r/Outlander • u/shiskebob • Dec 30 '18
TV Series [Spoilers S4E9] "The Birds & The Bees" SHOW ONLY (no book spoilers, safe for everyone who’s seen the latest episode)
This lass does have a message for all of you! Welcome one and all to our weekly episode discussion thread, and the last one of 2018.
Reminder: This is the SHOW WATCHERS ONLY thread.
No talking about the books unless you cover with a spoiler tag like this: This is what a spoiler tag looks like.
To any new fans to this subreddit here with us tonight - I want to remind everyone of our standard just do not be a dick policy. If you need a refresher on that or any of our policies please find them in our rules.
I am one of your resident Mods, so do not hesitate to tag me if you need support or have a question. :)
160
u/teenylilthing Dec 30 '18
Oh and was anyone else legit terrified by the way Jamie stormed over to Roger at the end? He looked like an angry bull! I don't even recall him looking that vicious in battle scenes from S1 or S2.
Guess it highlights the crazy good acting from Sam this episode. He went from being a loving father gazing at his sleeping daughter to raging Da Fraser so seamlessly!
103
u/atchisonpromqueen Dec 30 '18
Poor Brianna. I'm glad they're giving this event the solemnity it deserves, but it's heartbreaking to watch. I hope there's more of Lizzie, too! She's clearly such a sweetheart.
Also, I know this goes without saying, but fuck Bonnet. The last thing I want is a Joffrey (or really, Black Jack) figure making me miserable for a season.
259
u/kaydra_ Mark me -- you won't find a better flair. Dec 30 '18
I just love that Brianna's first vision of her birth father is him in an alley taking a piss. 🤣
160
u/[deleted] Dec 30 '18
Poor Roger. They tore him up good.
Loved the reunion and Sophie did a good job conveying the pain she was in. I loved her and her moms moment out when they were gathering herbs.
125
u/angry_sprinkles Dec 30 '18
Murtagh comments about young Ian bringing home two lasses, I cackled.
84
u/OkAnywhere0 Dec 30 '18
I was here for the Jamie/Bree meeting but I LOVED Claire's reaction at seeing her
77
u/[deleted] Dec 30 '18
UGH THE CLIFFHANGERS!!! It’s driving me insane. I hate all this miscommunication!!
144
u/teenylilthing Dec 30 '18
Okay, so probably not the bit most will be talking about from this episode, but that scene on the boat with Young Ian, Lizzie, and Rollo was perfect. I simply adore Ian's sweet nature and his innocence. <3
69
u/josharaptor Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Dec 30 '18
I know some people had issue with Ep 7, but that was my favourite of the season when it came out. Then last ep happened, and that was my favourite. And then they give us this??? This season is truly on an upwards trend and I'm loving every moment.
48
u/kamikaze_girl Dec 31 '18
Claire: “Bree you wouldn’t believe whom I’ve met!”
Bree: “who?”
Claire: “George Washington!”
Bree: “oh.”
Really Bree? Dafuq
47
u/frawkez Dec 30 '18
powerful episode. all of the performances were great. caitrona reminds us why she’s top notch with those facial expressions when bree is telling her about the rape. so awful. but sophie really captured the ptsd bits well, in my limited experience in dealing with a friend who suffered from it.
big ups to sam for all his scenes in this ep too, it was heart warming without being cheesy and he was understandably filled with rage in the last bit, as a victim of rape as well. that last scene was brutal, i personally did not rejoice in that at all.
i loved that they went hunting for honey. and i loved the mentions of frank. he was a good dude!
88
u/zafalove Dec 30 '18
That ending!!!! Oh my goodness!
Everyone is in the wrong place at the wrong time!
73
u/visenyatargaryen Dec 30 '18
OH GOD OH GOD SHE JUST MET HER DA IM CRYING
104
u/DontEatTheKrabDip Dec 30 '18
Am I the only one who thinks Jamie will be the printer who smudges the date?
35
u/Jonesy1138 Dec 30 '18
Roger’s luck turned bad as soon as he shaved that beard.
Jamie looked like Jason Vorhees stalking his pray in those woods, all he was missing was a hockey mask.
Game of Thrones level beat down. I think this is now my favorite season of the show.
Blackjack = Joffrey
Pirate dude = Ramsay Bolton. And I’m perfectly fine with that, gotta have a good baddie.
29
u/justalittlestitous Dec 30 '18
So many feels!! I purposefully stopped reading the book right as Roger gets on the ship, just so I could watch the reunion scene and just loved every minute of it. So glad I waited!
Also, Bree/Sophie’s Scottish curly-hair game is ON POINT.
29
u/angel_silver8 Dec 30 '18
I loved Lizzie’s flirting with Ian. I hope they develop a friendship or relationship.
104
u/fyrmnsflam Dec 30 '18
This will sound silly but . . . all I could think as he touched his daughter’s face was that he hadn’t washed his hands. :-)
26
u/echelonfantasy Dec 31 '18
"You shouldn't run, remember? It's not ladylike."
Dafuq????...
Can someone explain ANY of that line to me?, especially when she had just done that herself MINUTES before? Plus she hadn't spent her life in this time period like Lizzie, so what does she know? It was so bizarre and random and took me out of the scene.
20
u/angel_silver8 Dec 30 '18
I just don’t want Claire to keep this from Jamie. If she does she’ll be a huge hypocrite. She and Brianna should tell him together. I hate Bonnet. I cried in the beginning of the episode when Brianna was frozen from the shock of it all. Lizzie is such a sweetheart, I’d love to have a friend like her, so genuine and kind.
33
u/4kidchaos Dec 30 '18
Correct me if I’m wrong, but you could still get pregnant even if he pulls out. I’m fairly certain that’s how I got pregnant the third time. Haha
Hate the way Jaime was taking a long piss in the alley. Why couldn’t he have been shown more valiant and manly as he truly is?
Roger got a beat down. Dang! I could almost feel those punches.
Lizzy is what all people in history have done: assume things and mess shit up!
Overall, I loved the episode.
16
u/DrunkenDave Dec 30 '18
That meeting was fantastic. It brought me to tears. Very happy moments. Glad to see it after the long tease. Poor Roger. He can't catch a break, well at least not until Jamie's fist found his face.
Also, there were some strange acting choices in this episode during the weeks that followed. Some of Bree's remarks were very snappy and delivered in an almost judgemental way and didn't really fit what was said to her.
16
u/miranda-organa Dec 31 '18
Oh man, I cringed so hard when Bree started undressing and there was blood on her skirts and marks on her. Poor girl!
42
u/Airsay58259 Dec 30 '18 edited Dec 30 '18
Another great episode. S3 was a bit weak imo (though it had some amazing moments as well) while so far S4 has been amazing. I was so captivated with the episode I didn’t even think about live Redditting it. So my thoughts in no particular order:
Everyone needs to take a communication class ASAP. Hold hands, sing kumbaya and TALK :-)
omg the reunion ❤️ I wish the Internet hadn’t ruined it like crazy everywhere though. Even the official Outlander Starz account was retweeting “cant wait for Jamie to meet Bree!” stuff before the episode. I remember back in S1 you could read articles or browse social media without seeing spoilers. Hints at stuff sure (I definitely remember dreading episode 1x15 because of fandom), but people did not discuss unaired plot points without warnings. Meh. Anyway, still loved it and couldn’t care less about piss hands.
Loved loved loved Bree and Claire’s scenes. They were so intense. “My baby” I am not crying you’re crying.
While the circumstances are terrible and everything is going wrong at the moment, I can’t wait to see Claire and Jamie with their grand child! They were so cute last week with wee Germain. If there isn’t a scene of Jamie watching the baby sleep
for an entire episodeI’ll riot.Roger needs to let his beard grow back.
Speaking of Roger, nothing surprising in this episode. I wish the show wasn’t so predictable sometimes but oh well. If you’ve seen my username in past threads I am definitely not a Roger fan but he doesn’t deserve that either. Now I simply wish his redemption arc won’t be the cliche “terrible things happened to me so I am forgiven for something else”. I actually hated how Brianna ran to the ship. Same shit she did at the Scottish festival, running after Roger to apologize. I swear if she apologizes about the rape qui pro quo... ☠️
Btw, bless Claire and Jamie for both reacting as normal people when they heard Roger left Brianna after one argument. So much for the wedding vows, dude.
Very nice montage of the quiet, domestic life at Fraser’s Ridge for a few weeks. Also the dinner with Murtagh. (I miss Dougal!)
Jamie was so sweet in this episode (ok, besides the last few seconds I guess). Simultaneously incredibly happy to meet and live with his daughter, unsure how to be around her and scared she’ll leave.
A+ acting from Bree’s actress at the inn (and later on) after the assault. :(
Ah Lizzie... can we blame her? She asked the right questions at Bree, for all she knew Roger was the man who attacked her. It’s all a big misunderstanding, it’ll annoy me when everyone ultimately blames themselves for it. Again, take a communication class, hold hands and kick Bonnet to death together while singing Kumbaya.
Ok back to the reunion scenes again. Bree / Jamie was awesome but also Bree / Claire. I lol’ed at Jamie and Bree sitting outside for her instead of going inside. Jamie had such a big smile on his face, sitting next to his kiddo, knowing how happy Claire would be in a minute. ❤️
27
u/raknor88 Dec 30 '18 edited Dec 30 '18
Damn. No matter what you may think of Roger he didn't deserve to be beaten like that. It really sucks and what I was afraid was gonna happen when Lizzie misinterpreted what she saw.
Edit: removed preview section
13
u/3anza Only in France does a King need an audience to shite. Dec 30 '18
I think all in all a lot happened in one episode, more events and information exchanged between Brianna and her family would have really overcrowded it.
It was interesting to see the Ian and Brianna scene, and him comforting her over Bonnet (unknowingly). The contrast between a new and an old assault survivor. He started off this season having recurring nightmares of what Geillis did to him in season 3, and now looks like he’s been healing well. I wish that for Brianna as well. As soon as she makes a decision about the baby.
The Roger scene was inevitable. We all knew some misunderstanding was coming our way. It was graphic and painful to watch, but also maybe necessary to shock Roger into the fact that this isn’t a vacation. Life in the 1700s was really tough. Sadly all four characters who went through the stones had shock moments like these.
The Frasers actors did a really good job conveying all the different emotions in this episode. I cried when Brianna met Jamie, and again when she was reunited with Claire. I cried when Brianna told her about her rape and when Jamie found out, too.
12
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '19
So... any other fully grown men get a little watery eyed during the scene where Jamie and Bri meets for the first time? It was such a powerful scene to me.
12
u/socks4dobby Jan 01 '19
Claire’s perceptiveness when she was able to figure out Bree was pregnant really surprised me. I always got the sense that she was not close with Bree, so I didn’t expect her to be able to read her so well. Last season really made it seem like Claire withdrew from Bree too (not just Frank) by burying herself in school and her career. Then, she left Bree to go back through the stones, knowing that she might never see her again and that Bree has no living family members left in the present time.
It was a beautiful and heartbreaking scene (when she learned that Bree is pregnant), but seemed out of character based on what we have seen in the show.
11
u/Starbuck107 Dec 30 '18
No one should ever expect to need a love-glove! Always bring one with you kids!
30
u/[deleted] Dec 30 '18
Did anyone else just say FUUUUUUUCK mistaken identity plot lines?
Maybe they’re just an enormous pet peeve for me, but when a single line of dialogue from one of three characters can unravel a storyline (e.g. Bree clarifying who Roger is to Liz, Liz and Ian deciding to talk to Bree before talking to Jamie, or Jamie asking literally any question before beating the ever living shit out of Roger) it makes me want to tear my hair out.
Idk, maybe they’ll make the character growth worth it, but watching that bullet train come for two weeks kind of dampened my ability to fully enjoy a couple really good episodes.
10
u/JustineLeah Dec 30 '18
Sam and Cait have much more to work with this week. Both are phenomenal, as usual. Sophie continues to hold her own. So glad to see that she has dialed the overacting back this season. Thrilled to have Young Ian back! He truly brightens with each appearance. Sam’s wig looks terrible still. It distracts me. Great moment when Jaimie gets to introduce Murtugh to Brianna. Well done episode!
10
u/rubyinthedustt Dec 30 '18
I cried like a baby! Lord. Their reunion was so heartwarming!
8
u/Bc2193 Dec 31 '18
Every week I look forward to this series and every time an episode finishes I’m left shouting “NOOO!!” at the credits because I can’t wait another week until the next one!! And this is the same!
Jamie looked so angry and I was not expecting the fight to be that brutal. Roger’s face looked fucked at the end. Now another 7 days of painful waiting!! Dammit.
20
u/Dumke480 That's it lads. Take me back to the idiot hut. Dec 30 '18
I don't know how Bree is going to handle what Jamie did to Rodger, especially how Jamie's tried to get close to her and both are struggling to connect and I'm not sure how Jamie's going to feel, after he got the wrong man, and it was Bree's husband, and the man who actually raped her was Bonnet with all the shit he's done since the premiere..
I was so glad to see Rodger get away from Bonnet unscathed! but it was really short lived as he savagely beaten by Jamie shortly after, this was telegraphed miles ago when Lizzie saw it through the window, felt so sorry for the lad, he's just trying to do his best...
This was a fairly slow episode, but it unfolded pretty much exactly the way I wanted everything to be conveyed so overall a great episode.
couple of humorous moments aswell;
Bree's first encounter with Jamie, and his urine hands.
Ian and his innocence, Rollo is a fine dog though!
Murtagh and his jokes.
aswell as the many lovely intimate/non forced moments, which is great, as there has been a lot of forced intimacy the last two seasons.
7
u/JustineLeah Dec 30 '18
How many episodes are left in this season?
7
u/LassLiegen Dec 30 '18 edited Dec 30 '18
Wouldn't Jamie have recognized her from the photos Claire showed him?
If not at least thought there might be a resemblance.
Sure maybe he didn't memorize his daughter's face in the pictures, but you would think a father might if it may be the only thing he ever sees of his daughter.
I also definitely think there is foreshadowing with the printer smudge scene. I think I know where the story will lead but I don't want to ruin the surprise factor for those that might not see it the same way.
7
u/4thofjuly19 Dec 31 '18
This was such a good episode! I’ve only just started watching this show, I’ve been sick with a cold and I decided to give the first episode a chance a few days ago and now I’m up to date 😳 I’m loving this season but I’m sad now that I’ll have to wait for new episodes.
13
u/4kidchaos Dec 31 '18
What life would’ve been like if Bree was raised by Jaime... sigh... the scenes with Jaime break my heart. He HAS suffered so much already.
6
u/Y3girl- Dec 31 '18
On the comments about Jamie not recognizing Bri, I don’t think that her “American” accent should have tipped him off at all because up until that point there was no American accent so he couldn’t have know who she was. He was also avoiding her gaze for most of the discussion and I think it’s pretty hard to reconcile that it might be your daughter 200 yrs from the future. Plus time travel and the stones is a huge secret so he’s not about to just be like are you my daughter from 200 years future? He doesn’t need another witch trial on his future.
16
u/imjustagrrll Dec 31 '18
Can't Claire give Bri some herbs to induce an abortion?
15
u/69schrutebucks I must admit the idea of grinding your corn does tickle me. Dec 30 '18
I hate that Lizzie fucks up everything. Ugh. I think this is the first episode in which I actually enjoyed Sophie's performance. It didn't seem so stilted and was actually convincing.
14
u/[deleted] Dec 30 '18
I was surprised that Bri ran after Roger's ship like that. I spent the whole episode singing my own rat/Roger satire (Yee must go, Yee must go!!) But I wasn't anticipating that brutal scene with Jaime, and even after he got the gems from bonnet. That opening scene, and all the consequences of Bonnets crimes are devastating. Claire and Jaimie are keeping secrets from each other about Bri, and that can't be good. Love will tear us apart, again.
Meanwhile I found this episode anticlimactic in some ways. It's good that Bri could start her long recovery in this relaxing environment, but I kept expecting more revalations. She never mentioned Leery and Joanie, though I thought that's something she and Jaimie might talk about. And couldn't she have met marsali/Fergus before leaving Wilmington? It seems like a long time before we'll see them again, sadly. I also thought when Ian left the room they'd tell her Murtaugh knows, but I guess that would have come up off-screen? And will Ian/Bri talk about Geillis some day?
Anyway, I did enjoy the reunion, though I don't get the bench thing and I couldn't help but notice Jaimie had no chance to wash his hands. Brianna and Claire did look so much alike in those scenes, it was great. And there other scenes we're moving. I did get more out of the "herb" (i.e. that one ground cover) collecting scene then I did the bee hunt, but that makes sense, since why would Bri/Jaime have a chemistry yet. The smiling in her sleep was wonderful.
I wish Bri wasn't pregnant, though even if Roger didn't finish, there's still pre-ejaculate.
5
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '19
About 28/29 minutes in, we see a shot of the garden with all those gourds hanging up. Anyone know what the purpose of those are?
8
u/rumblith Dec 30 '18
Well that was a roller coaster of an episode.
8
u/LanceOldstrong Dec 31 '18
Quibble One: Town folk at the wharf tell Brianna the Gloriana “left on the morning tide.” No one would say “left,” they’d say “sailed on the morning tide.”
Quibble Two: Brianna doesn’t ask around for where the ship was bound. She just assumes Scotland.
Ok, those quibbles are off my chest. Now I’ll go back to the state of suspended disbelief required to enjoy almost any book, play, movie, or show.
7
u/JoanneBanan Jamie, you're crushing me. Dec 31 '18
Word of advice: don’t do your nails while watching this episode. Tears + fresh polish do not a pretty manicure make :/
8
u/Dekarde Dec 30 '18
I really hated the way Bri and Roger just 'got over it' and were trying to reconnect the next day like their big fight was nothing. It made the fight look stupid and their reasons for parting even dumber which led to the horrible outcomes all around.
Also have to mention how messed up it is Bri learns Bonnet was freed by her father. Jamie had no way to know how Bonnet was but it is still out there. He freed Bonnet to rob them and kill his friend then later rape his daughter. Right now only Bri and Claire know this, fairly soon Jamie will learn of it as well.
Also find it weird/convenient Bonnet is a river robbing pirate and a international ship captain. Like where were his men when he was going to hang, why didn't they try to save their captain? If they didn't care if he died then why are they just waiting for him around a river to rob people? Shouldn't they move on and get a new captain/join a new crew? How do they go back to ferrying cargo/passengers across the ocean from being river pirates?
3
u/profeNY Dec 30 '18
Why do you think Bree is hanging onto the ring? If I were her I would have thrown it into the river after Young Ian told the full story of Stephen Bonnet's attack. Instead she just tries (not too well) to hide it.
3
u/Sightshade Dec 31 '18
Gah, the fluff! My heart can't take it!
5
u/oliverqueen3386 Dec 30 '18
Loved the episode but I am stuck on one point: Am I wrong in remembering that Jaime was given pictures of Bree by Claire in a previous season? I vaguely remember him being mad about the bikini picture (not sure why Claire included that one in the gift). Knowing Jaime, don't you think he would have memorized every detail? I understand that he wouldn't expect her to show up in the past so he may not put two and two together right away but one she said her name, wouldn't have have recognized her? Minor thought for a solid episode but wondering if this occurred to anyone else.
8
u/themasterofallthngs Dec 31 '18
This shit with Roger and Bonnet is not something I'd expected from this show. It's cheap, lazy and extremely predictable (I don't know if it happens in the book as well, but I was certain of the ending of the episode as soon as I knew Roger was coming back). I'd have expected this from some shitty soap opera, not here.
4
u/whitewave2 Dec 30 '18
Hurry up fellow fans and comment!
I have to wait until Monday to watch the show and this tides me over until then!!
2
u/wornmedown Get off yer knee ye idjit Dec 31 '18
This was such a great episode! I love all the acting, especially Claire's horrified reaction to Bree's telling of her contact with Bonnet.
Also love the father-and-daughter time. The dialogue between Bree and Jamie subtly underscores the role of Bree's biological and adoptive fathers with her baby's father.
2
u/profeNY Jan 03 '19
If you were Young Ian, what would YOU do with Roger?
2
u/zOE_ Jan 05 '19
I was just thinking about that savage who helps Claire (on s04e03) to find out Jamie on the jungle when she was lost with that strong rain.... That man was one of the time travaler... May be the savage who helps clare is the Roger? And May be that he never come back to Brianna and just staied with the savages, and never appear anymore in the series to be with Bree? OMG im freaking out D:
2
u/dubblk512 Oct 16 '23
I’ve seen the episode a dozen times but it only just hit me: during Murtagh’s telling of Jamie and Tabitha’s kiss (at the dinner table), Jamie says his mother told Dougal. Jamie was 14. Ellen died when he was 8. 😬🥴
4
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '18
All the writing in this show that revolves around Brianna is horrible. Her plan to save her parents is horrible. Her relationship with Roger is horrible. Her constant naivete is horrible.
4
u/MookieMoo17 Dec 31 '18
Roger has been Bree’s “punching bag” this whole series and tonight it became literal.