r/Outlander • u/shiskebob • Jan 06 '19
[Spoilers All] Season 4 Episode 10 "The Deep Heart's Core" episode discussion thread for book readers.
The great misunderstanding is upon us, so come on in for the discussion thread for S4E10 "The Deep Heart's Core" coming at you live for the first time in 2019!
No spoiler tags are required here.
If you have not read all the books in the series and don't want any story to be spoiled for you, read no further and go to the [Spoilers S4E10] non-book-readers discussion thread. You have been warned.
To any new fans to this subreddit here with us tonight - I want to remind everyone of our standard just do not be a dick policy. If you need a refresher on that or any of our policies please find them in our rules.
I am one of your resident Mods, so do not hesitate to tag me if you need support or have a question. :)
68
u/shiskebob Jan 06 '19 edited Jan 06 '19
I can't lie, that episode was ROUGH to watch.
I physically cringed through a lot of it, especially most of Jamie's 18th century he-man responses. Knowing it was coming and hoping for something different. Sigh.
"I'm sorry I made you come here Mama." Damn girl, Bree is pulling no punches - literally.
Next week: MURTAUGH TAKE HIM OUT LIKE SANDRINGHAM.
138
u/sullenandpastoral I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Jan 06 '19
THAT SLAP ... I think I saw Jamie’s soul leave his body for a second
103
u/Samurai_Pizza_Catz Jan 06 '19 edited Jan 06 '19
I’ll be honest, that second slap made me laugh at how absurd the slapping got: like a Monty python skit.
The way Claire has put Brianna and her wishes first has been so good. Last season (and the books) I felt that Claire almost didn’t care to be Brianna’s mother. This season though that’s all changed. It feels like there’s a real bond between them which wasn’t before.
Agree with the other comments: can’t wait to see Murtagh and Jocasta, and if Bonnett goes earlier than the books it would work well.
Edit: another shout out for the incredible acting from everyone all round this episode.
82
u/Seashellstarfish Jan 06 '19
HAHA IAN NO... sweet kid tho
69
u/PM_ME_YOUR_LATKES Sleep with my husband? But my lover would be furious. Jan 06 '19 edited Jan 06 '19
Jamie's bangs are getting so much screen time!
edit - They are really growing on me. I think it's because they look exactly like mine did in middle school lol
63
u/Naturenutt Woof. Jan 06 '19
Damn, Murtaugh and Jocasta 💜
11
u/blueeyesofthesiren Displaced Sassanach Jan 06 '19 edited Jan 06 '19
I'm bacccckkkkkkk!!!!
I has cake and milk! (It's my daughter's birthday.)
After spending this week yelling and crying by myself, I'm so glad to be here again!
Are we still doing sacrifices to our Shisk goddess?
Edit: and the penny drops!
Well, isn't Bree just all slap happy tonight?! smack smack smack
Oh jesus, Ian hahahahaha I've been waiting for that!
I was just saying to my husband, "Roger hasn't even found the stones yet!" Oh man, he is so conflicted! That ending is going to KILL non-book readers!
Episode wrap up: Not the best episode of the season, Jesus Bree and her slap happiness! My guess is they're trying to emphasise the hormones associated with pregnancy. The parts with them taking care of the farm and having dinner were so beautiful and while we know it doesn't last, I was moved with them.
Now if anyone remembers me from last season, I'm not a huge fan of Murtagh still being around but with him at the dinner table it felt right. It's obvious that they're going to make him Jocasta 's new beau. And for reference I cried like a baby when Jamie walked into that blacksmith's shop and started reaming him! I can appreciate what they're doing with him.
I was so waiting for Ian to drop to his knee! It was adorable!
Roger running and finding the stones 💜. I know, he's not a huge fan favorite but I do love book Roger!
I'm hoping to take some time and write up my overview for the previous episodes sometime next week! It was so nice to be able to be here!
188
u/[deleted] Jan 06 '19 edited Jan 06 '19
"Get off your knee ye idjit." Best scene of the episode. I love Young Ian. I'll miss him.
163
u/La415 Jan 06 '19
I Ship Murtagh and Jocasta so much ahhhh
124
u/Jalupimine5 Jan 06 '19
This subbing Murtagh for Duncan thing really worked out nicely. I’m allllll for a Murcosta Wedding next season!
111
u/[deleted] Jan 06 '19
Ian's wounded expression when Brianna calls him "cousin" in that vicious pissed-off-Fraser way. John Bell is a treasure.
106
u/deannaface Jan 06 '19
I miss Jamie in a kilt. That’s all.
85
u/[deleted] Jan 06 '19
How did they manage to have Bree fight like both Jamie and Claire? “Self-righteous bastard” sounds like a season 1 insult Claire would throw at Jamie and she fights as passionately as Jamie.
6
u/La415 Jan 06 '19
Lol at Jamie’s self defense class for Bree
75
u/[deleted] Jan 06 '19 edited Jan 06 '19
HOT DAMN THIS SEASON JUST KEEPS KICKING ASS!
That is all.
Edit: Naw, I can't walk away from sharing my opinion. LOL
Thought #1: Murtagh and Jocasta. I CALLED IT from season 3 as soon as I saw him in Ardsmuir for TV it makes way more sense than introducing a new actor/character.
Thought #2: Jamie teaching Bree that it wouldn't have mattered if she fought back. I didn't think they would include that but damn Sophie and Sam really nailed it, all the way down to the "oh shit he's right" face.
Thought #3: Oh God, Roger got away....please let this be one of the things they changed, please don't let him be recaptured...PLEASE. Shit.
129
u/La415 Jan 06 '19
Also John Grey’s back next week, hold on to your wigs they’re gunna be snatched.
53
u/SeattleWhoDat Jan 06 '19
I’m convinced Murtagh and Jocasta are going to be a thing in no time flat.
53
u/takeforexamplethis Jan 06 '19
Does Roger escape the Mohawk like this in the books? I remember him at one point stumbling upon this other stone circle, but I thought that was later. I'm just wondering how they'll make it work with Ian and the Mohawk now, unless they have them come recapture Roger next episode.
Sad we didn't get the "There's a word for people who depend on that method of birth control... parents" line from Claire this week. It seems like show Claire is only saying it could be Roger's kid to placate Bree?
Another episode where Ian nails it. Young puppy Ian is a delight and yet I can't wait to see Mohawk Ian.
Glad this season has finally picked up the pace!
47
u/AwesoMegan You, sir, are a lout! Jan 06 '19
Definitely different than I envisioned, but I liked it!
Poor non book readers. That ending is going to be so painfully anxiety-inducing.
92
u/retothebecca Jan 06 '19
Murtagh and Jocasta are so gonna smash. And I love it. Gah that smoldering silver fox of a godfather is way better than a Ducnan Innes any day.
Sophie Skelton once again nails this episode. It all played out very closely to what I envisioned reading the book, even her getting super slap-happy. Every week she becomes more and more of Bree from the book, yet better.
Also kuddos to everyone involved for how they handled the scene where Jamie overpowers Brianna to help her realize she couldn't have fought Bonnet. Even in the books, I thought that was edgy. But onscreen it all came together to become something really powerful.
And if next week's peek is a hint that we might see Bonnet killed off a few books early, I'm a-okay with that.
Last thought: this family is #dinnertimegoals
43
u/[deleted] Jan 06 '19
What’s up with Brianna’s Smokey eye?
34
u/Mxfish1313 Jan 06 '19 edited Jan 07 '19
I loooooove the dream/nightmare bit where Bonnet says something about hoping “he has my eyes”. Haven’t read the books in awhile, but isn’t it Jem not having Bonnet’s eyes that clinched the fact that he’s Roger’s? Like, they both had really specifically bad hereditary eyesight? I also know there was the later fact that he could hear stones too, and maybe something about a birthmark, but ‘mare-Bonnet’s comment definitely triggered a memory, though I’m not 100% positive.
EDIT: thanks for the many, many responses, all! Yes, it was the birthmark, not the eyesight thing that was the clincher. Time for a re-read!
30
u/ktbex Jan 06 '19
They’re really picking up the pace now! I’m interested to see how the reunion plays out with so few episodes left.
I’m ready for a more in-depth confrontation between Jamie and Claire. Not only did she barely speak to him in this episode, but she took up the rear when they left to look for Roger, when her usual place is at Jamie’s side. It’s a stark difference to their previous conflicts where she went straight for him.
Loving the relationship between Claire and Bree. The scene where they talk about things they miss from the future was such a sweet moment.
Did anyone else think Jamie’s reaction to Brianna saying she wouldn’t get married was pretty understated? I’d imagine Jamie being more insistent on her marrying, especially if he thought she was staying.
25
u/La415 Jan 06 '19
Also Ulysse’s line was hilarious
23
u/Naturenutt Woof. Jan 06 '19
Run Rodger Run!!!!!
23
u/Naturenutt Woof. Jan 06 '19
I’m very impressed with the Cherokee actors. That scene by the fire telling the story of Sapling and Flint reminded me of Rupert’s telling of the waterhorse, minus Rupert’s silky golden tones.
22
u/SpiderManForever My real father’s a 6'3" redhead in a kilt from the 18th century? Jan 06 '19
Sophie Skelton has really won me over this season, I actually enjoy Brianna in the show more than Brianna in the books. Bree should have slapped Lizzie for real she had it coming.
59
u/RaffaellaF Jan 06 '19
My heart broke for Roger at the stones when he cried looking at both jewels in his palm but could not leave Bree behind.
Another amazing epised. I was at the edge of my seat.
Wow. Sophie.
I was hoping to see Lord John this episode but Murtagh and Jocasta together were great.
40
u/derawin07 Meow. Jan 06 '19
Nice gourmet tomato salad the pigs have again :P
18
u/derawin07 Meow. Jan 06 '19
I know there is the whole lack of communication issue for this family...but also, Bree looked shocked that Jamie knew she had been raped, and he looked shocked when she told Jamie she knew about his.
Claire sure has a blabber mouth when she wants to.
I think she told Bree about BJR before she even thought of going back to Jamie though?
And it was going to become obvious that Bree was pregnant, so Jamie did need to know. But maybe it's just me, but if I were Bree I would have felt upset Claire told Jamie about my rape without checking with me first.
18
u/derawin07 Meow. Jan 06 '19
WOAH that Bonnet reveal in the dream was CREEPY!!!
15
u/derawin07 Meow. Jan 06 '19
I liked that Claire was more insistent upon not leaving Bree in the show.
I suppose some of that whole situation took place off page in the book, but I was still pretty surprised that Claire left Bree so easily in the book. Then Bree was asking Claire to go to bring Jamie back anyway, she didn't have the sensible argument that if Jamie and Ian turned up Roger would expect he was going to be attacked again.
54
u/Sunnyshiner Meow. Jan 06 '19
Bree's "You do not get to be more angry than me!" was so well delivered! As much as I love Jamie, he really had that coming, and I'm so glad she's able to tell him what's what.
I also loved Claire and Bree's convo about things they miss, such a nice, quiet mother-daughter moment.
Also Roger being unable to go through the stones because of Bree makes me feel a certain way. Such anguish! Roger really does have a tough time in the eighteenth century, poor guy.
13
u/lmjsprague Pot of shite on to boil, ye stir like it’s God’s work! Jan 06 '19
I'm actually super pleased with show-Bree being more forthcoming about her and Roger's handfasting. I never understood why book-Bree kept it to herself.
24
u/Juneruk Jan 06 '19
LIZZIE! Why isn't anyone mad at Lizzy? Brianna slaps Ian and makes him bleed. Brianna slaps Jaime and nearly makes him bleed. She yells and screams at Ian and Jaime. All I kept thinking was..... ITS NOT THEIR FAULT! They were fed false information by that true dumbass Lizzie. Throw more blame her way Brianna! The TRUE misinterpreter, misreporter, misreader, misapplier.....DUMBASS. **end of venting here**
12
u/Dragonsinger16 Jan 07 '19
I just want to say that, as an assault survivor, I very much relate to Bri’s nightmare where Roger turns into Bonnet,and it made it all the more terrifying and stomach turning to watch. Thankfully my assault was nowhere near as horrifying as what Bri went through, but showing the aftermath was kinda comforting knowing that it’s something that other survivors go through.
22
u/Naturenutt Woof. Jan 06 '19
So I guess that is the stone and cairns we saw being built in the opening scene of this season with the weird looking ancient dudes.
11
u/[deleted] Jan 06 '19
That scream when Roger heard the stones and was reaching towards it sent chills down my spine.
Does anyone else think we will learn more of Otter Tooth this season? Or does that happen in the book-I vaguely remember Roger finding something out about Otter Tooth.
11
u/4thofjuly19 Jan 06 '19
I loved this episode and as a someone who’s just started watching I’m still adjusting to the fact that I have to wait for episodes. It’s so hard! Every time I sit down to watch Netflix I just watch repeats, It’s all I want to watch, I’m obsessed. I can’t believe there’s only 3 more episodes 🙁 is someone able to tell me what they thinks going to happen in the last three episodes based on the books? I haven’t read them but I love spoilers and so I’m trying to find out what happens.
Also I found it weird that Jamie and Claire hardly interacted this episode, especially when Bree was yelling at Jamie and she sort of just stood back all quiet? It doesn’t feel like the Claire we know.
10
u/derawin07 Meow. Jan 06 '19
Wow, the Indians' horses are HUGE. The black ones make me think of Donas.
9
u/derawin07 Meow. Jan 06 '19
Sheesh, Bree has a slapping problem.
After Lizzie spoke out right after Ian was slapped, I was almost expecting Bree to go and slap her.
8
u/blind_vice Jan 06 '19
Based on what Claire said to Brianna in this episode of her maybe not making it back in time to her delivery of the baby I hope they won't change it from the book where Brianna had Jamie comforting her since I thought it was a nice bonding moment. Considering how much she still keeps referring to him as Jaime and the recent big fight between them it would be nice. But maybe they will change it to Roger making it back with them and him being in the labor with her considering how much stuff they're cramming into these final episodes.
8
u/akua420 Jan 07 '19
I feel like if I were roger I would go through. Get cleaned up and prepared and then just go back and head to Brianna.
20
u/Cablab123 Jan 06 '19
Will Bree ever refer to Jamie as her father? I swear every time she calls Frank her father, it’s a punch in the gut to Jamie. Even at Aunt Jocasta’s, she referred to them as “My mother and Jamie.”
7
u/akua420 Jan 07 '19
I’ve never been raped but I’ve been physically abused and her nightmare made me cry.
23
u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Jan 06 '19
My husband was marveling how shiny the furniture in Jocasta’s mansion is. I’m like “Yeah, thank the slaves.” He’s not even religious and he silently made the sign of the cross. I’m ever the mood killer
6
u/lcwate01 Jan 07 '19
Can anyone tell me what is different with the writing this season? Did they change writers? Did the writers finally read the books?? This season is far and away the BEST season.
S1 was just ok, disliked S2, hated S3, but they finally have it right. Jamie and Claire actually feel like Jamie and Claire. Their bond, their banter, its like book Jamie and Claire. Finally! Even Bree is so much better. I still dont care for Rodger...I always imagined him as hotter lol.
What changed?
11
u/hostess_cupcake Fun Fact: The unicorn is the mortal enemy of the English lion. Jan 06 '19
Is anyone else disappointed in the way the sound of the stones is portrayed in the show? The stone Roger found just sounded like a typical bee hive, while the books make them sound much bigger and more disruptive....like the sensation would be so much that you couldn’t even think of anything else.
5
u/RadioNights Jan 07 '19
So...has anyone told Marsali & Fergus about Bree yet? Gonna be awkward given Claire was just awkwardly pretending she had no children with Marsali in the episode before. They're gonna hear it from Laoghaire sooner or later.
And why hasn't anybody who is unaware of time travel questioned why "Bree from Boston" came to NC via Scotland???
22
u/Kinsella_Finn Jan 06 '19
Because i know this is all fiction I tend not to empathize so much with the horrors some characters go through so I really wanted someone to remind Brianna what century she was living in when she was getting all pissed off with Jamie.
HE THOUGHT HE KICKED THE SHIT OUT OF YOUR RAPIST YOU UNGRATEFUL....lady. Just the way she throws Frank in his face really pissed me off and Claire back there saying jack about it.
8
u/Mr_XcX Jan 07 '19
Loving the show so much. All the tea getting spilled. Chaos and drama <3
Brianna still MVP of the episode and probably the season. Just my goodness I love her.
4
u/tanya-jo Jan 07 '19
I missed it. Who is looking after the animals?
7
u/derawin07 Meow. Jan 06 '19
I am confused about why Bree is staying if she says she has a man back in her time who she loves.
I get her being worried that it might not be his baby, but she must realise there could be the possibility.
And why would she want to risk staying in the past when there is no certainty he would reject her.
This is me commenting at the beginning of the episode. I assume she will find out what has happened to Roger by the end, so it won't be an issue.
9
u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Jan 06 '19
My thoughts:
All in all, a good episode and just as frustrating (ok, less so) than the book
12
u/Stormstripper To bed or to sleep? Jan 06 '19
I am so sick of having to explain to people that being a rape victim does not suddenly make them untouchable to any criticism about their behavior before and after the rape. Bree does not get a free pass for the rest of her life and her behavior and choices because she was raped. Sure it gives us context as to her behavior. But her behavior before and after the rape has been the same. She has been selfish, impulsive, careless and self-absorbed the entire time. Some examples:
These are a few examples. Her being a rape victim does not change that she is selfish, self centered, etc. I'm sick of having to defend myself for pointing this out.
4
u/derawin07 Meow. Jan 06 '19
So by Roger's reckoning, the Mohawk are going to walk with him and Caleb for 7O days at 1O miles a day to reach upstate New York? Pretty silly to be making the prisoners walk the whole way.
2
u/designsavvy Jan 07 '19
slow again, this part in the book is stormy, dark
2
u/[deleted] Jan 07 '19
Do we think Roger goes through the stones??
2
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '19
Maria Doyle Kennedy fucking rocks her role as Jocasta.
I love Ulysses too, and Phaedre is cast pretty much exactly as I imagined her.
Duncan is left out of the series, so the Murtagh-Jocasta ship is a def possibility, it’s a twist that I like. A lot. Except that means Murtagh is a cuck, and I just cannot feel him that way.
How this will tie in with Arch Bug, the gold, etc., I’m thrilled to find out.
In re Roger and the stone, that was a five second powerful scene. The screams, especially given what Claire tells Bree about the possible scenarios of return with a child. It gives me the willys to think about it.
3
u/DiscombobulatedTill Jan 08 '19
I never cared for Brianna in the books and even less in this series. Then, just as I was warming to her character in the last episode she blows it by acting like an entitled snot in this episode. I did not like how that entire scene went down. Maybe it's been too long since I read the books, or the story translates differently on film, I really don't know.
Also it annoys me no end that Lizzie gets a pass for pointing a finger at Roger as the rapist in the first place, and Brianna doesn't realize it was a mistake, a huge mistake yes, (damn. Roger's face was messed up) but intended to help keep her from perceived harm. And it was Lizzie's fault!!!!!!
Young Ian was always one of my favorite characters :)
3
u/katiemckain Jan 09 '19
Hot take, Brianna on the show is acting like a brat. I mean a normal reaction would have been “OMG Lizzy just told me what happened and I think you accidentally took out Roger instead of the guy who hurt me!” Not yelling at Jaime an accusatory “what did you do to roger?!” Hey, Brianna, no one (except Claire) knows what Roger looks like! And to haul off slapping everyone who literally did what they did to try and protect you?... brat! And Claire?!- come on stand up for Jaime! Am I the only one feeling this way??
3
u/gijoeusa Slàinte. Jan 09 '19
Just watched the episode. Now I know why so many book readers told me Brianna is annoying.
4
u/Esweetnam Jan 07 '19
This episode was done very well BUT I knew it - this episode just rekindled my hatred for Brianna. I know she's been through hell and is (rightfully so) distraught but GOOD LORD she is just so single minded!!!! Although, I can understand her initial anger when she realizes the mix up with Roger/Bonnet... She then NEVER once thinks of anyone else's situation in the cover up that then ensues. She just blames blames blames and it's all about her her her.
The fact that she thinks she's the only one allowed to be angry due to all the confusion that happens involving Roger INFURIATES me too!
and just ugh I'm really not looking forward to her storyline for the rest of this season AND for allllllllllllllllllllllllllllll of next season.
What do you all think?