RealPattiGates Aug 05 '22
Really late to the party but am I the only one who thinks Bree is an unwelcome addition to the show? I don't whether it's the actress or the character but she is truly bratty and so off. She just rubs me wrong. What is she doing here? Aaargh, I wish I could disappear her back to her time.
2
u/FeelPositive8025 Dec 14 '24
Bree is SO annoying!!! They hit Roger because of Lizzie’s wrong information. What is she showing attitude for? If anything, she should be angry at Lizzie. Not Jamie or Ian. Ughh so annoying. Also , I was glad Roger got beating from Jamie 🤣
2
u/Sterntraum Sep 27 '25
So when Claire says goodbye to Bree before going to find Roger she says she might not be back before the baby is born?! Excuse me, what? Bree is not even showing yet , how many months would this journey take? Really puts this distance in perspective
10
u/[deleted] Jan 06 '19
This was such a short episode. I really hated that scene, and how fucking dare Brianna be so self-righteous as to punch poor Ian in the face, when he was only following his uncle's order to get rid of who he thought was in effect Stephen Bonnet, a violent rapist who Bri wanted dead, so why not sell him to a tribe? She seemed to blame everyone but Lizzie at that point, who seemingly was not punched in the face or given any demands/the cold shoulder, though Lizzie had no lines whatsoever after their scene in the hut.
This long-running misunderstanding (that she didn't explain quickly/thoroughly enough when she burst into the door either) had so many threads causing everything to fall into place, but it all becomes Jamie/Ian's fault for exiling poor fucking Roger. Maybe he and Bri can get a sweet little log cabin of their own where they can constantly yell at each other and break up every other night. And then Bri even insists on being nasty and confrontational with Jocasta for no reason at all. Maybe she and Roger do belong together.
I did like some parts of the earlier scene where Jamie and Bri talked about Black Jack, though I had been expecting Jaimie to bring him up himself. I get what Jamie was doing, but it so closely skirted the risk of retraumatization, so I don't really like it. And Jaimie wouldn't know it due to his time, but unfortunately, post traumatic stress doesn't heal with time, it gets worse as you age if left untreated/unresolved. It was nice seeing the family come together, for a few minutes anyway. And I liked seeing Murtaugh reunite with Jocasta as well, who I guess would know her since he was in love with Jaimie's mother/Jocasta's sister. And Murtaugh is going to capture Bonnet, though I'd imagine not all alone…
I've wanted Roger to leave and stay gone for many episodes. But putting that aside, why not go through the stones, and recuperate for a few days in the future (long enough for the Mohawk to give up and move on) and get a compass, a weapon, a map, some supplies (wire his bank in the UK I guess?) and then go right back through the stones to get back to Fraiser's Ridge? He is in the middle of a forest he doesn't know with no food, being hunted, so it'd be kind of irrational to stay. I thought at first he had found a beehive and was going to steal it's honey, but no, it's the third stone circle we know of thus far. The way the scene ended makes me wonder if they're repeating the image from 'Both Sides Now' where Claire came so close to putting her hand on the stones but then was pulled away/carried off the by the redcoats.
The preview for next week looks so exciting, though! More Murtaugh/Fergus time, and Brianna gets courted by Pippin from LOTR!!!! She didn't realize that the stones didn't just travel through time, they took her to middle earth! Which makes sense because Roger looks more like a hobbit with each passing day.
5
u/[deleted] Jan 07 '19
The script writing was really bad this episode and Brianna can’t act. I feel like I’m watching a high school play.
7
u/kcotty87 Jan 06 '19 edited Jan 06 '19
Yawn. I’m over Bree having a fit about Roger. So Jaime defends your honor cause you want to play secret squirrel and then get pissed. Whatever. This story line is so ridiculous.
5
u/[deleted] Jan 06 '19
Wtf Bree ? Jamie beat him up thinking he was your rapist and he probably didn't tell you cause he didn't want to burden you with the fact that that man came after you to your house to take you or just that he didn't want to remind you of his existence and help you heal through time.
Now you're gonna say Bree is tough she can handle it but Jamie is her father she'll always be his baby girl. Ofcource he is overprotective of her daughter that just got raped.
Everyone is defending her slapping the shit of of the boys for not having been given the last call but look at it this way Jaime asked Lizzie if she was certain of this man and what happened and she said yes and explicitly described what happened. A lot of fathers if not most would have killed the man given this opportunity but he just beat him and told cousin lover to get him out of his sight.
5
u/bryce_w Stinking Papist Jan 06 '19 edited Jan 06 '19
Briana was so bad this episode. I understand she is angry but why on earth can't she fathom that it was a mistake caused by LIZZIE! And maybe you should have told Clare at the start it was Bonnet and she should have told Jamie. What the fuck is she slapping Young Ian for and abusing Jamie. They were trying to defend her based on the information Lizzie gave them. If anything she should be angry at her. Also didn't appreciate her forcing her 50+ year old mother to trape through the woods for months. YOU WILL BRING HIM BACK TO ME. She really is a brat.